SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Dynamic spectrum and the 
race for mobile capacity 
29th October 2014 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
Agenda 
• Increasing role for licence exempt spectrum sharing 
in serving the growing mobile data demand 
• Importance of lower frequencies – significance of 
TV white spaces and dynamic spectrum access 
• What the arrival of 802.11af and triple band access 
points will mean for Wi-Fi
Anytime, anywhere on a mobile 
device ….. 
• Mobile devices are becoming the 
dominant means of access to a 
growing host of online services 
• Tablets and smartphones have 
broadened Internet use 
• As services use higher quality 
images & video, wireless network 
capacity needs to rise…. 
• Spectrum is a key input … 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
Capacity is important but there 
are other factors 
Wireless access networks 
WAN + LAN 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
4 
Broadband 
Internet of 
Things 
Capacity 
Coverage 
Flexibility 
Resilience
Spectrum availability is critical to 
meeting expectations for wireless 
.47-.79 GHz .8 .9 1.8 2.1 2.4 2.6 
GSM 
GSM 
3G 
LTE 
Wi-FI 
LTE 
• Access to spectrum is key to extracting value from wireless technology 
• Harmonised access enables economies of scale in equipment 
• Wider bands enable greater performance – affecting the dimensioning of networks 
• Lower frequencies enable better coverage 
• Future networks need to straddle multiple bands to deliver the best possible connectivity 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
to users wherever they are 
Frequency 
1GHz 2GHz 3.5GHz 
TV 
+ 
802.11af 
Radio 
200 MHz 600 THz
Licence exempt access is now a key 
tool in meeting mobile demand 
• Licence exempt networks have taken an 
increasing share of mobile data traffic 
• Licence exemption (LE) is a powerful tool for 
wireless innovation 
• It enables flexible, ad-hoc and device-to-device 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
direct links 
• Until now, LE has been confined to short 
range applications & higher frequencies 
• Dynamic spectrum access technology allows 
higher transmission power according to 
location & safe sharing with licensed users 
Source: TCS-Sensor Lab 
6
Wi-Fi family tree 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
802.11b 
11 Mbps , 20 MHz DSSS, 
Band : 2.4 GHz 
802.11a 
54 Mbps, 20 MHz OFDM 
Band : 5 GHz 
802.11g 
54 Mbps, 20 MHz OFDM 
Band : 2.4 GHz 
802.11n 
600 Mbps, 20/40 MHz, OFDM + MIMO 
Bands: 2.4 or 5 GHz 
802.11af 
600 Mbps 
Band: TVWS 
802.11ac 
1.3 Gbps 
Band: 5 GHz 
802.11ad 
6 Gbps 
Band: 60 GHZ 
WiGig 
.47-.79 
(UHF) 
2.4 
GHz 
5 GHz 60 
Frequency (GHz) 
.47-.79 
(UHF) 
2.4 
GHz 
5 GHz 60 
Frequency (GHz) 
.47-.79 
(UHF) 
2.4 
GHz 
5 GHz 60 
Frequency (GHz) 
.47-.79 
(UHF) 
2.4 
GHz 
5 GHz 60 
Frequency (GHz) 
Source: Mediatek, Larkhill analysis
5 GHz is good for adding capacity 
Band Capacity 
(MHz) 
Status 
5150 to 5250 MHz 100 the “new global band” 
5250 to 5350 MHz 100 OK in many regulatory domains 
5350 to 5470 MHz ? problematic everywhere 
5470 to 5725 MHz 255 OK in EU; radars limit its use 
elsewhere 
5725 to 5825 MHz 100 OK in EU, but limited to 25 mW 
5825 to 5925 MHz EU plans to share with road 
tolling 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
Source: Mediatek, Larkhill analysis
60 GHz – massive additional 
licence-exempt capacity 
• Opportunity to deploy 
large additional Wi-Fi 
capacity 
• Fits well with urban 
environments where user 
density is high and fibre 
access is widely available 
• In-room networks 
• Point to point links for 
backhaul (line of sight) 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
Adding more sub-5 GHz capacity 
depends on more efficient sharing 
• Although spectrum is fully allocated, 
much is left unused – geographically 
and temporally 
• Dynamic spectrum access uses new 
technology to enable opportunistic, 
licence-exempt access 
• This provides a great opportunity to 
boost the coverage and capacity that 
Wi-Fi networks can enable 
• The Dynamic Spectrum Alliance is 
taking the technology around the world 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
OK, you can use 
channels x, y, z 
Geolocation 
database 
My 
device 
I’m in 
Glasgow 
10
Lower frequencies help fill coverage 
gaps and enhance capacity 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
Source: BT R&D 
Simulation of coverage 
with 20% access point 
penetration, in a 1 km2 
dense urban area in 
Fulham, London 
11 
Wi-Fi , 5 GHz Wi-Fi , 2.4 GHz TV White Spaces – 600 MHz
TV white spaces - global opportunity 
to access lower frequencies 
• UHF frequencies have bee allocated for TV 
broadcasting (470-790 MHz in EU) 
• Unused gaps in these bands are called TV 
white spaces (TVWS) 
• New Dynamic spectrum access technology 
protects TV reception whilst releasing 
valuable new capacity for licence-exempt 
use 
• Already commercialised in the US, pilot 
deployments are underway across the rest 
of the world, as regulators prepare enabling 
frameworks 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
12 
Image source: Ofcom
Dynamic Spectrum Access can enable a 
full range of business models 
Facilitates centralised 
infrastructure investment 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
Scope for innovation 
Coexistence of multiple 
users/applications 
Can protect services 
against effects of interference 
Enables infrastructure 
investment by end users 
Wi-Fi LTE 
13
IEEE 802.11af adds TV white 
spaces to the Wi-Fi band family 
• First wireless LAN standard using geo-location 
databases for access to spectrum 
• IETF PAWS will be the predominant interface 
• Adapted from state-of-the-art 802.11ac PHY 
• 6,7 or 8 MHz TV channels for global applicability 
• < 35 Mbit/s per TV channel (8 MHz) 
• < 560 Mbps with 4 TV channels bonded and 4 
spatial paths 
• Enterprise management of database access 
• Using a Registered Location Secure Server 
• Maintains a local copy of local white space map 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
8 8 8 8 
14 
8 
Total: 8 MHz 
8 8 
8 8 
Total: 16 MHz 
8 8 8 8 
Total: 32 MHz 
802.11af 
channel configurations
Three bands improve scalability of 
Wi-Fi coverage 
10-20 metres 
Kilometres 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
TV White 
Spaces 
5 GHz 2.4 GHz 
Tens of metres
Triple-band Wi-Fi set to become 
the new norm 
• Adding 802.11 af to standard Wi-Fi 
brings TV white spaces coverage 
and capacity 
• New triple band Wi-Fi will help 
improve coverage and capacity, in 
urban and rural locations 
• First prototypes were tested in the 
Glasgow White Spaces Pilot in June 
2014 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
Summary 
• Increasing personal connectivity is driving 
demand for more capacity and better coverage 
• Spectrum clearance is too slow, so dynamic 
spectrum access (DSA) technology enables 
faster access to extra capacity 
• DSA will revolutionise spectrum access & 
management 
• 3. Initially, enabling the TV white spaces to fill 
coverage gaps as well as adding valuable 
capacity, using the new 802.11af standard 
• Providing a foundation for other bands to be 
added over time (3.5 GHz is currently under 
discussion in the US) 
17 
Source: Microsoft
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 
Thank you 
• Contact: 
Andrew@larkhillconsult.co.uk 
About Larkhill 
18
Further reading 
• Background material and information about pilots 
etc. Dynamic Spectrum Alliance 
• The Centre for White Space Communications 
(University of Strathclyde) 
• Microsoft dynamic spectrum access pilots 
• White spaces applications in Singapore 
• Airties: 802.11ac is not sufficient 
(c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014

More Related Content

PPTX
TV White Space
PPTX
Commercial TVWS Solutions Webinar
PPTX
Tvws ppt 1
PPT
White Space Technology
PPTX
White space technology
PPT
TV White Space Webinar presented by Dorin Goldfeder, Sales Director
PPTX
Mark Thomas, Cambium Networks - INCA Full Fibre & 5G Seminar 12/7/17
PDF
TV White Space Networking: Characteristics, Challenges, and Opportunities
TV White Space
Commercial TVWS Solutions Webinar
Tvws ppt 1
White Space Technology
White space technology
TV White Space Webinar presented by Dorin Goldfeder, Sales Director
Mark Thomas, Cambium Networks - INCA Full Fibre & 5G Seminar 12/7/17
TV White Space Networking: Characteristics, Challenges, and Opportunities

What's hot (17)

PDF
TV White Space for Rural Broadband Connectivity
PPTX
RuralConnect & TV White Space
PPT
White space radio in scada systems
PDF
The Significance of TV White Spaces
PPTX
TVWS use case in Kenya
PDF
Prof. Andy Sutton: Backhauling the 5G Experience
PPTX
Super Wi-Fi TV White SPace and Wireless Broadband Inclusion
PDF
Yue Wang: AI in 5G –the Why and How - Jan 2019
PPTX
Introducing TV White Spaces
PDF
Connecting Next Billions: Rural Area Broadband Access Network using Saankhya ...
PPTX
TVWS use case in Malawi
PPTX
Carlson wireless investor 12 march 16
PPTX
Broadband 101 Wireless Solutions
PDF
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
PPT
Nasir faruk tv white spaces presentation iad2014
PDF
5G Spectrum in EUROPE
PDF
Yao Wenbing, Huawei - INCA Full Fibre & 5G Seminar 12/7/17
TV White Space for Rural Broadband Connectivity
RuralConnect & TV White Space
White space radio in scada systems
The Significance of TV White Spaces
TVWS use case in Kenya
Prof. Andy Sutton: Backhauling the 5G Experience
Super Wi-Fi TV White SPace and Wireless Broadband Inclusion
Yue Wang: AI in 5G –the Why and How - Jan 2019
Introducing TV White Spaces
Connecting Next Billions: Rural Area Broadband Access Network using Saankhya ...
TVWS use case in Malawi
Carlson wireless investor 12 march 16
Broadband 101 Wireless Solutions
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
Nasir faruk tv white spaces presentation iad2014
5G Spectrum in EUROPE
Yao Wenbing, Huawei - INCA Full Fibre & 5G Seminar 12/7/17
Ad

Viewers also liked (19)

PDF
Education and Enculturation of Junior Officers in USN FORCEnet & Network Cen...
PPT
I psec
PPT
PPTX
Types of authentication
PPT
A study on the awareness national anthem
PPTX
Lte tdd femto cell for usage of tv white space
PDF
WiFi new generation par Guy PUJOLLE - Fevrier 2013
DOCX
Drx in rrc idle
PPTX
Fanny Mlinarsky Octo Scope White Space Broadband10608
PPTX
01 06-16 carlson - crowdfunder private and confidential 10 slide deck v4
PPTX
Carlson Wireless Technologies - Gen 3 TV White Space Radio, RuralConnect
PDF
End-to-End Encryption of Distributed Applications
PDF
TV White Space Whitepaper
PPT
Network Centric Strategic Planning
PDF
Network centric warfare market, 2016 – 2024
PDF
SMi NCW 04 Conference, Chairman's Kickoff Presentation © 26 Oct 2004, Mark Te...
PPTX
Review on Whatsapp's End to End encryption and Facebook integration
PPTX
The Concept of Network Centric Warfare feat. India
PDF
Network Centric Warfare - An Introduction
Education and Enculturation of Junior Officers in USN FORCEnet & Network Cen...
I psec
Types of authentication
A study on the awareness national anthem
Lte tdd femto cell for usage of tv white space
WiFi new generation par Guy PUJOLLE - Fevrier 2013
Drx in rrc idle
Fanny Mlinarsky Octo Scope White Space Broadband10608
01 06-16 carlson - crowdfunder private and confidential 10 slide deck v4
Carlson Wireless Technologies - Gen 3 TV White Space Radio, RuralConnect
End-to-End Encryption of Distributed Applications
TV White Space Whitepaper
Network Centric Strategic Planning
Network centric warfare market, 2016 – 2024
SMi NCW 04 Conference, Chairman's Kickoff Presentation © 26 Oct 2004, Mark Te...
Review on Whatsapp's End to End encryption and Facebook integration
The Concept of Network Centric Warfare feat. India
Network Centric Warfare - An Introduction
Ad

Similar to Dynamic Spectrum Access and the race for mobile capacity (20)

PDF
U.S. Wireless Overview & Outlook Presentation (V02C)
PDF
PhxMobi Next-Generation Wireless Overview & Outlook Briefing 11/13/21
PDF
Future Proofing Wi-Fi - the Case for More Spectrum
PDF
Next-Generation Wireless Overview & Outlook Update 12/8/21
PPTX
High performance browser networking ch5,6
PDF
5G The Big Game Changer ?
PPTX
WLAN(802.11AX - WI-FI 6) Evolution, frequency band, channels & use cases
PDF
A Wireless Tipping Point, Open Spectrum Implications
PDF
Brough Turner's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 20...
PDF
A CLOSE ASSESSMENT AND ANALYSIS OF PUBLIC WIFI
PDF
2.4 GHz vs 5 GHz Wi-Fi.pdf
PDF
A Wireless Future - Making Waves
PPT
Robert Horvitz's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 2...
PDF
Mobile-Wireless-Networks.pdf
PDF
Whitespace Spectrum - Set It Free
PDF
Why Does Wi-Fi Need 6GHz.pdf
PDF
Next-Generation Wireless Overview & Outlook 7/7/20
PPTX
Wireless – It’s complicated! By Albert Kangas
PDF
Super wifi overview
PPTX
Wi fi technology
U.S. Wireless Overview & Outlook Presentation (V02C)
PhxMobi Next-Generation Wireless Overview & Outlook Briefing 11/13/21
Future Proofing Wi-Fi - the Case for More Spectrum
Next-Generation Wireless Overview & Outlook Update 12/8/21
High performance browser networking ch5,6
5G The Big Game Changer ?
WLAN(802.11AX - WI-FI 6) Evolution, frequency band, channels & use cases
A Wireless Tipping Point, Open Spectrum Implications
Brough Turner's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 20...
A CLOSE ASSESSMENT AND ANALYSIS OF PUBLIC WIFI
2.4 GHz vs 5 GHz Wi-Fi.pdf
A Wireless Future - Making Waves
Robert Horvitz's Presentation at Emerging Communication Conference & Awards 2...
Mobile-Wireless-Networks.pdf
Whitespace Spectrum - Set It Free
Why Does Wi-Fi Need 6GHz.pdf
Next-Generation Wireless Overview & Outlook 7/7/20
Wireless – It’s complicated! By Albert Kangas
Super wifi overview
Wi fi technology

Recently uploaded (9)

DOC
SIUE毕业证学历认证,阿祖萨太平洋大学毕业证学位证书复制
PDF
Date Right Stuff - Invite only, conservative dating app
PDF
Kids, Screens & Emotional Development by Meenakshi Khakat
PPTX
Social Media People PowerPoint Templates.pptx
PPTX
Introduction to Packet Tracer Course Overview - Aug 21 (1).pptx
DOC
NIU毕业证学历认证,阿比林基督大学毕业证留学生学历
PDF
2025 Guide to Buy Verified Cash App Accounts You Can Trust.pdf
PDF
Best 4 Sites for Buy Verified Cash App Accounts – BTC Only.pdf
DOC
EIU毕业证学历认证,贝尔维尤学院毕业证国外毕业证
SIUE毕业证学历认证,阿祖萨太平洋大学毕业证学位证书复制
Date Right Stuff - Invite only, conservative dating app
Kids, Screens & Emotional Development by Meenakshi Khakat
Social Media People PowerPoint Templates.pptx
Introduction to Packet Tracer Course Overview - Aug 21 (1).pptx
NIU毕业证学历认证,阿比林基督大学毕业证留学生学历
2025 Guide to Buy Verified Cash App Accounts You Can Trust.pdf
Best 4 Sites for Buy Verified Cash App Accounts – BTC Only.pdf
EIU毕业证学历认证,贝尔维尤学院毕业证国外毕业证

Dynamic Spectrum Access and the race for mobile capacity

  • 1. Dynamic spectrum and the race for mobile capacity 29th October 2014 (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
  • 2. (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 Agenda • Increasing role for licence exempt spectrum sharing in serving the growing mobile data demand • Importance of lower frequencies – significance of TV white spaces and dynamic spectrum access • What the arrival of 802.11af and triple band access points will mean for Wi-Fi
  • 3. Anytime, anywhere on a mobile device ….. • Mobile devices are becoming the dominant means of access to a growing host of online services • Tablets and smartphones have broadened Internet use • As services use higher quality images & video, wireless network capacity needs to rise…. • Spectrum is a key input … (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
  • 4. Capacity is important but there are other factors Wireless access networks WAN + LAN (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 4 Broadband Internet of Things Capacity Coverage Flexibility Resilience
  • 5. Spectrum availability is critical to meeting expectations for wireless .47-.79 GHz .8 .9 1.8 2.1 2.4 2.6 GSM GSM 3G LTE Wi-FI LTE • Access to spectrum is key to extracting value from wireless technology • Harmonised access enables economies of scale in equipment • Wider bands enable greater performance – affecting the dimensioning of networks • Lower frequencies enable better coverage • Future networks need to straddle multiple bands to deliver the best possible connectivity (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 to users wherever they are Frequency 1GHz 2GHz 3.5GHz TV + 802.11af Radio 200 MHz 600 THz
  • 6. Licence exempt access is now a key tool in meeting mobile demand • Licence exempt networks have taken an increasing share of mobile data traffic • Licence exemption (LE) is a powerful tool for wireless innovation • It enables flexible, ad-hoc and device-to-device (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 direct links • Until now, LE has been confined to short range applications & higher frequencies • Dynamic spectrum access technology allows higher transmission power according to location & safe sharing with licensed users Source: TCS-Sensor Lab 6
  • 7. Wi-Fi family tree (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 802.11b 11 Mbps , 20 MHz DSSS, Band : 2.4 GHz 802.11a 54 Mbps, 20 MHz OFDM Band : 5 GHz 802.11g 54 Mbps, 20 MHz OFDM Band : 2.4 GHz 802.11n 600 Mbps, 20/40 MHz, OFDM + MIMO Bands: 2.4 or 5 GHz 802.11af 600 Mbps Band: TVWS 802.11ac 1.3 Gbps Band: 5 GHz 802.11ad 6 Gbps Band: 60 GHZ WiGig .47-.79 (UHF) 2.4 GHz 5 GHz 60 Frequency (GHz) .47-.79 (UHF) 2.4 GHz 5 GHz 60 Frequency (GHz) .47-.79 (UHF) 2.4 GHz 5 GHz 60 Frequency (GHz) .47-.79 (UHF) 2.4 GHz 5 GHz 60 Frequency (GHz) Source: Mediatek, Larkhill analysis
  • 8. 5 GHz is good for adding capacity Band Capacity (MHz) Status 5150 to 5250 MHz 100 the “new global band” 5250 to 5350 MHz 100 OK in many regulatory domains 5350 to 5470 MHz ? problematic everywhere 5470 to 5725 MHz 255 OK in EU; radars limit its use elsewhere 5725 to 5825 MHz 100 OK in EU, but limited to 25 mW 5825 to 5925 MHz EU plans to share with road tolling (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 Source: Mediatek, Larkhill analysis
  • 9. 60 GHz – massive additional licence-exempt capacity • Opportunity to deploy large additional Wi-Fi capacity • Fits well with urban environments where user density is high and fibre access is widely available • In-room networks • Point to point links for backhaul (line of sight) (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
  • 10. Adding more sub-5 GHz capacity depends on more efficient sharing • Although spectrum is fully allocated, much is left unused – geographically and temporally • Dynamic spectrum access uses new technology to enable opportunistic, licence-exempt access • This provides a great opportunity to boost the coverage and capacity that Wi-Fi networks can enable • The Dynamic Spectrum Alliance is taking the technology around the world (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 OK, you can use channels x, y, z Geolocation database My device I’m in Glasgow 10
  • 11. Lower frequencies help fill coverage gaps and enhance capacity (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 Source: BT R&D Simulation of coverage with 20% access point penetration, in a 1 km2 dense urban area in Fulham, London 11 Wi-Fi , 5 GHz Wi-Fi , 2.4 GHz TV White Spaces – 600 MHz
  • 12. TV white spaces - global opportunity to access lower frequencies • UHF frequencies have bee allocated for TV broadcasting (470-790 MHz in EU) • Unused gaps in these bands are called TV white spaces (TVWS) • New Dynamic spectrum access technology protects TV reception whilst releasing valuable new capacity for licence-exempt use • Already commercialised in the US, pilot deployments are underway across the rest of the world, as regulators prepare enabling frameworks (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 12 Image source: Ofcom
  • 13. Dynamic Spectrum Access can enable a full range of business models Facilitates centralised infrastructure investment (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 Scope for innovation Coexistence of multiple users/applications Can protect services against effects of interference Enables infrastructure investment by end users Wi-Fi LTE 13
  • 14. IEEE 802.11af adds TV white spaces to the Wi-Fi band family • First wireless LAN standard using geo-location databases for access to spectrum • IETF PAWS will be the predominant interface • Adapted from state-of-the-art 802.11ac PHY • 6,7 or 8 MHz TV channels for global applicability • < 35 Mbit/s per TV channel (8 MHz) • < 560 Mbps with 4 TV channels bonded and 4 spatial paths • Enterprise management of database access • Using a Registered Location Secure Server • Maintains a local copy of local white space map (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 8 8 8 8 14 8 Total: 8 MHz 8 8 8 8 Total: 16 MHz 8 8 8 8 Total: 32 MHz 802.11af channel configurations
  • 15. Three bands improve scalability of Wi-Fi coverage 10-20 metres Kilometres (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 TV White Spaces 5 GHz 2.4 GHz Tens of metres
  • 16. Triple-band Wi-Fi set to become the new norm • Adding 802.11 af to standard Wi-Fi brings TV white spaces coverage and capacity • New triple band Wi-Fi will help improve coverage and capacity, in urban and rural locations • First prototypes were tested in the Glasgow White Spaces Pilot in June 2014 (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014
  • 17. (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 Summary • Increasing personal connectivity is driving demand for more capacity and better coverage • Spectrum clearance is too slow, so dynamic spectrum access (DSA) technology enables faster access to extra capacity • DSA will revolutionise spectrum access & management • 3. Initially, enabling the TV white spaces to fill coverage gaps as well as adding valuable capacity, using the new 802.11af standard • Providing a foundation for other bands to be added over time (3.5 GHz is currently under discussion in the US) 17 Source: Microsoft
  • 18. (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014 Thank you • Contact: Andrew@larkhillconsult.co.uk About Larkhill 18
  • 19. Further reading • Background material and information about pilots etc. Dynamic Spectrum Alliance • The Centre for White Space Communications (University of Strathclyde) • Microsoft dynamic spectrum access pilots • White spaces applications in Singapore • Airties: 802.11ac is not sufficient (c) Larkhill Consultancy Limited 2014