SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Dutch Case
A new approach to aggregation
Wilbert Helmus (wilbert.helmus@den.nl)
Enno Meijers (enno.meijers@kb.nl, @ennomeijers)
2015:
National Strategy Digital Heritage
Workpackages:
1. Visibility
2. Usability
3. Sustainability
and a revolution…
Platform Software Producers
The human factor
(organisational aspects…)
Source: Antoine Isaac – DBpedia Community Meeting, 2016-02
The challenge of
aggregating Digital
Heritage information
This sounds/looks familiar!
NDE aims at increasing the social value of
digital heritage by making it more visible,
usable and sustainable.
Problems current infrastructure…
• OAI-PMH based: so COPY and process…
• no clear definitions of collections, organizations
• no clear identifier schemes, limited use of formalized terms
• multiple aggregation routes for different purposes (thematic,
regional, domain)
• silo based platforms with integrated aggregation and user services
• data owners not happy about visibility, quality, provenance, usability
• limited possibilities for cross-domain, cross-material views
A new approach to aggregation
NDE’s approach on aggregation
• focus on registering instead of aggregation:
• collections (= datasets), terminology sources, objects
• refer to the source instead of copying the data
• selective aggregation/indexing/querying based on user demands
• encourage the use of formal definitions (‘who, where, what, when’)
• build a Knowledge Graph for Digital Heritage
• record the URI instead of copying the string
• adoption of Linked Data technologies
• publish collection data as Linked Open Data (build open data registries)
• support data owners for publishing their data as linked data (cooperate with suppliers)
Described in DERA 1.0 : Digitaal Erfgoed Referentie Architectuur
Register before aggregation
Step by step approach
Step 1: move central systems to LOD
- aggregators publish datasets as LOD
- reference sources openly available as LOD
- aggregators feed the registry
- service portals use registry & aggregated data
Step 2: synchronize local systems
-local systems use formal reference sources
-local adoption of formal identifiers
-aggregators feed the registry
-service portals use registry & aggregated data
Step 3: move local systems to LOD
- local systems publish datasets as LOD
- local systems feed the registry
- service portals use registry & aggregated LOD data
Step 4: LOD enabled network
- local systems feed the registry
- local systems support distributed querying
- service portals query local LOD data
- aggregators become service portals
Central registry for datasets, terminology sources and links to objects.
Based on
DCAT, DATAID(?)
Knowledge graph for (Dutch) Digital Heritage
Building on previous work!
Designing the NDE cross-
domain infrastructure
Proof-of-Concept phase (1)
NDE participates in projects to develop / test the approach:
• Zuiderzee Museum / Amsterdam Museum
• Network Dutch War Resources
• VTMK fashion thesaurus (Modemuze)
• Picture library Dutch East Indies
• GTAA @ Groninger Archieven (webarchive)
• Linked Data Pilot National Archives
• RKDArtists
Proof-of-Concept phase (2)
• Investigate possible alignment with
• Europeana
• CLARIAH
• Packed/Flemish Heritage institutions
• Investigate new protocols/solutions/platforms:
• Linked Data Fragments (LODLaundromat)
• Resource Sync, Webmention, Linked Data Notifications
• Experiment with distributed web technologies (IPFS/Blockchain)
Thanks for your attention!
Let’s exchange ideas…

More Related Content

PPTX
DIGITAL LIBRARY
PPT
Defining collections and creating their descriptions
PDF
Corrado -- Establishing the Landscape
PDF
A distributed network of digital heritage information - Semantics Amsterdam
ODP
Archive/Record Management for the Nuxeo Platform
PPT
MANTRA & Open Educational Resources
PPT
Digitalisation Project Considerations
DIGITAL LIBRARY
Defining collections and creating their descriptions
Corrado -- Establishing the Landscape
A distributed network of digital heritage information - Semantics Amsterdam
Archive/Record Management for the Nuxeo Platform
MANTRA & Open Educational Resources
Digitalisation Project Considerations

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Digital library
PPTX
CTDA Services for Cultural Heritage Institutions
PPTX
Ariadne: Archiving and Repositories
PDF
The Heterogenous Zone: Six use cases for six research data collections in Edi...
PPTX
Ppt 20120917 cor wash repository
PPTX
CTDA Services for Academic Institutions
PDF
A distributed network of digital heritage information by Enno Meijers - Europ...
PPTX
DIGITAL LIBRARY ARCHITECTURE
PPT
Digitising Hansard
PPTX
DLCS
PPTX
Paul hu bupdate_i_digbio_ecn_2012
PPTX
Digital library
PPT
Collaboration to Curation: The High Rise Project meets Edinburgh DataShare
PPTX
Levels of Service for Digital Libraries
PDF
EuropeanaTech 2018: A distributed network of digital heritage information
PDF
Local content in a Europeana cloud for small & medium content providers
PPTX
Interoperability in Digital Libraries
PPTX
An Introduction to the Connecticut Digital Archive
Digital library
CTDA Services for Cultural Heritage Institutions
Ariadne: Archiving and Repositories
The Heterogenous Zone: Six use cases for six research data collections in Edi...
Ppt 20120917 cor wash repository
CTDA Services for Academic Institutions
A distributed network of digital heritage information by Enno Meijers - Europ...
DIGITAL LIBRARY ARCHITECTURE
Digitising Hansard
DLCS
Paul hu bupdate_i_digbio_ecn_2012
Digital library
Collaboration to Curation: The High Rise Project meets Edinburgh DataShare
Levels of Service for Digital Libraries
EuropeanaTech 2018: A distributed network of digital heritage information
Local content in a Europeana cloud for small & medium content providers
Interoperability in Digital Libraries
An Introduction to the Connecticut Digital Archive
Ad

Similar to A new approach to aggregation (20)

PDF
Session 1.4 a distributed network of heritage information
PDF
A distributed network of digital heritage information - Unesco/NDL India
PDF
CLARIAH Toogdag 2018: A distributed network of digital heritage information
PDF
lodlam summit session browsable linked data
PPSX
INNOVATION AND ‎RESEARCH (Digital Library ‎Information Access)‎
PDF
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
PDF
20170501 Distributed Network of Digital Heritage Information
PPTX
Breaking Down Walls in Enterprise with Social Semantics
PPT
Open Data Masterclass - Europeana and LOD
PPT
IT Infrastructure for the Digital Humanities Observatory
PPTX
NDS Relevant Update from the NIH Data Science (ADDS) Office
PPT
Culture Hack panel SXSW 2013
PPTX
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
PPTX
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
PPTX
IASSIST 2012 - DDI-RDF - Trouble with Triples
PPTX
The Social Semantic Web
PPTX
CNI 2018: A Research Object Authoring Tool for the Data Commons
PPT
An introduction to repository reference models
PPTX
Linked Open Data for Cultural Heritage
PPTX
Connecting the Dots: Linking Digitized Collections Across Metadata Silos
Session 1.4 a distributed network of heritage information
A distributed network of digital heritage information - Unesco/NDL India
CLARIAH Toogdag 2018: A distributed network of digital heritage information
lodlam summit session browsable linked data
INNOVATION AND ‎RESEARCH (Digital Library ‎Information Access)‎
20191210 NDLI KEDL2019 Building the dutch digital heritage network
20170501 Distributed Network of Digital Heritage Information
Breaking Down Walls in Enterprise with Social Semantics
Open Data Masterclass - Europeana and LOD
IT Infrastructure for the Digital Humanities Observatory
NDS Relevant Update from the NIH Data Science (ADDS) Office
Culture Hack panel SXSW 2013
The Social Semantic Server: A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learning...
The Social Semantic Server - A Flexible Framework to Support Informal Learnin...
IASSIST 2012 - DDI-RDF - Trouble with Triples
The Social Semantic Web
CNI 2018: A Research Object Authoring Tool for the Data Commons
An introduction to repository reference models
Linked Open Data for Cultural Heritage
Connecting the Dots: Linking Digitized Collections Across Metadata Silos
Ad

More from Enno Meijers (12)

PDF
Building library networks with linked data
PDF
Linked Open Netwerken
PDF
20170407 Bruikbaar Erfgoed - Week van het Digitaal Erfgoed
PDF
Presentatie PCDB overleg Utrecht 28 juni 2016
PDF
Slimmer werken met metadata COPE 25 mei 2016
PPTX
Verbonden & Gevonden
PPT
Developing a national digital library stapel - meijers 20160302
PPT
Betere toegang tot onze informatie
PPT
Workshop linked open data en nbc+ 16 juni 2015
PPT
Workshop linked open data en nbc+ 16 juni 2015
PPTX
Nbc+ deel 2 informatiedag lokale collecties
PDF
Presentatie nl.dbpedia.org Datasalon 8 Gent 24 Februari 2012
Building library networks with linked data
Linked Open Netwerken
20170407 Bruikbaar Erfgoed - Week van het Digitaal Erfgoed
Presentatie PCDB overleg Utrecht 28 juni 2016
Slimmer werken met metadata COPE 25 mei 2016
Verbonden & Gevonden
Developing a national digital library stapel - meijers 20160302
Betere toegang tot onze informatie
Workshop linked open data en nbc+ 16 juni 2015
Workshop linked open data en nbc+ 16 juni 2015
Nbc+ deel 2 informatiedag lokale collecties
Presentatie nl.dbpedia.org Datasalon 8 Gent 24 Februari 2012

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
GSA Q+A Follow-Up To EO's, Requirements & Timelines
PPTX
PCCR-ROTC-UNIT-ORGANIZATIONAL-STRUCTURE-pptx-Copy (1).pptx
PDF
PPT - Primary Rules of Interpretation (1).pdf
PPTX
11Sept2023_LTIA-Cluster-Training-Presentation.pptx
PDF
26.1.2025 venugopal K Awarded with commendation certificate.pdf
PPTX
Nur Shakila Assesmentlwemkf;m;mwee f.pptx
PDF
सुशासन सप्ताह भारत रत्न श्री अटल बिहारी बाजपेयी जी जन्मदिवस समारोह 19-24 दिसं...
PDF
ISO-9001-2015-internal-audit-checklist2-sample.pdf
PDF
Abhay Bhutada and Other Visionary Leaders Reinventing Governance in India
PDF
Strategic Planning for Child Rights and Protection Programming.pdf
PPTX
Proposed Odisha State Highways Authority OSHA Act 2025 Draft
PDF
Item # 4 -- 328 Albany St. compt. review
PPTX
The DFARS - Part 250 - Extraordinary Contractual Actions
DOCX
Alexistogel: Solusi Tepat untuk Anda yang Cari Bandar Toto Macau Resmi
PPT
Adolescent Health Orientation and Health care
PDF
Population Estimates 2025 Regional Snapshot 08.11.25
PPTX
Weekly Report 17-10-2024_cybersecutity.pptx
PPTX
Quiz - Saturday.pptxaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
PPT
generalgeologygroundwaterchapt11-181117073208.ppt
PDF
PPT Item #s 2&3 - 934 Patterson SUP & Final Review
GSA Q+A Follow-Up To EO's, Requirements & Timelines
PCCR-ROTC-UNIT-ORGANIZATIONAL-STRUCTURE-pptx-Copy (1).pptx
PPT - Primary Rules of Interpretation (1).pdf
11Sept2023_LTIA-Cluster-Training-Presentation.pptx
26.1.2025 venugopal K Awarded with commendation certificate.pdf
Nur Shakila Assesmentlwemkf;m;mwee f.pptx
सुशासन सप्ताह भारत रत्न श्री अटल बिहारी बाजपेयी जी जन्मदिवस समारोह 19-24 दिसं...
ISO-9001-2015-internal-audit-checklist2-sample.pdf
Abhay Bhutada and Other Visionary Leaders Reinventing Governance in India
Strategic Planning for Child Rights and Protection Programming.pdf
Proposed Odisha State Highways Authority OSHA Act 2025 Draft
Item # 4 -- 328 Albany St. compt. review
The DFARS - Part 250 - Extraordinary Contractual Actions
Alexistogel: Solusi Tepat untuk Anda yang Cari Bandar Toto Macau Resmi
Adolescent Health Orientation and Health care
Population Estimates 2025 Regional Snapshot 08.11.25
Weekly Report 17-10-2024_cybersecutity.pptx
Quiz - Saturday.pptxaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
generalgeologygroundwaterchapt11-181117073208.ppt
PPT Item #s 2&3 - 934 Patterson SUP & Final Review

A new approach to aggregation

  • 1. The Dutch Case A new approach to aggregation Wilbert Helmus (wilbert.helmus@den.nl) Enno Meijers (enno.meijers@kb.nl, @ennomeijers)
  • 4. and a revolution… Platform Software Producers
  • 6. Source: Antoine Isaac – DBpedia Community Meeting, 2016-02 The challenge of aggregating Digital Heritage information
  • 7. This sounds/looks familiar! NDE aims at increasing the social value of digital heritage by making it more visible, usable and sustainable.
  • 8. Problems current infrastructure… • OAI-PMH based: so COPY and process… • no clear definitions of collections, organizations • no clear identifier schemes, limited use of formalized terms • multiple aggregation routes for different purposes (thematic, regional, domain) • silo based platforms with integrated aggregation and user services • data owners not happy about visibility, quality, provenance, usability • limited possibilities for cross-domain, cross-material views
  • 10. NDE’s approach on aggregation • focus on registering instead of aggregation: • collections (= datasets), terminology sources, objects • refer to the source instead of copying the data • selective aggregation/indexing/querying based on user demands • encourage the use of formal definitions (‘who, where, what, when’) • build a Knowledge Graph for Digital Heritage • record the URI instead of copying the string • adoption of Linked Data technologies • publish collection data as Linked Open Data (build open data registries) • support data owners for publishing their data as linked data (cooperate with suppliers)
  • 11. Described in DERA 1.0 : Digitaal Erfgoed Referentie Architectuur Register before aggregation
  • 12. Step by step approach Step 1: move central systems to LOD - aggregators publish datasets as LOD - reference sources openly available as LOD - aggregators feed the registry - service portals use registry & aggregated data Step 2: synchronize local systems -local systems use formal reference sources -local adoption of formal identifiers -aggregators feed the registry -service portals use registry & aggregated data Step 3: move local systems to LOD - local systems publish datasets as LOD - local systems feed the registry - service portals use registry & aggregated LOD data Step 4: LOD enabled network - local systems feed the registry - local systems support distributed querying - service portals query local LOD data - aggregators become service portals
  • 13. Central registry for datasets, terminology sources and links to objects. Based on DCAT, DATAID(?)
  • 14. Knowledge graph for (Dutch) Digital Heritage
  • 16. Designing the NDE cross- domain infrastructure
  • 17. Proof-of-Concept phase (1) NDE participates in projects to develop / test the approach: • Zuiderzee Museum / Amsterdam Museum • Network Dutch War Resources • VTMK fashion thesaurus (Modemuze) • Picture library Dutch East Indies • GTAA @ Groninger Archieven (webarchive) • Linked Data Pilot National Archives • RKDArtists
  • 18. Proof-of-Concept phase (2) • Investigate possible alignment with • Europeana • CLARIAH • Packed/Flemish Heritage institutions • Investigate new protocols/solutions/platforms: • Linked Data Fragments (LODLaundromat) • Resource Sync, Webmention, Linked Data Notifications • Experiment with distributed web technologies (IPFS/Blockchain)
  • 19. Thanks for your attention! Let’s exchange ideas…