SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Regional enterprise architecture (EA)
modeling for systemic development
of city's ICT
(рус. Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства
для системного развития средств ИКТ города)
Kostyrko Artem1, Kudryavtsev Dmitry 2,3, Grigoriev Lev2, Kislova Valentina2,
Zhulin Andrey1, Sinyatullina Leila1, Ermakov Roman4
1 NRU HSE, 2 Business Engineering Group, 3 NRU SPbSPU, 4 КТЕ Labs.
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Agenda
1. The role of regional EA modeling for systemic
ICT development
2. Regional EA modeling methodology
3. Decision support / reference system for
systemic (consistent) ICT development
4. Related work
5. Conclusions
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Information city 2011-2016 Program
Development of
advertising and
mass media
Program Implementation Management
Building public ICT
environment
Creation of the Intelligent
City Management System
ICT Development aimed
at improving city
inhabitants
quality of life and
facilitating business
conduct
Quality of life
High-level
infrastructure
Efficient
government
Information city 2011-2016 Program
Moscow city strategic goals
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Program Implementation Management
Carrying out integrated analysis and assessment of applicability and relevancy of the existing Moscow city
information systems and resources
1.
Integrated simulation of the processes of implementation of functions of Moscow city authorities and
institutions, and description of their targeted state
2.
Development of the risk management system, including development of the package of risk prevention
measures
3.
KEY FIGURE
DEVELOPMENT OF THE SYSTEMIC PROJECT OF THE PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION
4.
• The share of Moscow city information systems and resources meeting the system project
requirements: 100% by 2016
1.
Developing requirements to the solution architecture within the framework of the systemic project of the
Program implementation
Developing of training methodology and vocational training of state civil officials and employees of
Moscow city institutions; creating and providing methodological component of the technology training
center activity
2.
3.
Development and execution of public control and technical supervision procedures
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Models within systemic project
Process and performance model
Information modelOrganizational structure model
Information system model
Public function
Business area Line of business
City process
Outcome Output
Indicators
Government authorities
Lower organizations
Positions
Information entity
Attributes Domains
Business entity
Information resources (register,
repository, database…)
Information
system (IS)
IS functions IS passports
Interfaces
Informatizationactivities
(program“Informationcity”)
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Systemic project ontology
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Онтология для моделирования комплексов
городского хозяйства (фрагмент иерархии классов)
7
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Онтология для моделирования комплексов
городского хозяйства (свойства классов)
8
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Decision support /
Reference system
Portal
Project and
performance
management system
IS audit IS
Modeler
Projects and KPIs which are
related to government
authorities and IS IS passports
Comments and
moderation
Semi-automatic
amendment
System architecture
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Modeler
Ontology-based
enterprise model
editor
Ontology-based
enterprise model
Reporting and
query module
Documents
Diagrams
(visual, svg)
Modeling process wizard
Integration wizard
Diagram editor
Query results
Semi-
structured
data
OWL
XML
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Structure of the model
Classifier Matrix
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Classifier example: City processes
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Classifier example: Information resources
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Matrix example:
Organizational structure - City processes
Matrix examples:
• What processes are controlled by authority (Organizational structure -
City processes)
• What information resources are used by the process (City processes –
Information resources)
• What information resources are used by the authority
(Organizational structure – Information resources)
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Matrix example: Outcomes (Values) – City processes
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Metamodeling language - ORLAN (ORganizational LANguage)
This language allows to structure, represent and query enterprise model.
ORLAN :: = <TYPES, CL, MX, InferPR, D, TASKS, SPEC >, where:
TYPES – types descriptions, which specify the CLASSES, RELATIONSHIPS AND
PROPERTIES of enterprise ontology, together with their taxonomies,
CL – classifier, the representation format for entities, hierarhical relationships between
them and values for the properties of entities (including ontological types).
Hierarchy is the main feature of classifies and the main relationship types are
“part-of ”, “class-subclass”, “be subordinated to” etc.
MX – matrix (or table), the representation format for relationships between entities
from classifiers. Example relationship types are “perform”, “help achieve” etc.
InferMX – inference matrix, allows to infer implicit knowledge via transitive property
of relationships in several matrixes,
D – modeling domains (activities, norms, information resources, etc),
TASKS – enterprise engineering method specification,
SPEC – views specifications.
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Classes (metamodel)
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Outputs from the model: analytical reports
This data is not recorded by
any government authority yet
This data is already recorded by
another government authority
8
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Data is recorded in several
information resources
(repositories) by different
authorities
9
Outputs from the model: diagrams
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Portal – the tool for final users
Main users:
• managers of department of information
technologies of Moscow city,
• government authorities managers, responsible for
informatization
Future: Public
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Portal examples: line of business key activities
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Portal examples: Public function passport
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Portal examples: Public function context diagram
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Portal examples: Faceted search
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Related work
Enterprise architecture research and practice
Traditional methodologies:
• NGOSS (англ. New Generation Operations Support
System) from TMForum,
• FEA — Federal enterprise architecture,
• Business Systems Planning (BSP)— Information
Systems Planning Guide, IBM Corporation.
Semantic methods and tools:
Allemang D., Polikoff I. , Hodgson R. Enterprise Architecture Reference
Modeling in OWL/RDF // International Semantic Web Conference,
2005. — P. 844–857.
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Conclusions
• Regional enterprise architecture (EA)
modeling supports systemic development
of city's ICT (explicit link between outcomes,
city processes and information systems),
• Currently we are creating regional enterprise
architecture models and collecting feedback,
• Work in progress.
NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs
Publications
1. Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства для системного развития ИКТ города //
Костырко А., Кудрявцев Д., Григорьев Л., Кислова В., Жулин А., Синятуллина Л., Ермаков Р.
// Сборник трудов конференции «Инженерия знаний и технологии семантического веба -
2012», 1-9 октября 2012, г. Санкт-Петербург, Россия. СПб: СПбГУ ИТМО, 2012. – С. 81-88.
2. Административное моделирование на основе онтологий // Кудрявцев Д. В., Григорьев Л.
Ю., Кислова В. В., Жулин А. Б. // Вопросы государственного и муниципального управления.
– 2009. № 1. – с. 157-169.
3. Технология наполнения баз знаний онтологического типа // Григорьев Л. Ю., Заблоцкий А.
А., Кудрявцев Д. В. // Журнал «Научно-технические ведомости СПбГПУ. Серия
«Информатика. Телекоммуникации. Управление». №3. 2012. – С. 27–36.
4. Организационное проектирование на основе онтологий: методология и система ОРГ-
Мастер // Григорьев Л. Ю., Кудрявцев Д. В. // Журнал «Научно-технические ведомости
СПбГПУ. Серия «Информатика. Телекоммуникации. Управление». №1. 2012. – С. 21–28.
5. Ontology-based business architecture engineering technology // Kudryavtsev, D., Grigoriev, L. //
The 10th International Conference on Intelligent Software Methodologies, Tools and
Techniques, September 28-30, 2011. P. 233-252.
27
Thanks!
Questions?
Kostyrko Artem1, Kudryavtsev Dmitry 2,3, Grigoriev Lev2, Kislova Valentina2,
Zhulin Andrey1, Sinyatullina Leila1, Ermakov Roman4
1 NRU HSE artem.kost@gmail.com, a.zhulin@gmail.com,
l.sinyatullina@gmail.com.
2 «Business Engineering Group», dmitry.ku@gmail.com, griglev@gmail.com,
valya@big.spb.ru.
3 SPbSPU
4 КТЕ Labs, roman.ermakov@gmail.com.

More Related Content

PPTX
Political culture of somalia
PDF
The Politics of Clan Hegemonic States In Somalia: A Contestation Without Reco...
PPT
Saudi arabia(economy) PPT
PPTX
Saudi Arabia- Culture
PPT
Saudi Arabia Presentation, Saudi Culture, Saudi Women rights, Saudi Food, Sau...
PDF
STOCKSENTIX: A MACHINE LEARNING APPROACH TO STOCKMARKET
PDF
Algorithm for calculating relevance of documents in information retrieval sys...
PDF
Compliance driven process development with DCR graphs
Political culture of somalia
The Politics of Clan Hegemonic States In Somalia: A Contestation Without Reco...
Saudi arabia(economy) PPT
Saudi Arabia- Culture
Saudi Arabia Presentation, Saudi Culture, Saudi Women rights, Saudi Food, Sau...
STOCKSENTIX: A MACHINE LEARNING APPROACH TO STOCKMARKET
Algorithm for calculating relevance of documents in information retrieval sys...
Compliance driven process development with DCR graphs

Similar to Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling for systemic development of city's ICT (20)

PDF
International Journal of Computational Engineering Research(IJCER)
PDF
Ijciet 10 02_032
PDF
Development of an intelligent information resource model based on modern na...
PDF
Ijcsit12REQUIREMENTS ENGINEERING OF A WEB PORTAL USING ORGANIZATIONAL SEMIOTI...
PDF
IRJET-Computational model for the processing of documents and support to the ...
PDF
MODELS OF IT-PROJECT MANAGEMENT
PDF
MODELS OF IT-PROJECT MANAGEMENT
PDF
Management of time uncertainty in agile
PDF
Meffortmob a effort size measurement
PDF
WDES 2015 paper: A Systematic Mapping on the Relations between Systems-of-Sys...
PDF
Models of IT-Project Management - ijcst journal
PDF
Vol 17 No 1 - January June 2017
PDF
Process Oriented Analysis and Validation of Multi Agent Based Simulations 1st...
PPT
Strategic Management of S&T Information for Innovation Promotion
PDF
From Representation to Mediation: A New Agenda for Conceptual Modeling Resear...
PDF
Process Oriented Analysis and Validation of Multi Agent Based Simulations 1st...
PDF
Semantically Enriched Knowledge Extraction With Data Mining
PDF
Process Mining in Supply Chains: A Systematic Literature Review
PPT
Knowledge Engineering, Electronic Government and the applications to Scientom...
PDF
Continuity in the development of seamless mobility: An approach for a system-...
International Journal of Computational Engineering Research(IJCER)
Ijciet 10 02_032
Development of an intelligent information resource model based on modern na...
Ijcsit12REQUIREMENTS ENGINEERING OF A WEB PORTAL USING ORGANIZATIONAL SEMIOTI...
IRJET-Computational model for the processing of documents and support to the ...
MODELS OF IT-PROJECT MANAGEMENT
MODELS OF IT-PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Management of time uncertainty in agile
Meffortmob a effort size measurement
WDES 2015 paper: A Systematic Mapping on the Relations between Systems-of-Sys...
Models of IT-Project Management - ijcst journal
Vol 17 No 1 - January June 2017
Process Oriented Analysis and Validation of Multi Agent Based Simulations 1st...
Strategic Management of S&T Information for Innovation Promotion
From Representation to Mediation: A New Agenda for Conceptual Modeling Resear...
Process Oriented Analysis and Validation of Multi Agent Based Simulations 1st...
Semantically Enriched Knowledge Extraction With Data Mining
Process Mining in Supply Chains: A Systematic Literature Review
Knowledge Engineering, Electronic Government and the applications to Scientom...
Continuity in the development of seamless mobility: An approach for a system-...
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Deliverable file - Regulatory guideline analysis.pdf
PDF
Cours de Système d'information about ERP.pdf
PDF
pdfcoffee.com-opt-b1plus-sb-answers.pdfvi
PDF
Solaris Resources Presentation - Corporate August 2025.pdf
PDF
IFRS Notes in your pocket for study all the time
PDF
Family Law: The Role of Communication in Mediation (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PDF
SIMNET Inc – 2023’s Most Trusted IT Services & Solution Provider
PPT
Lecture 3344;;,,(,(((((((((((((((((((((((
PDF
Blood Collected straight from the donor into a blood bag and mixed with an an...
PPTX
Board-Reporting-Package-by-Umbrex-5-23-23.pptx
PDF
NEW - FEES STRUCTURES (01-july-2024).pdf
PDF
Booking.com The Global AI Sentiment Report 2025
PDF
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Aug 2025.pdf
PDF
Keppel_Proposed Divestment of M1 Limited
PDF
Digital Marketing & E-commerce Certificate Glossary.pdf.................
PDF
ANALYZING THE OPPORTUNITIES OF DIGITAL MARKETING IN BANGLADESH TO PROVIDE AN ...
PPTX
Slide gioi thieu VietinBank Quy 2 - 2025
PDF
Daniels 2024 Inclusive, Sustainable Development
PDF
Building a Smart Pet Ecosystem: A Full Introduction to Zhejiang Beijing Techn...
PDF
NISM Series V-A MFD Workbook v December 2024.khhhjtgvwevoypdnew one must use ...
Deliverable file - Regulatory guideline analysis.pdf
Cours de Système d'information about ERP.pdf
pdfcoffee.com-opt-b1plus-sb-answers.pdfvi
Solaris Resources Presentation - Corporate August 2025.pdf
IFRS Notes in your pocket for study all the time
Family Law: The Role of Communication in Mediation (www.kiu.ac.ug)
SIMNET Inc – 2023’s Most Trusted IT Services & Solution Provider
Lecture 3344;;,,(,(((((((((((((((((((((((
Blood Collected straight from the donor into a blood bag and mixed with an an...
Board-Reporting-Package-by-Umbrex-5-23-23.pptx
NEW - FEES STRUCTURES (01-july-2024).pdf
Booking.com The Global AI Sentiment Report 2025
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Aug 2025.pdf
Keppel_Proposed Divestment of M1 Limited
Digital Marketing & E-commerce Certificate Glossary.pdf.................
ANALYZING THE OPPORTUNITIES OF DIGITAL MARKETING IN BANGLADESH TO PROVIDE AN ...
Slide gioi thieu VietinBank Quy 2 - 2025
Daniels 2024 Inclusive, Sustainable Development
Building a Smart Pet Ecosystem: A Full Introduction to Zhejiang Beijing Techn...
NISM Series V-A MFD Workbook v December 2024.khhhjtgvwevoypdnew one must use ...
Ad

Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling for systemic development of city's ICT

  • 1. Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling for systemic development of city's ICT (рус. Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства для системного развития средств ИКТ города) Kostyrko Artem1, Kudryavtsev Dmitry 2,3, Grigoriev Lev2, Kislova Valentina2, Zhulin Andrey1, Sinyatullina Leila1, Ermakov Roman4 1 NRU HSE, 2 Business Engineering Group, 3 NRU SPbSPU, 4 КТЕ Labs.
  • 2. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Agenda 1. The role of regional EA modeling for systemic ICT development 2. Regional EA modeling methodology 3. Decision support / reference system for systemic (consistent) ICT development 4. Related work 5. Conclusions
  • 3. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Information city 2011-2016 Program Development of advertising and mass media Program Implementation Management Building public ICT environment Creation of the Intelligent City Management System ICT Development aimed at improving city inhabitants quality of life and facilitating business conduct Quality of life High-level infrastructure Efficient government Information city 2011-2016 Program Moscow city strategic goals
  • 4. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Program Implementation Management Carrying out integrated analysis and assessment of applicability and relevancy of the existing Moscow city information systems and resources 1. Integrated simulation of the processes of implementation of functions of Moscow city authorities and institutions, and description of their targeted state 2. Development of the risk management system, including development of the package of risk prevention measures 3. KEY FIGURE DEVELOPMENT OF THE SYSTEMIC PROJECT OF THE PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION 4. • The share of Moscow city information systems and resources meeting the system project requirements: 100% by 2016 1. Developing requirements to the solution architecture within the framework of the systemic project of the Program implementation Developing of training methodology and vocational training of state civil officials and employees of Moscow city institutions; creating and providing methodological component of the technology training center activity 2. 3. Development and execution of public control and technical supervision procedures
  • 5. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Models within systemic project Process and performance model Information modelOrganizational structure model Information system model Public function Business area Line of business City process Outcome Output Indicators Government authorities Lower organizations Positions Information entity Attributes Domains Business entity Information resources (register, repository, database…) Information system (IS) IS functions IS passports Interfaces Informatizationactivities (program“Informationcity”)
  • 6. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Systemic project ontology
  • 7. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Онтология для моделирования комплексов городского хозяйства (фрагмент иерархии классов) 7
  • 8. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Онтология для моделирования комплексов городского хозяйства (свойства классов) 8
  • 9. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Decision support / Reference system Portal Project and performance management system IS audit IS Modeler Projects and KPIs which are related to government authorities and IS IS passports Comments and moderation Semi-automatic amendment System architecture
  • 10. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Modeler Ontology-based enterprise model editor Ontology-based enterprise model Reporting and query module Documents Diagrams (visual, svg) Modeling process wizard Integration wizard Diagram editor Query results Semi- structured data OWL XML
  • 11. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Structure of the model Classifier Matrix
  • 12. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Classifier example: City processes
  • 13. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Classifier example: Information resources
  • 14. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Matrix example: Organizational structure - City processes Matrix examples: • What processes are controlled by authority (Organizational structure - City processes) • What information resources are used by the process (City processes – Information resources) • What information resources are used by the authority (Organizational structure – Information resources)
  • 15. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Matrix example: Outcomes (Values) – City processes
  • 16. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Metamodeling language - ORLAN (ORganizational LANguage) This language allows to structure, represent and query enterprise model. ORLAN :: = <TYPES, CL, MX, InferPR, D, TASKS, SPEC >, where: TYPES – types descriptions, which specify the CLASSES, RELATIONSHIPS AND PROPERTIES of enterprise ontology, together with their taxonomies, CL – classifier, the representation format for entities, hierarhical relationships between them and values for the properties of entities (including ontological types). Hierarchy is the main feature of classifies and the main relationship types are “part-of ”, “class-subclass”, “be subordinated to” etc. MX – matrix (or table), the representation format for relationships between entities from classifiers. Example relationship types are “perform”, “help achieve” etc. InferMX – inference matrix, allows to infer implicit knowledge via transitive property of relationships in several matrixes, D – modeling domains (activities, norms, information resources, etc), TASKS – enterprise engineering method specification, SPEC – views specifications.
  • 17. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Classes (metamodel)
  • 18. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Outputs from the model: analytical reports This data is not recorded by any government authority yet This data is already recorded by another government authority 8
  • 19. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Data is recorded in several information resources (repositories) by different authorities 9 Outputs from the model: diagrams
  • 20. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Portal – the tool for final users Main users: • managers of department of information technologies of Moscow city, • government authorities managers, responsible for informatization Future: Public
  • 21. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Portal examples: line of business key activities
  • 22. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Portal examples: Public function passport
  • 23. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Portal examples: Public function context diagram
  • 24. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Portal examples: Faceted search
  • 25. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Related work Enterprise architecture research and practice Traditional methodologies: • NGOSS (англ. New Generation Operations Support System) from TMForum, • FEA — Federal enterprise architecture, • Business Systems Planning (BSP)— Information Systems Planning Guide, IBM Corporation. Semantic methods and tools: Allemang D., Polikoff I. , Hodgson R. Enterprise Architecture Reference Modeling in OWL/RDF // International Semantic Web Conference, 2005. — P. 844–857.
  • 26. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Conclusions • Regional enterprise architecture (EA) modeling supports systemic development of city's ICT (explicit link between outcomes, city processes and information systems), • Currently we are creating regional enterprise architecture models and collecting feedback, • Work in progress.
  • 27. NRU HSE, Business Engineering Group, NRU SPbSPU, КТЕ Labs Publications 1. Моделирование комплексов городского хозяйства для системного развития ИКТ города // Костырко А., Кудрявцев Д., Григорьев Л., Кислова В., Жулин А., Синятуллина Л., Ермаков Р. // Сборник трудов конференции «Инженерия знаний и технологии семантического веба - 2012», 1-9 октября 2012, г. Санкт-Петербург, Россия. СПб: СПбГУ ИТМО, 2012. – С. 81-88. 2. Административное моделирование на основе онтологий // Кудрявцев Д. В., Григорьев Л. Ю., Кислова В. В., Жулин А. Б. // Вопросы государственного и муниципального управления. – 2009. № 1. – с. 157-169. 3. Технология наполнения баз знаний онтологического типа // Григорьев Л. Ю., Заблоцкий А. А., Кудрявцев Д. В. // Журнал «Научно-технические ведомости СПбГПУ. Серия «Информатика. Телекоммуникации. Управление». №3. 2012. – С. 27–36. 4. Организационное проектирование на основе онтологий: методология и система ОРГ- Мастер // Григорьев Л. Ю., Кудрявцев Д. В. // Журнал «Научно-технические ведомости СПбГПУ. Серия «Информатика. Телекоммуникации. Управление». №1. 2012. – С. 21–28. 5. Ontology-based business architecture engineering technology // Kudryavtsev, D., Grigoriev, L. // The 10th International Conference on Intelligent Software Methodologies, Tools and Techniques, September 28-30, 2011. P. 233-252. 27
  • 28. Thanks! Questions? Kostyrko Artem1, Kudryavtsev Dmitry 2,3, Grigoriev Lev2, Kislova Valentina2, Zhulin Andrey1, Sinyatullina Leila1, Ermakov Roman4 1 NRU HSE artem.kost@gmail.com, a.zhulin@gmail.com, l.sinyatullina@gmail.com. 2 «Business Engineering Group», dmitry.ku@gmail.com, griglev@gmail.com, valya@big.spb.ru. 3 SPbSPU 4 КТЕ Labs, roman.ermakov@gmail.com.