SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Lessons Learned from LOD
(Linked Open Data) Failure and
Big Data:
The Future Trend
Youngwhan Lee, Ph. D.
전화: 010-7997-0345
이메일: nicklee@konkuk.ac.kr
Facebook: Youngwhan Nick Lee
Twitter: nicklee002

1
Web Evolution and Big Data
Internet Today
2010:
• Estimated 1011 Web pages in the World

2012:
•
•
•

Social Media: Facebook (1 Billion Monthly Active Users)
문자 발명후 2003년까지 5 엑사 바이트  2012년 현재 매일 7 엑사바이트 데이터 생성 중
Is “big data” a big pile of garbage?

1-3
Web Explosion and Big Data
•
•

Number of Web Users (Mar. 2012): 2.3 Billion
1011 Web pages in the World (Est. 2010)
– Since the inception of Web, there were 7000 days (i.e. 20 years). This means humans
create over 10 Million pages a day.

•

Digital Information Created in the year 2010: 1 zetabytes (1021)
-

-

•

"There was 5 exabytes of information created between the dawn of civilization through
2003, but that much information is now created every 2 days, and the pace is
increasing.“ –Eric Schmitt (2010)
2012, almost 7 exabytes are created everyday.
We call it “Big Data.”

What does this mean?
Lessons Learned from Lod Failure and Big Data : The Future Trend
Aggregation

데이터분석

지식구조화

큐레이션

RIF
SPARQ
L
OWL
RDF
LOD

NoSQL
MapReduce
R-DBMS

Understanding

Modified, based on Gene Bellinger, Durval Castro, Anthony Mills http://www.systems-thinking.org/dikw/dikw.htm , http://yjhyjh.egloos.com/39721
빅데이터/웹에서의 정보/지식 추출
• 정보 검색
– SEO(Search Engine Optimization) PageRank, EdgeRank

• Data Mining: 프로그램에 의한 정보(지식) 추출 가능
– 통계분석, Rule-based Analysis, 신경망 분석
– Visualization

데이터사이언스

• 지식공학 이용
– RDF/OWL 사용한 온톨로지 누적 연결
– Raw Data 연결하고 분석 가능하도록 개방 (Linked Open Data; LOD)
– 프로그램에 의한 논리분석 가능한 지식 추출 가능
• SPARQL
• RIF(Rule-based Interface Framework)

지식공학

• 인간의 힘 이용: 큐레이션
– 인간의 눈과 지식을 이용하여 정보를 필터하고 종합
• 예: pinterest.com, videocooki.com, storify.com, scoop.it, curated.by
Pareto’s Law
Longtail

Bighead
Longtail Phenomena in
The Long Tail by Chris Anderson (Wired, Oct. ´04) adopted to
information domains

Longtail Applications

Popularity

Mobile Apps

iPhone Apps

Android Apps
SNS Apps

Facebook Apps

Twitter Apps
LOD and Others

Medical Apps

공공 정보 활용 Apps

…
…
…

Bighead Applications

…

…
지식공학에서의 접근
• 온톨로지 구축
– Cyc
– WolframAlpha
– Siri

• 데이터의 웹(Web of Data)
– LOD  LOD2
Old “Layercake” of Semantic Web

정보 교환
RDF
OWL2
OWL2
Linked Open Data (LOD) Principles
Linking Open Data (LOD) is to connect and to open data to public


A little history of LOD Project


Tim Berners-Lee proposed LOD(Linking Open Data) project (2006)



Since the proposal, numerous countries and organizations participated, caused LOD to
explode in terms of the number of data


Wikipedia  DBpedia (www.dbpedia.org)



Bio2RDF project opened in 27 fields of Biology, Genetics, Medical-related, of which the
data sets are about 2.3 billions (Bio2RDF.org) (2008.10)



BBC announced to participate LOD project (www.bbc.org), now one of the institutes
actively utilizing the data



US Data.gov released 5 billion data triples



US Library of Congress announced to join LOD project.
(http://id.loc.gov/authorities/sh85042531#concept)



NY Times ( data.nytimes.com) release their data of 150 years of publication (2009.10)



US Whitehouse release a plan to open data in RDF (2009.11)

4 Principles
of LOD

1.
2.
3.
4.

Use URIs as names for things
Use HTTP URIs
When someone looks up a URI, provide useful information
Include links to other URIs
Advantages of LOD
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Elegant
Expandable
Flexible
Powerful
Decentralized
Participatory
Inclusive, and
“Free” to use
Linked Open Data (LOD) Principles
Change of Web Structure

유저 인터페이스
인간을 위한
웹 페이지 연결

웹페이지 연결 버스

유저 인터페이스
인간을 위한
웹 페이지 연결

웹페이지 연결 버스
매쉬업

매쉬업
컴퓨터를 위한
웹 데이터 연결

웹데이터 연결 버스

18
Mar., 2008
May, 2007

Sep., 2008

July, 2009
Lessons Learned from Lod Failure and Big Data : The Future Trend
SPARQL
SPARQL (Simple Protocol and RDF Query Language)
Lessons Learned from Lod Failure and Big Data : The Future Trend
Web 3.0: Merging the two Perspectives

WWW Propoal
(1989)

Semantic
Web

Technology
Innovation
Perspective

LOD Proposal (2006)

“GGG” Proposal (2007)

Knowledge-based Semantics

Next Generation Web

Data-based Semantics

Market
Behavior
Perspective

WEB 1.0

WEB 2.0

Web 3.0
“WEB2” Proposal (2009)

Technical Proposal Phase
Practical Use Phase
But no Champaign…
• Definition Unclear
– Berners-Lee’s 4 principles are ambiguous

•
•
•
•

Interpretation difficult
Inconsistent
Difficult both to learn and use
Difficult to build browsers and reasoners

• “Free” to use
Full of incomplete and inconsistent RDFs, no way
to make them evolve
In short, “Garbage in, Garbage out” experienced
Solution to LOD problems: LOD2
• LOD2 Stack: A Technical Approach
– Linked Data Management
– Enrichment and Quality Improvement
– Various Tools to use
•
•
•
•
•

Storage and Querying
Revision and authoring
Interlinking and fusing
Classification and enrichment
…
Q: Is this technical approach for LOD good enough?

A: Business approach is
definitely needed.
Big Data
What did we do with big data in 2013?

What would we do with big data in 2014?
빅데이터와 데이터 지상주의

End of Theory
“이론의 종말” by Chris Anderson
Implication
• Issue: Have and Have-not are
separated
– E. g. in marketing
• 4Ps
– Price, product, place, promotion

• STP
– Segmentation, targeting, and positioning
Implication
• Is Technical Approach needed?
Business Approach
• Data Markets
– Azure Data Marketplace
– Data.com
– Infochimps.com
– DataMarket.com
– Kaggle.com
Data Market: Azure Data Marketplace
Data Market: Data.com
Data Market: Infochimps.com
Data Market: DataMarket.com
Data Market: Kaggle.com
Conclusion
• Positioning for Korea,
– Where are we?
– Where are we heading to?
참고문헌
• 웹3.0 세상을 바꾸고 있다.
– 이영환

• A Semantic Web Primer (Cooperative Information Systems series)
– Grigoris Antoniou, Frank van Harmelen

• Semantic Web for the Working Ontologist, Second Edition: Effective
Modeling in RDFS and OWL
– Dean Allemang, James Hendler

• 온톨로지: 인터넷 진화의 열쇠
– 노상규, 박진수

• 월드와이드웹
– 팀 버너스-리

• 큐레이션
– 스티븐 로젠바움 저, 이시은 역
Web sites
• Problems of Linked Data
– http://milicicvuk.com/blog/2011/07/26/problems-of-linked-data14-identity/

• LOD2
– http://lod2.eu/Welcome.html
– http://stack.lod2.eu/blog/

• How to Define Web 3.0
– http://howtosplitanatom.com/news/how-to-define-web-30-2/

• SPARQL by Example
– http://www.cambridgesemantics.com/semantic-university/sparqlby-example#(1)

• Practical P-P-P-Problems with Linked Data
– http://www.mkbergman.com/917/practical-p-p-p-problems-withlinked-data/

• Linked-Data-Api
– https://code.google.com/p/linked-data-api/

More Related Content

PDF
Online text data for machine learning, data science, and research - Who can p...
PDF
Open Research Problems in Linked Data - WWW2010
PPTX
Linked Data: opportunities and challenges
PDF
Internet Archives and Social Science Research - Yeungnam University
ZIP
Social Networks and Computer Science
PPT
Linked Data and the Future Internet Architecture: A motivation: Stefan Decker...
PPT
Introduction to the Social Data on the Web Workshop
Online text data for machine learning, data science, and research - Who can p...
Open Research Problems in Linked Data - WWW2010
Linked Data: opportunities and challenges
Internet Archives and Social Science Research - Yeungnam University
Social Networks and Computer Science
Linked Data and the Future Internet Architecture: A motivation: Stefan Decker...
Introduction to the Social Data on the Web Workshop

What's hot (7)

DOCX
Presentation internet programming report
PPTX
ExLibris National Library Meeting @ IFLA-Helsinki - Aug 15th 2012
PDF
Carpenter "The Future of the Scholarly Record"
PDF
"Plans are worthless, but planning is essential"
PDF
CAEPIA 2011
PPTX
Freddy Limpens: From folksonomies to ontologies: a socio-technical solution.
PPTX
Data.gov Overview, August 2012
Presentation internet programming report
ExLibris National Library Meeting @ IFLA-Helsinki - Aug 15th 2012
Carpenter "The Future of the Scholarly Record"
"Plans are worthless, but planning is essential"
CAEPIA 2011
Freddy Limpens: From folksonomies to ontologies: a socio-technical solution.
Data.gov Overview, August 2012
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

POT
Back to-school presentation
PPTX
Childhood Drinking: A New Kind Of Conversation
PPTX
웹의 진화와 지식 구조화 Ver 1 1
PPTX
집단지성에서 시민행동의 플랫폼으로
PPT
Rules 09 10
PPT
Life Success 4 Athletes
PPTX
공공정보의 개방활용의 필요성과 역할
PPT
The O Antiphons
PPSX
Planeta esti TU!
PPTX
Using Technology To Engage Citizens
PDF
시민의코딩(주) 소개서 Ver. 1.3
PPT
Ethics Presentation To Sorensen Institute
PPTX
소셜미디어 사용 해외사례 Ver 1 1
PDF
Document sur l'Auto provisioning, contacts, presence et streaming sur asterisk
PPTX
Barcamp AQUOPS (BarAQUOPS) 2015
PPTX
Présentation du dispositif des attestations scolaires de sécurité routière ou...
PDF
Babbler réinvente les relations presse #startup #digital #medias #rp
PDF
ANT2- Atelier 2: Communication stratégique efficace et planifiée
PPTX
xAPI - web-conférence FFFOD du 15/09/15
PPS
Internet, réseaux sociaux, mobilité: de nouvelles stratégies en oeuvre dans l...
Back to-school presentation
Childhood Drinking: A New Kind Of Conversation
웹의 진화와 지식 구조화 Ver 1 1
집단지성에서 시민행동의 플랫폼으로
Rules 09 10
Life Success 4 Athletes
공공정보의 개방활용의 필요성과 역할
The O Antiphons
Planeta esti TU!
Using Technology To Engage Citizens
시민의코딩(주) 소개서 Ver. 1.3
Ethics Presentation To Sorensen Institute
소셜미디어 사용 해외사례 Ver 1 1
Document sur l'Auto provisioning, contacts, presence et streaming sur asterisk
Barcamp AQUOPS (BarAQUOPS) 2015
Présentation du dispositif des attestations scolaires de sécurité routière ou...
Babbler réinvente les relations presse #startup #digital #medias #rp
ANT2- Atelier 2: Communication stratégique efficace et planifiée
xAPI - web-conférence FFFOD du 15/09/15
Internet, réseaux sociaux, mobilité: de nouvelles stratégies en oeuvre dans l...
Ad

Similar to Lessons Learned from Lod Failure and Big Data : The Future Trend (20)

PPTX
20100527 1400 1530_nia_정보사회와웹2.0세상_정보윤리교육기관강사대상_특강
PPT
Mapping (big) data science (15 dec2014)대학(원)생
PDF
도서관과 Linked Data
PDF
빅데이터 시대의 미디어&커뮤니케이션 교육과 연구
PDF
LOD(Linked Open Data) Recommendations
PDF
International Collaboration Networks in the Emerging (Big) Data Science
PPTX
Governmental Linked Data
PPTX
Ict와 사회과학지식간 학제간 연구동향(23 march2013)
PDF
PDF
Semantic web and Linked Data
PPT
Putting the L in front: from Open Data to Linked Open Data
PDF
관광 지식베이스와 스마트 관광 서비스 (Knowledge base and Smart Tourism)
PDF
OKFN Korea 소개자료
PPT
Broad Data
PDF
Llinked open data training for EU institutions
PDF
W3C HTML5 CT Forum 2016 - Revisited
PDF
Jung 2010
PDF
Methodological Guidelines for Publishing Linked Data
PDF
Data, Big Data and Communication - Ki-byoung Kim
PPTX
Publishing and Using Linked Open Data - Day 4
20100527 1400 1530_nia_정보사회와웹2.0세상_정보윤리교육기관강사대상_특강
Mapping (big) data science (15 dec2014)대학(원)생
도서관과 Linked Data
빅데이터 시대의 미디어&커뮤니케이션 교육과 연구
LOD(Linked Open Data) Recommendations
International Collaboration Networks in the Emerging (Big) Data Science
Governmental Linked Data
Ict와 사회과학지식간 학제간 연구동향(23 march2013)
Semantic web and Linked Data
Putting the L in front: from Open Data to Linked Open Data
관광 지식베이스와 스마트 관광 서비스 (Knowledge base and Smart Tourism)
OKFN Korea 소개자료
Broad Data
Llinked open data training for EU institutions
W3C HTML5 CT Forum 2016 - Revisited
Jung 2010
Methodological Guidelines for Publishing Linked Data
Data, Big Data and Communication - Ki-byoung Kim
Publishing and Using Linked Open Data - Day 4

More from Konkuk University (9)

PDF
비대면인증의 성공적 정착을 위한 제언
PDF
데이터 거래와 유통에 대하여 (논문)
PDF
핀테크를 통한 여신금융업계의 대응과 가치 창출 방안 여신금융 여름호 1508
PPTX
금융 보안사고 트렌드와 정부 금융사들의 과제
PPTX
빅데이터와 타겟 마케팅 Ver 1 0
PPT
하이텍크 마케팅 - 컬트 브랜딩 ( Hightech Marketing - Cult brainding )
PPTX
Smart gov 3 소통과 공유의 원칙 (최종)
PPTX
Smart gov 3 소통과 공유의 원칙 최종
PPT
웹 3.0 세상을 바꾸고 있다 요약
비대면인증의 성공적 정착을 위한 제언
데이터 거래와 유통에 대하여 (논문)
핀테크를 통한 여신금융업계의 대응과 가치 창출 방안 여신금융 여름호 1508
금융 보안사고 트렌드와 정부 금융사들의 과제
빅데이터와 타겟 마케팅 Ver 1 0
하이텍크 마케팅 - 컬트 브랜딩 ( Hightech Marketing - Cult brainding )
Smart gov 3 소통과 공유의 원칙 (최종)
Smart gov 3 소통과 공유의 원칙 최종
웹 3.0 세상을 바꾸고 있다 요약

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
PDF
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
PPTX
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
PPT
Teaching material agriculture food technology
PDF
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
PPTX
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
PDF
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
PDF
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
PDF
Spectral efficient network and resource selection model in 5G networks
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PDF
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PDF
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
PDF
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
PDF
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
PDF
CIFDAQ's Market Insight: SEC Turns Pro Crypto
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PPTX
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
PDF
Machine learning based COVID-19 study performance prediction
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
Teaching material agriculture food technology
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
Spectral efficient network and resource selection model in 5G networks
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
Advanced methodologies resolving dimensionality complications for autism neur...
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
CIFDAQ's Market Insight: SEC Turns Pro Crypto
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
Machine learning based COVID-19 study performance prediction

Lessons Learned from Lod Failure and Big Data : The Future Trend

  • 1. Lessons Learned from LOD (Linked Open Data) Failure and Big Data: The Future Trend Youngwhan Lee, Ph. D. 전화: 010-7997-0345 이메일: nicklee@konkuk.ac.kr Facebook: Youngwhan Nick Lee Twitter: nicklee002 1
  • 2. Web Evolution and Big Data
  • 3. Internet Today 2010: • Estimated 1011 Web pages in the World 2012: • • • Social Media: Facebook (1 Billion Monthly Active Users) 문자 발명후 2003년까지 5 엑사 바이트  2012년 현재 매일 7 엑사바이트 데이터 생성 중 Is “big data” a big pile of garbage? 1-3
  • 4. Web Explosion and Big Data • • Number of Web Users (Mar. 2012): 2.3 Billion 1011 Web pages in the World (Est. 2010) – Since the inception of Web, there were 7000 days (i.e. 20 years). This means humans create over 10 Million pages a day. • Digital Information Created in the year 2010: 1 zetabytes (1021) - - • "There was 5 exabytes of information created between the dawn of civilization through 2003, but that much information is now created every 2 days, and the pace is increasing.“ –Eric Schmitt (2010) 2012, almost 7 exabytes are created everyday. We call it “Big Data.” What does this mean?
  • 6. Aggregation 데이터분석 지식구조화 큐레이션 RIF SPARQ L OWL RDF LOD NoSQL MapReduce R-DBMS Understanding Modified, based on Gene Bellinger, Durval Castro, Anthony Mills http://www.systems-thinking.org/dikw/dikw.htm , http://yjhyjh.egloos.com/39721
  • 7. 빅데이터/웹에서의 정보/지식 추출 • 정보 검색 – SEO(Search Engine Optimization) PageRank, EdgeRank • Data Mining: 프로그램에 의한 정보(지식) 추출 가능 – 통계분석, Rule-based Analysis, 신경망 분석 – Visualization 데이터사이언스 • 지식공학 이용 – RDF/OWL 사용한 온톨로지 누적 연결 – Raw Data 연결하고 분석 가능하도록 개방 (Linked Open Data; LOD) – 프로그램에 의한 논리분석 가능한 지식 추출 가능 • SPARQL • RIF(Rule-based Interface Framework) 지식공학 • 인간의 힘 이용: 큐레이션 – 인간의 눈과 지식을 이용하여 정보를 필터하고 종합 • 예: pinterest.com, videocooki.com, storify.com, scoop.it, curated.by
  • 9. Longtail Phenomena in The Long Tail by Chris Anderson (Wired, Oct. ´04) adopted to information domains Longtail Applications Popularity Mobile Apps  iPhone Apps  Android Apps SNS Apps  Facebook Apps  Twitter Apps LOD and Others  Medical Apps  공공 정보 활용 Apps  … … … Bighead Applications … …
  • 10. 지식공학에서의 접근 • 온톨로지 구축 – Cyc – WolframAlpha – Siri • 데이터의 웹(Web of Data) – LOD  LOD2
  • 11. Old “Layercake” of Semantic Web 정보 교환
  • 12. RDF
  • 13. OWL2
  • 14. OWL2
  • 15. Linked Open Data (LOD) Principles Linking Open Data (LOD) is to connect and to open data to public  A little history of LOD Project  Tim Berners-Lee proposed LOD(Linking Open Data) project (2006)  Since the proposal, numerous countries and organizations participated, caused LOD to explode in terms of the number of data  Wikipedia  DBpedia (www.dbpedia.org)  Bio2RDF project opened in 27 fields of Biology, Genetics, Medical-related, of which the data sets are about 2.3 billions (Bio2RDF.org) (2008.10)  BBC announced to participate LOD project (www.bbc.org), now one of the institutes actively utilizing the data  US Data.gov released 5 billion data triples  US Library of Congress announced to join LOD project. (http://id.loc.gov/authorities/sh85042531#concept)  NY Times ( data.nytimes.com) release their data of 150 years of publication (2009.10)  US Whitehouse release a plan to open data in RDF (2009.11) 4 Principles of LOD 1. 2. 3. 4. Use URIs as names for things Use HTTP URIs When someone looks up a URI, provide useful information Include links to other URIs
  • 17. Linked Open Data (LOD) Principles
  • 18. Change of Web Structure 유저 인터페이스 인간을 위한 웹 페이지 연결 웹페이지 연결 버스 유저 인터페이스 인간을 위한 웹 페이지 연결 웹페이지 연결 버스 매쉬업 매쉬업 컴퓨터를 위한 웹 데이터 연결 웹데이터 연결 버스 18
  • 19. Mar., 2008 May, 2007 Sep., 2008 July, 2009
  • 22. SPARQL (Simple Protocol and RDF Query Language)
  • 24. Web 3.0: Merging the two Perspectives WWW Propoal (1989) Semantic Web Technology Innovation Perspective LOD Proposal (2006) “GGG” Proposal (2007) Knowledge-based Semantics Next Generation Web Data-based Semantics Market Behavior Perspective WEB 1.0 WEB 2.0 Web 3.0 “WEB2” Proposal (2009) Technical Proposal Phase Practical Use Phase
  • 25. But no Champaign… • Definition Unclear – Berners-Lee’s 4 principles are ambiguous • • • • Interpretation difficult Inconsistent Difficult both to learn and use Difficult to build browsers and reasoners • “Free” to use Full of incomplete and inconsistent RDFs, no way to make them evolve In short, “Garbage in, Garbage out” experienced
  • 26. Solution to LOD problems: LOD2 • LOD2 Stack: A Technical Approach – Linked Data Management – Enrichment and Quality Improvement – Various Tools to use • • • • • Storage and Querying Revision and authoring Interlinking and fusing Classification and enrichment …
  • 27. Q: Is this technical approach for LOD good enough? A: Business approach is definitely needed.
  • 28. Big Data What did we do with big data in 2013? What would we do with big data in 2014?
  • 29. 빅데이터와 데이터 지상주의 End of Theory “이론의 종말” by Chris Anderson
  • 30. Implication • Issue: Have and Have-not are separated – E. g. in marketing • 4Ps – Price, product, place, promotion • STP – Segmentation, targeting, and positioning
  • 31. Implication • Is Technical Approach needed?
  • 32. Business Approach • Data Markets – Azure Data Marketplace – Data.com – Infochimps.com – DataMarket.com – Kaggle.com
  • 33. Data Market: Azure Data Marketplace
  • 38. Conclusion • Positioning for Korea, – Where are we? – Where are we heading to?
  • 39. 참고문헌 • 웹3.0 세상을 바꾸고 있다. – 이영환 • A Semantic Web Primer (Cooperative Information Systems series) – Grigoris Antoniou, Frank van Harmelen • Semantic Web for the Working Ontologist, Second Edition: Effective Modeling in RDFS and OWL – Dean Allemang, James Hendler • 온톨로지: 인터넷 진화의 열쇠 – 노상규, 박진수 • 월드와이드웹 – 팀 버너스-리 • 큐레이션 – 스티븐 로젠바움 저, 이시은 역
  • 40. Web sites • Problems of Linked Data – http://milicicvuk.com/blog/2011/07/26/problems-of-linked-data14-identity/ • LOD2 – http://lod2.eu/Welcome.html – http://stack.lod2.eu/blog/ • How to Define Web 3.0 – http://howtosplitanatom.com/news/how-to-define-web-30-2/ • SPARQL by Example – http://www.cambridgesemantics.com/semantic-university/sparqlby-example#(1) • Practical P-P-P-Problems with Linked Data – http://www.mkbergman.com/917/practical-p-p-p-problems-withlinked-data/ • Linked-Data-Api – https://code.google.com/p/linked-data-api/