11.the theoretician and the practitioner represent a language community or its knowledge of the language

Information and Knowledge Management www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-5758 (Paper) ISSN 2224-896X (Online)
Vol 2, No.2, 2012

The Theoretician and the Practitioner Represent a Language
Community or its Knowledge of the Language

Ahmed Ali Abdel Sater
Department of English, Assiut University, Egypt
Tel:0020882354089 E-mail: abuwagdy_2005@yahoo.com

Safe El-Nasr Saleh Zanquor
Department of English, Assiut University, Egypt
Tel:00201220598376 E-mail: dr_safe42@yahoo.com

Abstract

There is no doubt that practice has determined theory, but theory has typically taken over the leading
role and at times has been disconnected from practice. In this respect education and linguistics reflect
the priorities of society.

The results of this paper's data show a strongly prevailing difference in the responses of our
informants towards the eight items of the suggested questionnaire. Hence, this difference supports the
fact that the theoretician and the practitioner can claim to represent a language community or its
knowledge of the language.

Keywords: The theoretician , the practitioner, integrated teamwork.

Objective of this Paper:

The objective of this paper is to clarify that there is a close relationship between theory and practice
in the Language Community or its Knowledge of the Language.

1. Introduction

At the beginning, the researcher will clarify the meaning of theory and practice, "A theory is an idea
and hypothesis which explains some things.
Practice is an exercise and application of any task or theory or in other words translation of an idea
into action, On the lighter side: Theory is where you know everything but nothing works. Practice is
where everything works but nobody knows why" .( Maiwandwall, 2011).

The serious problems of connecting theory with practice in applied linguistics and language teaching
are surveyed in view of the symptomatic disconnections of theory from practice in theoretical
linguistics. The relationship between theory and practice can form a difficult problem in almost all
fields of human activity. In most fields, human practices were well constructed long before theories
started to be produced and have also played an important role in the history of communities.

"Theory and Practice in the Teaching of Writing is designed to foster reflection on how theory
impacts practice, enabling prospective teachers to develop their own comprehensive and coherent
conception of what writing is or should be and to consider how people learn to write" ( Clark 2002) .

37

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

2.The Relationship Between Theory and Practice

The researcher expects that practice would play an effective role also in determining what kinds of
theories should be produced. In fact, theory has typically overcame the basic role and at times has
been isolated from practice altogether. This strategy allows a community or its institutions, especially
education, to maintain an official theory of humanity, equality, and efficiency.

"We examine three related ways in which the gap between theory and practice has been framed. One
approach views it as a knowledge transfer problem, a second argues that theory and practice
represent distinct kinds of knowledge, and a third incorporates a strategy of arbitrage leading to the
view that the gap is a knowledge production problem". (Andrew H Van De Ven, Paul E Johnson
2006 ).

It is evident that "the relationship between theory and practice also seems difficult within linguistics,
a branch of humanities science. In real life, we see a rich mosaic of practices relating to language,
ranging from the general operations of language learning and ordinary conversation over to highly
specialized strategies of communication such as translating poetry" (Beaugrande, R. de. 1997).

This similarity suggests a principle which, according to Widdowson H.G. has hardly been raised in
the central work on applied linguistics: how far a theory is applicable to practice is a good measure of
how far the theory is valid as a theory (Widdowson H.G. 1990 ).

In this connection, we can start by differentiating between the two main ways of going about
constructing theories of language.

"Fieldwork linguist is the backbone of an empirically-based science of linguistics. Firsthand
information on barely known minority languages is essential for our understanding of human
languages, their structural properties and their genetic relationships. ‘Immersion’ fieldwork as major
‘must’ is contrasted to ‘interview’ fieldwork as a less desirable option. We aim at an open-ended
documentation of each language, intended for various audiences, being both accessible and user-
friendly. This introductory essay introduces a number of issues concerning linguistic fieldwork,
discussed in some detail by the contributors to this issue, each a highly experienced fieldworker and a
recognized authority in their fields. This is what makes the issue special" (Alexandra, 2007).

On the contrary, homework linguists ‘work’ at ‘home’ or in the office with data that may have come
from different sources, such as samples from language textbooks, and finally to data invented by the
linguist during the homework process itself. (Beaugrande, R. de. 1997).

3. Review of Related Literature

3.1 Harste, J.C., Leland, C., Schmidt, K., Vasquez, V., & Ociepka (2004):

This article describes a study that examined the role that theory and practice play in the
preparation of new teachers. It presents multilayered observational, anecdotal, and
performance data relating to a group of undergraduate “interns” in an elementary teacher
education program in an urban location in the United States. These data lend support to the
hypothesis that a new teacher’s understanding of the relationship between theory and practice
influences the way she positions herself as a professional, the stance she takes in developing
curriculum, and whether she comes to see herself as a change agent who can make a
difference in the lives of children. Observational data obtained for four interns during their

38

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

student teaching experience and two years later when they were teaching on their own are
presented. The authors conclude that education is theory all the way down, and that teacher
educators have a particular obligation to address theoretical issues in their work with future
teachers.

3.2 Bongarets

This paper reports on two studies that addressed the issue of ultimate attainment by late second
language learners. The aim of the studies, which included a carefully screened group of highly
successful Dutch learners of English in their designs, was to determine whether or not late second
language learners who had achieved a native like performance in the pronunciation of a second
language could be identified. Speech samples provided by two groups of learners, one of which
consisted of highly successful learners only, and a native speaker control group were rated for accent
by native speakers of English. The ratings obtained by some learners were within the range of the
ratings assigned to the native speaker controls. Such results suggest that it is not impossible to
achieve an authentic, native like pronunciation of a second language after a specified biological
period of time. Examination of the learning histories of the highly successful learners lead the authors
to argue that certain learner characteristics and learning contexts may work together to override the
disadvantages of a late start.

3.3 Ioup

This study concerns the ability of adults to achieve native like competence in second language when
the acquisition context lacks formal instruction and, therefore, more closely resembles the
environment for first language acquisition. The study presents the results of extensive testing of an
adult who has apparently acquired native proficiency in Egyptian Arabic (EA) in an untutored
setting. The goal is to determine to what extent her linguistic competence matches that of native
speakers. Measures employed to assess her level of achievement are a speech production task, a
grammatically judgment task, a translation task, an anaphoric interpretation task, and an accent
recognition task. Results are compared to those of native speakers as well as to those of a proficient
learner of EA with extensive formal instruction. The results lead the authors to reexamine the critical
period hypothesis while addressing the role of talent in adult language learning. The study concludes
with an evaluation of our subject's language learning history to discover what factors differentiate her
from less successful naturalistic adult acquirers.

3.4 Munro

Untrained native English listeners assigned foreign accent scores to sentence and narrative utterances
that had been rendered unintelligible through low-pass filtering. Utterances produced by native
English talkers were assigned consistently higher ratings than those produced by Mandarin-speaking
learners of English, even when the listeners were unfamiliar with the content. Because these filtered
speech stimuli contained very little of what could be considered segmental information, the results
suggest that untrained listeners can identify foreign-accented speech on the basis of no segmental
information alone, whether they are presented with material of known or of unknown content.
Acoustical analyses of the stimuli suggested that differences in speaking rates, intonation patterns,
and timing may have played a role in the listeners' assessments, although the cues to foreign-
accentedness may have varied from talker to talker and from utterance from utterance. Surprisingly,
no relationship was observed between the ratings of the filtered and unfiltered versions of the
nonnative stimuli.

39

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

3. 5 Slavoff

The present study evaluates the role of age on the rate of acquiring English as a second language in
an immersion setting. Subjects were children with native languages. typologically very different from
English. The children arrived in the US between the ages of 7 and 12 years and were tested on their
knowledge of English grammatical morphology and syntax at different lengths of stay in the US,
ranging from 6 months to 3 years. Subjects' performance was predicted by the length of their stay in
the US and by gender, with females outperforming males. Age of arrival played no role in predicting
subjects' rate of acquisition. Performance was very similar between two age groups examined (7-9-
and 10-12-year-old arrivals) throughout the 3 years measured. The present results suggest that, on
certain aspects of grammar, different-aged children acquire a second language during the first 3 years
of acquisition at similar rates when their native language is very different in typology from the target
language.

3.6 Discussion

From the previous studies, it is evident that there is a close relationship between theory and practice
in the Language Community or its Knowledge of the Language. By reviewing the above studies, the
researcher can deduce the following:

• Both of theory and practice play an integrated role in the central work on applied
linguistics.

• The role of the theoretician and the practitioner would be explicitly accounted for within the
theories, stipulating under what conditions a theory or practice is related to a given language
or to language as general conception, and how the theoretician and the practitioner can
claim to represent a language community or its knowledge of the language. (Beaugrande,
R. de. 1997).

4. Fieldwork Linguistics and Language Learning

Anyone who studies this research, it comes to his mind an important question, it is : what is the
difference between fieldwork linguistics and language learning?

The case of the fieldworker linguist differs from that of the language learner in the following
points:

(1) The fieldworker tries to learn from the society’s language from multiple viewpoints. On the
contrary, many of the language learners have one source, i.e. their tutors..

(2) "Fieldworkers are asked to gather their own systematic data corpus, but language learners are
given textbooks compiled by other people may be in some ways non-specialist persons"
(Beaugrande, R. de. 1997).

(3) The fieldworker is a well educated scholar who has the ability to commit to the task as compared
to those language learners who are children and teenagers.

These three points assure the success of the fieldworker as an ideal language learner, but the
expectation of failure causes apprehensions and painful worry for ordinary classroom learners.

40

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

Consequently, there is no doubt that a practice-driven theory needs to explain how cultural
communications happen and how they might be guided to meet the specific needs of second language
learning.

In this sphere, we can deduce that a practice-driven theory also needs to explain how both the
training of teachers and the role of learners in conventional classrooms might effectively compensate
the lack of opportunity for cultural immersion.

5. To What Extent can the Application of Homework Linguistics be expected?

Chomsky’s followers believe to have achieved this high-minded goal. Newmeyer’s (1980: 249)
Linguistic Theory in America presented Chomsky’s as ‘the world’s principal linguistic theory’, for
which ‘no viable alternative exists’; ‘the vast majority’ of ‘linguists’ ‘who take theory seriously
acknowledge their adoption of Chomsky’s view of language’.

A leading argument in Chomsky’s campaign was that fieldwork would never attain ‘the deeper and
more important notions of linguistic theory’, due to its ‘limitation-in-principle to classification and
organization of data’ (Chomsky 1965: 18).

Frankly and without exaggeration, we should not expect that reliable operational criteria for the
deeper and more important ideas of linguistic theory will ever be forthcoming because knowledge of
the language, like most facts of interest and importance, is neither presented for direct observation
nor extractable from data by inductive procedures of any known sort.

The gap between what real native speakers say or what real children learning the language do versus
what the theory said or implied about them was continually blurred by rhetorical double-tracking to
connect each theoretical construct with a conveniently commonsense misinterpretation.

in this case ‘theory of language’ rather than ‘theory of a particular language’ — with a systematic
ambiguity to refer both to the child’s innate predisposition to learn a language of a certain type and to
the linguist’s account of this (Chomsky 1965: 25).

Of course, there is no clear notion of how a child could learn a language as a set of formal rules,
witness his audaciously evasive ‘instantaneous model’ wherein ‘successful language acquisition

( SLA )’ happens in a single ‘moment’ (Chomsky 65: 36). Otherwise, he would have had to specify
how the LAD proceeds by building up rule after rule.

6. The attitude towards the relationship between theory and practice among a group of students in
Assiut university, Egypt

In addition to the differences of opinion about the relation between theory and practice, an attempt
will be made in this paper to investigate the attitude of a group of undergraduate students in Assuit
university , Egypt, towards this relation. A hundred informants of those students (50 males and 50
females ) studying at three colleges in Assiut university were selected (colleges of medicine ,
engineering and education.) all of whom are native speakers of Arabic but due to their educational
background all of them have learned English as a foreign language and use it as a medium of
instruction in their colleges a mixed methods approach to data collection was employed using a self
report questionnaire and key informants interview . the questionnaire includes eight items used
earlier by Chomsky 1985 (number 1), Ferguson 1983 (number 2-3) and by Dives 2003(number 4-8).
The informants were interviewed individually to answer some questions (appendix1) , then were
asked to fill in the eight items of the questionnaire by choosing one of the four variables (strongly
agree, agree, uncertain, and disagree). (appendix 2).

41

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

7. Results and Discussion

The results of our data show a systematic difference in the responses of the one hundred subjects
towards almost every item of the suggested questionnaire.

Examining table 1 closely, we see that the informants of our study have chosen the ‘’strongly agree’’
variable with a percentage 65% in their response to item number 1 , while they have chosen the same
variable (i.e. strongly agree ) with a percentage 60% related to item number 2; 90% related to item
number 3 and they have chosen the same variable (i.e. strongly agree ) with a percentage 51% related
to item number 4.

Also they have chosen the variable ( agree ) with a percentage 90,85,80 and 70 % for items 5,6,7 and 8 .

These results show a strongly prevailing difference in the responses of our informants towards the
eight items of the suggested questionnaire. Hence, this difference supports the fact that the
theoretician and the practitioner can claim to represent a language community or its knowledge of the
language and indeed there is a close relation between theory and practice.

8. Conclusion

At last, we can say that the expectations of application were determined before the theories were
constructed, accordingly, the results of this paper's data show that the role of the theoretician and the
practitioner would be integrated within the theories, and how the theoretician and the practitioner
can claim to represent a language community or its knowledge of the language.

References

Alexandra, Y. Aikhenvald (2007),' Linguistic fieldwork: setting the scene. Language Typology and
Universals': Vol. 60, No. 1, pp. 3-11.
Andrew H Van De Ven, Paul E Johnson ( 2006 ), 'Knowledge for theory and practice. Academy of
Management', Volume: 31, Issue: 4, Pages: 802-821
Beaugrande, R. de. (1980), 'Text, Discourse, and Process', Norwood, N.J.: Ablex.
Beaugrande, R. de. (1992),'The heritage of functional sentence perspective from the standpoint of text
linguistics', Linguistica Pragiensa 34/1-2: 2-26 and 55-86.
Beaugrande, R. de. (1996), 'New Foundations for a Science of Text and Discourse', Norwood, N.J.:
Ablex.
Beaugrande, R. de.(1997),'Theory and Practice in Applied Linguistics: Disconnection, Conflict, or
Dialectic?', Applied Linguistics 18/3, 1997, 279-313.
Chomsky, N. (1965), 'Aspects of the Theory of Syntax',Cambridge: M.I.T. Press.
Chomsky, N. (1975), ' Reflections on Language', New York: Pantheon Books.
Clark L. Irene, Irene L. Clark, (2002), "Concepts in Composition: Theory and Practice in the Teaching of
Writing". ( online ) Available:
http://www.langacademy.net/vb/showthread.php?10093-Concepts-in-Composition-Theory
Harste, J.C., Leland, C., Schmidt, K., Vasquez, V., & Ociepka (January/February 2004). Practice makes
practice, or does it? The relationship between theory and practice in teacher education.
Ioup, Georgette, Boustagui, E., El Tigi, M. and Moselle, M. (1994), 'Reexamining the critical period
hypothesis: A case study of successful adult SLA in a naturalistic environment.' Studies in Second
Language Acquisition 16.1: 73-98.
Maiwandwall, Barai Mobarez (2011). What_is_the_difference_between_theory_and_practice.
( online )Available: http://wiki.answers.com/ #ixzz1f7eR1ta2

42

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

Munro, M. J. (1995),''Nonsegmental factors in foreign accent.' Studies in Second Language
Acquisition', 17.1: 17-34.
Newmeyer, F. (1980), 'Linguistic Theory in America', New York: Academic.
Slavoff, G. R. and Johnson, J. S. (1995), 'The effects of age on the rate of learning a second language',
Studies in Second Language Acquisition 17.1: 1-16
Widdowson, H.G. (1990),' Aspects of Language Teaching,' Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Appendix One

The Questionnaire

Table( 1 )

The attitude towards the relation between theory and practice among some students in Assuit
university.

Items Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree
1-The relation between theory and practice in learning 65% 10% 10% 15%
the English language

2-The theoretician and the practitioner represent a 60% 20% 10% 10%
language community

3-The fieldwork linguist should be well-educated and 90% 3% 2% 5%
well-qualified person

4-The language learners are given books compiled by 51% 20% 20% 9%
other people

5-The field worker is doing under the conditions of 90% 2% 3% 5%
cultural immersion

6-The learners of foreign languages may have scant 85% 5% 5% 5%
contact with the culture

7-"The theory should provide a framework for a 80% 5% 5% 10%
permanent interaction among the individuals concerned
with teaching and learning of both native and all foreign
languages"

8-"It is necessary to share all the learners as a whole in 70% 15% 10% 5%
contact"

43

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

Appendix Two

The Interview Questions

What is your name?

In which university do you study?

What is your major?

Language Background

What language do you know? How well?

Have you lived abroad? If yes which country?

What is the percentage of your study material given in Arabic vs. English? ( % )

How would you compare your speaking/reading/listening and writing abilities in Arabic and English?
(%)

44

Vol 2, No.2, 2012

Table (2): Summary of Results

Attitude Standard Mean Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree

Deviation
Number Number Number Number
Item

% % % %

Strongly Agree 0,869 3,45 65 10 10 15 1

Agree 1,090 3,22 60 20 10 10 2

Uncertain 2,040 5.40 90 3 2 5 3

Strongly Agree 0,600 2, 90 51 20 20 9 4

Disagree 2,040 5, 40 90 2 3 5 5

Disagree 1,090 4,80 85 5 5 5 6

Disagree 1,010 4,00 80 5 5 10 7

Disagree 0,900 3,00 70 15 10 5 8

45

International Journals Call for Paper
The IISTE, a U.S. publisher, is currently hosting the academic journals listed below. The peer review process of the following journals
usually takes LESS THAN 14 business days and IISTE usually publishes a qualified article within 30 days. Authors should
send their full paper to the following email address. More information can be found in the IISTE website : www.iiste.org

Business, Economics, Finance and Management PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
European Journal of Business and Management EJBM@iiste.org
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting RJFA@iiste.org
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development JESD@iiste.org
Information and Knowledge Management IKM@iiste.org
Developing Country Studies DCS@iiste.org
Industrial Engineering Letters IEL@iiste.org

Physical Sciences, Mathematics and Chemistry PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Natural Sciences Research JNSR@iiste.org
Chemistry and Materials Research CMR@iiste.org
Mathematical Theory and Modeling MTM@iiste.org
Advances in Physics Theories and Applications APTA@iiste.org
Chemical and Process Engineering Research CPER@iiste.org

Engineering, Technology and Systems PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Computer Engineering and Intelligent Systems CEIS@iiste.org
Innovative Systems Design and Engineering ISDE@iiste.org
Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy JETP@iiste.org
Information and Knowledge Management IKM@iiste.org
Control Theory and Informatics CTI@iiste.org
Journal of Information Engineering and Applications JIEA@iiste.org
Industrial Engineering Letters IEL@iiste.org
Network and Complex Systems NCS@iiste.org

Environment, Civil, Materials Sciences PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Environment and Earth Science JEES@iiste.org
Civil and Environmental Research CER@iiste.org
Civil and Environmental Research CER@iiste.org

Life Science, Food and Medical Sciences PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare JBAH@iiste.org
Food Science and Quality Management FSQM@iiste.org
Chemistry and Materials Research CMR@iiste.org

Education, and other Social Sciences PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Education and Practice JEP@iiste.org
Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization JLPG@iiste.org Global knowledge sharing:
New Media and Mass Communication NMMC@iiste.org EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's
Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy JETP@iiste.org Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP
Historical Research Letter HRL@iiste.org Open Archives Harvester, Bielefeld
Academic Search Engine, Elektronische
Public Policy and Administration Research PPAR@iiste.org Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate,
International Affairs and Global Strategy IAGS@iiste.org OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial Library ,
Research on Humanities and Social Sciences RHSS@iiste.org NewJour, Google Scholar.

Developing Country Studies DCS@iiste.org IISTE is member of CrossRef. All journals
Arts and Design Studies ADS@iiste.org have high IC Impact Factor Values (ICV).

11.the theoretician and the practitioner represent a language community or its knowledge of the language

More Related Content

What's hot (15)

Viewers also liked (9)

Similar to 11.the theoretician and the practitioner represent a language community or its knowledge of the language (20)

More from Alexander Decker (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

11.the theoretician and the practitioner represent a language community or its knowledge of the language