Investigation on Natural Circulation Loop with Nanofluid

G.Narendar et al. Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN: 2248-9622, Vol. 6, Issue 3, (Part - 2) March 2016, pp.53- 58
www.ijera.com 53 | P a g e
Investigation on Natural Circulation Loop with Nanofluid
G.Narendar*
, A.V.S.S. Kumara Swami Gupta**
, A.Krishnaiah*
*Department of Mechanical Engineering, Osmania University, Hyderabad, India
**Department of Mechanical Engineering, Jawaharlal Nehru Technological University Hyderabad, Hyderabad,
India
I. INTRODUCTION
The primary function of a natural
circulation loop is to transport heat from a heat
source to a heat sink. The advantage of the natural
circulation system is that the heat transport function
is achieved without the aid of any pump. The
absence of rotating parts/mechanical parts to
generate fluid circulation makes it less prone to
failures; thereby the maintenance and operating costs
are reduced.
A heat source, a heat sink and the connecting
pipes form the natural circulation loop. In the natural
circulation loops, the heat sink is located above the
heat source to promote natural circulation. The pipes
are connected to the source and sink in such a way
that it forms a continuous circulation path. When the
working fluid is filled in to the loop and by
supplying heat in to the heat source the NCL is
activated. With both the heat source and heat sink
conditions maintained constant, a steady loop fluid
circulation takes place.
Natural circulation is a phenomenon which
occurs in a fluid in the presence of temperature and
density gradients in a fluid field. The motive force
for the fluid circulation is generated within the loop
simply because of the presence of a heat source and
a heat sink maintained at different temperatures. Due
to this natural circulation loops find several
engineering applications such as solar water heaters,
transformer cooling, geothermal heat extraction,
natural circulation boilers, electronic device cooling
and heat extraction from nuclear reactor cores etc.
Nanofluids are fluids in which
nanoparticles are thoroughly dispersed in base
fluids. The base fluids may be water, ethylene
glycol, lubricating oil etc., and nanoparticles are
carbon nanotubes, metal oxides, metal nanoparticles,
etc. Nanofluids are having unique properties hence
they find many engineering applications.
Nanofluids are used for several industrial and
research applications because of their improved
properties in thermal, electrical, chemical and optical
fields. Higher surface-to-volume ratio of
nanoparticles enhances their chemical and thermal
properties. The thermal conductivity is high at
nanolevel compared to bulk material form. Hence,
this feature can be used in thermal systems to
enhance heat exchange process. When nanoparticles
are mixed with base fluid and properly sonicated, the
dispersed nanoparticles will float without settlement
for months together, will become a good thermal
fluid for increased heat transfer capability and the
thermal systems can be made compact by reducing
the size for the same heat loads.
The performance of natural circulation loop
can be improved with the use of nanofluids.
Increase in thermal conductivity is the key idea to
improve the heat transfer characteristics of the fluids
in NCL. Extensive research is going on across
research community on the usage of nanofluids to
enhance heat transfer in natural circulation loops and
in the heat exchange devices, so that lower driving
force, higher heat transfer can be achieved for the
same heat load, and thereby the size of the heat
exchange devices can be reduced.
RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS
ABSTRACT
Natural circulation loops transport heat from a heat source to a heat sink by natural convection process and
without the aid of pumps to circulate loop fluid to transport the heat. A vertically placed circular pipe loop is
equipped with two heat exchangers placed at its lower end and top end for heating and cooling of the loop
fluid respectively forms the Natural circulation loop. The fluid circulation is the result of buoyancy forces,
which in turn is the result of the density differences induced by the temperature differences existing in the
heat source and sink.
Investigation is carried out with loop fluid as distilled water alone and also with 0.25% concentration of CuO
nanofluids as loop fluid at various temperatures of heat source. It is observed that natural circulation flow
rates are enhanced with the use of nanofluid than with distilled water alone and also with increasing
temperature of hot fluid entering into the heat source.
Key words:- Natural circulation loop, nanofluid, hot end heat exchanger, cold end heat exchanger.

The working of Natural circulation loops,
functions and their advantages to transport heat from
a heat source to a heat sink is described by Vijayan
et al [1]. In this study, authors explained the natural
circulation phenomenon and application of the
principle in systems like natural circulation loops,
transformer cooling, solar water heaters, cooling of
engines and gas turbine blades, and nuclear reactor
cores. Authors also described that Nuclear power
plants use natural circulation as a means to remove
core power during normal operation.
Misale [2] addressed the issues like the problem
of the stability of the loops, which is of interest in
many industrial applications. The review
concentrated on the experimental aspects that could
be interesting in the study of the natural circulation
systems. In particular, the aspects related to natural
circulation loop were discussed viz., applications of
natural circulation loops, models, influence of loop
size and thermo-hydraulic behaviour. Author
suggested for single-phase NCLs, the
instrumentation should be able to measure the
velocity and the temperature of the fluid without
causing disturbance to the fluid movement. The
suggested measuring devices are Magnetic flow
meter, Ultrasound Pulsed Doppler Velocimetry etc.
Author also explained that the thermo-hydraulic
behaviour of a single-phase natural circulation loop
depends on interaction between the fluid properties,
material utilised to construct the loop, heaters and
coolers displacement and numbers, horizontal
parallel channels used new nuclear reactors, loop
inclination and the properties of loop fluid.
Experimental investigation is carried out on a
rectangular single-phase natural circulation mini-
loop by Misale, et al [3]. The preliminary results
show a stable flow rate with a steady temperature
difference across the heat sinks. It has been
confirmed that the fluid velocity in the mini loop is
very small (order of millimetres per second). The
effect of power transferred to the fluid and loop
inclination has been systematically investigated.
The process of natural circulation mechanism
which occurs due to density gradients inside a fluid
is investigated by Misale et al. [4]. They conducted
experiments on the thermal performance of a mini-
loop. They used two working fluids during the tests:
distilled water and alumina nanofluid characterized
by two different concentrations. They analyzed
mini-loop inclination, power transferred to the fluid,
and temperature at the cooler.
Natural circulation loop with the use of
nanofluids is experimentally investigated by Nayak
et al. [5] in which the loop was heated with electric
heating coil wire which was wrapped around
uniformly on the outer surface of the glass tube in
the bottom horizontal leg. They found that not only
the flow instabilities are suppressed but also the
natural circulation flow rate is increased. The
increase in steady natural circulation flow rate due to
addition of nanoparticles is found to be a function of
its concentration in base fluid. The flow instabilities
are found to occur with water alone only during a
sudden power addition from cold state condition,
step increase in power addition and step decrease in
power. With addition of small concentration of
nanoparcticles in the working fluid, these
instabilities in the flow are found to be suppressed
significantly.
The influence of pressure drops on the behavior
of a single phase natural circulation loop is
investigated by Misale et al. [6]. Two experimental
loops were constructed with different diameters but
same length/diameter ratio is maintained. The
natural circulation loop showed unstable behavior.
In order to stabilize the loop, two orifices of
different diameters were placed in the vertical legs.
Stabilising effect of pressure drops on the overall
behavior of the loop is observed. But it may lead to
reduction in flow rate.
Experimental work on single-phase natural
circulation loop is conducted by Misale et al. [7]
and the effect of loop inclination and tube wall
thermal conductivity were investigated. The
experiments were conducted analysing the
interaction between the pipe material and properties
of liquid as well as the inclination of the loop.
In this paper, the performance of NCL is
presented. The NCL is designed with hot water
supply into the bottom hot end heat exchanger i.e.
heat source of the natural circulation loop and loop
fluid is taken as distilled water alone and CuO
nanofluid .
II. METHODOLOGY
In the present investigation, nanofluid was
prepared by dispersing CuO nanoparticles of 0.25%
by weight which was used as loop fluid in NCL. The
nanofluid of CuO was prepared for the above stated
percentage using probe sonication process. The
schematic diagram of Natural circulation loop is
shown in figure 1. For the performance evaluation of
natural circulation loop, the flow rate of loop fluid,
total flow and temperatures in the loop at various
locations etc., were recorded in the experiments.
These parameters were used in determining the heat
gained by loop fluid, heat rejected by loop fluid in
heat sink and also to find the efficiency of the loop.

FIGURE 1. Schematic diagram of Natural
circulation loop
FIGURE 2. Probe sonicator used for
preparation of CuO nanofluid
Experimental investigation was carried out on
the natural circulation loop using nanofluids (CuO )
and also distilled water alone as loop fluid. During
conduction of the experiments, devices viz., Probe
sonicator, Ultrasonic flow meter, Data logger,
PT100 sensors and Purge rotameters were used.
Nanofluid is prepared using probe sonication
process in which the probe of sonicator is directly
immersed into the nano-particle loaded fluid. The
probe transfers energy in the form of ultrasonic
pulses/waves to the fluid thereby particles are
dispersed. The sonication process is shown in figure
2. With this energy the nanoparicle agglomerations
bursts, particles are dispersed and the fluid is
thoroughly mixed and homogenised. In the
preparation of nanofluid, probe sonicator is used
whose specifications are 20Khz and an Ultrasonic
Power 500 Watts. CuO nanoparticles of average
particle size of 40nm are used in preparation of
nanofluid.
An ultrasonic flow meter is used to measure the
flow rates of loop fluid flow. The sensors of the
Ultrasonic flow meter are connected at a specified
distance on the outer periphery of the pipe through
which the loop fluid is flowing. The sensors do not
interfere the flowing fluid hence flow is not
disturbed. The sensors connected to the riser of NCL
are shown in figure 3.The other ends of the sensors
are connected to the ultrasonic flow meter. The flow
rates can be directly read on the digital display
screen of the flow meter. Through RS232 port, the
instrument is connected to a computer for recording
the data continuously.
FIGURE 3. Data logger and Ultrasonic flow meter
FIGURE 4. Experimental setup
During conduction of experiments at a
particular temperature of heat source, a constant
temperature water supply is required which is
supplied by a constant temperature water bath. The
bath is insulated and the piping is also properly
insulated to prevent heat losses and to maintain a
constant temperature water supply into the NCL.
The experimental setup is shown in figure 4.
III. RESULTS
Experiments were carried out first with
distilled water as loop fluid and later, CuO nanofluid
of 0.25% by weight concentration was placed as
loop fluid. The heat source at the bottom of the NCL
was supplied with hot water from constant
temperature water bath at desired temperatures
(50°C, 60°C, 70°C, 80°C and 90°C) during the tests,
so that the required temperature was maintained in
the heat source. The heat will be transported by loop
fluid from the heat source at the bottom of the NCL
to the heat sink at the top of the loop. For various
heat source temperatures, performance of the NCL
was investigated for various loop fluids.

3.1 Experimentation with distilled water as loop
fluid
In the first part of experimental investigation
on the effect of varying the temperature of heat
source of NCL using distilled water as loop fluid
was carried out. The heat source temperatures
considered were 500
C, 600
C, 700
C, 800
C and 900
C.
The parameters such as flow rate, velocity, total
flow, temperatures at various locations of NCL are
recorded and these observations are used to calculate
heat given up by heat source, heat extracted by loop
fluid from the heat source, heat rejected by loop
fluid in the CEHE, the heat gained by circulating
water in the heat sink (CEHE) and finally, the
efficiency of natural circulation loop.
The plots for temperature variation and for
loop fluid flow in the loop were prepared for
different heat source temperatures. Typical plots are
presented when heat source temperature was kept
constant at 700
C is shown in figure 5 and figure 6.
Similar plots are obtained for other temperatures.
FIGURE 5. Variation of velocity of loop fluid
(distilled water) with Temperature of heat source
kept at 700
C.
FIGURE 6. Temperature variation at various
locations of NCL with time for loop fluid as
distilled water while heat source temperature kept at
700
C
From the experiments, it is observed that
the efficiency of the NCL for distilled water as loop
fluid is reached to a maximum value at 800
C and
further increase in temperature of hot water supply
into the heat source, the efficiency is found to be
slowly decreasing. This is due to the change in
properties of loop fluid at higher temperatures and
increased heat losses.
3.2 Experimentation with Cuo Nanofluid as loop
fluid
With varying the temperature of hot water
supplied into the hot end heat exchanger i.e. heat
source of the NCL, the parameters such as flow rate,
velocity, total flow, loop fluid temperatures at
various locations of NCL are observed and recorded
for CuO nanofluid of 0.25% concentration as loop
fluid. These observations are used to calculate heat
given up by heat source, heat extracted by loop fluid
from the heat source, heat rejected by loop fluid in
the cold end heat exchanger, heat gained by
circulating water in the cold end heat exchanger and
finally, the efficiency of natural circulation loop.
The variation of loop fluid flow rate and
temperature of NCL at various locations for CuO
nanofluid as loop fluid are shown in the figure 7
through figure 8 for heat source temperature kept
constant at 700
C. similar plots are obtained for other
temperatures.
FIGURE 7. Variation of temperatures of NCL with
Time for 0.25% CuO Nanofluid with Temperature
of heat source at 700
C
FIGURE 8. Variation of loop fluid velocity with
time for 0.25 % CuO nanofluid with Temperature of
heat source at 700
C
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0
150
300
450
600
750
900
1050
1200
1350
1500
1650
1800
Velocity(m/s)
Time (s)
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0
160
320
480
640
800
960
1120
1280
1440
1600
1760
Velocity(m/s)
Time (s)

FIGURE 9. Variation of Flow rate with
temperature of heat source for water and CuO
Nanofluid
FIGURE 10. Variation of Efficiency with
temperature of heat source for water and CuO
Nanofluid
Variation of loop fluid flow at different heat
source temperatures is shown in figure 9. The
performance of NCL was investigated at various
temperatures of hot water supplied into the hot end
heat exchanger i.e. heat source and for distilled
water alone and with 0.25% wt concentration of
CuO nanofluid as loop fluid. Variation of
Efficiencies with temperature of heat source for
water and CuO Nanofluid is shown in figure 10.
From the experiments, it is observed that the
efficiency of the NCL is reached to a maximum
value at 800
C and further increase in temperature of
hot water supply into the heat source, the efficiency
is found to be slowly decreasing. This is due to the
change in properties of loop fluid at higher
temperatures and heat losses at higher temperatures.
IV. CONCLUSIONS
In the present investigation, the performance of
Natural Circulation Loop with loop fluid as water
alone and also with CuO nanofluid with
concentrations of 0.25% by weight has been
investigated for various temperatures (500
C, 600
C,
700
C, 800
C and 900
C) of heat source of the NCL.
From the experimental investigation, the following
conclusions are drawn.
∑ Stabilization of loop fluid circulation is achieved
with the introduction of Nanofluid in the loop.
The fluctuations in the circulation of loop fluid
are of decreasing order with the addition of
nanofluid. The enhancement of flow rate in the
loop is encountered with the increase of
temperature of heat source.
∑ With the increase in temperature of hot water
supply into the hot end heat exchanger i.e. heat
source temperature, the efficiency of loop is
observed to increase for both distilled water as
well as Nanofluid as loop fluid but the rate of
increase in efficiency is higher with Nanofluids as
loop fluid when compared to distilled water.
∑ When temperature of HEHE is increased beyond
800
C it is observed that the efficiency of the loop
is slowly decreased due to high temperature
effect on properties of nanofluid.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to acknowledge and express
sincere thanks to the OU-DST-PURSE Program for
supporting the project.
REFERENCES
[1]. P.K. Vijayan and A.K. Nayak, Natural
circulation in water cooled nuclear power
plants: phenomena, models, and
methodology for System reliability
assessments, Conference Proceedings of
International Atomic Energy Agency,
November 2005, pp89-99.
[2]. Mario Misale, Overview on single-phase
natural circulation loops, Proc. of the Intl.
Conf. on Advances in Mechanical and
Automation Engineering – MAE 2014.
[3]. M. Misale, P. Garibaldi, J.C. Passos, G.
Ghisi de Bitencourt, Experiments in a
single-phase natural circulation mini-loop,
Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science 31
(2007) 1111–1120.
[4]. M. Misale, F. Devia, P. Garibaldi,
Experiments with Al2O3 nanofluid in a
single-phase natural circulation mini-loop:
Preliminary results, Applied Thermal
Engineering 40 (2012) 64-70.
[5]. A.K. Nayak, M.R. Gartia, P.K. Vijayan,
Thermal–hydraulic characteristics of a
single-phase natural circulation loop with
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
50 60 70 80 90
Flowrate(lpm)
Temperature (deg C)
Water 0.25P
0
20
40
60
80
100
50 60 70 80 90
Efficiency(%)
Temperature (0C)
water 0.25%

water and Al2O3 nanofluids, Nuclear
Engineering and Design 239 (2009) 526–
540.
[6]. M. Misale, M. Frogheri. Stabilization of a
single-phase natural circulation loop by
pressure drops, Experimental Thermal and
Fluid Science 25 (2001) 277–282.
[7]. Mario Misale, Francesco Devia, Pietro
Garibaldi, Some considerations on the
interaction between the fluid and wall tube
during experiments in a single-phase
natural circulation loops, Proceedings of the
3rd IASME/WSEAS Int. Conf. on Heat
Transfer, Thermal Engineering and
Environment, Corfu, Greece, August 20-22,
2005 (pp128-133) N.M. Rao, Steady-state
performance of a two-phase natural
circulation loop, International
Communications in Heat and Mass
Transfer 33 (2006) 1042–1052
[8]. N.M. Rao, Dynamic performance of a
natural circulation loop with end heat
exchangers under different excitations,
International Journal of Heat and Mass
Transfer 48 (2005) 3185–3196.
[9]. Pierre Welander (1967). On the oscillatory
instability of a differentially heated fluid
loop. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 29, pp
17-30.
[10]. Vijayan P.K .and Austregesilo H., Scaling
laws for single-phase natural circulation
loops, Nucl. Eng. Design, vol. 152, pp. 331-
334, 1994.
[11]. Tzeng, S., Lin, C., Huang, K., Heat
Transfer Enhancement of Nano Fluids in
Rotary Balde Coupling of Four Wheel
Drive Vehicles, Acta Mechanica, vol. 179,
no. 1, pp. 11-23, 2005.
[12]. Vijayan P.K., Nayak A.K., Experimental
validation and data base of simple loop
facilities, International Atomic Energy
Agency, Nuclear Power Technology
Development Section, Vienna (Austria), pp.
383-413.
[13]. Jaafar Albadr, Satinder Tayal a, Mushtaq
Alasadi, Heat transfer through heat
exchanger using Al2O3 nanofluid at
different concentrations, Case Studies in
Thermal Engineering 1 (2013) 38–44.
[14]. C.T. Nguyen, F. Desgranges, N. Galanis, G.
Roy, T. Mare, S. Boucher, H.A. Mintsa,
Viscosity data for Al2O3–water nanofluid-
hysteresis: is heat transfer enhancement
using nanofluids reliable?, International
Journal of Thermal Sciences 47 (2008)
103–111.

Investigation on Natural Circulation Loop with Nanofluid

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to Investigation on Natural Circulation Loop with Nanofluid (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Investigation on Natural Circulation Loop with Nanofluid