SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Top-­‐down 
and 
bo+om-­‐up 
curriculum 
maturing 
processes 
Kai 
Pata 
kpata@tlu.ee 
Tallinn 
University, 
Center 
for 
Educa?onal 
Technology
An 
expert: 
Crea?vity 
and 
freedom 
Tradi?onally 
top-­‐to 
down 
processes 
prevail 
in 
curriculum 
development: 
mapping 
to 
the 
standards, 
evalua?on 
based 
on 
fixed 
standards 
Courses 
can 
bring 
in 
evolving 
knowledge 
and 
competences 
and 
mature 
the 
curriculum 
and 
standards 
in 
bo+om-­‐up 
manner 
Evalua?on 
against 
the 
standard 
-­‐ 
an 
approved 
collec?ve 
knowledge
Mapping 
the 
curriculum 
to 
the 
standards 
Educa?onal 
technology 
curriculum 
– 
the 
competences 
ISTE 
NETS 
competences 
Standards 
maturing 
Curriculum 
development 
and 
evalua?on 
h+p://intelleo.eu/ 
see 
demonstrator 
3 
Issues: 
curriculum 
competences 
should 
incorporate 
new 
course 
competences, 
the 
standard 
should 
evolve 
based 
on 
bo+om-­‐up 
contribu?ons
Mapping 
the 
courses 
to 
the 
standard/ 
curriculum 
Matching 
learning 
outcomes 
from 
standard 
to 
the 
courses 
h+p://htk.tlu.ee/EpoAbi/ 
Mapping 
the 
competences/learning 
outcomes 
at 
courses 
Standard 
/ 
curriculum 
Course 
competence 
descrip?ons 
competences 
Are 
contextualized 
to 
domain 
context 
Issues: 
-­‐ 
ill-­‐formulated 
competences/learning 
outcomes 
cannot 
be 
objec?vely 
measured 
-­‐ 
standard 
is 
unevenly 
covered
Mapping 
ac?vi?es 
and 
assessment 
to 
competences/ 
learning 
outcomes 
Mapping 
competences/learning 
outcomes 
with 
learning 
ac4vi4es 
and 
assessment 
h+p://htk.tlu.ee/EpoAbi/ 
Competence/Learning 
outcome 
descrip?on 
Assessment 
types 
Learning 
ac?vity/assignment 
types 
Get 
advice 
from 
different 
formula?ons 
at 
the 
curriculum 
-­‐ 
standard 
competences 
-­‐ 
assessment 
types 
-­‐ 
learning 
ac?vity 
types 
Issues: 
-­‐ 
Mapping 
competences/learning 
with 
fiSng 
assignments 
and 
assessment 
-­‐ 
overlaps 
between 
learning 
ac?vi?es/ 
assignments 
at 
courses 
-­‐ 
Collec?ng 
academic 
analy?cs 
Shared 
vocabulary 
across 
the 
curriculum 
Academic 
analy4cs 
based 
on 
competences, 
ac4vity 
and 
assessment 
types
Academic-­‐ 
and 
learning 
analy?cs 
for 
evalua?on 
• In 
porTolio-­‐based 
eDidak?kum 
we 
can 
map 
course 
elements 
with 
competence 
standard 
(competence 
ontology) 
and 
domain 
ontology: 
– the 
learning 
ac?vi?es/assignments 
– the 
learning 
resources 
with 
competence 
standard 
– Academic 
analy4cs 
for 
courses 
can 
be 
used 
for 
forma4ve/ 
summa4ve 
evalua4on 
of 
the 
curriculum 
• The 
learner 
who 
takes 
the 
assignment 
will 
map 
the 
planned/graded 
competences 
to 
his 
eporTolio 
– Learning 
analy4cs 
for 
competence 
development 
at 
the 
course, 
forma4ve 
evalua4on 
of 
the 
course 
– Learning 
analy4cs 
of 
personal 
development 
h+p://edidak?kum.ee/
Curriculum 
maturing 
processes 
STANDARD 
COMPETENCES 
EVOLVING 
DOMAIN 
KNOWLEDGE 
& 
COMPETENCES 
??? 
KNOWLEDGE 
AND 
COMPETENCES 
STUDENT 
PORTFOLIOS 
PERSONAL 
LEARNING 
CONTRACTS 
DOMAIN 
ONTOLOGIES 
COMPETENCE 
/ 
LEARNING 
OUTCOMES 
ONTOLOGIES 
CURRICULUM 
LEARNING 
OUTCOMES 
STUDENTS’ 
EXPECTED 
LEARNING 
OUTCOMES
Seman?c 
curriculum 
management 
goals 
• Managing 
curriculum 
and 
course 
development 
(to 
address 
coherence 
within 
the 
curriculum 
courses, 
to 
maintain 
traceability 
of 
curriculum 
linkages 
with 
resources 
for 
planning 
and 
upda?ng 
it, 
to 
address 
coherence 
within 
the 
course 
competences, 
ac?vi?es 
and 
resources, 
to 
manage 
and 
update 
case-­‐based 
ac?vi?es 
and 
resources 
dynamically 
across 
the 
curriculum); 
• Managing 
curriculum 
and 
standard 
evolu4on 
(using 
standards 
such 
as 
competence 
models, 
domain 
ontologies 
and 
similar 
curricula 
as 
reference 
ontologies 
for 
modeling 
the 
curriculum 
and 
evolving 
the 
standards); 
• Managing 
internal 
and 
external 
evalua4on 
of 
curricula 
based 
on 
academic 
analy?cs 
and 
geSng 
overviews; 
• Managing 
shared 
vocabulary 
development, 
collabora4on 
and 
“ownership 
taking” 
in 
curriculum 
development; 
• Managing 
student-­‐centered 
approach 
to 
learning 
with 
personal 
porDolios 
in 
the 
curriculum 
development 
(to 
use 
the 
curriculum 
as 
the 
“underground 
map” 
for 
planning 
learning 
for 
competences, 
finding 
learning 
resources 
for 
personalized 
learning 
experiences, 
proposing 
learner’s 
expected 
learning 
outcomes, 
ac?vi?es 
and 
resources 
to 
the 
courses 
and 
the 
curriculum).
Curriculum 
maturing 
concepts

More Related Content

PDF
Diploma Supplements – Responsibilities, Processes, Practice at FAU
PDF
General principles of Diploma Supplement
PDF
IT Instructional Quality
PDF
WP3.1 Journey of FAU
PDF
3.2 Implementation of DS: Wrapping Up Our Experiences and Approaches
PPT
PPTX
Grounding of the UN CPD Scheme in the UKPSF
PPT
Roger Williams University: Using Sakai to meet accreditation standards
Diploma Supplements – Responsibilities, Processes, Practice at FAU
General principles of Diploma Supplement
IT Instructional Quality
WP3.1 Journey of FAU
3.2 Implementation of DS: Wrapping Up Our Experiences and Approaches
Grounding of the UN CPD Scheme in the UKPSF
Roger Williams University: Using Sakai to meet accreditation standards

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Lehman Assessment and ePortfolio for 5.6.11
PDF
TU Delft Brightspace Matrix as Instructor Tool
PPT
Christopher Costigan - Partnering With Employers
PPTX
He survival+ cpd scheme
PPT
1.Three Cycle System Eqf
PPTX
Taaccct On! Presentation
PPT
Realising Opportunities eMentoring
PPTX
Sticking Points: Tips for Advancing the PLA Conversation presentation at the ...
PPTX
12 Promising Non-traditional College Pathways
PPTX
Programme Design @ NU
PPTX
New to teaching_in_he_part2_he_quals_programmes_modules_nov16
PPTX
Online Teaching and Learning during and after the Pandemic
PDF
WP3.1 Review of Cyprus Workshop
PDF
Project: European Maturity Model for Blended Education
PPTX
ePortfolio: Challenge or Opportunity
PPTX
Swansea HEA presentation July 2015
PPT
Selecting And Training Students For The External Review Panels
PPT
DPS Academic Plan: "Meeting the Challenge"
PPTX
Annual Program Monitoring @ NU
PPT
The Irish experience of developing and implementing a national qualifications...
Lehman Assessment and ePortfolio for 5.6.11
TU Delft Brightspace Matrix as Instructor Tool
Christopher Costigan - Partnering With Employers
He survival+ cpd scheme
1.Three Cycle System Eqf
Taaccct On! Presentation
Realising Opportunities eMentoring
Sticking Points: Tips for Advancing the PLA Conversation presentation at the ...
12 Promising Non-traditional College Pathways
Programme Design @ NU
New to teaching_in_he_part2_he_quals_programmes_modules_nov16
Online Teaching and Learning during and after the Pandemic
WP3.1 Review of Cyprus Workshop
Project: European Maturity Model for Blended Education
ePortfolio: Challenge or Opportunity
Swansea HEA presentation July 2015
Selecting And Training Students For The External Review Panels
DPS Academic Plan: "Meeting the Challenge"
Annual Program Monitoring @ NU
The Irish experience of developing and implementing a national qualifications...
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
Loeng4
PDF
email and angel
PPTX
Creating Great Slides - After
PPTX
Using Computer Games To Unlock Learning
PPSX
Tutor blogs 101
KEY
SSM / Dog's Dot - grupa 2
PPT
Brighton And Hove 2. Getting The Basics Right Pt2
PDF
Macisms
PDF
Macromedia Dreamweaver
PPT
Globalgiving
PPT
fotitos
PPT
Tc fake money
 
PPT
wahoom 2.0 : soon to a computer near you
PDF
Scanaroo Overview
PPTX
Integrating figshare into our RDM workflow: University of Salford
PPT
Geocaching November09
PDF
Tabata exercises - Beginner
PPS
Chiste garganta
PPT
Delivering Web To Mobile
PPT
m1 garand
Loeng4
email and angel
Creating Great Slides - After
Using Computer Games To Unlock Learning
Tutor blogs 101
SSM / Dog's Dot - grupa 2
Brighton And Hove 2. Getting The Basics Right Pt2
Macisms
Macromedia Dreamweaver
Globalgiving
fotitos
Tc fake money
 
wahoom 2.0 : soon to a computer near you
Scanaroo Overview
Integrating figshare into our RDM workflow: University of Salford
Geocaching November09
Tabata exercises - Beginner
Chiste garganta
Delivering Web To Mobile
m1 garand
Ad

Similar to Curriculum maturing processes (20)

PPT
London 2009 Curriculum Mapping
PPTX
PPT (Unpacking Curriculum Standard and Competencies) Jeferson Espiritu.pptx
PPT
Web-based curriculum mapping and personalised learning
PPTX
CompetencyWorks Aug 23 Webinar Slides
PDF
Ped 104 curriculum improvement final (1)
PDF
Curriculum Mapping (Development of Curriculum Materials in Industrial Educati...
PDF
Principles of curriculum construction pdf
PPT
Specific Approaches To Curriculum Development
PPT
C mand c21
PPTX
Curriculum Development by Jamshah
PDF
Re-culture, Re-structure: Setting the Stage for a Successful Curriculum Mappi...
PPT
Whole School Planning For Student Learning
PDF
Curriculum development – towards 21st century skills
PDF
Curriculum and instruction 21st c skills
PPSX
EKI PROIEKTUA - English
PPTX
Various Stages of Curriculum Development .pptx
PPTX
Curriculum implementation
PPTX
Selection of content for social science curriculum-DRAFT_.pptx
PPTX
The Impact of a Curriculum Leader
PPTX
Coherent curriculum programs
London 2009 Curriculum Mapping
PPT (Unpacking Curriculum Standard and Competencies) Jeferson Espiritu.pptx
Web-based curriculum mapping and personalised learning
CompetencyWorks Aug 23 Webinar Slides
Ped 104 curriculum improvement final (1)
Curriculum Mapping (Development of Curriculum Materials in Industrial Educati...
Principles of curriculum construction pdf
Specific Approaches To Curriculum Development
C mand c21
Curriculum Development by Jamshah
Re-culture, Re-structure: Setting the Stage for a Successful Curriculum Mappi...
Whole School Planning For Student Learning
Curriculum development – towards 21st century skills
Curriculum and instruction 21st c skills
EKI PROIEKTUA - English
Various Stages of Curriculum Development .pptx
Curriculum implementation
Selection of content for social science curriculum-DRAFT_.pptx
The Impact of a Curriculum Leader
Coherent curriculum programs

More from Kai Pata (20)

PDF
Symposium on Qualifications, Training, Micro-Credentials and Sustainable Deve...
PDF
Kestlikkuse võimekuse praktikad hariduses.pdf
PDF
Karjäärispetsialistide uuringust ettevõtete vaates.pdf
PDF
Cultural resilience in digital heritage ecosystems
PDF
Kogukonna kestlikkuse saavutamise viisidest
PDF
Kaasavate õpitehnoloogiatega õpetamise valmidus kõrghariduses.pdf
PDF
Learning from Citizen Science though several educational institutions.pptx.pdf
PDF
The guide of best practices on open knowledge activities.pptx.pdf
PDF
Transformations of scaffolding concept in socio-technical systems.pdf
PDF
Responsive education for sustainable development: LIFE course case
PDF
Social media services ecosystem for marginalized youth to access adult educat...
PDF
DesignIT kasutamine kõrghariduse disainimõtlemise praktikas
PDF
DesignIT multiplier
PPTX
Citizen science in education
PPTX
Smartness of the learning ecosystem
PDF
Achso opetamispraktikad
PDF
Policyworkshop edu map_active citizenship
PDF
International perspectives: ICT in education
PDF
Projektikeskkonnad
PDF
Workshop distributed cognition
Symposium on Qualifications, Training, Micro-Credentials and Sustainable Deve...
Kestlikkuse võimekuse praktikad hariduses.pdf
Karjäärispetsialistide uuringust ettevõtete vaates.pdf
Cultural resilience in digital heritage ecosystems
Kogukonna kestlikkuse saavutamise viisidest
Kaasavate õpitehnoloogiatega õpetamise valmidus kõrghariduses.pdf
Learning from Citizen Science though several educational institutions.pptx.pdf
The guide of best practices on open knowledge activities.pptx.pdf
Transformations of scaffolding concept in socio-technical systems.pdf
Responsive education for sustainable development: LIFE course case
Social media services ecosystem for marginalized youth to access adult educat...
DesignIT kasutamine kõrghariduse disainimõtlemise praktikas
DesignIT multiplier
Citizen science in education
Smartness of the learning ecosystem
Achso opetamispraktikad
Policyworkshop edu map_active citizenship
International perspectives: ICT in education
Projektikeskkonnad
Workshop distributed cognition

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
UNIT III MENTAL HEALTH NURSING ASSESSMENT
PPTX
Final Presentation General Medicine 03-08-2024.pptx
PDF
Black Hat USA 2025 - Micro ICS Summit - ICS/OT Threat Landscape
PDF
A GUIDE TO GENETICS FOR UNDERGRADUATE MEDICAL STUDENTS
PDF
Chinmaya Tiranga quiz Grand Finale.pdf
PDF
LNK 2025 (2).pdf MWEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHE
DOC
Soft-furnishing-By-Architect-A.F.M.Mohiuddin-Akhand.doc
PDF
medical_surgical_nursing_10th_edition_ignatavicius_TEST_BANK_pdf.pdf
PDF
A systematic review of self-coping strategies used by university students to ...
PPTX
Introduction to Building Materials
PPTX
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
PPTX
A powerpoint presentation on the Revised K-10 Science Shaping Paper
PPTX
Unit 4 Skeletal System.ppt.pptxopresentatiom
PDF
RMMM.pdf make it easy to upload and study
PDF
Complications of Minimal Access Surgery at WLH
PPTX
Radiologic_Anatomy_of_the_Brachial_plexus [final].pptx
PPTX
1st Inaugural Professorial Lecture held on 19th February 2020 (Governance and...
PDF
OBE - B.A.(HON'S) IN INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE -Ar.MOHIUDDIN.pdf
PPTX
Onco Emergencies - Spinal cord compression Superior vena cava syndrome Febr...
PPTX
CHAPTER IV. MAN AND BIOSPHERE AND ITS TOTALITY.pptx
UNIT III MENTAL HEALTH NURSING ASSESSMENT
Final Presentation General Medicine 03-08-2024.pptx
Black Hat USA 2025 - Micro ICS Summit - ICS/OT Threat Landscape
A GUIDE TO GENETICS FOR UNDERGRADUATE MEDICAL STUDENTS
Chinmaya Tiranga quiz Grand Finale.pdf
LNK 2025 (2).pdf MWEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHE
Soft-furnishing-By-Architect-A.F.M.Mohiuddin-Akhand.doc
medical_surgical_nursing_10th_edition_ignatavicius_TEST_BANK_pdf.pdf
A systematic review of self-coping strategies used by university students to ...
Introduction to Building Materials
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
A powerpoint presentation on the Revised K-10 Science Shaping Paper
Unit 4 Skeletal System.ppt.pptxopresentatiom
RMMM.pdf make it easy to upload and study
Complications of Minimal Access Surgery at WLH
Radiologic_Anatomy_of_the_Brachial_plexus [final].pptx
1st Inaugural Professorial Lecture held on 19th February 2020 (Governance and...
OBE - B.A.(HON'S) IN INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE -Ar.MOHIUDDIN.pdf
Onco Emergencies - Spinal cord compression Superior vena cava syndrome Febr...
CHAPTER IV. MAN AND BIOSPHERE AND ITS TOTALITY.pptx

Curriculum maturing processes

  • 1. Top-­‐down and bo+om-­‐up curriculum maturing processes Kai Pata kpata@tlu.ee Tallinn University, Center for Educa?onal Technology
  • 2. An expert: Crea?vity and freedom Tradi?onally top-­‐to down processes prevail in curriculum development: mapping to the standards, evalua?on based on fixed standards Courses can bring in evolving knowledge and competences and mature the curriculum and standards in bo+om-­‐up manner Evalua?on against the standard -­‐ an approved collec?ve knowledge
  • 3. Mapping the curriculum to the standards Educa?onal technology curriculum – the competences ISTE NETS competences Standards maturing Curriculum development and evalua?on h+p://intelleo.eu/ see demonstrator 3 Issues: curriculum competences should incorporate new course competences, the standard should evolve based on bo+om-­‐up contribu?ons
  • 4. Mapping the courses to the standard/ curriculum Matching learning outcomes from standard to the courses h+p://htk.tlu.ee/EpoAbi/ Mapping the competences/learning outcomes at courses Standard / curriculum Course competence descrip?ons competences Are contextualized to domain context Issues: -­‐ ill-­‐formulated competences/learning outcomes cannot be objec?vely measured -­‐ standard is unevenly covered
  • 5. Mapping ac?vi?es and assessment to competences/ learning outcomes Mapping competences/learning outcomes with learning ac4vi4es and assessment h+p://htk.tlu.ee/EpoAbi/ Competence/Learning outcome descrip?on Assessment types Learning ac?vity/assignment types Get advice from different formula?ons at the curriculum -­‐ standard competences -­‐ assessment types -­‐ learning ac?vity types Issues: -­‐ Mapping competences/learning with fiSng assignments and assessment -­‐ overlaps between learning ac?vi?es/ assignments at courses -­‐ Collec?ng academic analy?cs Shared vocabulary across the curriculum Academic analy4cs based on competences, ac4vity and assessment types
  • 6. Academic-­‐ and learning analy?cs for evalua?on • In porTolio-­‐based eDidak?kum we can map course elements with competence standard (competence ontology) and domain ontology: – the learning ac?vi?es/assignments – the learning resources with competence standard – Academic analy4cs for courses can be used for forma4ve/ summa4ve evalua4on of the curriculum • The learner who takes the assignment will map the planned/graded competences to his eporTolio – Learning analy4cs for competence development at the course, forma4ve evalua4on of the course – Learning analy4cs of personal development h+p://edidak?kum.ee/
  • 7. Curriculum maturing processes STANDARD COMPETENCES EVOLVING DOMAIN KNOWLEDGE & COMPETENCES ??? KNOWLEDGE AND COMPETENCES STUDENT PORTFOLIOS PERSONAL LEARNING CONTRACTS DOMAIN ONTOLOGIES COMPETENCE / LEARNING OUTCOMES ONTOLOGIES CURRICULUM LEARNING OUTCOMES STUDENTS’ EXPECTED LEARNING OUTCOMES
  • 8. Seman?c curriculum management goals • Managing curriculum and course development (to address coherence within the curriculum courses, to maintain traceability of curriculum linkages with resources for planning and upda?ng it, to address coherence within the course competences, ac?vi?es and resources, to manage and update case-­‐based ac?vi?es and resources dynamically across the curriculum); • Managing curriculum and standard evolu4on (using standards such as competence models, domain ontologies and similar curricula as reference ontologies for modeling the curriculum and evolving the standards); • Managing internal and external evalua4on of curricula based on academic analy?cs and geSng overviews; • Managing shared vocabulary development, collabora4on and “ownership taking” in curriculum development; • Managing student-­‐centered approach to learning with personal porDolios in the curriculum development (to use the curriculum as the “underground map” for planning learning for competences, finding learning resources for personalized learning experiences, proposing learner’s expected learning outcomes, ac?vi?es and resources to the courses and the curriculum).