SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Agile at the enterprise level 
01/10/2014
Jan De Baere 
20+ years in IT 
10+ years into Agile 
5+ years Agile @ scale 
Chair Agile Consortium 
Belgium 
Jan.debaere@cegeka.be
INTRO 
3
In the good old days 
Project: 
Build 1 
long lasting 
stable (stand alone) 
application
In the good old days
Projects in the old days: 
Build 1 
long lasting 
stable application 
Projects today: 
Create/update a 
complex 
dynamic service 
? 
IT centric Business/user centric
2001 
Snowbird 
Agile 
Manifesto
Global vision
Agile at enterprice level
When is Agile useful? 
Solution/technology 
Requirements
11 
Process 
PostIT’s… 
Values 
Principles 
Attitude
SCALING 
12
Development 
Classical 
Agile
Scrum
Testing
Requirements
DevOps
Scaling
SAFE 
19
Portfolio 
Program 
Team
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Scaled 
Agile 
Framework
Scaled 
Agile 
Framework 
e
SAFe is a template, 
for a large scale software 
development organisation, 
that exhibits agility.
SAFe Overview 
Team Program Portfolio
SAFe Overview 
Team Program Portfolio
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Scrum master
Product owner 
Scrum master
SAFe Overview 
Team Program Portfolio
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Product manager
Product manager
Product manager
Product manager 
Release train engineer
Product manager 
Release train engineer 
Product manager
SAFe Overview 
Team Program Portfolio
Agile at enterprice level
Program Portfolio manager
Program Portfolio manager
Program Portfolio manager
Program Portfolio manager
Agile at enterprice level
Enterprise 
architect 
Epic owner
EA EO
EA EO
EA EO
SAFe Overview 
Team Program Portfolio
SOME SAFE ELEMENS 
62
Portfolio 
Program 
Team
There is more value created 
with overall alignment 
than with local excellence. 
>> Don. Reinertsen, The Principles of Product Development Flow <<
Epic layer 
Feature layer 
Story layer
Feature Planning Meeting
• Context 
• Roadmap 
• Architecture 
ITC 
PM FO 
EA 
IT Integrator
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
71
72
73
Fast feedback optimizes payoff. 
Tackle highest risk first
Portfolio 
Program 
Team
System Demo
System Demo
System Team
Constrain WIP to control cycle 
time and flow. 
>> Don. Reinertsen, The Principles of Product Development Flow <<
Constrain WIP to control cycle 
time and flow. 
>> Don. Reinertsen, The Principles of Product Development Flow << 
WIP = Work In Progress
Portfolio 
Program 
Team
Epic Kanban
Kanban properties 
1. Visualize workflow 
2. Limit work-in-progress 
3. Measure and manage flow 
4. Make process policies explicit 
5. Use models to recognize improvement opportunities
1. Visualize workflow
1. Visualize workflow
E 
F 
G 
H 
A 
B 
C 
D 
1. Visualize workflow
E 
F 
G 
H 
A 
B 
C 
D 
1. Visualize workflow
2. Limit work-in-progress 
E 
F 
G 
H 
A 
B 
C 
D 
2 
2 
1
2. Limit work-in-progress
2. Limit work-in-progress 
E 
F 
I 
G 
H 
D C B A 
2 
2 
1 
J 
M 
K 
L
2. Limit work-in-progress 
E 
F 
I 
G 
H 
C B A 
D 
2 
2 
1 
J 
M 
K 
L
3. Measure and manage flow 
A 
C 
D 
A 
B
4. Make process policies explicit 
A 
B 
C 
D
4. Make process policies explicit 
B 
C 
D 
A A
5. Use models to improve 
2 
2 
1 
A 
B 
C 
D 
3 
2
Kanban 
A 
B 
C 
D 
2 
2 
1
Weighted 
Shortest 
Job 
First
If you only quantify one thing, 
quantify the cost of delay. 
>> Don. Reinertsen, The Principles of Product Development Flow <<
Epic layer 
Feature layer 
Story layer
Job Sequencing
ROI = 
Value 
Cost
ROI = 
Value 
Cost
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Agile at enterprice level
Equal Cost of Delay 
A: $$, 1 day B: $$, 3 days 
C: $$, 10 days
Equal Duration 
A: $$$, 3 days B: $$, 3 days 
C: $, 3 days
Agile at enterprice level
WSJF = 
Cost of Delay 
Duration 
ROI = 
Value 
Cost
WSJF = 
Cost of Delay 
Duration 
User/Business Value + Time Criticality + RR/OE Value 
Job Size 
= 
ROI = 
Value 
Cost
Agile at enterprice level
112 
Conslusion 
Overall alignment Cost of delay 
WSJF = 
Cost of Delay 
Duration 
Constrain WIP Fast feedback 
System Team
ADENDUM
The case against scaling 
From EGO to ECO
Visibility
Visibility
Visibility
Silo’s 
Collaboration

More Related Content

PDF
Introduction to Agile Scrum
PDF
Scrum and DevOps training
PDF
Laurens Bonnema: The Agile Project Management Bootcamp Taster
PPTX
Daria Nevenchanaya: PoC (proof of concept) -  Початок чи кінець?
PPTX
Capturing Lessons Learned Information – Making your current and future projec...
PPTX
Lessons learned from managing a distributed agile team
PDF
Finding the First Slice
PPTX
A Guide to Risk Management
Introduction to Agile Scrum
Scrum and DevOps training
Laurens Bonnema: The Agile Project Management Bootcamp Taster
Daria Nevenchanaya: PoC (proof of concept) -  Початок чи кінець?
Capturing Lessons Learned Information – Making your current and future projec...
Lessons learned from managing a distributed agile team
Finding the First Slice
A Guide to Risk Management

What's hot (20)

PDF
Agile Anywhere in the 21st Century: Setting up distributed teams to be effective
PDF
From Divided to United - Aligning Technical and Business Teams
PPTX
Simon Powers - Scaling Frameworks in Organisational Design
PDF
Flow-based road mapping & options thinking
PPTX
Day in the life of product manager
PDF
Beyond the Crystal Ball –The Agile PMO - Heather Fleming and Justin Riservato
PDF
What not to do when adopting Agile
PPTX
Design thinking, agile & lean
PPT
Intro to Agile Practices and Values
PDF
Get into bed with qa and keep testing agile
PDF
Lean agile meets design thinking
PPTX
The Agile PMO
PDF
Resource Pools - How is This Still a Thing? at LAST Conf 2016 in Sydney, Aust...
PDF
From dysfunction to cross function in 8,593 easy steps- team building at the cbc
PPTX
Situational retrospectives
PPTX
Release wednesdays and the agile release train upload
PPTX
Soni Meckam and Geeta Wilson Presentation
PPTX
Agile Scrum Lean & Kanban explained in a flash
PDF
6.2 Cross-Functional Team Framework - v2.0
PDF
العصف الذهني Brainstorming
Agile Anywhere in the 21st Century: Setting up distributed teams to be effective
From Divided to United - Aligning Technical and Business Teams
Simon Powers - Scaling Frameworks in Organisational Design
Flow-based road mapping & options thinking
Day in the life of product manager
Beyond the Crystal Ball –The Agile PMO - Heather Fleming and Justin Riservato
What not to do when adopting Agile
Design thinking, agile & lean
Intro to Agile Practices and Values
Get into bed with qa and keep testing agile
Lean agile meets design thinking
The Agile PMO
Resource Pools - How is This Still a Thing? at LAST Conf 2016 in Sydney, Aust...
From dysfunction to cross function in 8,593 easy steps- team building at the cbc
Situational retrospectives
Release wednesdays and the agile release train upload
Soni Meckam and Geeta Wilson Presentation
Agile Scrum Lean & Kanban explained in a flash
6.2 Cross-Functional Team Framework - v2.0
العصف الذهني Brainstorming
Ad

Similar to Agile at enterprice level (20)

PPTX
Lean Prod Development ProductCamp Vancouver Feb15
PPTX
Xanpan extended presentation
PDF
Keynote: Know the Way, Show the Way, Go the Way: Scaling Agile Development
PDF
Business Value of Lean Thinking
ODP
Intro to Agile and Lean Software Development
PDF
The SAFe Way to Lean Software Development for AgileNCR - April 5, 2014
PDF
Lean Based Sofware Development
PDF
AgileLIVE – Accelerate Enterprise Agile with the Scaled Agile Framework®: Part I
PDF
Be Agile. Scale Up. Stay Lean. And Have More Fun by Dean Leffingwell
PDF
AgileCamp 2014 Track 1: Accelerating Agile Enterprise Adoption with Scaled Ag...
PDF
Normalizing agile and lean product development and aim
PPTX
Lean Software Development Is for Everyone
PPTX
Kanban Agile.pptx
PDF
Foundations of the Scaled Agile Framework: Be Agile. Scale Up. Stay Lean. And...
PPTX
Foundations of the Scaled Agile Framework 3.0
PDF
Lean Principles
PDF
Scaling Agile Up to the Enterprise and Staying Lean
PPT
Lean Software Development & Kanban
PPTX
LKIN17: Enabling Enterprise Agility though a Hybrid Agile Implementation Mode...
PDF
Lean Kanban India 2017 | Case study - Hybrid Agile Implementation Model to En...
Lean Prod Development ProductCamp Vancouver Feb15
Xanpan extended presentation
Keynote: Know the Way, Show the Way, Go the Way: Scaling Agile Development
Business Value of Lean Thinking
Intro to Agile and Lean Software Development
The SAFe Way to Lean Software Development for AgileNCR - April 5, 2014
Lean Based Sofware Development
AgileLIVE – Accelerate Enterprise Agile with the Scaled Agile Framework®: Part I
Be Agile. Scale Up. Stay Lean. And Have More Fun by Dean Leffingwell
AgileCamp 2014 Track 1: Accelerating Agile Enterprise Adoption with Scaled Ag...
Normalizing agile and lean product development and aim
Lean Software Development Is for Everyone
Kanban Agile.pptx
Foundations of the Scaled Agile Framework: Be Agile. Scale Up. Stay Lean. And...
Foundations of the Scaled Agile Framework 3.0
Lean Principles
Scaling Agile Up to the Enterprise and Staying Lean
Lean Software Development & Kanban
LKIN17: Enabling Enterprise Agility though a Hybrid Agile Implementation Mode...
Lean Kanban India 2017 | Case study - Hybrid Agile Implementation Model to En...
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Sustainable Forest Management ..SFM.pptx
PDF
Swiggy’s Playbook: UX, Logistics & Monetization
PPTX
Intro to ISO 9001 2015.pptx wareness raising
PPTX
lesson6-211001025531lesson plan ppt.pptx
PPTX
Tour Presentation Educational Activity.pptx
PPTX
_ISO_Presentation_ISO 9001 and 45001.pptx
PPTX
water for all cao bang - a charity project
PPTX
Effective_Handling_Information_Presentation.pptx
PPTX
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORAGNISATION PPT ON SOCIAL SCIENCE
PPTX
BIOLOGY TISSUE PPT CLASS 9 PROJECT PUBLIC
PPT
The Effect of Human Resource Management Practice on Organizational Performanc...
DOC
学位双硕士UTAS毕业证,墨尔本理工学院毕业证留学硕士毕业证
PDF
Microsoft-365-Administrator-s-Guide_.pdf
PPTX
Presentation for DGJV QMS (PQP)_12.03.2025.pptx
DOC
LSTM毕业证学历认证,利物浦大学毕业证学历认证怎么认证
PPTX
The Effect of Human Resource Management Practice on Organizational Performanc...
PDF
Nykaa-Strategy-Case-Fixing-Retention-UX-and-D2C-Engagement (1).pdf
PDF
natwest.pdf company description and business model
PPTX
Self management and self evaluation presentation
PDF
Instagram's Product Secrets Unveiled with this PPT
Sustainable Forest Management ..SFM.pptx
Swiggy’s Playbook: UX, Logistics & Monetization
Intro to ISO 9001 2015.pptx wareness raising
lesson6-211001025531lesson plan ppt.pptx
Tour Presentation Educational Activity.pptx
_ISO_Presentation_ISO 9001 and 45001.pptx
water for all cao bang - a charity project
Effective_Handling_Information_Presentation.pptx
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORAGNISATION PPT ON SOCIAL SCIENCE
BIOLOGY TISSUE PPT CLASS 9 PROJECT PUBLIC
The Effect of Human Resource Management Practice on Organizational Performanc...
学位双硕士UTAS毕业证,墨尔本理工学院毕业证留学硕士毕业证
Microsoft-365-Administrator-s-Guide_.pdf
Presentation for DGJV QMS (PQP)_12.03.2025.pptx
LSTM毕业证学历认证,利物浦大学毕业证学历认证怎么认证
The Effect of Human Resource Management Practice on Organizational Performanc...
Nykaa-Strategy-Case-Fixing-Retention-UX-and-D2C-Engagement (1).pdf
natwest.pdf company description and business model
Self management and self evaluation presentation
Instagram's Product Secrets Unveiled with this PPT

Agile at enterprice level

Editor's Notes

  • #6: Before you could say read the fucking manual. If today you still need manual you’re out of business It’s about another level of service IT has to provide. Business knows the price & speed at which you can rent storage at amazon and they demand the same level of service. App market? There is abundance of software. They aim is not longer to make software, nor to sell software just to get your free app used by a customer… Differentiator? added value for the user. Remark that added value is not only functionality but can be – and is more and more - design as well.
  • #10: Promise of agile: More business value faster
  • #12: The difficulty of Agile is in values, principles and Attitude.
  • #18: Close the part with putting in production. Collaboration is not enough. Tools is nessesary e.g. testautomation, deployment…
  • #19: From agile team/project to agile company/IT Less: Large scale scrum Dad: Disciplined agile delivery SAFe: Scaled agile framework In common Combine Lean & Agile Basic component: scrum team recurcivity
  • #21: Goal: decisions are taken at the right level: Priority of epics is decided at portfolio/epic level: not to be discussed further on – as a guidance for the other levels Priority of features in PSI: decided on program/feature level … Combine Agile & lean
  • #68: Presence: everybody of the release train (organize yourselves!) Organizer: ING IT Integrator or IT Integrator Start with context (PPM), Roadmap en Architectore ING termen: Investment them committee, program manager, feature owner en it integrator ipv Program Portfolio management, Epic owner, Program manager and release train engineer
  • #69: EO, EA, RTE and PPM are present for questions SoS each hour (SM, PO an program level)
  • #70: Outcome for a team: PSI objectives (PO gives bus. Value (with PPM and Product Manager (CPO)) Risks and impediments per team
  • #71: Features: so when a feature as a whole is delivered Yellow: dependent feature input that need to be finished (by other teams) in order to deliver the features Place of the post-its does not say anything of when a team starts with a feature or feature input. Line: features with input: features to be developed by different teams, with dependencies (for each team)
  • #85: Slice the work in small pieces. Make a card for each of these pieces.
  • #86: Draw columns for each of the process steps.
  • #87: Stick the cards in the columns.
  • #88: And pull the work items through the process steps. It’s visual, simple and improves shared understanding.
  • #89: Put a limit on the number of work items that can live in a column. This limit is called the W.I.P. limit, Work-In-Progress limit.
  • #90: Prevent overload. Avoid to start many but to finish few. Avoid task switching. Increase focus.
  • #91: Decrease lead time. Enable fast feedback.
  • #92: Identify bottlenecks. And hence improve flow.
  • #93: Measure lead time.
  • #94: Class of service
  • #95: Definition of done
  • #98: Job sequencing algorithm If you only quantify one thing, quantify the cost of delay
  • #101: How do you prioritize epic and feature backlogs?
  • #102: Cost of delay Duration => job size Ratio of business value over effort size Business value => value to user or business; time criticality to user or business; … => opportunity cost to delay implementation => cost of delay Effort size => duration
  • #103: Cost of delay Duration => job size Ratio of business value over effort size Business value => value to user or business; time criticality to user or business; … => opportunity cost to delay implementation => cost of delay Effort size => duration
  • #105: Example: fashion
  • #106: Example: process automation
  • #110: Cost of delay Duration => job size Ratio of business value over effort size Business value => value to user or business; time criticality to user or business; … => opportunity cost to delay implementation => cost of delay Effort size => duration
  • #111: Cost of delay Duration => job size Ratio of business value over effort size Business value => value to user or business; time criticality to user or business; … => opportunity cost to delay implementation => cost of delay Effort size => duration
  • #115: Controversy around scaling in agile community: Culture for value creation and speed?: free market. They produce more and faster then people can follow. Companies adore it and ask less government, less rules, less administration in order to speed up. Basically: get out of the way of companies who want to work, that is how added value is created. By contract there is no added value create : how the western world sees communism with their central and planned economy wand lots of control. They needed to build a wall to keep people inside. Strange: external, organizations want free market, internal organization of companies is more like... Feedback from people in bigger companies: less governance, less rules, less administration get out of the way of people who want to work that is how added value is created. Fundamental remark from agile community: you can turn a blue triangle into a green one but it remains a triangle. Agile is going to another type of organisation like adhocraty, network organisation, innovative ecosystems… My conclusion: there will be a case against scaling in 5-10 years time for the bigger companies. You can’t go from a blue triangle to a green circle directly (evolution not revolution.) From talking about agile (triangle) to being agile e.g. Spotiy: by the time the structure is described it has changed. (tip as long as you have reorganisations you have planned change
  • #119: All Disiplines are done one after another Business involvement is high in the beginning and the end of te project