SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Open access is not enough,
information skills are also needed
Open Access, Open Science and Open Research Culture Session /
6th International Conference on Digital Learning and Innovations in Libraries (ICDLIL 2020)
Association of Indian Law Libraries, National Law University Delhi, Chanakya National Law
University, Patna and Modern Rohini Education Society, New Delhi
September 05-06, New Delhi, INDIA
Jesús Lau, PhD
jlau@uv.mx / jesuslau@gmail.com / www.jesuslau.com.mx /jesuslau: FB, Twitter,
Instagram, Flickr, LinkedIn, Google Academic, Research.edu
Researcher, Faculty of Pedagogy, Universidad Veracruzana, Region Veracruz,
Boca del Río, Veracruz, MEXICO
www.uv.mx
September 4, 2020
*This presentation version builds on previous related ones
Topics
1. Open Access information in Latin
America
2. Info-Skills Role in OA Information
3. A call to info skills action: Syllabus
rubric for higher education proposal
Open Access in Latin America
First Part
Redalyc: Latin America OA Journal Repository
https://www.redalyc.org/home.oa
Scielo: Another OA Ibero American Repository
https://scielo.org/es/
La Referencia: An OA Repository Federation
http://www.lareferencia.info/es/
OpenAIRE
https://www.openaire.eu/
DOAJ: Information Reservoir
https://doaj.org/
Info-Skills Role in OA Information
Second Part
Access
Identify need / Express /
Search / Locate
Core skills Subsidiary skills
Analyze / Induction / Deduction
(Understand) / Process
Apply / Learn / Ethics /
Communicate / Reproduce / Produce
Evaluation/
Understanding
Use
Lau, Jesus (2010) Conceptual Relationship of Information Literacy and Media Literacy
Info-Competencies: Knowledge, skills, and attitudes
Holistic Learning
Holistic
Learning
21st. Century
literacies
INFORMATION LITERACY
ICT SKILLS – MEDIA LITERACY
LITERACY
ORAL COMMUNICATION
REASONING
Other
information
Skills
Digital
technology
Use
Use of
Communication
Tools
Use of
Networks
Sift media
messages
Analyze
media
messages
Other ICT /
Media Skills
Reading Writing Numeracy
Other Basic
Skills
Speaking Listening
Thinking Skills
Definition and
articulation of
information
need
Location and
access of
information
Assessment
of
information
Organization
of
information
Use of
information
Communication
and ethical use
of information
Info-Communication Skills Constellation
A Call to Info Skills Action:
Syllabus Rubric for Higher Education
First Part
Rubric Elements
1. Promotes Information Skills
Development
2. Avoids Textbooks or Anthologies
3. Includes Different Source Types
4. Literature Is Available in the
Library
5. Relies on Electronic and Copyright
Licensed Materials
1. Incorporates Foreign Language
Readings
2. Literature Is Current
3. Promotes ICT Use
4. Requests a Term Paper
5. Applies Research Methodology
and Paper Style Standards
Components 1-2
1. Promotes Information Skills Development. The
course learning activities promote search, retrieval, evaluation
and use of information and media by the student.
2. Avoids Textbooks or Anthologies. The course does not
include textbooks or anthologies. Professor allows students to
find relevant information by themselves. If a textbook is
required, professors need to justify it, and book needs to be in
electronic format.
Components 3-4
3. Includes Different Source Types. The course includes varied
literature, ideally in the following proportion:
– Books 20-40%
– Scientific articles 40-50%
– Other documents in digital format, for example, websites, databases,
Twitter, lectures, videos, podcasts, movies, documentaries, and maps,
among others. 40-50%
4. Literature Is Available in the Library. Includes information sources
available in CETYS libraries or have been ordered for acquisition.
Component 5-6
5. Relies on Electronic and Copyright Licensed Materials. The
electronic sources have either copyright clearance, are open
access, or are under license such as that of Creative Commons.
6. Incorporates Foreign Language Readings. It includes a
minimum of 50% of material in English or other foreign
languages, ​​and the rest in Spanish, depending on the subject.
Components 7-8
7. Literature Is Current. Bibliography is current, 50% of sources are
recent, and the rest may be classics within the discipline. Ideal time
span by discipline is:
– Science and Engineering: 5 years
– Social sciences, business & administration:10 years
– Humanities: 15 years.
8. Promotes ICT Use. The course requires students to use information
and communication technology in its learning activities, in addition
to the implementing Blackboard (Learning Platform).
Components 9-10
9. Requests a Term Paper. There is a strong recommendation that
students write at least one term paper, where they show
information skills proficiency (See Appendix of Recommendations).
10. Applies Research Methodology and Paper Style Standards. The
term paper requires research methodology and the use of style
standards. CETYS recommends: Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E.
(2013) Manual for Submission of Written Works. Tijuana, BC,
Mexico: CETYS University. / Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E.
(2012) Guide to Write Academic Papers. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS
University.
Full Rubric
• 1. Promotes Information Skills Development. The
course learning activities promote search, retrieval,
evaluation and use of information and media by the
student.
• 2. Avoids Textbooks or Anthologies. The course does
not include textbooks or anthologies. Professor allows
students to find relevant information by themselves. If
a textbook is required, professors need to justify it,
and book needs to be in electronic format.
• 3. Includes Different Source Types. The course
includes varied literature, ideally in the following
proportion:
– Books 20-40%
– Scientific articles 40-50%
– Other documents in digital format, for example, websites,
databases, Twitter, lectures, videos, podcasts, movies,
documentaries, and maps, among others. 40-50
• 4. Literature Is Available in the Library. Includes
information sources available in CETYS libraries or
have been ordered for acquisition.
• 5. Relies on Electronic and Copyright Licensed
Materials. The electronic sources have either
copyright clearance, are open access, or are under
license such as that of Creative Commons.
• 6. Incorporates Foreign Language Readings. It includes
a minimum of 50% of material in English or other
foreign languages, ​​and the rest in Spanish, depending
on the subject.
• 7. Literature Is Current. Bibliography is current, 50% of
sources are recent, and the rest may be classics within
the discipline. Ideal time span by discipline is:
– Science and Engineering: 5 years
– Social sciences, business & administration:10 years
– Humanities: 15 years.
• 8. Promotes ICT Use. The course requires students to
use information and communication technology in its
learning activities, in addition to the implementing
Blackboard (Learning Platform).
• 9. Requests a Term Paper. There is a strong
recommendation that students write at least one term
paper, where they show information skills proficiency
(See Appendix of Recommendations).
• 10. Applies Research Methodology and Paper Style
Standards. The term paper requires research
methodology and the use of style standards. CETYS
recommends: Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E.
(2013) Manual for Submission of Written
Works. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS University. / Bonilla,
J.L., and Montes, M.E. (2012) Guide to Write Academic
Papers. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS University.
Conclusions
• Open access information is an excellent initiative for learning and
research
• However, information skills are needed to fully benefit from open
access information
• Educational systems ought to foster information skills: Info-Skills
Sylabus Rubric are a big step
• Info-skills enable graduates to access, evaluate and critically use
and contribute to open access resources

More Related Content

PPTX
Convergence of Media and Information Skills, and The Role of UNESCO MIL Alliance
PPTX
Www in-education
PPT
Information Literacy In The Eyes Of Teachers And Librarians
PPTX
Mapping teaching and learning as (dis)location/(re)location: the role of stud...
PPTX
Web 2.0 In University Life
PPTX
Learning at the back door? (Re)considering the role of open and distance lear...
PPTX
Information literacy
PPT
Transliteracy the latest stage of the literacy continuum.
Convergence of Media and Information Skills, and The Role of UNESCO MIL Alliance
Www in-education
Information Literacy In The Eyes Of Teachers And Librarians
Mapping teaching and learning as (dis)location/(re)location: the role of stud...
Web 2.0 In University Life
Learning at the back door? (Re)considering the role of open and distance lear...
Information literacy
Transliteracy the latest stage of the literacy continuum.

What's hot (17)

PPTX
Information Literacy Grade 11
PDF
2010 Copyright Fair Use Resources
PPTX
Hed 510
PDF
Media and information sources
PPT
Young and Wired: How today's young tech elite will influence the libraries of...
PPTX
Eng 204 sunumu
PPTX
Information Literacy
PPT
Technology Lesson Plan (Progressive Era)
PPTX
Gate Keepers to Tour Guides
PPTX
Information literacy
PPT
Digital Tattoo SCOPE Presentation
PPT
Future of open education scenarios
PPTX
(Un)framing online/blended learning: getting the mix right
PDF
Slides - Leveraging institutional open practices to promote access- AVU Confe...
PDF
Open online courses call for papers sept11
PPTX
Managing Today's Digital Divide
PPTX
Promoting information literacy in the academic library
Information Literacy Grade 11
2010 Copyright Fair Use Resources
Hed 510
Media and information sources
Young and Wired: How today's young tech elite will influence the libraries of...
Eng 204 sunumu
Information Literacy
Technology Lesson Plan (Progressive Era)
Gate Keepers to Tour Guides
Information literacy
Digital Tattoo SCOPE Presentation
Future of open education scenarios
(Un)framing online/blended learning: getting the mix right
Slides - Leveraging institutional open practices to promote access- AVU Confe...
Open online courses call for papers sept11
Managing Today's Digital Divide
Promoting information literacy in the academic library
Ad

Similar to Open access is not enough, information skills are also needed (20)

PPT
Aberlecture 011211
DOCX
Article review
DOCX
Article review
DOCX
Article review
PPTX
Faculty Support: Shaping an Information Literacy Learning Activity Handbook
PPT
NetworkEd2011
PDF
The use of the internet in higher education
DOCX
syllabus-2020-edited.docx
PPT
Network Ed2011
PPT
LILO Workshop
PPT
DELILA: information literacy and open educational resources (OERs)
PDF
STCC Library Information Literacy Assignment Tips 2017
PPTX
Faculty Support: Shaping an Information Literacy Learning Activity Handbook ...
PDF
Glogster Edu Educator Resource Library
PPT
Provide an overview of the issues relating to the use of learning technologie...
PDF
Com510 syllabus
PPT
Educational Technology (Quintana, Almendros, Pimienta)
PPTX
Crash course on open educational resources
PPT
Informatica
Aberlecture 011211
Article review
Article review
Article review
Faculty Support: Shaping an Information Literacy Learning Activity Handbook
NetworkEd2011
The use of the internet in higher education
syllabus-2020-edited.docx
Network Ed2011
LILO Workshop
DELILA: information literacy and open educational resources (OERs)
STCC Library Information Literacy Assignment Tips 2017
Faculty Support: Shaping an Information Literacy Learning Activity Handbook ...
Glogster Edu Educator Resource Library
Provide an overview of the issues relating to the use of learning technologie...
Com510 syllabus
Educational Technology (Quintana, Almendros, Pimienta)
Crash course on open educational resources
Informatica
Ad

More from Jesus Lau (20)

PDF
Pon UV Docencia Investigacion MIL 23 04 19.pptx.pdf
PPTX
Pon Curso UV - IA ChatGPT - Subase barco FINAL 23 05 11 .pptx
PPTX
Pon Bosnia - MIL Curriculum 22 12 07.pptx
PPTX
Pon Nigeria MIL Trust 22 10 25 (1).pptx
PPTX
Pon CDMX MIL CNB Apertura 22 10 24 (1).pptx
PPTX
Pon Beijing Media MIL Curriculum 22 09 19.pptx
PPTX
Pon Info Comp Aprend - Rubrica 22 09 07 .pptx
PPTX
Tendencias post-pandémicas: en educación e info-servicios
PPTX
Habilidades mediáticas e informacionales; papel de la Alianza MIL de UNESCO
PPTX
Infodimia: Estrategias para crear una info-cultura sólida
PPTX
Docencia Virtual en la Educación Superior:
PPTX
Info-habilidades mediáticas e informacionales UNESCO:
PPTX
Perfil de competência em Informação do bibliotecário no cenário de fake news ...
PPTX
Navigate information oceans with Media and Information Competencies
PPTX
Outstanding Virtual Libraries and Museums
PPTX
IFLA Newcomers Inducción LAC
PPTX
GAPMIL Alianza Global de Asociaciones sobre Desarrollo de Habilidades Mediáti...
PPTX
Habilidades mediáticas e informacionales, y cultura informativa para la const...
PPTX
Cultura informativa: Fomento cognitivo en el aula de competencias mediáticas ...
PPTX
Praxis: info-docente: Actividades de aprendizaje para el desarrollo de habili...
Pon UV Docencia Investigacion MIL 23 04 19.pptx.pdf
Pon Curso UV - IA ChatGPT - Subase barco FINAL 23 05 11 .pptx
Pon Bosnia - MIL Curriculum 22 12 07.pptx
Pon Nigeria MIL Trust 22 10 25 (1).pptx
Pon CDMX MIL CNB Apertura 22 10 24 (1).pptx
Pon Beijing Media MIL Curriculum 22 09 19.pptx
Pon Info Comp Aprend - Rubrica 22 09 07 .pptx
Tendencias post-pandémicas: en educación e info-servicios
Habilidades mediáticas e informacionales; papel de la Alianza MIL de UNESCO
Infodimia: Estrategias para crear una info-cultura sólida
Docencia Virtual en la Educación Superior:
Info-habilidades mediáticas e informacionales UNESCO:
Perfil de competência em Informação do bibliotecário no cenário de fake news ...
Navigate information oceans with Media and Information Competencies
Outstanding Virtual Libraries and Museums
IFLA Newcomers Inducción LAC
GAPMIL Alianza Global de Asociaciones sobre Desarrollo de Habilidades Mediáti...
Habilidades mediáticas e informacionales, y cultura informativa para la const...
Cultura informativa: Fomento cognitivo en el aula de competencias mediáticas ...
Praxis: info-docente: Actividades de aprendizaje para el desarrollo de habili...

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
RTP_AR_KS1_Tutor's Guide_English [FOR REPRODUCTION].pdf
PPTX
Microbial diseases, their pathogenesis and prophylaxis
DOC
Soft-furnishing-By-Architect-A.F.M.Mohiuddin-Akhand.doc
PDF
grade 11-chemistry_fetena_net_5883.pdf teacher guide for all student
PPTX
Tissue processing ( HISTOPATHOLOGICAL TECHNIQUE
PDF
Supply Chain Operations Speaking Notes -ICLT Program
PDF
Trump Administration's workforce development strategy
PDF
Complications of Minimal Access Surgery at WLH
PDF
VCE English Exam - Section C Student Revision Booklet
PPTX
Orientation - ARALprogram of Deped to the Parents.pptx
PDF
Microbial disease of the cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
PPTX
Lesson notes of climatology university.
PDF
STATICS OF THE RIGID BODIES Hibbelers.pdf
PPTX
1st Inaugural Professorial Lecture held on 19th February 2020 (Governance and...
PPTX
Cell Structure & Organelles in detailed.
PDF
2.FourierTransform-ShortQuestionswithAnswers.pdf
PDF
Black Hat USA 2025 - Micro ICS Summit - ICS/OT Threat Landscape
PPTX
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
PDF
OBE - B.A.(HON'S) IN INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE -Ar.MOHIUDDIN.pdf
PDF
Weekly quiz Compilation Jan -July 25.pdf
RTP_AR_KS1_Tutor's Guide_English [FOR REPRODUCTION].pdf
Microbial diseases, their pathogenesis and prophylaxis
Soft-furnishing-By-Architect-A.F.M.Mohiuddin-Akhand.doc
grade 11-chemistry_fetena_net_5883.pdf teacher guide for all student
Tissue processing ( HISTOPATHOLOGICAL TECHNIQUE
Supply Chain Operations Speaking Notes -ICLT Program
Trump Administration's workforce development strategy
Complications of Minimal Access Surgery at WLH
VCE English Exam - Section C Student Revision Booklet
Orientation - ARALprogram of Deped to the Parents.pptx
Microbial disease of the cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
Lesson notes of climatology university.
STATICS OF THE RIGID BODIES Hibbelers.pdf
1st Inaugural Professorial Lecture held on 19th February 2020 (Governance and...
Cell Structure & Organelles in detailed.
2.FourierTransform-ShortQuestionswithAnswers.pdf
Black Hat USA 2025 - Micro ICS Summit - ICS/OT Threat Landscape
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
OBE - B.A.(HON'S) IN INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE -Ar.MOHIUDDIN.pdf
Weekly quiz Compilation Jan -July 25.pdf

Open access is not enough, information skills are also needed

  • 1. Open access is not enough, information skills are also needed Open Access, Open Science and Open Research Culture Session / 6th International Conference on Digital Learning and Innovations in Libraries (ICDLIL 2020) Association of Indian Law Libraries, National Law University Delhi, Chanakya National Law University, Patna and Modern Rohini Education Society, New Delhi September 05-06, New Delhi, INDIA Jesús Lau, PhD jlau@uv.mx / jesuslau@gmail.com / www.jesuslau.com.mx /jesuslau: FB, Twitter, Instagram, Flickr, LinkedIn, Google Academic, Research.edu Researcher, Faculty of Pedagogy, Universidad Veracruzana, Region Veracruz, Boca del Río, Veracruz, MEXICO www.uv.mx September 4, 2020 *This presentation version builds on previous related ones
  • 2. Topics 1. Open Access information in Latin America 2. Info-Skills Role in OA Information 3. A call to info skills action: Syllabus rubric for higher education proposal
  • 3. Open Access in Latin America First Part
  • 4. Redalyc: Latin America OA Journal Repository https://www.redalyc.org/home.oa
  • 5. Scielo: Another OA Ibero American Repository https://scielo.org/es/
  • 6. La Referencia: An OA Repository Federation http://www.lareferencia.info/es/
  • 9. Info-Skills Role in OA Information Second Part
  • 10. Access Identify need / Express / Search / Locate Core skills Subsidiary skills Analyze / Induction / Deduction (Understand) / Process Apply / Learn / Ethics / Communicate / Reproduce / Produce Evaluation/ Understanding Use Lau, Jesus (2010) Conceptual Relationship of Information Literacy and Media Literacy Info-Competencies: Knowledge, skills, and attitudes
  • 12. INFORMATION LITERACY ICT SKILLS – MEDIA LITERACY LITERACY ORAL COMMUNICATION REASONING Other information Skills Digital technology Use Use of Communication Tools Use of Networks Sift media messages Analyze media messages Other ICT / Media Skills Reading Writing Numeracy Other Basic Skills Speaking Listening Thinking Skills Definition and articulation of information need Location and access of information Assessment of information Organization of information Use of information Communication and ethical use of information Info-Communication Skills Constellation
  • 13. A Call to Info Skills Action: Syllabus Rubric for Higher Education First Part
  • 14. Rubric Elements 1. Promotes Information Skills Development 2. Avoids Textbooks or Anthologies 3. Includes Different Source Types 4. Literature Is Available in the Library 5. Relies on Electronic and Copyright Licensed Materials 1. Incorporates Foreign Language Readings 2. Literature Is Current 3. Promotes ICT Use 4. Requests a Term Paper 5. Applies Research Methodology and Paper Style Standards
  • 15. Components 1-2 1. Promotes Information Skills Development. The course learning activities promote search, retrieval, evaluation and use of information and media by the student. 2. Avoids Textbooks or Anthologies. The course does not include textbooks or anthologies. Professor allows students to find relevant information by themselves. If a textbook is required, professors need to justify it, and book needs to be in electronic format.
  • 16. Components 3-4 3. Includes Different Source Types. The course includes varied literature, ideally in the following proportion: – Books 20-40% – Scientific articles 40-50% – Other documents in digital format, for example, websites, databases, Twitter, lectures, videos, podcasts, movies, documentaries, and maps, among others. 40-50% 4. Literature Is Available in the Library. Includes information sources available in CETYS libraries or have been ordered for acquisition.
  • 17. Component 5-6 5. Relies on Electronic and Copyright Licensed Materials. The electronic sources have either copyright clearance, are open access, or are under license such as that of Creative Commons. 6. Incorporates Foreign Language Readings. It includes a minimum of 50% of material in English or other foreign languages, ​​and the rest in Spanish, depending on the subject.
  • 18. Components 7-8 7. Literature Is Current. Bibliography is current, 50% of sources are recent, and the rest may be classics within the discipline. Ideal time span by discipline is: – Science and Engineering: 5 years – Social sciences, business & administration:10 years – Humanities: 15 years. 8. Promotes ICT Use. The course requires students to use information and communication technology in its learning activities, in addition to the implementing Blackboard (Learning Platform).
  • 19. Components 9-10 9. Requests a Term Paper. There is a strong recommendation that students write at least one term paper, where they show information skills proficiency (See Appendix of Recommendations). 10. Applies Research Methodology and Paper Style Standards. The term paper requires research methodology and the use of style standards. CETYS recommends: Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E. (2013) Manual for Submission of Written Works. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS University. / Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E. (2012) Guide to Write Academic Papers. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS University.
  • 20. Full Rubric • 1. Promotes Information Skills Development. The course learning activities promote search, retrieval, evaluation and use of information and media by the student. • 2. Avoids Textbooks or Anthologies. The course does not include textbooks or anthologies. Professor allows students to find relevant information by themselves. If a textbook is required, professors need to justify it, and book needs to be in electronic format. • 3. Includes Different Source Types. The course includes varied literature, ideally in the following proportion: – Books 20-40% – Scientific articles 40-50% – Other documents in digital format, for example, websites, databases, Twitter, lectures, videos, podcasts, movies, documentaries, and maps, among others. 40-50 • 4. Literature Is Available in the Library. Includes information sources available in CETYS libraries or have been ordered for acquisition. • 5. Relies on Electronic and Copyright Licensed Materials. The electronic sources have either copyright clearance, are open access, or are under license such as that of Creative Commons. • 6. Incorporates Foreign Language Readings. It includes a minimum of 50% of material in English or other foreign languages, ​​and the rest in Spanish, depending on the subject. • 7. Literature Is Current. Bibliography is current, 50% of sources are recent, and the rest may be classics within the discipline. Ideal time span by discipline is: – Science and Engineering: 5 years – Social sciences, business & administration:10 years – Humanities: 15 years. • 8. Promotes ICT Use. The course requires students to use information and communication technology in its learning activities, in addition to the implementing Blackboard (Learning Platform). • 9. Requests a Term Paper. There is a strong recommendation that students write at least one term paper, where they show information skills proficiency (See Appendix of Recommendations). • 10. Applies Research Methodology and Paper Style Standards. The term paper requires research methodology and the use of style standards. CETYS recommends: Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E. (2013) Manual for Submission of Written Works. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS University. / Bonilla, J.L., and Montes, M.E. (2012) Guide to Write Academic Papers. Tijuana, BC, Mexico: CETYS University.
  • 21. Conclusions • Open access information is an excellent initiative for learning and research • However, information skills are needed to fully benefit from open access information • Educational systems ought to foster information skills: Info-Skills Sylabus Rubric are a big step • Info-skills enable graduates to access, evaluate and critically use and contribute to open access resources

Editor's Notes

  • #16: Sugerencia de foto: Textbook https://www.flickr.com/photos/nomadic_lass/5457425293
  • #17: Sugerencia de foto: Biblioteca CETYS
  • #18: Dugerencia de foto: Diccionario https://www.flickr.com/photos/lexnger/6732379801
  • #19: Sugerencia de foto: Alumnos usando blackboard
  • #20: Sugerencia de foto: Alumnos escribiendo, consultando libros o en biblioteca