SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Managing Diversity: Using the CLAS Standards to guide organizational change Julia Puebla Fortier  Executive Director
DiversityRx: Resources for  Cross Cultural Health Care US-based NGO founded in 1995 providing  education, technical assistance, research and policy development on  improving health care for diverse populations National standards for culturally and linguistically appropriate health care (CLAS) National conferences Website and resource database: www.DiversityRx.org Online education, professional development, and discussion forums
Key messages Policy shapes practice Standards offer a roadmap Integration with mainstream health agendas Social and political support is key
Key questions How can health care organizations provide  the same quality of care for migrants as for nationals? How can this be realized? Why should you do it?
Same quality, same services? Services need to be adapted to the needs of individuals and families - patient centered care System must anticipate different needs, and plan for them Staff must be flexible enough to understand differences and accommodate them
From ideas to action Mindset Consultation Preparation Collaborative evaluation
Why do this? Humane and ethical Makes it easier for staff to do their jobs well Prioritises patient safety Addresses medical errors, quality improvement and outcomes Improves efficiency and saves money
National Standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services in Health Care (CLAS Standards) Issued by the Federal government in 2001 after a multi-year development process involving multiple stakeholders and public comment process
CLAS Standards:  Categories of interventions Culturally Sensitive Interventions Cultural competence education Race, ethnic and linguistic concordance Community  health workers and culturally competent health promotion Language Assistance Bilingual services, oral interpretation, translated written materials
CLAS Standards:  Categories of interventions Organizational Supports for Cultural Competence Management and policy strategies Community engagement Information and data for planning and evaluation Appropriate ethics and conflict resolution processes Public reporting
The importance of strategic leadership: HealthEast, Minnesota: Effort led by CEO and Board of Directors Organizational assessment Leaders addressed needs identified in assessment immediately hired interpreters improved translated materials trained staff to work with interpreters collected patient data related to language and origin Culturally responsive services integrated into mission statements and quality improvement activities A director for cross cultural health was hired, reporting directly to the Chief Medical Officer
How to engage leadership: Lehigh Valley Health Network, Pennsylvania Maintain patient-centered care focus Connect cultural awareness to other organizational goals Engage leaders through a transformational event Communicate achievements internally and externally Work with recognized cultural experts to provide feedback and next steps
Partnering with the community: Children's Mercy Hospitals and Clinics, Kansas Objective: to improve communication between families and the hospital. Parents learn about hospital practice and policy, hospital staff get feedback about patient experiences 12 families participated Hospital improvements include new orientation materials in Spanish, symbol-based wayfinding system Menu and TV channel accomodations Ongoing dialogue with community
ICMs: Community House Calls, Harborview Medical Center, Seattle 115,000 interventions/year in 6 languages: Amharic, Cambodian, Somali, Tigrigna, Spanish and Vietnamese  Services for patients: Interpretation Advocacy for patients in healthcare, social service, school and agency settings. Assist with applications for health insurance Coordination of patient care, including arranging transportation Help with forms and applications Health education Home visits
ICMs: Community House Calls Services for providers Interpretation Cultural mediation, including facilitating clinical encounters that involve cultural differences Cultural consultation about issues affecting patient care Education sessions to provide cultural information about a variety of topics, such as health beliefs, traditional health practices, explaining diagnoses to patients, end-of-life issues and parenting practices Services for the community  Community education programs about tuberculosis, cancer, asthma, depression, HIV/AIDS and other topics.
Standards: A starting place and the power of perception Recommended standards, not regulations Something to point to Leverage to move forward Many voluntary  ‘compliance’ efforts
Other quality organizations follow Initiatives from key health care quality and accreditation organizations: The Joint Commission National Committee for Quality Assurance The National Quality Forum
The Joint Commission Required accreditation process  Early interest in cultural, linguistic issues Comparison of CLAS standards and JC standards Hospital, Language and Culture  study Standards and implementation guide released in 2011
National Committee  for Quality Assurance Voluntary standards and accrediting body for managed care plans Test waters with CLAS awards program – highlight best practices Multicultural Health Standards released this year Focus on data collection, staff diversity/ cultural competence, language services
National Quality Forum Comprehensive voluntary framework and preferred practices for measuring and reporting cultural competency 45 preferred practices in 6 domains: Leadership Integration into management systems Patient-provider communication Care delivery structures Workforce diversity and training Community engagement
Unique social acceptance factors  Civil rights movement Rise of minority group power Political Demographic Disgrace of disparities Health professions societies
Political and financial challenges Anti-immigrant sentiment Interpersonal Political Financial crisis New paradigms, new imperatives
Role of foundations and government The California Endowment, The Commonwealth Fund, The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Funding for demonstration projects and research
For more information: Julia Puebla Fortier , Executive Director [email_address] DiversityRx  - Resources for Cross Cultural Health Care www.diversityRx.org
www.diversityRx.org
Thank You Merci beaucoup Dank u

More Related Content

PPT
Adapting health systems to the challenge of diversity in the US and Europe
PPT
New Requirements And Challenges Joint Commission Cultural Competency Requir...
PPT
Improving health care for immigrant and minority populations in the US
PPTX
Dual Purposing of Interpreters to Increase Colorectal Cancer Screening in Vie...
PPS
Cultural Competence for HIV/AIDS Services and Agencies
PPTX
APCRSHR10 Virtual abstract presentation of Dr Harjyot Khosa
PPTX
Better with Age: Health systems planning for the aging population
PPTX
APCRSHR10 Virtual abstract presentation of Samreen of Asia Pacific Transgende...
Adapting health systems to the challenge of diversity in the US and Europe
New Requirements And Challenges Joint Commission Cultural Competency Requir...
Improving health care for immigrant and minority populations in the US
Dual Purposing of Interpreters to Increase Colorectal Cancer Screening in Vie...
Cultural Competence for HIV/AIDS Services and Agencies
APCRSHR10 Virtual abstract presentation of Dr Harjyot Khosa
Better with Age: Health systems planning for the aging population
APCRSHR10 Virtual abstract presentation of Samreen of Asia Pacific Transgende...

What's hot (20)

PPT
The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Executive Nurse Fellows Program
PPTX
Session i important consideration in addressing the health needs of the latin...
PPTX
A Promotores Approach in the Management of Parkinson's Disease Interactive Se...
PDF
Plenary session health policy and community engaged interventions addressing ...
PDF
Bostick- HPOE Building a Culturally Competent Organization
PPT
Impact of Trauma in Latino Families: Implications for Practice and Policy
PDF
Innovations of virginias aaa bay aging 2016 governors conference on aging
PPTX
APCRSHR10 Virtual abstract presentation of Manisha Dhakal of Blue Diamond Soc...
PDF
Washtenaw County Community Health Needs Assessment.pptx
PDF
SOPHEnicollette3
PPTX
Access & equity in healthcare by v
 
PPTX
Improving access to oral health of underserved immigrants
PDF
Grandparents raising grandchildren strategies for effective service delivery ...
PDF
APCRSHR10 Virtual plenary presentation of Eamonn Murphy, Regional Director of...
PPT
Equitable choices for Health
PPTX
Improving Access to Oral Health Care for Vulnerable People living in Canada
PPT
03 20-14 gpt telehealth presentation s-salgado
PDF
Policy memo-expanding access to healthcare resources to the undocumented immg...
PPTX
Creating inclusive learning environments
PPTX
Enhancing Health Equity: The Potential of Peer Health Ambassadors
The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Executive Nurse Fellows Program
Session i important consideration in addressing the health needs of the latin...
A Promotores Approach in the Management of Parkinson's Disease Interactive Se...
Plenary session health policy and community engaged interventions addressing ...
Bostick- HPOE Building a Culturally Competent Organization
Impact of Trauma in Latino Families: Implications for Practice and Policy
Innovations of virginias aaa bay aging 2016 governors conference on aging
APCRSHR10 Virtual abstract presentation of Manisha Dhakal of Blue Diamond Soc...
Washtenaw County Community Health Needs Assessment.pptx
SOPHEnicollette3
Access & equity in healthcare by v
 
Improving access to oral health of underserved immigrants
Grandparents raising grandchildren strategies for effective service delivery ...
APCRSHR10 Virtual plenary presentation of Eamonn Murphy, Regional Director of...
Equitable choices for Health
Improving Access to Oral Health Care for Vulnerable People living in Canada
03 20-14 gpt telehealth presentation s-salgado
Policy memo-expanding access to healthcare resources to the undocumented immg...
Creating inclusive learning environments
Enhancing Health Equity: The Potential of Peer Health Ambassadors
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPT
Blerta Interpreter 1
PPT
Proekt Kaladina L
PDF
iPhone offline webapps
PDF
Arai thesis
PPT
Report z Vyškov
PPT
Guerrilla Readers - výroční prezentace
PDF
Bgs120 debopriyo roy
PDF
Going the extra mile in designing for the web
PDF
Graphic Design Portfolio
PPT
Banana2008
PDF
IPCC2010-2
PPT
Health-e-cITi NJ
PPT
Los gansos
PPT
GeekMeet Iasi Intro
PPTX
Webinar: Measuring Online Brand Loyalty and Benchmarking websites: Cartier, G...
PDF
Watanabe presentation
PDF
Rational Risk and Crisis Management Course
PPT
Referaat 31 05 2011
PDF
IVI Presentation at UNECE Conference, May 2008
PDF
Large scale data-parsing with Hadoop in Bioinformatics
Blerta Interpreter 1
Proekt Kaladina L
iPhone offline webapps
Arai thesis
Report z Vyškov
Guerrilla Readers - výroční prezentace
Bgs120 debopriyo roy
Going the extra mile in designing for the web
Graphic Design Portfolio
Banana2008
IPCC2010-2
Health-e-cITi NJ
Los gansos
GeekMeet Iasi Intro
Webinar: Measuring Online Brand Loyalty and Benchmarking websites: Cartier, G...
Watanabe presentation
Rational Risk and Crisis Management Course
Referaat 31 05 2011
IVI Presentation at UNECE Conference, May 2008
Large scale data-parsing with Hadoop in Bioinformatics
Ad

Similar to Managing Diversity: Using the CLAS Standards to guide organizational change (20)

PPT
Multicultural health standards around the world
PPT
Addressing culture in health care delivery: policy, practice and research
PPTX
Utilizing National CLAS Standards (Cultural and Linguistic Appropriate Servic...
PPTX
Utilizing National CLAS Standards (Cultural and Linguistic Appropriate Servic...
PPTX
Improving Health Care for Foreigners in Japan: Stories, Data and Policy Models
DOCX
Sheet1Year of ImplementationStrategies for Implementation and Anti.docx
PDF
Language_Services_Guide_2014
PPT
06chap ppt
PPT
Cafe Scientifique: Cultural Competency and Safety
PPTX
Chw panel presentation lr slides 03.13.2013
PPT
Cultural Competence And Global Health Workers
PPTX
PDF
criticalmeasures_xculturalprogram_v1
PDF
Building a Culturally Competent Organization: The Quest for Equity in Health ...
PDF
DBHDS Office of CLC What We Do 2014
DOCX
Respecting cultural needs.docx
PDF
C. Godfrey Jacobs Legislative Updates ILSC 2013
PPTX
Salon 2 15 kasim 11.00 12.00 nuran aydin-ing
PDF
Cleveland Local Conversation on Health Disparities
PPT
The Institute for Family Health
Multicultural health standards around the world
Addressing culture in health care delivery: policy, practice and research
Utilizing National CLAS Standards (Cultural and Linguistic Appropriate Servic...
Utilizing National CLAS Standards (Cultural and Linguistic Appropriate Servic...
Improving Health Care for Foreigners in Japan: Stories, Data and Policy Models
Sheet1Year of ImplementationStrategies for Implementation and Anti.docx
Language_Services_Guide_2014
06chap ppt
Cafe Scientifique: Cultural Competency and Safety
Chw panel presentation lr slides 03.13.2013
Cultural Competence And Global Health Workers
criticalmeasures_xculturalprogram_v1
Building a Culturally Competent Organization: The Quest for Equity in Health ...
DBHDS Office of CLC What We Do 2014
Respecting cultural needs.docx
C. Godfrey Jacobs Legislative Updates ILSC 2013
Salon 2 15 kasim 11.00 12.00 nuran aydin-ing
Cleveland Local Conversation on Health Disparities
The Institute for Family Health

Managing Diversity: Using the CLAS Standards to guide organizational change

  • 1. Managing Diversity: Using the CLAS Standards to guide organizational change Julia Puebla Fortier Executive Director
  • 2. DiversityRx: Resources for Cross Cultural Health Care US-based NGO founded in 1995 providing education, technical assistance, research and policy development on improving health care for diverse populations National standards for culturally and linguistically appropriate health care (CLAS) National conferences Website and resource database: www.DiversityRx.org Online education, professional development, and discussion forums
  • 3. Key messages Policy shapes practice Standards offer a roadmap Integration with mainstream health agendas Social and political support is key
  • 4. Key questions How can health care organizations provide the same quality of care for migrants as for nationals? How can this be realized? Why should you do it?
  • 5. Same quality, same services? Services need to be adapted to the needs of individuals and families - patient centered care System must anticipate different needs, and plan for them Staff must be flexible enough to understand differences and accommodate them
  • 6. From ideas to action Mindset Consultation Preparation Collaborative evaluation
  • 7. Why do this? Humane and ethical Makes it easier for staff to do their jobs well Prioritises patient safety Addresses medical errors, quality improvement and outcomes Improves efficiency and saves money
  • 8. National Standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services in Health Care (CLAS Standards) Issued by the Federal government in 2001 after a multi-year development process involving multiple stakeholders and public comment process
  • 9. CLAS Standards: Categories of interventions Culturally Sensitive Interventions Cultural competence education Race, ethnic and linguistic concordance Community health workers and culturally competent health promotion Language Assistance Bilingual services, oral interpretation, translated written materials
  • 10. CLAS Standards: Categories of interventions Organizational Supports for Cultural Competence Management and policy strategies Community engagement Information and data for planning and evaluation Appropriate ethics and conflict resolution processes Public reporting
  • 11. The importance of strategic leadership: HealthEast, Minnesota: Effort led by CEO and Board of Directors Organizational assessment Leaders addressed needs identified in assessment immediately hired interpreters improved translated materials trained staff to work with interpreters collected patient data related to language and origin Culturally responsive services integrated into mission statements and quality improvement activities A director for cross cultural health was hired, reporting directly to the Chief Medical Officer
  • 12. How to engage leadership: Lehigh Valley Health Network, Pennsylvania Maintain patient-centered care focus Connect cultural awareness to other organizational goals Engage leaders through a transformational event Communicate achievements internally and externally Work with recognized cultural experts to provide feedback and next steps
  • 13. Partnering with the community: Children's Mercy Hospitals and Clinics, Kansas Objective: to improve communication between families and the hospital. Parents learn about hospital practice and policy, hospital staff get feedback about patient experiences 12 families participated Hospital improvements include new orientation materials in Spanish, symbol-based wayfinding system Menu and TV channel accomodations Ongoing dialogue with community
  • 14. ICMs: Community House Calls, Harborview Medical Center, Seattle 115,000 interventions/year in 6 languages: Amharic, Cambodian, Somali, Tigrigna, Spanish and Vietnamese Services for patients: Interpretation Advocacy for patients in healthcare, social service, school and agency settings. Assist with applications for health insurance Coordination of patient care, including arranging transportation Help with forms and applications Health education Home visits
  • 15. ICMs: Community House Calls Services for providers Interpretation Cultural mediation, including facilitating clinical encounters that involve cultural differences Cultural consultation about issues affecting patient care Education sessions to provide cultural information about a variety of topics, such as health beliefs, traditional health practices, explaining diagnoses to patients, end-of-life issues and parenting practices Services for the community Community education programs about tuberculosis, cancer, asthma, depression, HIV/AIDS and other topics.
  • 16. Standards: A starting place and the power of perception Recommended standards, not regulations Something to point to Leverage to move forward Many voluntary ‘compliance’ efforts
  • 17. Other quality organizations follow Initiatives from key health care quality and accreditation organizations: The Joint Commission National Committee for Quality Assurance The National Quality Forum
  • 18. The Joint Commission Required accreditation process Early interest in cultural, linguistic issues Comparison of CLAS standards and JC standards Hospital, Language and Culture study Standards and implementation guide released in 2011
  • 19. National Committee for Quality Assurance Voluntary standards and accrediting body for managed care plans Test waters with CLAS awards program – highlight best practices Multicultural Health Standards released this year Focus on data collection, staff diversity/ cultural competence, language services
  • 20. National Quality Forum Comprehensive voluntary framework and preferred practices for measuring and reporting cultural competency 45 preferred practices in 6 domains: Leadership Integration into management systems Patient-provider communication Care delivery structures Workforce diversity and training Community engagement
  • 21. Unique social acceptance factors Civil rights movement Rise of minority group power Political Demographic Disgrace of disparities Health professions societies
  • 22. Political and financial challenges Anti-immigrant sentiment Interpersonal Political Financial crisis New paradigms, new imperatives
  • 23. Role of foundations and government The California Endowment, The Commonwealth Fund, The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Funding for demonstration projects and research
  • 24. For more information: Julia Puebla Fortier , Executive Director [email_address] DiversityRx - Resources for Cross Cultural Health Care www.diversityRx.org
  • 26. Thank You Merci beaucoup Dank u

Editor's Notes

  • #4: Tell the story of how a combination of obscure issues, practices and policies came to capture the attention of the Federal government and the top health care quality agencies in the United States. Rooted in the minority and refugee health programs and civil rights law, the CLAS standards evolved from an interplay of practice, policy and perception that continues to this day. We ’ll review. Tell this story from as the Principle Investigator that led two Federally funded projects to develop the CLAS standards, supported before and after by years of gathering and disseminating information about best practices, policies and research related to culturally and linguistically appropriate health care.
  • #10: CLAS Standards: http://www.omhrc.gov/templates/browse.aspx?lvl=2&lvlID=15
  • #19: http://www.jointcommission.org/PatientSafety/HLC/
  • #20: NCQA awards program, best practices and toolkit: http://www.ncqa.org/tabid/451/Default.aspx Proposed CLAS standards within their overall standards framework: http://www.ncqa.org/Portals/0/PublicComment/2010_Products_Update/Appendix_3_Creation_of_CLAS_Standard.pdf http://www.ncqa.org/Portals/0/PublicComment/2010_Products_Update/Appendix_2_Incorporating_Aspects_of_CLAS.pdf Final standards and accompanying tools: http://www.ncqa.org/tabid/1157/Default.aspx
  • #21: Project summary: http://www.qualityforum.org/projects/ongoing/cultural-comp/ Framework summary: http://www.qualityforum.org/pdf/projects/cultural-comp/txReportDraft%2002-25-09PREPUB.pdf
  • #24: The California Endowment: www.Calendow.org: click on: Publications -> Program Areas -> Cultural Competent Health Systems The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation www.rwjf.org Search cultural competence and interpretation for a full list of publications and projects The Commonwealth Fund: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/Grants-and-Programs/Browse-Grants.aspx?program=Health+Care+Disparities Also search cultural competence and interpretation for a full list of publications and projects