Feedback for Supervisors

Giving & Receiving Feedback for Supervisors
Kevin R.Thomas, Manager,Training & Development · Office of Human Resources · kevin.r.thomas@williams.edu · 413-597-3542
May 23, 2017
krt4@williams.edu
413-597-3542
Training & Development Manager
Human Resources
Kevin R. Thomas
Supervisory Training Series 2
Feedback for Supervisors

• Name
• Where you work
• How long you’ve been supervising
• How long you’ve been supervising at Williams
Introductions

• Confidentiality
• Participation
• Listening
• Judgement free zone
Ground Rules
Program Overview

• Who here likes giving
feedback?
• What makes giving
feedback difficult?
You Write the Slide

• Who looks forward to
giving positive feedback?
• Did you think of positive
feedback?
• Why not?
What about … ?

• Imagine your boss comes by your desk and
says:
“Can you come into my office?
• How do you feel?
• When you come into the office, your boss
closes the door and says:
“I need to give you some feedback.”
• Now how do you feel?
The Threat Response
Provide Constructive Feedback

• Social Needs Are Primary
• Brain is Wired to Notice
Threats to:
o Status
o Certainty
o Autonomy
o Relatedness
o Fairness
Managing the Threat Response
Provide Constructive Feedback

Dimension Threat Reward
Status Unfavorable
comparisons
Being less than
“Let me give you some
feedback.”
High status
“Good Job”
Certainty Ambiguity
Change
Familiarity
Predictability
Knowing what to do
Knowing what is going
on
Autonomy Micromanagement Choice
Latitude
Relatedness Loneliness, Rejection
Other is a “foe”
Inclusion, Team Building
Other is a friend
Fairness Sneakiness
Favoritism
Equity, even dealing
Mission of fairness
SCARF

• When the threat response is
triggered:
o Fight
o Flight
o Freeze
• When triggered, we can’t
learn or plan.
Threats Lead to Amygdala Hijack

• How do we train ourselves
to notice positive
behaviors and give positive
feedback?
• How do we give
constructive feedback
while minimizing the threat
response?
Central Questions

1. Formula
2. Exercise
Positive Feedback

Positive Feedback Formula
Giving Feedback
Behavior Impact
Best
chance for
repeated
behavior

• Complete the worksheet
• Share with your partner.
Your Turn

• Actually give the positive
feedback you just
discussed
• Set a goal for how many
times per week you’ll give
positive feedback.
• Add it to your to do list like
anything else.
Post-class Challenge

1. Investigate / Prepare
2. Opening the conversation
– Exercise
3. Joint investigation
4. Joint action planning
5. Follow through
Constructive Feedback

• What data is relevant
o Records and reports
o Interviews with colleagues and other stakeholders (e.g.
attendance records)
• Are you sure:
o Expectations have been clearly stated?
o They know how to do it?
o There aren’t obstacles beyond their control?
o It’s a reasonable expectation give their other
responsibilities?
Investigate / Prepare

Constructive Feedback Opening
Giving Feedback
Behavior
Impac
t
1. Use behavior + impact to describe
what you are seeing
2. Ask if they have additional information
you should know. Listen.

Labeling the Person vs. Describing Behavior
Giving and Receiving
Feedback
Principles
Labeling the
Person
Describe the Behavior
Bad Attitude • Uses sarcasm
• Crosses arms, frowns, avoids eye contact
• Makes comments that undermine morale
Lazy • Delays or ignores certain tasks
• Disappears and cannot be found
• Arrives at work tardy, returns late from breaks.
• Takes longer than needed to complete tasks
• Performance suffers without frequent direction
and oversight
• Ignores obvious problems
• Leaves work for the next shift

• Behavior: I’ve noticed you’ve been over 10 minutes
late 3 times in the last two weeks.
• Impact: When you’re not here when we open, others
have to greet visitors and answer the phone, which
takes them away from the work they’re supposed to
be doing, and often they don’t know how to direct
people properly, which can lead to more confusion for
everyone.
• Inquiry: What’s going on? Is there anything I should
know about this?
Example: Tardy Receptionist

• Complete the worksheet
(5 minutes)
• Share with your partner.
(10 minutes each)
Your Turn

• Jointly investigate causes
o e.g. Why reports haven’t
been submitted on time
• Jointly develop an action
plan
o Specific, Measurable, Time
Bound
o Check for level of
commitment
• Offer Support
o Demonstrate your
commitment to their success
• Follow through
o Track progress
o Show appreciation for
Next Steps

Questions?

krt4@Williams.edu
413-597-3542
Supervisory Training Series
Feedback for Supervisors
• More takes on feedback in upcoming courses:
Performance Development, Resolving performance
problems
• Program evaluation link and course page coming via
email
• Check in with your partner about how it’s going!

Feedback for Supervisors

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to Feedback for Supervisors (20)

More from eph-hr (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Feedback for Supervisors