SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Finding Media
         Illustrating Events

Xueliang Liu <xueliang.liu@eurecom.fr>
Raphaël Troncy <raphael.troncy@eurecom.fr>
Benoit Huet <benoit.huet@eurecom.fr>
What are Events?

 Events are observable occurrences grouping



                      People                       Places Time

                 Experiences documented by Media




  19/04/2011 -         Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   -2
http://www.flickr.com/photos/crsan/3697785107
Searching for an event




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   -4
Searching for media about an event




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   -5
There’s a lot of information out there…




   19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   -6
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mwparenteau/432039783
       19/04/2011 -                                  7
Organize the mess



                                                Event
                                                Media




 Scrape event directories
 Link the information
 Find media illustrating events
 Design the application Interface
                 Linking Open Data cloud diagram, by Richard Cyganiak and Anja Jentzsch. http://lod-cloud.net/


  19/04/2011 -    Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   -8
Róisín Murphy at Nouveau Casino




                                                                                E0-001-005971169-9



                                             350591




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy        -9
Representing Events with




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 10
Interlinking
 Linking Agents with
    Freebase, Dbpedia, MusicBrainz

 Linking Venues with
    Geonames, Dbpedia, Foursquare (via Uberblic)

 Linking Events with
    Last.fm, Upcoming, Eventful

 Linking Categories with
    Facebook, Eventful, Upcoming, Zevents, LinkedIn,Eventbrite,
     TicketMaster

 Linking Users with
    Social Graph API


    19/04/2011 -     Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 11
Róisín Murphy at Nouveau Casino




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 12
Media explicitly associated with the event




                  APIs
                          Machine tags
                         “lastfm:events”
                                                          4790 photos, 263                   1.7 million images over
                                                       videos over 110 events                    108.000 events

   19/04/2011 -               Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 13
Representing Media with Media Ontology




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 14
How much data is there?

                       Event              Agent                       Location                Photos         User
Last.fm                 57,258                 50,150                          16,471         1,425,318       18,542
Upcoming                13,114                               0                    7,330        347,959         4,518
Eventful                37,647                    6,543                        14,576                    0          0
Total                  108,019                 56,693                          38,377         1,773,277       23,060


                         1,248,021 geo-tagged photos
                   by propagating information from events!




        19/04/2011 -           Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy       - 15
How fast media are uploaded?




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 16
Finding more media that illustrate an event

A. Compute the bounding box area of a venue
B. Retrieve all media geo-tagged in this area
C. Retrieve all media with a similar title
D. Prune the results with visual analysis
E. Extend the result set with all media from the
   same uploader




    19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 17
A. Bounding box of Nouveau Casino?




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 18
B. 74 photos taken in this area this day




   19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 19
C. 85 additional photos with a similar title




   19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 20
D. 6 photos after visual pruning


                                                                                            
                                                               
                                                                                           

  
    19/04/2011 -
                                                                          
                       Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 21
                                                                                             
How is the visual pruning performed?

 Model dataset: photo id + photo geo
 Testing dataset: similar title
 Low-level features used:
   Color moments, Gabor texture, Edge histogram

 L1 distance on the K-nearest neighbors
 Threshold
   Min L1 distance between two model image pairs
   Conservative approach



    19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 22
E. 66 photos after uploader heuristics

                                                                                                
                               hellerpop

                                                                       DustGraph / Stefan
   cartoixa




                             13 photos                                                   46 photos
              19/04/2011 -       Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 23
Same process for videos

1 video (id)
3 videos (geo)
                                                                                          
26 videos (title)




                       Visual pruning
                       performed on
                       key frames
                                                                                   
                      Nb positive > 50%


     19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 24
How illustrated are the events?

                      Query By ID Query By Geo Query By Title Visual Pruning Heuristic

  Photos                  5            74 (74)                            85 (85)               6 (6)    66 (66)
  Videos                  1               3 (0)                             23 (0)              13 (0)      -
   (title)
  Videos                                                                  10 (10)
(title+venue)
    20 events
    Model dataset: 785 photos
    Testing dataset: 1766 photos (1573 positive, 193 negative)
    Results: 439 photos (99% precision, 28% recall)


       19/04/2011 -              Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy    - 25
User Interface




  19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 26
Conclusions

 Method for finding media illustrating scheduled
  events
   Search media with machine and geo tags
   Search media with title and normal tags
   Prune visually and retrieve all media from confirmed users
   Challenge: do not necessarily trust the geo-coordinates

 Event-based approach for users to explore,
  annotate and share media
   UX can help semantics, semantics can help UX
   Outstanding challenges in interlinking and curating the data
   Detecting events from social media activity
    19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 27
http://www.slideshare.net/troncy

19/04/2011 -   Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy   - 28

More Related Content

PDF
Experiencing Events through User-Generated Media
PDF
Designing User Support for Event-based Annotation and Exploration of Media
PPTX
MediaEval 2011 SED Opening
PPTX
Social Sharing In a Web of Things
PDF
PPTX
Tourism and the Web of Things
PDF
tech tools for global collaboration 4 good
PPTX
Community-based Crowdsourcing
Experiencing Events through User-Generated Media
Designing User Support for Event-based Annotation and Exploration of Media
MediaEval 2011 SED Opening
Social Sharing In a Web of Things
Tourism and the Web of Things
tech tools for global collaboration 4 good
Community-based Crowdsourcing

Viewers also liked (20)

PPT
Challenges for the Language Technology Industry
PPT
Multilingual challenges in Europeana
PPTX
NISO Annual Report of 2012 Activities
PPT
Europeana and the relevance of the DM2E results
PPT
Interlinking Multimedia: How to Apply Linked Data Principles to Multimedia F...
PPT
Networked books and networked reading
PPT
Data modelling at Europeana and DM2E - SMW13
PDF
Implementing the Media Fragments URI Specification
PPT
Europeana DSI - LT-Accelerate 14
PPT
Wikidata, a target for Europeana's semantic strategy - GLAM-WIKI 2015
PDF
NISO's Standards Update & Annual Membership Meeting
PPT
Europeana and RDF data validation
PPT
ALA2009_Andy Weissberg (Bowker)
PPT
Multilingual challenges for accessing digitized culture online - Riga Summit 15
PDF
Progress Report on Government Linked Data Worldwide
PPT
AAC Education Session
PPTX
NASIG 2014: Actions and Updates on the Standards and Best Practices Front
PDF
Carpenter Library Assessment Conference Presentation
PPTX
Challenges for the Language Technology Industry
Multilingual challenges in Europeana
NISO Annual Report of 2012 Activities
Europeana and the relevance of the DM2E results
Interlinking Multimedia: How to Apply Linked Data Principles to Multimedia F...
Networked books and networked reading
Data modelling at Europeana and DM2E - SMW13
Implementing the Media Fragments URI Specification
Europeana DSI - LT-Accelerate 14
Wikidata, a target for Europeana's semantic strategy - GLAM-WIKI 2015
NISO's Standards Update & Annual Membership Meeting
Europeana and RDF data validation
ALA2009_Andy Weissberg (Bowker)
Multilingual challenges for accessing digitized culture online - Riga Summit 15
Progress Report on Government Linked Data Worldwide
AAC Education Session
NASIG 2014: Actions and Updates on the Standards and Best Practices Front
Carpenter Library Assessment Conference Presentation
Ad

Similar to Finding media illustrating events (20)

PPT
SED2012 Dataset
PDF
Linking Events with Media
PPSX
Multimedia Data Collection using Social Media Analysis
KEY
Automatic Heritage Metadata Enrichment with Historic Events
PDF
Science of culture? Computational analysis and visualization of cultural imag...
PPTX
Aggregating Social Media for Enhancing Conference Experiences
PDF
Mediating Media Art. Digital Visual Archives as Mediation-Tools
PPT
Socialsensor project overview and topic discovery in tweeter streams
PPT
Tracking Social Media Participation: New Approaches to Studying User-Gener...
PDF
Semantic structuring and linking of event-centric data in the social web
PDF
Explorations in media visualization
PDF
SEWM'14 keynote: Mining Events from Multimedia Streams
PPTX
Contextual studies New & emerging industries
PDF
Oz fest digital marketing strategy
PDF
EventMedia Live: Exploring Events Connections in Real-Time to Enhance Content
PDF
Mining Events from Multimedia Streams (WAIS Research group seminar June 2014)
PDF
The Meta-Experience of (Media) Art. Activating the Archive
PDF
Machine learning and multimedia information retrieval
PPTX
Audiovisual content exploitation JTS2010
PDF
Intro to CAA 2012 session "Visualization as a Method in Art History"
SED2012 Dataset
Linking Events with Media
Multimedia Data Collection using Social Media Analysis
Automatic Heritage Metadata Enrichment with Historic Events
Science of culture? Computational analysis and visualization of cultural imag...
Aggregating Social Media for Enhancing Conference Experiences
Mediating Media Art. Digital Visual Archives as Mediation-Tools
Socialsensor project overview and topic discovery in tweeter streams
Tracking Social Media Participation: New Approaches to Studying User-Gener...
Semantic structuring and linking of event-centric data in the social web
Explorations in media visualization
SEWM'14 keynote: Mining Events from Multimedia Streams
Contextual studies New & emerging industries
Oz fest digital marketing strategy
EventMedia Live: Exploring Events Connections in Real-Time to Enhance Content
Mining Events from Multimedia Streams (WAIS Research group seminar June 2014)
The Meta-Experience of (Media) Art. Activating the Archive
Machine learning and multimedia information retrieval
Audiovisual content exploitation JTS2010
Intro to CAA 2012 session "Visualization as a Method in Art History"
Ad

More from Raphael Troncy (20)

PDF
K CAP 2019 Opening Ceremony
PDF
Semantic Technologies for Connected Vehicles in a Web of Things Environment
PDF
HyperTED: exploring video lectures at the fragment levels for enhancing learning
PDF
Location Embeddings for Next Trip Recommendation
PDF
A replication study of the top performing systems in SemEval twitter sentimen...
PDF
Contextualizing Events in TV News Shows - SNOW 2014
PDF
Modeling Geometry and Reference Systems on the Web of Data - LGD 2014
PDF
NERD: an open source platform for extracting and disambiguating named entitie...
PDF
Deep-linking into Media Assets at the Fragment Level SMAM 2013
PDF
Describing Media Assets: Media Fragment Specification and Description
PDF
Semantics at the multimedia fragment level SSSW 2013
PDF
Live topic generation from event streams
PDF
MediaFinder: Collect, Enrich and Visualize Media Memes Shared by the Crowd
PDF
Extracting Media Items from Multiple Social Networks
PDF
Semantics at the multimedia fragment level or how enabling the remixing of on...
PDF
MediaEval 2012 SED Opening
PDF
DeRiVE 2011 workshop opening
PDF
ShareIt: Mining SocialMedia Activities for Detecting Events
PDF
Multimedia Semantics - SSMS 2010
PDF
LODE: Une Ontologie pour representer des evenements dans le Web de Donnees
K CAP 2019 Opening Ceremony
Semantic Technologies for Connected Vehicles in a Web of Things Environment
HyperTED: exploring video lectures at the fragment levels for enhancing learning
Location Embeddings for Next Trip Recommendation
A replication study of the top performing systems in SemEval twitter sentimen...
Contextualizing Events in TV News Shows - SNOW 2014
Modeling Geometry and Reference Systems on the Web of Data - LGD 2014
NERD: an open source platform for extracting and disambiguating named entitie...
Deep-linking into Media Assets at the Fragment Level SMAM 2013
Describing Media Assets: Media Fragment Specification and Description
Semantics at the multimedia fragment level SSSW 2013
Live topic generation from event streams
MediaFinder: Collect, Enrich and Visualize Media Memes Shared by the Crowd
Extracting Media Items from Multiple Social Networks
Semantics at the multimedia fragment level or how enabling the remixing of on...
MediaEval 2012 SED Opening
DeRiVE 2011 workshop opening
ShareIt: Mining SocialMedia Activities for Detecting Events
Multimedia Semantics - SSMS 2010
LODE: Une Ontologie pour representer des evenements dans le Web de Donnees

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles - August'25 Week I
PDF
CIFDAQ's Market Insight: SEC Turns Pro Crypto
PDF
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PDF
Review of recent advances in non-invasive hemoglobin estimation
PDF
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
PPTX
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
PDF
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
PDF
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
PDF
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
PDF
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
PDF
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
PPT
Teaching material agriculture food technology
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
PPTX
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
PPTX
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
PPTX
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
PDF
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
PDF
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
PPTX
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles - August'25 Week I
CIFDAQ's Market Insight: SEC Turns Pro Crypto
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
Review of recent advances in non-invasive hemoglobin estimation
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
Teaching material agriculture food technology
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx

Finding media illustrating events

  • 1. Finding Media Illustrating Events Xueliang Liu <xueliang.liu@eurecom.fr> Raphaël Troncy <raphael.troncy@eurecom.fr> Benoit Huet <benoit.huet@eurecom.fr>
  • 2. What are Events? Events are observable occurrences grouping People Places Time Experiences documented by Media 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy -2
  • 4. Searching for an event 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy -4
  • 5. Searching for media about an event 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy -5
  • 6. There’s a lot of information out there… 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy -6
  • 8. Organize the mess Event Media  Scrape event directories  Link the information  Find media illustrating events  Design the application Interface Linking Open Data cloud diagram, by Richard Cyganiak and Anja Jentzsch. http://lod-cloud.net/ 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy -8
  • 9. Róisín Murphy at Nouveau Casino E0-001-005971169-9 350591 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy -9
  • 10. Representing Events with 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 10
  • 11. Interlinking  Linking Agents with  Freebase, Dbpedia, MusicBrainz  Linking Venues with  Geonames, Dbpedia, Foursquare (via Uberblic)  Linking Events with  Last.fm, Upcoming, Eventful  Linking Categories with  Facebook, Eventful, Upcoming, Zevents, LinkedIn,Eventbrite, TicketMaster  Linking Users with  Social Graph API 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 11
  • 12. Róisín Murphy at Nouveau Casino 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 12
  • 13. Media explicitly associated with the event APIs Machine tags “lastfm:events” 4790 photos, 263 1.7 million images over videos over 110 events 108.000 events 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 13
  • 14. Representing Media with Media Ontology 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 14
  • 15. How much data is there? Event Agent Location Photos User Last.fm 57,258 50,150 16,471 1,425,318 18,542 Upcoming 13,114 0 7,330 347,959 4,518 Eventful 37,647 6,543 14,576 0 0 Total 108,019 56,693 38,377 1,773,277 23,060 1,248,021 geo-tagged photos by propagating information from events! 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 15
  • 16. How fast media are uploaded? 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 16
  • 17. Finding more media that illustrate an event A. Compute the bounding box area of a venue B. Retrieve all media geo-tagged in this area C. Retrieve all media with a similar title D. Prune the results with visual analysis E. Extend the result set with all media from the same uploader 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 17
  • 18. A. Bounding box of Nouveau Casino? 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 18
  • 19. B. 74 photos taken in this area this day 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 19
  • 20. C. 85 additional photos with a similar title 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 20
  • 21. D. 6 photos after visual pruning          19/04/2011 -  Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 21 
  • 22. How is the visual pruning performed?  Model dataset: photo id + photo geo  Testing dataset: similar title  Low-level features used:  Color moments, Gabor texture, Edge histogram  L1 distance on the K-nearest neighbors  Threshold  Min L1 distance between two model image pairs  Conservative approach 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 22
  • 23. E. 66 photos after uploader heuristics  hellerpop DustGraph / Stefan cartoixa 13 photos 46 photos 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 23
  • 24. Same process for videos 1 video (id) 3 videos (geo)  26 videos (title) Visual pruning performed on key frames   Nb positive > 50% 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 24
  • 25. How illustrated are the events? Query By ID Query By Geo Query By Title Visual Pruning Heuristic Photos 5 74 (74) 85 (85) 6 (6) 66 (66) Videos 1 3 (0) 23 (0) 13 (0) - (title) Videos 10 (10) (title+venue)  20 events  Model dataset: 785 photos  Testing dataset: 1766 photos (1573 positive, 193 negative)  Results: 439 photos (99% precision, 28% recall) 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 25
  • 26. User Interface 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 26
  • 27. Conclusions  Method for finding media illustrating scheduled events  Search media with machine and geo tags  Search media with title and normal tags  Prune visually and retrieve all media from confirmed users  Challenge: do not necessarily trust the geo-coordinates  Event-based approach for users to explore, annotate and share media  UX can help semantics, semantics can help UX  Outstanding challenges in interlinking and curating the data  Detecting events from social media activity 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 27
  • 28. http://www.slideshare.net/troncy 19/04/2011 - Finding Media Illustrating Events - ICMR 2011, Trento, Italy - 28