Organic Click Through Rate Optimisation Tactics - MKGO - June 2018

How to Drive More Organic Traffic
(Without Increasing a Ranking)
Stacey MacNaught
@staceycav #mkgo

After 9 years in SEO, I’ve heard this a fair
few times…
@staceycav #mkgo

In my head, what it really means is…
@staceycav #mkgo

But sometimes…
@staceycav #mkgo

Getting organic traffic isn’t easy.
@staceycav #mkgo

And for all the changes over the years, it’s
still very much the case that…
@staceycav #mkgo

…you don’t drive traffic if you don’t rank
for the right phrases.
@staceycav #mkgo

So a focus on rankings is, in my view,
still essential
(following solid keyword research)
@staceycav #mkgo

But being visible for something isn’t the
only thing you need to consider if you’re
going to drive the traffic.
@staceycav #mkgo

Click Through Rate.
@staceycav #mkgo

And then we’re back to…
@staceycav #mkgo

So, why does it happen?
@staceycav #mkgo

@staceycav #mkgo
1. The Query Has No Volume.

https://kwfinder.com/features/search-volume/

https://moz.com/explorer

2. You’re not really ranking where you
think you are consistently
@staceycav #mkgo

3. Your click through rate is poor.
@staceycav #mkgo

3. Your click through rate is poor.
We can fix this! J
@staceycav #mkgo

So, what’s a good click through rate?

https://www.advancedwebranking.com/cloud/ctrstudy/

Treat datasets like
this as a starting
point only.

29,899 websites.
22 categories.
1,359 sites per category if an (unlikely) even split.

It’s an excellent study. But then…
@staceycav #mkgo

Another study suggests that 35% of
users on desktop don’t click at all.
https://moz.com/blog/state-of-searcher-behavior-revealed
@staceycav #mkgo

And that 57% of users on mobile don’t
click at all.
@staceycav #mkgo

@staceycav #mkgo

These studies often
contradict one another.
But here’s what we do
know for sure…

@staceycav@staceycav #mkgo
Sometimes, users simply
don’t need to click.

@staceycav@staceycav #mkgo
And SERP layouts affect
CTRs hugely.

CTR is (of course)
influenced heavily by
your position
@staceycav

Device affects click
through rate
@staceycav

CTR is different in
different sectors. And
can even fluctuate
seasonally.
@staceycav

So, while studies are a good starting point,
don’t take them as gospel.

If you want to improve your CTR, you
need to know what it is right now.

Search Console is your best friend.
https://search.google.com/search-console
@staceycav #mkgo

Find the keyword(s) you’re most
interested in from your query list
@staceycav #mkgo

Click through for further detail about
each one.
@staceycav #mkgo

You’ll get an export
that looks a bit
like this.
@staceycav #mkgo

Delete all but CTR
and position columns
@staceycav #mkgo

Remove decimals
From position column
@staceycav #mkgo

Order by position and
then get an average for
each position.
@staceycav #mkgo

Then create a shorter
sheet just with the
average CTR for each
Position you have data
for.
@staceycav #mkgo

A full how-to on getting position based
CTR data for your own websites:
https://www.staceymacnaught.co.uk/measuring
-organic-click-through-rate/
@staceycav #mkgo

Now you have at least some data about
your own query level CTR by position.
This will be a key reference point in assessing
the impact of any CTR optimization work you
do.
@staceycav #mkgo

A little housekeeping before we talk
techniques.

My test environment
19 websites in varied sectors ranging from
3,000 to 150,000 monthly organic visits.
Some live commercial websites, others
specifically set up for testing.
@staceycav #mkgo

My test environment
I don’t have as much data as the studies.
And my test environment almost certainly
wouldn’t qualify as “scientific.”
@staceycav #mkgo

My test environment
While I’m testing things, other things are
happening in SERPS, Google as a whole and
with competitors.
@staceycav #mkgo

My test environment
But I often find “tried and tested hands on by
me” to be more useful to me than third party
studies in developing techniques and
experiments.
@staceycav #mkgo

Techniques I’ve tried and tested to
improve click through rate from organic
search

This is about identifying the adjectives that
your potential customers associate as
particularly positive in the context of your
products and services
@staceycav #mkgo

Then using them in your page title and meta
description to compel a user to click.
@staceycav #mkgo

Start by visiting the Feefo or Trustpilot page
for the market leader in your sector.
@staceycav #mkgo

Copy and paste the reviews into a Word doc
or similar and filter out common phrases like
“review,” “thanks,” “2018,” “insurance” etc
@staceycav #mkgo

Pop the rest into any word cloud generator
@staceycav #mkgo

It’s worth adding that this could help you to
uncover new keyword opportunities too:
@staceycav #mkgo

For speed, test in Adwords.
I tested ad headlines including both “quick,”
and “easy,” and “quick” had almost twice
the CTR in paid search.
@staceycav #mkgo

CPCs too High for Testing?
Where possible/relevant, run the ads in other
English speaking countries (Canada,
Australia, New Zealand) where CPCs can be
lower.
@staceycav #mkgo

Budget still an issue?
https://start.usabilityhub.com
@staceycav #mkgo

Budget still an issue?
https://www.google.com/analytics/surveys/
@staceycav #mkgo

Impact of adding “quick,” to life insurance
landing page title and meta description
@staceycav #mkgo

Like for like position 5 - CTR increase
of 50%.
CTR for the landing page optimised rather than one specific query as it’s a reasonably medium to long
tail page.
@staceycav #mkgo

54% increase in organic traffic and a 62%
increase in organic leads through that
landing page comparing the 14 days prior to
the change with the 14 days after.
@staceycav #mkgo

In December 2017,
Google increased length
of meta descriptions
shown in results pages to
about 300 characters.
@staceycav #mkgo

So, off I went and updated 300 meta
descriptions on an ecommerce website from
around 150 characters to around 300.
@staceycav #mkgo

CTR increase on 87% of the pages worked
on.
@staceycav #mkgo

41% CTR increase (though a small positional
increase too)
@staceycav #mkgo

20% CTR increase despite a position drop
over this time.
@staceycav #mkgo

22% CTR increase – slight position increase
could pay a part
@staceycav #mkgo

All in all, the changes were credited with
delivering a 20% increase in organic traffic.
@staceycav #mkgo

Google reverted to the shorter descriptions
showing in results:
@staceycav #mkgo

Following, CTR dropped, but not quite to the
levels previously.
@staceycav #mkgo

This is likely to be partly down to the fact that
their result is no longer the biggest on the
page.
@staceycav #mkgo

But I also wondered if the ellipses at the end
of the visible description were causing a
problem.
@staceycav #mkgo

@staceycav #mkgo
There are lots of examples of bad placement
of these ellipses…

So far, 120 shortened.
CTRs improved around 15%.
@staceycav #mkgo

An improvement to the opening sentence,
for example, might have had CTR impact
regardless of the length.
@staceycav #mkgo

But, it makes sense to have control over
what is visible to users in results page.
@staceycav #mkgo

So, the best advice I can give on meta
descriptions…
@staceycav #mkgo

Do write original ones.
Do use the 150-155 characters.
Don’t have them tail off if you can help it.
And do test on your own sites!
@staceycav #mkgo

https://moz.com/blog/how-to-write-meta-descriptions-in-a-changing-world
And do read this:
@staceycav #mkgo

A study by Conductor found that you could
improve CTRs by 36% by including numbers in
a headline/page title.
@staceycav #mkgo

Never one to take 3rd party studies as gospel,
I tested it myself.
@staceycav #mkgo

This is really easy to do for non commercial
content like blog posts, buying guides or
other informational content.
@staceycav #mkgo

With the bottom title, the page CTR
increased from 4.21% to 5.81%, an
improvement of 38%
@staceycav #mkgo

With the bottom title, the page CTR
increased from 3.89% to 5.02%, an
improvement of 29%
@staceycav #mkgo

Made changes like this on 40 pages. CTR
improved on 33.
82.5% success rate
positive correlation rate.
@staceycav #mkgo

But what about commercial landing pages?
@staceycav #mkgo

Not as easy to test on BIG sites because it’s
not always feasible to put specific numbers
in.
@staceycav #mkgo

What I want to do….
@staceycav #mkgo

So that’s ongoing for me. If any of you test it,
do let me know how it goes (please?)
@staceycav #mkgo

This one had mixed results.
@staceycav #mkgo

With the bottom title, page CTR went from
2.12% to 3.13%. That’s +42%
@staceycav #mkgo

With the bottom title, page CTR went from
1.21% to 1.43%. That’s +18%
@staceycav #mkgo

But beware competitors with better offers
undercutting you and slashing your CTR.
@staceycav #mkgo

CTR dropped by 51% on a site on which we
were specifying ”From £319,” when a
competitor added “from £299,” to their title.
@staceycav #mkgo

https://ahrefs.com/blog/featured-snippets-study/
@staceycav #mkgo

The specifics of achieving featured snippets
are a talk unto themselves. But here are
some great resources:
@staceycav #mkgo

https://getstat.com/blog/featured-snippets/
@staceycav #mkgo

https://moz.com/blog/optimize-featured-snippets
@staceycav #mkgo

https://yoast.com/featured-snippets/
@staceycav #mkgo

Organic Click Through Rate Optimisation Tactics - MKGO - June 2018

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to Organic Click Through Rate Optimisation Tactics - MKGO - June 2018 (20)

More from Stacey MacNaught (8)

Recently uploaded (20)

Organic Click Through Rate Optimisation Tactics - MKGO - June 2018