PROTECTION OF MICROGRID FROM HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT USING DIFFERENTIAL RELAY

NOVATEUR PUBLICATIONS
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INNOVATIONS IN ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGY [IJIERT]
ISSN: 2394-3696
VOLUME 2, ISSUE 9, Sept.-2015
1 | P a g e
PROTECTION OF MICROGRID FROM HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT
USING DIFFERENTIAL RELAY
Prof.P.M.Khandare
Department of Technology, University of Pune
Dr.S.A.Deokar
Campus Director, ZES’s, DCOER, Pune
Abstract
As source of traditional energy is vanishes day by day, importance of microgrid increasing very
effectively. In traditional generation and transmission of electrical power we have to rely on frequency and
generation of power but in case of microgrid we have to depend on whether condition. Managing these
systems to change of atmospheric condition becomes challenging. All study going on all over world related
to microgrid protection of microgrid is one of them. Micro grids can either operate connected to the grid, or
in the case of a grid fault, in an islanded mode. Effect of high impedance fault is studied in this paper, by
taking help of Matlab-Simulink’s SimPower Systems. We model a microgrid containing mix of renewable
DG and one dispatch able source, we then simulate the HIF fault at one of the bus in both grid-connect and
island modes and analyze fault currents and voltage levels in order to determine how the protection scheme
of the distribution network would need to be changed to facilitate microgrid functionality. We show that
standard protection methods are insufficient and propose the use of digital relays which is different from
traditional system.
Keywords: Fault analysis, Microgrid, Protection
INTRODUCTION
From the United state report Investigator says “Microgrid has been proposed as way of integrating large
number of distributed renewable energy sources with distribution system, one problem with microgrid
implementation is designing proper protection scheme”. Relay protection of microgrid is different than
conventional power distribution grid in following ways (1) Current flow in microgrid in both direction while
in conventional grid support single end power supply.(2)Use of large power electronic converters cause
another problem.(3)Relay protection should be provided for islanding and normal mode, with high speed,
selectivity and reliability Which lead to great challenge for protection of Microgrid.
Domestic and foreign researchers have made extensive studies on the relay protection of MG. N-line
operation. Similarly, N. Schaefer et al. [4, 9] describe a scheme and the algorithm of an adaptive protection
relay, which comprises a real-time block and a non-real time block, both implemented in software and
hardware. Y. Han et al. [13] propose that, comparing the system’s impedance and the microgrid’s
impedance, over current instantaneous protections can be automatically adjusted to the new situation. Then,
K. Dang et al. [14] propose to use a way of comparison between the zero-sequence current and a threshold.
T. S. Ustun, et al [2] present an adaptive protection system based on an extensive communication system
that monitors the microgrid by means of a Central Protection Unit (CPU).
The main objective of this thesis is the modeling of a hybrid microgrid with its protection which will also
clear high impedance faults. A development of novel method for modeling high impedance faults is

ISSN: 2394-3696
2 | P a g e
important to demonstrate to show how the protection scheme can protect against them. This is important in
microgrid protection not only because as the percentage of high impedance faults on the distribution system
is not insignificant [7], but also because microgrids, in the islanded mode, typically have lower fault
currents. Hence modeling and complete protection of microgrid are the main part of this paper. The overall
system is simulated using MATLAB environment. In simulation work the renewable sources are modeled
using different equations.
SYSTEM TOPOLOGY AND DG MODELS
A. SYSTEM DESCRIPTION
A microgrid is group of controllable interconnected loads and distributed generation (DGs) with clearly
defined electrical boundaries that act as single controllable entity with respect to grid. Dynamic structure of
microgrid and its versatile operation will lead to alternative protection strategy. The system used in this
study is taken from [3] an 18-bus network with a load capacity of 3.03 MVA connected to a 10 MVA
transformer. The system with line parameters and feeder source impedance are given. The phase loads of
each bus were also given and are shown in Table 1. The system is protected using fuses and reclosers on the
overhead lines and breakers on the underground lines. To this system we added four solar arrays, two wind
turbines, and one diesel generator. The solar arrays are each connected to three-phase inverters and provide
a total of 2,256 kW. The wind generators provide an additional 500 kW to the grid. During islanded
operations, additional generation and load following is provided by a 300 kW diesel generator. System is
shown with solar arrays, wind turbine, disel generator is shown in fig 1
Table 1 bus loads for the microgrid in fig. 1
B. DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM WITH DG SOURCE
The given system in [3] is converted to microgrid by adding 4 solar arrays having capacity 564 Kw, 2 wind
turbines provides 500Kw to grid and 1 diesel generator which gives additional generation and load
following is provided by 300 kW. They are connected to three phase inverters to give total of 2256 kW.
Solar array are connected to node no. 3,6,16 and 18 and wind turbine is connected to 5th and 10th node of
system. Diesel generator is connected to node no.13

ISSN: 2394-3696
3 | P a g e
Fig1:- One line diagram of the microgrid with added DG sources
C. MODELING MICROGRID IN MATLAB SIMULINK
(i) PV arrays are built up with combined series/parallel combinations of PV solar cells, there are several
ways to model a PV cell, module, or array for simulation. A possible model of a photovoltaic array and
inverter [17] was researched. According to theory, its features were modeled in Simulink.
(ii)The diesel motor model used in this study is a modified version of matlab-simulink library demo
model [5] and is connected to a 300-kW/12.47-kV synchronous generator .The asynchronous motor is rated
150 HP, 12.47 kV and the synchronous machine is rated 375 KVA, 12.47kV.The diesel engine and
governor system are modeled by a Simulink block initially, the motor develops mechanical power of 150
HP (300 kW) and the diesel generator is in standby, providing no active power
(iii)Wind turbines are connected to a 100-kW and 400-kW squirrel-cage induction generators. According to
Wind turbine characteristics given wind speed is calculated which will give maximum power output.
Constant Wind Speed is fed to turbine to give required output.
Figure 2 shows grid connected system with DGs at various nodes; measurements are taken at each node as
shown.
Fig2:- MATLAB model of micro grid with different DG sources

ISSN: 2394-3696
4 | P a g e
SIMULATION OF HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT
A. INTRODUCTION
When fault current is below pick up of conventional over current, If<100 Amps on grounded system, which
occurs because of Incipient insulator failures, Fallen conductors on concrete, tree, soil, gravel, sand, asphalt,
etc. this condition raises the electric potential of tangible objects around us and may result in death by
electrocution, severe electrical burns, or fires ignited by arcing and heating of materials. The occurrence of
such conditions also constitutes a loss of energy to the power companies as not all of the produced electrical
power is delivered to their appointed loads. Power is lost on the way of delivery and dissipated through
foreign objects which should not be in contact with the line. Conventional relaying schemes monitor short-
circuit conditions where a significant amount of the energy supplied by the power company flows directly
into the ground and never reaches its load. In this paper a new technique is proposed to model, locate, and
detect high-impedance faults. Patterns and characteristics in the line’s current provide for recognition and
are investigated to detect such faults. [21]
B. STATEMENT OF PROBLEM
Conventional detection schemes monitor only low-impedance faults (LIFs that result in instantaneous and
large increments of current due to a low-impedance path to ground ).A HIF seems invisible to such
detection methods because it presents only a small increment in line current and appears to be a normal load
increment. Following figure 6.1 depicts this scenario.
Fig3:- Distribution network with HIF
C. PURPOSE OF STUDY
HIF can occur in two cases. In one case, a conductor breaks and fall to ground and fallen phase current
decreases and protection relays cannot detect fault because current is not more than setting current of relays.
In other state conductor isn’t break but it touches a high impedance thing such as tree limbs. In this state
feeder current increase but it is not enough to detect by conventional protection relay. Therefore this type of
fault is very difficult to detect also it is very dangerous for human life and necessary to detect.
D. STATERGY OF HIF FAULT DETECTION
HIFs detection is very difficult by conventional techniques, various methods are proposed before [23]-[25]
but no effective solution. This paper proposed technique based on measurement of current sequence
component. One of the advantage is that it can easily incorporated with digital Relays .Based on
superposition theorem, cureent can be consist of two component (i) a normal-running component, and (2) a
fault-imposed component. The fault-imposed component can be calculated using superimposed networks
[26],[27]. Assuming that in(t) is the current of the normal system (normal-running current), if (t) is the
current of the faulted system (fault current), and ifi(t) is the current of the superimposed network (fault-
imposed current), one can write:

ISSN: 2394-3696
5 | P a g e
if (t) = in(t) + if i(t)
Typical HIF currents values of above type for a 12.5-kV distribution feeder are listed in Table 2[10].
TABLE 2 HIF currents values
Material Current(Amps)
Dry Asphalt 0
Concrete(non-reinforced) 0
Dry Sand 0
Wet Sand 15
Dry Sod 20
Dry Grass 25
Wet Sod 40
Wet Grass 50
Concrete Reinforced 75
To evaluate the method of HIF detection, a model based on Emanuel model for HIF is utilized, which is
depicted in Figure 4. HIF Current changes between 0 and 80 Amp as shown in above table 2 and it is
obtained with change of Emanuel parameters. A list of Emanuel parameter that is result from practical test
[18] is brought in Table 3.
TABLE 3 Value of Emanuel model parameter
Rp Rn
1 208 212
2 215 223
3 235 225
4 244 227
5 245 245
6 247 271
7 255 280
8 267 286
9 269 289
10 272 290
Data in Table 3 are used to simulate a HIF in a distribution feeder
Fig3:- Emanuel Model of HIF

ISSN: 2394-3696
6 | P a g e
SIMULATION OF HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT
Emanuel model used to create Matlab Model which includes two DC sources, Vp and Vn. These represent the
arcing voltage of air in soil and/or between trees and the distribution line; two resistances, Rp and Rn,
between diodes which represent the resistance of trees and/or the earth resistance. When the line voltage is
greater than the positive DC voltage Vp, the fault current starts flowing towards the ground. The fault current
reverses backward from the ground when the line voltage is less than the negative DC voltage Vn.
Using above parameters of resistance from table 3 a variable resistance is modeled in matlab with controlled
voltage source. Resistance value is taken of 15% of constant resistance of 250ohm.Hence variable resistance
is obtained for which min and max values are from a table 3 To study a simulation of HIF, a sample
distribution system is considered with 12.47kVthree phase source and transmission line with two circuit
breakers on both sides. Figure 4 gives High impedance fault created on sample distribution system in
matlab.
Model of HIF thus discovered is used to simulate a fault on 18 bus distribution system. This fault is
simulated on various buses of Microgrid system.
Fig4:- HIF Fault on sample distribution System
MODELING OF NUMERICAL RELAY FOR COMPLETE PROTECTION OF MICROGRID
A.INTRODUCTION
There are different philosophies of protecting islanded microgrids. One is to simply trip the entire
microgrid offline once the fault is detected during islanding. For additional reliability, the faulted line will
need to be removed from service and the remaining connected loads and sources will operate as two smaller
islands. This will only work if the generation and load in each smaller system match. If higher reliability is
required, the feeders can be connected as a loop, so the loss of a feeder or a lateral will not result in service
disruption to customers. The higher reliability, however, comes at a higher cost.
B. PROPOSED PROTECTION SCHEME FOR MICROGRID
This proposed protection scheme uses a current differential relay with specified algorithm which considers
internal, external and high impedance faults. By using these relays on the end of each line segment, a very
robust protection scheme can be developed. During this simulation study, HIF current patterns are evaluated
by decomposing the line current into its spectral content and studying its harmonic content. It is observed

ISSN: 2394-3696
7 | P a g e
that HIF currents content different patterns than load switching and other system variation condition.
Specifically, it is noticed that phase shift for the 3rd
harmonics current with respect to the fundamental has
occurred. This phase shift of 3rd
harmonics current is used to distinguish the presence of high impedance
fault than load switching condition. This differentiating criterion is used to find out the algorithm for
numerical relay for HIF protection.
Acknowledgment (HEADING 5)
Fig 5:- algorithm for numerical relay for HIF protection
C. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE DIGITAL DIFFERENTIAL PROTECTION USING
MATLAB
Different protection functions are required to design an appropriate protection scheme for microgrids. “the
amplitude comparator module", “the harmonic comparator module" inside each comparator block. The
amplitude comparator module compares the magnitude of the fault currents at two end of protective device
and the output trip signal of the amplitude comparator module is used by the islanded-mode protection
module. Harmonic calculation module is generally comes in picture when high impedance faults exists in
system. Finally, the tripping module decides whether or not a trip signal should be issued to external
controlled circuit breaker.
Fig 6:- Tripping Module

ISSN: 2394-3696
8 | P a g e
SIMULATION RESULT
High impedance fault is simulated on sample distribution system. Results obtained for current waveform of
HIF is shown in figure 7
Fig7:- current waveform of HIF
Phasor shift in waveform detects the presence of HIF and distinguishes it from load switching conditions.
Load switching waveforms are shown in figure 8 below. It can be seen that there is no phase shift occur in
load switching case.
Fig 8:- Load switching waveforms
Numerical Differential relay deployed in system is used to protect against HIF types of fault.
Fig 9:- Clearance of HIF fault using differential relay
CONCLUSION
The economical and environmental merits of microgrids have motivated extensive researches and
development efforts toward resolving the technical challenges of this new and fast-growing technology. The
main objective of this study is to address some concerns related to the protection of microgrids. The issues
studied in the thesis are modeling of distribution generation and protection of the microgrid against different
fault scenarios in both modes of operation.
Microgrids can be protected using digital current differential relay deployed at each line end in system.
Relay structure thus proposed is able to protect all types of fault in medium voltage microgrid. In this way
complete protection of microgrid system can be achieved

ISSN: 2394-3696
9 | P a g e
REFERENCES
[1] "Fault Analysis and Protection of a Microgrid" E. Sortomme, Student Member, IEEE, G. J. Mapes, B.
A. Foster, S. S. Venkata, Fellow, IEEE
[2] T. S. Ustun, et al., "A microgrid protection system with central protection unit and extensive
communication", in Environment and Electrical Engineering (EEEIC), 2011 10th International Conference
on, 2011,
[3]G. Sybille Hydro-Quebec, Simulink: Emergency Diesel-Generator and Asynchronous Motor. [Matlab].
Natick, MA: MathWorks, Inc., 2007.
[4]R. Reid, B. Saulnier, R. Gagnon, Simulink: Wind-turbine asynchronous generator in isolated network,
[Matlab]. Natick, MA: MathWorks, Inc.,2007
[5]C. G. Wester, High Impedance Fault Detection on Distribution Systems, General Electric Company,
2008 [Online]. Available:http://pm.geindustrial.com/faq/documents/f60/ger3993.pdf
[6]S. R. Nam, J. K. Park, Y. C. Kang, and T. H. Kim, “A modeling method of a high impedance fault in a
distribution system using two series time varying resistances in EMTP,” in Proc. IEEE Power Eng.Soc.
Summer Meeting, Vancouver, BC, Canada, Jul. 2001, vol. 2, pp.1175–1180.
[7] N. Schaefer, et al., "Adaptive protection system for distribution networks with distributed energy
resources", in Developments in Power System Protection (DPSP 2010). Managing the Change, 10th IET
International Conference on, 2010, pp. 1-5
[8] “High Impedance Fault Detection of Distribution Network by Phasor Measurement Units” ,Mohsen
Ghalei Monfared Zanjani, Hossein Kazemi Karegar, Hasan Ashrafi Niaki, Mina Ghalei Monfared Zanjani,
Smart Grid and Renewable Energy, 2013, 4, 297-305
[9] “A New Approach to Current Differential Protection for Transmission Lines”, M. G. Adamiak,W.
Premerlani, ELECTRIC COUNCIL OF NEW ENGLAND Protective Relaying Committee Meeting October
22-23, 1998
[10] “Protection of Microgrids Using Differential Relays”, Manjula Dewadasa, Member, IEEE, Arindam
Ghosh, Fellow, IEEE and Gerard Ledwich, Senior Member, IEEE
[11] Y. Han, et al., "Study of adaptive fault current algorithm for microgrid dominated by inverter based
distributed generators", in Power Electronics for Distributed Generation Systems (PEDG), 2010 2nd IEEE
International Symposium on, 2010, pp. 852-854.
[12] D. Ke, et al., "An adaptive protection method for the inverter dominated microgrid", in Electrical
Machines and Systems (ICEMS), 2011 International Conference on, 2011, pp. 1-5.

ISSN: 2394-3696
10 | P a g e
[13] “Modeling and Simulation of Micro Grid System Based on Renewable Power Generation Units by
using Multilevel Converter”, K. Venkateswarlu, J. Krishna Kishore, QIS College of Engineering &
Technology, Prakasam dt (AP)
[14] “Study of Micro Grid Safety & Protection Strategies with Control System Infrastructures”, Md Razibul
Islam, Hossam A. Gabbar, Faculty of Energy System and Nuclear Science, University of Ontario Institute of
Technology, Oshawa, Canada.
[15] “A Photovoltaic Array Simulation Model for Matlab-Simulink GUI Environment” I. H. Altas1 and
A.M. Sharaf2
[18] “High-Impedance Fault Detection Using Discrete Wavelet Transform and Frequency Range and RMS
Conversion”, T. M. Lai, L. A. Snider, Senior Member, IEEE, E. Lo, Member, IEEE, and D. Sutanto, Senior
Member, IEEE
[16] “IEEE Guide for the Application of Current Transformers Used for Protective Relaying Purposes,"
IEEE Std C37.110-2007), pp. C1-67, 2008.
[17] “Protection of micro-grids dominated by distributed generation using solid state converters”, by M. A.
Red fern and H. Al-Nasseri, in Proc. IET 9th Int. Conf. Develop. Power Syst. Protection, 2008, pp. 670–
674.
[18] “High Impedance Fault Detection on Distribution Systems”, by C. G. Wester, General Electric
Company, 2008 [Online].
[19] “Selection of current transformer and wire sizing in substations”, Sethuraman Ganesan ,ABB Inc.
,Allentown, PA
[20] “High impedance fault detection in low voltage networks” R. C. Christie, H. Zadehgol and M. M.
Habib, , IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 1829-1836, Oct. 1993.
[21] “Distribution high impedance fault detection utilizing high frequency current components” B. M.
Aucoin and B. D. Russell, IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 101, no. 6, pp. 1596-1606,
Jun. 1982.
[22] “Unique aspects of distribution system harmonics due to high impedance ground faults” D. I. Jeering
and J. R. Linders, , IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 1086-1094, Apr. 1990.
[23] “Research on no communication protection of distribution lines based on fault components” ,B.
Jianguang, D. Xinzhou, G. Yongji and B. Zhiqian, in Proc. intl. Conf.
[24]Power System Technology, pp. 1151-1155, Oct. 2002. J. D. Glover and M. S. Sarma, Power System
Analysis and Design, 3rd Edition, Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole, 2002.
[25] “Cooper Power Systems”, Ed. 3, Electrical Distribution-System Protection, Cooper Industries, 1990.

PROTECTION OF MICROGRID FROM HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT USING DIFFERENTIAL RELAY

More Related Content

What's hot (18)

Similar to PROTECTION OF MICROGRID FROM HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT USING DIFFERENTIAL RELAY (20)

More from ijiert bestjournal (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

PROTECTION OF MICROGRID FROM HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT USING DIFFERENTIAL RELAY