Cisa domain 1

CISA Study Guide in EasyFAQs
Domain 1: The Information System Audit Process
Organization of the IS AUDIT function
How will you establish the role of the IS audit function?
The role of the audit function is described in the Audit Charter.
What are the five (5) components of the Audit Charter?
1. Scope of the audit
2. Responsibility of the audit function
3. Management’s responsibility
4. Objective and delegation
5. Delegation of authority
Who approves the Audit Charter?
Senior management or the top-level management
IS Resource Management
How should an audit begin?
1. Audit charter
2. Project plan for the audit
3. Availability of the proper skills
What if the proper skills are not available for the audit? Is it acceptable to
ask the auditee to help?
Auditors should obtain the appropriate skills. If the auditee provides help during the
auditing process, the audit might not be very objective, so it should be avoided.
31

Audit Planning
What are the two (2) types of Audit Planning?
1. Short term (less than a year)
2. Long term (more than a year)
How often should the Audit Planning be reviewed?
At least once a year.
What are the five (5) factors that should be considered in an Audit Plan?
1. Risk assessment
2. Local and international regulatory requirements
3. Corporate deadlines
4. Future technologies
5. Limitation of information subsystems
What five (5) step strategy should an IS Auditor use to draw up an Audit
Plan?
1. In-depth understanding of the business and its
a. Mission statement
b. Business objective
c. Process involved
d. Technology
2. Risk assessment
3. Internal control
4. Setting the scope and objective of the audit
5. Development of the audit strategy.
What are the six (6) common methods the auditor can use to understand
the auditee’s business?
1. Acquire domain knowledge
2. Annual reports, reading on web, industry publications
Sold as Single Copy Unauthorized 32

3. Review the short-term and long-term plans
4. Meet the key managers
5. Review the previous audit reports
6. Tour the organization
What is the biggest challenge for the IS auditor in terms of planning the
audit?
Matching the available resources with the audit plan.
Effect of laws and regulations on the Audit Plan
What are the four (4) common types of laws and regulations an IS auditor
should know about the auditee’s business?
1. Federal law regarding the business
2. State law applicable (if any)
3. Industry-specific law; for example, banking industry has its own set of rules and
regulation
4. International law (where applicable)
ISACA IS Auditing Standards
What are the objectives of the ISACA IS auditing standards?
1. Minimum level of acceptable performance, as per the Code of Professional Ethics
2. Should meet the professional’s expectations.
Sold as Single Copy
Unauthorized Circulation Strictly Prohibited
33

Risk, Risk Analysis and Risk Management
What is risk?
Risk: The possibility of something harmful or damaging occurring is known as risk. In
technical terms, risk is the probability of a threat or a threatening agent exploiting the
system's vulnerability.
The ISO’s guidelines for the Management of IT Security defines risk as:
"The potential that a given threat will exploit the vulnerability of an asset or group of
assets to cause loss or damage to the assets. The impact or relative severity of the risk is
proportional to the business value of the loss/damage and to the estimated frequency of
the threat ."
What is a Business Risk?
This is a risk that may have an impact on the following:
1. Asset
2. Process
3. Objective of organization or business
What is Risk Management?
Risk Management: The process of identifying, assessing and minimizing the risk to an
acceptable level and, later, maintaining that level.
What is the primary role of Risk Management?
1. To identify the threat
2. To estimate how often threats occur
Sold as Single Copy
34

What steps are required in a typical Risk Management project?
1. Identify the business objectives
2. Carry out a Risk Analysis (quantitative or qualitative), which has three
components:
Sold as Single Copy
35
i. Asset-related: (includes hardware, software, processes and any
resource valuable to the organization)
1. Asset identification
2. Valuation of asset
ii. Threat
1. Identification of threat
2. Probability determination of each threat
Vulnerability
1. Likelihood and/or
2. Probability of occurrence
iii.
3. Assess the risk
4. Risk Control and Treatment: avoidance or mitigation with the help of
i. Safeguards
ii. Counter-measures
5. Delegate or accept risk
Important Note:
In the classical methodology, first the critical assets are identified and then the threats.
However, some organizations start with identifying the threats rather than the assets,
which is perfectly acceptable.
How can an event that may result in loss be identified?
1. Actual threat
2. Threat probability
3. Threat has already materialized and the organization is facing the consequences.

What is the nature of the threat?
It can be one of the following:
1. Financial
2. Regulatory
3. Operational
What are the four (4) basic questions that should be asked during the Risk
Analysis?
1. What is the value of the asset?
2. What is the threat?
3. What are the vulnerabilities?
4. What is the likelihood of occurrence?
What are the two (2) main purposes of the Risk Assessment?
1. Quantifying the impact of the threat
2. Putting a price tag or price value on the risk or the impact on the business
What is the end result of the Risk Assessment?
1. Identification of the risk
2. Recommendations regarding safeguards and countermeasures with cost/benefit
justifications
What is the difference between Risk Assessment and Risk Analysis?
Sometimes the terms are used interchangeably; however, when they are differentiated, it
is on the following terms:
Sold as Single Copy
36
Risk Analysis Risk Assessment
Initial stage More advanced stage
Initial step In a way, a Risk Analysis is the
prerequisite for a Risk Assessment
The identification of assets, related threats,
VA and probability of occurrence
Once the threat is identified, Risk
Assessment deals with quantifying the

impact and putting a price tag on the risk.
What is the Risk Management Triple?
1. Asset
2. Vulnerability
3. Threat
What are the four (4) key components of Risk Assessment?
1. Asset
2. Vulnerability
3. Threat
4. Safeguards
What types of items are included as assets?
1. Products
2. Resources
3. Processes
How is an asset valued?
An asset is valued on the basis of:
1. Cost incurred in terms of
a. Creation
b. Development
c. Support
2. Plus the cost when it is
a. Replaced
b. Refurbished/overhauled
3. Plus the actual market cost
4. Plus the goodwill cost
Sold as Single Copy
37

What is a Threat?
A threat is an event that might cause harm or have an undesirable impact on the system.
A threat can be natural or man-made.
What is a Vulnerability (VA )?
A vulnerability can be defined as a security loophole or an open door. It is basically a
weakness in the system, or in the infrastructure. Threats exploit vulnerabilities.
What is a Safeguard?
A safeguard is also known as a "counter-measure". The main objective of a safeguard or
counter-measure is to overcome the threat, resulting in the reduction of risk.
Rule of Thumb: If you are confused as to whether something is a threat or a
vulnerability, put yourself in the situation. For Example: You can say to yourself, “ I can
be threat to an organization but vulnerability, I can’t .”
Sold as Single Copy
38
What is an Exposure Factor?
The Exposure Factor (EF) provides the percentage of loss if a certain adverse event takes
place. Take the case of an electrical surge in the power supply to a key component, for
example. If the component burns out, this might represent 25% of the entire exposure.
The EF will then be 25%.
What is an ARO?
ARO is the Annual Rate of Occurrence.
1. It is an estimation of the frequency of a threat occurrence in a year.
2. If a hard disk crash occurs once in five years, the ARO will be 1/5 = . 20.
3. The ARO can be a whole number or a fraction.

What is an ALE?
ALE is the Annual Loss Expectancy, representing the loss in terms of the dollar value.
What are the key equations for Risk Assessment?
Single Loss Exposure ($) = Asset Value ($) x Exposure Factor (%)
Annual Rate of Occurrence = Number of occurrences ÷ Number of years
Annual Loss Expectancy ($) = SLE ($) x ARO
How is the value of the ALE useful to the organization?
If the ALE is $5000 and the safeguard cost is $100,000 over five years, the per year
safeguard cost will be 100,000/5 = $20,000/year.
It is obviously not feasible to spend $20,000/per year for an Annual Loss Expectancy of
$5000.
Points to remember:
1. The value of all assets should be known
2. The auditor should be aware of the Exposure Factor (EF) percentage.
3. Management concerns itself only with the ALE
4. The EF is always given as a percentage
5. The EF provides the possible degree of destruction to an asset
6. The EF represents the percentage of loss, not the percentage chance of occurrence
7. The EF is the percentage of loss, irrespective of the frequency of occurrence. It
might occur once in three years or three times in one year.
What is the Quantitative Risk Assessment?
1. Measurement of the potential loss (EF and SLE)
2. Establish rate of occurrence (ARO)
3. Calculate value (ALE)
Sold as Single Copy
39

How do is a Qualitative Risk Assessment Analysis performed?
1. No hard and fast rule
2. Scenario-oriented
3. Based on the same assets and threat scenarios as in the Quantitative Analysis
What is the role of the Delphi Technique in Qualitative Risk Analysis?
The Delphi Technique is simply a group discussion method, where each member has a
vote.
1. Group members are asked to write down their responses
2. All responses are compiled and distributed to members
3. Their comments are written down, and are again compiled and redistributed
4. The process continues until consensus is reached
How do the Quantitative and Qualitative Risk Assessments compare?
Sold as Single Copy
40
What is a PSE?
PSE stands for Preliminary Security Examination. Top management reviews the PSE
prior to launching a Risk Assessment assignment.
What are the components of a PSE?
1. Asset cost/value
2. Listing of threats
3. Documentation of existing security measures.
Quantitative Qualitative
Objective Subjective
Dollar value is assigned to risk No dollar value is assigned
Cost Benefit Analyses No
Automated (how?) and complex No automation; less complex
Less guess work More guess work
Result easy to communicate Result difficult to communicate

What is the difference between a Risk Analysis and BIA?
Sold as Single Copy
41
In technical terms, what are the three steps of a Risk Analysis?
1. Estimate possible losses
2. Analyze the threat
3. Define ALE
How is the Risk Analysis carried out?
The Risk Analysis is carried out by a simple three-step process:
Step 1: Estimate Potential Losses
a. Valuation of the Asset
b. Calculation of SLE
Step 2: Analyze the threat potential
a. Probability of threat occurring
b. Find the asset VA
c. Estimate ARO
Step 3: Calculate ALE
a. ALE = SLE x ARO
Risk Analysis Business Impact Analysis
More complex Less complex
Most companies need to perform a Risk
Analysis exercise when they start out
Undertaken once the Risk Analysis has
been performed. Later, if small magnitude
changes are needed, a BIA is performed.
3- Step Process Same 3-Step Process

What is the checklist of threat sources?
1. Internal users
2. Hackers
3. International or regional conflict
4. Badly-defined Operational Procedures
5. Poorly written applications
6. Environmental hazards
7. Weak computer infrastructure
8. Misplaced priorities
What is the checklist for compiling the Risk Analysis?
1. List of critical assets
2. Critical asset costs
3. List of threats
4. Probability that threat will occur
5. Potential losses
6. Remedial measures
How do you estimate Potential Losses?
1. Valuation of assets
2. Calculate SLE
Once the risk is defined, how it is handled?
1. Risk Reduced: With the help of safeguards
2. Risk Transferred: With the help of insurance and other instruments
3. Risk Accepted: Management is aware of the risk, but there are not sufficient
funds available to reduce or transfer the risk
4. Risk Rejected: Management does not accept the risk in the first place
Sold as Single Copy
42

What is the most difficult part of Risk Assessment?
Asset Valuation is the most difficult part of RA.
How is the Asset Valuation carried out?
1. Take the initial cost
2. Establish the cost of testing
3. Estimate the cost of roll-out
4. Estimate the cost of maintenance
5. Lastly, establish the value in the open market (external to the company)
Why is Asset Valuation so important?
Asset valuation is a prerequisite for the following activities:
1. Risk Assessment
2. Business Impact Analysis
3. Selecting the correct safeguard
4. Cost Benefit Analysis
5. Security audit
6. Security control
What happens if the Information Asset Valuation is not done properly?
This could result in the following:
1. Improper controls
2. Protection of the incorrect assets
3. Acquisition of the wrong safeguard
What is a prerequisite for applying the security controls?
You must define the value of the information.
Sold as Single Copy
43

What is Risk Mitigation?
1. Selecting a counter-measure / safeguard
2. Accepting the residual risk
3. Implementation of control and monitoring mechanisms
What is the Total Risk?
Total Risk = Threat x Vulnerability x Asset Value
What is the Residual Risk?
It is a well-known fact that it is impossible to ensure 100% security. If you have
implemented safeguards against 95% of threats, then the Residual Risk is 5%.
Residual Risk = Total Risk - Safeguards
Safeguards:
What is the next step, once the Risk Assessment has been completed?
Search for the counter-measures and safeguards
How are safeguards selected?
The threats are matched against the appropriate safeguards.
What to look for when selecting a safeguard:
1. Functionality
2. Cost
3. Cost Benefit
What is the most important factor to be considered before a safeguard is
implemented?
A Cost Benefit Analysis is essential before a safeguard is implemented.
What should be the default of a safeguard?
Sold as Single Copy
44

The default should be a fail-safe, with the fewest possible privileges
Sold as Single Copy
45
Selection of Safeguards
On what basis are safeguards selected?
The safeguard selection criteria can be divided into two categories:
I. Primary Criteria
a. Operations should be simple
b. Most operations should be automated
iii. Recovery from Failure
a. Recovery should be safe
b. No asset destruction
c. No rights violation
II. Secondary Criteria
i. Easy to Audit
a.
b.
Must provide an audit of logs
Viewer for log is preferred
ii. Vendor Support
a. Local vendor or local support
b. Proven solution
iii. Easy to Maintain
i. Cost/Benefit
a. ALE before safeguard US$ 20,000
b. ALE after safeguard 2,000
c. Reduction in ALE (a-b) 18,000
d. Cost of safeguard per year 5,000
e. Benefit from safeguard (c-d) 13,000
ii. Minimal Manual Intervention

a. Average person should be able to maintain it with formal
training
b. Simple operations and troubleshooting
Sold as Single Copy
46

Risk Analysis and Auditing
Why is risk analysis part of Audit Planning?
A risk analysis helps to identify the following:
1. Risk
2. Vulnerability
Once the risk and vulnerability have been defined, it is easier for the auditor to determine the controls.
Internal Controls
What is the purpose of using internal controls?
Internal controls provide the following:
1. Assurance that the organization’s objectives are met
2. Prevention or mitigation of risk of undesired events
What are some examples of internal controls?
1. Policies
2. Standards
3. Procedures and Practices.
What is the relationship between control and the control objectives?
Control is way in which the control objectives are met.
Who has the ultimate responsibility for the control?
Senior Management
Sold as Single Copy
47

How is the strength of the control measured?
The strength of the control is measured in the following terms:
1. Design strength
2. Effectiveness
When evaluating the strength of the controls, what factors should be
considered?
1. Preventive or detective
2. Formal or ad hoc
3. Manual or Automated/Programmed
Sold as Single Copy
48

Internal Control Objective
What is an Internal Control Objective?
This is a statement used to implement a particular "control procedure” for a certain
activity.
Or
A statement of the desired result achieved by implementing certain control procedures for
a particular activity.
What are the main objectives of implementing internal control?
1. Protecting and safeguarding the asset
2. Assuring integrity for the resources
3. Ensuring effectiveness and efficiency of the options
4. Complying with growth polices and procedures
5. Providing business continuity and disaster recovery capability.
What are the three (3) major controls in the Internal Control System?
1. Internal accounting control: Related to the accounting function.
2. Operational controls: Related to day-to-day operations
3. Administrative controls: Compliance with management polices and operation
efficiency in the functional areas. (Administrative controls also support the
operational controls, to some extent)
What are some examples of Information System Control objectives?
To ensure:
1. Information is up-to-date and secure
2. Data entered in the system is relevant
3. All of the rejected logins are reported
4. Duplicate records are recorded and reported for securitization
5. Data is backed up
6. Changes follow the change control procedures
Sold as Single Copy
49

Information Systems Control Procedures
What do the control procedures include?
1. Policies
2. Practices
What are some examples of control procedures?
1. Strategy and direction
2. System administration and change control management
3. Data processing controls
4. Quality Assurance procedures
5. Physical controls
6. DRP/BCP
7. Database administration controls.
What is the relationship between General Control Procures and IS-Specific
procedures?
Normally general control procedures can be mapped to Information System procedures
What are the six Information Control procedures?
1. General organization control procedures
2. Control of access to data and programs
3. System development controls
4. Data processing operations
5. Technical support controls
6. Processing of Quality Assurance control
Does the “Internal Control Objective” apply only to the manual system?
No; it applies to all areas, manual or automated. However, the control implementation
features are different.
Sold as Single Copy Unauthorized
Circulation Strictly Prohibited
50

COBIT
What is COBIT?
COBIT stands for the Control Objectives for Information and related Technology.
What does COBIT provide?
1. Framework for Information System control
2. Good practices for IT governance
3. Control and assurance for effective use of IT
How many hi-Level and detail control objectives are there in COBIT?
Hi-level objectives: 34
Detail objectives: 300 plus
How many standards does COBIT relate to?
36plus.
What are the six (6) components of COBIT?
1. Executive Summary
2. Framework
3. Control objectives
4. Management guidelines
5. Audit guidelines
6. Implementation toolset
What are the three major classifications of controls?
1. Preventive
2. Detective
3. Corrective
Sold as Single Copy
51

What are some examples of preventative controls?
1. Employing well-qualified people
2. Segregating duties
3. Well-designed documents
4. Implementing proper procedures
5. Edit Checks
6. Controlling access
What are some examples of detective controls?
1. Hash Totals
2. Check points
3. Error Message
4. Performance Review
5. Double checking of calculations
What are the examples of corrective controls?
1. Recovery Procedures
2. Disaster Recovery Planning
Sold as Single Copy
52

Performing an Information System Audit
What is Auditing?
A structured process by which an independent, competent person obtains relevant
evidence to ascertain an opinion regarding an event or economic entity, and reports
conformance to a pre-defined set of standards.
What does the audit program consist of?
1. Objectives
2. Audit Procedures
What is required from an IS auditor during the audit process?
1. Ascertain the objectives
2. Gather evidence
3. Evaluate the control strength
4. Prepare the report
5. Present to management
What are the five (5) types of audits?
1. Financial Audit: Focuses on the integrity and reliability of the financial
statement
2. Operational Audit: Evaluates the internal controls of a given area
3. Integrated Audit: Financial audit + Operational audit
4. Administrative Audit: Evaluates the efficiency of an organization’s operational
activity
5. Information Systems Audit: Evaluates Information Systems and related
resources. The main emphasis is on the following:
a. Safety of assets
b. Integrity of data
c. Confidentiality of information
d. Presence of appropriate internal controls
Sold as Single Copy
53

What is the major difference between an IS audit and other types of audit?
As all audits are based on objectives and scopes, the IS auditor sees things from a
different aspect , such as confidentiality, availability, quality, efficiency, service and
reliability.
What are the “General Audit Procedures” in a typical audit?
1. Understanding of the audit area
2. Risk assessment and audit schedule and plan
3. Preliminary review
4. Evaluations
5. Control test
6. Further testing, i.e. substantive testing
7. Communication of result and preparation of report
8. Follow-up
What should the IS auditor be aware of regarding the testing and evaluation
of the Information System control?
1. Third party generalized audit software used to survey contents, e.g. the data file
2. Flow-charging technique
3. Specialized software used at the Operating System level in order to understand
vulnerabilities.
4. Use of previous audit report
Sold as Single Copy
54

Audit Methodology
What is the Audit Strategy or Methodology?
This is a set of audit procedures (documented) used to achieve the audit objective.
What are the components of an Audit Strategy?
1. SOS (Statement of Scope)
2. Statement of Audit Objectives
3. Statement of Work Program
What are the eight (8) steps in a typical audit?
1. Identify the area to be audited.
2. Audit Objective
3. Audit Scope
4. Pre-Audit Planning
5. Data-gathering and audit procedure
6. Review the result
7. Methods of communications to communicate result to the senior management
8. Audit report
What is the difference between an Audit Objective and an Audit Scope?
Audit Objective: Purpose of audit, e.g. in e-banking, whether proper controls are there or
not.
Audit Scope: Specify the function, system or unit to the included in audit
What are the two major components needed in pre-audit planning?
1. Identification of technical skills
2. Resources needed.
Sold as Single Copy
55

What sources of Information can be used in the pre-audit planning phase,
in order to get a better understanding of the auditee?
1. Polices and procedures
2. Standards and guidelines
3. Previous audit work
What information is included in a typical audit report?
1. Follow-up procedure of the last audit
2. Process to evaluate
3. Procedure to test the controls
4. Evaluations of policies, procedures and documentation
What is the Audit Program?
It is a product of the audit process.
What does the Audit Program provide?
1. Guide for recording and documenting the steps of the audit
2. Type and extent of the matter reviewed
3. Accountability of the performance
Sold as Single Copy
56

Audit Risk and Materiality
What is the new trend in the auditing approach?
Risk-based auditing
What are the different tests in risk-based auditing?
Auditor to decide between two types of testing, i.e.
1. Compliance Testing or
2. Substantive Testing
What are the five steps in risk-based auditing?
1. Gather the information and do the planning
2. Understand the internal controls
3. Perform the compliance test
4. Perform the substantive test
5. Write the reports and recommendations
How can the IS auditor gather information?
1. Review the business’s and industry’s products
2. Previous year’s audit report
3. Financial information
4. Web site of the company
5. Web site of the competition
How can the internal control be understood?
The internal control can be understood through an examination of the control
environment, carrying out a Risk Assessment, control procedures, etc.
What does the compliance test evaluate?
Mainly it tests the policies, procedures and segregation of duties.
Sold as Single Copy
57

What is a substantive test?
This is a detailed test.
What is the audit risk?
This refers to the risk of having an incorrect assumption about the subject under audit.
What is the material risk?
This term refers to errors or non-compliance or a weakness in the internal control, which
can be a significant threat to the organization.
How can a threat be identified as “significant” or not?
Through the use of a risk-based audit report.
Is the significance of non-compliance absolute or relative?
It is relative. Something that is significant at the operations level might not be significant
for top management.
How can audit risk be avoided?
If the sample is chosen “scientifically”, the audit risk is minimized.
What role do “inherent risk” in detection risk or “control risk” in “risk-
based auditing” play?
They play no role; they are not assessed.
On what bases do IS auditors rely?
IS auditors rely on the risks inherent in
1. Internal Control
2. External Controls
Sold as Single Copy
58

What are the three (3) areas of business risk?
1. Financial
2. Regulatory
3. Operations
Why is it necessary for IS auditors to understand the nature of the
business?
If the IS auditor understands the business, he is in a better position to identify the risk and
categorize it accordingly.
What is a Risk Model Assessment?
This specifies the weights for the different types of risks associated with a particular
business.
Sold as Single Copy
59

Risk Assessment Techniques
Which business should be audited first?
A business with high risk.
How are the high-risk areas determined?
Through the use of a risk Assessment.
How does the risk assessment help to determine which areas should be
audited?
1. Limited auditing resources are effectively allocated for high-risk area auditing
2. A Risk Assessment helps the auditor focus on the relevant critical business
information for top management
3. Improves efficiency
What are the different methods for carrying out Risk Assessments?
1. Scoring System
2. Judgmental
What does the scoring system do?
The scoring system makes use of the risk factor to prioritize the audits.
What variables are considered in the scoring system?
1. Technical Complexity
2. Financial loss (if any)
3. Level of control procedures
Are the variable always weighted?
No, these are not always weighted.
Sold as Single Copy
60

How do scoring systems help in auditing?
Audits are scheduled for those areas with higher risk values.
With regard to selecting the area to be audited, what is the judgmental
method?
When the judgmental method is used, decisions are made based on following:
1. Business insight
2. Senior management directives
3. Business goals
4. Results of earlier audit
Will the risk assessment methods remain the same in the future?
No, the methods might change based on the needs of the organization.
Sold as Single Copy
61

Audit Objectives
What is the difference between Control Objectives and Audit Objectives?
Sold as Single Copy
62
With regard to access, what should the audit include?
1. Compliance with regulatory and legal requirements
2. Assessment of the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information.
Is it possible that management will give the IS Auditor some General
objectives?
Yes, the IS auditor may be given some general objectives. For example, the auditor might
be asked to:
1. Audit the internal control of application development
2. Audit the integrity of the core business application.
What is the key element in planning the Information System audit?
It is the mapping, or the translation of:
Basic audit objectives  Information System objectives.
So, the IS auditor should have the skills to understand that the basic objective of an audit
can be mapped to the IS control objectives.
What is the basic purpose of an IS Audit?
1. Identify control objectives
2. Establish Related controls for addressing objectives
Control Objectives Audit Objective
Focus is on the functioning of the
internal control.
Focus is on the "specific goals" that the audit
should achieve

What should the IS auditor identify in the initial review?
Firstly the IS auditor should identify the initial controls.
What does the IS auditor specify in the initial review?
The key controls
How are the controls tested?
Through the use of the following:
1. Compliance
2. Substantive Testing
What is the difference between Compliance and Substantive Testing?
Sold as Single Copy
63
What is the correlation between the level of internal control and the amount
of substantive testing required?
1. The more adequate the controls, the fewer substantive tests are needed.
2. The weaker the Internal Control, the more substantive tests are needed.
Compliance Testing Substantive Testing
The compliance testing is done initially to
check whether the key controls are working
Substantive testing usually follows
compliance testing
Testing of the control (for compliance) Testing of integrity
Check compliance against policies and
procedures
Used for monetary transactions or places
where there is little structure.
Mostly dependent on the availability of
trail documentation
Not very dependent on the documentation.
Once the documentation is available for a
particular issue, the compliance test is
positive
Availability of documentation is not
enough. The validity and integrity of the
documentation are challenged in the testing

What are the four (4) steps for checking control in an environment?
1. Preview: The system is previewed so that the controls can be checked
2. Compliance test: Confirms the functionality of the controls
3. Control evaluation: Evaluates the scope and size of the substantive test
4. Substantive test: Evaluates the validity of the data
What are the two (2) types of substantive test?
1. Test for balances and transactions (more financially related)
2. Test for analytical procedure review
Sold as Single Copy
64

Evidence
What is the definition of evidence?
This is proof, in the form of information or documents, that the organization is following
certain audit criteria or objectives.
What is the importance of evidence?
The auditor’s opinion is based on the evidence gathered.
What are the five (5) forms of evidence that the IS Auditor can use?
1. Auditor observation
2. Interview notes
3. Correspondence extracts
4. Internal documentation
5. Results of the audit tests
What are the three (3) factors showing the reliability of the evidence?
1. Provider of the evidence must be independent.
2. Provider of the evidence is qualified.
3. Evidence is more of an objective nature rather than subjective.
Should the IS auditor only look for “good evidence ”?
No, the auditor should focus on evidence that supports the objective, not on whether the
evidence is good or bad.
How does the quality and quantity of the evidence map to IFAC
(International Federation of Accountants )?
Sold as Single Copy
Copyright © 2004 Pacific Information Security Consulting
www.PacificIS.com
65
ISACA IFAC
Quality of the evidence Competency, i.e. validity and
relevancy
Quantity of the evidence Sufficient – The auditor decides
whether the evidence is sufficient

What is ISCA number stands for auditing?
060.020
What techniques are used to gather evidence?
1. Review of IS Organization Structure
2. Review of policies, standards and procedures
3. Baseline documentation for
a. Input validity
b. Information processing
c. Integrity of the process
d. Validity of the output
e. SDLC DOCUMENTATION
f. User manual
g. Operation manual
h. Log files
i. Quality Assurance Reports
Is traditional documentation required for CASE or prototyping?
No, traditional documentation is only required for SDLC and related methodology, but
not for CASE and prototyping.
What documentation is relevant for CASE and prototyping?
1. Initial requirement and justification of the project
2. Database specification
3. File layout and others.
Sampling
When is sampling used?
Sampling is used when time and cost are the constraints and verification of the total
policy is not possible.
Sold as Single Copy
66

What is the meaning of population with respect to sampling?
Population refers to all the members of a group which need to be examined.
What is a sample?
A sample is the subset of the population.
What is a sample used for?
Often it is used to draw an inference about the characteristics of the population.
Sold as Single Copy
67

Sampling Basics - Confidence Coefficient & Level of Risk
What is the confidence coefficient?
The confidence coefficient is the probability that the sample is truly representative of the
population.
How is the confidence coefficient represented?
It is represented as a percentage.
At what confidence coefficient level should the IS auditor feel comfortable?
95%
What is the relationship between the confidence coefficient and sample
size?
The higher the confidence coefficient, the greater the sample size. For greater confidence
a bigger sample size is needed; e.g., if the confidence coefficient is 100% (which it can't
be), 100% of the population would have to be used.
What is the difference between the "Confidence Coefficient", "Confidence
Level" and "Reliability Factor "?
No difference; they all refer to the same thing.
What is the level of risk?
Level of Risk = 1 - Confidence Coefficient
Sold as Single Copy
68

Sampling Basics - Precision
What does the term ‘sampling precision’ refer to?
Precision is the acceptable range of difference between the actual population and the
sample.
What is the difference between Precision and Confidence Level?
1. Precision is the opposite of Confidence Level
2. When the precision level is low, the confidence level is high
Which is better: a higher or lower precision level?
1. If the required precision is 0%, this means that there would is no difference
between my sample and the population, i.e. Sample Size = Population. Even with
a precision of 5%, the sample is almost as big as the population.
2. Similarly, if the precision is 100%, this means that Actual - Sample = 100%
difference is acceptable
3. The precision level should be decided by the IS Auditor.
What is the relationship between Precision and Sample Size?
The relationship is inversely proportional.
What is the difference between "Attribute Sampling" and “Variable
Sampling ”?
Attribute Sampling: Represented as a percentage
Variable Sampling: Represented in numbers, or the monetary amount.
What is the difference between "Precision range” and "Precision Mean "?
There is no difference; they mean the same thing. (Substantive testing).
Sold as Single Copy
69

Sampling Basics - Expected Error Rate & Tolerable Error Rate
What is the Expected Error Rate (EER )?
As the name indicates, this refers to the expected errors, represented as a percentage of
the error.
What is the effect of EER on Sample Size?
It is directly proportional, i.e. if the EER is high it means that more errors are foreseen.
Smaller the sample size, there is possibility of bigger EER.
How is the EER applied to the variable sampling formula?
The EER is not applied to the variable sampling formula; it is only used with the
"Attribute Sampling" formulas.
What is the tolerable error rate?
This is the number of errors or mis-statements that can exist without the result being
materially mis-stated.
How are tolerable error rates used in sampling?
They are used to plan the upper limit of the "precision range" for testing compliance.
How is the tolerable error rate represented?
Sold as Single Copy
70

Sampling Basics - Standard Deviation and Variance
What is the prerequisite of Standard Deviation?
The sample mean.
What is the sample mean?
Sample Mean = Sum of Sample Value/ Sample Size
The mean of a random sample is an unbiased estimate of the mean of the population from
which it was drawn.
Another way to say this is to assert that regardless of the size of the population and the
size of the random sample, it can be shown (through the Central Limit Theorem) that if
random samples of the same size were repeatedly taken from the same population, the
sample means would cluster around the exact value of the population mean.
What does the sample mean indicate?
The average size of the sample.
What is Standard Deviation?
To calculate the standard deviation of a population it is first necessary to calculate that
population's variance. Numerically, the standard deviation is the square root of the
variance. Unlike the variance, which is a somewhat abstract measure of variability, the
standard deviation can be readily conceptualized as a distance along the scale of
measurement.
What is Variance?
Variance calculates variability that characterizes the dispersion among the measures in a
population. Numerically, the variance is the average of the squared deviations from the
mean.
To calculate the variance of a given population:
1. First calculate the mean of the scores
2. Measure how much each score deviates from the mean
.3Square that deviation (by multiplying it by itself .) 71

What is the Standard Deviation?
Standard deviation is the square root of the variance.
What is the Sample Standard Deviation?
This refers to the variance of the sample from the sample mean.
What is the Population Standard Deviation?
Measures the deviation from the Normal Distribution.
What is the relationship between the standard deviation and sample size?
The relationship is directly proportional. As with any of the error measurement tools, the
higher the standard deviation or EER, the larger the error / deviation can be expected. In
order to minimize these effects, the sample size must be increased.
How can a population’s standard deviation be applied to the attribute
sampling formula?
It can’t; it can be only applied to the "Variable Sampling Formula ".
Sold as Single Copy
72

Other Sampling Issues
What are the two approaches for auditing?
1. Statistical Sampling
2. Non-Statistical Sampling (also known as Judgmental Sampling)
What is the difference between Statistical Sampling and Non-Statistical
Sampling?
Sold as Single Copy
73
In statistical sampling, how can the closeness of “sample size” be
determined?
The closeness is represented by the sample’s precision
How does one know that the sample is reliable?
The reliability or the confidence level is presented by a number between 1 and 100.
How is the final assessment represented in Statistical Sampling?
What is Sample Risk?
Sample size is not a true representative of the population and the conclusion drawn from
the sample is wrong.
What is the “confidence coefficient ”?
This quantifies the probability of error in the sample.
Statistical Sampling Non Statistical Sampling
Objective in nature. Used for determining
the following:
a. Sample Size
b. Selection Criteria
Subjective; uses auditor’s judgment to
determine the following:
a. Sample Size
b. Selection Criteria
Quantitative decision Qualitative decision
Quantifiable result Non-quantifiable result

What is the ideal statistical sample?
Each item in the population should have an equal opportunity to be selected.
What are the two general approaches?
1. Attribute Sampling
2. Variable Sampling
What are the differences between attribute sampling and variable
sampling?
Sold as Single Copy
74
Attribute Sampling Variable Sampling
Used in compliance testing situations More commonly used in substantive testing
Focuses on whether the attribute is present
or absent
Focuses on the characteristics of the
population e.g. weight, dollar, etc…
Output/conclusion is in the form of “Rate
of Incidence”
Output/conclusion is in the form of
“Deviation from the norm”
"Yes or No" check Checks for “Yes, but also how much 'YES'
has deviated from the normal

Attribute Sampling
What are the three different methods of proportional attribute sampling?
1. Fixed sample-size attribute sampling
2. Discovery sampling
3. Stop-or-go sampling
What is the difference between “Attribute Sampling,” “Fixed Sample Size
Attribute Sampling” and “Frequency-estimating Sampling ”?
None; they are all the same.
What are the main features of “Fixed Sample Size ”?
1. Look for the percentage of occurrence of attribute
2. Questions regarding “how many” questions are addressed
What are the features of “stop-or-go” sampling?
1. Avoids excess sampling.
2. Useful when expected occurrences are low.
What are the features of Discovery Sampling?
1. Used when the objective is to “discover” fraud or irregularities
2. Useful when expected occurrences of events are extremely low
Sold as Single Copy
75

Variable Sampling
What is the difference between “variable sampling”, “mean estimation
sampling” and “dollar estimation ”?
There is no difference; they are all the same.
What is the variable sampling used for?
To estimate the quantitative value, e.g. dollar, weight.
What are the seven (7) items the auditor should consider while evaluating
the sample?
1. Determine the test objective of the test
2. Define the populations
3. Determine the sampling method
4. Determine the sample size
5. Select the sample
6. Evaluate the sample
7. Confirm that the sample is representative of the population
Sold as Single Copy
76

CAAT
What is CAAT?
CAAT stands for Computer-Assisted Audit Technique. These are tools for auditors.
How can CAAT assist auditors?
CAAT assists the IS auditor in the following ways:
1. Access relevant data and information
2. Analyze the data as per the objective of the audit
3. Report findings.
Why is CAAT important for the IS auditor?
Today most of the evidence required by IS auditors is not in hard copy format; rather it is
spread over different media across different platforms. The only way of collecting all
these pieces of evidence efficiently is by using CAAT.
What are the five (5) Functional Capabilities of CAAT?
1. The ability to access files across different platforms
2. File manipulation and reorganization, e.g. indexing, sorting, linking and merging
3. Data selection on the basis of criteria and filtering conditions
4. Performs statistical functions, e.g. sampling, frequency analyses
5. Has an arithmetical function
What are some examples of CAAT software?
1. IDEA
2. ACL
3. SQL Command
4. Third party software
5. Other utility software
Sold as Single Copy
77

a. Database auditing software
b. Integrity testing software
What is GAS?
GAS stands for Generalized Audit Software.
What are the sources of input for GAS?
GAS can read and access the following:
1. Different databases
2. Flat files
3. ASCII files
What does GAS do?
1. Collects data
2. Organizes information and sequencing
3. Mathematical computation
4. Stratification
5. Duplicate checks
6. Statistical analysis
What are the IS auditor’s concerns regarding CAAT?
Prior to selecting the CAAT software, the IS auditor should check that it does the
following:
1. Provides reliable results
2. Does not compromise the integrity of the system
3. Maintain the confidentiality of the client.
Sold as Single Copy
78

What does the CAAT program record and retain?
1. Critical online reports
2. Comments on programs
3. Sample reports
4. Flow charts
5. File layouts
6. Recorded and filed definitions
7. Operating instructions
What types of accesses are recommended for the CAAT programs?
Read-only access.
What are the limitations of CAAT?
1. Might require more resources to install
2. IS auditor may need extensive training on the software
3. Integration with existing applications might be challenging.
Sold as Single Copy
79

Evaluating the Audit's Strengths and Weakness
What is the next step after the information and evidence for the audit have
been gathered?
Develop an auditing opinion.
What does the IS auditor do in order to develop an opinion?
1. The auditor uses his/her experience
2. Assesses the results of the evidence.
3. With regard to compliance, he checks that the controls match the control
objectives.
How should the control be evaluated?
Controls should match the control objective and should minimize or remove risk or
perceived risk.
How is the proper level of control assessed?
Most of the time the Control Matrix is used for this.
How is the control Matrix constructed?
1. Error types (top axis)
2. Control (side axis)
3. Matrix is filled using the ranking method
4. Once completed, the matrix shows the areas where the controls are lacking.
What are the compensating controls?
A strong control in one area can compensate for a weak control in another area. This type
of control is known as a compensating control.
What is the difference between a compensating control and an overlapping
controls?
Sold as Single Copy
80

1. A compensating control is when a strong control takes care of (supports) a weaker
control
2. An overlapping control is when two strong controls cover the same area.
What should an auditor do regarding a compensating control and
overlapping controls?
Prior to reporting the control weakness, the auditor should see whether there are any
compensating controls for the weak control area.
The auditor should report an overlapping control, as it might not be needed.
Sold as Single Copy
81

Materiality of the finding
What is the concept of the materiality of the finding?
This refers to the decision whether to mention a particular finding in an audit report,
based on its significance to the audience of the report. If the IS auditor concludes that
the it is a "material error" and may lead to a larger problem regarding control, it should be
reported.
To whom are IS auditors responsible?
1. Senior management
2. The Audit Committee of the Board of Directors.
Why should the IS auditor discuss a matter with the management staff
before communicating it to senior management?
For two reasons:
1. Get consensus
2. Develop a corrective action plan
What is the end result of the IS audit work?
An Audit Report.
What is the structure of the Audit Report?
1. Introduction
a. Audit Objective and Scope
b. Audit Period Coverage
c. Nature and Extent of the audit
Sold as Single Copy
82
2.
3.
4.
Auditor conclusion
Auditor reservations
Detailed findings and recommendations
Should the audit report only mention the negative points?
No; the audit report should report both negative and positive (constructive) points.

Should the IS auditor insist that his/her recommendations be implemented
immediately?
No. Immediate implication might not be possible due to constraints in resources.
However, the IS auditor can agree to planned implementation dates, and later the
progress of the implementation should be monitored.
Should the IS Auditor mention some of his/her findings in the report, even
if modifications are made prior to the report being given to the top
management?
Yes, the IS auditor should mention all of the findings, as they were at the start of the
audit. However, he should mention that the issues are being addressed.
What should the auditor do prior to the releasing the reports?
1. Discuss the recommendations
2. Establish the planned implementation dates/ time of implementation
3. Review and follow up on plans
What is the main sprit behind the audit?
1. Presence of control based on the risk assessment
2. In the case where controls are missing, there should be some corrective action
plan.
3. Once the report has been presented, there should be a follow-up to the corrective
action
Do corrective actions resolve all of the problems?
No, the corrective action may result in its own risks and problems.
What happens just prior to the end of the auditing assignment?
An exit interview is conducted.
Sold as Single Copy
83

What is discussed in the Exit Interview?
1. Findings and recommendations
2. Implementation dates
3. Justification of recommendations in terms of realistic approach and cost
4. Discussion of alternative and compensating controls
What is the IS audit documentation?
This refers to the record and evidence of the audit work performed. It contains complete
interview questionnaires, notes, system flowcharts, narratives and work papers.
Sold as Single Copy
84

CSA- Control Self-Assessment
What is the CSA?
This is a formal method of examining the existing controls of the system in a professional
way.
What are the two methods of self-assessment?
1. Structured questionnaire
2. Automated tools
Is it possible to include outsiders in the CSA?
Yes, if the skills are not available, it can be done.
What is the primary objective of an internal audit?
To shift some of the responsibility from an internal audit to the functional areas.
Does a CSA replace the responsibility of the internal audit?
No, it actually enhances it.
Who is responsible for the controls?
Functional managers, e.g. the line managers.
What are the additional benefits of using a CSA?
1. Education
2. Empowerment of the worker to assess the asset
3. Atmosphere to enhance the control environment
Sold as Single Copy
85

What are the three phases of a CSA?
1. Planning
2. Implementation
3. Monitoring
What is the role of the auditor in a CSA?
1. Assessment facilitator
2. Internal control specialist/professional
3. Leading and guiding the functional people to do a CSA.
How could an auditor understand the business before starting the audit?
1. Preliminary survey
2. Walk-through
What is the first step in a CSA project?
Conduct a meeting with the business unit manager to determine the scope and objective
of the CSA.
What are the tools used in a CSA?
1. Management meeting
2. Worksheet
3. Workshops
4. Questionnaire
What development techniques are needed for the CSA program?
1. Information gathering
2. Empowerment
3. Decision-making.
Sold as Single Copy
86

What is the main advantage of a workshop-based CSA?
1. Group decision-making
2. Empowerment of the employee.
How would you differentiate between the traditional approach and the CSA
approach?
Sold as Single Copy
87
Traditional Approach CSA Approach
Primary responsibility is on the IS auditor Primary responsibility is shared between
the management and the IS auditor
Management and other staff are not directly
responsible for the audit
Management and other staff are
empowered to have more responsibility
Duties are assigned Empowerment is carried out
Rule and policy-driven Ongoing process of learning and
improvement
IS auditor involvement is maximum.
Employee participation is limited.
Employee participation is extensive. IS
auditor involvement is limited.
Narrow focus Broader focus
Only auditors and special consultants are
involved
Staff members at different levels are
involved.

Corporate Governance
What is corporate governance?
This refers to the ethical corporate behavior of top management with regard to
supervising, monitoring, controlling and directing the business entity, in order to
safeguard the corporate assets and minimize the potential risk.
The Organization of Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) defines it as:
"The distribution of rights and responsibilities among different participants in the
corporation, such as the Board, managers, shareholders and other stakeholders, and spells
out the rules and procedures for making decisions on corporate affairs. By doing this, it
also provides the structure through which the company objectives are set and the means
of attaining those objectives and monitoring performance ".
What are the advantages to proper corporate governance?
1. A framework is formed to manage and report risk.
2. It is an internal method of monitoring, addressing and minimizing risk.
Sold as Single Copy
88

Cisa domain 1

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to Cisa domain 1 (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Cisa domain 1