GOOD AFTERNOON
RURAL DEVELOPMENT

     BIODIVERSITY

   PUBLIC POLICIES

Challenges and conflicts
Building the concept of development...
                                             green
                  Ecological Development     economy




   Growth        Sustainable
                 Development




  Progress                     LOGIC BEHIND THE
                                  METHODS



                                            From a DYNAMIC
              From a STATIC point
                                             point of view, to
             of view, it leads to the
                                             innovation that
                idea of efficiency
                                           increases efficiency   Furtado, 1981
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
O Estado de S. Paulo newspaper   (2013/07/16)


• Es
Rural development – LOGIC BEHIND THE METHODS




                                 EXTERNAL FACTORS                    NEW SIGNIFICANCE
                           * Concentration of land ownership
BACKGROUND                 and income                                • Private space vs Public space
• Rural v Urban            * Monoculture
  relationship             * Discrimination and social exclusion     • Production vs Conservation
• Agricultural evolution   * Class struggle
                           * Market model                            • Multifunctional (farming and
• Several Green            * Industrial corporations have taken        landscape)
                           command
  Revolutions
                           * Systemic degradation
                                                                     • GREEN ECONOMY.....
                                          (social – environmental)
The dominant power in the countryside

Diffusionist methodology

 Research is popularizing unsuitable
technologies

 Development of professionals who
are acritical regarding the model –
UNIVERSITIES...
Development           Sustainability



                                               Social




                 Rural
              Development                     Cultural
                             Biodiversity


                                            Environmental
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Sustainability (Utopia)
•   Social
•   Economic
•   Cultural
•   Political
•   Ethical
•   Ecological-Environmental
                        More than 200 definitions !!
New rural significance and attributes

                                                      Public
                                                      Space


                                Private
                                Space

      Multifuncional
                                                                Agroecosystems
                                                                                     ETC
                                       Land



       Agribusiness               Family Farming               Ecosystem Services



       Commodities                 Legislation                                       Green
                                                                   Violence
                                                                                    Economy

       Sustainability         Sovereignty / nutritional
                                      security                    Biotechnology

                                                                                     Agrarian
  Agricultural Biodiversity          Ecological                                      Reform
                                     Economy                      Agroecology
Conceptual framework – Looking for simplification!
                             DISTINCT UNITS OF ANALYSIS
                                 IMPÉRIOS ALIMENTARES E OUTROS



       NO NEED FOR A PHYSICAL
         PRODUCTION UNIT                                         SPECIFIC PRODUCTION UNIT OR
                                                                            ACTIVITY
       agriculture according                                      agriculture according to
        to Capitalist Logic                                            Business Logic




                                   agriculture according to Rural Logic
                                             (variety of forms)
                                AGROECOSYSTEM WITH UNIT OF ANALYSIS

                 State                        Society                     Biodiversity
Figure : (adapted from PLOEG, 2008).
Brazilian
Biomes
Brazilian social ‘mega’ diversity
 More than 200 different indigenous peoples
 Traditional peoples and communities occupy roughly 1/3 of
Brazil’s territory


 Micro-economy based on
forest products

 Knowledge and practices
relating to biodiversity
management

                               Crianças kaxinawás, Feijó, Acre
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Conflicts, degradation and social exclusion

   DEVELOPMENT
         vs
     Social and
Environmental Issues
                         “Public Policies”




                        DEVELOPMENT MODELS /
                               POLICIES
Conservation vs Preservation vs Development


A challenge to
society !!!
For the first
time in Brazil..a
public debate ...
Examples



           Action
           Projects
           Policies...
Development plus Biodiversity:
  Research and outreach at Rural
settlements in the Vale do Ribeira –
         São Paulo state
Management... Is it sustainable ?
Respect, Manage and Coexist with the regional
                          biodiversity




Fruit of the Bromelia pinguin, used to make
                                              Jaguar footprint at the Apiaí settlement
a medicinal syrup.
Farmers participating in the surveying of the biodiversity at the Apiaí
    settlement – training / skill building / participative planning
Agroecological tomato production




                                   Biological pest control – bait (Tajujá
Pontal do Paranapanema- SP
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
State of São Paulo
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Settlement, Santa Zélia, 2010
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Bioenergy plus Biodiversity and
     Nutritional Security



             '''
 A. hassleri
                                                                        A. emensis
                                                                        A. glaucescens
                                                                        A. totai
Source: L.H.C.Berton   Source : L.H.C.Berton   Source : H.Lorenzi
                                                                        A. intumescens
                                                                        A. aculeata




                                                                           Lorenzi, 2010

 Source : H.Lorenzi      Source : H.Lorenzi    Source : L.H.C.Berton
Macaw palm (Acrocomia aculeata)
                                              Bioenergy
-   Native, rustic and abundant
-   Longevity: about 100 years
-   Starts to produce after 3 to 4 years
-   Oil has excellent physical and chemical characteristics
-   Multiple uses: 2 types of oil, 2 types of cake, activated charcoal, integration
-   with livestock and crop farming, agroforestry systems
-   Plantation density: 120 to 400 plants/ha
-   Considerable research efforts and growth in commercial initiatives ;
-   High productivity: 30 t. of biomass/ha and up to 4 t. of oil/ha
-   SOYBEANS - 550 KG/HA OF OIL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!




     36
Estimates of biodiesel production/ha




   Soybean
420 kg.ha.year-1 Sunflower
                   890 kg.ha. year-1 Castor bean
                                  1,320 kg.ha. year-1

 (CESAR, 2003)
 (AMBIENTE, 2005)                                 Macaw palm (average)
 (Berton et al.)                                   4,966 kg.ha. year-1
                                                                         10,926 kg.ha.year-1
In 2,480 fruit,
the individual
mass varied
from 14.8 to
63.6 g
39
     S. Motoike
Sustainable Rural Landscapes

 Production plus Conservation: Family farming
adhering to agrobiodiversity in the far south region
                  of Bahia state




                                      Others....
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Regional Context


              Technology, Wealth and Poverty !

              In an essentially rural region..
6th / 8th year
0 to 6 years
Diagnóstico de conflitos sócio-ambientais em relação à plantações de
árvores; Coord. Anna Fanzeres
Relatório Final; Março 2005
www.ufrrj.br/institutos/if/lmbh
Reactions in the past...
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
?   ?
        ?
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
? ??   ??
     ?



?   ?
BIODIVERSE AGROFORESTRY SYSTEMS

                                      What is
                                    Agroforestry?




    Subsistence             Generation of       Living savings       Community
(nutritional security)     monthly income      (forest products)
                                                                     Investments

                   Restoration and                                 RL + APP +
              Environmental Adaptation                             Landscape
Aiii
Guri..
Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers'  Movement (MST) in Brazil
Cocoa plantation as a theoretical and methodological reference
Thank You

More Related Content

PDF
Modular Ecological Design: A Fruit and Vegetable Polyculture System
PPTX
Vaasu rawat
ZIP
Permaculture: Urban-Rural Regeneration
PPTX
Ecologisch ontwerpen voor onze toekomst
PPTX
Patrice BURGER "Agrécologie, une opportunité pour le développement? Paroles d...
PPTX
Mark shepard restoration agriculture
PDF
Start a Farm in the City
PDF
Ecosystem Investing
Modular Ecological Design: A Fruit and Vegetable Polyculture System
Vaasu rawat
Permaculture: Urban-Rural Regeneration
Ecologisch ontwerpen voor onze toekomst
Patrice BURGER "Agrécologie, une opportunité pour le développement? Paroles d...
Mark shepard restoration agriculture
Start a Farm in the City
Ecosystem Investing

What's hot (10)

PDF
Dr. Angelika Hilbeck - Hotspot Gentechnik: Chancen und Risiken bezüglich Eins...
PDF
Seminar 2 presentation, Project Communicating Biodiversity
PPTX
Reaching food and nutrition security:
PDF
Increasing resilience when undertaking restoration
PDF
Financial Permaculture & Ecosystem Investing
PDF
Carbon Farming: Concepts, Tools & Markets
PPTX
Keynote wg5 wg6_van veenhuizen_resilient cities
PDF
6.4 agri food industry and its unsustainability
PDF
Breeding for Resilience: A Strategy for Organic and Low-Input Farming Systems
PDF
Fao agroforestry working paper
Dr. Angelika Hilbeck - Hotspot Gentechnik: Chancen und Risiken bezüglich Eins...
Seminar 2 presentation, Project Communicating Biodiversity
Reaching food and nutrition security:
Increasing resilience when undertaking restoration
Financial Permaculture & Ecosystem Investing
Carbon Farming: Concepts, Tools & Markets
Keynote wg5 wg6_van veenhuizen_resilient cities
6.4 agri food industry and its unsustainability
Breeding for Resilience: A Strategy for Organic and Low-Input Farming Systems
Fao agroforestry working paper
Ad

Viewers also liked (9)

PDF
Day 1_3. xiaoting hou
PPTX
Day 1. Presentation 4. patrick kipalu
PPTX
Day 2. Co chairs reflections
PPTX
1С-Битрикс: Управление сайтом 11.5
PDF
TFD UNFF AHEG2 ILCF Presentation
PPTX
Investment In Locally Controlled Forestry: Implementation of the Guide
PDF
O-NET วิทย์ 49
PPTX
Iceotope Overview
PPTX
Day 1.Presentation 1. grace wong
Day 1_3. xiaoting hou
Day 1. Presentation 4. patrick kipalu
Day 2. Co chairs reflections
1С-Битрикс: Управление сайтом 11.5
TFD UNFF AHEG2 ILCF Presentation
Investment In Locally Controlled Forestry: Implementation of the Guide
O-NET วิทย์ 49
Iceotope Overview
Day 1.Presentation 1. grace wong
Ad

Similar to Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers' Movement (MST) in Brazil (20)

PPTX
Action plan for changing course in agriculture
PPTX
Farming Systems Ecology Group
PDF
Sustainability in Everyday Life
PDF
Forestcluster ltd bio based economy scenario process
PPTX
From a local experience of minimum till to a strategy for no-til development ...
PPTX
Lecture agrobiodiversity
PDF
Agroecological Transformations: Background and Rationale
PPTX
Agroecology - the need for stakeholder collaboration
PDF
Enhancing the roles of ecosystem services in agriculture: agroecological prin...
 
PPT
TEEB Agriculture and Food
 
PPTX
Agroecology: Principles and Practices
PPTX
Heirloom value as relevant policy belief for agro-biodiversity initiatives
PDF
Biodiversity, Biofuels, Agroforestry and Conservation Agriculture
PDF
Biodiversity, Biofuels, Agroforestry and Conservation Agriculture
PDF
Eko Gea Presentation San Francisco April 2nd 2011 [ZdružLjivostni NačIn]
PDF
Agroecology and Sustainable Development
 
PDF
TEEB Incentive Measures by Patrick ten Brink of IEEP Stromstadt 7 September F...
PPT
Plant Biotechnology and Food Security
PDF
Forests, biodiversity and food security
Action plan for changing course in agriculture
Farming Systems Ecology Group
Sustainability in Everyday Life
Forestcluster ltd bio based economy scenario process
From a local experience of minimum till to a strategy for no-til development ...
Lecture agrobiodiversity
Agroecological Transformations: Background and Rationale
Agroecology - the need for stakeholder collaboration
Enhancing the roles of ecosystem services in agriculture: agroecological prin...
 
TEEB Agriculture and Food
 
Agroecology: Principles and Practices
Heirloom value as relevant policy belief for agro-biodiversity initiatives
Biodiversity, Biofuels, Agroforestry and Conservation Agriculture
Biodiversity, Biofuels, Agroforestry and Conservation Agriculture
Eko Gea Presentation San Francisco April 2nd 2011 [ZdružLjivostni NačIn]
Agroecology and Sustainable Development
 
TEEB Incentive Measures by Patrick ten Brink of IEEP Stromstadt 7 September F...
Plant Biotechnology and Food Security
Forests, biodiversity and food security

More from The Forests Dialogue (20)

PDF
Design of national programs to accommodate different local contexts - Experi...
PDF
Alto Mayo Case Study: Conservation International Peru
PDF
Linking Policy and Practice: Approaches to REDD+ Benefit Sharing
PDF
Doing Dialogue: Using multi-stakeholder processes as a tool to reduce conflic...
PDF
Realizing the Potential of Investing in Locally Controlled Forestry
PDF
UNFF10 PRESENTATION on Investing in locally controlled forestry
PPTX
Day2. Group discussion
PPTX
Day 2. Presentation. diji chandrasekharan
PPTX
Group discussion
PPTX
Day 1.Presentation 3. augustin silvani
PPTX
Day 1. Presentation 2. iwan wibisono
PPTX
Day 1_2. george akwah
PPTX
Day 1_TFD. gary dunning
PDF
Doing Dialogue: Using MSD processes as a tool to reduce conflict in the for...
PDF
The Forests Dialogue (TFD) & IUCNREDD’s impact on Communities, Capacity and C...
PDF
Day 2 paulo kagyama aula 8 biodiv ferram
PDF
Dialogo florestal arnaldo.sae
PDF
7b) day 1 ma orlando montenegro - translated english
PDF
Successful Forestry Project Experiences in the Mato Grosso Do Sul Silvopastor...
PDF
TFD 4Fs Dialogue Presentation BOA TARDE
Design of national programs to accommodate different local contexts - Experi...
Alto Mayo Case Study: Conservation International Peru
Linking Policy and Practice: Approaches to REDD+ Benefit Sharing
Doing Dialogue: Using multi-stakeholder processes as a tool to reduce conflic...
Realizing the Potential of Investing in Locally Controlled Forestry
UNFF10 PRESENTATION on Investing in locally controlled forestry
Day2. Group discussion
Day 2. Presentation. diji chandrasekharan
Group discussion
Day 1.Presentation 3. augustin silvani
Day 1. Presentation 2. iwan wibisono
Day 1_2. george akwah
Day 1_TFD. gary dunning
Doing Dialogue: Using MSD processes as a tool to reduce conflict in the for...
The Forests Dialogue (TFD) & IUCNREDD’s impact on Communities, Capacity and C...
Day 2 paulo kagyama aula 8 biodiv ferram
Dialogo florestal arnaldo.sae
7b) day 1 ma orlando montenegro - translated english
Successful Forestry Project Experiences in the Mato Grosso Do Sul Silvopastor...
TFD 4Fs Dialogue Presentation BOA TARDE

Land use conflicts and projects related to Landless Workers' Movement (MST) in Brazil

  • 2. RURAL DEVELOPMENT BIODIVERSITY PUBLIC POLICIES Challenges and conflicts
  • 3. Building the concept of development... green Ecological Development economy Growth Sustainable Development Progress LOGIC BEHIND THE METHODS From a DYNAMIC From a STATIC point point of view, to of view, it leads to the innovation that idea of efficiency increases efficiency Furtado, 1981
  • 6. O Estado de S. Paulo newspaper (2013/07/16) • Es
  • 7. Rural development – LOGIC BEHIND THE METHODS EXTERNAL FACTORS NEW SIGNIFICANCE * Concentration of land ownership BACKGROUND and income • Private space vs Public space • Rural v Urban * Monoculture relationship * Discrimination and social exclusion • Production vs Conservation • Agricultural evolution * Class struggle * Market model • Multifunctional (farming and • Several Green * Industrial corporations have taken landscape) command Revolutions * Systemic degradation • GREEN ECONOMY..... (social – environmental)
  • 8. The dominant power in the countryside Diffusionist methodology  Research is popularizing unsuitable technologies  Development of professionals who are acritical regarding the model – UNIVERSITIES...
  • 9. Development Sustainability Social Rural Development Cultural Biodiversity Environmental
  • 11. Sustainability (Utopia) • Social • Economic • Cultural • Political • Ethical • Ecological-Environmental More than 200 definitions !!
  • 12. New rural significance and attributes Public Space Private Space Multifuncional Agroecosystems ETC Land Agribusiness Family Farming Ecosystem Services Commodities Legislation Green Violence Economy Sustainability Sovereignty / nutritional security Biotechnology Agrarian Agricultural Biodiversity Ecological Reform Economy Agroecology
  • 13. Conceptual framework – Looking for simplification! DISTINCT UNITS OF ANALYSIS IMPÉRIOS ALIMENTARES E OUTROS NO NEED FOR A PHYSICAL PRODUCTION UNIT SPECIFIC PRODUCTION UNIT OR ACTIVITY agriculture according agriculture according to to Capitalist Logic Business Logic agriculture according to Rural Logic (variety of forms) AGROECOSYSTEM WITH UNIT OF ANALYSIS State Society Biodiversity Figure : (adapted from PLOEG, 2008).
  • 15. Brazilian social ‘mega’ diversity  More than 200 different indigenous peoples  Traditional peoples and communities occupy roughly 1/3 of Brazil’s territory  Micro-economy based on forest products  Knowledge and practices relating to biodiversity management Crianças kaxinawás, Feijó, Acre
  • 19. Conflicts, degradation and social exclusion DEVELOPMENT vs Social and Environmental Issues “Public Policies” DEVELOPMENT MODELS / POLICIES
  • 20. Conservation vs Preservation vs Development A challenge to society !!! For the first time in Brazil..a public debate ...
  • 21. Examples Action Projects Policies...
  • 22. Development plus Biodiversity: Research and outreach at Rural settlements in the Vale do Ribeira – São Paulo state
  • 23. Management... Is it sustainable ?
  • 24. Respect, Manage and Coexist with the regional biodiversity Fruit of the Bromelia pinguin, used to make Jaguar footprint at the Apiaí settlement a medicinal syrup.
  • 25. Farmers participating in the surveying of the biodiversity at the Apiaí settlement – training / skill building / participative planning
  • 26. Agroecological tomato production Biological pest control – bait (Tajujá
  • 29. State of São Paulo
  • 34. Bioenergy plus Biodiversity and Nutritional Security '''
  • 35.  A. hassleri  A. emensis  A. glaucescens  A. totai Source: L.H.C.Berton Source : L.H.C.Berton Source : H.Lorenzi  A. intumescens  A. aculeata Lorenzi, 2010 Source : H.Lorenzi Source : H.Lorenzi Source : L.H.C.Berton
  • 36. Macaw palm (Acrocomia aculeata) Bioenergy - Native, rustic and abundant - Longevity: about 100 years - Starts to produce after 3 to 4 years - Oil has excellent physical and chemical characteristics - Multiple uses: 2 types of oil, 2 types of cake, activated charcoal, integration - with livestock and crop farming, agroforestry systems - Plantation density: 120 to 400 plants/ha - Considerable research efforts and growth in commercial initiatives ; - High productivity: 30 t. of biomass/ha and up to 4 t. of oil/ha - SOYBEANS - 550 KG/HA OF OIL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 36
  • 37. Estimates of biodiesel production/ha Soybean 420 kg.ha.year-1 Sunflower 890 kg.ha. year-1 Castor bean 1,320 kg.ha. year-1 (CESAR, 2003) (AMBIENTE, 2005) Macaw palm (average) (Berton et al.) 4,966 kg.ha. year-1 10,926 kg.ha.year-1
  • 38. In 2,480 fruit, the individual mass varied from 14.8 to 63.6 g
  • 39. 39 S. Motoike
  • 40. Sustainable Rural Landscapes Production plus Conservation: Family farming adhering to agrobiodiversity in the far south region of Bahia state Others....
  • 42. Regional Context Technology, Wealth and Poverty ! In an essentially rural region..
  • 43. 6th / 8th year 0 to 6 years
  • 44. Diagnóstico de conflitos sócio-ambientais em relação à plantações de árvores; Coord. Anna Fanzeres Relatório Final; Março 2005 www.ufrrj.br/institutos/if/lmbh
  • 45. Reactions in the past...
  • 47. ? ? ?
  • 52. ? ?? ?? ? ? ?
  • 53. BIODIVERSE AGROFORESTRY SYSTEMS What is Agroforestry? Subsistence Generation of Living savings Community (nutritional security) monthly income (forest products) Investments Restoration and RL + APP + Environmental Adaptation Landscape
  • 56. Cocoa plantation as a theoretical and methodological reference