Models of democracy
- 1. Principles of GovernmentModels of Democracy
- 2. Principles of GovernmentCourse OverviewThis course focuses on the institutions, methods, and procedures of governance and the reconfiguration with the advent of globalizations.This course exposes students to broad subject areas such as democracy, the state, nations, and globalization, political culture, legitimacy, representation and voting, constitution and judiciaries as well as the Westminster Whitehall Model, political executives, government policy and performance, bureaucracies and power sharing.
- 3. Course ObjectivesAt the end of this course students should be able to:describe the institutions, methods and procedures of governance;
- 4. explain key concepts which are fundamental to understanding of government;
- 5. analyze critically nationhood in a global context;
- 6. assess the historical structural dimensions of governance in the Caribbean; and
- 7. evaluate public policy and decision-making.Fundamentals of GovernanceLesson 1
- 8. Fundamentals of GovernanceLearning objective:Students should be able to explain the various models of democracy and their effectiveness in practice.
- 9. Models of DemocracyDefining democracyThe origins of the term democracy can be traced back to Ancient Greece. The terminology is derived from the Greek words kratos, meaning power or rule and from demos, meaning people.these words combine mean ‘rule by the people’.
- 10. Models of DemocracyThere are variouscontrasting models of democracy:Classical democracyProtective democracyDevelopmental democracyPeople’s democracyLiberal democracy
- 11. Classical democracyThe word democracy has different meanings to many people, this promiscuousness, according to Heywood (2007), “has threatened the term’s undoing as a meaningful political concept.Among the many meanings are the following:a form of government in which the people rule themselves directlyA system of rule that secure the rights and interests of the minorities by placing checks upon the power of the majority.A society based on equal opportunity and individual merit, rather than hierarchy and privilege,
- 12. Classical democracyQuestions central to defining democracy:Who are the people?
- 13. In what sense should the people rule?
- 14. How far should the people rule extend?Models of DemocracyClassical democracyThis model of democracy is based on the polis, or city-state of Athens Greece.The form of direct democracy is portrayed as the only ideal system of popular participation.Athenian democracy can be described as a form of government by mass meetings.All major decisions were made by the Assembly to which all citizens belong.Officials were chosen by ballots to demonstrate that a microcosm of the citizenry participated
- 15. Models of DemocracyClassical democracy (con’t)• Every Athenian citizen (male over 20 yearsof age) had the right to attend, to speakand to vote in the meetings of theAssembly which met 40 times a year• Decisions at the Assembly were taken onmajority vote and then became law• Every citizen belonged to one of ten ‘tribes’and each year 50 members of each tribewere chosen to sit on the Council which setagenda for Assembly• Citizens held office for one year, and nomore than twice in a lifetime, except for tengenerals who could be re-elected
- 16. KEY PRINCIPLES OF ATHENIAN DEMOCRACY:• Every citizen should have the right to voteand to hold office• The duty of all citizens is to participateactively in the system• Decisions should be made by the majorityvote
- 17. Models of democracyProtective DemocracyThe idea of direct democracy was shelved. In the 17th and 18th centuries the focus was on protecting citizens from the encroachment of government, hence protective democracy.John Locke argued in the 17th century that the right to vote was based on the existence of natural rights (God-given rights that are fundamental to human beings and are inalienable).
- 18. Models of democracyLocke argued that if government, through taxation, has the power to expropriate property, citizen were entitled to control the composition of the legislature. Democracy now meant a system of government by consent, operating through a representative assembly.Jeremy Bentham and John Mills, utilitarian theorists in the 18th century proposed a radial approach and advanced their argument in support of individual interest. Bentham opined that individuals seek pleasure and avoid pain, which was a way of promoting ‘the greatest happiness for the greatest number.’
- 19. Models of democracyJohn MillsHis overall concern was with self development, and laissez faire policies seemed to provide the scope needed for individual freedom.
- 20. Models of democracyThe critical point of protective democracy is that it aims to give people the widest scope to live their lives as they choose. This liberty must then be protected by a mechanism of the separation of powers via separate executive, legislature and judiciary.
- 21. Developmental democracyJean-Jacques Rousseauprovided an alternative view to the democratic theory. At the centre of Rousseau’s model is the general will: the genuine interests of a collective body, equivalent to the common good; the will of all provided each person acts selflessly. He proposed that ‘ no citizen shall be rich enough to buy another, and none so poor as to be forced to sell himself.’Rousseau’s system of radical development required economic equality. Development of self can only be achieved when citizen by participate in decisions that shape the their lives.Mills views are also instructive as he promotes the ‘highest and harmonious’ development of individual capacities, by participating citizen enhance their understanding, strengthen their sensibilities, and achieve the highest personal development.
- 22. People’s democracyThe term people democracy is derived from the orthodox communist regime.Karl Marx believed in the principle of a democracy based its implication of egalitarian prospects and thought of a society in which there was common ownership of wealth (social democracy)He believed the overthrow of capitalism would lead to the flourishing of a genuine democracyA system of ‘bourgeois’ democracy would be replaced by ‘proletarian’ democracy.He predicted that class antagonisms would dissolved and the capitalist state would ‘wither away’. There would only be one class
- 23. Liberal DemocracyLiberal democracy is accepted as the worldwide practices of politics. Its key constructs are:Indirect or representative form of democracy in which political office is gained by success in regular elections.It is based on competition and electoral choice.There is a clear distinction between the state and civil society.
- 24. Liberal democracyVarious interpretation of liberal democracy as advanced by the following:PluralismElitismCorporatismThe new rightMarxism
- 25. The pluralist viewThe pluralists argued that society is ruled by competing organized groups in which individuals are represented largely through their membership, and all groups have access to the policy process. The main features of the pluralist perspective are as follows:There is a wide dispersal of political power amongst competing groups. There is a high degree of responsiveness with group leaders being accountable to membersThere is a neutral government machine that is sufficiently fragmented to offer groups a number of points of access.
- 26. Elitist view Elitism developed as a critique of egalitarian ideas such as democracy and socialism (Heywood2007). Classical elitists argue that democracy is a ‘foolish delusion’, according to them the privileged minority in society always dominate with political power. It is this minority group that organize and make decisions, even in parliamentary democracy.
- 27. Corporatist viewNeo corporatism or liberal corporatism gives rise to ‘tripartite government’ in which government is conducted through organizations, state officials, employers’ groups and unions to deal directly with one another.
- 28. Marxist viewThe Marxists view of democracy is that power can not be evenly dispersed in society as long as class power is unequally distributed.