SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Embedding NomLex-BR nominalizations into
OpenWordnet-PT
Livy Maria Real Coelho1 Alexandre Rademaker2,5
Valeria de Paiva3 Gerard de Melo4
UFP
IBM Research
Nuance Comms.
Tsinghua University
FGV/EMAp

February 1, 2014
The English NomLex
NomLex (cont.)

a dictionary of English
nominalizations, under
Catherine Macleod.
relate the nominal complements
to the arguments of the
corresponding verb.
1025 entries of several types of
lexical nominalizations.
Alexander’s destruction of the
city happened in 330 BC.

first version on January 15,
1999, latest version October
2001 downloadable from
http://bit.ly/1aZWQmh
Nomlex (cont.)

( nom : o r t h ” p r o m o t i o n ”
: v e r b ” promote ”
: nom−type ( ( verb−nom ) )
: v e r b − s u b j ( ( n−n−mod) ( d e t − p o s s ) )
: v e r b − s u b c ( ( nom−np : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) ( n−n−mod ) ( pp−of ) ) )
( nom−np−as−np : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) ( pp−of ) ) )
( nom−possing : nom−subc ( ( p − p o s s i n g : p v a l ( ” o f ” ) ) ) )
( nom−np−pp : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) (n−n−mod) ( pp−of ) )
: p v a l ( ” i n t o ” ” from ” ” f o r ” ” t o ” ) )
( nom−np−pp−pp : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) (n−n−mod) ( pp−of ) )
: p v a l ( ” f o r ” ” i n t o ” ” t o ” ) : p v a l 2 ( ” from ” ) ) ) )
Related Works
Nominalizations have been studied for more than 4 decades
(Chomsky, 1970).
NomLex-Plus (Meyers et al., 2004). Extension of NomLex with 7.050
nominalizations.
The NomBank Project (Meyer, 2007) http://bit.ly/1d5G7L9.
“ mark the sets of arguments that co-occur with nouns in the
PropBank Corpus, just as PropBank records such information for
verbs... firmly on the shoulders of NOMLEX...”
Berkeley FrameNet (https://framenet.icsi.berkeley.edu/).
11600 lexical units based on frame semantics supported by corpus
evidence. Deverbal nominalizations are annotated as events (in the
frame of verbs) or entities/results (diff. semantic frame).
FrameNet-Brazil, http://www.ufjf.br/framenetbr/.
Using for NLP (IE)

To write maps bettween IE patterns for active clauses to IE patterns
for nominalizations.
Active clause: “IBM appointed Alice Smith as vice president”.
Passive clause: “IBM’s appointment of Alice Smith as vice president”
and “Alice Smith’s appointment as vice president”.
Main use for NLP (IE) (cont.)
The Proteus Extraction System starts with:
np(C-company) vg(appoint) np(C-person) "as" np(C-position)
Meta rules to produce passive clause pattern:
np(C-person) vg-pass(appoint) "as" np(C-position) "by"
np(C-company)
When a pattern matches the input, the pieces corresponding to its
constituents are used to build a semantic representation of the patter (e.g.
logical form).
vg = verb group (plus auxiliares). vg-pass = passive verb group.
Project Motivation: DHBB

7.5K entries Brazilian Historical
Biographic Dictionary (DHBB).
Enrich the structure (semantics).
Uniform data treatment (standards and
interlinks between collections).
NLP of DHBB entries: (1) word sense
disambiguation with openWordnet-PT;
and (2) named entity recognition to
make links. (133K proper names)
We need grammars, lexical resources, ontologies, KBs, automated theorem
provers etc to reason about knowledge extracted from text. This will
empower QA, KE, MT, personal assistents and other systems.
Nominalizations in Portuguese

Nominalizations: difficult to deal with in KR systems, harder to
obtain the arguments of nominal predicate;
NOMLEX project (Macleod et al., 1998) provides a well-established,
open access baseline;
nominalizations with the suffixes -¸˜o/-ion, -mento/-ment and
ca
-or/-er, which work well in Portuguese;
E.g. constru¸˜o (construction), adiamento (adjournment) and
ca
escritor (writer );
90% of the original resource easily manually translated.
How we expanded it

We translate both noun/verb by looking up in extractions from the EN
and PT Wiktionary dumps, generating all combination of noun/verb
translations. Filter to compare the noun and verb translations to see if
they are similar enough to be morphologically related.
Other experiments with DHBB and openWordnet-PT.
NomLex-BR
a dictionary of Portuguese nominalizations
Relate nominals to corresponding verbs
Over 2,539 entries of several types of lexical nominalizations
first version of NOMLEX-BR in 2011, much expanded 2013
Freely available for download and embeded in openWordnet-PT.
A RDF vocabulary to describe nominalizations. Future extensions to
cover more information from COMLEX and COMNOM (extension
from NomBank).
URI for the schema,
http://arademaker.github.com/nomlex/schema/! Need a better
and stable URI.
“Constru¸˜o da rodovia Transamazˆnica, na d´cada de 70, pelo governo
ca
o
e
Medici, uma das obras faraˆnicas da ditadura militar.”
o
Embedding in openWordnet-PT

But nomlex:noun and nomlex:verb should point to wn30:WordSense
not wn30:Word! Future work!
By Provenance
See http://bit.ly/Mohmni
select ?prov (count(?x) as ?total) {
?x a nomlex:Nominalization ;
dc:provenance ?prov .
}
group by ?prov
provenance
nomlex
wiktionary-pt
wiktionary-en
framenet
nomage
dhbb
openWordnet-PT
linguateca

total
1032
61
91
142
262
159
82
484
By suffix

See:
http://bit.ly/LmAXn4; and
http://bit.ly/1fKEnKr.
Result:
suffix
mento
¸˜o
ca
or

total
329
660
891

Some other cases http://bit.ly/1fyia3a.
Results
Extension of OpenWN-PT aims at incorporating links to connect
deverbal nouns with their corresponding verbs.
The integration into OpenWN-PT will facilitate their use for linguistic
research as well as information extraction
Incorporating NOMLEX-BR data into OpenWN-PT has shown itself
useful in pinpointing some issues with the coherence and richness of
OpenWN-PT.
the word abasement corresponds in NOMLEX to the verb abase,
and thus we would like a similar correspondence between the
Portuguese noun “aviltamento” and the verb “aviltar” (suggested
translations). OpenWN-PT simply has two synsets “humilhar,
abaixar” and “humilhar, rebaixar”. The more common verb humilhar
is repeated, while the uncommon aviltar was left out.
Next Steps

Finish to embed Nomlex-BR into OpenWN-PT (anchor floating
words, http://bit.ly/1aQdpkr).
Work with Claudia Freitas and Hugo Gon¸alvez on leveraging
c
Linguatecas PAPEL, Cart˜o, ACDC and Floresta Sint´(c)tica.
a
a
Lists from Linguateca’s resources complement NomLex-BR using
corpora and make sure our resource is not simply a translation.
Adding the Portuguese terms that satisfy different relations?
OpenVerbNet-PT? Glosses? Classification of nominalizations?
We are developing our own web interface for browsing and
collaborative editing. Most important pending issue!
Use and test the accuracy of the resource! More applications!
Conclusion
We presented NomLex-BR, an lexicon
of nominalizations in Brazilian
Portuguese.
NomLex-BR is embedded into
OpenWordNet-PT and shares its RDF
representation.
Recent improvements include better
coverage: newer suffixes and Nomage
incorporation.
The work with Nomlex-BR helped us to
improve openWordnet-PT (new words,
senses).
The data is freely available from
http://github.com/arademaker/wordnet-br/ and a SPARQL
Endpoint at http://logics.emap.fgv.br:10035.
Obrigado!
Multilingual Wordnet 1.0

1/26/14, 8:21 AM

Synset 01146493-a
Danish
English
Finnish
French
Galician
Indonesian
Italian

taknemmelig
thankful, grateful
kiitollinen
reconnaissant
grato, agradecido
bersyukur, berterima kasih, tanda terima kasih, terhutang budi
grato, riconoscente

Japanese

忝い, 有り難い, 感謝を感じた, 幸甚, ありがたい, 有難い, 感謝を表した

Bokmål
takknemlig
Portuguese reconhecido, grato, agradecido
Thai
ซึ่งสำนึกในบุญคุณ
bersyukur, berterima kasih, tanda terima kasih, menampakkan tanda kesyukuran,
Malaysian
memperlihatkan tanda kesyukuran, terhutang budi
Eng: feeling or showing gratitude; "a grateful heart"; "grateful for the tree's shade"; "a thankful
smile";
Similar to: appreciative glad

More Related Content

PDF
Session6 04.giuseppe celano
PDF
Verifying Integrity Constraints of a RDF-based WordNet
PDF
It’s a WIN, WIN: ‘WordPress On Windows’
PDF
Is it important to explain a theorem? A case study in UML and ALCQI
PDF
On the Computational Complexity of Intuitionistic Hybrid Modal Logic
PDF
OpenWordnet-PT: A Project Report
PDF
A linked open data architecture for contemporary historical archives
PDF
An overview of Portuguese WordNets
Session6 04.giuseppe celano
Verifying Integrity Constraints of a RDF-based WordNet
It’s a WIN, WIN: ‘WordPress On Windows’
Is it important to explain a theorem? A case study in UML and ALCQI
On the Computational Complexity of Intuitionistic Hybrid Modal Logic
OpenWordnet-PT: A Project Report
A linked open data architecture for contemporary historical archives
An overview of Portuguese WordNets

Similar to Embedding NomLex-BR nominalizations into OpenWordnet-PT (15)

PDF
Embedding Nomlex-BR into OpenWN-PT
PDF
Lexical Resources for Portuguese
PDF
Logics and Ontologies for Portuguese Understanding
PDF
OWN-PT: Taking Stock
PDF
Seeing is Correcting:Linked Open Data for Portuguese
PPT
ijcnlp04.....................................................
PDF
OpenLogos Semantico-Syntactic Knowledge-Rich Bilingual Dictionaries
PPTX
NLP_KASHK:Text Normalization
PDF
Towards the Detection and Formal Representation of Semantic Shifts in Inflect...
PDF
Experiments on the construction and enrichment of a Portuguese wordnet
PPTX
Nominalisation (v2)
PPTX
Word Tagging with Foundational Ontology Classes
PDF
An Extensible Multilingual Open Source Lemmatizer
PDF
Portuguese Linguistic Tools: What, Why and How
PPTX
Categorizing and pos tagging with nltk python
Embedding Nomlex-BR into OpenWN-PT
Lexical Resources for Portuguese
Logics and Ontologies for Portuguese Understanding
OWN-PT: Taking Stock
Seeing is Correcting:Linked Open Data for Portuguese
ijcnlp04.....................................................
OpenLogos Semantico-Syntactic Knowledge-Rich Bilingual Dictionaries
NLP_KASHK:Text Normalization
Towards the Detection and Formal Representation of Semantic Shifts in Inflect...
Experiments on the construction and enrichment of a Portuguese wordnet
Nominalisation (v2)
Word Tagging with Foundational Ontology Classes
An Extensible Multilingual Open Source Lemmatizer
Portuguese Linguistic Tools: What, Why and How
Categorizing and pos tagging with nltk python
Ad

More from Alexandre Rademaker (6)

PDF
Processamento de Linguagem Natural em textos da História Comptemporânea do Br...
PDF
On the proof theory for Description Logics
PDF
OpenWN-PT: a Brazilian Wordnet for all
PDF
A database approach to monitoring the quality of information in RDF stores
PDF
Intuitionistic Description Logic for Legal Reasoning
PDF
First Order Logic
Processamento de Linguagem Natural em textos da História Comptemporânea do Br...
On the proof theory for Description Logics
OpenWN-PT: a Brazilian Wordnet for all
A database approach to monitoring the quality of information in RDF stores
Intuitionistic Description Logic for Legal Reasoning
First Order Logic
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Group 1 Presentation -Planning and Decision Making .pptx
PPTX
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
PDF
TokAI - TikTok AI Agent : The First AI Application That Analyzes 10,000+ Vira...
PDF
Accuracy of neural networks in brain wave diagnosis of schizophrenia
PPTX
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
PDF
MIND Revenue Release Quarter 2 2025 Press Release
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PDF
Approach and Philosophy of On baking technology
PPTX
SOPHOS-XG Firewall Administrator PPT.pptx
PDF
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
PDF
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
PDF
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
PDF
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
PDF
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
PDF
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
PDF
A comparative analysis of optical character recognition models for extracting...
PDF
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
PPTX
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
PDF
Encapsulation_ Review paper, used for researhc scholars
PPTX
1. Introduction to Computer Programming.pptx
Group 1 Presentation -Planning and Decision Making .pptx
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
TokAI - TikTok AI Agent : The First AI Application That Analyzes 10,000+ Vira...
Accuracy of neural networks in brain wave diagnosis of schizophrenia
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
MIND Revenue Release Quarter 2 2025 Press Release
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
Approach and Philosophy of On baking technology
SOPHOS-XG Firewall Administrator PPT.pptx
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
A comparative analysis of optical character recognition models for extracting...
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
Encapsulation_ Review paper, used for researhc scholars
1. Introduction to Computer Programming.pptx

Embedding NomLex-BR nominalizations into OpenWordnet-PT

  • 1. Embedding NomLex-BR nominalizations into OpenWordnet-PT Livy Maria Real Coelho1 Alexandre Rademaker2,5 Valeria de Paiva3 Gerard de Melo4 UFP IBM Research Nuance Comms. Tsinghua University FGV/EMAp February 1, 2014
  • 3. NomLex (cont.) a dictionary of English nominalizations, under Catherine Macleod. relate the nominal complements to the arguments of the corresponding verb. 1025 entries of several types of lexical nominalizations. Alexander’s destruction of the city happened in 330 BC. first version on January 15, 1999, latest version October 2001 downloadable from http://bit.ly/1aZWQmh
  • 4. Nomlex (cont.) ( nom : o r t h ” p r o m o t i o n ” : v e r b ” promote ” : nom−type ( ( verb−nom ) ) : v e r b − s u b j ( ( n−n−mod) ( d e t − p o s s ) ) : v e r b − s u b c ( ( nom−np : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) ( n−n−mod ) ( pp−of ) ) ) ( nom−np−as−np : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) ( pp−of ) ) ) ( nom−possing : nom−subc ( ( p − p o s s i n g : p v a l ( ” o f ” ) ) ) ) ( nom−np−pp : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) (n−n−mod) ( pp−of ) ) : p v a l ( ” i n t o ” ” from ” ” f o r ” ” t o ” ) ) ( nom−np−pp−pp : o b j e c t ( ( d e t − p o s s ) (n−n−mod) ( pp−of ) ) : p v a l ( ” f o r ” ” i n t o ” ” t o ” ) : p v a l 2 ( ” from ” ) ) ) )
  • 5. Related Works Nominalizations have been studied for more than 4 decades (Chomsky, 1970). NomLex-Plus (Meyers et al., 2004). Extension of NomLex with 7.050 nominalizations. The NomBank Project (Meyer, 2007) http://bit.ly/1d5G7L9. “ mark the sets of arguments that co-occur with nouns in the PropBank Corpus, just as PropBank records such information for verbs... firmly on the shoulders of NOMLEX...” Berkeley FrameNet (https://framenet.icsi.berkeley.edu/). 11600 lexical units based on frame semantics supported by corpus evidence. Deverbal nominalizations are annotated as events (in the frame of verbs) or entities/results (diff. semantic frame). FrameNet-Brazil, http://www.ufjf.br/framenetbr/.
  • 6. Using for NLP (IE) To write maps bettween IE patterns for active clauses to IE patterns for nominalizations. Active clause: “IBM appointed Alice Smith as vice president”. Passive clause: “IBM’s appointment of Alice Smith as vice president” and “Alice Smith’s appointment as vice president”.
  • 7. Main use for NLP (IE) (cont.) The Proteus Extraction System starts with: np(C-company) vg(appoint) np(C-person) "as" np(C-position) Meta rules to produce passive clause pattern: np(C-person) vg-pass(appoint) "as" np(C-position) "by" np(C-company) When a pattern matches the input, the pieces corresponding to its constituents are used to build a semantic representation of the patter (e.g. logical form). vg = verb group (plus auxiliares). vg-pass = passive verb group.
  • 8. Project Motivation: DHBB 7.5K entries Brazilian Historical Biographic Dictionary (DHBB). Enrich the structure (semantics). Uniform data treatment (standards and interlinks between collections). NLP of DHBB entries: (1) word sense disambiguation with openWordnet-PT; and (2) named entity recognition to make links. (133K proper names) We need grammars, lexical resources, ontologies, KBs, automated theorem provers etc to reason about knowledge extracted from text. This will empower QA, KE, MT, personal assistents and other systems.
  • 9. Nominalizations in Portuguese Nominalizations: difficult to deal with in KR systems, harder to obtain the arguments of nominal predicate; NOMLEX project (Macleod et al., 1998) provides a well-established, open access baseline; nominalizations with the suffixes -¸˜o/-ion, -mento/-ment and ca -or/-er, which work well in Portuguese; E.g. constru¸˜o (construction), adiamento (adjournment) and ca escritor (writer ); 90% of the original resource easily manually translated.
  • 10. How we expanded it We translate both noun/verb by looking up in extractions from the EN and PT Wiktionary dumps, generating all combination of noun/verb translations. Filter to compare the noun and verb translations to see if they are similar enough to be morphologically related. Other experiments with DHBB and openWordnet-PT.
  • 11. NomLex-BR a dictionary of Portuguese nominalizations Relate nominals to corresponding verbs Over 2,539 entries of several types of lexical nominalizations first version of NOMLEX-BR in 2011, much expanded 2013 Freely available for download and embeded in openWordnet-PT. A RDF vocabulary to describe nominalizations. Future extensions to cover more information from COMLEX and COMNOM (extension from NomBank). URI for the schema, http://arademaker.github.com/nomlex/schema/! Need a better and stable URI. “Constru¸˜o da rodovia Transamazˆnica, na d´cada de 70, pelo governo ca o e Medici, uma das obras faraˆnicas da ditadura militar.” o
  • 12. Embedding in openWordnet-PT But nomlex:noun and nomlex:verb should point to wn30:WordSense not wn30:Word! Future work!
  • 13. By Provenance See http://bit.ly/Mohmni select ?prov (count(?x) as ?total) { ?x a nomlex:Nominalization ; dc:provenance ?prov . } group by ?prov provenance nomlex wiktionary-pt wiktionary-en framenet nomage dhbb openWordnet-PT linguateca total 1032 61 91 142 262 159 82 484
  • 15. Results Extension of OpenWN-PT aims at incorporating links to connect deverbal nouns with their corresponding verbs. The integration into OpenWN-PT will facilitate their use for linguistic research as well as information extraction Incorporating NOMLEX-BR data into OpenWN-PT has shown itself useful in pinpointing some issues with the coherence and richness of OpenWN-PT. the word abasement corresponds in NOMLEX to the verb abase, and thus we would like a similar correspondence between the Portuguese noun “aviltamento” and the verb “aviltar” (suggested translations). OpenWN-PT simply has two synsets “humilhar, abaixar” and “humilhar, rebaixar”. The more common verb humilhar is repeated, while the uncommon aviltar was left out.
  • 16. Next Steps Finish to embed Nomlex-BR into OpenWN-PT (anchor floating words, http://bit.ly/1aQdpkr). Work with Claudia Freitas and Hugo Gon¸alvez on leveraging c Linguatecas PAPEL, Cart˜o, ACDC and Floresta Sint´(c)tica. a a Lists from Linguateca’s resources complement NomLex-BR using corpora and make sure our resource is not simply a translation. Adding the Portuguese terms that satisfy different relations? OpenVerbNet-PT? Glosses? Classification of nominalizations? We are developing our own web interface for browsing and collaborative editing. Most important pending issue! Use and test the accuracy of the resource! More applications!
  • 17. Conclusion We presented NomLex-BR, an lexicon of nominalizations in Brazilian Portuguese. NomLex-BR is embedded into OpenWordNet-PT and shares its RDF representation. Recent improvements include better coverage: newer suffixes and Nomage incorporation. The work with Nomlex-BR helped us to improve openWordnet-PT (new words, senses). The data is freely available from http://github.com/arademaker/wordnet-br/ and a SPARQL Endpoint at http://logics.emap.fgv.br:10035.
  • 18. Obrigado! Multilingual Wordnet 1.0 1/26/14, 8:21 AM Synset 01146493-a Danish English Finnish French Galician Indonesian Italian taknemmelig thankful, grateful kiitollinen reconnaissant grato, agradecido bersyukur, berterima kasih, tanda terima kasih, terhutang budi grato, riconoscente Japanese 忝い, 有り難い, 感謝を感じた, 幸甚, ありがたい, 有難い, 感謝を表した Bokmål takknemlig Portuguese reconhecido, grato, agradecido Thai ซึ่งสำนึกในบุญคุณ bersyukur, berterima kasih, tanda terima kasih, menampakkan tanda kesyukuran, Malaysian memperlihatkan tanda kesyukuran, terhutang budi Eng: feeling or showing gratitude; "a grateful heart"; "grateful for the tree's shade"; "a thankful smile"; Similar to: appreciative glad