SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Comparing Four e_Learning Applications
                         SiatMoy Chong, Ph.D., CPT
                                      Kiva Learning
                          siatmoychong@yahoo.com
                         smchong@kivalearning.com
Mirror , Mirror on the wall, which
is the best of all, Lectora,
Articulate, Captivate or
Camtasia?
Lectora   Articulate   Captivate   Camtasia
Captivate




…Adobe Captivate (formerly RoboDemo) is an electronic learning tool for Microsoft Windows which can be
used to author software demonstrations, software simulations, branched scenarios, and randomized quizzes in
.swf format. It can also convert Adobe Captivate generated .swf to .avi which can be uploaded to video hosting
websites. For software simulations, Captivate can use left mouse clicks, key presses and rollover images.

It can also be used for screencasts, podcasts, and the conversion of Microsoft PowerPoint presentations to the
Adobe Flash format.
Camtasia




•   …Camtasia Studio is a screen video capture program for Microsoft Windows. It is published by TechSmith. The user defines
    the area of the screen or the window that is to be captured before recording begins; it is also possible to capture the entire
    screen area. You can also talk, and use a videocam.
Articulate
Lectora




•   …Lectora is an Electronic learning (elearning) development tool, also known as authoring software, developed by Trivantis Corporation.
    Lectora is used to create online training courses, assessments, and presentations. It is also used for the conversion of Microsoft
    PowerPoint presentations into elearning content.




                                                                                                                                             7
Here is a request
Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker.
               Camtasia is known authoring tool.
                  Captivate can an screen recording.
                      Lectora is do Engage, recording..




Lectora           Articulate            Captivate             Camtasia
Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker.
               Camtasia is known authoring tool.
                  Captivate can an screen recording.
                      Lectora is do Engage, recording..




Lectora           Articulate            Captivate             Camtasia
Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker.
               Camtasia is known authoring tool.
                  Captivate can an screen recording.
                      Lectora is do Engage, recording..




Lectora           Articulate            Captivate             Camtasia
Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker.
               Camtasia is known authoring tool.
                  Captivate can an screen recording.
                      Lectora is do Engage, recording..




Lectora           Articulate            Captivate             Camtasia
Let’s see some examples

               Screen     Screen
                                                        Link                Format
              Recording    Cast

 Camtasia        X                 Demo Link                          AVI

                 X                                                    Html
                                   Screen Recording_demo_to be used
                                                                      AVI
 Captivate                         Updated_081509_demo_to be used
                            X      Captivate_demo
                                   Captivate_practice
                                                                      Html
 Articulate                 X
                                   Engage_procedure demo

                            X                                         Html
                                   Demo Link
 Lectora         X
Special Features


                  Translation

               Text to Speech




Lectora    Articulate     Captivate   Camtasia
Special Features




          Record Camera Video




Lectora    Articulate   Captivate   Camtasia
Camera Recording
Special Features



          Engage – templates for
               Interaction




Lectora     Articulate   Captivate   Camtasia
Articulate Engage
Let’s see an example of interaction.   Link
Special Features




            An authoring tool




Lectora    Articulate   Captivate   Camtasia
Published Options
                    Lectora          Articulate   Captivate    Camtasia
 Adobe Acrobat                                         X
 Connect Pro
 CD                     X                X             X           X


 Web                     X               X                         X
                  (AICC/Web-Based)
                 (SCORM/Web-Based)


 Word                   X                X             X
                                                     (print)
 LMS                    X                X


 Articulate                              X
 Online
 Podcast                                 X                         X


 E-mail                                                X

 FTP                                                   X

 Review                                                X

 CourseMill             X
I would like to repackage some of our ILT
PPT slides. Which applications would you
recommend?
Select me.




Lectora   Articulate     Captivate   Camtasia
Camtasia
Captivate
Articulate
Articulate
Articulate
Lectora Pro Suite
Lectora Pro Suite
Our little experiment


                                       Time             File size        Animation

Captivate    Create project from PPT   2.5 mins         4931 KB          Yes
                                                        2 KB (HTML)                  Link to example _after_Captive
                                                                                     Captivate
Camtasia     Record PowerPoint         1 min (AVI)      2429 KB (AVI)    Yes         Link to example_after_Camtasia
                                       3 mins (Flash)   400 KB (Flash)


Lectora      Use the Integrator        ---              1.3 MB           No
                                                                                     Link to example _after_Lectora

Articulate   Use Presenter             7 mins (Flash)   1 MB             Yes
                                                                                     Link to example _after articulate



                                                                                     Link to example _before
Review Process
Captivate Reviewer




                     33
Captivate Reviewer




                     34
Captivate Reviewer




                     35
Captivate Reviewer




                     36
Quiz Options
Types                    Lectora   Articulate   Captivate   Camtasia
                                        X            X            X
True/False                   X
                             X          X            X
Multiple Choice

Multiple Response                       X
                             X                       X
Short Answer
                             X
Essay
                             X          X            X            X
Fill in the Blank
                             X          X            X
Matching
                             X          X
Drag and Drop
                             X          X            X
Hot Spot
                                                                   X
Survey (short answer)
                                                             (not scored)
Sequence Drag and Drop                  X
                                                     X
Sequence
                                        X
Numeric
                                                     X
Rating Scale (Likert)

Word Bank                               X
Articulate Quizmaker
Which of the four applications could
produce e_Learning material without
using PPT?
Which of the four applications would you
prefer to use for producing e_Learning?
Demo 1
Demo 2

Demo 3
A word of thanks to Andrew Beckelman, Bob Doyle,
  Janet Castelli, and Nancy Arient for their contributions making the
                       presentation successful.

To learn more about Lectora, please contact Andrew Beckelman
              (andrew.bockelman@trivantis.com)

Send me a note if you have any questions regarding these four
applications. I will get the answers for you so that we can share
                             and learn.
Thank You
I added some of the screenshots
   because the demos are not
     included in this PPT file
Let’s see some examples




  Camtasia
Let’s see some examples

Captivate




I don’t include the
screenshots for Captivate
demo and practice
because I can’t share the
client’s content.
Let’s see some examples




Articulate
You can move the screen to the left side.
Let’s see some examples




Lectora
You can make changes to make it look nicer
Special Features – Captivate – Text to Speech




Special Features – Articulate Engage

More Related Content

PPT
BP203 limitless languages
PDF
Scala as "Better Java" from object-oriented viewpoint
PDF
Oop Article Jan 08
PDF
Rails Scala Citec Presentation
PDF
BeJUG JavaFx In Practice
PDF
Why I Love Python V2
PDF
Java Technicalities
PPT
January month gk quiz
BP203 limitless languages
Scala as "Better Java" from object-oriented viewpoint
Oop Article Jan 08
Rails Scala Citec Presentation
BeJUG JavaFx In Practice
Why I Love Python V2
Java Technicalities
January month gk quiz

Viewers also liked (18)

PDF
PPT
October month gk quiz
PPTX
GK quiz
PPTX
Palakkad AJK Grand finale quiz 2016
PPTX
SDSS Assembly Quiz 2016
PPS
----- The Management’S Game ------
DOCX
Management games
PPTX
Gk quiz ppt avi
PPT
Video Game Powerpoint
PPT
Introduction to computer hardware
PPT
basics of computer system ppt
PPT
a quiz with sound effects,personalities, famous people quiz,personality quiz,...
PPT
Computer hardware component. ppt
PPTX
GENERAL QUIZ 2013
PPTX
Honda ppt
PPTX
Audio Visual Quiz Nov 19,2013
PPT
Computer Basics 101 Slide Show Presentation
KEY
Agile Program and Portfolio Management
October month gk quiz
GK quiz
Palakkad AJK Grand finale quiz 2016
SDSS Assembly Quiz 2016
----- The Management’S Game ------
Management games
Gk quiz ppt avi
Video Game Powerpoint
Introduction to computer hardware
basics of computer system ppt
a quiz with sound effects,personalities, famous people quiz,personality quiz,...
Computer hardware component. ppt
GENERAL QUIZ 2013
Honda ppt
Audio Visual Quiz Nov 19,2013
Computer Basics 101 Slide Show Presentation
Agile Program and Portfolio Management
Ad

Similar to Chong Comparing Four E Learning Applications (20)

PPTX
Camtasia versus Captivate versus Free: Comparing Screencasting Software for L...
PPTX
Lambda The Extreme: Test-Driving a Functional Language
PPTX
On the Future of Libraries: How? not What? (Skills Assessment) - METRO - 13_0115
PDF
JAX2010 Flex Java technical session: interactive dashboard
PDF
Your java script library
PPTX
Danielmele software evaluation
PDF
Quality Best Practices & Toolkit for Enterprise Flex
PDF
Hello Gumbo
PDF
Flex For Java Architects Ledroff Breizh Jug V Blog Cc
PDF
What's new in CQ 5.3? Top 10 features.
PDF
David Nuescheler: Igniting CQ 5.3: What's New and Roadmap
PPT
Intro to Flash 8 welcome & course outline (2008)
PDF
Apache MXNet EcoSystem - ACNA2018
PDF
Flex Continuous Quality Builds Flex & (Ant || Maven)
PPT
Catching Your Screen
PDF
Striding towards the Future Multiple Edits at a Time
PDF
20111007 activiti
PDF
Rapid Prototyping
PDF
Kamaelia Europython Tutorial
PDF
CommunityOneEast 09 - Dynamic Languages: the next big thing for the JVM or an...
Camtasia versus Captivate versus Free: Comparing Screencasting Software for L...
Lambda The Extreme: Test-Driving a Functional Language
On the Future of Libraries: How? not What? (Skills Assessment) - METRO - 13_0115
JAX2010 Flex Java technical session: interactive dashboard
Your java script library
Danielmele software evaluation
Quality Best Practices & Toolkit for Enterprise Flex
Hello Gumbo
Flex For Java Architects Ledroff Breizh Jug V Blog Cc
What's new in CQ 5.3? Top 10 features.
David Nuescheler: Igniting CQ 5.3: What's New and Roadmap
Intro to Flash 8 welcome & course outline (2008)
Apache MXNet EcoSystem - ACNA2018
Flex Continuous Quality Builds Flex & (Ant || Maven)
Catching Your Screen
Striding towards the Future Multiple Edits at a Time
20111007 activiti
Rapid Prototyping
Kamaelia Europython Tutorial
CommunityOneEast 09 - Dynamic Languages: the next big thing for the JVM or an...
Ad

More from CISPI, STC Chicago, CCASTD, Roosevelt University (20)

DOC
Centrax 3 D And Video In E Learning
PDF
Duffy Who Says Good Training Cant Be Fun
PDF
Harvey Making Second Life Work For Training And Education
PPT
Martins Engaging Everyone In E Learning
PDF
PDF
De Vries PM For Rapid E Learning
PPT
PPT
DOC
PDF
Hybert 2 Web Based Collaboration
PDF
MacKenzie 1 When Is E Learning Right
DOC
Buzinski 6 Tips For Presenters
DOC
PDF
Butler2 Blended Media Recipe Handouts
PPTX
Lowenthal Moodle Changing The Face Of Corporate Learning
DOC
Buzinski 3 Design Of Host Training
PPT
Hubert Managing The Content Explosion
PDF
Omalley Teaching Procedures Through E Learning Aqp Handout
Centrax 3 D And Video In E Learning
Duffy Who Says Good Training Cant Be Fun
Harvey Making Second Life Work For Training And Education
Martins Engaging Everyone In E Learning
De Vries PM For Rapid E Learning
Hybert 2 Web Based Collaboration
MacKenzie 1 When Is E Learning Right
Buzinski 6 Tips For Presenters
Butler2 Blended Media Recipe Handouts
Lowenthal Moodle Changing The Face Of Corporate Learning
Buzinski 3 Design Of Host Training
Hubert Managing The Content Explosion
Omalley Teaching Procedures Through E Learning Aqp Handout

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Cell Structure & Organelles in detailed.
PDF
Basic Mud Logging Guide for educational purpose
PPTX
Renaissance Architecture: A Journey from Faith to Humanism
PDF
O7-L3 Supply Chain Operations - ICLT Program
PPTX
human mycosis Human fungal infections are called human mycosis..pptx
PPTX
PPH.pptx obstetrics and gynecology in nursing
PPTX
school management -TNTEU- B.Ed., Semester II Unit 1.pptx
PDF
Classroom Observation Tools for Teachers
PDF
01-Introduction-to-Information-Management.pdf
PDF
Abdominal Access Techniques with Prof. Dr. R K Mishra
PDF
VCE English Exam - Section C Student Revision Booklet
PDF
102 student loan defaulters named and shamed – Is someone you know on the list?
PPTX
PPT- ENG7_QUARTER1_LESSON1_WEEK1. IMAGERY -DESCRIPTIONS pptx.pptx
PDF
3rd Neelam Sanjeevareddy Memorial Lecture.pdf
PPTX
Introduction to Child Health Nursing – Unit I | Child Health Nursing I | B.Sc...
PPTX
Institutional Correction lecture only . . .
PPTX
Introduction_to_Human_Anatomy_and_Physiology_for_B.Pharm.pptx
PDF
Physiotherapy_for_Respiratory_and_Cardiac_Problems WEBBER.pdf
PPTX
IMMUNITY IMMUNITY refers to protection against infection, and the immune syst...
PDF
FourierSeries-QuestionsWithAnswers(Part-A).pdf
Cell Structure & Organelles in detailed.
Basic Mud Logging Guide for educational purpose
Renaissance Architecture: A Journey from Faith to Humanism
O7-L3 Supply Chain Operations - ICLT Program
human mycosis Human fungal infections are called human mycosis..pptx
PPH.pptx obstetrics and gynecology in nursing
school management -TNTEU- B.Ed., Semester II Unit 1.pptx
Classroom Observation Tools for Teachers
01-Introduction-to-Information-Management.pdf
Abdominal Access Techniques with Prof. Dr. R K Mishra
VCE English Exam - Section C Student Revision Booklet
102 student loan defaulters named and shamed – Is someone you know on the list?
PPT- ENG7_QUARTER1_LESSON1_WEEK1. IMAGERY -DESCRIPTIONS pptx.pptx
3rd Neelam Sanjeevareddy Memorial Lecture.pdf
Introduction to Child Health Nursing – Unit I | Child Health Nursing I | B.Sc...
Institutional Correction lecture only . . .
Introduction_to_Human_Anatomy_and_Physiology_for_B.Pharm.pptx
Physiotherapy_for_Respiratory_and_Cardiac_Problems WEBBER.pdf
IMMUNITY IMMUNITY refers to protection against infection, and the immune syst...
FourierSeries-QuestionsWithAnswers(Part-A).pdf

Chong Comparing Four E Learning Applications

  • 1. Comparing Four e_Learning Applications SiatMoy Chong, Ph.D., CPT Kiva Learning siatmoychong@yahoo.com smchong@kivalearning.com
  • 2. Mirror , Mirror on the wall, which is the best of all, Lectora, Articulate, Captivate or Camtasia?
  • 3. Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 4. Captivate …Adobe Captivate (formerly RoboDemo) is an electronic learning tool for Microsoft Windows which can be used to author software demonstrations, software simulations, branched scenarios, and randomized quizzes in .swf format. It can also convert Adobe Captivate generated .swf to .avi which can be uploaded to video hosting websites. For software simulations, Captivate can use left mouse clicks, key presses and rollover images. It can also be used for screencasts, podcasts, and the conversion of Microsoft PowerPoint presentations to the Adobe Flash format.
  • 5. Camtasia • …Camtasia Studio is a screen video capture program for Microsoft Windows. It is published by TechSmith. The user defines the area of the screen or the window that is to be captured before recording begins; it is also possible to capture the entire screen area. You can also talk, and use a videocam.
  • 7. Lectora • …Lectora is an Electronic learning (elearning) development tool, also known as authoring software, developed by Trivantis Corporation. Lectora is used to create online training courses, assessments, and presentations. It is also used for the conversion of Microsoft PowerPoint presentations into elearning content. 7
  • 8. Here is a request
  • 9. Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker. Camtasia is known authoring tool. Captivate can an screen recording. Lectora is do Engage, recording.. Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 10. Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker. Camtasia is known authoring tool. Captivate can an screen recording. Lectora is do Engage, recording.. Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 11. Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker. Camtasia is known authoring tool. Captivate can an screen recording. Lectora is do Engage, recording.. Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 12. Articulate has Presenter,for screenand Quizmaker. Camtasia is known authoring tool. Captivate can an screen recording. Lectora is do Engage, recording.. Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 13. Let’s see some examples Screen Screen Link Format Recording Cast Camtasia X Demo Link AVI X Html Screen Recording_demo_to be used AVI Captivate Updated_081509_demo_to be used X Captivate_demo Captivate_practice Html Articulate X Engage_procedure demo X Html Demo Link Lectora X
  • 14. Special Features Translation Text to Speech Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 15. Special Features Record Camera Video Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 17. Special Features Engage – templates for Interaction Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 19. Let’s see an example of interaction. Link
  • 20. Special Features An authoring tool Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 21. Published Options Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia Adobe Acrobat X Connect Pro CD X X X X Web X X X (AICC/Web-Based) (SCORM/Web-Based) Word X X X (print) LMS X X Articulate X Online Podcast X X E-mail X FTP X Review X CourseMill X
  • 22. I would like to repackage some of our ILT PPT slides. Which applications would you recommend?
  • 23. Select me. Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia
  • 31. Our little experiment Time File size Animation Captivate Create project from PPT 2.5 mins 4931 KB Yes 2 KB (HTML) Link to example _after_Captive Captivate Camtasia Record PowerPoint 1 min (AVI) 2429 KB (AVI) Yes Link to example_after_Camtasia 3 mins (Flash) 400 KB (Flash) Lectora Use the Integrator --- 1.3 MB No Link to example _after_Lectora Articulate Use Presenter 7 mins (Flash) 1 MB Yes Link to example _after articulate Link to example _before
  • 37. Quiz Options Types Lectora Articulate Captivate Camtasia X X X True/False X X X X Multiple Choice Multiple Response X X X Short Answer X Essay X X X X Fill in the Blank X X X Matching X X Drag and Drop X X X Hot Spot X Survey (short answer) (not scored) Sequence Drag and Drop X X Sequence X Numeric X Rating Scale (Likert) Word Bank X
  • 39. Which of the four applications could produce e_Learning material without using PPT?
  • 40. Which of the four applications would you prefer to use for producing e_Learning?
  • 42. A word of thanks to Andrew Beckelman, Bob Doyle, Janet Castelli, and Nancy Arient for their contributions making the presentation successful. To learn more about Lectora, please contact Andrew Beckelman (andrew.bockelman@trivantis.com) Send me a note if you have any questions regarding these four applications. I will get the answers for you so that we can share and learn.
  • 44. I added some of the screenshots because the demos are not included in this PPT file
  • 45. Let’s see some examples Camtasia
  • 46. Let’s see some examples Captivate I don’t include the screenshots for Captivate demo and practice because I can’t share the client’s content.
  • 47. Let’s see some examples Articulate You can move the screen to the left side.
  • 48. Let’s see some examples Lectora You can make changes to make it look nicer
  • 49. Special Features – Captivate – Text to Speech Special Features – Articulate Engage