SlideShare a Scribd company logo
October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software 2012 / Page 1
About the Speaker
Project Controls Expo – 13th Oct 2015
Emirates Stadium, London
Artificial Intelligence Meets Project Controls
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
About the Speaker
Charlie Sundling
Charlie is currently the CEO, Pipeline Group, Inc., a
software technology company based in California. He has
more than 25 years of computer science and industrial
engineering background. Charlie has a particular focus on
human work performance as it relates to complex project
execution. In this field he has design many advanced
systems, publications and holds related patents.
October 20, 2015
About the Topic
Artificial Intelligence and Project Controls
This presentation explores the development of an
advanced computer system used by the US civil nuclear
industry to gain better control over the execution of their
reactor refueling projects.
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
October 20, 2015
Case Study
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
October 20, 2015
SAN ONOFRE, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA DIABLO CANYON, CENTRAL CALIFORNIA
The Syntempo Initiative
Joint research between US civil
nuclear operators and Pipeline
Software, Inc.
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Anatomy of a Nuclear Refueling Project
○ Refuel every 18 mos
○ 2,500 people
○ 35,000 activities
○ Scheduled to hour/minute
○ 25-30 day schedule
○ $40M-$50M budget
○ ~$3M per day late
October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Delima
October 20, 2015
We invested millions of dollars
in best-in-class project
management systems and
processes but our refuel project
performance has not improved.
Why?
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
October 20, 2015
Missing Link
Work Scheduling systems & controls
Work Planning systems & controls
Work Execution systems & controlsFAIL
PASS
PASS
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Project Execution Communication Cycle
October 20, 2015
Team 1 Team 2
Project Controls
Schedule
Update Analyze Publish
Distribute
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Unmanageable
October 20, 2015
Mechanical
Operations
InstrumentationElectrical
40-60 project controls staff
Chemistry Radiation
~ 1,200 workers on shift
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software 2012 / Page 11
Cause and Effect
Impossible to Track
Jobs Timely
Impaired Visibility
Unable to Dynamically Adjust
Resource Utilization Reduced
Jobs Slip and Bow Wave Grows
£££ Blown Schedule $$$
What Was Needed?
○ Monitor 1,000’s of activities in parallel
○ Follow up with hundreds of workers in parallel
○ Analyze the schedule every 30 seconds
○ Publish and distribute updated schedule every
30 seconds to everyone involved in the project
October 20, 2015
Hire 200 additional project control staff, OR,
hire one that could…
Impossible. But could a computer do this?
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Artificial Intelligence:
“The branch of science that pertains to making
computers perform the tasks normally requiring
human intelligence”
October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
NEW TEAM MEMBER
Hello Dave.
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Would you like me to
help you manage your
project?
>_
STEP 1: Prepare Facility
Monitors, kiosks and tablets throughout the facility;
offices, meeting rooms, shops, desktops, plant floor,
etc.
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
STEP 2: Discover Team Structure
Mechanical
Instrumentation
Electrical
Operations
Chemistry
Radiation
Project Controls
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
“Hello team. Please tell me how
you are organized.”
STEP 3: Discover Individuals
“Hello Bob. Please give me your
badge number, email, phone, and
pager ids. Oh, and where do you
usually sit?”
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
STEP 4: Load Schedule & Press “Play”
PLAY
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
• Primavera P6
• MS Project
• SAP PS
• Maximo
Let the Fun Begin
Shop 2
Begin Broadcast
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Communicate
“Hello. Have you completed that
task yet?”
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
“I thought you might like to
know about this problem.”
Collect Feedback From The Field
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Perform Schedule Analysis
Shop 2© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
“Hmm. How can we do better?”
Do it Again
Shop 2
Potential problems
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
Results
October 20, 2015
○ Massive reduction in “status chasing”
○ 90% reduction in keyboard time
○ Improved visibility
○ Increased human resource utilization rates
○ Bow wave reduction
○ Schedule publishing cut by 70%
○ Nearly 3 days of slip avoided in a single refuel
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
October 20, 2015
Q&A
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
October 20, 2015
Thank you!
cs@gopipeline.com
© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015

More Related Content

PDF
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Improving Professionalism in Project ...
PDF
Session T2 - Best Practice Project Controls with EcoSys
PDF
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Data Integration Throughout the Proje...
PDF
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Lessons Learned from an Interna.onal ...
PDF
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Accurate Management Reports on 1me, e...
PDF
M3 - An overview of High Speed 2
PDF
Session M1- The Challenges of Tracking Earned Value on The SV Scout Project
PDF
Session T4 - Deliverables Management - A strategic Opportunity
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Improving Professionalism in Project ...
Session T2 - Best Practice Project Controls with EcoSys
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Data Integration Throughout the Proje...
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Lessons Learned from an Interna.onal ...
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Accurate Management Reports on 1me, e...
M3 - An overview of High Speed 2
Session M1- The Challenges of Tracking Earned Value on The SV Scout Project
Session T4 - Deliverables Management - A strategic Opportunity

What's hot (20)

PDF
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Extending Earned Value Methodology To...
PDF
Project Controls Expo 13th Nov 2013 - "From Cost Plan To Bid Evaluation To Co...
PPTX
Innovations in program controls integrating primavera and cost systems
PDF
Managing Changes on a Capital Programme by "Iain Cameron - Technical Director...
PPTX
Advanced Work Packaging - CCT Solutions at a Glance
PDF
Major CAPEX Project Success Assurance-Best Practices and Lessons Learned
PPTX
Advanced Work Packaging - Real Life Implementation
PDF
Next Generation of Front End Construction Driven Planning Provides Solutions ...
PDF
Cost Effective Debottleneck Expansions
PDF
ACONEX-workflow System
PDF
Advanced Work Packaging (AWP): An Illustration of the Mortar Concept(c)
PDF
Eastman Chemical Company introduces SEIGA
PDF
Think Differently when Executing Capital Projects by Sandy Vasser, formerly ...
PDF
Project Management Track: Lean Projects, Cost Controls, Price Forecasts, & Re...
DOC
TC-CV-2015
PPTX
The SPH EPC Way
PDF
Project Management Track: Lean Projects, Cost Controls, Price Forecasts, & Re...
PDF
Ac2017 8. metrics forprivacysafety-notes
PDF
Cost Estimation and Control on Projects: Addressing today's challenges
PDF
A Journey to E3D
Project Controls Expo - 31st Oct 2012 - Extending Earned Value Methodology To...
Project Controls Expo 13th Nov 2013 - "From Cost Plan To Bid Evaluation To Co...
Innovations in program controls integrating primavera and cost systems
Managing Changes on a Capital Programme by "Iain Cameron - Technical Director...
Advanced Work Packaging - CCT Solutions at a Glance
Major CAPEX Project Success Assurance-Best Practices and Lessons Learned
Advanced Work Packaging - Real Life Implementation
Next Generation of Front End Construction Driven Planning Provides Solutions ...
Cost Effective Debottleneck Expansions
ACONEX-workflow System
Advanced Work Packaging (AWP): An Illustration of the Mortar Concept(c)
Eastman Chemical Company introduces SEIGA
Think Differently when Executing Capital Projects by Sandy Vasser, formerly ...
Project Management Track: Lean Projects, Cost Controls, Price Forecasts, & Re...
TC-CV-2015
The SPH EPC Way
Project Management Track: Lean Projects, Cost Controls, Price Forecasts, & Re...
Ac2017 8. metrics forprivacysafety-notes
Cost Estimation and Control on Projects: Addressing today's challenges
A Journey to E3D
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
Session T7 - Total Cost Management - The synergy between Cost Estimating and ...
PDF
Session T5 - Data Driven Decision Making - 3DM
PDF
Session B3 - Introduction to Project Cost and Schedule Risk Analysis
PPTX
Give Your I.T. Department Control - RMM Tech Fair - 2015
PDF
Session M2 - Scream If You Want To Go Faster - The contractual, legal, financ...
PPTX
The role of SA Municipalities in dams operations and management
PDF
Milestone Report format
PDF
Project Management: The Basics for Success
PDF
Session B1 - Planning, Scheduling Monitoring and Control
PPS
FIDIC, CONTRACT MANAGEMENT
PDF
HUMAN RESOURCE CERTIFICATE
PDF
Eng. Alaa Attia's FIDIC Certificate Course
PDF
Session M6 - BIM –Building Information Modellingfood for thought -Chef Master...
PDF
GCC2015 Course_Day2
PDF
Hill Claims Services Presentation Linkedin Ppt
PDF
GCC2015 Course_Day2
PPTX
5.J.B Nartey
PDF
Eot claims due to scope change under fidic contracts
PDF
Session W1 - Reliable Risk Quantification For Project Cost and Schedule
PDF
1 Day FIDIC Claims Workshop, 5 October 2015, Movenpick Hotel Ankara, Turkey
Session T7 - Total Cost Management - The synergy between Cost Estimating and ...
Session T5 - Data Driven Decision Making - 3DM
Session B3 - Introduction to Project Cost and Schedule Risk Analysis
Give Your I.T. Department Control - RMM Tech Fair - 2015
Session M2 - Scream If You Want To Go Faster - The contractual, legal, financ...
The role of SA Municipalities in dams operations and management
Milestone Report format
Project Management: The Basics for Success
Session B1 - Planning, Scheduling Monitoring and Control
FIDIC, CONTRACT MANAGEMENT
HUMAN RESOURCE CERTIFICATE
Eng. Alaa Attia's FIDIC Certificate Course
Session M6 - BIM –Building Information Modellingfood for thought -Chef Master...
GCC2015 Course_Day2
Hill Claims Services Presentation Linkedin Ppt
GCC2015 Course_Day2
5.J.B Nartey
Eot claims due to scope change under fidic contracts
Session W1 - Reliable Risk Quantification For Project Cost and Schedule
1 Day FIDIC Claims Workshop, 5 October 2015, Movenpick Hotel Ankara, Turkey
Ad

Similar to Session T6 - Artificial Intelligence Meets Project Controls (20)

PDF
ABB Scheduling.pdf
PDF
The Work Ahead in Utilities: Powering a Sustainable Future with Digital
PDF
Pipeline_Patterns_R7.pdf
PDF
Operations Research and Cyber Infrastructure John W. Chinneck
PDF
Energy Predictions 2016
PDF
Agile Infrastructure Automation Presentation to Wall Street Technology Associ...
PDF
Midstream Automation, Instrumentation & Control Congress 2015
PDF
Scheduling or routing technology
PPT
Construction Monkey.com
PDF
Scheduling Survival Guide
PDF
Operations Research and Cyber Infrastructure John W. Chinneck
PPT
PMI Global 2007 - Urucu/Manaus
PDF
5 Steps on the Way to Continuous Delivery
PDF
Shift Left with Continuous Inspection
PDF
Crafting the Utility of the Future
PDF
Automating the Petroleum Industry, from Wells to Wheels
PDF
Pipeline and Gas Tech April 09 - SCADA Evolution
PDF
Mastering Modern Software Delivery The Essential Guide to CICD Pipelines.pdf
PPTX
iOG Corporate Presentation_for distribution
PDF
Building Your Digital Assembly Line Mastering the Modern CICD Pipeline.pdf
ABB Scheduling.pdf
The Work Ahead in Utilities: Powering a Sustainable Future with Digital
Pipeline_Patterns_R7.pdf
Operations Research and Cyber Infrastructure John W. Chinneck
Energy Predictions 2016
Agile Infrastructure Automation Presentation to Wall Street Technology Associ...
Midstream Automation, Instrumentation & Control Congress 2015
Scheduling or routing technology
Construction Monkey.com
Scheduling Survival Guide
Operations Research and Cyber Infrastructure John W. Chinneck
PMI Global 2007 - Urucu/Manaus
5 Steps on the Way to Continuous Delivery
Shift Left with Continuous Inspection
Crafting the Utility of the Future
Automating the Petroleum Industry, from Wells to Wheels
Pipeline and Gas Tech April 09 - SCADA Evolution
Mastering Modern Software Delivery The Essential Guide to CICD Pipelines.pdf
iOG Corporate Presentation_for distribution
Building Your Digital Assembly Line Mastering the Modern CICD Pipeline.pdf

More from Project Controls Expo (20)

PDF
National Grids Project Controls Journey – past, present and future
PDF
Case study in Company Project Controls Transformation By Rod Whiting - Region...
PDF
Balancing burdens of proof in dispute avoidance and resolution by "Ari Isaacs...
PDF
Navigating BIM waters by "Natacha Redon - Associate / BIM Lead for Identity C...
PDF
NEC4: Evolution of the ECC by "Ben Walker - NEC4 Contract Drafter, CEO for CE...
PDF
Managing the risk of change by "Simon White - Risk Management Consultant for ...
PDF
Economic Value Chains - costing the impact of risk by "Colin Sandall - Senior...
PDF
What makes a good plan, and how do you know you’ve got one? by "Paul Kidston ...
PDF
Next Generation Planning for Mega Projects by "Dr. Dan Patterson - CEO and Fo...
PDF
Project Control Staff – Make or Buy? by "Mike Laws - Project Controls Manager...
PDF
Governance: An Enabler? by " Ian Beaumont - Delivery Partner Programme Direc...
PDF
Governance and the art of decision making on Crossrail by "Walter Macharg - H...
PDF
Tideway - Transforming the Thames by "Niall Faris - Project Controls Leader f...
PDF
Adding Value through the Lower Thames Crossing project by "Iain Minns - Partn...
PDF
Governance and Assurance for Nationally Significant Infrastructure Projects b...
PDF
A review of whether interdependency exists in effective Project Control Metho...
PDF
A Source of Project Cost Integration by "David Hurren - Technical Director fo...
PDF
Programmatic Controls Approach to; Fast track Disaster Recovery by "Saurabh B...
PDF
Enterprise Scheduling and Risk Management at Los Angeles Metro by "Julie Owen...
PDF
Enterprise Project Management Solutions - Install and train, job done? by "Da...
National Grids Project Controls Journey – past, present and future
Case study in Company Project Controls Transformation By Rod Whiting - Region...
Balancing burdens of proof in dispute avoidance and resolution by "Ari Isaacs...
Navigating BIM waters by "Natacha Redon - Associate / BIM Lead for Identity C...
NEC4: Evolution of the ECC by "Ben Walker - NEC4 Contract Drafter, CEO for CE...
Managing the risk of change by "Simon White - Risk Management Consultant for ...
Economic Value Chains - costing the impact of risk by "Colin Sandall - Senior...
What makes a good plan, and how do you know you’ve got one? by "Paul Kidston ...
Next Generation Planning for Mega Projects by "Dr. Dan Patterson - CEO and Fo...
Project Control Staff – Make or Buy? by "Mike Laws - Project Controls Manager...
Governance: An Enabler? by " Ian Beaumont - Delivery Partner Programme Direc...
Governance and the art of decision making on Crossrail by "Walter Macharg - H...
Tideway - Transforming the Thames by "Niall Faris - Project Controls Leader f...
Adding Value through the Lower Thames Crossing project by "Iain Minns - Partn...
Governance and Assurance for Nationally Significant Infrastructure Projects b...
A review of whether interdependency exists in effective Project Control Metho...
A Source of Project Cost Integration by "David Hurren - Technical Director fo...
Programmatic Controls Approach to; Fast track Disaster Recovery by "Saurabh B...
Enterprise Scheduling and Risk Management at Los Angeles Metro by "Julie Owen...
Enterprise Project Management Solutions - Install and train, job done? by "Da...

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
AcademyNaturalLanguageProcessing-EN-ILT-M02-Introduction.pptx
PPTX
Impressionism_PostImpressionism_Presentation.pptx
PPT
First Aid Training Presentation Slides.ppt
PPTX
Non-Verbal-Communication .mh.pdf_110245_compressed.pptx
PDF
natwest.pdf company description and business model
PPTX
2025-08-10 Joseph 02 (shared slides).pptx
PPTX
worship songs, in any order, compilation
PPTX
Intro to ISO 9001 2015.pptx wareness raising
PPTX
Learning-Plan-5-Policies-and-Practices.pptx
PPTX
Effective_Handling_Information_Presentation.pptx
PPTX
Hydrogel Based delivery Cancer Treatment
PPTX
Self management and self evaluation presentation
PPTX
Emphasizing It's Not The End 08 06 2025.pptx
PPTX
The spiral of silence is a theory in communication and political science that...
PPTX
The Effect of Human Resource Management Practice on Organizational Performanc...
PDF
Nykaa-Strategy-Case-Fixing-Retention-UX-and-D2C-Engagement (1).pdf
PPTX
Anesthesia and it's stage with mnemonic and images
PDF
Tunisia's Founding Father(s) Pitch-Deck 2022.pdf
PPTX
Introduction to Effective Communication.pptx
PPTX
PHIL.-ASTRONOMY-AND-NAVIGATION of ..pptx
AcademyNaturalLanguageProcessing-EN-ILT-M02-Introduction.pptx
Impressionism_PostImpressionism_Presentation.pptx
First Aid Training Presentation Slides.ppt
Non-Verbal-Communication .mh.pdf_110245_compressed.pptx
natwest.pdf company description and business model
2025-08-10 Joseph 02 (shared slides).pptx
worship songs, in any order, compilation
Intro to ISO 9001 2015.pptx wareness raising
Learning-Plan-5-Policies-and-Practices.pptx
Effective_Handling_Information_Presentation.pptx
Hydrogel Based delivery Cancer Treatment
Self management and self evaluation presentation
Emphasizing It's Not The End 08 06 2025.pptx
The spiral of silence is a theory in communication and political science that...
The Effect of Human Resource Management Practice on Organizational Performanc...
Nykaa-Strategy-Case-Fixing-Retention-UX-and-D2C-Engagement (1).pdf
Anesthesia and it's stage with mnemonic and images
Tunisia's Founding Father(s) Pitch-Deck 2022.pdf
Introduction to Effective Communication.pptx
PHIL.-ASTRONOMY-AND-NAVIGATION of ..pptx

Session T6 - Artificial Intelligence Meets Project Controls

  • 1. October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software 2012 / Page 1 About the Speaker Project Controls Expo – 13th Oct 2015 Emirates Stadium, London Artificial Intelligence Meets Project Controls
  • 2. © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015 About the Speaker Charlie Sundling Charlie is currently the CEO, Pipeline Group, Inc., a software technology company based in California. He has more than 25 years of computer science and industrial engineering background. Charlie has a particular focus on human work performance as it relates to complex project execution. In this field he has design many advanced systems, publications and holds related patents.
  • 3. October 20, 2015 About the Topic Artificial Intelligence and Project Controls This presentation explores the development of an advanced computer system used by the US civil nuclear industry to gain better control over the execution of their reactor refueling projects. © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 4. October 20, 2015 Case Study © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 5. October 20, 2015 SAN ONOFRE, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA DIABLO CANYON, CENTRAL CALIFORNIA The Syntempo Initiative Joint research between US civil nuclear operators and Pipeline Software, Inc. © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 6. Anatomy of a Nuclear Refueling Project ○ Refuel every 18 mos ○ 2,500 people ○ 35,000 activities ○ Scheduled to hour/minute ○ 25-30 day schedule ○ $40M-$50M budget ○ ~$3M per day late October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 7. Delima October 20, 2015 We invested millions of dollars in best-in-class project management systems and processes but our refuel project performance has not improved. Why? © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 8. October 20, 2015 Missing Link Work Scheduling systems & controls Work Planning systems & controls Work Execution systems & controlsFAIL PASS PASS © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 9. Project Execution Communication Cycle October 20, 2015 Team 1 Team 2 Project Controls Schedule Update Analyze Publish Distribute © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 10. Unmanageable October 20, 2015 Mechanical Operations InstrumentationElectrical 40-60 project controls staff Chemistry Radiation ~ 1,200 workers on shift © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 11. October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software 2012 / Page 11 Cause and Effect Impossible to Track Jobs Timely Impaired Visibility Unable to Dynamically Adjust Resource Utilization Reduced Jobs Slip and Bow Wave Grows £££ Blown Schedule $$$
  • 12. What Was Needed? ○ Monitor 1,000’s of activities in parallel ○ Follow up with hundreds of workers in parallel ○ Analyze the schedule every 30 seconds ○ Publish and distribute updated schedule every 30 seconds to everyone involved in the project October 20, 2015 Hire 200 additional project control staff, OR, hire one that could… Impossible. But could a computer do this? © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 13. Artificial Intelligence: “The branch of science that pertains to making computers perform the tasks normally requiring human intelligence” October 20, 2015© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 14. NEW TEAM MEMBER Hello Dave. © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015 Would you like me to help you manage your project? >_
  • 15. STEP 1: Prepare Facility Monitors, kiosks and tablets throughout the facility; offices, meeting rooms, shops, desktops, plant floor, etc. © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 16. STEP 2: Discover Team Structure Mechanical Instrumentation Electrical Operations Chemistry Radiation Project Controls © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015 “Hello team. Please tell me how you are organized.”
  • 17. STEP 3: Discover Individuals “Hello Bob. Please give me your badge number, email, phone, and pager ids. Oh, and where do you usually sit?” © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 18. STEP 4: Load Schedule & Press “Play” PLAY © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015 • Primavera P6 • MS Project • SAP PS • Maximo
  • 19. Let the Fun Begin Shop 2 Begin Broadcast © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 20. Communicate “Hello. Have you completed that task yet?” © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015 “I thought you might like to know about this problem.”
  • 21. Collect Feedback From The Field © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 22. Perform Schedule Analysis Shop 2© Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015 “Hmm. How can we do better?”
  • 23. Do it Again Shop 2 Potential problems © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 24. Results October 20, 2015 ○ Massive reduction in “status chasing” ○ 90% reduction in keyboard time ○ Improved visibility ○ Increased human resource utilization rates ○ Bow wave reduction ○ Schedule publishing cut by 70% ○ Nearly 3 days of slip avoided in a single refuel © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 25. October 20, 2015 Q&A © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015
  • 26. October 20, 2015 Thank you! cs@gopipeline.com © Pipeline Software, Inc. 2015