A teacher implemented Moodle at a high school to enhance student learning. Initially, Moodle was underutilized with no clear support structure and grades tracked separately in Excel. After redesigning courses to be more visually appealing, relevant, and easy to navigate, engagement and time spent with students increased. A Moodle working group and administrator were created to provide top-down support. The teacher found that tailoring learning activities, monitoring progress, and rewarding engagement helped improve the student experience with Moodle.