Cleveland Tree Plan Tree Selection Guide

CLEVELAND TREE PLAN 2020: TREE SELECTION GUIDE 1
TREE SELECTION GUIDE
A LIST OF APPROPRIATE TREES FOR
URBAN AND SUBURBAN AREAS

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Charles Tubesing, Plant Collections Curator (ret.)
Roger Gettig, Curator of Living Collections and
Land Assets
Ethan Johnson, Plant Records Curator
Margeaux Apple, Plant Recorder
Courtney Blashka, Director of Community Forestry
& Conservation
Guide available at holdenfg.org
This Tree Selection Guide was developed by Holden
Forests & Gardens staff and cannot be reproduced
without expressed permission from Holden Forests
& Gardens.
ABOUT THIS GUIDE
This Tree Selection Guide provides essential information to help
you choose climate-resilient trees suitable for urban and suburban
areas in northeast Ohio. This region includes Cuyahoga, Summit,
Lorain, Wayne, Lake, Geauga, Portage, Stark, Ashtabula, Trumbull,
Mahoning, Columbiana and Ashland counties. It is designed to help
you choose from a diverse list of appropriate trees for a variety of
situations, with consideration given to trees that are resistant to pests
and diseases and tolerate conditions like de-icing salt, air pollution,
soil compaction, saturated soils and drought.
Our recommendations are based on our best available current
knowledge as to what species will provide the greatest positive
impact to increasing Cleveland’s canopy cover and also do no harm.
The list includes native as well as non-native trees. Trees that are
known to be invasive are not included in this guide.
All trees listed are well-suited for the temperature extremes of this
region. For ease of use, trees in the guide are grouped by size
at maturity (Small, Medium and Large) and then alphabetically
by scientific name. Each column provides information about the
tree including whether it is deciduous or evergreen and native to
the eastern United States, or not. Physical characteristics such
as canopy form and spread at maturity, growth rate, tolerances to
shade, salt, soil types, landscape suitability, value to wildlife, people
and additional notes that would benefit the user are also included.
LIMITATIONS OF THIS GUIDE
This guide does not include all native trees nor does it include
all cultivars and varieties, and acknowledges that there is no
perfect tree for every situation. Commercially available and
appropriate cultivars are listed, along with some rarer cultivars
worth noting. It does not include trees that will only perform well
in a limited number of areas.
NORTHEAST OHIO
HARDINESS ZONE MAP
The USDA’s Hardiness Zone Map divides the U.S. into 11
zones based on average minimum winter temperature. A
plant’s Hardiness Zone refers to its ability to thrive in the
corresponding map location.
Northeast Ohio is in zones 5b, 6a and 6b, with average
annual minimum temperatures between 0° to -15° F. Trees
featured in this guide are suitable for planting in these zones.
You can also find the hardiness zone for the area where
you wish to plant by entering the location’s zip code in this
Interactive Plant Hardiness Zone Map created by the USDA’s
Agricultural Research Service.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
About this Guide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Hardiness Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Considerations: Key to Successful Planting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Native Trees . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Diversity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Maximizing Benefits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
RTRP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Site Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Species Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8
Choosing a Tree in the Nursery: What to look for. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Tree Matrix Category Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Size . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Tolerances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Site Selection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15
Value . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
Additional Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
Tree Selection Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18-33
Literature Cited . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35

CONSIDERATIONS: KEYS TO
SUCCESSFUL PLANTING
BIODIVERSITY: PRIORITIZE NATIVE SPECIES
As an organization, we recommend planting native trees or selections
created from natives whenever possible but recognize there are times
when native trees are not the best choice, especially in urban environ-
ments. Our list does include non-native trees that to the best of our
knowledge should not be invasive. Invasive trees should
be avoided.
Native species provide many benefits including:
• Protective cover for many animals
• Seeds, nuts, and fruits for squirrels and other mammals
• Seeds, fruits, and insects for birds
• Nectar for hummingbirds and butterflies
• Serving as larval host plants for butterfly caterpillars
• Suppressing introduction of invasive plants
• Creation of natural corridors for migrating wildlife
• Requiring less water, fertilizer, pesticides & fungicides since they
are suited to our climate and soil types
DIVERSIFY: PLANT A DIVERSE PALETTE OF TREES
In many urban areas, only a handful of species make up a
great majority of trees planted. For example, maple trees
(Acer genus) are currently in excess of the 25% of the
street tree population in Cleveland. While percentages
are unknown, it’s assumed a great majority of park and
private property trees are also maple. An insect or disease
infestation on maple could result in loss of over a quarter of
the street tree canopy and even more catastrophic to the
broader urban forest.
Institute the 10-20-30 rule as a guideline to reduce the risk
of catastrophic tree loss due to pests. The rule suggests
an urban tree population should include no more than 10%
of any one species, 20% of any one genus, or 30% of any
family. A more ambitious aspiration is planting no more than
15% of any family, 10% of any genus, or 5% of any species.
As a result, 90-95% of the tree population would remain
intact and unscathed should an insect or disease infestation
occur. Creating a tree planting plan before planting can aid in
urban forest diversity.
Planting only one species, as shown in this residential street, may
provide a uniform look but also proliferate insect pests and diseases
resulting in decline of the entire planting and loss of benefits to the
community. Callery pear (Pyrus calleryana) are also invasive and not
recommended to plant. (Photo Credit: Courtney Blashka)
MAXIMIZE BENEFITS PLANT LARGE-STATURE TREES
WHENEVER POSSIBLE TO MAXIMIZE SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND
ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS
Some of the many benefits trees provide communities include:
Improving Public Health & Safety
• Trees provide oxygen and remove particulate matter from the
air
• Trees reduce stress
• Tree-lined streets create a visual barrier and slow traffic,
providing safe, walkable streets
Adding Economic Value to Residential Properties & Businesses
• Trees save energy
• Trees increase property values
• Trees increase business traffic
Combating Climate Change
• Trees remove carbon dioxide and sequester carbon
• Trees cool the air, provide shade & lessen the effects of
urban heat islands
• Trees help prevent water pollution
Well maintained, large-stature trees provide more community benefits
as they grow. Tree benefits in terms of property value and ecosystem
services (stormwater managed, air pollution removed and carbon dioxide
absorbed) varies widely but can be as much as $80 to $120 per tree per
year for a large tree. Small stature trees, like the Japanese Tree Lilac,
may not provide much more than $15 in benefits on average. In some
cases, they are a net loss to communities after the costs of maintenance
are subtracted. The Center for Urban Forest Research has studied large,
medium, and small trees in a number of locations and found that, on
average, mature large trees deliver an annual net benefit two to six times
greater than mature small trees.
Tree-lined streets shade hardscape and offer respite on hot
summer days. (Photo Credit: CBlashka)
Native trees such as Tuliptree (Liriodendron tulipifera), Sycamore
(Platanus occidentalis) and Black Gum (Nyssa sylvatica) increase
biodiversity and are great selections for restoration sites.
(Photo Credit: Courtney Blashka)

RTRP: PLANT THE RIGHT TREE IN THE RIGHT PLACE
Improperly siting trees can result in economic, environmental, and
social losses to the community. The “right tree right place” maxim
is central to changing the conversation around trees, specifically
with respect to thinking of trees as assets versus liabilities (Arbor
Day Foundation). Tree planting and transplanting projects should
carefully consider a number of factors.
SITE CONSIDERATIONS
Conduct a thorough inspection of the planting site prior to selecting a
tree. Consider the following:
LIGHT EXPOSURE
Is the site in full sun, part sun, shade, or dense shade?
SOIL ISSUES
Drainage – is there standing water for more than a few hours at
any time? If there is, you may have a problem.
Compaction – is the ground hard like concrete or soft as the
forest floor? Harder, or dense soils make it more difficult for trees
to grow.
pH – a measurement on a scale from (1-14), 7 is neutral; below
that is acidic and above is alkaline. The ideal pH for most
conditions is 6.5.
Fertility – this factor is directly related to organic matter content.
All urban soils in northeast Ohio are low in organic matter and
thus, low in fertility.
AVAILABLE ROOT SPACE
Tree roots can extend two to three times the crown width. The larger
the tree, the more extensive the root system. Minimum soil volumes
for root space are suggested to be 1–2 ft3 for each square foot of
projected mature crown (Lindsey and Bassuk 1991). Other formulas
have derived minimum soil volumes based on trunk to crown diameter
(Urban 2008). Urban foresters generally adhere to the following soil
volume minimums: 300 cubic feet for small trees, 600 cubic feet for
medium trees, and 1,000 cubic feet for large trees.
PROXIMITY TO INFRASTRUCTURE
How tall and wide will the crown be? How fast does it grow?
Overhead Utilities: Planting medium or large trees underneath
overhead utilities is a potentially costly mistake. Only small trees
less than 25 feet tall at maturity should be planted underneath
utility lines to limit the potential for future conflicts as trees mature
in size.
Underground Utilities - The location of below-ground utilities is
equally concerning. The presence of buried electrical, natural gas,
and water lines can limit the viability of planting sites. Detection of
these utilities can be accomplished by dialing 811 for Ohio Utilities
Protection Services (OUPS) or visiting oups.org at least 48 hours
in advance of planting.
Trees that reach heights over 25’ at maturity will become
disfigured by utility pruning like this honeylocust (Gleditsia
triacanthos) and should not be planted under energized lines.
(Photo Credit: CBlashka)
Girdling roots of a tree lawn planted red maple (Acer rubrum)
exposed via airspade. Photo taken in a suburban cul-de-sac on
Cleveland’s east side. July 2018. (Photo Credit: Margeaux Apple)

SPECIES CONSIDERATIONS
Conduct a thorough inspection of the planting site prior to selecting a
tree. Consider the following:
HARDINESS
Can it withstand the temperature extremes in NE Ohio? Where
was it grown?
FORM
What is the expected shape of the canopy?
FUNCTION
What is it being planted to do? Provide screening, shade, beauty,
attract pollinators or something else.
MESSINESS
Will it frequently shed bark or produce copious amounts of seed?
Sweetgum’s (Liquidambar styraciflua) spiky seed capsules are
considered a nuisance to many property owners.
American elm (Ulmus americana) trees have vase-shaped
canopies and require considerable space to expand.
SIZE AT MATURITY (BOTH HEIGHT AND CROWN SPREAD)
How tall and wide will the crown be? How fast does it grow?
SENSITIVITIES AND WEAKNESSES
Is it weak wooded and likely to break in a storm? Is it resistant to pests
& disease threats?
Ash (Fraxinus sp.) trees were once a revered selection for
urban areas, especially along streets, until Emerald Ash Borer
arrived. Knowledge of existing and potential pest and disease
threats will result in resilient selections.

CHOOSING A TREE AT THE
NURSERY: WHAT TO LOOK FOR
GENERAL APPEARANCE
• The tree should have a balanced shape.
• Make sure there are no bare spots in the foliage, missing or
damaged limbs, spotted or discolored leaves.
• The tree should have a single “central leader” (main stem).
• Check the size of the crown and root ball in relation to the
caliper of the tree - should not be top heavy.
CROWN
• Seek trees with branches which come off the trunk at between
45° and 90° angles. The closer the angle is to 90°, the stronger
the branch will be.
• Wounds from pruning should be callused over or well on their
way.
• Branches should be distributed evenly with 6-8” between them
on the main trunk.
• Branches should not be longer than 1/4 the height of the tree.
Too long limbs place undue burden on the tree.
TRUNK
• The trunk should be straight.
• Look for insect damage such as borer holes.
• The trunk should be free of discolored, swollen, or sunken
areas.
• No wound should be larger than 1/4 of the trunk’s
circumference.
BAILED AND BURLAPPED (B&B) TREES
• Trees should be dug during or close to dormant season.
• The trunk should not move independently of the root ball.
• The burlap should be tightly wrapped.
• The trunk should be in the center of the root ball.
• Select trees with some indication of a trunk flare at the top of
the ball. This indicates you are getting a larger portion of the
root system than you would with one in which the trunk flare is
buried in
the ball.
CONTAINERIZED TREES
• Pot bound roots are in danger of “girdling” – encircling the pot
and cutting off the vascular system. This can continue even
after planting.
• Avoid trees that have large roots coming out of the container’s
water holes or roots circling on the soil surface.
BARE ROOT TREES
• When available, bare root is a good choice. Properly dug, they
will retain more roots than similar sized B&B trees. Bare-root
trees will adapt to their site more quickly.
• Care must be taken to ensure that the roots do not dry out.
• Bare-root trees must be planted before leafing-out.
A native green ash (Fraxinus pennsylvanica [Foothills])
in decline due to borer damage. June 2020
(Photo cred: Margeaux Apple)
Root-bound Tree. The circling roots of this tree indicate it was in
the container too long.

Rounded
Ball or circular shaped crown.
Vase
Inverted triangular shaped crown; widest at the top and tapering
towards the bottom of the crown.
Weeping
Spreading crown with branches that cascade downward.
TREE MATRIX CATEGORY DEFINITIONS
SIZE CLASSIFICATIONS
Trees are grouped by size which indicates the expected mature
height from the ground to top of the crown under
ideal conditions.
Small- A tree that can attain a height of less than 25’ at maturity.
Only small trees should be planted under
power lines.
Medium- A tree that can attain a height between 25 and 50 feet
at maturity.
Large- A tree that can attain a height over 50 feet at maturity.
EVERGREEN
Trees are considered evergreen if they have foliage that persists
throughout the year. Trees not indicated as evergreen are deciduous
and will drop their leaves during the fall or dormant season.
GENERAL FORM AT MATURITY
This refers to the expected characteristic shape of the tree’s crown
(branches and leafy area) at maturity. It provides a mental picture of the
ultimate form of the tree. A tree’s overall form may vary due to age and
site selection. The tree’s mature form provides guidance for how well it
will fit into the space available, helps forecast problems that might occur
and provides insight into how well the tree will meet the goals for the
above-ground space
Forms include:
Columnar
Cylindrical shaped and/or narrow crown. Their shape makes them
useful where space is limited.
Irregular
Crown is not uniform
Oval
Egg-shaped or elliptical; wider along the horizontal axis and narrower
at the top and bottom of the crown.
Pyramidal
Christmas tree or triangular shaped; widest at the base and more nar-
rowly pointed toward the upper crown.
Spreading
Horizontally extending crown.
MATURE SPREAD
Mature spread refers to the expected width of its canopy, measured
from edge to edge, at maturity.
GROWTH RATE
The growth rate refers to the expected increase in vertical growth
of the tree. Growth rates vary for different species and can be
influenced by numerous factors including light, exposure, root
volume, soil fertility, tree care, etc. In the matrix tree growth rates
are categorized as Slow, Medium or Fast.  
Slow- grows 12” or less per year
Medium- 13 to 24” of growth per year
Fast- grows 25” or greater per year
Landscape features such as soil compaction, moisture, texture,
shade and salt can influence how well a tree will grow and prosper.
It is important to match these features with the needs of a tree
before selecting.
A NOTE ABOUT MAPLE TREES
A very few select maples are listed in the species matrix and
noted with an asterisk(*). Maples (Acer genus) are over-
represented in Cleveland’s urban forest and should planted
sparingly; only after consideration is given to other species.
The City’s Urban Forester requests no maples be planted in
the city’s right-of-way.
The broadly pyramidal mature habit of a silver linden cultivar
(Tilia tomentosa [Sterling]) (Photo Credit: CBlashka)
Nordmann fir (Abies nordmanniana)
(Photo cred: Margeaux Apple)

TOLERANCES
SOIL COMPACTION
Soil compaction reduces pore space in the soil and can limit water,
oxygen and nutrients to the tree roots. Trees in this category are known
to perform well in areas of high traffic where soil is compacted.  
DROUGHT
Soil compaction reduces pore space in the soil and can limit water,
oxygen and nutrients to the tree roots. Trees in this category are known
to perform well in areas of high traffic where soil is compacted.
CLAY SOILS
Clay soils tend to have poor drainage and are dense and compact.
Trees in this category have shown to perform well in heavy soils such
as clay.
WET/SATURATED SOILS
Trees in this category can withstand prolonged periods of saturated
soils. A wet tolerant tree selection may need to be considered when a
site will have excessive moisture present.
AIR POLLUTION
Polluted air can contribute to decline in trees causing short term (acute)
damage or longer term (chronic) damage. Ozone, sulfur dioxide and
other particulates can damage tissues and inhibit leaf function. Trees in
this category are generally not negatively affected by
airborne pollutants.
SHADE
Most trees require full sun, although some will tolerate the lower
light levels of partial shade and a few will tolerate full shade.
SALT
Careful consideration should be given to trees that are to be planted
along roads, in parking lots or other or areas where they are subject
to de-icing salts. Salt damages trees in two ways: salt in the soil and
salt in the air. Soil salt can pull water out of the tree and salt spray can
damage evergreen foliage, buds and stem tissue. Data on species
tolerance to salt varies and doesn’t always differentiate between salt
spray and soil salt. This section is referencing only the tree’s known
tolerance to salt.
Full sun
Partial shade
Full shade
Require more than 6 hours of direct sunlight
a day.
Tolerate direct sun for less than 6 hours a day,
or filtered light for most of the day.
Tolerate little or no direct sunlight, or less than 6
hours of filtered sunlight a day.
SITE SELECTION
Site selections include location recommendations for the tree based on its
size, characteristics, tolerances and limitations.
BENEATH POWERLINES
Trees in this category are suitable for planting underneath overhead
powerlines. They achieve mature heights under 25 feet and will not
require pruning by utility companies.
STREET
Trees in this category are suitable to plant in areas with restricted growth
space. This can be along streets in the
tree-lawn, or grassed strip between street and sidewalk, a median
area or parking lot island. If the area falls within the city’s right-of-way,
a permit for planting is required and can be obtained by contacting
Cleveland’s Urban Forestry Department at jkipp@city.cleveland.oh.us or
calling 216-664-2388.
NOTE: Evergreen trees are not recommended for planting in tree-lawn
spaces or medians due to their low branching habit and foliage that can
obstruct visibility. We would not plant them due to their growth habit &
need for additional maintenance for visibility purposes.
OPEN AREAS
Trees in this category require more root space and are recommended for
planting in unrestricted lawns, vacant lots or open areas such as parks.
WETLAND, RIPARIAN, BIORETENTION
Trees help mitigate flooding and reduce pollutants that flow into storm
sewers and streams through reducing runoff, improving soil infiltration
and decreasing erosion. Trees in this category are suited for wet sites
such as rain gardens, wetlands, riparian areas and/or bioretention
planters.
This Japanese Tree Lilac
(Syringa reticulata) is
considered a small stature tree
and good choice under power
lines. (Photo Credit: CBlashka)
Elm tree (Ulmus) planted in an
adequately sized tree-lawn.
A 65 year old red oak (Quercus rubra) in bloom: 58’ tall x 71’ wide. A
good specimen for an open area. (Photo Credit: Margeaux Apple)

VALUE
This section includes trees that are beneficial to pollinators such as
bees, moths, birds, beetles and other wildlife. It also includes trees that
provide sheer enjoyment to people in the form of showy flowers, unique
bark, displays of fruit/fall color or provide an interesting backdrop to the
winter landscape.
POLLINATOR FRIENDLY
Many trees have flowers that provide nutrient-rich pollen and nectar and
are a critical source of forage for many pollinators such as bees, birds,
beetles, moths and butterflies. Trees in this category are known to
support pollinators.
ORNAMENTAL VALUE
Trees in this category display the following noteworthy
aesthetic attributes:
Flower
Although all angiosperm trees flower, some are more conspicuous
than others. Trees in this category are often selected for their showy
flowers which are in bloom for one to three weeks in spring to early
summer. In rarer instances some trees bloom in fall.
Fruit
Trees in this category have unique fruit of interest
Fall Foliage
Trees in noted in this category display strong autumn foliage in yel-
low, orange, red, and/or purple. Leaf color can create
interesting views.
Winter Interest
Trees in this category display interesting foliage, form, structure
or fruit through the dormant season.
Bark
Trees in this category display unique bark that can be used as
an identification feature and described as exfoliating, mottled or
striped to name a few.
NATIVE TO EASTERN US
Trees in this category are native to states east of the Mississippi, but
not including small portions of Louisiana and Minnesota. According to
The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Natural Resources
Conservation Service, only plants found in the United States before
European settlement are considered to be native.  
ADDITIONAL NOTES
This section expands on a unique feature or adaptability trait worth
mentioning, such as the tree’s resistance to disease
or edibility.
Redbud (Cercis canadensis) flowers
decorate leafless branches in spring.
The flowers are edible too.
Photo Credit: CBlashka
Fall foliage on a black gum (Nyssa sylvatica)
Fall foliage on a ginkgo (Gingko biloba).
(Phot0 Cred: Margeaux Apple)
Redbud (Cercis canadensis) flowers decorate
leafless branches in spring. The flowers are
edible too. (Photo credit: CBlashka)
Horizontally peeling bark on river birch (Betula nigra
[Heritage]) May 2020 (Photo Cred: Margeaux Apple)

Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Wet/
Sat.
Soils
Clay
Soils
Small Trees
35' and under
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Acer buergerianum*
Aesculus pavia
Asimina triloba
Cercis canadensis
Chionanthus retusus
Juniperus chinensis
’Keteleeri’
Magnolia ’Golden Gift’
Magnolia stellata
Magnolia virginiana
Magnolia x loebneri
Malus ’Bob White’
Malus ‘’Prairifire’
Malus [Red Jewel]
Malus [Sugar Tyme]
Quercus prinoides
25’
20’
20’
25’
20’
15’’
20’
15’
20’
15’
20’
20’
15’
15’
10’
slow
moderate
moderate
moderate
slow
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
slow
Salt
trident maple
red buckeye
pawpaw
eastern redbud
Chinese fringetree
upright Chinese
juniper
magnolia
star magnolia
sweet bay magnolia
Loebner magnolia
flowering crabapple
flowering crabapple
flowering crabapple
flowering crabapple
dwarf
chinquapin oak
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Legend
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Beneath
Powerlines
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
edible fruit
edible fruit
SITE SELECTION
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Weeping
Small Trees
35' and under
TOLERANCES
Scientific Name
VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS

Syringa pekinensis
‘’Great Wall’
Syringa reticulata
’Ivory Silk’
Tilia cordata
[Summer Sprite]
Zelkova serrata
[City Sprite]
15’
20’
15’
20’
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
Chinese tree lilac
Japanese tree lilac
littleleaf linden
Japanese zelkova
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Small Trees
35' and under
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Common Name
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Wet/
Sat.
Soils

paperbark maple
Miyabei maple
three-flower maple
Ohio buckeye
apple serviceberry
upright European
hornbeam
American hornbeam
hackberry
hybrid hackberry
American
yellowwood
flowering dogwood
Asian flowering
dogwood
green hawthorn
Carolina silverbell
eastern redcedar
Acer griseum*
Acer miyabei*
Acer triflorum*
Aesculus glabra
Amelanchier x
grandiflora
Carpinus betulus
[Emerald Avenue]
Carpinus caroliniana
Celtis laevigata
Celtis ‘’Magnifica’
Cladrastis kentukea
Cornus florida
‘’Appalachian Spring’
Cornus kousa
Crataegus viridis
’Winter King’
Halesia tetraptera
Juniperus virginiana
’Canaertii’
20’
25’
30’
40’
30’
30’
30’
50’
40’
40’
20’
30’
25’
30’
20’
slow
slow
slow
moderate
moderate
moderate
slow
moderate
fast
moderate
slow
slow
slow
moderate
moderate
edible fruit
resistant to dogwood anthracnose
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Medium Trees
35' - 50'
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Wet/
Sat.
Soils
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS

Liriodendron tulipifera
’Little Volunteer’
Maackia amurensis
Maclura pomifera
‘’Whiteshield’
Magnolia ‘’Butterflies’
Magnolia ‘’Coral Lake’
Magnolia ’Daybreak’
Magnolia ’Elizabeth’
Magnolia ’Yellow Bird’
Magnolia tripetala
Parrotia persica
’Vanessa’
Pinus virginiana
Quercus x warei
[Kindred Spirit]
15’
20’
35’
20’
20’
20’
20’
20’
20’
15’
30’
10’
25’
moderate
slow
fast
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
slow
slow
fast
tuliptree
Amur maackia
Osage-orange
yellow-flowered
magnolia
magnolia
magnolia
magnolia
magnolia
umbrella magnolia
Persian parrotia
Virginia pine
hybrid white oak
white elm
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Medium Trees
35' - 50'
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Wet/
Sat.
Soils
Ulmus davidiana
[Emerald Sunshine]

Abies nordmanniana
Acer x freemanii
[Autumn Blaze]*
Acer rubrum
Aesculus flava
Betula nigra [Heritage]
Betula nigra
[City Slicker]
30’
40’
40’
50’
50’
50’
50’
35’
40’
40’
40’
35’
20’
35’
34’
slow
fast
moderate
moderate
fast
fast
slow
moderate
slow
fast
fast
fast
fast
slow
slow
many cultivars available
resistant to bronze birch borer
resistant to bronze birch borer
edible fruit
male clones preferred
Nordmann fir
Freeman maple
red maple
yellow buckeye
river birch
river birch
cedar of Lebanon
common
persimmon
gingko
honeylocust
honeylocust
honeylocust
honeylocust
Kentucky
coffee-tree
Kentucky
coffee-tree
Cedrus libani
var. stenocoma
Diospyros virginana
Ginkgo biloba
Gleditsia triacanthos
[Imperial]
[Shademaster]
[Skyline]
[Street Keeper]
Gymnocladus dioica
‘Espresso’
Gymnocladus dioica
[Prairie Titan]
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Large Trees
50' and over
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)

Kentucky
coffee-tree
katsura tree
sweetgum
variegated
sweetgum
tuliptree
tuliptree
cucumber
magnolia
dawn redwood
tupelo
hop hornbeam
Serbian spruce
Oriental spruce
eastern white pine
pitch pine
pitch-lob pine
40’
30’
40’
35’
40’
25’
40’
25’
30’
30’
20’
20’
40’
40’
40’
slow
moderate
fast
moderate
fast
fast
moderate
fast
moderate
slow
slow
slow
fast
moderate
fast
variegated leaf form
wildlife forage
deciduous conifer
high nutrient mammal &
bird forage
Wetlands
Gymnocladus dioica
‘Stately Manor’
Cercidiphyllum
japonicum
Liquidambar styraciflua
‘Moraine’
Liquidambar sytraciflua
‘Variegata’
[Emerald City]
Magnolia acuminata
Metasequoia
glyptostroboides
Nyssa sylvatica
Ostrya virginiana
Picea omorika
Picea orientalis
Pinus strobus
Pinus rigida
Pinus rigida x taeda
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Large Trees
50' and over
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Wet/
Sat.
Soils
shallow-rooted; needs
cool soil temps

London planetree
sycamore
swamp white oak
shingle oak
overcup oak
bur oak
chinkapin oak
pin oak
pin oak
willow oak
hybrid oak
red oak
Shumard oak
Japanese
pagodatree
bald cypress
40’
50’
50’
60’
40’
70’
40’
40’
15’
40’
20’
60’
50’
40’
25’
fast
fast
moderate
slow
slow
slow
moderate
fast
fast
fast
slow
fast
moderate
fast
moderate
high wildlife value
deciduous conifer
Platanus x acerifolia
[Exclamation!]
Platanus occidentalis
Quercus bicolor
Quercus imbricaria
Quercus lyrata
Quercus macrocarpa
Quercus muehlenbergii
Quercus palustris
Quercus palustris
[Green Pillar]
Quercus phellos
Quercus x warei
[Regal Prince]
Quercus rubra
Quercus shumardii
Styphnolobium
japonicum [Regent]
Taxodium distichum
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Large Trees
50' and over
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Wet/
Sat.
Soils
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS
cold hardy selection

arborvitae
western redcedar
giant arborvitae
basswood
littleleaf linden
silver linden
Crimean linden
American elm
American elm
elm
elm
Japanese zelkova
Japanese zelkova
Japanese zelkova
Thuja occidentalis
Thuja plicata
Thuja ‘Green Giant’
Tilia americana
Tilia cordata
[Green Spire]
Tilia tomentosa
Tilia x euchlora
Ulmus americana
‘Princeton’
Ulmus americana
‘Jefferson’
Ulmus ‘Regal’
Ulmus [Triumph]
Zelkova serrata
[Green Vase]
Zelkova serrata
’Musashino’
Zelkova serrata
[Village Green]
15’
25’
20’
40’
30’
40’
25’
50’
50’
25’
45’
30’
15’
40’
slow
moderate
fast
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
moderate
fast
fast
moderate
moderate
moderate
fragrant flowers
Dutch Elm Disease
(DED) resistance
Dutch Elm Disease
(DED) resistance
Dutch Elm Disease
(DED) resistance
Dutch Elm Disease
(DED) resistance
fragrant flowers
Light Conditions
Ornamental
Applicable
Full Sun
Partial Shade
Shade
Form
Oval
Round
Columnar
Pyramidal
Vase
Spreading
Irregular
Fruit
Fall Color
Flower
Bark
Winter Interest
Weeping
Common Name
Evergreen
Form
Spread
Growth Rate
Compacted
Soil
Drought
Clay
Soils
Native
to
eastern
N.
America
Salt
Scientific Name
Air
Pollution
Beneath
Powerlines
Polllinator
Friendly
Notes
Ornamental
Wetlands
Shade
Treelawn
or
Median
Large Trees
50' and over
SITE SELECTION
TOLERANCES VALUE
CHARACTERISTICS
Open
spaces
(parks/
lawns)
Wet/
Sat.
Soils

TOP TEN TREE CARE TIPS TO HELP YOUR
NEWLY PLANTED TREE THRIVE
#1 PLANT DURING THE RIGHT TIME OF YEAR.
Spring (late March through early-June) and fall (late October to mid-December)
are the best times for planting new trees in NEOH. Plant when the tree is
dormant - either before the tree breaks bud in the spring or just after it loses
leaves in the fall. Another good rule is to plant at least four to six weeks before
either the extreme conditions of winter or summer are expected to arrive.
#2 BREAK UP AND LOOSEN ENCIRCLING ROOTS PRIOR TO PLANTING.
Containerized trees often have roots that encircle the trunk. Roots should be
gently massaged or teased to loosen them from the soil. Pruning matted roots
with bypass pruners or vertically shaving the outside root ball with a saw may be
required to loosen the roots.
#3 DIG A SHALLOW AND WIDE (ELLIPTICAL-SHAPED) PLANTING HOLE.
Tree roots are shallow, typically found in the first foot of soil, and need oxygen as
they grow. It’s important to not plant them too deeply. Digging a saucer-shaped
hole, 2 to 3 times the width of the tree’s root ball, will allow the roots to expand
freely into surrounding soil.
#4 KEEP ROOT FLARE ABOVE GROUND.
The root flare is the fluted area at the base of the trunk where support roots
emerge. It keeps the tree stable, provides oxygen to the root system and should
always be exposed.
#5 REMOVE EXCESS SOIL FROM THE ROOT FLARE.
Excess soil or other materials around a root f lare or trunk should be removed
either by hand or with a pneumatic air tool. An air tool uses high-pressure air to
blow away soil from the roots or trunk without inflicting any damage. Removing
soil or materials by hand requires great care as roots and trunks are easily
damaged by the slip of a shovel.
#6 MULCH WIDE, LOW AND AWAY FROM THE TRUNK.
Mulch 2-4 inches deep and as wide as the canopy of the tree with natural mulch
such as decomposing wood chips. Keep the mulch at least a fist’s-width away from
touching the trunk.
Proper mulching:
•Reduces mechanical damage to the bark from lawn mowers and string trimmer
• Keeps the root system moist
•Reduces root competition from weeds and grasses
•Insulates the soil and keeps it from becoming too dry or cold
•Provides nutrients and conditions the soil as it breaks down
#7 USE NATURAL HARDWOOD MULCH.
Wood chip mulch breaks down over time and slowly add nutrients to the soil.
Natural mulch also loosens compacted soil, adds organic matter and keeps
moisture levels up.
#8 CONTINUE TO WATER YOUR NEWLY PLANTED TREE DURING THE GROWING
SEASON UNTIL IT’S ESTABLISHED.
Newly planted trees expend a lot of energy getting their roots to grow into the
surrounding soil and require frequent watering during the hot, dry months. Tree
roots drying out from lack of water is one of the main causes of new planting
failures
Apply water:
•frequently – a few times a week unless there is frequent rain
•slowly – to ensure it doesn’t run off the mulch
•deeply – enough saturation to ensure water gets into the root system
Applying 15 gallons of water, 2-3x/week at the root system during the dry, summer
months for the first 3 years after planting should do the trick!
#3 Dig a shallow and wide (elliptical-shaped) planting hole.
#4 Keep root flare above ground.
#6 Mulch wide, low and away from the trunk.
#8 Continue to water your newly planted tree during the
growing season until it’s established.

REFERENCES
Bassuk, Nina. Recommended Urban Trees: Site Assessment and Tree Selection for Stress Tolerance. Cornell Urban Horticulture Institute.
2009. http://www.hort.cornell.edu/uhi/outreach/recurbtree/pdfs/~recurbtrees.pdf
Calpoly Urban Forest Ecosystem Institute. SelecTree: A Tree Selection Guide. https://selectree.calpoly.edu/
Dirr, Michael. Manual of Woody Landscape Plants: Their Identification, Ornamental Characteristics, Culture, Propagation and Uses. 6th ed.
Champagne: Stipes Publishing L.L.C. 2009. Print.
Dirr, Michael. Selection of Trees for Tolerance to Salt Injury. Journal of Arboriculture. 1976. 209-216.
OSU Extension. Ash Replacements for Urban and Woodland Plantings. 2005. Print.
Yang, et.al. Ranking the suitability of common urban tree species for controlling PM2.5 pollution. Atmospheric Pollution Research. 2015.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S130910421530235X
ODNR Division of Wildlife. Trees of Ohio Field Guide. Publication 5509. 2019.
Center for Urban Forest Research, Pacific Southwest Research Station, USDA Forest Service, Davis, California and the Southern Center for
Urban Forestry Research & Information, Southern Research Station, USDA Forest Service. The Large Tree Argument: The Case for Large-
Stature Trees vs. Small Stature Trees. Athens, Georgia. 2004  
https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/content/dam/pubs_ext_vt_edu/430/430-022/430-022_pdf.pdf
Tree plantings should follow tree care industry standards, such as ANSI A300 (Part 6) Planting and Transplanting and ANSI Z60.1 American
Standard for Nursery Stock https://www.americanhort.org/page/standards?&hhsearchterms=%22nursery+and+stock+and+standards%22
#9 PROTECT THE TRUNK OF YOUNG, THINBARKED TREES SUCH AS
MAPLE FROM DEER AND OTHER CRITTERS.
Properly pruning a young tree every few years is essential for
developing a tree with a strong structure and desirable form. Trees that
receive the appropriate pruning measures while they are young will
require less corrective pruning as they mature.
#10 TRAIN YOUR YOUNG TREE TO BECOME HEALTHY AND STRONG
THROUGH STRUCTURAL PRUNING.
Properly pruning a young tree every few years is essential for
developing a tree with a strong structure and desirable form. Trees that
receive the appropriate pruning measures while they are young will
require less corrective pruning as they mature.
#10 Train your young tree to become healthy and strong
through structural pruning.

Cleveland Tree Plan Tree Selection Guide

More Related Content

Similar to Cleveland Tree Plan Tree Selection Guide (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Cleveland Tree Plan Tree Selection Guide