SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Nov 6th, 2014 Gaithersburg, MD
? 
? 
IMPACT = Social & economic impact on the U.S. society
Scientific Value 
Commercial 
User Value 
Publication 1 
Publication 2 
Publication ... 
* A Best Guess is 100% better than nothing
Filed Patents 
Visibility to business execs, entrepreneurs and investors 
Visibility to industry research community and academia
Transferring Value From Lab To Market
Research 
Results from lab 
Large Corporations and Spin-offs 
New Products in Marketplace = Impact & Benefit 
•Publications 
•Conferences 
•CRADA 
•IP Licensing
Market 
Assessment 
(EIR) 
Business 
Model 
(EIR) 
Invention 
disclosure, 
IP filing 
• Novelty 
• Prior-art 
• Match with 
NIST mission 
• Ready for licensing 
& 
• Ready for spin-off 
• Market potential 
• Validated value 
proposition 
Commercial 
IMPACT 
AK 9/16/2014 
Markets and customers 
Inventor’s 
Value 
Proposition 
• Commercial 
value 
proposition 
hypothesis 
Draft diagram, similar programs under discussion at NIST
I-Corps 6 weeks Team of 3 20 h per week 100 customer calls
NIST Inventor + EIR 5-10 customer calls = value proposition 1.0 hypothesis validated I-Corps, TEDCO, IP-Crossing, etc. outsourced programs* 
*Future programs & outside providers being evaluated at PTO
(1) Clarity (Commercial Value) (2) Communication (Commercial language) 
To maximise NIST’s IMPACT on the market, we need: (1) Clarity (Commercial Value vs. Scientific Value) (2) Communication (Commercial Language vs. Patenting Language)
Building Business.
Time 
Company Growth 
No need for product 
Good-enough Solutions available already 
Market/business not big enough 
Entrepreneur Mistake #1: Fell in love with his first idea/product! 
Entrepreneur Mistake #3: Failed to test and validate Value Proposition! 
Entrepreneur Mistake #2: Failed in assessing the market size! 
3 Ways to Fail:
66% of succesful startups CHANGE their original plans
”No plan survives first contact with the enemy.” - Helmuth von Moltke the Elder
”No business plan survives first contact with a customer.” 
- Steve Blank 
”No business plan survives first contact with a customer.” - Steve Blank
”Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.” - Mike Tyson 
”Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.” - Mike Tyson
A dynamic diagram of business ... just a set of hypotheses 
(Business) Plan Does NOT Guarantee Success
http://www.slideshare.net/sblank/lean-launchpad-educators-handbook-sept-2013
Lean Startup:
Your BUSINESS MODEL is the PRODUCT
Lean Startup Myths: 
(1) Lean startup is Bootsrapping! 
(2) Lean startup is a shortcut!
PROBLEM/SOLUTION FIT 
Big enough problem vs. unique solution? 
Markets and customers
PROBLEM/SOLUTION 
FIT 
PRODUCT/MARKET 
FIT 
Using MVP, validate that 
A)Customers want your product and 
B)Business model is scaleable/repeatable 
Markets and customers 
MVP
PROBLEM/SOLUTION FIT 
PRODUCT/MARKET FIT 
SCALE 
SCALE: execute business and 
grow your Gross Margin faster than your OPEX! 
Markets and customers 
MVP
Customers don’t care about your solution.
Customers only care about their PROBLEM.
Value Proposition.
VALUE = BENEFITS – COSTS 
Easy! 
...whose benefit?
VALUE PROPOSITION = Defines the benefits the end-users will gain from your invention
Value Proposition for scientific invention
NIST Value Proposition Toolbox 
1.WHAT is the problem? 
2.WHO has the problem? 
3.WHAT are the current methods of solving the problem? 
4.WHAT is your solution and its advantage? 
5.WHAT is the customer benefit from your advantage?
Value Proposition Template 
For [customer], who [wants/needs to do X], our new invention is a [solution with customer language], that provides [the key use- case/benefit it delivers], and unlike competing methods, such as [key competitors/competing methods], our invention [key differentiators, use numbers, or %], at a price [less than, equal to, or higher than competing methods]. 
Adopted from: Crossing the Chasm by Geoffrey Moore
? 
? 
IMPACT = Social & economic impact on the U.S. society
Thank You! Mr. Antti Korhonen Guest Researcher/EIR antti.korhonen@nist.gov Tel: 703-504-8157 For consulting engagements, contact: anttik@takehill.com www.takehill.com

More Related Content

PDF
QM-081-品質控制統計製程管制
PPTX
Business Innovation
PDF
The Value Proposition Canvas vs. The 1-Minute Value Proposition Act: A BETTER...
PPTX
Product Market Fit - How to know your product is market fit
PPTX
Innovation and Entrepreneurship as a Career Opportunity
PPTX
Innovation as a core business process
PPTX
The innovators Dilemma by Aki Inoue Anuar Beibytov Yihua (Elaine) Pan Kheama...
PDF
Design Thinking, Why It Matters
QM-081-品質控制統計製程管制
Business Innovation
The Value Proposition Canvas vs. The 1-Minute Value Proposition Act: A BETTER...
Product Market Fit - How to know your product is market fit
Innovation and Entrepreneurship as a Career Opportunity
Innovation as a core business process
The innovators Dilemma by Aki Inoue Anuar Beibytov Yihua (Elaine) Pan Kheama...
Design Thinking, Why It Matters

What's hot (15)

PPT
ProIdeal Plus: First Annual Project Review Meeting
PDF
Idea Validation using Validation Board
PPTX
ARPA- E Steve Blank Presentation
PPTX
Lecture 1: Business Model & Customer Development
PDF
Business Model Design
PDF
Tools for design thinking - University of Virginia
PPTX
Using jobs-to-be-done to design better user experiences (UX Cambridge 2017)
PPTX
Design Thinking in Project Management
PPTX
Design Thinking For Innovation.pptx
PDF
How-to Build a Minimum Viable Product (MVP)
PPTX
How to find product market fit
PPTX
The search for Product-Market Fit
PPTX
Design thinking
PPTX
Trl and value chain
PDF
Portfolio Pitch
ProIdeal Plus: First Annual Project Review Meeting
Idea Validation using Validation Board
ARPA- E Steve Blank Presentation
Lecture 1: Business Model & Customer Development
Business Model Design
Tools for design thinking - University of Virginia
Using jobs-to-be-done to design better user experiences (UX Cambridge 2017)
Design Thinking in Project Management
Design Thinking For Innovation.pptx
How-to Build a Minimum Viable Product (MVP)
How to find product market fit
The search for Product-Market Fit
Design thinking
Trl and value chain
Portfolio Pitch
Ad

Similar to Value Proposition for scientific invention (20)

PPTX
B2 b marketing part 2 prof abha wankhede
PPTX
Startup Workshop #1: Product/Market Fit
PPTX
Startup entrepreneurship with Shlomo Maital
PPT
What customers want
PPT
Is there a market for my new product nf programme 2012 mirc athlone
PPTX
Introduction to Running Lean Startups
PPT
Entrepreneurship class 2
PPT
New Product Development by Dr. Ranjan Kantha
PPT
New Product Development by Dr. Ranjan Kantha
PPT
Principles And Strategies For Technology Startups 10 09 09
PPTX
Product Management - Development of New product
PPTX
New product development
PDF
Emerce eTravel - 5 startups lessons to build better products faster
PDF
From a concept to viable business — How do we know if we are building the rig...
PDF
From a concept to viable business — How do we know if we are building the rig...
PPTX
786-PRODUCT-DESIGN-ARC-4302-3-2-3-V-II-CHAPTER-1-03032020-converted.pptx
PDF
From Pain to Cash - Building software products as B2B founders
PDF
Innovation day 2013 1.4 zane smilga (verhaert) - give your million idea a c...
PDF
Product Development - Entrepreneurship 101 (2013/2014)
PDF
Innovation Ready: A Practical Guide
B2 b marketing part 2 prof abha wankhede
Startup Workshop #1: Product/Market Fit
Startup entrepreneurship with Shlomo Maital
What customers want
Is there a market for my new product nf programme 2012 mirc athlone
Introduction to Running Lean Startups
Entrepreneurship class 2
New Product Development by Dr. Ranjan Kantha
New Product Development by Dr. Ranjan Kantha
Principles And Strategies For Technology Startups 10 09 09
Product Management - Development of New product
New product development
Emerce eTravel - 5 startups lessons to build better products faster
From a concept to viable business — How do we know if we are building the rig...
From a concept to viable business — How do we know if we are building the rig...
786-PRODUCT-DESIGN-ARC-4302-3-2-3-V-II-CHAPTER-1-03032020-converted.pptx
From Pain to Cash - Building software products as B2B founders
Innovation day 2013 1.4 zane smilga (verhaert) - give your million idea a c...
Product Development - Entrepreneurship 101 (2013/2014)
Innovation Ready: A Practical Guide
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Tortilla Mexican Grill 发射点犯得上发射点发生发射点犯得上发生
PDF
income tax laws notes important pakistan
PDF
TyAnn Osborn: A Visionary Leader Shaping Corporate Workforce Dynamics
PDF
ANALYZING THE OPPORTUNITIES OF DIGITAL MARKETING IN BANGLADESH TO PROVIDE AN ...
PDF
Family Law: The Role of Communication in Mediation (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PDF
PMB 401-Identification-of-Potential-Biotechnological-Products.pdf
PDF
ICv2 White Paper - Gen Con Trade Day 2025
PDF
533158074-Saudi-Arabia-Companies-List-Contact.pdf
PDF
Satish NS: Fostering Innovation and Sustainability: Haier India’s Customer-Ce...
PDF
Kishore Vora - Best CFO in India to watch in 2025.pdf
PPTX
Project Management_ SMART Projects Class.pptx
PPTX
CTG - Business Update 2Q2025 & 6M2025.pptx
PPTX
TRAINNING, DEVELOPMENT AND APPRAISAL.pptx
PDF
Booking.com The Global AI Sentiment Report 2025
PDF
Robin Fischer: A Visionary Leader Making a Difference in Healthcare, One Day ...
PDF
Keppel_Proposed Divestment of M1 Limited
PDF
Nante Industrial Plug Factory: Engineering Quality for Modern Power Applications
PDF
THE COMPLETE GUIDE TO BUILDING PASSIVE INCOME ONLINE
PDF
Ron Thomas - Top Influential Business Leaders Shaping the Modern Industry – 2025
PPTX
operations management : demand supply ch
Tortilla Mexican Grill 发射点犯得上发射点发生发射点犯得上发生
income tax laws notes important pakistan
TyAnn Osborn: A Visionary Leader Shaping Corporate Workforce Dynamics
ANALYZING THE OPPORTUNITIES OF DIGITAL MARKETING IN BANGLADESH TO PROVIDE AN ...
Family Law: The Role of Communication in Mediation (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PMB 401-Identification-of-Potential-Biotechnological-Products.pdf
ICv2 White Paper - Gen Con Trade Day 2025
533158074-Saudi-Arabia-Companies-List-Contact.pdf
Satish NS: Fostering Innovation and Sustainability: Haier India’s Customer-Ce...
Kishore Vora - Best CFO in India to watch in 2025.pdf
Project Management_ SMART Projects Class.pptx
CTG - Business Update 2Q2025 & 6M2025.pptx
TRAINNING, DEVELOPMENT AND APPRAISAL.pptx
Booking.com The Global AI Sentiment Report 2025
Robin Fischer: A Visionary Leader Making a Difference in Healthcare, One Day ...
Keppel_Proposed Divestment of M1 Limited
Nante Industrial Plug Factory: Engineering Quality for Modern Power Applications
THE COMPLETE GUIDE TO BUILDING PASSIVE INCOME ONLINE
Ron Thomas - Top Influential Business Leaders Shaping the Modern Industry – 2025
operations management : demand supply ch

Value Proposition for scientific invention

  • 1. Nov 6th, 2014 Gaithersburg, MD
  • 2. ? ? IMPACT = Social & economic impact on the U.S. society
  • 3. Scientific Value Commercial User Value Publication 1 Publication 2 Publication ... * A Best Guess is 100% better than nothing
  • 4. Filed Patents Visibility to business execs, entrepreneurs and investors Visibility to industry research community and academia
  • 5. Transferring Value From Lab To Market
  • 6. Research Results from lab Large Corporations and Spin-offs New Products in Marketplace = Impact & Benefit •Publications •Conferences •CRADA •IP Licensing
  • 7. Market Assessment (EIR) Business Model (EIR) Invention disclosure, IP filing • Novelty • Prior-art • Match with NIST mission • Ready for licensing & • Ready for spin-off • Market potential • Validated value proposition Commercial IMPACT AK 9/16/2014 Markets and customers Inventor’s Value Proposition • Commercial value proposition hypothesis Draft diagram, similar programs under discussion at NIST
  • 8. I-Corps 6 weeks Team of 3 20 h per week 100 customer calls
  • 9. NIST Inventor + EIR 5-10 customer calls = value proposition 1.0 hypothesis validated I-Corps, TEDCO, IP-Crossing, etc. outsourced programs* *Future programs & outside providers being evaluated at PTO
  • 10. (1) Clarity (Commercial Value) (2) Communication (Commercial language) To maximise NIST’s IMPACT on the market, we need: (1) Clarity (Commercial Value vs. Scientific Value) (2) Communication (Commercial Language vs. Patenting Language)
  • 12. Time Company Growth No need for product Good-enough Solutions available already Market/business not big enough Entrepreneur Mistake #1: Fell in love with his first idea/product! Entrepreneur Mistake #3: Failed to test and validate Value Proposition! Entrepreneur Mistake #2: Failed in assessing the market size! 3 Ways to Fail:
  • 13. 66% of succesful startups CHANGE their original plans
  • 14. ”No plan survives first contact with the enemy.” - Helmuth von Moltke the Elder
  • 15. ”No business plan survives first contact with a customer.” - Steve Blank ”No business plan survives first contact with a customer.” - Steve Blank
  • 16. ”Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.” - Mike Tyson ”Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.” - Mike Tyson
  • 17. A dynamic diagram of business ... just a set of hypotheses (Business) Plan Does NOT Guarantee Success
  • 20. Your BUSINESS MODEL is the PRODUCT
  • 21. Lean Startup Myths: (1) Lean startup is Bootsrapping! (2) Lean startup is a shortcut!
  • 22. PROBLEM/SOLUTION FIT Big enough problem vs. unique solution? Markets and customers
  • 23. PROBLEM/SOLUTION FIT PRODUCT/MARKET FIT Using MVP, validate that A)Customers want your product and B)Business model is scaleable/repeatable Markets and customers MVP
  • 24. PROBLEM/SOLUTION FIT PRODUCT/MARKET FIT SCALE SCALE: execute business and grow your Gross Margin faster than your OPEX! Markets and customers MVP
  • 25. Customers don’t care about your solution.
  • 26. Customers only care about their PROBLEM.
  • 28. VALUE = BENEFITS – COSTS Easy! ...whose benefit?
  • 29. VALUE PROPOSITION = Defines the benefits the end-users will gain from your invention
  • 31. NIST Value Proposition Toolbox 1.WHAT is the problem? 2.WHO has the problem? 3.WHAT are the current methods of solving the problem? 4.WHAT is your solution and its advantage? 5.WHAT is the customer benefit from your advantage?
  • 32. Value Proposition Template For [customer], who [wants/needs to do X], our new invention is a [solution with customer language], that provides [the key use- case/benefit it delivers], and unlike competing methods, such as [key competitors/competing methods], our invention [key differentiators, use numbers, or %], at a price [less than, equal to, or higher than competing methods]. Adopted from: Crossing the Chasm by Geoffrey Moore
  • 33. ? ? IMPACT = Social & economic impact on the U.S. society
  • 34. Thank You! Mr. Antti Korhonen Guest Researcher/EIR antti.korhonen@nist.gov Tel: 703-504-8157 For consulting engagements, contact: anttik@takehill.com www.takehill.com