SlideShare a Scribd company logo
15 Years of UNDP/GEF in the Black Sea Region,
Final Seminar,
14-15 February 2008, Istanbul
Zoobenthos (1)
Macro- and meio-benthos
Standardised macro-methods
manual
Excellent overview of data
analysis options in research
cruise reports and Todorova &
Konsulova presentation (univariate and
multivariate approaches)
Ecological indices represent the best forward
for result presentation
Zoobenthos (2)
No. of species distribution:
Zoobenthos (3)
Abundance distribution:
Zoobenthos (4)
Biomass distribution:
Zoobenthos (5)
AMBI geographic distribution
Zoobenthos (6)
Zoobenthos is not evenly distributed over short
distances. Thus:
•Both abundance and biomass of individual species
vary substantially between replicates
•The total number of species can vary greatly
between replicates
•30 nautical miles offshore of Constanta, the number
of macrozoobenthos species varied between 5 and
14 in individual replicates, with a total number of 25
species in 5 replicates
WARNIN
G
Phyllophora field (1)
The Phyllophora field once provided a habitat
for 118 species of invertebrates and 47
species of fish
In 1964, 32 macro-algal species were
recorded, but this had halved by 1986
3 years later only a quarter of the species
recorded in the 1960s were present
However, in 2004, a slight increase in
macroalgal species numbers was recorded
when compared to the 1989 situation
Phyllophora field (2)
1979 2002
Shading by phytoplankton
Phyllophora field (3)
Sediment deposition rates - Danube Prodelta
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
1960
1962
1964
1966
1968
1970
1972
1974
1976
1978
1980
1982
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
T,mlntons
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
CRSMAR,gcm-2
y-1
Sediment Discharge 3y AVG Annual Sediment Discharge CRS MAR
Phyllophora field (4)
Meiobenthos
Macrobentho
s
Phyllophora field (5)
Relatively low levels of zoobenthos occur in
the Phyllophora field, but often with a high
number of species, particularly of
macrozoobenthos
While one species dominates, this dominance
is much less complete than in the other
polygons and indicative of higher biodiversity
Large numbers of ascidians actively process
high organic flux from water column,
preventing sediment enrichment
Phyllophora field (6)
Originally Phyllophora nervosa dominated
Phyllophora brodiaei in southern part of field,
but rarely dominant. Ph. pseudoceranoides
has not been recorded since 1989
Now filamentous reds (Polysiphonia) and
greens (Ectocarpus,
Desmarestia) cover 70-80% bed
Phyllophora (and other
seaweeds) reduce internal
loading of nutrients
Plankton
Manuals written; equipment provided
Plankton populations change quickly (on a
seasonal basis)
Participating scientists asked to present
results in relation to long-term monitoring data
Phytoplankton biomass and abundance have
been on a decreasing trend since the early
1990s
Species richness and other univariate indices
are in favour of the “recovery phase” of the
NW Black Sea ecosystem
Phytoplankton (1)
0
3
6
9
1961-
1963
1983-
1990
1995-
1997
1998-
2005
Biomass(g/m
3
)
0
3
6
9
1960s
1983-
1990
1991-
2000
2001-
2005
Biomass(g/m
3
)
Danube
Phytoplankton (2)
However, the dominance of mixotrophic/
heterotrophic dinoflagellates strongly resembles
the “eutrophication phase”
Concern over colonisation by invasive species
(Alexandrium cysts – 2006)
In the 1960s, the phytoplankton population was
dominated by diatoms and dinoflagellates
Now “others” constitute a much greater
proportion – the ecology is changing
Zooplankton (1)
Two patterns of vertical distribution:
•Maximum close to the thermocline
where Noctiluca dominates
•Maximum in surface waters
Copepods, Cladocera, Meroplankton,
Appendicularia and Chaetognatha predominate
in Northern Shelf waters
Further south, Noctiluca dominates
Improved diversity in northern (Ukrainian)
waters
Mnemiopsis/Beroe battle continues
Zooplankton (2)
Long-term summer abundance of Cladocera
and Copepoda (Cape Galata):
Nutrients and Fluxes (1)
Annual water transport across the shelf/open
sea boundary:
0 4 8 1 2
m o n t h s
8 0
1 0 0
1 2 0
1 4 0
volume
Nutrients and Fluxes (2)
Annual water transport
across the shelf/open
sea boundary:
Peaks in October
Nutrients and Fluxes (3)
Annual DIN fluxes across the shelf/open sea
boundary:
Ammonium Nitrate Nitrite
Nutrients and Fluxes (4)
Surface trackers following anticyclonic eddy:
A= Release point
B = Cape Kaliakra
C = fishing vessel
route
Nutrients and Fluxes (5)
The nitrate maximum defines the oxycline
boundary in deep regions of the Sea
Phosphate conc’s increase within the oxycline
and the upper
suboxic zone
Surface conc’s
low, but may
be locally
elevated

More Related Content

PDF
ZoopsWestport
PDF
2010 Poster presentation
PPT
Atbc talks hawaii 2015 kowiyou yessoufou_final
PPTX
Landscape mosaicness in the ocean
PPTX
Salish Sea Poster - final
PDF
Finlay j.b. ,g.f.esteban & t. fenchel (1998) .protozoan diversity.converging ...
PDF
A preliminary survey of gastrointestinal parasites of animals in
PDF
the biological indicators studies of zooplankton
ZoopsWestport
2010 Poster presentation
Atbc talks hawaii 2015 kowiyou yessoufou_final
Landscape mosaicness in the ocean
Salish Sea Poster - final
Finlay j.b. ,g.f.esteban & t. fenchel (1998) .protozoan diversity.converging ...
A preliminary survey of gastrointestinal parasites of animals in
the biological indicators studies of zooplankton

What's hot (20)

PDF
Trends in Macrophyte Diversity in Anthropogenic Perturbed Lentic Ecosystems w...
PDF
The role of abiotic factors in diurnal vertical distribution of
PDF
Polyploidy in Bulinid Snails, with Emphasis on Bulinus truncatus/tropicus Com...
PPTX
Community Diversity - Foraminifera
PDF
Comparative transcriptome analysis of Eugenia uniflora L. (Myrtaceae) shed li...
PDF
GEOGRAPHIC ISOLATION OF Hypostomus cordovae (SILURIFORMES, LORICARIIDAE) IN A...
PDF
First discovery of dicyemida (mesozoa) in caribbean cephalopods
PPTX
Diatom biogeography: distribution of the Luticola species found in Iguazú Nat...
PDF
PerkinElmer 2019 Applied Genomics Calendar
PDF
Do pitcher plants control the assembly of pitcher microbiomes?
DOCX
Bird report
PDF
Bacterial Numbers, Biomass and Productivity within the KwaZulu-Natal Bight: A...
PPT
Emerging Diversity Within Well-known Heterotrophic Flagellates Groups Reveal...
PPTX
Emerging Diversity Within Well-known Heterotrophic Flagellates Groups Reveale...
PDF
RIVER NETWORKS AS ECOLOGICAL CORRIDORS FOR SPECIES POPULATIONS AND WATER-BORN...
PDF
Historical biogeography and diversification in Sisyrinchium (Iridaceae)
PPT
PPT
Research Poster
PPTX
INTRODUCTION OF PLANKTON
PPTX
Phylogeography and genetic diversity of Baetodes huaico (EPHEMEROPTERA: BAETI...
Trends in Macrophyte Diversity in Anthropogenic Perturbed Lentic Ecosystems w...
The role of abiotic factors in diurnal vertical distribution of
Polyploidy in Bulinid Snails, with Emphasis on Bulinus truncatus/tropicus Com...
Community Diversity - Foraminifera
Comparative transcriptome analysis of Eugenia uniflora L. (Myrtaceae) shed li...
GEOGRAPHIC ISOLATION OF Hypostomus cordovae (SILURIFORMES, LORICARIIDAE) IN A...
First discovery of dicyemida (mesozoa) in caribbean cephalopods
Diatom biogeography: distribution of the Luticola species found in Iguazú Nat...
PerkinElmer 2019 Applied Genomics Calendar
Do pitcher plants control the assembly of pitcher microbiomes?
Bird report
Bacterial Numbers, Biomass and Productivity within the KwaZulu-Natal Bight: A...
Emerging Diversity Within Well-known Heterotrophic Flagellates Groups Reveal...
Emerging Diversity Within Well-known Heterotrophic Flagellates Groups Reveale...
RIVER NETWORKS AS ECOLOGICAL CORRIDORS FOR SPECIES POPULATIONS AND WATER-BORN...
Historical biogeography and diversification in Sisyrinchium (Iridaceae)
Research Poster
INTRODUCTION OF PLANKTON
Phylogeography and genetic diversity of Baetodes huaico (EPHEMEROPTERA: BAETI...
Ad

Viewers also liked (19)

PPT
Supporting Private Investment in Infrastructure Finance
PPT
First GEF Regional Project in the Mediterranean (Civili) [IWC4 Presentation]
PPT
Global Response to BW Issue: Can GEF be a Catalyst for Legal Reforms
PPT
Valuing Recreation/Amenity Benefits: Travel Costs, CVM, and Hedonics
PPT
From Diye to Value of Statistical Life: A Case Study for the Islamic Republi...
PPT
2007 Black Sea TDA
PPTX
Pissierssens - International Oceanographic Data and Information Exchange Pres...
PPT
Pollution Reduction Revloving Fund for the LMEs of East Asia
PPT
5-Presentation Skadar-Shkodra Lake Project_Novak Cajedenovic
PPT
Building Environmental Citizenship to Support Transboundary Pollution Reducti...
PPT
Achievements and results of pilot projects, results and scaling-up
PPTX
Corporate Engagement in Water Stewardship
PPT
Public Participation in transboundary issues in the Republic of Moldova (Ilya...
PPT
Applying an ecosystem-based approach to fisheries management: focus on seamou...
PPTX
Geonode Presentation (ppt)
PPTX
HCLME Private Sector Added Value for Partnership
PPT
Slovenia: Danube River Basin EBRD/GEF Environmental Credit Facility
PPT
Lake Manzala Engineered Wetland, Port Said, Egypt [IWC4 Presentation]
PPT
Global Nitrogen Cycle, Eutrophication, and Coastal Hypoxia: State of Knowledg...
Supporting Private Investment in Infrastructure Finance
First GEF Regional Project in the Mediterranean (Civili) [IWC4 Presentation]
Global Response to BW Issue: Can GEF be a Catalyst for Legal Reforms
Valuing Recreation/Amenity Benefits: Travel Costs, CVM, and Hedonics
From Diye to Value of Statistical Life: A Case Study for the Islamic Republi...
2007 Black Sea TDA
Pissierssens - International Oceanographic Data and Information Exchange Pres...
Pollution Reduction Revloving Fund for the LMEs of East Asia
5-Presentation Skadar-Shkodra Lake Project_Novak Cajedenovic
Building Environmental Citizenship to Support Transboundary Pollution Reducti...
Achievements and results of pilot projects, results and scaling-up
Corporate Engagement in Water Stewardship
Public Participation in transboundary issues in the Republic of Moldova (Ilya...
Applying an ecosystem-based approach to fisheries management: focus on seamou...
Geonode Presentation (ppt)
HCLME Private Sector Added Value for Partnership
Slovenia: Danube River Basin EBRD/GEF Environmental Credit Facility
Lake Manzala Engineered Wetland, Port Said, Egypt [IWC4 Presentation]
Global Nitrogen Cycle, Eutrophication, and Coastal Hypoxia: State of Knowledg...
Ad

Similar to Increase in understanding of environmental status and functioning of the BS ecosystem (20)

PDF
Study of Temporal Trends of Pollution in the Russian Coastal Areas of the Bla...
PPT
preynolds_blacksearecovery.ppt
PDF
Diversity and abundance of Macrobenthos in a subtropical estuary, Bangladesh
PPT
Benthic fauna of the inner part of ariake
PPT
Seagrasses of Red Sea
PDF
B.28.2357
PDF
A field assessment on karnafully river estuarine ecology
PDF
Ayoon & Sulayao.pdf rerererererercrecre
PDF
Ijciet 10 01_187
PDF
Distribution of zooplankton community in Toli shad (Tenualosa toli) habitats,...
PPTX
Presentation1
PDF
Zooplankton species composition and diversity in the seagrass habitat of Lawa...
PPT
PPTX
Pengantar Planktology bab pendahuluan dan pengantar
PDF
Study of Zooplankton Abundance and Species Diversity in Shahjangi Pond of Bha...
PDF
1996 hossainfs62 350 (2)
PDF
Marine Biodiversity Patterns And Processes Assessment Threats Management And ...
PPTX
Msc_Marine_Environment_2022.pptx
PPTX
Msc_Marine_Environment_2022 - Copy.pptx
PPTX
Marine water
Study of Temporal Trends of Pollution in the Russian Coastal Areas of the Bla...
preynolds_blacksearecovery.ppt
Diversity and abundance of Macrobenthos in a subtropical estuary, Bangladesh
Benthic fauna of the inner part of ariake
Seagrasses of Red Sea
B.28.2357
A field assessment on karnafully river estuarine ecology
Ayoon & Sulayao.pdf rerererererercrecre
Ijciet 10 01_187
Distribution of zooplankton community in Toli shad (Tenualosa toli) habitats,...
Presentation1
Zooplankton species composition and diversity in the seagrass habitat of Lawa...
Pengantar Planktology bab pendahuluan dan pengantar
Study of Zooplankton Abundance and Species Diversity in Shahjangi Pond of Bha...
1996 hossainfs62 350 (2)
Marine Biodiversity Patterns And Processes Assessment Threats Management And ...
Msc_Marine_Environment_2022.pptx
Msc_Marine_Environment_2022 - Copy.pptx
Marine water

More from Iwl Pcu (20)

PPTX
Flood and Drought Management Tools (IWC8)
PPT
Caribbean Wastewater - Innovative Solutions (IWC8)
PPT
Large Marine Ecosystems: Megaregional Best Practices for LME Assessment and M...
PPTX
Understanding the audience (IWC8)
PPTX
Effective slide designing
PPTX
How to communicate science effectively (IWC8 Presentation)
PPTX
Presentation vs Publication
PPTX
Introduction to Nutrient Roundtable (IWC8)
PPTX
GEF Oceanic Fisheries Management Project – Towards Transformation Change (IWC...
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 1
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 10
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 10
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 9
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 7
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 6
PPTX
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
Flood and Drought Management Tools (IWC8)
Caribbean Wastewater - Innovative Solutions (IWC8)
Large Marine Ecosystems: Megaregional Best Practices for LME Assessment and M...
Understanding the audience (IWC8)
Effective slide designing
How to communicate science effectively (IWC8 Presentation)
Presentation vs Publication
Introduction to Nutrient Roundtable (IWC8)
GEF Oceanic Fisheries Management Project – Towards Transformation Change (IWC...
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 1
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 10
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 10
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 9
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 7
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 6
TDA/SAP Methodology Training Course Module 2 Section 5

Increase in understanding of environmental status and functioning of the BS ecosystem

  • 1. 15 Years of UNDP/GEF in the Black Sea Region, Final Seminar, 14-15 February 2008, Istanbul
  • 2. Zoobenthos (1) Macro- and meio-benthos Standardised macro-methods manual Excellent overview of data analysis options in research cruise reports and Todorova & Konsulova presentation (univariate and multivariate approaches) Ecological indices represent the best forward for result presentation
  • 3. Zoobenthos (2) No. of species distribution:
  • 7. Zoobenthos (6) Zoobenthos is not evenly distributed over short distances. Thus: •Both abundance and biomass of individual species vary substantially between replicates •The total number of species can vary greatly between replicates •30 nautical miles offshore of Constanta, the number of macrozoobenthos species varied between 5 and 14 in individual replicates, with a total number of 25 species in 5 replicates WARNIN G
  • 8. Phyllophora field (1) The Phyllophora field once provided a habitat for 118 species of invertebrates and 47 species of fish In 1964, 32 macro-algal species were recorded, but this had halved by 1986 3 years later only a quarter of the species recorded in the 1960s were present However, in 2004, a slight increase in macroalgal species numbers was recorded when compared to the 1989 situation
  • 9. Phyllophora field (2) 1979 2002 Shading by phytoplankton
  • 10. Phyllophora field (3) Sediment deposition rates - Danube Prodelta 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 1960 1962 1964 1966 1968 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 T,mlntons 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 CRSMAR,gcm-2 y-1 Sediment Discharge 3y AVG Annual Sediment Discharge CRS MAR
  • 12. Phyllophora field (5) Relatively low levels of zoobenthos occur in the Phyllophora field, but often with a high number of species, particularly of macrozoobenthos While one species dominates, this dominance is much less complete than in the other polygons and indicative of higher biodiversity Large numbers of ascidians actively process high organic flux from water column, preventing sediment enrichment
  • 13. Phyllophora field (6) Originally Phyllophora nervosa dominated Phyllophora brodiaei in southern part of field, but rarely dominant. Ph. pseudoceranoides has not been recorded since 1989 Now filamentous reds (Polysiphonia) and greens (Ectocarpus, Desmarestia) cover 70-80% bed Phyllophora (and other seaweeds) reduce internal loading of nutrients
  • 14. Plankton Manuals written; equipment provided Plankton populations change quickly (on a seasonal basis) Participating scientists asked to present results in relation to long-term monitoring data Phytoplankton biomass and abundance have been on a decreasing trend since the early 1990s Species richness and other univariate indices are in favour of the “recovery phase” of the NW Black Sea ecosystem
  • 16. Phytoplankton (2) However, the dominance of mixotrophic/ heterotrophic dinoflagellates strongly resembles the “eutrophication phase” Concern over colonisation by invasive species (Alexandrium cysts – 2006) In the 1960s, the phytoplankton population was dominated by diatoms and dinoflagellates Now “others” constitute a much greater proportion – the ecology is changing
  • 17. Zooplankton (1) Two patterns of vertical distribution: •Maximum close to the thermocline where Noctiluca dominates •Maximum in surface waters Copepods, Cladocera, Meroplankton, Appendicularia and Chaetognatha predominate in Northern Shelf waters Further south, Noctiluca dominates Improved diversity in northern (Ukrainian) waters Mnemiopsis/Beroe battle continues
  • 18. Zooplankton (2) Long-term summer abundance of Cladocera and Copepoda (Cape Galata):
  • 19. Nutrients and Fluxes (1) Annual water transport across the shelf/open sea boundary: 0 4 8 1 2 m o n t h s 8 0 1 0 0 1 2 0 1 4 0 volume
  • 20. Nutrients and Fluxes (2) Annual water transport across the shelf/open sea boundary: Peaks in October
  • 21. Nutrients and Fluxes (3) Annual DIN fluxes across the shelf/open sea boundary: Ammonium Nitrate Nitrite
  • 22. Nutrients and Fluxes (4) Surface trackers following anticyclonic eddy: A= Release point B = Cape Kaliakra C = fishing vessel route
  • 23. Nutrients and Fluxes (5) The nitrate maximum defines the oxycline boundary in deep regions of the Sea Phosphate conc’s increase within the oxycline and the upper suboxic zone Surface conc’s low, but may be locally elevated