SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Next generation API Portals...
...what will they look like?
Allan Knabe, API Product Manager & Co-founder- apiable.io
Allan Knabe, API Product Manager & co-founder of
https://apiable.io/
BECOME API ABLE
API Portals as a Service
@apiable_io
apiable-io | allanknabe
Twenty years of experience working with large organization across a wide range of industries:
API Portals Today.
What have we
built so far?
● Developer Portals
● Developer Documentation
● Developer Communities
● Examples
● Sandboxes
● Hackathons
● Developer Portals
● Developer Documentation
● Developer Communities
● Examples
● Sandboxes
Connected
Developer
Experience?
Done!
Then why don’t
the developers
come?
Reasons why developers don’t come:
Reason 1:
Your DX is
terrible.
Reason 2:
Developers are
not interested in
your APIs.
Then who is
interested in my
APIs?
Developers,
Developers,
Developers.
“A customer is someone who
pays for your product. A user
does not.”
- Maurya, Ash. Running Lean: Iterate from Plan A to a Plan That
Works
The developer is
probably not
your target
customer.
Developer vs Business Products
Developer Products: Immediate Access Business Products: Agreement must be signed
Product
Manager
Developer
Developer
Enabled!
Just add
Developer!
Trusted by
Developers!
● SMS
● 2FA
● Call Forwarding
● Google Docs
● Live cricket scores
● SMS
● 2FA
● Call Forwarding
● Google Docs
● Live cricket scores
● Call Elevator
● Create new mobile subscription
● Track vehicle location
● Create Bank Account
● Call Elevator
● Create new mobile subscription
● Track vehicle location
● Create Bank Account
API Portals of Tomorrow.
Your APIs will
be consumable.
You’ll give a great API experience when:
Your APIs are Products
They have a clear value proposition
They are consumable
They are monetizable
Understandable by mere mortals
Your APIs are Products
They have a clear value proposition
They are consumable
They are monetizable
How do we present APIs as Products?
Developer eXperience Customer eXperience
Digital Marketplace vs Developer Portal
When to use a Digital Marketplace? When to use a Developer Portal?
● When the decision maker is Non-Technical
● When you have API Products
● When you wish to Monetize
● When you want a subscription model
● Technical Decision Maker
● The APIs are really clear
● If you can reach developers
● If your APIs can be found
● When the decision maker is Non-Technical ● Technical Decision Maker
● When you have API Products ● The APIs are really clear
● When you wish to Monetize ● If you can reach developers
Should we use
both?
Probably.
apidays LIVE Jakarta - What will the next generation of API Portals look like? by Allan Knabe, apiable.io
KPI’s will be baked
in
Prioritise your business goals.
Avoid vanity metrics.
Monetisation
We’ll see more cases of
Monetisation, led by Business
Goals for your API Product.
How to build the API Portal of
the future?
Off the Shelf -
from API
Management
Vendor
Pros Cons
All major api vendors include a
developer portal of some kind.
No integration to underlying API
Management needed.
Enterprise Architects like
homogeneous systems
architecture, or “all their eggs in
one basket.”
Quite often an afterthought /
hasn’t been upgraded in years.
Can be quite expensive if you
need a separate license.
Can still require substantial
development to bring to
production. Ongoing
maintenance.
All major api vendors include a
developer portal of some kind.
No integration to underlying API
Management needed.
Enterprise Architects like
homogeneous systems
architecture, or “all their eggs in
one basket.”
Quite often an afterthought /
hasn’t been upgraded in years.
Can be quite expensive if you
need a separate license.
Custom Portal -
from a
Software
Agency
Pros Cons
You’ll get exactly what you
want..
Your branding/marketing team
will love you!
Can be extremely expensive.
Requires an ongoing support
contract so that when the API
Management system changes
your portal needs to be
upgraded.
Needs a large project with a
team, substantial amount of
time needs to be invested.
You’ll get exactly what you
want..
Your branding/marketing team
will love you!
Can be extremely expensive.
Requires an ongoing support
contract so that when the API
Management system changes
your portal needs to be
upgraded.
SaaS Based -
API Portal as a
Service
Pros Cons
Continuous improvements, new
features available all the time.
Subscription based, no need to
invest a lot of CAPEX up-front.
Is maintained and run as a
Service, no need to worry about
API Management upgrades.
Multiple API Gateway support.
If hosted “off-premise” then
users data needs to be secure.
Loss of control, someone else is
running the system.
There are very few API Portals
as a Service…
Continuous improvements, new
features available all the time.
Subscription based, no need to
invest a lot of CAPEX up-front.
Is maintained and run as a
Service, no need to worry about
API Management upgrades.
Multiple API Gateway support.
If hosted “off-premise” then
users data needs to be secure.
Loss of control, someone else is
running the system.
apiable.io Portal as a Service
Next-gen API Portal
Demo available - Prototype API Portal
● Technology agnostic (Apigee, Mulesoft,
Kong, Axway, etc)
● Marketplace concept with
subscriptions
● Role based (Business, BizDev,
Developer)
● Identity Provider integration
● Technology agnostic (Apigee, Mulesoft,
Kong, Axway, etc)
● Identity Provider integration
● Role based (Business, BizDev,
Developer)
Coming June 2021
Ways to get in touch
apiable.io
API + ABLE + .io
+358 (0)50 564 75 03
allan.knabe@apiable.io
+358 (0)50 564 75 03
@apiable_io
apiable-io | allanknabe
Backup
API as a Product
● Not just for externals! Create “Internal
Products”
“Using established Product
Management tools and techniques to
create API Products with a value
proposition, thus ensuring their
success.”
● The product is a much better vehicle for
delivering value, especially when compared
to a project. A product endures, a project
fades away.
● Speaking to your customers and understanding
their pain is a vital step, don’t miss this part
out!
● No point in having the best API Portal in the
world if you have nothing to put on it.
● No point in having the best API Portal in the
world if you have nothing to put on it.
● Not just for externals! Create “Internal
Products”
● The product is a much better vehicle for
delivering value, especially when compared
to a project. A product endures, a project
fades away.

More Related Content

PPTX
API Products: Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How?
PDF
apidays LIVE Paris - Succeeding with API Programs by Kiran Nadgir
PDF
apidays LIVE Hong Kong 2021 - Automating the API Product Lifecycle by Jeremy ...
PDF
apidays LIVE Paris - Potential of API integrations, common traps and advices ...
PPT
apidays LIVE Helsinki & North - Bye bye to the insurance monolith - case Eule...
PDF
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - 5 Learnings Shaping Our View on the Future of APIs ...
PDF
apidays LIVE Jakarta - Serverless powered Low Code by Alex-Adrien Auger, Sipios
PDF
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - Low-Code API DevOps approach to API Lifecycle Manag...
API Products: Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How?
apidays LIVE Paris - Succeeding with API Programs by Kiran Nadgir
apidays LIVE Hong Kong 2021 - Automating the API Product Lifecycle by Jeremy ...
apidays LIVE Paris - Potential of API integrations, common traps and advices ...
apidays LIVE Helsinki & North - Bye bye to the insurance monolith - case Eule...
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - 5 Learnings Shaping Our View on the Future of APIs ...
apidays LIVE Jakarta - Serverless powered Low Code by Alex-Adrien Auger, Sipios
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - Low-Code API DevOps approach to API Lifecycle Manag...

What's hot (20)

PDF
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - Beyond API Governance: Run your API org like a lean...
PDF
INTERFACE, by apidays - Low code APIs that don't break by Zdenek Nemec, Supe...
PPTX
Guide to an API-first Strategy
PDF
APIs Are Just Like LEGO Blocks | APPSeCONNECT
PDF
London Adapt or Die: Opening Keynot
PPTX
Executing on API Developer Experience
PPTX
London Adapt or Die: Securing your APIs the Right Way!
PDF
INTERFACE, by apidays - From Monolith to Open Finance with APIs by Marcilio ...
PDF
Building an API Platform for Digital Transformation
PDF
apidays LIVE London 2021 - Productization of APIs by Jay Dembani, Avalara
PPTX
What It Takes to Build API Integrations
PDF
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - Building an analytics API by David Wobrock, Botify
PPTX
Vizag Virtual Meetup #7: Trending API Topics for 2022
PDF
apidays LIVE Paris - Innovation and rejuvenation combined: a beneficial appro...
PDF
I Love APIs 2015: Implementing an API Tier to Enable a New Mobile Platform
PPTX
apidays LIVE Paris - Interface Economy: The true potential of APIs by Kristof...
PDF
Lean Method for Building Good APIs for Business – APIOps Cycles
PPTX
Apigee Product Roadmap Part 2
PPTX
API Management and Kubernetes
PDF
Api architectures for the modern enterprise
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - Beyond API Governance: Run your API org like a lean...
INTERFACE, by apidays - Low code APIs that don't break by Zdenek Nemec, Supe...
Guide to an API-first Strategy
APIs Are Just Like LEGO Blocks | APPSeCONNECT
London Adapt or Die: Opening Keynot
Executing on API Developer Experience
London Adapt or Die: Securing your APIs the Right Way!
INTERFACE, by apidays - From Monolith to Open Finance with APIs by Marcilio ...
Building an API Platform for Digital Transformation
apidays LIVE London 2021 - Productization of APIs by Jay Dembani, Avalara
What It Takes to Build API Integrations
apidays LIVE Paris 2021 - Building an analytics API by David Wobrock, Botify
Vizag Virtual Meetup #7: Trending API Topics for 2022
apidays LIVE Paris - Innovation and rejuvenation combined: a beneficial appro...
I Love APIs 2015: Implementing an API Tier to Enable a New Mobile Platform
apidays LIVE Paris - Interface Economy: The true potential of APIs by Kristof...
Lean Method for Building Good APIs for Business – APIOps Cycles
Apigee Product Roadmap Part 2
API Management and Kubernetes
Api architectures for the modern enterprise
Ad

Similar to apidays LIVE Jakarta - What will the next generation of API Portals look like? by Allan Knabe, apiable.io (20)

PDF
I am sorry Developer, your API just became a Product.pdf
PPSX
APIs as a Product Strategy
PPTX
apidays LIVE New York 2021 - API as a product: who, what, where, when, why, a...
PPTX
Driving Digital Innovation with a Layered API Design Approach
PDF
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Shift RIGHT to Better Product Resilience by Abhijit ...
PDF
INTERFACE by apidays - API Success: Running a Successful API Program by Nelso...
PPTX
API Product Management - Driving Success through the Value Chain
PDF
apidays Australia 2022 - Accelerate business innovation by improving API prog...
PPTX
apidays LIVE India 2022 - Building the API Banking capability
PPTX
apidays New York 2025 - API Platform Survival Guide by James Higginbotham (La...
PDF
apidays LIVE London 2021 - Moving from a Product as API to API as a Product b...
PPTX
Smartone v1.0
PPTX
API-as-a-product: The Key to a Successful API Program
PDF
INTERFACE, by apidays - Why are API Products so hard? by Allan Knabe, apiabl...
PDF
A Brief Guide on API Integration
PDF
INTERFACE, by apidays - API Design is where culture and tech meet each other...
PDF
apidays LIVE New York 2021 - API design is where culture and tech meet each o...
PPTX
APIdays Helsinki 2019 - How to Design and Publish API Products that Your Cust...
PPTX
APIdays Helsinki 2019 - Lean Method for Building Good APIs for Business – API...
PPTX
Applying Domain-Driven Design to APIs and Microservices - Austin API Meetup
I am sorry Developer, your API just became a Product.pdf
APIs as a Product Strategy
apidays LIVE New York 2021 - API as a product: who, what, where, when, why, a...
Driving Digital Innovation with a Layered API Design Approach
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Shift RIGHT to Better Product Resilience by Abhijit ...
INTERFACE by apidays - API Success: Running a Successful API Program by Nelso...
API Product Management - Driving Success through the Value Chain
apidays Australia 2022 - Accelerate business innovation by improving API prog...
apidays LIVE India 2022 - Building the API Banking capability
apidays New York 2025 - API Platform Survival Guide by James Higginbotham (La...
apidays LIVE London 2021 - Moving from a Product as API to API as a Product b...
Smartone v1.0
API-as-a-product: The Key to a Successful API Program
INTERFACE, by apidays - Why are API Products so hard? by Allan Knabe, apiabl...
A Brief Guide on API Integration
INTERFACE, by apidays - API Design is where culture and tech meet each other...
apidays LIVE New York 2021 - API design is where culture and tech meet each o...
APIdays Helsinki 2019 - How to Design and Publish API Products that Your Cust...
APIdays Helsinki 2019 - Lean Method for Building Good APIs for Business – API...
Applying Domain-Driven Design to APIs and Microservices - Austin API Meetup
Ad

More from apidays (20)

PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - The Physics of Requirement Sciences Through Application...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Developer Portals, API Catalogs, and Marketplaces, Miri...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Making Sense of AI-Ready APIs in a Buzzword World, Andr...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Integrate Your APIs into the New AI Marketplace, Senthi...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - The Double Life of the API Product Manager, Emmanuel Pa...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Let’s build, debug and test a magic MCP server in Postm...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - The life-changing magic of great API docs, Jens Fischer...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Automating Operations Without Reinventing the Wheel, Ma...
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Geospatial Artificial Intelligence (GeoAI) with OGC API...
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - GraphQL 101: I won't REST, until you GraphQL, Surbhi Si...
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - Effectively incorporating API Security into the overall...
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - Federated API Management and Governance, Vince Baker (D...
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - Agentic AI: A Friend or Foe?, Merja Kajava (Aavista Oy)
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - Streamline & Secure LLM Traffic with APISIX AI Gateway ...
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - Building Telco-Aware Apps with Open Gateway APIs, Subhr...
PPTX
apidays Munich 2025 - Building an AWS Serverless Application with Terraform, ...
PDF
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - REST in Peace? Hunting the Dominant Design fo...
PDF
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - Monetizing AI APIs: The New API Economy, Alla...
PDF
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - How (not) to run a Graphql Stewardship Group,...
PDF
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - APIs in the healthcare sector: hospitals inte...
apidays Munich 2025 - The Physics of Requirement Sciences Through Application...
apidays Munich 2025 - Developer Portals, API Catalogs, and Marketplaces, Miri...
apidays Munich 2025 - Making Sense of AI-Ready APIs in a Buzzword World, Andr...
apidays Munich 2025 - Integrate Your APIs into the New AI Marketplace, Senthi...
apidays Munich 2025 - The Double Life of the API Product Manager, Emmanuel Pa...
apidays Munich 2025 - Let’s build, debug and test a magic MCP server in Postm...
apidays Munich 2025 - The life-changing magic of great API docs, Jens Fischer...
apidays Munich 2025 - Automating Operations Without Reinventing the Wheel, Ma...
apidays Munich 2025 - Geospatial Artificial Intelligence (GeoAI) with OGC API...
apidays Munich 2025 - GraphQL 101: I won't REST, until you GraphQL, Surbhi Si...
apidays Munich 2025 - Effectively incorporating API Security into the overall...
apidays Munich 2025 - Federated API Management and Governance, Vince Baker (D...
apidays Munich 2025 - Agentic AI: A Friend or Foe?, Merja Kajava (Aavista Oy)
apidays Munich 2025 - Streamline & Secure LLM Traffic with APISIX AI Gateway ...
apidays Munich 2025 - Building Telco-Aware Apps with Open Gateway APIs, Subhr...
apidays Munich 2025 - Building an AWS Serverless Application with Terraform, ...
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - REST in Peace? Hunting the Dominant Design fo...
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - Monetizing AI APIs: The New API Economy, Alla...
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - How (not) to run a Graphql Stewardship Group,...
apidays Helsinki & North 2025 - APIs in the healthcare sector: hospitals inte...

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
PDF
Approach and Philosophy of On baking technology
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
PDF
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
PDF
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
PDF
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles - August'25 Week I
PDF
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
PDF
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
PDF
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
PPTX
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
PDF
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
PDF
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
PDF
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
PPTX
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
PDF
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
PPTX
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
PDF
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PPTX
PA Analog/Digital System: The Backbone of Modern Surveillance and Communication
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
Approach and Philosophy of On baking technology
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles - August'25 Week I
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PA Analog/Digital System: The Backbone of Modern Surveillance and Communication

apidays LIVE Jakarta - What will the next generation of API Portals look like? by Allan Knabe, apiable.io

  • 1. Next generation API Portals... ...what will they look like? Allan Knabe, API Product Manager & Co-founder- apiable.io
  • 2. Allan Knabe, API Product Manager & co-founder of https://apiable.io/ BECOME API ABLE API Portals as a Service @apiable_io apiable-io | allanknabe Twenty years of experience working with large organization across a wide range of industries:
  • 4. What have we built so far? ● Developer Portals ● Developer Documentation ● Developer Communities ● Examples ● Sandboxes ● Hackathons ● Developer Portals ● Developer Documentation ● Developer Communities ● Examples ● Sandboxes
  • 6. Then why don’t the developers come?
  • 7. Reasons why developers don’t come: Reason 1: Your DX is terrible. Reason 2: Developers are not interested in your APIs.
  • 10. “A customer is someone who pays for your product. A user does not.” - Maurya, Ash. Running Lean: Iterate from Plan A to a Plan That Works
  • 11. The developer is probably not your target customer.
  • 12. Developer vs Business Products Developer Products: Immediate Access Business Products: Agreement must be signed Product Manager Developer Developer Enabled! Just add Developer! Trusted by Developers! ● SMS ● 2FA ● Call Forwarding ● Google Docs ● Live cricket scores ● SMS ● 2FA ● Call Forwarding ● Google Docs ● Live cricket scores ● Call Elevator ● Create new mobile subscription ● Track vehicle location ● Create Bank Account ● Call Elevator ● Create new mobile subscription ● Track vehicle location ● Create Bank Account
  • 13. API Portals of Tomorrow.
  • 14. Your APIs will be consumable.
  • 15. You’ll give a great API experience when: Your APIs are Products They have a clear value proposition They are consumable They are monetizable Understandable by mere mortals Your APIs are Products They have a clear value proposition They are consumable They are monetizable
  • 16. How do we present APIs as Products? Developer eXperience Customer eXperience
  • 17. Digital Marketplace vs Developer Portal When to use a Digital Marketplace? When to use a Developer Portal? ● When the decision maker is Non-Technical ● When you have API Products ● When you wish to Monetize ● When you want a subscription model ● Technical Decision Maker ● The APIs are really clear ● If you can reach developers ● If your APIs can be found ● When the decision maker is Non-Technical ● Technical Decision Maker ● When you have API Products ● The APIs are really clear ● When you wish to Monetize ● If you can reach developers
  • 20. KPI’s will be baked in Prioritise your business goals. Avoid vanity metrics.
  • 21. Monetisation We’ll see more cases of Monetisation, led by Business Goals for your API Product.
  • 22. How to build the API Portal of the future?
  • 23. Off the Shelf - from API Management Vendor Pros Cons All major api vendors include a developer portal of some kind. No integration to underlying API Management needed. Enterprise Architects like homogeneous systems architecture, or “all their eggs in one basket.” Quite often an afterthought / hasn’t been upgraded in years. Can be quite expensive if you need a separate license. Can still require substantial development to bring to production. Ongoing maintenance. All major api vendors include a developer portal of some kind. No integration to underlying API Management needed. Enterprise Architects like homogeneous systems architecture, or “all their eggs in one basket.” Quite often an afterthought / hasn’t been upgraded in years. Can be quite expensive if you need a separate license.
  • 24. Custom Portal - from a Software Agency Pros Cons You’ll get exactly what you want.. Your branding/marketing team will love you! Can be extremely expensive. Requires an ongoing support contract so that when the API Management system changes your portal needs to be upgraded. Needs a large project with a team, substantial amount of time needs to be invested. You’ll get exactly what you want.. Your branding/marketing team will love you! Can be extremely expensive. Requires an ongoing support contract so that when the API Management system changes your portal needs to be upgraded.
  • 25. SaaS Based - API Portal as a Service Pros Cons Continuous improvements, new features available all the time. Subscription based, no need to invest a lot of CAPEX up-front. Is maintained and run as a Service, no need to worry about API Management upgrades. Multiple API Gateway support. If hosted “off-premise” then users data needs to be secure. Loss of control, someone else is running the system. There are very few API Portals as a Service… Continuous improvements, new features available all the time. Subscription based, no need to invest a lot of CAPEX up-front. Is maintained and run as a Service, no need to worry about API Management upgrades. Multiple API Gateway support. If hosted “off-premise” then users data needs to be secure. Loss of control, someone else is running the system.
  • 26. apiable.io Portal as a Service
  • 27. Next-gen API Portal Demo available - Prototype API Portal ● Technology agnostic (Apigee, Mulesoft, Kong, Axway, etc) ● Marketplace concept with subscriptions ● Role based (Business, BizDev, Developer) ● Identity Provider integration ● Technology agnostic (Apigee, Mulesoft, Kong, Axway, etc) ● Identity Provider integration ● Role based (Business, BizDev, Developer) Coming June 2021
  • 28. Ways to get in touch apiable.io API + ABLE + .io +358 (0)50 564 75 03 allan.knabe@apiable.io +358 (0)50 564 75 03 @apiable_io apiable-io | allanknabe
  • 30. API as a Product ● Not just for externals! Create “Internal Products” “Using established Product Management tools and techniques to create API Products with a value proposition, thus ensuring their success.” ● The product is a much better vehicle for delivering value, especially when compared to a project. A product endures, a project fades away. ● Speaking to your customers and understanding their pain is a vital step, don’t miss this part out! ● No point in having the best API Portal in the world if you have nothing to put on it. ● No point in having the best API Portal in the world if you have nothing to put on it. ● Not just for externals! Create “Internal Products” ● The product is a much better vehicle for delivering value, especially when compared to a project. A product endures, a project fades away.