IRJET- Comparative Study of Maximum Power Point Techniques

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 05 Issue: 11 | Nov 2018 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
© 2018, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.211 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 413
Comparative Study of Maximum Power Point Techniques
Chinmay Sharma1, Prakash Bahrani2
1,2Aravali Institute of Technical Studies, Rajasthan, India
----------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - This paper aimed to study the behavior of different
maximum power point tracking (MPPT) techniquesappliedto
PV systems. In this work, techniques such as incremental
conductance (INC), perturb-and-observe (P&O), and fuzzy
logic controller (FLC) are assessed. The response of the
different MPPT techniques is evaluated in rapidly changing
weather conditions. The results indicate that, INC performed
best among compared MPPT techniques followed by P&O, FLC
and HC MPPT techniques in both dynamic response and
steady-state in most of the normal operating range.
Keywords: photovoltaic (PV), Incremental conductance
(INC), perturb-and-observe(P&O),andfuzzylogic controller
(FLC)
1. INTRODUCTION
Solar PV array has many advantages and disadvantages
such as Solar PV systems operate differently than solar
thermal ones. Solar PV system actually generates free
electricity while solar thermal systems heat up your water.
Though the feed-in tariff has changed quite a bit since it was
introduced, solar PV systems are still a great investment
because they substantially lower your electric bill .Theprice
of solar panels has gone down by 45 percent or more, which
makes the entire system much more affordable. Solar
photovoltaic systems require daylight and so will work in
days when the sun is not shining. All you need is light to
create energy, so although the effectiveness of the solar PV
array will be less when the sun is covered by clouds, it will
still generate some electricity. Utilizing solar power helps
lower your electric bills because you are generating some of
the electricity you use. Some systems can generate as much
as 40 percent of the electricity you use on an annual basis.
There is very little maintenance involved in owning a solar
PV system. Just make sure that you purchase the system
from a company with a solid reputation so that you know
you are buying quality panels and a good aftercare service
.The feed-in tariff is designed to increase the amountofsolar
power being utilized in the UK, but it also makes the
installation of solar PV systems look even more attractive to
home and business owners .By usinggreenenergyinsteadof
fossil fuels, you are doing what you can to protect the
environment. Our world’s fossil fuel reserves are rapidly
decreasing, so we will have to find alternative fuels soon.
Solar PV panels provide a green way to produce electricity.
The disadvantages are such as Solar PV panels are more
expensive than panels designed for solar thermal energy.
However, they do a lot more for your home or business than
solar thermal panels do, and there are some incentives and
grants to help pay for them .You needanadequateroofspace
to display your solar PV panels. The larger the panel
covering the more the electricity generated .Solar PV panels
may not be a viable green energy option for be used. Other
font types may be used if needed for special purposes.
Your home or business if you have a predominantly north or
east facing roof or if tall buildings and/or trees place your
roof in the shade during the day.
2. STUDY OF MAXIMUM POWER POINT TRACKING
TECHNIQUES
For a long term and sustainable supply of energy, it is
essential to exploit and utilize the renewable sources at a
much larger scale. Among the renewables, the solar
photovoltaic (PV) is expected to be among the most
prominent due to its abundance, ease of installation and
almost maintenance free. In addition, it is considered as
green energy and thus addresses the concerns over the
environment Photovoltaic (PV) array is usually an essential
part of PV systems. In general, PV generation systems have
two major Problems: the conversion efficiency of electric
power generation is low(ingeneral lessthan17%,especially
under low irradiation conditions) and the amountof electric
power generated by solar arrays changes continuously with
weather conditions. Moreover, the solar cell (current-
voltage) characteristic is non-linear and varies with
irradiation and temperature. There is a unique point on the
I-V or (power-voltage) curve of the solararraycalledMPP, at
which the entire PV system operates with maximum
efficiency and produces its maximum output power. The
location of the MPP is not known, but can be located, either
through calculation models, or by search algorithms.
Therefore MPPT techniques are needed to maintain the PV
array’s operating point at its MPP. However, due to the low
conversion efficiency of the PV modules, the cost of solar
power is still higher relative to the fossil fuel. One effective
way to increase the efficiency is to improve its maximum
power point tracking (MPPT) algorithm. Since the MPPT
comprises of software codes, thisapproachappearsto bethe
most economical waytoenhancethe energy throughput. The
function of MPPT is to ensure that the operating voltage and
current always stay at the maximum power point (MPP) on
the P-V characteristic curve. To date, numerous MPPT
techniques are reported, they are broadly classifiedintotwo
categories, namely the conventional and soft computing
approach. The most popular conventional MPPT are the
perturb and observe (P&O), hill climbing and incremental
conductance. These algorithms are widely used in

commercial products—mainly due to their simplicity and
robustness. On the other hand, soft computing based MPPT
such as artificial neural network, fuzzy logic, differential
evolution, particle swarm optimization and cuckoo search
tend to be more versatile and flexible. Despite exhibiting
better steady state performance, they are much slower and
in practice, are not as acceptable.
Among the conventional MPPT, P&O is the simplest and
exhibits very good convergence. However, the algorithm
suffers from two serious drawbacks. First is the continuous
oscillation that occurs around the MPP. Second, the P&O is
prone to lose its tracking direction when the irradiance (G)
increases rapidly. Both problems contributes to the loss of
power and hence reducedtrackingefficiency.Althoughthere
exists several works that address the oscillation issue using
the adaptive P&O schemes, none has comprehensively
address the loss of tracking direction. Notwithstandinghave
introduced several solutions to address thesetwoproblems.
However, the methods are limited for specific conditions as
shall be discussed in Section II. Withthishindsight,thiswork
proposes a more comprehensive modification to the P&O,
with the aim to solve both problems simultaneously. The
modified algorithm maintains a similar structure to the
conventional P&O, but it incorporates a unique dynamic
perturbation to decrease the oscillation, whilemaintaininga
reasonable convergence time. In addition, the method
introduces boundary conditions on the P-V curve that
prevents the operating point from being diverged
(uncontrollably) from the MPP.
Another issue that has been neglected is the performance
benchmarking of the MPPT algorithms. In almost all
publications, the P&O are tested against very simple
irradiance profiles—which in most cases do not reflect the
Conditions that occur inthereal environment.Consequently,
the margin of improvement between the conventional and
adaptive P&O is not very significant. In this work, the
conventional as well as the modified P&O is
comprehensivelybenchmarkedusingtheEN 50530dynamic
MPPT efficiency test. This test is very rigorous asitdemands
the algorithm to track a set of irradiancerampswithvariable
rate of change. The results for theconventional andmodified
P&O is compared side by side and the performance
enhancement due to the proposed method is clarified.
3. FUTURE SCOPE
As well know that distributed computing is the latest trend
in all the fields. They are more widely used all over the
world. As there are many positives from this, there are also
certain aspects that might make distributed computing a
menace to the world. The main issues regardingthismenace
will be the security issue. Which is to be implemented very
strongly such that, the systems are protected from whatever
the attack, it might get even in the upcoming future.
4. CONCLUSIONS
The use of solar energy is essential for providingsolutions to
the environmental problems and also energy demand. The
vast development to improve the efficiency by the MPPT
algorithms encouraged the domestic generation of power
using solar panels. The available MPPT techniques based on
the number of control variables involved, types of control
strategies, circuitry, and applications are possibly useful for
selecting an MPPT technique for a particular application for
grid tied or standalone mode of operations. This review has
included many recent hybrid MPPT techniques along with
their benefits for mismatched conditions such as partial
shading, nonuniformity of PV panel temperatures, and dust
effects.
It is observed that Perturbation and Observation and
Incremental Conductance methods are simple and used by
many researches, but they have the slow tracking and low
utilization efficiency. To overcome the drawbacks,fuzzyand
neural network techniques are used in the present days by
which the efficiency is increased. To boost up the voltage
various DC-DC converters are used along with battery
storage systems in order to store the excessive energy from
solar PV panel. The DC link voltage oscillations in the grid
connected PV system can be obtained by using Cuk
converters, SEPIC converters, and Zeta converters with
reducing current ripple injected in the PV array and load.
The harmonic content is reduced from the output of DC-DC
converters using the filter circuits. The passive filters as LC,
LCL, and LLCC are used for harmonic distortion as well as to
improve the power quality. Filter capacitors are used to
reduce high frequency current ripple.
This DC is again fed to the inverter for converting the DC to
AC with various PWM techniques. These PWM inverter
techniques yield the better AC outputs which are used to
connect the grid interconnections and standalone AC loads.
Multilevel inverters with sinusoidal PWM and SVM are used
to reduce the harmonics in the load voltage even in low
switching frequency. Grid tied inverterswithbattery backup
are preferred in hybrid systems for backup even if the grid
goes down for both grid tied and off grid systems.
5. REFERENCES
[1]S. Lee, J.-E. Kim, and H. Cha, “Design and implementation
of photovoltaic power conditioning system using a current-
based maximum power point tracking,” Journal of Electrical
Engineering & Technology, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 606–613, 2010
[2]C. Hua and C. Shen, “Control ofDC/DCconvertersforsolar
energy system with maximum power tracking,”
in Proceedings of the 23rd Annual International Conference
on Industrial Electronics, Control, and Instrumentation
(IECON '97), pp. 827–832, November 1997.

[3]A. H. M. Nordin and A. M. Omar, “Modeling and simulation
of photovoltaic (PV) array and maximum power point
tracker (MPPT) for grid-connected PV system,”
in Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium and
Exhibition in Sustainable Energy and Environment (ISESEE
'11), pp. 114–119, June 2011
[4]R. L. Carletti, L. C. G. Lopes, and P. G. Barbosa, “Active and
reactive power control scheme for a grid-connected
photovoltaic generation system based on VSI with selective
harmonic elimination,” in Proceedings of the 8th Brazilian
Power Electronics Conference, pp. 1–8, 2005
[5]HASAN, K. N.; et al. An improved maximum power point
tracking technique for the photovoltaic modulewithcurrent
mode control. In: AUPEC, 19, 2009, p. 1-6.
[6] LI, W.; et al. A Smart and Simple PV Charger for Portable
Applications. In: APEC, 25, 2010, p. 2080-2084.

IRJET- Comparative Study of Maximum Power Point Techniques

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to IRJET- Comparative Study of Maximum Power Point Techniques (20)

More from IRJET Journal (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

IRJET- Comparative Study of Maximum Power Point Techniques