SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Gathering of State Networks February 6, 2002 IP VIDEO ISSUES
IP VIDEO ISSUES AGENDA BACKGROUND  QUALITY OF SERVICE (QoS) CODECS GATEKEEPERS/GATEWAYS DIAL PLAN  DIRECTORY SERVICES
BACKGROUND TWO-WAY INTERACTIVE VIDEO ATM VIDEO (H.321)  1998 ISSUES COST OF END POINT EQUIPMENT DESKTOP EQUIPMENT COST CURRENTLY – 165 ENDPOINTS ON NETWORK FOR CONVERGED NETWORKS ONLY GAME IN TOWN
BACKGROUND  H.323 – IP VIDEO 1999 PRODUCTS AVAILABLE IP ACCESS ALREADY IN PLACE COSTS OF ENDPOINTS MUCH CHEAPER MORE DESKTOP SOLUTIONS AVAILABLE
 
BACKGROUND MCU TESTING – FALL 1999 Accord , Ezenia, Radvision Operability issues Performance CONCLUSION: TECHNOLOGY TOO IMMATURE FOR A RELIABLE PRODUCTION IMPLEMENTATION
BACKGROUND H.323 – IP VIDEO 2001 MCU TESTING – FALL 2000 RESULT:  THEY ACTUALLY WORK!! RECOMMENDATION:  Accord MGC 100 NEED TO LOOK AT THE VARIOUS ISSUES AND COMPONENTS NEEDED TO IMPLEMENT H.323 ON THE NETWORK – IP VIDEO TASK FORCE
 
QoS (Quality of Service) What is QoS Set of techniques to manage network resources in a manner which enables the network to differentiate traffic based on policy Why implement QoS Provide reliable and guaranteed delivery of service to users Bandwidth is not the complete solution
Quality of Service Challenges providing QoS for IP video Head of line blocking (HOLB) IP video uses UDP (universal datagram protocol) for transport of video and only uses TCP for control data – can’t resend lost video packets Video uses large, variable length packets
Video Conferencing Traffic  Packet Size Breakdown  37% 1025-1518 Bytes 20% 513-1024 Bytes 34% 129-256 Bytes 1% 65-128 Bytes 8% 257-512 Bytes 384 kbps Video Call Courtesy Cisco Systems Inc.
Video Data Rate + 20% = Bandwidth Required 128kbps = 153kbps 384kbps = 460kbps 512kbps = 614kbps 768kbps = 921kbps 1.5Mbps = 1.8Mbps Video Data Rate BW Required Provisioning < 33% of Link Capacity < 75% of Link Capacity Link Capacity “ Recommendations” Courtesy Cisco Systems Inc . Video Voice Data Routing etc.
CODECs
 
Requirements That a vendor have both a desktop (PC based) and a room system in their product line Support interoperability Ease of Support Financial considerations
What We Looked At Cameras (Fixed and Pan/Tilt/Zoom) Appliance based PC based Ease of installation Ease of configuration Chair Control Far end camera control MCU capability QoS
Types of Codecs Tested Room Systems Polycom VCON VTEL Tandberg
Types of Codecs Tested cont’d Desktop Systems (PC Based) Polycom VCON
Recommendations Room Systems Polycom Viewstation FX (Appliance Based) VCON Media Connect 8000 (PC Based) Desktop Systems (PC Based) Polycom ViaVideo VCON ViGO, Crusier & Escort
GATEKEEPERS The Brains of an H.323 System
 
Difference between Gatekeepers and Gateways Gatekeeper IP based Address Resolution – Layer 3 Bandwidth Management Call Admission Control (CAC) Call forwarding Technology Prefixes Exist in hierarchies Gateway Can transcode between ISDN, ATM and IP Address Resolution – Layer 2
Limitations of Gatekeepers 4 Levels of Hierarchies Can have no more than 6 Forwarded Location Requests (LRQ)
IP Video Gatekeeper Hierarchy Institutional Gatekeepers 2 levels of hierarchy Zone = Area Code  Gatekeepers placed at current network nodes ITN Directory Gatekeeper
DIAL PLAN To DID or Not to DID?
Why Do We Need A Dial Plan? To support legacy ISDN and ATM codecs To enable a seamless connection between codecs in various parts of the state. To let people off net to be able to call IP codecs on net (Inbound calls) USER FRIENDLY
ITN Dial Plan E[*T]ZZZNNNNNNN E = Exit Zone Prefix.  “1” *T = Technology Prefix (Optional) ZZZ = Area Code NNNNNNN = Seven digit E.164 number
Technology Prefixes Used for making off net calls to ISDN codecs *9 – Single channel voice only call *6 – 6-B 64 KB ISDN call or 384 kbps *2 – 2-B 64 KB ISDN call or 128 kbps *3 – 2-B 64 KB ISDN restricted to 56 KB call or 112 kbps
 
 
Common Failures of Video Calls Within the ITN Network Unit has not been rebooted for several days PC NIC is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex LAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex Video call is not set up through a gatekeeper Gatekeeper not properly configured WAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex
Common Failures of Video Calls Outside the ITN Network ISDN Cloud Internet Cloud WAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex Gatekeeper not properly configured Video call is not set up through a gatekeeper LAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex PC NIC is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex Unit has not been rebooted for several days LAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex
Directory Services How Do I Find You
Two types of Directories Lightweight Directory Access Protocol - LDAP Click To Meet
LDAP Contains information on endpoints Runs on Unix platform Can connect to a global directory service Does not connect to gatekeepers Will interact with First Virtual Communications  Click To Meet  in future versions
Click To Meet - CTM Designed specifically for multimedia applications Works with VTEL, TANDBERG, VCON, POLYCOM, PICTURETEL and ACCORD Works with ISDN, ATM and IP protocols Can schedule calls in advance T.120 application sharing and whiteboards
CTM – Cont’d Continuous presence built in Will handle streaming media Supports firewall NAT/proxy/VPN transversal Connects to a gatekeeper Support for Active Directory December 2001 Subsequent versions will have native LDAP support
Dialing Made Simple Courtesy First Virtual Communications, Inc.
Scheduling Made Simple Courtesy First Virtual Communications, Inc.
Recommendation First Virtual Communications Click To Meet for use as directory services for ITN
IP Video Task Force Members Vern Draper, BSU Fred Nay, BSU, Co-Chair Mike Huffman, DOE Alan Benjamin, DoIT Tim Holt, INCOLSA Gerry Oliver, ISU Jeff Steinmiller, ISU Steve Egyhazi, IU Doug Pearson, IU Art Mahan, Ind. Wesleyan
IP Video Task Force Members Brain Stone, IMCPL Jason Whiteaker, ITSC Jerry Sullivan, Intelinet Chad Miller, Intelinet Michael Gay, Purdue University Don Kindred, Purdue University Pat Smoker, Purdue University Ed Stanish, Purdue University Wayne Bohm, USI Tim Lockridge, USI
IP Video Task Force Members Carl Koenig, Vincennes University Ron Dekoker, IHETS Dave Kaufman, IHETS Tony McClelland, IHETS Kevin Siminski, IHETS Alan Stillerman, IHETS Ed Stockey, IHETS, Co-Chair Marty Stricker, IHETS
IP Video Task Force Dial-Plan Committee Members Vern Draper, BSU Fred Nay, BSU Steve Egyhazi, IU Michael Gay, Purdue University Earle Nay, Purdue Unviersity  Ron DeKoker, IHETS Tony McClelland, IHETS Kevin Siminski, IHETS Shawn Solomon, IHETS Alan Stillerman, IHETS, Chair Ed Stockey, IHETS
How To Reach Us Ed Tully [email_address] 317-263-8922

More Related Content

PDF
Điện thoại ip không dây Yealink w53P datasheet
PDF
Cbaa Ip Workshop
PDF
SpeakerLinX_SL254
PPT
/conferences/spr2002/presentations/kirby.ppt
PDF
2012 ah vegas rf troubleshooting
PPTX
Video-over-IP for AV
PPTX
SVSi_Networked AV
Điện thoại ip không dây Yealink w53P datasheet
Cbaa Ip Workshop
SpeakerLinX_SL254
/conferences/spr2002/presentations/kirby.ppt
2012 ah vegas rf troubleshooting
Video-over-IP for AV
SVSi_Networked AV

What's hot (20)

PPT
Practical Fundamentals of Voice over IP (VoIP) for Engineers and Technicians
PDF
Introduction to VoIP, RTP and SIP
PPT
Voice Over IP Overview w/Secuirty
PPTX
Sydney UC - February 2015
PDF
Optimizing wlan operations peter lane
PDF
Rf troubleshooting advanced kelly griffin_peter lane
PDF
Airheads barcelona 2010 rf design for retail warehousing manufacturing
PDF
2012 ah apj wi fi design for voice & video
PPT
Avaya VoIP on Cisco Best Practices by PacketBase
PDF
Outdoor network engineering jeffrey weaver
PDF
Mobility access switches_madani adjali
PDF
2012 ah apj wlan security fundamentals
PPTX
Anaren Integrated Radio (AIR) module introduction
PDF
Jain Sip Tutorial
PDF
HEAnets' Video Conferencing Service
PPTX
VOIP security
PDF
2012 ah vegas remote networking fundamentals
PDF
2012 ah apj rf troubleshooting
PPT
VoIP Security
PDF
4 healthcare forum deploying vocera on aruba wlan_kevin huey
Practical Fundamentals of Voice over IP (VoIP) for Engineers and Technicians
Introduction to VoIP, RTP and SIP
Voice Over IP Overview w/Secuirty
Sydney UC - February 2015
Optimizing wlan operations peter lane
Rf troubleshooting advanced kelly griffin_peter lane
Airheads barcelona 2010 rf design for retail warehousing manufacturing
2012 ah apj wi fi design for voice & video
Avaya VoIP on Cisco Best Practices by PacketBase
Outdoor network engineering jeffrey weaver
Mobility access switches_madani adjali
2012 ah apj wlan security fundamentals
Anaren Integrated Radio (AIR) module introduction
Jain Sip Tutorial
HEAnets' Video Conferencing Service
VOIP security
2012 ah vegas remote networking fundamentals
2012 ah apj rf troubleshooting
VoIP Security
4 healthcare forum deploying vocera on aruba wlan_kevin huey
Ad

Viewers also liked (14)

PDF
A nossa escola!
PPT
PPTX
Palavras Quanto à AcentuaçãO
PPT
O primeiro dia de escola antónio mota 2011
PPT
HistóRias Que A 5ª C Conta VersãO Antiga Power Point
PPSX
Bom ano letivo 2012/2013
PPTX
Pwpoint o primeiro dia de escola
PPT
Início do ano letivo 2013/2014
DOC
Guía sumas pirámides mágicas - 3º básico
PDF
Tabuada de multiplicar
PDF
Regresso às aulas - Como preparar um novo ano letivo
PDF
Piramides numericas ejercicios resueltos de sexto de primaria
PDF
Cata palavras: bota
PPTX
A menina que só sabia contar até
A nossa escola!
Palavras Quanto à AcentuaçãO
O primeiro dia de escola antónio mota 2011
HistóRias Que A 5ª C Conta VersãO Antiga Power Point
Bom ano letivo 2012/2013
Pwpoint o primeiro dia de escola
Início do ano letivo 2013/2014
Guía sumas pirámides mágicas - 3º básico
Tabuada de multiplicar
Regresso às aulas - Como preparar um novo ano letivo
Piramides numericas ejercicios resueltos de sexto de primaria
Cata palavras: bota
A menina que só sabia contar até
Ad

Similar to Gathering of State Networks (20)

PPS
How To Successfully Implement IP Video
PPTX
Videoconference
PPT
Download
PPT
Videoconferencing Technology Workshop
PPTX
Assessing Network Readiness
PDF
PPT
AETA_2004_VOIP.ppt
PPTX
PPT
Videoconferencing Technology
PPT
goldman5gdoevrosps8evosyurobaibd80wkq8.ppt
PPT
/resources/presentations/200101-amiot1.ppt
PPT
/resources/presentations/200101-amiot1.ppt
PPT
/resources/presentations/200101-amiot1.ppt
PPT
Linkedin
PPT
Wan technology
PDF
ETE405-lec9.pdf
PPT
Comparison of IP Video Phone Software
PPTX
CISSP - Chapter 4 - Intranet and extranets
PDF
Videoconferencing Technical Considerations for IT Professionals
How To Successfully Implement IP Video
Videoconference
Download
Videoconferencing Technology Workshop
Assessing Network Readiness
AETA_2004_VOIP.ppt
Videoconferencing Technology
goldman5gdoevrosps8evosyurobaibd80wkq8.ppt
/resources/presentations/200101-amiot1.ppt
/resources/presentations/200101-amiot1.ppt
/resources/presentations/200101-amiot1.ppt
Linkedin
Wan technology
ETE405-lec9.pdf
Comparison of IP Video Phone Software
CISSP - Chapter 4 - Intranet and extranets
Videoconferencing Technical Considerations for IT Professionals

More from Videoguy (20)

PDF
Energy-Aware Wireless Video Streaming
PDF
Microsoft PowerPoint - WirelessCluster_Pres
PDF
Proxy Cache Management for Fine-Grained Scalable Video Streaming
PDF
Adobe
PDF
Free-riding Resilient Video Streaming in Peer-to-Peer Networks
PDF
Instant video streaming
PDF
Video Streaming over Bluetooth: A Survey
PDF
Video Streaming
PDF
Reaching a Broader Audience
PDF
Considerations for Creating Streamed Video Content over 3G ...
PDF
ADVANCES IN CHANNEL-ADAPTIVE VIDEO STREAMING
PDF
Impact of FEC Overhead on Scalable Video Streaming
PDF
Application Brief
PDF
Video Streaming Services – Stage 1
PDF
Streaming Video into Second Life
PDF
Flash Live Video Streaming Software
PDF
Videoconference Streaming Solutions Cookbook
PDF
Streaming Video Formaten
PDF
iPhone Live Video Streaming Software
PDF
Glow: Video streaming training guide - Firefox
Energy-Aware Wireless Video Streaming
Microsoft PowerPoint - WirelessCluster_Pres
Proxy Cache Management for Fine-Grained Scalable Video Streaming
Adobe
Free-riding Resilient Video Streaming in Peer-to-Peer Networks
Instant video streaming
Video Streaming over Bluetooth: A Survey
Video Streaming
Reaching a Broader Audience
Considerations for Creating Streamed Video Content over 3G ...
ADVANCES IN CHANNEL-ADAPTIVE VIDEO STREAMING
Impact of FEC Overhead on Scalable Video Streaming
Application Brief
Video Streaming Services – Stage 1
Streaming Video into Second Life
Flash Live Video Streaming Software
Videoconference Streaming Solutions Cookbook
Streaming Video Formaten
iPhone Live Video Streaming Software
Glow: Video streaming training guide - Firefox

Gathering of State Networks

  • 1. Gathering of State Networks February 6, 2002 IP VIDEO ISSUES
  • 2. IP VIDEO ISSUES AGENDA BACKGROUND QUALITY OF SERVICE (QoS) CODECS GATEKEEPERS/GATEWAYS DIAL PLAN DIRECTORY SERVICES
  • 3. BACKGROUND TWO-WAY INTERACTIVE VIDEO ATM VIDEO (H.321) 1998 ISSUES COST OF END POINT EQUIPMENT DESKTOP EQUIPMENT COST CURRENTLY – 165 ENDPOINTS ON NETWORK FOR CONVERGED NETWORKS ONLY GAME IN TOWN
  • 4. BACKGROUND H.323 – IP VIDEO 1999 PRODUCTS AVAILABLE IP ACCESS ALREADY IN PLACE COSTS OF ENDPOINTS MUCH CHEAPER MORE DESKTOP SOLUTIONS AVAILABLE
  • 5.  
  • 6. BACKGROUND MCU TESTING – FALL 1999 Accord , Ezenia, Radvision Operability issues Performance CONCLUSION: TECHNOLOGY TOO IMMATURE FOR A RELIABLE PRODUCTION IMPLEMENTATION
  • 7. BACKGROUND H.323 – IP VIDEO 2001 MCU TESTING – FALL 2000 RESULT: THEY ACTUALLY WORK!! RECOMMENDATION: Accord MGC 100 NEED TO LOOK AT THE VARIOUS ISSUES AND COMPONENTS NEEDED TO IMPLEMENT H.323 ON THE NETWORK – IP VIDEO TASK FORCE
  • 8.  
  • 9. QoS (Quality of Service) What is QoS Set of techniques to manage network resources in a manner which enables the network to differentiate traffic based on policy Why implement QoS Provide reliable and guaranteed delivery of service to users Bandwidth is not the complete solution
  • 10. Quality of Service Challenges providing QoS for IP video Head of line blocking (HOLB) IP video uses UDP (universal datagram protocol) for transport of video and only uses TCP for control data – can’t resend lost video packets Video uses large, variable length packets
  • 11. Video Conferencing Traffic Packet Size Breakdown 37% 1025-1518 Bytes 20% 513-1024 Bytes 34% 129-256 Bytes 1% 65-128 Bytes 8% 257-512 Bytes 384 kbps Video Call Courtesy Cisco Systems Inc.
  • 12. Video Data Rate + 20% = Bandwidth Required 128kbps = 153kbps 384kbps = 460kbps 512kbps = 614kbps 768kbps = 921kbps 1.5Mbps = 1.8Mbps Video Data Rate BW Required Provisioning < 33% of Link Capacity < 75% of Link Capacity Link Capacity “ Recommendations” Courtesy Cisco Systems Inc . Video Voice Data Routing etc.
  • 14.  
  • 15. Requirements That a vendor have both a desktop (PC based) and a room system in their product line Support interoperability Ease of Support Financial considerations
  • 16. What We Looked At Cameras (Fixed and Pan/Tilt/Zoom) Appliance based PC based Ease of installation Ease of configuration Chair Control Far end camera control MCU capability QoS
  • 17. Types of Codecs Tested Room Systems Polycom VCON VTEL Tandberg
  • 18. Types of Codecs Tested cont’d Desktop Systems (PC Based) Polycom VCON
  • 19. Recommendations Room Systems Polycom Viewstation FX (Appliance Based) VCON Media Connect 8000 (PC Based) Desktop Systems (PC Based) Polycom ViaVideo VCON ViGO, Crusier & Escort
  • 20. GATEKEEPERS The Brains of an H.323 System
  • 21.  
  • 22. Difference between Gatekeepers and Gateways Gatekeeper IP based Address Resolution – Layer 3 Bandwidth Management Call Admission Control (CAC) Call forwarding Technology Prefixes Exist in hierarchies Gateway Can transcode between ISDN, ATM and IP Address Resolution – Layer 2
  • 23. Limitations of Gatekeepers 4 Levels of Hierarchies Can have no more than 6 Forwarded Location Requests (LRQ)
  • 24. IP Video Gatekeeper Hierarchy Institutional Gatekeepers 2 levels of hierarchy Zone = Area Code Gatekeepers placed at current network nodes ITN Directory Gatekeeper
  • 25. DIAL PLAN To DID or Not to DID?
  • 26. Why Do We Need A Dial Plan? To support legacy ISDN and ATM codecs To enable a seamless connection between codecs in various parts of the state. To let people off net to be able to call IP codecs on net (Inbound calls) USER FRIENDLY
  • 27. ITN Dial Plan E[*T]ZZZNNNNNNN E = Exit Zone Prefix. “1” *T = Technology Prefix (Optional) ZZZ = Area Code NNNNNNN = Seven digit E.164 number
  • 28. Technology Prefixes Used for making off net calls to ISDN codecs *9 – Single channel voice only call *6 – 6-B 64 KB ISDN call or 384 kbps *2 – 2-B 64 KB ISDN call or 128 kbps *3 – 2-B 64 KB ISDN restricted to 56 KB call or 112 kbps
  • 29.  
  • 30.  
  • 31. Common Failures of Video Calls Within the ITN Network Unit has not been rebooted for several days PC NIC is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex LAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex Video call is not set up through a gatekeeper Gatekeeper not properly configured WAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex
  • 32. Common Failures of Video Calls Outside the ITN Network ISDN Cloud Internet Cloud WAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex Gatekeeper not properly configured Video call is not set up through a gatekeeper LAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex PC NIC is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex Unit has not been rebooted for several days LAN is not set for 100 Mbps – Full Duplex
  • 33. Directory Services How Do I Find You
  • 34. Two types of Directories Lightweight Directory Access Protocol - LDAP Click To Meet
  • 35. LDAP Contains information on endpoints Runs on Unix platform Can connect to a global directory service Does not connect to gatekeepers Will interact with First Virtual Communications Click To Meet in future versions
  • 36. Click To Meet - CTM Designed specifically for multimedia applications Works with VTEL, TANDBERG, VCON, POLYCOM, PICTURETEL and ACCORD Works with ISDN, ATM and IP protocols Can schedule calls in advance T.120 application sharing and whiteboards
  • 37. CTM – Cont’d Continuous presence built in Will handle streaming media Supports firewall NAT/proxy/VPN transversal Connects to a gatekeeper Support for Active Directory December 2001 Subsequent versions will have native LDAP support
  • 38. Dialing Made Simple Courtesy First Virtual Communications, Inc.
  • 39. Scheduling Made Simple Courtesy First Virtual Communications, Inc.
  • 40. Recommendation First Virtual Communications Click To Meet for use as directory services for ITN
  • 41. IP Video Task Force Members Vern Draper, BSU Fred Nay, BSU, Co-Chair Mike Huffman, DOE Alan Benjamin, DoIT Tim Holt, INCOLSA Gerry Oliver, ISU Jeff Steinmiller, ISU Steve Egyhazi, IU Doug Pearson, IU Art Mahan, Ind. Wesleyan
  • 42. IP Video Task Force Members Brain Stone, IMCPL Jason Whiteaker, ITSC Jerry Sullivan, Intelinet Chad Miller, Intelinet Michael Gay, Purdue University Don Kindred, Purdue University Pat Smoker, Purdue University Ed Stanish, Purdue University Wayne Bohm, USI Tim Lockridge, USI
  • 43. IP Video Task Force Members Carl Koenig, Vincennes University Ron Dekoker, IHETS Dave Kaufman, IHETS Tony McClelland, IHETS Kevin Siminski, IHETS Alan Stillerman, IHETS Ed Stockey, IHETS, Co-Chair Marty Stricker, IHETS
  • 44. IP Video Task Force Dial-Plan Committee Members Vern Draper, BSU Fred Nay, BSU Steve Egyhazi, IU Michael Gay, Purdue University Earle Nay, Purdue Unviersity Ron DeKoker, IHETS Tony McClelland, IHETS Kevin Siminski, IHETS Shawn Solomon, IHETS Alan Stillerman, IHETS, Chair Ed Stockey, IHETS
  • 45. How To Reach Us Ed Tully [email_address] 317-263-8922

Editor's Notes

  • #12: CIF – common interface format 352X288 pixels QCIF 176X144