Ops gen2 phen oa datasharing 19 sep 2011 copy
- 1. No Free Lunch OpenPHACTS/Gen2Phen workshop Jan Velterop – 19 September 2011
- 2. « And they say unto him, we have here but five loaves, and two fishes »
- 3. « And they say h t unto him, we have here but u g five loaves, h o and two r T fishes » f o o d F o
- 4. No miracle; just a fundamental difference between « And they say unto him, we information goods and have here but five loaves, and two fishes »
- 5. No miracle; just a fundamental difference between « And they say unto him, we information goods and have here but es n five loaves, red whe reas and two sha fishes » Dec
- 6. No miracle; just a fundamental difference between « And they say unto him, we information goods and have here but ot* n es n five loaves, ed red whe whe reas s *n and two shar sha fishes » ease Dec Doe decr
- 8. © © © © © © ©© © © © © © ©© © Copyright is an attempt to © eliminate this difference © ©© © © © ©© © ©© ©
- 9. But information flows – like water – it just finds its way
- 10. © © © © © © ©© © ©© © © ©© © © © © ©© © © ©© © ©© ©
- 11. © © © © In science, © © is © © copyright © the © © © © ©© © wrong solution for the wrong © © problem ©© © © © ©© © ©© ©
- 13. Noösphere ✮ ✮ ✮ ✮ ✮ ✮ ✮
- 14. ( ) As opposed to the ‘access-licence-sphere’ or L-sphere
- 15. Science is a bit like a parachute
- 16. Science is a bit like a parachute It works better if it’s open
- 17. Science is a bit like a parachute Does open mean free, gratis?
- 18. But what about Costs?
- 19. But what about Costs?
- 21. Clearly, there is tension in the system
- 23. Perhaps more than you might think
- 24. Hype
- 25. Hypothesis
- 26. Hypocrisy
- 27. t e m S y s g o E
- 28. Men pay most attention to what is their own – less to what is common Ἀριστοτέλης
- 29. The four pillars of sustainability
- 30. ©
- 31. © Sell
- 32. ©
- 34. Open Access is a means to an end; not an end in itself
- 35. What content in OPS?
- 36. What content in OPS? Should it be literature converted to ‘nanopublications’
- 37. What content in OPS? Should it be literature converted to ‘nanopublications’ on-the-fly?
- 38. What content in OPS? Should it be literature converted to ‘nanopublications’ on-the-fly? Is that even possible?
- 40. And what does that make nanopublications?
- 41. And what does that make nanopublications? What are they?
- 42. And what does that make nanopublications? What are they? Data or publications?
- 43. And what does that make nanopublications? What are they? Data or publications? Copyrightable or not?
- 44. Content is King
- 45. Content X is King
- 46. “Used to be”
- 47. ©
- 48. What can be copyrighted?
- 49. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature
- 50. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art
- 51. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama
- 52. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 53. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 54. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 55. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 56. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 57. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 58. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 59. What can be copyrighted? ✓ Literature (including articles, novels, song lyrics and instruction manuals) ✓ Art (including photographs, logos, paintings, maps and architecture) ✓ Music ✓ Sound recordings ✓ Films ✓ Broadcasts ✓ Drama (including dance and mime) ✓ Computer software
- 61. What about data?
- 62. What cannot be copyrighted?
- 63. What cannot be copyrighted? ✓ Data
- 64. What cannot be copyrighted? ✓ Data (Well, depending on what the data are. Factual data are not copyrightable. Creative or expressive data are – think e.g. photos. Even then, not the information and ideas expressed in them) ✓ Any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery
- 65. What cannot be copyrighted? ✓ Data (Well, depending on what the data are. Factual data are not copyrightable. Creative or expressive data are – think e.g. photos. Even then, not the information and ideas expressed in them) ✓ Any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery (Regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied) ✓ Titles, names, short phrases, and slogans
- 66. What cannot be copyrighted? ✓ Data (Well, depending on what the data are. Factual data are not copyrightable. Creative or expressive data are – think e.g. photos. Even then, not the information and ideas expressed in them) ✓ Any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery (Regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied) ✓ Titles, names, short phrases, and slogans
- 67. What cannot be copyrighted? ✓ Data (Well, depending on what the data are. Factual data are not copyrightable. Creative or expressive data are – think e.g. photos. Even then, not the information and ideas expressed in them) ✓ Any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery (Regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied) ✓ Titles, names, short phrases, and slogans
- 68. What cannot be copyrighted? ✓ Data (Well, depending on what the data are. Factual data are not copyrightable. Creative or expressive data are – think e.g. photos. Even then, not the information and ideas expressed in them) ✓ Any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery (Regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied) ✓ Titles, names, short phrases, and slogans Nobody mentions nanopublications!
- 69. Access charges
- 70. Depends on © Access charges
- 71. Depends on © Access charges Not compatible
- 73. Depends on need Authority services
- 74. Depends on need Authority services compatible
- 77. Authority services? Think: ✓ driver’s licence
- 78. Authority services? Think: ✓ driver’s licence ✓ diploma
- 79. Authority services? Think: ✓ driver’s licence ✓ diploma ✓ acceptance in journal
- 80. Authority services? Think: ✓ driver’s licence ✓ diploma ✓ acceptance in journal ...
- 81. Authority services? Think: ✓ driver’s licence ✓ diploma ✓ acceptance in journal ... ...
- 82. Authority services? Think: ✓ driver’s licence ✓ diploma ✓ acceptance in journal ✓ ... acceptance in OPS ...
- 83. t e m S y s g o E
- 84. t e m S y s g o Impact? E
- 86. “Scientific impact is the sound you hear if you drop a feather down the Grand Canyon and wait for the echo.” Paraphrasing Don Marquis, 1878-1937
- 87. “The notion of impact is incoherent, likely to reward the sensationalist and second- rate ... and risks turning academics into door-to-door salesmen for vulgarised versions of their increasingly market- oriented products.” Stefan Collini, professor of intellectual history and English literature at the University of Cambridge
- 88. impact : citation famous : known
- 89. t e m y s Citation, S g o Acknowledgement! E
- 91. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> publish or perish! .
- 92. Articles >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> publish or perish! .
- 93. Articles Data? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> publish or perish! .
- 94. Articles Data? This recent paper (September 7, 2011) . PLoS ONE 6(9): e24357. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0024357 suggests not: >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> publish or perish! “A substantial proportion of original research papers published in high-impact journals are either not subject to any data availability policies, or do not adhere to the data availability instructions in their respective journals.”
- 95. Enable citation (acknowledgement) scores for data
- 96. Enable citation (acknowledgement) scores for data First step: provenance attribution
- 97. ?
- 100. Depends on desire Convenience services
- 101. Depends on desire Convenience services compatible
- 104. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing
- 105. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning
- 106. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning ✓ standardising
- 107. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning ✓ standardising ✓ ranking
- 108. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning ✓ standardising ✓ ranking ✓ aggregating
- 109. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning ✓ standardising ✓ ranking ✓ aggregating ✓ visualising
- 110. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning ✓ standardising ✓ ranking ✓ aggregating ✓ visualising ✓ integrating
- 111. Convenience services? Think: ✓ indexing ✓ cleaning ✓ standardising ✓ ranking ✓ aggregating ✓ visualising ✓ integrating ...
- 112. Convenience services? Doesn’t ‘open’ mean ‘free’? Think: It means ‘free’ as in ‘free to travel’, but if you want to travel fast, you still need to pay for the train
- 113. Does ‘open’ mean ‘immediate’? Not necessarily – Open after a short delay and charging for immediacy may be an option.
- 114. However, paying money is not the only way
- 115. However, paying money is not the only way Paying attention
- 116. Advertising & affiliations compatible
- 117. Depends on usage, appropriate products Advertising & affiliations compatible
- 119. Authority services
- 121. Authority services Convenience services Advertising & affiliations
- 124. Concrete practical small Grand, vague, pipe-dream-oid
- 125. Concrete practical small Grand, vague, pipe-dream-oid
- 127. Every problem has its solution
- 128. Every solution has its problem
- 130. Pictures in slides – acknowledgements • Loaves and fishes mosaic: Benedictine Monastery at the Church of the Multiplication of the Loaves and Fishes • Braided river: unknown • Earth: NASA • Coins: unknown • Parachute: Airborne Systems EPC • Mouse trap: www.wizzairsucks.com • Columns: unknown • Padlock: unknown • Fly swatter: clipart www.cksinfo.com • Louis XVI (by Antoine-François Callet): Wikipedia • Execution of Louis XVI: unknown • Grand Canyon: own photo • Problem Solver: www.funny-wallpapers.com
Editor's Notes
- #2: \n
- #3: \n
- #4: \n
- #5: \n
- #6: \n
- #7: \n
- #8: \n
- #9: \n
- #10: \n
- #11: \n
- #12: \n
- #13: \n
- #14: \n
- #15: \n
- #16: \n
- #17: \n
- #18: \n
- #19: \n
- #20: \n
- #21: \n
- #22: \n
- #23: \n
- #24: \n
- #25: \n
- #26: \n
- #27: \n
- #28: \n
- #29: \n
- #30: \n
- #31: \n
- #32: \n
- #33: \n
- #34: \n
- #35: \n
- #36: \n
- #37: \n
- #38: \n
- #39: \n
- #40: \n
- #41: \n
- #42: \n
- #43: \n
- #44: \n
- #45: \n
- #46: \n
- #47: \n
- #48: \n
- #49: \n
- #50: \n
- #51: \n
- #52: \n
- #53: \n
- #54: \n
- #55: \n
- #56: \n
- #57: \n
- #58: \n
- #59: \n
- #60: \n
- #61: \n
- #62: \n
- #63: \n
- #64: \n
- #65: \n
- #66: \n
- #67: \n
- #68: \n
- #69: \n
- #70: \n
- #71: \n
- #72: \n
- #73: \n
- #74: \n
- #75: \n
- #76: \n
- #77: \n
- #78: \n
- #79: \n
- #80: \n
- #81: \n
- #82: \n
- #83: \n
- #84: \n
- #85: \n
- #86: \n
- #87: \n
- #88: \n
- #89: \n
- #90: \n
- #91: \n
- #92: \n
- #93: \n
- #94: \n
- #95: \n
- #96: \n
- #97: \n
- #98: \n
- #99: \n
- #100: \n
- #101: \n
- #102: \n
- #103: \n
- #104: \n
- #105: \n
- #106: \n
- #107: \n
- #108: \n
- #109: \n
- #110: \n
- #111: \n
- #112: \n
- #113: \n
- #114: \n
- #115: \n
- #116: \n
- #117: \n
- #118: \n
- #119: \n
- #120: \n
- #121: \n
- #122: \n
- #123: \n
- #124: \n
- #125: \n
- #126: \n
- #127: \n
- #128: \n
- #129: \n
- #130: \n
- #131: \n
- #132: \n
- #133: \n
- #134: \n
- #135: \n
- #136: \n
- #137: \n
- #138: \n
- #139: \n
- #140: \n
- #141: \n
- #142: \n
- #143: \n
- #144: \n
- #145: \n
- #146: \n
- #147: \n
- #148: \n
- #149: \n
- #150: \n
- #151: \n
- #152: \n
- #153: \n
- #154: \n
- #155: \n
- #156: \n
- #157: \n
- #158: \n
- #159: \n
- #160: \n
- #161: \n
- #162: \n
- #163: \n
- #164: \n
- #165: \n
- #166: \n
- #167: \n