SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Fra Open Data tilLinkedOpen DataStian Danenbarger <@stidan>Bouvet ASA <stian@bouvet.no>
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
 30 dager...
 47 nye anvendbare tjenester...
 Totalkostnad USD 50k (20k i premier)
 Estimert ROI på 4000 % (!)W. David Stephenson“The potential benefits of democratizing data are many, and varied:more informed policy debate, grounded in fact, rather than rhetoricconsensus buildingbetterlegislationgreater transparency and less corruption: greater accountabilityoptimizing program efficiency and reducing costsnew perspectives, especially when “the wisdom of crowds” emerges.Who would have believed that dry data […] could become the engine to involve the public in governmental transformation!””Democratizing Data” (O’Reilly Media, under arbeid)
“A hierarchy of database journalism”Level 5: Data experiences and storytellingLevel 4: Data visualizationLevel 3: Data explorationLevel of ambitionLevel 2: Data searchLevel 1: Data delivery"If we can find enough of these things that intersect with the lives of our readers, I think we will be all right.“− Dennis Ryerson, Editor, “the Indianapolis Star”Basert på Rich Gordon: “Data as journalism, journalism as data” (2007)
COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT, Brussels, 7.5.2009onthere-useof Public SectorInformation– ReviewofDirective 2003/98/EC –
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
		Offentlige Norge: 		”Tjenestetrappa”
SemicolonHvordan blir handlingsplanene fulgt opp? De årlige tildelingsbrevene fra det enkelte fagdepartement til underliggende etater definerer hvilke oppgaver etatene skal utføre gjennom det kommende året. Disse har lite eller ingen fokus på samhandling med andre etater.“Siloene” går hele veien fra departement og ned til operativ etat.Regjeringens samhandlingsstrategier blir ikke fulgt opp av departementene !!
ftp://ftp.cordis.europa.eu/pub/ist/docs/ict-ent-net/isg-report-4-0-erratum_en.pdf
“So far, the deployment of EI has been based strongly on a combination of the following two objectives:Objective 1: Supporting a “big bang” transition to a more efficient, enterprise-wide “best way” of working. This seeks to make sure that the enterprise remains competitive under changing market conditions. This new best way of working is defined by a relatively small group of dedicated expert analysts (industrial engineers, business engineers, information analysts etc.) and implemented and maintained top-down.
Objective 2: Once the major change related to Objective 1 is completed and the new way of working has become business as usual, exploiting the predicted gains in efficiency as much and as long as possible in order to secure a proper return on the investment made during the initial big bang change process.”Objective 3: EI should stimulate value creation based on innovation and co-creation in a context of networked enterprises that is very much defined bottom-up, by creative, committed workers. According to this perspective, EI helps “reflective practitioners” to manage their work, their responsibilities, the key knowledge they possess, and their relations to the work and knowledge of others (inside and outside their own enterprise). Unlike the traditional approach, this support is not driven top-down and purely enterprise centric, but allows a much more individual and subjective approach that leverages personal creativity and initiative. While traditionally individuals were supposed to adjust to “the system”, now the situation is reversed: the system is much moreabout supporting the individuals.”
		“If we let the computer 		do the job and stop 			worrying about the 			operations executed inside the black box, this may imply an ever-greater decrease in our knowledge and insight on how the public sector in society works with regard, for example, to distribution and re-distribution of money between the different layers in the community. Moreover, we will be more and more helpless if we try to examine the correctness of government decisions concerning our lives and welfare. Such a situation would affect the very relationship between government and its' citizens in a democratic society under the rule of law, namely, the capability of citizens to participate in the decision-making and control of dispositions by government authorities. The many at the bottom may have greater problems than before in controlling the few at the top.”“Transparent computer systems - transparent government“, D. W. Schartum (1995)
Skiftende paradigmer?Desentralisert og emergentFokus: Prosesserbar informasjonData: Delte identifikatorer (URI),          selvbeskrivende          hypermedia-formater          over HTTPKomponent-basertFokus: TjenesterData: XML, åpne skjema, namespacesObjekt-orientertFokus: StrukturData: Databaser med proprietære skjema, tekstProsedyre-orientertFokus: SyntaksData: Internt i applikasjoner199519752005201519851965
Tom Coates, Yahoo: ”The web as it was”…
Tom Coates, Yahoo: ”Web of the future?”
Samhandling krever delte definisjoner – og delte identifikatorer for disseGjelder ikke bare entiteter – også relasjoner og føringerEksempel: Skole, skoleeier – og relasjonene mellom Fag, eksamen, skole – og relasjonene mellomNår flere løsninger skal spille sammen, må identifikatorene løftes ut av de lokale systemene
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data
Utdanningsdirektoratets Grep:Delt datamodell med forskriftsstatus for grunnutdanningenOppdateringerResultaterDefinisjonerFormidling/annoteringSpørring/abonnement
DirektoratetSkoler og lærereLeverandører av læringsressurserElever Veilede
 Tilrettelegge
 Skape muligheterLokale læreplanerRessurserfraprivateaktørerRessurserfraSkolenettetMaterialefunnet ellerlaget avlærereKompetansemålMaterialefunnet ellerlaget aveleverHovedområderFagVisjonen er der, byggeklossene også…

More Related Content

PPT
Keynote Topic Maps 2010: "Occurrences"
PPT
Deling av data: ”Tenke det, ønske det, ville det med, men gjøre det...?”
DOC
Speech Maarten Brouwer at Open Data for Development Camp, May 2011, Amsterdam
PDF
The Case For Portals -- When Citizens Demand Online Access to Their Governmen...
PPT
Sookman justice canada_keynote
PPT
GoOpen 2009: Den Digitale Moltemyras Forbannelse
PPTX
Semantic search - for journalists
PPT
Enkle Grep – omfattende Grep…anvendt semantikk i utdanningssektoren
Keynote Topic Maps 2010: "Occurrences"
Deling av data: ”Tenke det, ønske det, ville det med, men gjøre det...?”
Speech Maarten Brouwer at Open Data for Development Camp, May 2011, Amsterdam
The Case For Portals -- When Citizens Demand Online Access to Their Governmen...
Sookman justice canada_keynote
GoOpen 2009: Den Digitale Moltemyras Forbannelse
Semantic search - for journalists
Enkle Grep – omfattende Grep…anvendt semantikk i utdanningssektoren

Similar to GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data (20)

PDF
GoOpen 2010: Stian Danenbarger
PPT
Interoperability challenges for Norwegian Tax Administration (Skatteetaten)
PPTX
Læringsanalyse - hva er det?
PPTX
NBSintro2013
PPT
Research Council of Norway on eGov R&amp;I
PDF
Keynote Address: Changing Public Sector Through ICT-innovation
PPTX
Electronic Open and Collaborative Governance - An Introduction
PDF
Healthcare’s fragmented ICT systems - how can qualitative research contribut...
PPTX
Electronic Open and Collaborative Governance - An Overview
PPTX
Samos 2020 Summit - Digital Governance Overview
PDF
Interoperability: How legislation and running code should be connected, Erlen...
PDF
GrEAnland
PDF
Innovation in the public sector/Innovasjon i offentlig sektor
PDF
Labs bason 27e_region
PDF
Sask 3.0 Summit -Seeing the Meaning, IBM R. Loepp
PPT
Dan Jellinek Transform Slides 13.05.2004
PDF
Collaboration for a better society, Terje Grimstad, Karde AS
PPTX
Newcastle Intro 2015
PPT
Privacy in networked society guiding data protection principles
PDF
Opening up government
GoOpen 2010: Stian Danenbarger
Interoperability challenges for Norwegian Tax Administration (Skatteetaten)
Læringsanalyse - hva er det?
NBSintro2013
Research Council of Norway on eGov R&amp;I
Keynote Address: Changing Public Sector Through ICT-innovation
Electronic Open and Collaborative Governance - An Introduction
Healthcare’s fragmented ICT systems - how can qualitative research contribut...
Electronic Open and Collaborative Governance - An Overview
Samos 2020 Summit - Digital Governance Overview
Interoperability: How legislation and running code should be connected, Erlen...
GrEAnland
Innovation in the public sector/Innovasjon i offentlig sektor
Labs bason 27e_region
Sask 3.0 Summit -Seeing the Meaning, IBM R. Loepp
Dan Jellinek Transform Slides 13.05.2004
Collaboration for a better society, Terje Grimstad, Karde AS
Newcastle Intro 2015
Privacy in networked society guiding data protection principles
Opening up government
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
PDF
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
PPTX
Spectroscopy.pptx food analysis technology
PDF
Electronic commerce courselecture one. Pdf
PDF
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
PPTX
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
PDF
MIND Revenue Release Quarter 2 2025 Press Release
PPTX
Machine Learning_overview_presentation.pptx
PDF
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PPTX
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
PDF
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
PPT
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
PDF
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
PDF
Encapsulation_ Review paper, used for researhc scholars
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PDF
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
PDF
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
PDF
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
Spectroscopy.pptx food analysis technology
Electronic commerce courselecture one. Pdf
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
MIND Revenue Release Quarter 2 2025 Press Release
Machine Learning_overview_presentation.pptx
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
Encapsulation_ Review paper, used for researhc scholars
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
Ad

GoOpen 2010: Fra Open Data til Linked Open Data

  • 1. Fra Open Data tilLinkedOpen DataStian Danenbarger <@stidan>Bouvet ASA <stian@bouvet.no>
  • 7. 47 nye anvendbare tjenester...
  • 8. Totalkostnad USD 50k (20k i premier)
  • 9. Estimert ROI på 4000 % (!)W. David Stephenson“The potential benefits of democratizing data are many, and varied:more informed policy debate, grounded in fact, rather than rhetoricconsensus buildingbetterlegislationgreater transparency and less corruption: greater accountabilityoptimizing program efficiency and reducing costsnew perspectives, especially when “the wisdom of crowds” emerges.Who would have believed that dry data […] could become the engine to involve the public in governmental transformation!””Democratizing Data” (O’Reilly Media, under arbeid)
  • 10. “A hierarchy of database journalism”Level 5: Data experiences and storytellingLevel 4: Data visualizationLevel 3: Data explorationLevel of ambitionLevel 2: Data searchLevel 1: Data delivery"If we can find enough of these things that intersect with the lives of our readers, I think we will be all right.“− Dennis Ryerson, Editor, “the Indianapolis Star”Basert på Rich Gordon: “Data as journalism, journalism as data” (2007)
  • 11. COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT, Brussels, 7.5.2009onthere-useof Public SectorInformation– ReviewofDirective 2003/98/EC –
  • 17. SemicolonHvordan blir handlingsplanene fulgt opp? De årlige tildelingsbrevene fra det enkelte fagdepartement til underliggende etater definerer hvilke oppgaver etatene skal utføre gjennom det kommende året. Disse har lite eller ingen fokus på samhandling med andre etater.“Siloene” går hele veien fra departement og ned til operativ etat.Regjeringens samhandlingsstrategier blir ikke fulgt opp av departementene !!
  • 19. “So far, the deployment of EI has been based strongly on a combination of the following two objectives:Objective 1: Supporting a “big bang” transition to a more efficient, enterprise-wide “best way” of working. This seeks to make sure that the enterprise remains competitive under changing market conditions. This new best way of working is defined by a relatively small group of dedicated expert analysts (industrial engineers, business engineers, information analysts etc.) and implemented and maintained top-down.
  • 20. Objective 2: Once the major change related to Objective 1 is completed and the new way of working has become business as usual, exploiting the predicted gains in efficiency as much and as long as possible in order to secure a proper return on the investment made during the initial big bang change process.”Objective 3: EI should stimulate value creation based on innovation and co-creation in a context of networked enterprises that is very much defined bottom-up, by creative, committed workers. According to this perspective, EI helps “reflective practitioners” to manage their work, their responsibilities, the key knowledge they possess, and their relations to the work and knowledge of others (inside and outside their own enterprise). Unlike the traditional approach, this support is not driven top-down and purely enterprise centric, but allows a much more individual and subjective approach that leverages personal creativity and initiative. While traditionally individuals were supposed to adjust to “the system”, now the situation is reversed: the system is much moreabout supporting the individuals.”
  • 21. “If we let the computer do the job and stop worrying about the operations executed inside the black box, this may imply an ever-greater decrease in our knowledge and insight on how the public sector in society works with regard, for example, to distribution and re-distribution of money between the different layers in the community. Moreover, we will be more and more helpless if we try to examine the correctness of government decisions concerning our lives and welfare. Such a situation would affect the very relationship between government and its' citizens in a democratic society under the rule of law, namely, the capability of citizens to participate in the decision-making and control of dispositions by government authorities. The many at the bottom may have greater problems than before in controlling the few at the top.”“Transparent computer systems - transparent government“, D. W. Schartum (1995)
  • 22. Skiftende paradigmer?Desentralisert og emergentFokus: Prosesserbar informasjonData: Delte identifikatorer (URI), selvbeskrivende hypermedia-formater over HTTPKomponent-basertFokus: TjenesterData: XML, åpne skjema, namespacesObjekt-orientertFokus: StrukturData: Databaser med proprietære skjema, tekstProsedyre-orientertFokus: SyntaksData: Internt i applikasjoner199519752005201519851965
  • 23. Tom Coates, Yahoo: ”The web as it was”…
  • 24. Tom Coates, Yahoo: ”Web of the future?”
  • 25. Samhandling krever delte definisjoner – og delte identifikatorer for disseGjelder ikke bare entiteter – også relasjoner og føringerEksempel: Skole, skoleeier – og relasjonene mellom Fag, eksamen, skole – og relasjonene mellomNår flere løsninger skal spille sammen, må identifikatorene løftes ut av de lokale systemene
  • 29. Utdanningsdirektoratets Grep:Delt datamodell med forskriftsstatus for grunnutdanningenOppdateringerResultaterDefinisjonerFormidling/annoteringSpørring/abonnement
  • 30. DirektoratetSkoler og lærereLeverandører av læringsressurserElever Veilede
  • 32. Skape muligheterLokale læreplanerRessurserfraprivateaktørerRessurserfraSkolenettetMaterialefunnet ellerlaget avlærereKompetansemålMaterialefunnet ellerlaget aveleverHovedområderFagVisjonen er der, byggeklossene også…
  • 46. “[…] regardless of what may be regarded as a true service-orientation, we should avoid employing computerized systems in a way that reduces the number of citizens who are actively participating in legal decision-making processes, concerning him- or herself, and in democratic debates. […] Here, when I talk about transparency, I am not primarily thinking of the insight represented by thin layers of pleasant simplifications, in the shape of glossy brochures. Instead, I wish to give attention to the problem of communicating knowledge concerning the very bedrock of legal and administrative complexity. […] Our society is not based on freedom and justice because this is the most cost-efficient way to construct a society”“Transparent computer systems - transparent government“, D. W. Schartum (1995)

Editor's Notes

  • #4: http://www.data.gov/about
  • #5: http://www.whitehouse.gov/open/innovations/
  • #6: http://sunlightlabs.com/contests/appsforamerica2/
  • #7: http://www.appsfordemocracy.org/
  • #8: http://www.slideshare.net/WDavidStephenson/democratizing-data
  • #9: http://www.readership.org/blog2/2007/11/data-as-journalism-journalism-as-data.html
  • #10: EU-direktiv fra 2003 – det såkalte PSI-direktivet (Public SectorInformation). Direktivet slår fast at mest mulig offentlige data og dokumenter skal gjøres tilgjengelig for borgerne. Direktivet sier imidlertid også at man kan ta betalt for ekstra innsats knyttet til å gjøre dataene tilgjengelige. MEPSIR-rapporten brukes mye av dem som mener det ligger et stort innovasjonspotensial i offentlige data. Den er basert på spørreundersøkelser i alle EU-land + Norge, hvor blant annet respondentene er bedt om å anslå størrelsen av markedet for offentlige data. 15 norske offentlige dataeiere og en såkalt ”re-user” har svart.Danskene har fått Gartner til å lage en rapport: Den sier ikke så mye mer konkret om innovasjonspotensialet enn at det finnes, men anbefaler noen strategier videre:Å fastsette en strategi for innovativ bruk av off. dataDefinere prinsipper og retningslinjer, herunder transparent prisstrukturLøse prinsipielle problemstillinger knyttet til sikkerhet, rettigheter, lisensstruktur og rettferdig konkurranse (det høres så lett ut når man ramser det opp på den måten der)Etablere prosess for vurdering av søknader om tilgang til offentlige dataEtablere oversikt over offentlige data og legge til rette for infrastruktur som sikrer adgang til offentlige data
  • #17: ftp://ftp.cordis.europa.eu/pub/ist/docs/ict-ent-net/isg-report-4-0-erratum_en.pdf
  • #18: ftp://ftp.cordis.europa.eu/pub/ist/docs/ict-ent-net/isg-report-4-0-erratum_en.pdf
  • #19: ftp://ftp.cordis.europa.eu/pub/ist/docs/ict-ent-net/isg-report-4-0-erratum_en.pdf
  • #20: http://folk.uio.no/dags/artikler/transparent.html
  • #26: http://www4.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/bizer/pub/lod-datasets_2009-07-14.png
  • #27: Los (eng.: “harbor pilot”)Spring 2007: Launch (municipality of Bergen portal first pilot)Shared classification system for information about public services - used by maybe 100 municipalities/counties todayLos has a two level topical structure that can be used as a navigation structure by public web sitesStated advantages:Counties don’t have to work out a local information structureResidents can easily find out the information he / she needs without necessarily knowing much about public sectorPublic websites and the use of these concepts are harmonized and easily recognizable for citizensIt will be easier to share data with other government agencies that use the systemhttp://www.norge.no/los/
  • #33: http://folk.uio.no/dags/artikler/transparent.html