20071104 verification konev_lecture11

‘gg
Ž
Œ‹‹‰ ˆ… … Vh ‡†ˆ… … Vf
```Šv¦r©ˆgv¦„‰R ƒ
‚€ p~}jtr qvggywvjtr qo
us p| {zxx us p
”tnl¤jDD¤D`¦W¤t¦S¦`¦”
mh k ih d • • g f — ˜ e d ™ ˜ — – •
dPsh ’ ‘UdPˆ… ‡ †U…h
S¦©“S‰vESv¦4„
ƒ €h€hx w usfq p hfd b aXX VU TRP
'‚rtrWyvtr©¦igec``YW¦SSQI
£5GG 8 7¨ $!C !3 8 7¨ 5$!$33
'4¦'©HFEE'D#BA@96%4'$
2 1$0 )!£¡ £¨$¡ ! £ ¥ ¡ £¨£ ¥£¡
§¤©©¤('%# §©©§¦¤¢

‘g‚
Ž
¹¸ ·±°¶ ´ ² ± ¯ ® ¬ © « ª © ¨ §¦ ¥ ¤£
º tWgn„‚~µe³rn°Sv6riri‚rvˆ@¢ ¡ t
F(t ∧ Gt)
hd f†w hd† œ žœ
‰D‰S¦‰S ŸqU
t ¬t
d h €hP…Px ˆ šP €h p pU…fh p††q
¦c‚rgWSW›„¤r'™vDS'S‚c˜
!£ !3 – • 1$0 )!£¡ ’ “
©Š—F#¦H''¤”Yv’

‘g‚
Ž
ƒ f† d U €P q…x p VUd h š†Ê w U Ï Ò V… hdfP šd h €
Ut‰`h„Bš¦„‰dvDS†ÓBi¦„‚ÐŠQˆ¦‰D‰¦ˆ¦cqÊ
ÎiDWÊ‚Ñwv‘SW¦hˆS‚`…›BšÐ‰‰gD‰‚ŸD„B6S¦ˆS‰¦WÃ
ˆf x us Ps R†P U fPÊdf†P ÏÊ† Î pP V…Pd h…
UsP €PdÍUh…x pUh…
PSvSc„‰Si¦WDÌt¦Wtf È
DSNF (¬ϕ)
Vš€ h€ … x Ê pPf†U† pUh…
D¦d¦c‚hrgPWSPWË¼S‰SSÉt¦Wtf È
Ç Æ Å Ä R pU €hdU…
À¼¢Ht4r„vÃ
¬ϕ = ¬F(t ∧ Gt) ≡ G(¬t ∨ F¬t)
qdf†whd† PUsqTU…fh pPqdU…fq p††q
‚D‰S¦‰SÂSvvvvDSÁSW‚vDW©S‚Wc˜
£$ £ ¥ 7 5
'À§¿¾½¼Š»

‘gŽ Þ

GF¬w
G(w → X(¬t ∨ w ))∧
G(t → w )∧
R pP €PdU…
™Sc„„vÃ
G(t → F¬t)
pP ÝUxP…P
SQvSWS©Ã
ƒƒƒU € Ò š u p hf‘ Î pUs phx†
‚‚4lBÉ6yil6tD6¦WS4Ü
¬ϕ = G(¬t ∨ F¬t)
Û Ú Ù × 0 ¥¡ !
“EØÖ ¦ÕÔ

'Dá§''c''§¤¤#ÂÔ
)$!C à 0G£ß¨£ ¥£¡

U = {G(t → w )} E = {GF¬w }
S = {G(w → X(¬t ∨ w ))} I = {}

t, w ¬t, w

t, ¬w ¬t, w
¬t, ¬w

‘gŽ â

'Dá§''c''§¤¤#ÂÔ
)$!C à 0G£ß¨£ ¥£¡

U = {G(t → w )} E = {GF¬w }
S = {G(w → X(¬t ∨ w ))} I = {}

t, w ¬t, w

¬t, ¬w ¬t, w
t, ¬w

‘gŽ â

'Dá§''c''§¤¤#ÂÔ
)$!C à 0G£ß¨£ ¥£¡

U = {G(t → w )} E = {GF¬w }
S = {G(w → X(¬t ∨ w ))} I = {}

t, w ¬t, w

¬t, ¬w

t, ¬w

‘gŽ â

'%c§§#ÀD0 ã
£å! ¨ ä

t, w
¬t, w t, w ¬t, w
t, ¬w
¬t t
t, ¬w
¬t
t
¬t, ¬w

t, ¬w

‘g‚æ
Ž

‘gŽ ï ¬w EG
U f† hd U š €Pd q… x† pPUd h š†Ê í ìë
D‰`‰t¦„„DvSîSii¦„‚9† tt‚ê Ê šÊ p… h é œ ž è pP V…Pd h…
Dq¼v¦¢Ÿ¼SgS„¦W§Ã
t, ¬w
¬t, ¬w
t
¬t
t, w ¬t, w
£¨£ ¥£¡ç !
''§¦¤l4#ÕÔ

Ž
‘g‚¡
(qi , wi , qi +1 ) ∈ ∆ q0 ∈ Q 0 q0 q1 q2
w
U A
a ¦w‘‚t‚‚ Îƒ Î Î
ƒ ƒfƒƒ
wUvsBrh‰†`‚†Âˆt‰†`hWiˆB„PW‚¦¤„¦„`Wx û s iW©¦„Dq ivô yñ ‚r‰W§Ã
V f h f s š fqdh €Pš†h
Σ N
q qfq phfd øÿ þ €hh… w
ƒ ø d SýVSvt9n“‰¦„Â`tSW¦gS‚`… û t‰‰'Ã
Í U U T R s Ê éñ hd h š† P h s ‘ P s hR †P ˆf†Ê
F
w s Vhf h U Ï Òq pUsU… hdf†P ühs
tUv‚i‰†`‚† WŠQD©tDtvDx ‰D‰‚—‚W6p û Q0
wvBrf‰`‚†Õ¼viBr`iÑ‰D‰‚—‚6p û
Us Vh †h usˆ šq‘qs hdf†P ühs
∆⊆Q ×Σ×Q
q € P…P P s Ý hsf
%rh‚gWSx›iUDSPQ¦WDSh û
Q
w Vhf†h† hdf†P ühs
tUvs‚i‰`‚¾‰D‰‚—‚W6p û
Σ
fUdq éšq w us‘Psh
ivŠ¦‚¾§vtS¦ˆR û
P c€ ú
A = (Σ, Q, ∆, Q0 , F ),
ùø`SW§qyt©ÕW©¦„eb
÷ ö õ óô ò ñ U Ò „ f q p h f d
ð ω
7 5$ 5¡
6%Ð#¼$

Ž
‘g‚
L(A1 × A2 ) = L(A1 ) ∩ L(A2 )
A2 A1
U 6DiW©¦„v¾¼vvD%‚rB¦ˆ§SÂivSSS‚‚WSWx
U pqfq p hfdq ussq €qÍ Îd hR uÍ V PUsP‘P†P…P
wU Ï Ò Vš†U‘ ud Î pfU… šq w usˆ šqU p hsU šhx fPÊdf†P Ï
ŠQD„St§l6Div¦h ú rË§v‚`6¦WBiWÕ‰‰gD‰‚ŸDÊ È
L(A) = L(A) = Σω L(A)
L(A) A
qR uÍV PUsPs šhx h € wU Òq pUsU…x
g§SSvSWiW¦c tŠÏ v©vvv4Î
A
f hfdq ˆfU h…f†hx hs üh
rq©p¦igDÂDi¦WD‰`WÂr'p t©ËrW©¦„D¢¼¦WvD%¢©Ã
U Ò „ Êfq phfdq Ê phssq € h
a ufRq
§D‰D¢
w} ¨©¨¦
§§§§¥L(A) = {w |A
R uÍ
S¤
w A
A
ƒ is r‚‚WvyŠQD©tvvvx
q €hh…x wU Ï Òq pUsU…
w
f Ê f† Ï Ê† U š†P p hfq p hfd V†fPq p Us U…
‰P‚ˆdt‰‚P D„›B„‚¤Î ¦W©¦„vq q‰©tvvvx „¦¦š È
r
hdh
qf ∈ F
ƒ hf†q‘ hs‘Ps hR†P
¤‰SÑWtS¦ˆS‚`… d q‰SSWt‰„d
r
V†fPq‘P… f†
h f† w hR qR U š† €h h … x w U Ò q p U s U … ˆ f† € hh …
inW¦gvgy„‚P ‚r‰vytŠÏ v©vvvx D‰‚P r‚‚WÃ
7 BBc©Ó£ÐÕÔ
¥8!3 £ ¢ 2$ ¨ !

Ž
‘gr$# ...
b n1 ab n2 ab n3 b ω
b n1 ab n2 b ω
pU…fh p††q
tvtS'S‚Wc˜
b n1 ab ω
pU…fh p††q
tvtS'S‚Wc˜
pU…fh p††q
tvtS'S‚Wc˜
bω
L
pU…fh p††q
tvtS'S‚Wc˜
a SEh ú P QD©vtDvx
R uÍV Ï ÒqpUsU…
Î U Ò „ qfq p hfd hssqd h… UsU p…PfP fPÊdf† ÏÊ† P
t©ËiW©¦„vq h ú WDv‚¦Wvt6DS‰c€ ‰‚ˆt‰‚P D„Šl‡
a w ∈ L(A) ⇐⇒ w
wUsP € ühd h š†U ‘ Phs ‘Ps hR fU ü…P €h
tvScQr‚ˆ¦„iE`WSW¦ˆyiÂgS¤r‚† aR uÍ
`S¦V
b a, b
fq phfd
W©¦„eb
$5$ 5¡ 7¨ ß£¨ 0 G 0$0 ! 5G!3 0$5 £G¡ £
¾'%ÐÀ$ EË'¼#tHÁ¤Q¦©Éc¤Ð

‘g„‘
Ž a ∧ G(a → Xb) ∧ G(b → Xa)?
C©U£§ª ¥§
Vr0‚‰Ÿiy¥
¹C©¬S¤¬¤Q ©
ˆPD‰FD„‰R‰ªT
a ∧ G(a → X¬a) ∧ G(¬a → Xa)
IG E¤CA
PHF„DB¤ @
us fP‘ V†ˆ fq‘P… f†d Ps fP üh p P qs h 8 VUs Vhf†h
¼vt‰i d q„tr`SWt‰„›Õ‰—‚'›s i¦%9vv‚‰`‚†
a
us fP‘Ps d V†ˆ fq‘P… f†d fP üh hf‘ Î p U fP p
¼vt‰iSW yU q„tr`SWt‰„y‰—‚'p i'6tt‰'vq 7
σ2i = {a} σ |= ϕ
ϕ
ƒ hf
icÎ U š†
„‚P
hf‘ Î w hRq u šÊ p … h é œ žœ fPÊd f† Ï Ê† P a fR q
i4t¦gvSf Bq¼D¦ Ÿqy‰‰gD‰‚P t„ŠWs t‰D¢
a
ƒ VU s Vhf†h† u s f5‘ d V†fPq‘P… f† p h… hfhR d ÎR uÍ V fPq p U s U …
vv‚‰`‚›¼vt‰6¢Yy‰`SWD‰‰d ¦W¦Sˆ¢4SS¦Ð‰©vtDvx
3 )
4210(
a '
fq phfd
W©¦„eb
$ G •$¨% £5ç$! 7
À©ác'44¼©B'Ë¢

‘gr
Ž
FA = Q ∪ {ι}
Q0,A {ι}
α = L(s ) ¨ ∆A : ((s, α, s ) ∈ ∆) ⇐⇒ (s, s ) ∈ T
QA = S ∪ ι
ΣA = 2Prop
P c€ ú
A = (ΣA , QA , ∆A , Q0,A , FA ),
U Ò „ fq p hfdq RqR qsPšdqf† €P…x ˆf u … fP üh
t©ËW©¦„DDgyiSgvS‰¤„vÐt'¦›‰er'p
S = (Q, T , q0 , L)
d h €hP…Px q pPf†
¦cr‚gWSE©Si‰iU È
→
8 2 W 75$ 5¡
§Š¢X%ÐÀ$ ¡ ¥8£!£3 7 £5G
#BD¼'¼ÖE'4¦' ã

‘gr
Ž
r qi qi
Pi ∈ F
ƒ hf†q‘ hs ‘Ps hR†P d V†fPq‘P… f†
¤‰`ÑWSW¦ˆS‚`… Yy‰`SWD‰‰d a
qÝvS‰dýqf‰cWwDs
s U …P V† P € q p h € üqR d U š† €hh…x wU Ï Òq pUsU…
¦cQrg¢yB„‚P r‚‚WvŠQD©tDtv§Ã
F ⊆ 2Q
wvBVr‰`h‚† dt‰‚PerhW6pyWŠQÒD©vtDvx ‰D‰‚—‚W6p û
Us hf† f† ü s U Ï q pUsU… hdf†P ühs
Q0
wU Vhf† † usˆ šq‘qs hdf†P ühs
vsBr‰`h‚Õ¼viBr`iÑ‰D‰‚—‚6p û
∆⊆Q ×Σ×Q
q €hP Px P s Ý hsf
%r‚gW…S›iUDSPQ¦WDSh û
Q
w Vhf†h† hdf†P ühs
tUvs‚i‰`‚¾‰D‰‚—‚W6p û
Σ
fUdq éšq w us‘Psh
ivŠ¦‚¾§vtS¦ˆR û
P c€ ú
A = (Σ, Q, ∆, Q0 , F ),
8 2 W 75$ 5¡$ £ 7¨¨ ¢ ä
§Š¢a%ÐÀîÐ'£ `l©ä Y

‘gŽ Þ

∼
ƒUÒ
¦t©„
fq phfdq w uss Ï…h…
W©¦„D›§vvSP ¦```h éq wUR†P‘sP €Pdhx w ussqdh…UTÊ€P
… ú SS‚ivSc„‰¦WÑ§vvD‰¦W¦D¦„¤˜
eeec £ß$
fd©'4ç b

'D@''c©©§¦¤#3 §'ŠÕÔ
)$!C à 0G£ß¨£ ¥£¡ – !£ !
D‰‚‚¦Qg
pUf†Êxh U = {G(t → w )} E = {GF¬w }, GFw
S = {G(w → X(¬t ∨ w ))} I = {}

t, w ¬t, w

¬t, ¬w

t, ¬w

‘gŽ â

§Š¢i%Ð#¼ØË'ýh©l©§'ŠÕÔ
8 2 W 5$ 5¡$ à 7¨¨£ ¢ ää – !£ !

a1 a2

a2
s0 s1
a1
a1 = {t, w }
a1
a2 a3 a2 = {¬t, w }
a1 a3 a3 = {¬t, ¬w }
a4 = {t, ¬w }
a4
a2 s2

ι a3
a3
P1 = {s0 , s1 }, P2 = {s2 }

‘gr æ
Ž

‘gŽ ï
x =y ¹ I U§
B©rr‰ª q
¹
x =n y =0 ¤ „C «¦y£
¹ y =i ¤C
„I «
q ∈ Pi x = i − 1 «
¦y£ pp
(q, a, q ) ∈ ∆ ((q, x), a, (q , y ) ∈ ∆
U U š†
B„‚P
P c€ ú
B = (Σ, Q × {0, . . . , n}, ∆ , Q0 × {0}, Q × n)
pU h…f†h Ã ƒ U Ò „ fq p hfdq w uss Ï …h…
¦WD‰`l'¦t'Ër©¦igD¾vDSP ¦```h
A = (Σ, Q, ∆, Q0 , {P1 , . . . , Pn })
ˆf†Ê
t‰‰'Ã
→
8 2 W 7 5$ 5¡
Š›a6%ÐÀ$ 8 2 W 75$ 5¡$ £ 7¨¨ ¢ ä
§Š¢a%ÐÀîÐ'£ `l©ä Y

Ž
‘gr$¡
Gª«tG v ¥£«¤Q S ˆªª© ‡¤
‘`v6 RR‚WD„‰Bir`
§ ®u¦§ „ EC«¦ § uC§v ¤€u ¤Q
‚ªyBi¤…r0iv¤ ƒ„§rˆwqVƒr‰‚£ q†
« © ¤ h V ϕ
©riªr‰ª¦r‰QF¤D¬Ÿ¤ 0#B§yu® SVÂiUvS„SxP‚‚WwSgP¤…EP WDyÀr¢D„Di„idiv«S‰¦WÃ
© d¦uˆRC € Í vy« P s ¤ P Q S † §B C x 6§ u š 0« ¤‰¦‚C‚£ ©¤ Î Q DfWU0… P d h …
‘C v U Chf†Êx ˆ¤t
¬ϕ ¤ C§ ¤ v uC« ¤¦C£¤Q ¤t
„QxBEwgCD6§Àr0D„Di„dW0« ss
A(ϕ)
fq phfdq ˆfUh…f†h
W©¦„Dt¦D‰`©Ã
A(S)
ϕ S
fq phfdq ˆfUh…f†h
W©¦„Dt¦D‰`©Ã
q šÊ p… h é žœ
¦ˆ¼v¦¢œ qyU d h €hP…Px q pPf†U† us
¦¤r‚gSWÕ©S‰SSÓvDq g
C 5
r§¼Šb

Ž
‘gr$
O((|S| × |ψ|) × 2|ϕ| )luC£¤ª ‡¤
rBDi„ŸS k
ƒqdf†P ühs p
t‰t‰‚erW6“h ú P QD©tvvvx
Ï ÒqpUsU…
P €Ud d ˆfUÍq… ud hs üh p Uf†hdU š€Pdq…x† VUdhš†Ê P uf†h…
cWi¢¢DiSW§ÑWÂ‚'ÑD‰`‰t„‰DvS“Wi¦„‚F©t‰`WÃ
O(|S| × 2|ϕ|+|ψ|) luC£¤ª ‡¤
rBDi„ŸS k
ϕ ⇐⇒ S |= (Gψ) → ϕ j™ih e™˜—
f‚‘–gfd–•” S |=ψ
Êdf†w hd† R ˆfUdq…h
ˆt‰i¦‰S tiDv`¤€
hs üh p Uf†hdU š €Pdq…x† VUd h š†Ê žœ d hf‘ Î pPqsÍ u
WÂr'D‰`‰t¦„„DvS“¦¦„‰Ðœ ˆ¢yi©6SWSÓ¾“
5G¡ ¥£¡$!3G •¡ G
6¦l¦§Q¤¤4'½4#E’

Ž
‘gr“#
¸GC© §ª¯ §¥ ¦©v ¤
gPV`—‚jÀyirqw„¦
©«ª©v§C£ ¬©¦Q ©¤ªC¥§Q E
rWSy6‰Dtq„iŠ„Vi‚‹F¤ @
v ¤¥ ¬®¦ ¤Q ‡ ˆªU«C£§U ®« ¥G ¬
Fycqv‰6`tWV‚W‘‚D0Fq© ’
ˆ G E¦ ¤ Ž « « © ¬¤ E S ¤ ¬ ‡§¥ ® ¬ Œ § G E E§¦ ¤¦Q C©§ ¬ ‡¤¦
4j6vÀRF¦qD„%FD§‘qÐSv›R‚ª ‹6‚tF‰ŠV‰t‰v¤ @
£ª§
C § E ¤ C v S ˆ ª U © ª ¤ v £ C © G U ¦ U « T q ‚ÍiU‰ U f
BF„D6§ ˆ6`0‰vy¥ ‰j®‰Vˆ‘`¦¦vyrS6tCp¦ trx ƒ
ˆˆr0«iv¤ ƒ„ÀBir`ˆDy‰0‚‰ŸB6D„SP`‚‚§
EC ¦ § © ˆªª©© ¬©¦Q£§¦ © ˆªª ¤¦‡ª«£
ø o † s ô¤rÿ ƒƒ„s tí vfo õ €ë DEs Rƒ|{©z¦vg¢SSSŠS¤
† … ‚ v ~ñ qo } þ y U U TqR U éU TPx† R uÍ
X¦xt0X †PDr‰†`hcÉp¦t‘Bi…rxÂd49‘`x0Ft¤rqp¢ÕDiS`SWc˜
x xÊf € hs Uš Ê 8 †‹w d vusœ qo ò d qsqfh…q…Íq
wP šP €h p žœ UR…Pd h…x q pPf†
S„cr'yœ q“SvS‰¦Wv¾©S‰SU È
Ún m
jdÙ

‘g„
Ž © ªº µ«« ´³²— ·Á² ªº µ ² ³
h0f¢Ä‚fV2˜DVD›fd¦0‘ ª‚ ¶2˜´· ³€·¶D¼— ˜ · Á ² šV¼ ¶
Â¿Ã© tfDV€·«¼« ‚DfVd›»fdVª³x2•¶‘–•‚€·¶
ª ¾ ¶ ¶ ´ ³VÁ ³f¼½f
6D22´–•¬²dV2•dVf½½ ª ˜ ² • 0½ À
ª¤£ ž ™ ± ®˜
tfd¢ž–¡‚2Ÿy‘f–¹¿¶t½ D• –À¶¶« ¶ Dª¾dD¶22´¬•–•¬²´
ª ˜ ² • 0½ À
ª ¼ ¶ – ² • ³VÁ ³f¼½f
tD€·ffV2•dVf½½
ª ¨ §Ÿ¡ ™ ± ® ˜
tf–œ‚fd›‘f–¹¿¶tDd½• D–À¬•¼ ¶« ¶ – ²
ªF¶ D€·ff•
ª ˜ ² • 0½ À
ª ¾ ¶ ¶ ´ ³ · ³VÁ ³f¼½f
6D22´–•¬²‘¬·PxV2•dVf½½
ª ¤ £ ž œ ™ ˜ ¶d ´ ³ •
tfd¢ž–¡‚2ŸD2œV›‘f¿¶–¹½± Dt2´2®¾ DD¶–À¶–•¬•«¬²‘¬·P·
š º ¶ • µ « « ½ — ¼ ¶— · ¶ ¼
–¹¸D€·¢¶‚fV ´ ³ ² FD€·‚–f€·³–d˜² »
ª © ¤ £ ž ¥ ¨ § Ÿ ¡ ¥ ¤ £ ª 2Ÿžd ® VœDdšD¬•«y˜V—d–f•‘
dfd¢ž–¡‚2Ÿ`tf–œ‚fd¦tfd¢ž–¡‚tD2œ°¯t›‰Vdf‘”” ±2˜DV˜D•yV™˜ df˜¬•D—´ V•D—
!£ !
'ŠÕÔ

‘gr‘
Ž
Ún m Ù ¡ 5 G à ! 5 G
jdH¦6¦'ÀB6¦E’

20071104 verification konev_lecture11

More Related Content

What's hot (16)

More from Computer Science Club (20)

20071104 verification konev_lecture11