SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Overview of Livestock Judging
    Livestock Judging Workshop:
      Oneida County, New York

           April 6, 2013
       By Cari B. Rincker, Esq.
What is Livestock Judging?
  • Evaluation of an animal’s characteristics
    making a comparison to other animals
    according to the “ideal standard”
       – What is “ideal” can be somewhat subjective and
         can change overtime according to trends in the
         industry
       – Using both objective and subjective tools
  • After evaluating each animal, a ranking is
    assigned to that class
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
My Livestock Judging Experience
• Judged in 4-H & FFA
   – Illinois State 4-H Team (NAILE
     Champions)
   – Invited to Judge in Edinburgh,
     Scotland
• Judged at Lake Land College
   – 1st Place Oral Reasons at National
     Western Stock Show in Denver,
     Colorado
   – 1st Place Overall at the Houston
     Livestock Show & Rodeo
• Judged at Texas A & M University
   – All-American Livestock Judging
     Team
My Livestock Coaching Experience


Coached the Shelby
County 4-H Livestock
Judging Team in Illinois
What I Do Now with Livestock Judging

• Owner of Rincker Cattle Co.
   – SimAngus beef cattle
     operation in Shelbyville,
     Illinois
• Judge beef cattle shows at
  the local, state, national,
  and international level
   – Occasionally judge pigs,
     sheep & goats
How Livestock Judging Helps Me As an
        Agriculture Attorney
• Analytical Skills
• Public Speaking Skills
• Organizational Skills
• Short-term
  memorization
• Persuasive arguments
Benefits of Livestock Judging


   “Judging instills confidence in those people who
   may be timid and humbles those who tend to be
   conceited.”
        – Harlan Ritchie (Michigan State University)




Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
What Is A Livestock Judging Contest?
• Ranking of livestock
  animals
  – 4 animals to a class
  – Identified with Numbers
  – Compared to the Official
    Placing (by a Judge or
    Committee)
What Is A Livestock Judging Contest?
Beef Cattle, Meat Sheep,
& Pigs
  – Some contests have
    wool sheep, meat
    goats, and horses
  – Separate contests for
    dairy, poultry & rabbits
    (typically)
What Is A Livestock Judging Contest?
• Judging 6-12 classes
  of livestock
  – Some breeding classes
    might also have EPD’s
• Questions and/or
  “Oral Reasons”
What We’ll Discuss Today
• Beef Cattle
  – Steers
  – Heifers
  – Bulls
• Pigs
  – Gilts
  – Barrows
• Sheep
  – Market Lambs
  – Ewes
What We’ll Discuss Today
• Expected Progeny
  Differences (“EPD’s”)
  for breeding animals
• How to Calculate
  “Cuts”
• Taking notes on your
  “Steno Pad” for
  Questions or Oral
  Reasons
• Overview of Oral
  Reasons
Judging Beef Cattle
Learn Your Anatomy
Learn Your Anatomy
Learn Your Wholesale Cuts of Beef
Learn Your Retail Cuts of Beef
Judging (Bred) Heifers
   • Priorities
        – Functionality / Ease of
          Fleshing
        – Structural Correctness
        – Balance and Symentry
        – Growth Performance
        – Femininity/ Eye Appeal
        – Muscle
        – Width of Base

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging (Bred) Heifers
 Functionality/ Ease of Fleshing
 (“Easy Keeping” or “Brood
 Cow Utility”)
      – Rib shape (depth and
        outward curvature to rib)
      – Depth of heart and bold in
        forerib
      – Volume
      – Flesh/ condition
      – Sound structured
      – Multiple characteristics go
        into these terms
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging (Bred) Heifers
Growth Performance
  – Cattle need to moderate
    framed
     • If too big/tall, then tend to be
       harder keeping and produce
       market animals with carcass
       weight problems
  – Look at length of maturity
    pattern                               Photo from Lautner Farms
     • Length of face, cannon, body,
       hooks to pins
  – Look at overall volume and
    weight of the animal
Judging Cattle
Structural Correctness
    – Front foot alignment
    – Shoulder angle
    – Strength to topline
    – Levelness and length of hip
    – Set to hock
                                                       Photo from Hanewich Cattle Co.
    – Set to pastern
    – Heaviness of structure
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Bulls
• “Butts, Nuts & Guts”
  – Muscularity
  – Athletism
  – Structural Soundness
  – Rib/Volume
  – Testicle Size/ Scrotal
    Circumference
                             Photo from Oklahoma State
Judging Market Steers
 • Priorities:
      – Muscle
      – Market Readiness/
        Correctness of Finish
      – Rib and Feeding Ability
      – Structural Soundness
                                                       Photo from Lautner Farms
      – Balance and Eye Appeal


Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Steers
   • Muscle Indicators
        – Quarter
        – Rib
        – Loin
        – Stifle
        – Forearm

                                                       Photo from Gregory Farms



Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Steers
                           • Finish Indicators
                              – Brisket
                              – Over Ribs
                              – Pins/ Around
                                Tailhead
                              – Flank
                              – Cod Fat
Photo from Lautner Farms
                           Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa
                           State University
Judging Market Steers
   • Evaluating Rib/ Feeding Ability
        – Steers should possess dimension to their skeleton
          in terms of chest width and center body shape to
          ensure efficiency in a feedlot setting and the
          ability to deposit finish
             •   Width of chest
             •   Depth of body
             •   Rib Shape
             •   Uniformity of body depth


Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Steers
   • Evaluating Balance and Eye
     Appeal
        – The steer should be
          proportional
        – Look at how the steer
          balance from the profile
             •   Length of neck
             •   Levelness of topline and hip          Photo from Rodgers Cattle

             •   Smooth pattern
             •   General attractiveness

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Let’s Judge a Class of Market Steers




Photo by Lautner Farms
Feedlot Market Steers Profile
        1                                     2




                                                  4
         3




Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Feedlot Market Steers Rear View
     1                   2                    3   4




Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Write Your Placing Down
How Did You Place It?

My Placing: 3-2-4-1                           We’ll discuss how to calculate your score later.
                                              Just write it down right now.
Cuts: 2-5-3


Note: I differed opinion from K-State. K-State Placed it 2-3-4-1 with cuts of 3-4-5.

This also illustrates that there is no one right answer – judges/officials will have
different preferences.
We’ll Talk More About Reasons Later
• Overview
  – Divide class into 3 pairs
  – Describe why you placed
    the class the way you did
  – Read & learn the
    terminology in the
    Livestock judging Team
    Manual                      Livestock Judging Teammates from
                                Texas A & M University
  – Example sets of reasons
    for your reference
Market Steer: Reasons Example # 1
   •   I placed this class of feedlot steers 2-3-4-1. The red steer wins as he best
       combines yield and quality grade. He shows the most natural shape down
       his top, over the loin and is thicker and more expressive through his
       quarter. Additionally, he is more structurally sound, being more neatly laid
       through the shoulder than 3. He should hang the carcass receiving a lower
       numerical yield than 3. 3 is longer sided. However he is fatter and straighter
       through his shoulder than 2, so he is second.

   •   Nevertheless it is 3 over 4 in the middle pair. The black steer is the thicker
       topped, wider based steer of the pair that should produce the more
       muscular carcass. I realize the Hereford appearing steer is sounder made,
       however he is lighter muscled, being flatter through the quarter and
       narrower based when viewed from the rear, so he is third.

   •   Yet in the bottom pair, its 4 over 1. 4 is more market ready as he shows
       more evidence of finish over his rib, around his tailhead and is fuller in the
       flank. Additionally he is higher volumed, have more depth and dimension to
       his rib. Yes, the yellow steer is leaner, but he is the furthest from his
       endpoint and should hang the least desirable carcass of the four, so he is
       last.



By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Steer Reasons Example # 2
  •   I place the market steers 2341. In the top pair I place 2 over 3. 2 is
      the heavies muscled, most expressively shaped steer that should rail the
      most shapely carcass. I grant that 3 is longer sided. But I faulted him and
      placed him 2nd, he is heavier conditioned and straight in his shoulder.

  •   In my middle pair I placed 3 over 4. 3 is a wider based, thicker topped steer
      that should rail a heavier muscled carcass. I grant that 4 is sounder
      structured but he is also light muscled and narrow based.

  •   In my bottom pair I placed 4 over 1. 4 is the bigger bodied steer that
      appears to have been easier feeding. Also I would expect him to be
      safer grading. I realize 1 is leaner made, but he is the lightest
      muscled and barest finished steer in class.




By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Steer Reasons Example # 3
  •   My preferred alignment of the Market steers is 2341. Starting the class with
      a pair of heavier muscled, more complete steers, and of the pair I preferred
      the added advantages in expression to align him over 3. 2 is a long
      patterned, trimmer conditioned steer that measures longer and wider out of
      his hip. I appreciate the softer, more market ready look of 3 yet he also gets
      plainer in his design and a little courser fronted.

  •   However despite these criticisms, 3 is a heavier muscled more correctly
      finished steer that has more volume and expression of muscle out of his hip
      and due to his external indicators suggest that he should be safer to role the
      choice stamp. I realize that 4 is bolder ribbed, however the Hereford is also
      the heaviest finished, shortest coupled steer in the class.

  •   In my concluding pair of lighter muscled steers I still preferred the body and
      depth of 4. He is deeper bodied, bolder sprung steer that has a softer look
      and is closer to a marketable endpoint, I understand that they yellow steer is
      longer bodied cleaner designed, yet he is the flattest, narrowest made,
      lightest muscled steer in the class.


By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Judging Pigs
Learn Your Anatomy
Learn Your Wholesale Cuts of Pork
Learn Your Retail Cuts of Pork
Judging Breeding Swine (Gilts)
Priorities
    – Scale/ Growth
    – Lean / Condition
    – Structural Correctness/
      Functionality
         • Helps to ensure sow longevity
    –   Internal Dimension/ Rib                        Photo from Dick Kuecker & Sons
    –   Skeletal Width and Dimension
    –   Balance and Eye Appeal
    –   Muscle Content
    –   Maternal characteristics
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Gilts
   • Condition
        – Leanness is important
          with breeding swine
        – Don’t want females to
          be too heavy
          conditioned but an
          adequate degree of
          condition is needed                          Photo from National Swine Registry
          for sound
          reproductive intervals

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Gilts
 • Maternal Characteristics
      – Vulva
           • Estrus Detection
           • Upturned/ Tipped
           • Infantile
      – Underline
           • Pin Nipples/ Blunt Teats
           • Size and spacing issues                   Hint: These are GREAT for questions
                                                       and oral reasons. Take lots of notes!
           • Count

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Swine
 • Skeletal Width and
   Dimension
      – Width of Chest
      – Square Rib Design
      – Depth of Flank
      – Natural Base Width at
        the Ground
      – Ability to Convert Feed                        Photo from gctelegram.com
        to Gain
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Swine
   • Balance and Eye Appeal
        – Proportional Skeleton
        – Attractive and well balanced
          look from the profile
             • Levelness of topline and hip
             • Strength behind the blades and to
               Loin
             • Quality to hair and skin coat     Photo from Sharrett Family Farms

        – Structural Correctness
             • Looseness of skeleton and
               mobility
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Hogs
Pay attention to whether
they are gilts or barrows
  – Especially for Questions
    and Reasons (ID’s, proper
    pronouns like “he”
    “she”)
  – Gilts are typically leaner
    than barrows
Judging Market Hogs
• Priorities
    – Muscle Content
    – Lean Growth
    – Skeletal Width and
      Dimension
    – Structural
                                                       Photo of Kelly Goneke
      Correctness
    – Balance and Eye
      Appeal
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Hogs
  • Indicators of Muscles
       – Ham
       – Loin
       – Dimple at Ham-Loin
         Junction
       – Grove down top
       – Forearm
       – Blades                                   Photo from the National Swine Registry

       – Stifle

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Hogs
• Indicators of Leaness
    – Jowl
    – Over blades
    – Elbow pocket
    – Loin Edge
    – Seam of ham                                      Photo from Swinegenetics.com
    – Lower one-third of body


Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Sheep




Photo from WestsideConnect.com
Judging Ewes & Rams (Breeding Sheep)
   • Priorities
        – Growth and
          Performance
             • Frame
             • Length
        – Functionality/ Rib
                                                       Photo from Strat Hearl Suffolks
        – Balance and Eye Appeal
        – Structural correctness
        – Muscle
Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Breeding Sheep
• Balance, Eye Appeal and
  Structural Soundness
    – Length and smoothness of
      front end
    – Cleanliness thru shoulder
      and chest
    – Levelness of topline and
      hip
    – Pasterns
    – Length of stride                                 Photo from DDJ Suffolks

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Lambs
   • Priorities
        – Muscle
        – Correctness of finish
        – Growth and Weight
        – Skeletal Correctness
        – Balance and Eye Appeal
                                                       From www.agri-media.ca


        *Pay attention to sex

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Lambs
   • Muscle Indicators
        – Rack
        – Loin
        – Hip
        – Leg
        – Forearm
                                                       Photo from Rennvue Farms




Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Lambs
   • Finish Indicators
        – Breast/ Chest Plate
        – Ribs
        – Flank
        – Twist

                                                       Photo from Oklahoma Report




Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Lambs
   • Growth Indicators
        – Length of head, neck,
          cannon bone and
          hindsaddle
        – Height at the top of the
          shoulders
        – Length of body                               Photo from South Dakota State Fair

        – Weight

Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Lambs
Skeletal Correctness
     – Angle to shoulder and knee
     – Appropriate set to pastern
     – Levelness of top and dock set
     – Square set from hock to
       ground from behind
     – Heaviness of structure
                                                       Photo from KearnyHub.com




Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Judging Market Lambs
   • Balance and Eye Appeal
        – Proportionalism
        – Trim chested/ clean fronted
        – Length and smoothless of
          front end
        – Level topline and square hip
                                                       Photo from Thomas Show Lambs
        – Attractive rib design



Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
Market Lambs Profile
 1                                            2




                                              4
3




Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Lambs Rear View
     1                      2                 3   4




Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Lambs Top View
  1                       2                   3   4




Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Lambs Front View
  1                       2                   3   4




Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Write Down Your Placing
Official

My Placing: 4-1-2-                        We’ll discuss how to calculate your score later.
                                          Just write it down right now.
3
Cuts: 3-5-2
 Note: I differed opinion from K-State on the bottom pair.
 K-State placed the class 4-1-3-2 with the same cuts

 This also illustrates that there is no one right answer – judges/officials will have
 different preferences.
Market Lambs: Reasons Example # 1
 •   I placed the market lambs 4-1-3-2. In the top pair of more muscular wethers, I
     personally like the blue sheep to win. For me, he ties his muscularility into a bigger,
     more correctly finished package. Not only is 4 a taller fronted lamb, that is longer
     measuring from his last rib back. But this compliments the fact that he is a cleaner
     profiling lamb that is leaner to touch. I would expect him to have an advantage in
     cutability. True, 1 is a heavier weight lamb that wraps with a bigger leg. However, I
     placed him second because he is a heavy middled lamb that is deep in his sternum.

 •   However, 1 is a more powerfully muscled, growthier lamb, and needs to beat 3 in the
     middle pair. No doubt, 1 is a wider based sheep that has more tone and shape of
     muscle from his rack back into his leg. To add to this, I find him to be a heavier
     weight lamb and he should go to the cooler with more product from his 13th rib back.
     Yes, 3 is more correct in his body depth. However, for me he goes third, because 3 is
     clearly the lightest muscled, thickest hided lamb in the class, that is a bit too stale.

 •   Now, in the bottom pair of lambs that differ in composition I elected to use the leaner
     lamb and placed 3 over 2. I predict he will have an advantage in yield grade because
     he handles leaner down his spine and is especially cleaner over his forerib. On the
     other hand 2 is a more muscular sheep. He has a bolder shape of muscle over his
     rack, a fuller loin edge and more volume to his leg. Nonetheless, I placed him
     fourth. Not only is he short bodied, but he is clearly the softest handling, most
     overdone lamb in the class.


By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Lambs: Reasons Example # 2
   •   I placed the Market Lambs 4132. In my top pair I placed 4 over 1. 4 is the
       heaviest muscled, largest framed and most correct in his degree of finish. I
       grant that 1 has a larger leg, but I faulted him and placed him second
       because he is heavier conditioned.

   •   In my middle pair I place 1 over 3. 1 is wider based and more
       expressive in his muscle shape. I grant that 3 is cleaner and trimmer in his
       middle, but I faulted him and place him 3rd. He is light
       muscled and narrow constructed.

   •   In my bottom pair I placed 3 over 2. 3 is leaner made sheep that I
       would expect to rail a higher cutability carcass. I grant 2 for being
       heavier muscled, but I place him fourth, He is the shortest bodied and
       fattest made sheep in the class.




By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Market Lambs: Reasons Example # 3
  •   My preferred alignment of the market lambs is 4132, starting the class with
      a more massive muscular lamb who remains stronger down his top. 4 is a
      long bodied lamb who spreads a squarer shape over his rack, spans wider
      over his loin and has a longer, wider, deeper tying leg, which leads me to
      believe that he should rail more pounds of trimmed hindsaddle. I
      understand that 1 has more expression of muscle throughout his leg, yet he
      also is narrower made and sharper over his shoulder.
  •   However in my middle pair it is 1s advantage in both Muscularity and
      expression that aligns him over 3. 1 has more expression over muscle
      over his crisper, firmer rack and carries this back through his more defined
      loin and into his bolder more dimensional leg. This suggests that he
      should simply rail a carcass that is totally freer of fat. Yes, 3 is more
      opened up in his chest floor, but he also is plainer and nondescript in his
      design, and appears to be heavier conditioned.
  •   In my concluding pair of heavier conditioned lambs, I preferred the added
      length and volume of 3. 3 is a taller, longer patterned lamb, who is more
      attractive on the profile and is more extended from his last rib back. I
      understand that 2 is deeper bodied, but he also is the heaviest conditioned,
      lightest muscled lamb of the class.



By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
Learn Your Anatomy
Learn Your Wholesale Cuts of Lamb
Learn Your Retail Cuts of Lamb
How to Calculate Cuts
• Best Score is 50
• Calculate by adding the “Drop”
• Cuts are 3 numbers-- for Top Pair, Middle Pair and
  Bottom Pair
• Total cannot exceed 15 points
• Example
  – Placing 4321
  – Official 4231
  – Cuts 7-3-4
  – Score 47
  (Switched middle pair)
How to Calculate Cuts
• Illustration:               Ask:
                              Is 2 over 1?
   – My Placing: 2134         Is 2 over 4?
                              Is 2 over 3?
   – Official Placing: 2143   Is 1 over 4?
                              Is 1 over 3?
   – Cuts: 5-3-2              Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2
   – Score: 48
How to Calculate Cuts
• Illustration:               Ask:
                              Is 2 over 1? No, so minus 5
   – My Placing: 1234         Is 2 over 4?
                              Is 2 over 3?
   – Official Placing: 2143   Is 1 over 4?
                              Is 1 over 3?
   – Cuts: 5-3-2              Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2
   – Score: 43
How to Calculate Cuts
• Illustration:               Ask:
                              Is 2 over 1?
   – My Placing: 2314         Is 2 over 4?
                              Is 2 over 3?
   – Official Placing: 2143   Is 1 over 4? No, so minus 3
                              Is 1 over 3? No, so minus 5 (3+2)
   – Cuts: 5-3-2              Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2
   – Score: 40

   The simple bust.
How to Calculate Cuts
• Illustration:               Ask:
                              Is 2 over 1?
   – My Placing: 4213         Is 2 over 4? No, so minus 8
                              Is 2 over 3?
   – Official Placing: 2143   Is 1 over 4? No, so minus 3
                              Is 1 over 3?
   – Cuts: 5-3-2              Is 4 over 3?
   – Score: 39

   The simple bust.
How to Calculate Cuts
• Illustration:               Ask:
                              Is 2 over 1? No, so minus 5
   – My Placing: 3142         Is 2 over 4? No, so minus 8 (5 +3)
                              Is 2 over 3? No, so minus 10 (5+3+2)
   – Official Placing: 2143   Is 1 over 4?
                              Is 1 over 3? No, so minus 5 (3+2)
   – Cuts: 5-3-2              Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2
   – Score: 20

   The major bust.
Now, You Try It

• Example:
  – My Placing: 2431
  – Official Placing: 2413
  – Cuts: 5-4-3
  – Score:
Now, You Try It

• Example:
  – My Placing: 3124
  – Official Placing: 1234
  – Cuts: 3-2-5
  – Score:
Now, You Try It

• Example:
  – My Placing: 1234
  – Official Placing: 3124
  – Cuts: 2-3-7
  – Score:
Now, You Try It

• Example:
  – My Placing: 1324
  – Official Placing: 4213
  – Cuts: 4-3-2
  – Score:
Now, You Try It

• Example:
  – My Placing: 1234
  – Official Placing: 4321
  – Cuts: 2-5-2
  – Score:
Taking Notes on Your Steno Pad
• Get several steno
  pads for livestock
  judging
• Keep notes in them
• I still have my steno
  pads from livestock
  judging at Lake Land
  & Texas A & M
  University
Getting Ready for the Contest
• Get your steno pad set-up
  the night before
• Fill in the information
  about the classes the day
  of the contest
• Columns for your placing,
  the official placing, official
  cuts, and your score
• This will be your “Master
  Score Sheet”
• Identify Questions and/or
  Reasons Classes
• Identify Classes where
  there will be EPD’s
  available
Setting Up Notes for Questions
• There’s no one right way to
  do this
   – This is how I set-up my notes
     for question classes
• Need to take notes on
  “identification” (e.g., tick-
  backed Hereford heifer),
  positives, and negatives
   – Will also get questions on
     comparison
• Make sure to write down
  your placing
• The goal is to take accurate
  enough notes to jog your
  memory later
Taking Notes for Questions Classes
• Write down whatever
  comes to mind
• Can be a useful
  exercise to help rank
  the animals
Another Way to Take Notes for Questions



Again, there’s no one
“right way”
  – Find what works for
    you
Trick for Questions

• Write your placing
  down on answer sheet
  – Will help job your
    memory
  – Place on scantron
    away from the circles
Oral Reasons
• Overview: Explaining to a judge why you
  chose to place the animals the way you did
• Judged on the correctness of the reasons
  (even if different than the official) and overall
  presentation
• 50 points maximum
• Should be 60-90 seconds
Taking Notes for Reasons
• Divide your notebook
  into 3 pair
  – Top pair
  – Middle pair
  – Bottom pair
• Then you’ll divide it in
  half again
  – Positives & negatives
Strategy for Reasons Notes
• Top Pair
   – Why 1st Place beats all the
     rest
   – Why 1st is better than 2nd
     place
   – How the 1st place animal
     could improve
   – How 2nd place might be
     better than 1st place
   – Why the 2nd place animal
     is second
   – Don’t forget to mention
     ID’s
Reason Notes
• Middle Pair
  – Is it a close decision?
  – Why second place
    beats third place
  – How second place can
    be improved
  – How third place may be
    better than second
    place
  – Why 3rd place animal is
    in third place
Reason Notes
• Bottom Pair
  – Is it a close decision?
  – Why third place beats
    fourth place
  – How third place can be
    improved
  – How fourth place may
    be better than third
    place
  – Why 4th place animal is
    in fourth place
• Transitions
Cari’s Reasons Tricks
• I use my notes to help visualize the animals
  – I “see” the animals as I give my reasons
  – If I forget what I memorized, I just talk about the
    animals
• I talked outloud to myself to practice (don’t
  worry about what others think of you – you’ll
  beat them!)
Cari’s Reasons Tricks
• I memorized one pair at a time
  – Got the first pair down before moving on to the
    second pair
• Smile.. But not too much. Be pleasant and
  upbeat but not cheesy
• Articulation and strong voice
  – Emphasize important words
  – Think about pauses
• Dress professionally
Cari’s Reasons Tricks
• As a woman, I was taught to turn slightly to
  make me look more feminine
• Pay attention to posture
• Remember that the judges want to hear the
  “big points”
  – Don’t get too carried away in the details
• Say “Good Afternoon” and “Thank You”
  (confidently)
Cari’s Reasons Tricks
• If you don’t feel confident in your placing,
  then stay away from words like “easily,”
  “unquestionably” and “without a doubt” –
  use soft language
  – Remember to talk the differences
  – Doing well in reasons is about describing the
    animals accurately and giving a good presentation
  – If you “see” the animals correctly, it’s okay to
    place them differently
Sample Reasons
Placing: 4-3-2-1
Cuts: 3-5-3

•   I placed this class of feedlot steers 4-3-2-1.

•   In the top pair of steers comparable in finish, I placed 4 over 3 due to his advantage in muscling. Ideally, I
    would like to see 4 more structurally correct through his shoulder, however, the bald-faced steer shows
    more shape and natural thickness down his top and through his hip, and stands wider based when viewed
    from the rear. He should hang a carcass with the highest percent of saleable product in the class. No
    doubt, 3 is more structurally correct, particularly through the shoulder and deeper bodied. However, he is
    narrower topped and flatter through the quarter than the class winner, so he is second.

•   It is easily 3 over 2 in the middle pair. He is the nicer balanced steer that better combines yield and quality
    grade. He is freer of waste through the lower 1/3 of his body and shows more muscle expression down his
    top and through his quarter.

•   In the bottom pair, its 2 over 1 due to his advantage in market readiness. He is carrying more finish over
    his fore and rear rib and should be safer into the choice grade. I realize that 1 is the leaner. However, he is
    the least market ready as he runs out of finish over his rear rib. He is also the lightest muscled, narrowest
    made steer in the class that should hang the least amount of red meat, so he is last.


From Louisiana State University,
Department of Animal Science
More Info on Oral Reasons & EPD’s
Please get out the
Livestock Judging
Manual from Lake Land
College

*We’ll go through
several sections
Additional Resources
• Livestock Judging.com
   – http://www.livestockjudging.com/free_livestock_judging_practice_clas
     ses.aspx
• Judging 101
   – http://www.judging101.com/
• Animal Science 101
   – www.animalscience101.com
Please Stay in Touch
• Send Me Snail Mail: 535 Fifth Avenue, 4th Floor,
  New York, NY 10017
• Call Me: (212) 427-2049 (office)
• Email Me: cari@rinckerlaw.com
• Visit My Website: www.rinckerlaw.com
• Read My Food & Ag Law Blog: www.rinckerlaw.com/blog
• Tweet Me: @CariRincker @RinckerLaw
• Facebook Me: www.facebook.com/rinckerlaw
• Link to Me: http://www.linkedin.com/in/caririncker
• Skype Me: Cari.Rincker

More Related Content

PPTX
Carbohydrate metabolism
PPTX
Practical Unit 7 Judging of cattle, buffalo, and poultry.pptx
PPSX
External Body Parts of Chicken
PPT
Genetics of animal breeding 9
PPTX
Contamination, Preservation and Spoilage of milk
PPTX
DIGESTION & ABSORPTION OF PROTEINS
PPTX
Practical Unit 2 Approaching, Handling methods, and restraining.pptx
PDF
Principles of milking
Carbohydrate metabolism
Practical Unit 7 Judging of cattle, buffalo, and poultry.pptx
External Body Parts of Chicken
Genetics of animal breeding 9
Contamination, Preservation and Spoilage of milk
DIGESTION & ABSORPTION OF PROTEINS
Practical Unit 2 Approaching, Handling methods, and restraining.pptx
Principles of milking

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Swine-Production-Management.pptx
PDF
Poultry production management
PPTX
Nutrient requirements of sheep and goats
PPT
POULTRY NUTRITION AND FEEDING
PPTX
economic Traits of swine
PDF
Livestock production systems and animal land holding pattern
PPTX
Selectionof dairy animals
PPTX
final poultry (1) [Autosaved].pptx
PPT
Balanced ration suresh
PPTX
Swine feeding.pptx
PPTX
PPT
Lecture 4: Calf management
PDF
Hatchery Managment.pdf
PPTX
Introduction to poultry production
PPT
Feeds, Nutrients and Animal Requirements
PDF
Identification of various breeds of poultry
PPTX
Fodder management
PPTX
Lighting Management for Poultry
PPTX
Poultry management
PPS
Female bovine reproduction system
Swine-Production-Management.pptx
Poultry production management
Nutrient requirements of sheep and goats
POULTRY NUTRITION AND FEEDING
economic Traits of swine
Livestock production systems and animal land holding pattern
Selectionof dairy animals
final poultry (1) [Autosaved].pptx
Balanced ration suresh
Swine feeding.pptx
Lecture 4: Calf management
Hatchery Managment.pdf
Introduction to poultry production
Feeds, Nutrients and Animal Requirements
Identification of various breeds of poultry
Fodder management
Lighting Management for Poultry
Poultry management
Female bovine reproduction system
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPT
Sheep goats
PPTX
Jan judging team mtg2013
DOCX
Livestock terminology
PPT
Livestock
PPTX
Pekingese
PPSX
PPT
Health
PPT
Advanced Email
PPTX
Crabbing in Charleston SC
PPTX
Lesson 4 breed of cattle
DOC
Adec8446
PDF
Sheepdog内部实现机制
PDF
DNSSEC and DANE – E-Mail security reloaded
PDF
Growth and Development of Craniofacial Complex
PPT
"Água viva"
PPTX
Types of livestock ,
PPT
07. The Deciduous Teeth - Dentition
PPT
Maxillary and Mandibular Canines
PPT
Parvovirus
Sheep goats
Jan judging team mtg2013
Livestock terminology
Livestock
Pekingese
Health
Advanced Email
Crabbing in Charleston SC
Lesson 4 breed of cattle
Adec8446
Sheepdog内部实现机制
DNSSEC and DANE – E-Mail security reloaded
Growth and Development of Craniofacial Complex
"Água viva"
Types of livestock ,
07. The Deciduous Teeth - Dentition
Maxillary and Mandibular Canines
Parvovirus
Ad

Similar to Overview of Livestock Judging (20)

PPT
Beef cattleselection
PDF
5 Steps to Compelling, Informative Illustrations
PPTX
Phenotypic Selection of Dairy Cattle
PDF
Steps to judging sheep, Live stock judging
PPTX
different kinds of meat and its sources.
PPT
Judging dairy animals copy
PPT
Judging dairy animals
PPTX
Grading judging and fabrication of meat carcass
PPTX
Ch. 2 - Eval.pptx
PPTX
4 CONFORMATION.pptxJSFDLSFNSJNSLNFLJSDNJSNFSDFNSJFNLSDNFJLSNFLJSNFLJSDF
PPTX
Replacement ewe selection and culling underperforming ewes
PPT
SElection and evaluation of horses. Equineppt
PPTX
Criteria for selection of a good replacement breeder stock
PPTX
Reasons let make it easy
PDF
breedingsoundnessexaminbulls-230105032210-ece1bc39.pdf
PPTX
breeding soundness exam in bulls.pptx
PPT
Goat Meat: America’s Hottest Commodity
PPTX
EVALUATION, GRADING AND FABRICATION OF DRESSED CARCASSES INCLUDING POULTRY.pptx
PPTX
Highland pony society
Beef cattleselection
5 Steps to Compelling, Informative Illustrations
Phenotypic Selection of Dairy Cattle
Steps to judging sheep, Live stock judging
different kinds of meat and its sources.
Judging dairy animals copy
Judging dairy animals
Grading judging and fabrication of meat carcass
Ch. 2 - Eval.pptx
4 CONFORMATION.pptxJSFDLSFNSJNSLNFLJSDNJSNFSDFNSJFNLSDNFJLSNFLJSNFLJSDF
Replacement ewe selection and culling underperforming ewes
SElection and evaluation of horses. Equineppt
Criteria for selection of a good replacement breeder stock
Reasons let make it easy
breedingsoundnessexaminbulls-230105032210-ece1bc39.pdf
breeding soundness exam in bulls.pptx
Goat Meat: America’s Hottest Commodity
EVALUATION, GRADING AND FABRICATION OF DRESSED CARCASSES INCLUDING POULTRY.pptx
Highland pony society

More from Cari Rincker (20)

PPTX
Cari Rincker's Path to Success
PPTX
Laws that Apply to Agriculture Photographers and Videographers
PPTX
I'm Talking about the Big D- Family Law Issues in Agriculture
PPTX
Legal Issues as it Applies to Agritourism
PPTX
Farm Estate and Succession Planning
PPTX
Choice of Business Entities for Illinois Farmers and Agri-Businesses
PPTX
Farm Labor Laws: What You Need to Know
PPTX
Farm Estate and Succession Planning
PPTX
Top 5 Legal Issues for Ilinois Farmers in 2017
PPTX
That's a Lie -- A Presentation for Career Day
PPTX
Lawyer's Guide to the Veterinary Feed Directive
PPTX
Overview of the Veterinary Feed Directive
PPTX
Lawline: Overview of Common Agriculture Contracts
PPTX
Lawline Presentation: Building a Law Practice Brick by Brick
PPTX
Wine & Vineyard Law: Federal and New York State Licenses, Permits & Regulations
PPTX
Overview of New York Farm Animal Welfare Law
PPTX
Multimedia Specialist: Using their Skills to Grow Your Food & Agricultural L...
PPTX
National Agriculture Law Update
PPTX
Powerpoint panel discussion
PPTX
Overview of the Veterinary Feed Directive
Cari Rincker's Path to Success
Laws that Apply to Agriculture Photographers and Videographers
I'm Talking about the Big D- Family Law Issues in Agriculture
Legal Issues as it Applies to Agritourism
Farm Estate and Succession Planning
Choice of Business Entities for Illinois Farmers and Agri-Businesses
Farm Labor Laws: What You Need to Know
Farm Estate and Succession Planning
Top 5 Legal Issues for Ilinois Farmers in 2017
That's a Lie -- A Presentation for Career Day
Lawyer's Guide to the Veterinary Feed Directive
Overview of the Veterinary Feed Directive
Lawline: Overview of Common Agriculture Contracts
Lawline Presentation: Building a Law Practice Brick by Brick
Wine & Vineyard Law: Federal and New York State Licenses, Permits & Regulations
Overview of New York Farm Animal Welfare Law
Multimedia Specialist: Using their Skills to Grow Your Food & Agricultural L...
National Agriculture Law Update
Powerpoint panel discussion
Overview of the Veterinary Feed Directive

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Trump Administration's workforce development strategy
PPTX
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
PDF
Updated Idioms and Phrasal Verbs in English subject
PDF
2.FourierTransform-ShortQuestionswithAnswers.pdf
PPTX
master seminar digital applications in india
PDF
Weekly quiz Compilation Jan -July 25.pdf
PPTX
UV-Visible spectroscopy..pptx UV-Visible Spectroscopy – Electronic Transition...
PPTX
Radiologic_Anatomy_of_the_Brachial_plexus [final].pptx
PPTX
Tissue processing ( HISTOPATHOLOGICAL TECHNIQUE
PDF
Module 4: Burden of Disease Tutorial Slides S2 2025
PDF
Yogi Goddess Pres Conference Studio Updates
PDF
LDMMIA Reiki Yoga Finals Review Spring Summer
PDF
Microbial disease of the cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
PDF
The Lost Whites of Pakistan by Jahanzaib Mughal.pdf
PDF
Classroom Observation Tools for Teachers
PDF
OBE - B.A.(HON'S) IN INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE -Ar.MOHIUDDIN.pdf
PDF
01-Introduction-to-Information-Management.pdf
PDF
Black Hat USA 2025 - Micro ICS Summit - ICS/OT Threat Landscape
PPTX
Microbial diseases, their pathogenesis and prophylaxis
PPTX
Introduction-to-Literarature-and-Literary-Studies-week-Prelim-coverage.pptx
Trump Administration's workforce development strategy
Cell Types and Its function , kingdom of life
Updated Idioms and Phrasal Verbs in English subject
2.FourierTransform-ShortQuestionswithAnswers.pdf
master seminar digital applications in india
Weekly quiz Compilation Jan -July 25.pdf
UV-Visible spectroscopy..pptx UV-Visible Spectroscopy – Electronic Transition...
Radiologic_Anatomy_of_the_Brachial_plexus [final].pptx
Tissue processing ( HISTOPATHOLOGICAL TECHNIQUE
Module 4: Burden of Disease Tutorial Slides S2 2025
Yogi Goddess Pres Conference Studio Updates
LDMMIA Reiki Yoga Finals Review Spring Summer
Microbial disease of the cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
The Lost Whites of Pakistan by Jahanzaib Mughal.pdf
Classroom Observation Tools for Teachers
OBE - B.A.(HON'S) IN INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE -Ar.MOHIUDDIN.pdf
01-Introduction-to-Information-Management.pdf
Black Hat USA 2025 - Micro ICS Summit - ICS/OT Threat Landscape
Microbial diseases, their pathogenesis and prophylaxis
Introduction-to-Literarature-and-Literary-Studies-week-Prelim-coverage.pptx

Overview of Livestock Judging

  • 1. Overview of Livestock Judging Livestock Judging Workshop: Oneida County, New York April 6, 2013 By Cari B. Rincker, Esq.
  • 2. What is Livestock Judging? • Evaluation of an animal’s characteristics making a comparison to other animals according to the “ideal standard” – What is “ideal” can be somewhat subjective and can change overtime according to trends in the industry – Using both objective and subjective tools • After evaluating each animal, a ranking is assigned to that class Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 3. My Livestock Judging Experience • Judged in 4-H & FFA – Illinois State 4-H Team (NAILE Champions) – Invited to Judge in Edinburgh, Scotland • Judged at Lake Land College – 1st Place Oral Reasons at National Western Stock Show in Denver, Colorado – 1st Place Overall at the Houston Livestock Show & Rodeo • Judged at Texas A & M University – All-American Livestock Judging Team
  • 4. My Livestock Coaching Experience Coached the Shelby County 4-H Livestock Judging Team in Illinois
  • 5. What I Do Now with Livestock Judging • Owner of Rincker Cattle Co. – SimAngus beef cattle operation in Shelbyville, Illinois • Judge beef cattle shows at the local, state, national, and international level – Occasionally judge pigs, sheep & goats
  • 6. How Livestock Judging Helps Me As an Agriculture Attorney • Analytical Skills • Public Speaking Skills • Organizational Skills • Short-term memorization • Persuasive arguments
  • 7. Benefits of Livestock Judging “Judging instills confidence in those people who may be timid and humbles those who tend to be conceited.” – Harlan Ritchie (Michigan State University) Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 8. What Is A Livestock Judging Contest? • Ranking of livestock animals – 4 animals to a class – Identified with Numbers – Compared to the Official Placing (by a Judge or Committee)
  • 9. What Is A Livestock Judging Contest? Beef Cattle, Meat Sheep, & Pigs – Some contests have wool sheep, meat goats, and horses – Separate contests for dairy, poultry & rabbits (typically)
  • 10. What Is A Livestock Judging Contest? • Judging 6-12 classes of livestock – Some breeding classes might also have EPD’s • Questions and/or “Oral Reasons”
  • 11. What We’ll Discuss Today • Beef Cattle – Steers – Heifers – Bulls • Pigs – Gilts – Barrows • Sheep – Market Lambs – Ewes
  • 12. What We’ll Discuss Today • Expected Progeny Differences (“EPD’s”) for breeding animals • How to Calculate “Cuts” • Taking notes on your “Steno Pad” for Questions or Oral Reasons • Overview of Oral Reasons
  • 16. Learn Your Wholesale Cuts of Beef
  • 17. Learn Your Retail Cuts of Beef
  • 18. Judging (Bred) Heifers • Priorities – Functionality / Ease of Fleshing – Structural Correctness – Balance and Symentry – Growth Performance – Femininity/ Eye Appeal – Muscle – Width of Base Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 19. Judging (Bred) Heifers Functionality/ Ease of Fleshing (“Easy Keeping” or “Brood Cow Utility”) – Rib shape (depth and outward curvature to rib) – Depth of heart and bold in forerib – Volume – Flesh/ condition – Sound structured – Multiple characteristics go into these terms Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 20. Judging (Bred) Heifers Growth Performance – Cattle need to moderate framed • If too big/tall, then tend to be harder keeping and produce market animals with carcass weight problems – Look at length of maturity pattern Photo from Lautner Farms • Length of face, cannon, body, hooks to pins – Look at overall volume and weight of the animal
  • 21. Judging Cattle Structural Correctness – Front foot alignment – Shoulder angle – Strength to topline – Levelness and length of hip – Set to hock Photo from Hanewich Cattle Co. – Set to pastern – Heaviness of structure Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 22. Judging Bulls • “Butts, Nuts & Guts” – Muscularity – Athletism – Structural Soundness – Rib/Volume – Testicle Size/ Scrotal Circumference Photo from Oklahoma State
  • 23. Judging Market Steers • Priorities: – Muscle – Market Readiness/ Correctness of Finish – Rib and Feeding Ability – Structural Soundness Photo from Lautner Farms – Balance and Eye Appeal Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 24. Judging Market Steers • Muscle Indicators – Quarter – Rib – Loin – Stifle – Forearm Photo from Gregory Farms Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 25. Judging Market Steers • Finish Indicators – Brisket – Over Ribs – Pins/ Around Tailhead – Flank – Cod Fat Photo from Lautner Farms Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 26. Judging Market Steers • Evaluating Rib/ Feeding Ability – Steers should possess dimension to their skeleton in terms of chest width and center body shape to ensure efficiency in a feedlot setting and the ability to deposit finish • Width of chest • Depth of body • Rib Shape • Uniformity of body depth Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 27. Judging Market Steers • Evaluating Balance and Eye Appeal – The steer should be proportional – Look at how the steer balance from the profile • Length of neck • Levelness of topline and hip Photo from Rodgers Cattle • Smooth pattern • General attractiveness Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 28. Let’s Judge a Class of Market Steers Photo by Lautner Farms
  • 29. Feedlot Market Steers Profile 1 2 4 3 Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 30. Feedlot Market Steers Rear View 1 2 3 4 Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 32. How Did You Place It? My Placing: 3-2-4-1 We’ll discuss how to calculate your score later. Just write it down right now. Cuts: 2-5-3 Note: I differed opinion from K-State. K-State Placed it 2-3-4-1 with cuts of 3-4-5. This also illustrates that there is no one right answer – judges/officials will have different preferences.
  • 33. We’ll Talk More About Reasons Later • Overview – Divide class into 3 pairs – Describe why you placed the class the way you did – Read & learn the terminology in the Livestock judging Team Manual Livestock Judging Teammates from Texas A & M University – Example sets of reasons for your reference
  • 34. Market Steer: Reasons Example # 1 • I placed this class of feedlot steers 2-3-4-1. The red steer wins as he best combines yield and quality grade. He shows the most natural shape down his top, over the loin and is thicker and more expressive through his quarter. Additionally, he is more structurally sound, being more neatly laid through the shoulder than 3. He should hang the carcass receiving a lower numerical yield than 3. 3 is longer sided. However he is fatter and straighter through his shoulder than 2, so he is second. • Nevertheless it is 3 over 4 in the middle pair. The black steer is the thicker topped, wider based steer of the pair that should produce the more muscular carcass. I realize the Hereford appearing steer is sounder made, however he is lighter muscled, being flatter through the quarter and narrower based when viewed from the rear, so he is third. • Yet in the bottom pair, its 4 over 1. 4 is more market ready as he shows more evidence of finish over his rib, around his tailhead and is fuller in the flank. Additionally he is higher volumed, have more depth and dimension to his rib. Yes, the yellow steer is leaner, but he is the furthest from his endpoint and should hang the least desirable carcass of the four, so he is last. By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 35. Market Steer Reasons Example # 2 • I place the market steers 2341. In the top pair I place 2 over 3. 2 is the heavies muscled, most expressively shaped steer that should rail the most shapely carcass. I grant that 3 is longer sided. But I faulted him and placed him 2nd, he is heavier conditioned and straight in his shoulder. • In my middle pair I placed 3 over 4. 3 is a wider based, thicker topped steer that should rail a heavier muscled carcass. I grant that 4 is sounder structured but he is also light muscled and narrow based. • In my bottom pair I placed 4 over 1. 4 is the bigger bodied steer that appears to have been easier feeding. Also I would expect him to be safer grading. I realize 1 is leaner made, but he is the lightest muscled and barest finished steer in class. By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 36. Market Steer Reasons Example # 3 • My preferred alignment of the Market steers is 2341. Starting the class with a pair of heavier muscled, more complete steers, and of the pair I preferred the added advantages in expression to align him over 3. 2 is a long patterned, trimmer conditioned steer that measures longer and wider out of his hip. I appreciate the softer, more market ready look of 3 yet he also gets plainer in his design and a little courser fronted. • However despite these criticisms, 3 is a heavier muscled more correctly finished steer that has more volume and expression of muscle out of his hip and due to his external indicators suggest that he should be safer to role the choice stamp. I realize that 4 is bolder ribbed, however the Hereford is also the heaviest finished, shortest coupled steer in the class. • In my concluding pair of lighter muscled steers I still preferred the body and depth of 4. He is deeper bodied, bolder sprung steer that has a softer look and is closer to a marketable endpoint, I understand that they yellow steer is longer bodied cleaner designed, yet he is the flattest, narrowest made, lightest muscled steer in the class. By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 39. Learn Your Wholesale Cuts of Pork
  • 40. Learn Your Retail Cuts of Pork
  • 41. Judging Breeding Swine (Gilts) Priorities – Scale/ Growth – Lean / Condition – Structural Correctness/ Functionality • Helps to ensure sow longevity – Internal Dimension/ Rib Photo from Dick Kuecker & Sons – Skeletal Width and Dimension – Balance and Eye Appeal – Muscle Content – Maternal characteristics Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 42. Judging Gilts • Condition – Leanness is important with breeding swine – Don’t want females to be too heavy conditioned but an adequate degree of condition is needed Photo from National Swine Registry for sound reproductive intervals Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 43. Judging Gilts • Maternal Characteristics – Vulva • Estrus Detection • Upturned/ Tipped • Infantile – Underline • Pin Nipples/ Blunt Teats • Size and spacing issues Hint: These are GREAT for questions and oral reasons. Take lots of notes! • Count Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 44. Judging Swine • Skeletal Width and Dimension – Width of Chest – Square Rib Design – Depth of Flank – Natural Base Width at the Ground – Ability to Convert Feed Photo from gctelegram.com to Gain Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 45. Judging Swine • Balance and Eye Appeal – Proportional Skeleton – Attractive and well balanced look from the profile • Levelness of topline and hip • Strength behind the blades and to Loin • Quality to hair and skin coat Photo from Sharrett Family Farms – Structural Correctness • Looseness of skeleton and mobility Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 46. Judging Market Hogs Pay attention to whether they are gilts or barrows – Especially for Questions and Reasons (ID’s, proper pronouns like “he” “she”) – Gilts are typically leaner than barrows
  • 47. Judging Market Hogs • Priorities – Muscle Content – Lean Growth – Skeletal Width and Dimension – Structural Photo of Kelly Goneke Correctness – Balance and Eye Appeal Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 48. Judging Market Hogs • Indicators of Muscles – Ham – Loin – Dimple at Ham-Loin Junction – Grove down top – Forearm – Blades Photo from the National Swine Registry – Stifle Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 49. Judging Market Hogs • Indicators of Leaness – Jowl – Over blades – Elbow pocket – Loin Edge – Seam of ham Photo from Swinegenetics.com – Lower one-third of body Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 50. Judging Sheep Photo from WestsideConnect.com
  • 51. Judging Ewes & Rams (Breeding Sheep) • Priorities – Growth and Performance • Frame • Length – Functionality/ Rib Photo from Strat Hearl Suffolks – Balance and Eye Appeal – Structural correctness – Muscle Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 52. Judging Breeding Sheep • Balance, Eye Appeal and Structural Soundness – Length and smoothness of front end – Cleanliness thru shoulder and chest – Levelness of topline and hip – Pasterns – Length of stride Photo from DDJ Suffolks Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 53. Judging Market Lambs • Priorities – Muscle – Correctness of finish – Growth and Weight – Skeletal Correctness – Balance and Eye Appeal From www.agri-media.ca *Pay attention to sex Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 54. Judging Market Lambs • Muscle Indicators – Rack – Loin – Hip – Leg – Forearm Photo from Rennvue Farms Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 55. Judging Market Lambs • Finish Indicators – Breast/ Chest Plate – Ribs – Flank – Twist Photo from Oklahoma Report Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 56. Judging Market Lambs • Growth Indicators – Length of head, neck, cannon bone and hindsaddle – Height at the top of the shoulders – Length of body Photo from South Dakota State Fair – Weight Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 57. Judging Market Lambs Skeletal Correctness – Angle to shoulder and knee – Appropriate set to pastern – Levelness of top and dock set – Square set from hock to ground from behind – Heaviness of structure Photo from KearnyHub.com Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 58. Judging Market Lambs • Balance and Eye Appeal – Proportionalism – Trim chested/ clean fronted – Length and smoothless of front end – Level topline and square hip Photo from Thomas Show Lambs – Attractive rib design Presentation by Jeff Thayne at Iowa State University
  • 59. Market Lambs Profile 1 2 4 3 Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 60. Market Lambs Rear View 1 2 3 4 Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 61. Market Lambs Top View 1 2 3 4 Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 62. Market Lambs Front View 1 2 3 4 Presentation by Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 63. Write Down Your Placing
  • 64. Official My Placing: 4-1-2- We’ll discuss how to calculate your score later. Just write it down right now. 3 Cuts: 3-5-2 Note: I differed opinion from K-State on the bottom pair. K-State placed the class 4-1-3-2 with the same cuts This also illustrates that there is no one right answer – judges/officials will have different preferences.
  • 65. Market Lambs: Reasons Example # 1 • I placed the market lambs 4-1-3-2. In the top pair of more muscular wethers, I personally like the blue sheep to win. For me, he ties his muscularility into a bigger, more correctly finished package. Not only is 4 a taller fronted lamb, that is longer measuring from his last rib back. But this compliments the fact that he is a cleaner profiling lamb that is leaner to touch. I would expect him to have an advantage in cutability. True, 1 is a heavier weight lamb that wraps with a bigger leg. However, I placed him second because he is a heavy middled lamb that is deep in his sternum. • However, 1 is a more powerfully muscled, growthier lamb, and needs to beat 3 in the middle pair. No doubt, 1 is a wider based sheep that has more tone and shape of muscle from his rack back into his leg. To add to this, I find him to be a heavier weight lamb and he should go to the cooler with more product from his 13th rib back. Yes, 3 is more correct in his body depth. However, for me he goes third, because 3 is clearly the lightest muscled, thickest hided lamb in the class, that is a bit too stale. • Now, in the bottom pair of lambs that differ in composition I elected to use the leaner lamb and placed 3 over 2. I predict he will have an advantage in yield grade because he handles leaner down his spine and is especially cleaner over his forerib. On the other hand 2 is a more muscular sheep. He has a bolder shape of muscle over his rack, a fuller loin edge and more volume to his leg. Nonetheless, I placed him fourth. Not only is he short bodied, but he is clearly the softest handling, most overdone lamb in the class. By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 66. Market Lambs: Reasons Example # 2 • I placed the Market Lambs 4132. In my top pair I placed 4 over 1. 4 is the heaviest muscled, largest framed and most correct in his degree of finish. I grant that 1 has a larger leg, but I faulted him and placed him second because he is heavier conditioned. • In my middle pair I place 1 over 3. 1 is wider based and more expressive in his muscle shape. I grant that 3 is cleaner and trimmer in his middle, but I faulted him and place him 3rd. He is light muscled and narrow constructed. • In my bottom pair I placed 3 over 2. 3 is leaner made sheep that I would expect to rail a higher cutability carcass. I grant 2 for being heavier muscled, but I place him fourth, He is the shortest bodied and fattest made sheep in the class. By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 67. Market Lambs: Reasons Example # 3 • My preferred alignment of the market lambs is 4132, starting the class with a more massive muscular lamb who remains stronger down his top. 4 is a long bodied lamb who spreads a squarer shape over his rack, spans wider over his loin and has a longer, wider, deeper tying leg, which leads me to believe that he should rail more pounds of trimmed hindsaddle. I understand that 1 has more expression of muscle throughout his leg, yet he also is narrower made and sharper over his shoulder. • However in my middle pair it is 1s advantage in both Muscularity and expression that aligns him over 3. 1 has more expression over muscle over his crisper, firmer rack and carries this back through his more defined loin and into his bolder more dimensional leg. This suggests that he should simply rail a carcass that is totally freer of fat. Yes, 3 is more opened up in his chest floor, but he also is plainer and nondescript in his design, and appears to be heavier conditioned. • In my concluding pair of heavier conditioned lambs, I preferred the added length and volume of 3. 3 is a taller, longer patterned lamb, who is more attractive on the profile and is more extended from his last rib back. I understand that 2 is deeper bodied, but he also is the heaviest conditioned, lightest muscled lamb of the class. By Drew Obermeyer from K-State
  • 69. Learn Your Wholesale Cuts of Lamb
  • 70. Learn Your Retail Cuts of Lamb
  • 71. How to Calculate Cuts • Best Score is 50 • Calculate by adding the “Drop” • Cuts are 3 numbers-- for Top Pair, Middle Pair and Bottom Pair • Total cannot exceed 15 points • Example – Placing 4321 – Official 4231 – Cuts 7-3-4 – Score 47 (Switched middle pair)
  • 72. How to Calculate Cuts • Illustration: Ask: Is 2 over 1? – My Placing: 2134 Is 2 over 4? Is 2 over 3? – Official Placing: 2143 Is 1 over 4? Is 1 over 3? – Cuts: 5-3-2 Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2 – Score: 48
  • 73. How to Calculate Cuts • Illustration: Ask: Is 2 over 1? No, so minus 5 – My Placing: 1234 Is 2 over 4? Is 2 over 3? – Official Placing: 2143 Is 1 over 4? Is 1 over 3? – Cuts: 5-3-2 Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2 – Score: 43
  • 74. How to Calculate Cuts • Illustration: Ask: Is 2 over 1? – My Placing: 2314 Is 2 over 4? Is 2 over 3? – Official Placing: 2143 Is 1 over 4? No, so minus 3 Is 1 over 3? No, so minus 5 (3+2) – Cuts: 5-3-2 Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2 – Score: 40 The simple bust.
  • 75. How to Calculate Cuts • Illustration: Ask: Is 2 over 1? – My Placing: 4213 Is 2 over 4? No, so minus 8 Is 2 over 3? – Official Placing: 2143 Is 1 over 4? No, so minus 3 Is 1 over 3? – Cuts: 5-3-2 Is 4 over 3? – Score: 39 The simple bust.
  • 76. How to Calculate Cuts • Illustration: Ask: Is 2 over 1? No, so minus 5 – My Placing: 3142 Is 2 over 4? No, so minus 8 (5 +3) Is 2 over 3? No, so minus 10 (5+3+2) – Official Placing: 2143 Is 1 over 4? Is 1 over 3? No, so minus 5 (3+2) – Cuts: 5-3-2 Is 4 over 3? No, so minus 2 – Score: 20 The major bust.
  • 77. Now, You Try It • Example: – My Placing: 2431 – Official Placing: 2413 – Cuts: 5-4-3 – Score:
  • 78. Now, You Try It • Example: – My Placing: 3124 – Official Placing: 1234 – Cuts: 3-2-5 – Score:
  • 79. Now, You Try It • Example: – My Placing: 1234 – Official Placing: 3124 – Cuts: 2-3-7 – Score:
  • 80. Now, You Try It • Example: – My Placing: 1324 – Official Placing: 4213 – Cuts: 4-3-2 – Score:
  • 81. Now, You Try It • Example: – My Placing: 1234 – Official Placing: 4321 – Cuts: 2-5-2 – Score:
  • 82. Taking Notes on Your Steno Pad • Get several steno pads for livestock judging • Keep notes in them • I still have my steno pads from livestock judging at Lake Land & Texas A & M University
  • 83. Getting Ready for the Contest • Get your steno pad set-up the night before • Fill in the information about the classes the day of the contest • Columns for your placing, the official placing, official cuts, and your score • This will be your “Master Score Sheet” • Identify Questions and/or Reasons Classes • Identify Classes where there will be EPD’s available
  • 84. Setting Up Notes for Questions • There’s no one right way to do this – This is how I set-up my notes for question classes • Need to take notes on “identification” (e.g., tick- backed Hereford heifer), positives, and negatives – Will also get questions on comparison • Make sure to write down your placing • The goal is to take accurate enough notes to jog your memory later
  • 85. Taking Notes for Questions Classes • Write down whatever comes to mind • Can be a useful exercise to help rank the animals
  • 86. Another Way to Take Notes for Questions Again, there’s no one “right way” – Find what works for you
  • 87. Trick for Questions • Write your placing down on answer sheet – Will help job your memory – Place on scantron away from the circles
  • 88. Oral Reasons • Overview: Explaining to a judge why you chose to place the animals the way you did • Judged on the correctness of the reasons (even if different than the official) and overall presentation • 50 points maximum • Should be 60-90 seconds
  • 89. Taking Notes for Reasons • Divide your notebook into 3 pair – Top pair – Middle pair – Bottom pair • Then you’ll divide it in half again – Positives & negatives
  • 90. Strategy for Reasons Notes • Top Pair – Why 1st Place beats all the rest – Why 1st is better than 2nd place – How the 1st place animal could improve – How 2nd place might be better than 1st place – Why the 2nd place animal is second – Don’t forget to mention ID’s
  • 91. Reason Notes • Middle Pair – Is it a close decision? – Why second place beats third place – How second place can be improved – How third place may be better than second place – Why 3rd place animal is in third place
  • 92. Reason Notes • Bottom Pair – Is it a close decision? – Why third place beats fourth place – How third place can be improved – How fourth place may be better than third place – Why 4th place animal is in fourth place • Transitions
  • 93. Cari’s Reasons Tricks • I use my notes to help visualize the animals – I “see” the animals as I give my reasons – If I forget what I memorized, I just talk about the animals • I talked outloud to myself to practice (don’t worry about what others think of you – you’ll beat them!)
  • 94. Cari’s Reasons Tricks • I memorized one pair at a time – Got the first pair down before moving on to the second pair • Smile.. But not too much. Be pleasant and upbeat but not cheesy • Articulation and strong voice – Emphasize important words – Think about pauses • Dress professionally
  • 95. Cari’s Reasons Tricks • As a woman, I was taught to turn slightly to make me look more feminine • Pay attention to posture • Remember that the judges want to hear the “big points” – Don’t get too carried away in the details • Say “Good Afternoon” and “Thank You” (confidently)
  • 96. Cari’s Reasons Tricks • If you don’t feel confident in your placing, then stay away from words like “easily,” “unquestionably” and “without a doubt” – use soft language – Remember to talk the differences – Doing well in reasons is about describing the animals accurately and giving a good presentation – If you “see” the animals correctly, it’s okay to place them differently
  • 97. Sample Reasons Placing: 4-3-2-1 Cuts: 3-5-3 • I placed this class of feedlot steers 4-3-2-1. • In the top pair of steers comparable in finish, I placed 4 over 3 due to his advantage in muscling. Ideally, I would like to see 4 more structurally correct through his shoulder, however, the bald-faced steer shows more shape and natural thickness down his top and through his hip, and stands wider based when viewed from the rear. He should hang a carcass with the highest percent of saleable product in the class. No doubt, 3 is more structurally correct, particularly through the shoulder and deeper bodied. However, he is narrower topped and flatter through the quarter than the class winner, so he is second. • It is easily 3 over 2 in the middle pair. He is the nicer balanced steer that better combines yield and quality grade. He is freer of waste through the lower 1/3 of his body and shows more muscle expression down his top and through his quarter. • In the bottom pair, its 2 over 1 due to his advantage in market readiness. He is carrying more finish over his fore and rear rib and should be safer into the choice grade. I realize that 1 is the leaner. However, he is the least market ready as he runs out of finish over his rear rib. He is also the lightest muscled, narrowest made steer in the class that should hang the least amount of red meat, so he is last. From Louisiana State University, Department of Animal Science
  • 98. More Info on Oral Reasons & EPD’s Please get out the Livestock Judging Manual from Lake Land College *We’ll go through several sections
  • 99. Additional Resources • Livestock Judging.com – http://www.livestockjudging.com/free_livestock_judging_practice_clas ses.aspx • Judging 101 – http://www.judging101.com/ • Animal Science 101 – www.animalscience101.com
  • 100. Please Stay in Touch • Send Me Snail Mail: 535 Fifth Avenue, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10017 • Call Me: (212) 427-2049 (office) • Email Me: cari@rinckerlaw.com • Visit My Website: www.rinckerlaw.com • Read My Food & Ag Law Blog: www.rinckerlaw.com/blog • Tweet Me: @CariRincker @RinckerLaw • Facebook Me: www.facebook.com/rinckerlaw • Link to Me: http://www.linkedin.com/in/caririncker • Skype Me: Cari.Rincker