SlideShare a Scribd company logo
New Worlds ImagerWebster CashUniversity of Colorado
New Worlds Imager 
An Alternative to TPF 
Webster CashUniversity of ColoradoJim GreenEric SchindhelmNishanthRajanJeremy KasdinPrinceton UniversityBob VanderbeiDavid SpergelEd TurnerSara SeagerCarnegie Institution –WashingtonAlan SternSouthwest Research Institute –BoulderSteve KilstonBall AerospaceErik WilkinsonMike LeiberJim LeitchJon ArenbergNorthrop GrummanRon PolidanChuck LillieWillard SimmonsMITand growing…
Exo-Planets 
•Exo-planets are the planets that circle stars other than our Sun. 
•There are probably 10,000 exo-planets within 10pc (30 light years) of the Earth.
Are Any Habitable?? 
Are Any Occupied??? 
To Be Human Is to Want to Know
Some Poetry (?) 
Certain knowledge of 
a destination 
could 
drive future generations 
to cross 
the awful gulf of interstellar space.
The Problem with Exo-Planet Studies 
•Planets are lost in the glare of parent star. 
•The Earth as viewed from light years is 
10 billion times fainter than the Sun.
Terrestrial Planet Finder•Telescopes must be PERFECT to suppress scatter: λ/5000 surface, 99.999% reflection uniformity•TPF is verydifficult•Is there any easier way?
New Worlds ImagerConventionalTelescopeStarshade
A Pinhole Camera Meets The Requirements: 
Perfect Transmission 
No Phase Errors 
Scatter only from edges –can be very low 
Diffraction Issues Remain 
Large Distance Set by 0.01 arcsecrequirement 
diffraction: λ/D = .01” ÆD = 10m @500nm 
geometric: F = D/tan(.01”) = 180,000km
Focal Plane
View Back Toward StarshadeBackground Stars & Zodiacal LightStarshadeDiffracted Starlightaround edge fallsoutside slitSpectrographEntrance Slit(Projected) Planet LightBackground Light
Starshade Aperture Shapes
View Dark Side of Starshade 
Target 
Sun
“Standard” Observatory Views Starshade 
~1” resolution or somewhat better 
(not necessarily diffraction limited) 
High efficiency, low noise spectrograph (e.g. COS)
Reduces Noise Almost to Zero 
Detector Noise (counts) 
Diameter (m) 
Required integration time (days) to get 100,000 counts 
MCPglass 
MCPSi 
CCD 
1 
28 
363 
15 
604800 
5 
1.1 
15 
0.6 
24192 
10 
.3 
4 
0.1 
6070 
15 
.1 
2 
0.06 
2700 
20 
.07 
1 
0.04 
1512 
Assumptions: Fλ~3e-9 photons/cm2/sec/Åfor Earth at 10pc, system efficiency ~0.35, λ=5000Å. Background calculations done using MCPglass=0.5 counts/cm2/sec, MCPsilicon=0.02 counts/cm2/sec, CCD=1e-read noise and readout every 20 minutes, and a 0.03x1 mm resolution element with 0.010 mm pixels.
Orbital Considerations 
Need Study
Planet Finding Mode 
Solar System at 10pcMarsVenusEarthJupiterEarthVenus 
Survey to 7AU 
Survey Habitable Zone
Inverse Pinhole 
Occulter 
Pinspeck 
•Smaller Starshade 
–Create null zone, image around occulter 
•10m shade, 1m diffraction limited telescope and 20,000km separation would work 
•Observe entire planetary system at once 
•Highly affordable. Could build today
Predecessors 
BOSS 
http://umbras.org/ 
Starkmanshowed that starlight 
could be reduced by 10,000x.
Pinspeckwith 1m Telescope50,000 seconds400,000 secondsJupiterEarthVenusMars
Pinspeckwith 8m Telescope 
50,000 secondsEarthMarsHalley’s Comet
Simulated Data 
Earth at 10pc
Spectroscopic Biomarkers 
WaterNecessary for habitability 
OxygenFree oxygen results only from active plant life 
OzoneResults from free oxygen 
Nitrous OxideAnother gas produced by living organisms 
MethaneLife indicator if oxygen also present 
VegetationRed edge of vegetation at 750nm
Photometry 
Photometric Imaging is Possible!
Pale Blue Planet Mission
PBP Requirements 
100km Resolution at 10pc is 0.06 micro-arcseconds 
Interferometer requires a 1500km baseline 
And the same collecting area as Keck Telescope in Hawaii 
(10 meter diameter) 
We can do this right now if we have the will.
The “Freeway Mission” From the movie Contact. Dr Arrowaygets a brief glimpse of this alien landscape.
Freeway Requirements 
300m resolution at 10 parsecs = 0.02 nano-arcseconds 
500,000km baseline 
Huge collecting area –one square kilometer 
Right now this is impossibly expensive, 
but not necessarily tomorrow
The New Worlds ImagerA simulated exo-planet at 500 km resolution. Earth at 200km resolution. Oceans, continents and clouds are visible.
NWI Conceptcollector craft1500kmstarshadescollector craftcombiner 180,000km 1500km
Holding the Arrayplanet collimatorfield star collimatorprimary collectorto combinerplanet beamsfield star beamsDelay Lines –Mixers -Detectorsplanet Detectors
Fits Into NASA Planning•Identify Earth-like Planets•Search for oceans•Search for unambiguous tracers of life•Study new eco-systemsLife FinderObjective•Reacquire Earth- like planets•Perform spectroscopy with λ/δλ> 1000•Search forH20, O2, N2O, O3, etc•Survey dozens of nearby systemsScienceGoalInstrumentRequirements•Suppress starlight to below 10-10•Separate planets at .01” •Operate in visible or near IR•10m class aperture for signal•High Efficiency Spectrograph•Low noise detectors•Two craft•Shaped aperture in large, deployable light stop•10m, 1”class telescope with Rowland spectrograph•Formation flying to ~1m line of sight at 180,000km•L2 or drift away orbitMissionRequirements•HST•JWST•TPF•LISA•SIMRelevantPredecessorsNew WorldsObserverNew WorldsImagerPictures of Earth- like Planets with 100km Resolution•WorldsObserverImagerPictures Resolution
New Worlds Observer Roadmap 
•PinspecksvsPinholes 
•Minimize Size (and hence cost) 
•Deployment of Starshade 
•Orbit Tradeoff 
•Formation Flying 
•Telescope Design 
•Simulations and Limitations
New Worlds Imager Roadmap 
•Formation Flying Requirements 
•Interferometer Design 
•Image Formation 
•Pathlength Nulling 
•Simulations 
N.B. NWI is very challenging, but it’s the first true planet 
imaging architecture for which we can write specifications that 
are not ridiculously difficult.
Size Minimization 
•Pinspeckif at all possible 
•Diffraction dominates signal but drops with size of starshade. 
•I have five mathematicians working on the problem. (N.B. Mathematicians are not used to working on deadlines!)
Orbital Analysis 
At L4, L5 or any Sun-centered orbit, it takes .001N 
continuous thrust to keep a 1000kg craft in alignment. 
Milli-Newton thrusters are now available, and a few square 
meters of solar panels can power it. 
These thrusters can move the starshadeto the next target in 
a day or two. 50 planetary systems per year.
Formation Flying 
1W laser can be seen at 200,000km. 
Can track relative to back ground stars. 
Craft need to be designed to find each 
other and align against sky. Background Stars & Zodiacal LightStarshadeDiffracted Starlightaround edge fallsoutside slitSpectrographEntrance Slit(Projected) Planet LightBackground Light
NIAC: 
They Bring Good Things To Life 
•Press Interest 
–Publicity Crucial to Shifting Opinions 
•Industry Interest 
–Northrop Grumman Putting in Resources 
•Government Interest 
–White Paper Put Us in NASA Roadmap 
–Goddard Studying This as Alternative 
•TPF Off-ramp?
Conclusion 
•Needs ThoroughStudy 
•If No Major Problems Emerge, then… 
•We have an exo-planet observatory concept that can be implemented with today’s technology 
•Biggest Problem may be political 
By 2011 
By 2018

More Related Content

PDF
1200 cash[2]
PPT
Marois triumf-20101120pub
PDF
1316 ditto[1]
PPS
Hubble space telescope
PDF
Astronomy - State of the Art - Telescopes
PDF
1200 cash[1]
PPT
The hubble space telescope
PDF
Institute for Interstellar Studies
1200 cash[2]
Marois triumf-20101120pub
1316 ditto[1]
Hubble space telescope
Astronomy - State of the Art - Telescopes
1200 cash[1]
The hubble space telescope
Institute for Interstellar Studies

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Hubble Space telescope
PPSX
Pwr10Show
PPT
Hubble Space Telescope
PDF
The Square Kilometre Array Science Cases (CosmoAndes 2018)
PPTX
The Hubble Space Telescope
PPT
Hubble Telescope
PPT
Hubble Space telescope
PPTX
Hubble Telescope
PPTX
Applications Of Computer Science in Astronomy
PPT
Telescopes & astronomy andie
PPTX
Hubble space telescope
PPTX
Hubble Telescope
PPT
Space telescopes
PPTX
Lunar Ultraviolet Cosmic Imager (LUCI)
PPTX
Telescopes 101
PDF
PDF
UK Space Conference: James Webb Space Telescope (Gillian Wright)
PPTX
Hubble telescope [Dev N Patel]
PPTX
[Challenge:Future] Space Debris
PPT
Sect 8.1
Hubble Space telescope
Pwr10Show
Hubble Space Telescope
The Square Kilometre Array Science Cases (CosmoAndes 2018)
The Hubble Space Telescope
Hubble Telescope
Hubble Space telescope
Hubble Telescope
Applications Of Computer Science in Astronomy
Telescopes & astronomy andie
Hubble space telescope
Hubble Telescope
Space telescopes
Lunar Ultraviolet Cosmic Imager (LUCI)
Telescopes 101
UK Space Conference: James Webb Space Telescope (Gillian Wright)
Hubble telescope [Dev N Patel]
[Challenge:Future] Space Debris
Sect 8.1
Ad

Similar to 999 cash[2] (20)

PDF
Recent Science Highlights and Future Prospects
PPT
The James Webb Space Telescope
PDF
Marietta College Colloquium
PDF
The ExoplanetSat Mission to Detect Transiting Exoplanets with a C
PPTX
Astronauts and Robots 2015: Gary Blackwood, JPL
PDF
A gallery of_planet_hunters
PPTX
Astrophotography Presentation
PDF
A young protoplanet_candidate_embedded_in_the_circumstellar_disk_of_hd100546
PDF
1207 angel[1]
PPTX
Exoplanets Notre Dame college (13t h MACFAIR International)
PDF
Value of Starshade Observations CL25_0309.pdf
PDF
Ultimate astronomicalimaging
PDF
The Diversity of Exoplanetary Environments and the Search for Signs of Life B...
PPT
AAS National Conference 2008: Michael Werner
PDF
Cepheid calibrations of_modern_type_ia_supernovae_implications_for_the_hubble...
PDF
Dhrimaj_Helion_FinalPaper_ECE523
PDF
Data Science Education: Needs & Opportunities in Astronomy
PDF
Wolfram Data Summit: New Frontiers in Astronomy
PPT
kitp_ucsb_armagan_2010.ppt
PDF
Observational evidence from supernovae for an accelerating universe and a cos...
Recent Science Highlights and Future Prospects
The James Webb Space Telescope
Marietta College Colloquium
The ExoplanetSat Mission to Detect Transiting Exoplanets with a C
Astronauts and Robots 2015: Gary Blackwood, JPL
A gallery of_planet_hunters
Astrophotography Presentation
A young protoplanet_candidate_embedded_in_the_circumstellar_disk_of_hd100546
1207 angel[1]
Exoplanets Notre Dame college (13t h MACFAIR International)
Value of Starshade Observations CL25_0309.pdf
Ultimate astronomicalimaging
The Diversity of Exoplanetary Environments and the Search for Signs of Life B...
AAS National Conference 2008: Michael Werner
Cepheid calibrations of_modern_type_ia_supernovae_implications_for_the_hubble...
Dhrimaj_Helion_FinalPaper_ECE523
Data Science Education: Needs & Opportunities in Astronomy
Wolfram Data Summit: New Frontiers in Astronomy
kitp_ucsb_armagan_2010.ppt
Observational evidence from supernovae for an accelerating universe and a cos...
Ad

More from Clifford Stone (20)

PDF
Zubrin nov99
PDF
Xray telescopeconcept
PDF
Xray interferometry
PDF
Wpafb blue bookdocuments
PDF
What gov knows_about_ufos
PDF
Welcome oct02
PDF
Weather jun02
PDF
Wassersug richard[1]
PDF
Washington, d.c., jul 26 27, 1952
PDF
Wash dc jul 19 to 20 1952
PDF
Vol4ch03
PDF
Vol4ch02
PDF
Vol4ch01
PDF
Vol3ch16
PDF
Vol3ch14
PDF
Vol3ch13
PDF
Vol3ch12
PDF
Vol3ch11
PDF
Vol3ch10
PDF
Vol3ch09
Zubrin nov99
Xray telescopeconcept
Xray interferometry
Wpafb blue bookdocuments
What gov knows_about_ufos
Welcome oct02
Weather jun02
Wassersug richard[1]
Washington, d.c., jul 26 27, 1952
Wash dc jul 19 to 20 1952
Vol4ch03
Vol4ch02
Vol4ch01
Vol3ch16
Vol3ch14
Vol3ch13
Vol3ch12
Vol3ch11
Vol3ch10
Vol3ch09

999 cash[2]

  • 1. New Worlds ImagerWebster CashUniversity of Colorado
  • 2. New Worlds Imager An Alternative to TPF Webster CashUniversity of ColoradoJim GreenEric SchindhelmNishanthRajanJeremy KasdinPrinceton UniversityBob VanderbeiDavid SpergelEd TurnerSara SeagerCarnegie Institution –WashingtonAlan SternSouthwest Research Institute –BoulderSteve KilstonBall AerospaceErik WilkinsonMike LeiberJim LeitchJon ArenbergNorthrop GrummanRon PolidanChuck LillieWillard SimmonsMITand growing…
  • 3. Exo-Planets •Exo-planets are the planets that circle stars other than our Sun. •There are probably 10,000 exo-planets within 10pc (30 light years) of the Earth.
  • 4. Are Any Habitable?? Are Any Occupied??? To Be Human Is to Want to Know
  • 5. Some Poetry (?) Certain knowledge of a destination could drive future generations to cross the awful gulf of interstellar space.
  • 6. The Problem with Exo-Planet Studies •Planets are lost in the glare of parent star. •The Earth as viewed from light years is 10 billion times fainter than the Sun.
  • 7. Terrestrial Planet Finder•Telescopes must be PERFECT to suppress scatter: λ/5000 surface, 99.999% reflection uniformity•TPF is verydifficult•Is there any easier way?
  • 9. A Pinhole Camera Meets The Requirements: Perfect Transmission No Phase Errors Scatter only from edges –can be very low Diffraction Issues Remain Large Distance Set by 0.01 arcsecrequirement diffraction: λ/D = .01” ÆD = 10m @500nm geometric: F = D/tan(.01”) = 180,000km
  • 11. View Back Toward StarshadeBackground Stars & Zodiacal LightStarshadeDiffracted Starlightaround edge fallsoutside slitSpectrographEntrance Slit(Projected) Planet LightBackground Light
  • 13. View Dark Side of Starshade Target Sun
  • 14. “Standard” Observatory Views Starshade ~1” resolution or somewhat better (not necessarily diffraction limited) High efficiency, low noise spectrograph (e.g. COS)
  • 15. Reduces Noise Almost to Zero Detector Noise (counts) Diameter (m) Required integration time (days) to get 100,000 counts MCPglass MCPSi CCD 1 28 363 15 604800 5 1.1 15 0.6 24192 10 .3 4 0.1 6070 15 .1 2 0.06 2700 20 .07 1 0.04 1512 Assumptions: Fλ~3e-9 photons/cm2/sec/Åfor Earth at 10pc, system efficiency ~0.35, λ=5000Å. Background calculations done using MCPglass=0.5 counts/cm2/sec, MCPsilicon=0.02 counts/cm2/sec, CCD=1e-read noise and readout every 20 minutes, and a 0.03x1 mm resolution element with 0.010 mm pixels.
  • 17. Planet Finding Mode Solar System at 10pcMarsVenusEarthJupiterEarthVenus Survey to 7AU Survey Habitable Zone
  • 18. Inverse Pinhole Occulter Pinspeck •Smaller Starshade –Create null zone, image around occulter •10m shade, 1m diffraction limited telescope and 20,000km separation would work •Observe entire planetary system at once •Highly affordable. Could build today
  • 19. Predecessors BOSS http://umbras.org/ Starkmanshowed that starlight could be reduced by 10,000x.
  • 20. Pinspeckwith 1m Telescope50,000 seconds400,000 secondsJupiterEarthVenusMars
  • 21. Pinspeckwith 8m Telescope 50,000 secondsEarthMarsHalley’s Comet
  • 23. Spectroscopic Biomarkers WaterNecessary for habitability OxygenFree oxygen results only from active plant life OzoneResults from free oxygen Nitrous OxideAnother gas produced by living organisms MethaneLife indicator if oxygen also present VegetationRed edge of vegetation at 750nm
  • 25. Pale Blue Planet Mission
  • 26. PBP Requirements 100km Resolution at 10pc is 0.06 micro-arcseconds Interferometer requires a 1500km baseline And the same collecting area as Keck Telescope in Hawaii (10 meter diameter) We can do this right now if we have the will.
  • 27. The “Freeway Mission” From the movie Contact. Dr Arrowaygets a brief glimpse of this alien landscape.
  • 28. Freeway Requirements 300m resolution at 10 parsecs = 0.02 nano-arcseconds 500,000km baseline Huge collecting area –one square kilometer Right now this is impossibly expensive, but not necessarily tomorrow
  • 29. The New Worlds ImagerA simulated exo-planet at 500 km resolution. Earth at 200km resolution. Oceans, continents and clouds are visible.
  • 30. NWI Conceptcollector craft1500kmstarshadescollector craftcombiner 180,000km 1500km
  • 31. Holding the Arrayplanet collimatorfield star collimatorprimary collectorto combinerplanet beamsfield star beamsDelay Lines –Mixers -Detectorsplanet Detectors
  • 32. Fits Into NASA Planning•Identify Earth-like Planets•Search for oceans•Search for unambiguous tracers of life•Study new eco-systemsLife FinderObjective•Reacquire Earth- like planets•Perform spectroscopy with λ/δλ> 1000•Search forH20, O2, N2O, O3, etc•Survey dozens of nearby systemsScienceGoalInstrumentRequirements•Suppress starlight to below 10-10•Separate planets at .01” •Operate in visible or near IR•10m class aperture for signal•High Efficiency Spectrograph•Low noise detectors•Two craft•Shaped aperture in large, deployable light stop•10m, 1”class telescope with Rowland spectrograph•Formation flying to ~1m line of sight at 180,000km•L2 or drift away orbitMissionRequirements•HST•JWST•TPF•LISA•SIMRelevantPredecessorsNew WorldsObserverNew WorldsImagerPictures of Earth- like Planets with 100km Resolution•WorldsObserverImagerPictures Resolution
  • 33. New Worlds Observer Roadmap •PinspecksvsPinholes •Minimize Size (and hence cost) •Deployment of Starshade •Orbit Tradeoff •Formation Flying •Telescope Design •Simulations and Limitations
  • 34. New Worlds Imager Roadmap •Formation Flying Requirements •Interferometer Design •Image Formation •Pathlength Nulling •Simulations N.B. NWI is very challenging, but it’s the first true planet imaging architecture for which we can write specifications that are not ridiculously difficult.
  • 35. Size Minimization •Pinspeckif at all possible •Diffraction dominates signal but drops with size of starshade. •I have five mathematicians working on the problem. (N.B. Mathematicians are not used to working on deadlines!)
  • 36. Orbital Analysis At L4, L5 or any Sun-centered orbit, it takes .001N continuous thrust to keep a 1000kg craft in alignment. Milli-Newton thrusters are now available, and a few square meters of solar panels can power it. These thrusters can move the starshadeto the next target in a day or two. 50 planetary systems per year.
  • 37. Formation Flying 1W laser can be seen at 200,000km. Can track relative to back ground stars. Craft need to be designed to find each other and align against sky. Background Stars & Zodiacal LightStarshadeDiffracted Starlightaround edge fallsoutside slitSpectrographEntrance Slit(Projected) Planet LightBackground Light
  • 38. NIAC: They Bring Good Things To Life •Press Interest –Publicity Crucial to Shifting Opinions •Industry Interest –Northrop Grumman Putting in Resources •Government Interest –White Paper Put Us in NASA Roadmap –Goddard Studying This as Alternative •TPF Off-ramp?
  • 39. Conclusion •Needs ThoroughStudy •If No Major Problems Emerge, then… •We have an exo-planet observatory concept that can be implemented with today’s technology •Biggest Problem may be political By 2011 By 2018