Discussion of Dotter and Klasen (2014)
Conceptualization of Poverty
Absolute Poverty
Relative Poverty
Unidimensional/Moneymetric Poverty
Multidimensional Poverty
Relative Multidimensional Poverty
Builds on MPI (Foster and Alkire; Alkire and 
Santos) – adapt for living standards.
Uses DHS data to understand poverty in India
State; Different for rural and urban within the 
state.
State: higher than global MPI
Different Rural & Urban: lower than global 
MPI
Differences across states.
More even contribution of the three 
dimensions.
22
Appendix
Table A1: Decomposition of global MPI across states
H A MPI rank by H
all India 53.79% 52.82% 0.2841
Jammu and
Kashmir 40.82% 46.95% 0.1917 13
Himachal Pradesh 29.32% 41.22% 0.1208 6
Punjab 24.72% 45.91% 0.1135 5
Uttarchanal 39.63% 46.33% 0.1836 11
Haryana 40.10% 47.20% 0.1893 12
Delhi 13.13% 43.12% 0.0566 2
Rajasthan 63.41% 54.11% 0.3431 24
Uttar Pradesh 67.63% 54.26% 0.3669 25
Bihar 79.51% 60.44% 0.4805 29
Sikkim 33.55% 46.82% 0.1571 8
Arunchanal
Pradesh 53.68% 51.34% 0.2756 19
Nagaland 48.64% 50.67% 0.2465 17
Manipur 39.57% 46.59% 0.1844 10
Mizoram 19.83% 44.22% 0.0877 4
Tripura 53.23% 49.76% 0.2649 18
Meghalaya 53.72% 52.99% 0.2846 20
Assam 60.32% 52.60% 0.3173 22
West Bengal 57.45% 53.77% 0.3089 21
Jharkhand 74.22% 59.13% 0.4389 28
Orissa 63.06% 53.84% 0.3395 23
Chhattisgarh 69.91% 53.32% 0.3728 27
Madhya Pradesh 68.73% 54.94% 0.3776 26
Gujarat 41.87% 48.65% 0.2037 14
Maharashtra 37.69% 47.56% 0.1792 9
Andhra Pradesh 43.88% 46.84% 0.2055 16
Karnataka 43.56% 47.40% 0.2065 15
Goa 19.26% 42.97% 0.0828 3
Kerala 12.48% 40.19% 0.0502 1
Tamil Nadu 30.99% 42.41% 0.1314 7
Table A2: Decomposition of relative multidimensional poverty (1) across states
H A MPI rank by H
all India 61.30% 55.16% 0.338
Jammu and
Kashmir 48.05% 51.84% 0.249 11
Himachal Pradesh 48.37% 49.59% 0.240 12
Punjab 38.90% 52.98% 0.206 5
Uttarchanal 50.35% 52.84% 0.266 13
Haryana 47.65% 52.16% 0.249 10
Delhi 35.69% 50.87% 0.182 4
Rajasthan 62.26% 52.77% 0.329 23
Uttar Pradesh 70.86% 54.78% 0.388 28
Bihar 67.75% 56.04% 0.380 25
Sikkim 44.97% 51.82% 0.233 7
Arunchanal Pradesh 57.46% 55.05% 0.316 17
Nagaland 54.06% 55.52% 0.300 16
Manipur 40.30% 51.87% 0.209 6
23
Mizoram 34.83% 51.37% 0.179 2
Tripura 45.39% 54.21% 0.246 8
Meghalaya 61.22% 57.84% 0.354 22
Assam 60.62% 54.67% 0.331 21
West Bengal 67.90% 61.44% 0.417 26
Jharkhand 69.83% 56.60% 0.395 27
Orissa 57.78% 52.71% 0.305 18
Chhattisgarh 59.42% 52.12% 0.310 20
Madhya Pradesh 71.55% 58.44% 0.418 29
Gujarat 52.52% 54.45% 0.286 15
Maharashtra 62.62% 55.65% 0.348 24
Andhra Pradesh 58.30% 55.19% 0.322 19
Karnataka 51.60% 51.93% 0.268 14
Goa 35.30% 50.98% 0.180 3
Kerala 20.76% 46.10% 0.096 1
Tamil Nadu 46.77% 49.83% 0.233 9
Table A3: Decomposition of relative multidimensional poverty (2) across states
H A MPI rank by H
all India 42.47% 48.84% 0.207
Jammu and
Kashmir 36.11% 48.77% 0.176 11
Himachal Pradesh 23.09% 45.86% 0.106 2
Punjab 29.54% 50.31% 0.149 8
Uttarchanal 31.57% 48.88% 0.154 10
Haryana 39.12% 51.23% 0.200 18
Delhi 29.77% 50.00% 0.149 9
Rajasthan 47.53% 47.60% 0.226 25
Uttar Pradesh 47.58% 48.53% 0.231 26
Bihar 51.71% 47.87% 0.248 28
Sikkim 26.53% 47.66% 0.126 5
Arunchanal Pradesh 41.97% 53.25% 0.223 20
Nagaland 37.70% 50.76% 0.191 15
Manipur 29.52% 50.33% 0.149 7
Mizoram 24.64% 49.20% 0.121 4
Tripura 36.79% 49.55% 0.182 12
Meghalaya 39.79% 51.51% 0.205 19
Assam 37.85% 49.34% 0.187 17
West Bengal 42.59% 49.87% 0.212 22
Jharkhand 50.48% 48.89% 0.247 27
Orissa 42.73% 51.24% 0.219 23
Chhattisgarh 46.11% 47.10% 0.217 24
Madhya Pradesh 53.15% 50.48% 0.268 29
Gujarat 42.23% 49.86% 0.211 21
Maharashtra 37.35% 49.19% 0.184 14
Andhra Pradesh 37.19% 47.79% 0.178 13
Karnataka 37.73% 48.35% 0.182 16
Goa 29.04% 50.46% 0.147 6
Kerala 14.39% 46.04% 0.066 1
Tamil Nadu 23.37% 46.55% 0.109 3
24
Table A4: Relative contribution of indicators to overall poverty
Global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2)
schooling 9.11% 10.76% 10.40%
enrolment 11.66% 15.18% 19.92%
mortality 12.91% 13.04% 17.76%
nutrition 23.07% 20.91% 24.96%
sanitation 9.84% 3.90% 3.34%
water 3.08% 9.33% 4.14%
floor 7.55% 5.37% 3.69%
cooking fuel 10.62% 9.94% 4.32%
electricity 4.48% 0.61% 0.57%
assets 7.68% 10.97% 10.91%
Table A5: Relative contribution of household size to overall poverty
global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2)
small hh (1-3) 27.52% 29.56% 25.14%
medium hh (4-6) 31.45% 32.12% 31.64%
large hh (7+) 41.03% 38.32% 43.22%
Table A6: Relative contribution of household age to overall poverty
global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2)
above 25 38.57% 41.47% 37.67%
below 25 61.43% 58.53% 62.33%
Table A7: Relative contribution of place of residence to overall poverty
global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2)
urban 26.92% 32.84% 47.62%
rural 73.08% 67.16% 52.38%
Table A8: Relative contribution of sex of household head to overall poverty
global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2)
female-headed hh 51.13% 50.66% 49.70%
male-headed hh 48.87% 49.34% 50.30%
Session 4 c motiram comments_iariw
Session 4 c motiram comments_iariw
Context can be expanded upon/improved
Details of the data
Issues in the conceptualization of MPI
Thank You

More Related Content

PDF
NCRB Statistics On Serious Crimes Against Women.
PPT
Profile of AgriWatch & ISAP
PPT
KA data 2008
PPTX
Session 4 c sharpe, a session 4c
PPTX
Session 7 c de haan measuring global production in na_bp
PPTX
Session 8 d bruckmeier iariw session8_d_copy2-1
PDF
The River of Life. - Presentazione del libro - Roma 20 maggio 2016
PPTX
анастасия тенизова Crematorium идея
NCRB Statistics On Serious Crimes Against Women.
Profile of AgriWatch & ISAP
KA data 2008
Session 4 c sharpe, a session 4c
Session 7 c de haan measuring global production in na_bp
Session 8 d bruckmeier iariw session8_d_copy2-1
The River of Life. - Presentazione del libro - Roma 20 maggio 2016
анастасия тенизова Crematorium идея

Viewers also liked (6)

PPTX
Cremation procedures newest 2015 ii
PDF
Ge Guo
PPTX
Endocarditis infecciosa
PPT
Dili en paciente vih
PPTX
Tratamiento hepatitis viral b crónica
PDF
Patrick Kramer Starbucks Mobile Marketing Proposal
Cremation procedures newest 2015 ii
Ge Guo
Endocarditis infecciosa
Dili en paciente vih
Tratamiento hepatitis viral b crónica
Patrick Kramer Starbucks Mobile Marketing Proposal
Ad

Similar to Session 4 c motiram comments_iariw (16)

PDF
Demograpic profile of indian states presentation
PDF
Covid 19 stats in india update 8 22.09.20
PPT
Multidimensional Poverty Index
DOCX
Features of Indian Economy
PPT
Water and sanitation, situation & hygine(wash) in nepal
PDF
Census vital data 2011 pop size and decadal change
DOCX
population in villages
DOCX
rural population
PPTX
Swachh Bharat Mission and Diarrhoea data
PPT
O&g sgh updates focus on contraception
PPT
Presentation on at&c_losses(r)
PPT
AT & C LOSSES
DOCX
National A Catings Fune 2009
PDF
IOSR Journal of Pharmacy (IOSRPHR), www.iosrphr.org, call for paper, research...
PDF
2008 09 thru 2013-2014 istep for sbsc - nov 2014
PPT
Widowhood In India
Demograpic profile of indian states presentation
Covid 19 stats in india update 8 22.09.20
Multidimensional Poverty Index
Features of Indian Economy
Water and sanitation, situation & hygine(wash) in nepal
Census vital data 2011 pop size and decadal change
population in villages
rural population
Swachh Bharat Mission and Diarrhoea data
O&g sgh updates focus on contraception
Presentation on at&c_losses(r)
AT & C LOSSES
National A Catings Fune 2009
IOSR Journal of Pharmacy (IOSRPHR), www.iosrphr.org, call for paper, research...
2008 09 thru 2013-2014 istep for sbsc - nov 2014
Widowhood In India
Ad

More from IARIW 2014 (20)

PDF
Session 7 d sakuma discussion
PPT
Session 7 d iariw 2014 session 7 d gueye and gruetz
PPT
Session 7 d iariw 2014 session 7 d schmidt and heil
PPTX
Session 7 d dutch revisioniariw
PPT
Session 7d van devenpresentation
PPT
Session 7 c presentation session 7 c xuguang song & yafei wang
PPTX
Session 7 c global corporate income
PPTX
Session 7 a coli tartamella
PDF
Session 7 a 20140829 rotterdam bruckmeier
PPTX
Session 7 a fantozzi raitano discussion_gv
PPTX
Session 7 a pabilonia paper presented by gao
PPTX
Session 7 b bobbio et al service lives paper 7 b iariw discussion
PPT
Session 7 b commentson daneilkerpaperonukr&d servicelives2014iariw[1]
PPTX
Session 7 b 2014 08-29 voskob wu
PPTX
Session 7 b 7 b role of capital in india’s economic growth
PDF
Session 7 b iariw oulton 290814
PDF
Session 7 b d s rambaldi
PPTX
Session 7 c iariw august14 erumban
PPTX
Session 8 a iariw discussion clark paper -ruggles
PPTX
Session 8 a iariw discussion wolfson paper -ruggles
Session 7 d sakuma discussion
Session 7 d iariw 2014 session 7 d gueye and gruetz
Session 7 d iariw 2014 session 7 d schmidt and heil
Session 7 d dutch revisioniariw
Session 7d van devenpresentation
Session 7 c presentation session 7 c xuguang song & yafei wang
Session 7 c global corporate income
Session 7 a coli tartamella
Session 7 a 20140829 rotterdam bruckmeier
Session 7 a fantozzi raitano discussion_gv
Session 7 a pabilonia paper presented by gao
Session 7 b bobbio et al service lives paper 7 b iariw discussion
Session 7 b commentson daneilkerpaperonukr&d servicelives2014iariw[1]
Session 7 b 2014 08-29 voskob wu
Session 7 b 7 b role of capital in india’s economic growth
Session 7 b iariw oulton 290814
Session 7 b d s rambaldi
Session 7 c iariw august14 erumban
Session 8 a iariw discussion clark paper -ruggles
Session 8 a iariw discussion wolfson paper -ruggles

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Management Accounting Information for Decision-Making and Strategy Execution ...
PDF
3CMT J.AFABLE Flexible-Learning ENTREPRENEURIAL MANAGEMENT.pdf
PPTX
Grp C.ppt presentation.pptx for Economics
PDF
CLIMATE CHANGE AS A THREAT MULTIPLIER: ASSESSING ITS IMPACT ON RESOURCE SCARC...
PPTX
Q1 PE AND HEALTH 5 WEEK 5 DAY 1 powerpoint template
PDF
Truxton Capital: Middle Market Quarterly Review - August 2025
PPTX
2. RBI.pptx202029291023i38039013i92292992
PPTX
INDIAN FINANCIAL SYSTEM (Financial institutions, Financial Markets & Services)
PPTX
Machine Learning (ML) is a branch of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
PPTX
Maths science sst hindi english cucumber
PDF
5-principles-of-PD-design.pdfvvvhvjvvcjcxhhcjb ggfvjhvjjhbvbbbvccxhgcxzzghjbv...
PPTX
Group Presentation Development Econ and Envi..pptx
PDF
Pitch Deck.pdf .pdf all about finance in
PPTX
28 - relative valuation lecture economicsnotes
PDF
Financial discipline for educational purpose
PDF
DTC TRADIND CLUB MAKE YOUR TRADING BETTER
PDF
Pension Trustee Training (1).pdf From Salih Shah
PPT
KPMG FA Benefits Report_FINAL_Jan 27_2010.ppt
PPTX
lesson in englishhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
PPTX
PROFITS AND GAINS OF BUSINESS OR PROFESSION 2024.pptx
Management Accounting Information for Decision-Making and Strategy Execution ...
3CMT J.AFABLE Flexible-Learning ENTREPRENEURIAL MANAGEMENT.pdf
Grp C.ppt presentation.pptx for Economics
CLIMATE CHANGE AS A THREAT MULTIPLIER: ASSESSING ITS IMPACT ON RESOURCE SCARC...
Q1 PE AND HEALTH 5 WEEK 5 DAY 1 powerpoint template
Truxton Capital: Middle Market Quarterly Review - August 2025
2. RBI.pptx202029291023i38039013i92292992
INDIAN FINANCIAL SYSTEM (Financial institutions, Financial Markets & Services)
Machine Learning (ML) is a branch of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Maths science sst hindi english cucumber
5-principles-of-PD-design.pdfvvvhvjvvcjcxhhcjb ggfvjhvjjhbvbbbvccxhgcxzzghjbv...
Group Presentation Development Econ and Envi..pptx
Pitch Deck.pdf .pdf all about finance in
28 - relative valuation lecture economicsnotes
Financial discipline for educational purpose
DTC TRADIND CLUB MAKE YOUR TRADING BETTER
Pension Trustee Training (1).pdf From Salih Shah
KPMG FA Benefits Report_FINAL_Jan 27_2010.ppt
lesson in englishhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
PROFITS AND GAINS OF BUSINESS OR PROFESSION 2024.pptx

Session 4 c motiram comments_iariw

  • 4. 22 Appendix Table A1: Decomposition of global MPI across states H A MPI rank by H all India 53.79% 52.82% 0.2841 Jammu and Kashmir 40.82% 46.95% 0.1917 13 Himachal Pradesh 29.32% 41.22% 0.1208 6 Punjab 24.72% 45.91% 0.1135 5 Uttarchanal 39.63% 46.33% 0.1836 11 Haryana 40.10% 47.20% 0.1893 12 Delhi 13.13% 43.12% 0.0566 2 Rajasthan 63.41% 54.11% 0.3431 24 Uttar Pradesh 67.63% 54.26% 0.3669 25 Bihar 79.51% 60.44% 0.4805 29 Sikkim 33.55% 46.82% 0.1571 8 Arunchanal Pradesh 53.68% 51.34% 0.2756 19 Nagaland 48.64% 50.67% 0.2465 17 Manipur 39.57% 46.59% 0.1844 10 Mizoram 19.83% 44.22% 0.0877 4 Tripura 53.23% 49.76% 0.2649 18 Meghalaya 53.72% 52.99% 0.2846 20 Assam 60.32% 52.60% 0.3173 22 West Bengal 57.45% 53.77% 0.3089 21 Jharkhand 74.22% 59.13% 0.4389 28 Orissa 63.06% 53.84% 0.3395 23 Chhattisgarh 69.91% 53.32% 0.3728 27 Madhya Pradesh 68.73% 54.94% 0.3776 26 Gujarat 41.87% 48.65% 0.2037 14 Maharashtra 37.69% 47.56% 0.1792 9 Andhra Pradesh 43.88% 46.84% 0.2055 16 Karnataka 43.56% 47.40% 0.2065 15 Goa 19.26% 42.97% 0.0828 3 Kerala 12.48% 40.19% 0.0502 1 Tamil Nadu 30.99% 42.41% 0.1314 7 Table A2: Decomposition of relative multidimensional poverty (1) across states H A MPI rank by H all India 61.30% 55.16% 0.338 Jammu and Kashmir 48.05% 51.84% 0.249 11 Himachal Pradesh 48.37% 49.59% 0.240 12 Punjab 38.90% 52.98% 0.206 5 Uttarchanal 50.35% 52.84% 0.266 13 Haryana 47.65% 52.16% 0.249 10 Delhi 35.69% 50.87% 0.182 4 Rajasthan 62.26% 52.77% 0.329 23 Uttar Pradesh 70.86% 54.78% 0.388 28 Bihar 67.75% 56.04% 0.380 25 Sikkim 44.97% 51.82% 0.233 7 Arunchanal Pradesh 57.46% 55.05% 0.316 17 Nagaland 54.06% 55.52% 0.300 16 Manipur 40.30% 51.87% 0.209 6
  • 5. 23 Mizoram 34.83% 51.37% 0.179 2 Tripura 45.39% 54.21% 0.246 8 Meghalaya 61.22% 57.84% 0.354 22 Assam 60.62% 54.67% 0.331 21 West Bengal 67.90% 61.44% 0.417 26 Jharkhand 69.83% 56.60% 0.395 27 Orissa 57.78% 52.71% 0.305 18 Chhattisgarh 59.42% 52.12% 0.310 20 Madhya Pradesh 71.55% 58.44% 0.418 29 Gujarat 52.52% 54.45% 0.286 15 Maharashtra 62.62% 55.65% 0.348 24 Andhra Pradesh 58.30% 55.19% 0.322 19 Karnataka 51.60% 51.93% 0.268 14 Goa 35.30% 50.98% 0.180 3 Kerala 20.76% 46.10% 0.096 1 Tamil Nadu 46.77% 49.83% 0.233 9 Table A3: Decomposition of relative multidimensional poverty (2) across states H A MPI rank by H all India 42.47% 48.84% 0.207 Jammu and Kashmir 36.11% 48.77% 0.176 11 Himachal Pradesh 23.09% 45.86% 0.106 2 Punjab 29.54% 50.31% 0.149 8 Uttarchanal 31.57% 48.88% 0.154 10 Haryana 39.12% 51.23% 0.200 18 Delhi 29.77% 50.00% 0.149 9 Rajasthan 47.53% 47.60% 0.226 25 Uttar Pradesh 47.58% 48.53% 0.231 26 Bihar 51.71% 47.87% 0.248 28 Sikkim 26.53% 47.66% 0.126 5 Arunchanal Pradesh 41.97% 53.25% 0.223 20 Nagaland 37.70% 50.76% 0.191 15 Manipur 29.52% 50.33% 0.149 7 Mizoram 24.64% 49.20% 0.121 4 Tripura 36.79% 49.55% 0.182 12 Meghalaya 39.79% 51.51% 0.205 19 Assam 37.85% 49.34% 0.187 17 West Bengal 42.59% 49.87% 0.212 22 Jharkhand 50.48% 48.89% 0.247 27 Orissa 42.73% 51.24% 0.219 23 Chhattisgarh 46.11% 47.10% 0.217 24 Madhya Pradesh 53.15% 50.48% 0.268 29 Gujarat 42.23% 49.86% 0.211 21 Maharashtra 37.35% 49.19% 0.184 14 Andhra Pradesh 37.19% 47.79% 0.178 13 Karnataka 37.73% 48.35% 0.182 16 Goa 29.04% 50.46% 0.147 6 Kerala 14.39% 46.04% 0.066 1 Tamil Nadu 23.37% 46.55% 0.109 3
  • 6. 24 Table A4: Relative contribution of indicators to overall poverty Global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2) schooling 9.11% 10.76% 10.40% enrolment 11.66% 15.18% 19.92% mortality 12.91% 13.04% 17.76% nutrition 23.07% 20.91% 24.96% sanitation 9.84% 3.90% 3.34% water 3.08% 9.33% 4.14% floor 7.55% 5.37% 3.69% cooking fuel 10.62% 9.94% 4.32% electricity 4.48% 0.61% 0.57% assets 7.68% 10.97% 10.91% Table A5: Relative contribution of household size to overall poverty global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2) small hh (1-3) 27.52% 29.56% 25.14% medium hh (4-6) 31.45% 32.12% 31.64% large hh (7+) 41.03% 38.32% 43.22% Table A6: Relative contribution of household age to overall poverty global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2) above 25 38.57% 41.47% 37.67% below 25 61.43% 58.53% 62.33% Table A7: Relative contribution of place of residence to overall poverty global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2) urban 26.92% 32.84% 47.62% rural 73.08% 67.16% 52.38% Table A8: Relative contribution of sex of household head to overall poverty global MPI relative MP (1) relative MP (2) female-headed hh 51.13% 50.66% 49.70% male-headed hh 48.87% 49.34% 50.30%