SUPPRESSION OF COMMON-MODE RADIATION FROM HIGH SPEED PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD USING MODIFIED GROUND PATTERNS

International Journal of Information Sciences and Techniques (IJIST) Vol.4, No.3, May 2014
DOI : 10.5121/ijist.2014.4318 147
SUPPRESSION OF COMMON-MODE
RADIATION FROM HIGH SPEED PRINTED
CIRCUIT BOARD USING MODIFIED GROUND
PATTERNS
Dr.N.Suresh kumar1
, V.Anandha jothi2
, Darshini.B2
, S.Raja Suhanya2
,
P.Rajeswari3
1
Principal ,Velammal College of Engineering and Technology Madurai-625009,India.
2
UG Students,ECE Department,Velammal College of Engineering And
Technology,Madurai-625009,India.
3
Assistant Professor,ECE department,Velammal College of Engineering and
Technology,Madurai-625009,India
Abstract-
Now-a-days, the usage for the high speed printed circuit boards are increased. Inorder to satisfy the high
demand of low cost and size reduction, chips must be integrated in a same package in which the signal
integrity issues may occur. One of the major issues is radiated emission. The common mode and
differential mode radiation occur when the differential signal crosses the splitted reference plane. In this
paper, to reduce the common mode radiation, asymmetric resonators with the interdigital capacitors on the
splitted ground plane with shorting vias is implemented. The physical dimensions for the stub and the
interdigital capacitors are determined by using the design theory of transmission line model. The insertion
loss, return loss and the field pattern are determined using the Ansoft HFSS Tool.
Keywords-
Common mode radiation, Electromagnetic Interference (EMI), Interdigital Capacitors (IDC), Radiated
Emission, Split plane.
I. INTRODUCTION
In the high speed printed circuit board, the chips must be integrated in a single package.
Electronic devices are becoming light weight and so demands of miniaturizing PCBs in this
device increase. Now-a-days signal integrity has become a major issue. The signal quality is more
important for the high speed products and the signal integrity analysis should ensure reliable
transmission. The signal integrity issues include ringing, crosstalk, ground bounce, radiated
emission and reflection [1]. One of the major issues is radiated emission. The radiated emission is
the unintentional release of electromagnetic energy from a device. The emission from one device
may interfere with the neighbouring device which would cause the circuit malfunction. The main
source of the radiated emission is the common mode current. This radiated emission can be
reduced by using the stitching capacitors [5]. It provides return current path of signal lines. It
degrades the noise isolation or they suppress the signal distortion and decreases radiation

148
emission. But it may cause internal reflection and resonance. By decreasing the distance between
the ground plane and the signal traces, the radiation can be reduced but it may induce the
coupling mechanism. Inorder to decrease the coupling, the ground guard fence was used between
the microstrip lines and the disadvantage in using the ground guard fence is that, it increases the
size of the printed circuit board. It is common to introduce slots in the reference plane to provide
the DC isolation [6]. An asymmetrical grounded resonators technique was proposed to reduce the
EMI for slot crossing differential signals. These asymmetric resonators with one end shorting to
the ground plane provides efficient shorting path between the split planes at different frequencies.
The vias were used at the one end of the resonators to electrically connect the resonators and the
ground plane [1].
In this paper, the asymmetric grounded resonators with interdigital capacitors is proposed to
decrease the slot crossing differential signals. The grounded resonators are placed on the PCB by
designing a stub with a shorting via connecting to the ground. The interdigital capacitors are
placed at one end of the stub. These resonators provide the return current path and would acts as
an inductor. The interdigial capacitors provide capacitance and this capacitance and inductance
get cancelled and thus reduces the radiated emission.
II. RADIATED EMISSION ON PCB
Radiated emission is one of the major issues of signal integrity. Radiated emission is the
unintensional discharge of electromagnetic energy from an electronic device. Radiated emission
occurs when there is a via or a split or a bend in a trace. Emission from one device may cause
malfunction in the neighbouring device. The main source of radiated emission is common mode
noise. Common mode radiation and differential mode radiation arises when a differential signal
crosses a slotted reference plane. The differential mode current and common mode current occurs
in a parallel conductor. Common mode current are equal in magnitude and same in direction
where as the differential mode current are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction. Common
mode noise arises when the signal trace radiates energy with respect to the ground. It is result of
undesired voltage drop in the circuit that causes some parts of the system to be at a common
mode potential and it is harder to control than the differential mode radiation. Differential mode
radiation is the result of current flowing around the loop formed by the conductor of the circuit.
The common mode radiation can be reduced by minimizing the common mode current. This
common mode current is controlled by minimizing the source voltage that drives the antenna,
providing large common mode choke in series with the cable, shunting the current to ground and
by shielding the cable. Fig 1 and Fig 2 shows the existing method. The insertion loss is about -
8dB and the return loss is -10dB. They are measured at a frequency of 4GHz.
Fig. 1. Coupled microstrip in a splitted reference plane

149
Fig 1 shows the coupled microstrip placed on the FR4 epoxy substrate near the differential lines
on a splitted reference plane.
Fig 2. Asymmetric grounded resonators in a splitted reference plane with stub
Fig 2 shows that the vias are placed at one end of the asymmetric grounded resonators which are
placed on the FR4 epoxy substrate near the differential lines on a splitted reference plane. In this
method the return loss is -8.3dB and the insertion loss is about -12dB.
III. PROPOSED METHOD
The asymmetrical grounded resonators with interdigital capacitors and a shorting via are placed
in a splitted reference plane. The method of realising a capacitor is by providing a slot in the
middle of the conductive strip. This will act as a parallel plate capacitor which is known as the
interdigital capacitor (IDC).
Fig 3Asymmetric grounded resonators in a splitted reference place with IDC
The physical structure is shown in the Fig 3. The differential line with width, W and a space, S
aymmetrically crosses its split reference plane with a width of, Ws. The distance between the
centre of the differential line and the both end of the split is given by Lo and Ls respectively. The
length and width is given by and . The height of substrate is H. The relative
permittivity of the dielectric is . The grounded resonators are kept in parallel to the differential
line in which one end of them is shorted with vias and the other end is connected with the
interdigital capacitors. The width of the resonators is . The distance from the centre of the

150
spacing between the differential lines to the resonator is given by and the dissimilar length of
the resonators are denoted by and . These two grounded resonators have same
characteristic impedance and a phase constant of used to control the transmission
frequency. The resonators are designed using the following equations [1]. The characteristic
impedance is given as,
= 73.6-2.15 + (638.9-1.37 )(λ
) .
+(36.23√( +41)-225)
/
( . . )
+0.51( +2.12)( )ln(100
λ
)-0.753
(
λ
)
√ /λ
And the phase constant,
βs=2 /λ
Where λ is defined as
λ
λ
=0.9217-0.277ln ( ) + 0.0322( ) (
.
) ^0.5-0.01ln (λ
) [4.6-
.
√ /λ ( .
λ
)
]
λ is the wavelength of vacuum.
The gap between the interdigital capacitors are equal and if the gap between it decreases then the
capacitance increases. Reducing the width of the finger reduces the required area but decreases
the characteristic impedance of the line and so the effective capacitance decreases. If the length
of the finger increases then the capacitance increases and so the board area gets increased. The
number of fingers may range from 2 to 200.
The design of the interdigital capacitors is described. The effective capacitance can be found by
three capacitive structures as shown in Fig 4.
= *
( )
,
( )
*l
( )
2

151
Fig 4 . Interdigital Capacitors
2 *
( )
( ,
)
*
Where,
= l/4
=4 *
( ′ )
( )
*l
=
∗
( )∗( )
C= (n-3) +(n-1) +2
= 1+
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The ground plane has a dimension of 60 x 66mm. The height of the FR4 epoxy substrate is about
1.6mm. The length and width of the differential line is about 60mm and 1.27mm. The width of
the split is given by 0.5mm. The asymmetric grounded resonators L_gro and L_grs are said to be
9.3mm and 12.5mm. The distance between the two differential lines is 0.51mm. The S_(gr )is
about 10mm.The scattering parameters are used to study the characteristics of common mode
radiation. The return loss and insertion loss are defined by and . They are derived by using
the following equations [4].
(dB)= 20 log ( + + + )
(dB)= 20 log ( + + + )

152
The resonators which are used are inductive in nature. The interdigital capacitors placed above
the resonators have a capacitve effect and thus cancells with each other.
Fig 5. Proposed structure in Ansoft HFSS tool
The proposed structure is implemented using the Ansoft HFSS tool snapshot is shown in the Fig
5. The Fig 6 and Fig 7 show the return loss and inserion loss of the proposed and the conventional
models. These scattering parameters are simulated for the frequency range of 0 to 4 GHz. For the
proposed model the insertion loss is -14dB and the return loss is found to be -2 dB.
Fig 6. Compared results of the return loss for the splitted reference plane, splitted plane with a vais and the
splitted reference plane with IDC

153
Fig 7. Compared results of the insertion loss for the splitted reference plane, splitted plane with a vias and the splitted
reference plane with IDC
V. CONCLUSION
Thus the asymmetrical grounded resonators with the interdigital capacitors is designed and
proposed using the Ansoft HFSS tool. The return loss, insertion loss and the field pattern are
simulated for the proposed structure. At 4GHz, the return loss shows a reduction of about 6 dB
and the insertion loss increases approximately 2 dB. The physical dimensions for the stub and the
interdigital capacitors are determined by using the design theory.
REFERENCES
[1] Hao-Hsiang Chuang and Tzong-Lin Wu, Senior member IEEE, “Suppression of common- mode
radiation and mode conversion for slot crossing GHz Differential signals Using Novel grounded
Resonators” ,IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic compatability, Vol.53,No.2,May 2011.
[2] A.K. Arya, A.Patnaik, M.V.Karthikeyen, “A compact array with low mutual coupling using defected
ground structures” in IEEE Conference, 2011.
[3] Hao-Hsiang Chuang and Tzong-Lin Wu, Senior member IEEE, “A Novel ground resonator technique
to reduce common mode radiation on slot-crossing differential signals” in IEEE Microwave and
wireless Components letters,Vol.20,No.12,December 2010.
[4] Hao-Hsiang Chuang and Tzong-Lin Wu, Senior member IEEE, “A new common mode EMI
Suppression technique for GHz differential signals crossing slotted reference planes” in IEEE
conference, 2010.
[5] Jingook Kim, Student Member, IEEE, Heeseok Lee and Joungho Kim, Associate member,
IEEE,”Effects on Signal Integrity and Radiated Emission by Split Reference Plane on High- Speed
Multilayer Printed Circuit Boards”, in IEEE Transactions on Advanced
Packaging,Vol.28,No.4,November 2005 .
[6] Hitoshi Nagakubo,Kimitoshi Murano,Fengchao Xiao,Yoshio Kami, “Circuit Model for Two Parallel
Microstrip Lines on Slotted Ground Plane”, in IEEE Conference in 2007.
[7] Guang-Hwa Shiue, Member, IEEE, and Ruey-Beei Wu, Senior Member, IEEE,”Reduction in
Reflections and Ground Bounce for Signal line Over Slotted Power Plane Using Differential coupled
Microstrip Lines” in IEEE Transactions on Advanced Packaging,Vol.32,No.3,August 2009.
[8] Mark L Montrose, Jin Hong-Fang, Er-Ping Li,”Analysis on the Effectiveness of High Speed Printed
Circuit Board Edge Radiated Emissions Based on Stimulus Source Location” in IEEE Conference.
[9] Sergiu Radu and David Hockanson,”An Investigation of PCB Radiated Emissions from
Simultaneous Switching Noise” in IEEE Conference, 1999.

154
[10] Mark I. Montrose, “Analysis on Loop Area Trace Radiated Emissions from Decoupling Capacitor
Placement on Printed Circuit Boards”,in IEEE Conference, 1999.
[11] Junho Lee, Hyungsoo Kim, and Joungho Kim, “Broadband Suppression of SSN and Radiated
Emissions using High-DK Thin Film EBG Power Distribution Network for High-Speed Digital PCB
Applications”, in IEEE Conference, 2005.
[12] Changyi Su, Student Member, IEEE, and Todd H. Hubing,”Calculating Radiated Emissions Due to
I/O Line Coupling on Printed Circuit Boards Using the Imbalance Difference Method”.
[13] Bert Wong, Antonio Cantoni,”Radiated Emissions and Signal Integrity of Printed Circuit Board
Microstrips”, in IEEE Conference.

SUPPRESSION OF COMMON-MODE RADIATION FROM HIGH SPEED PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD USING MODIFIED GROUND PATTERNS

More Related Content

Similar to SUPPRESSION OF COMMON-MODE RADIATION FROM HIGH SPEED PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD USING MODIFIED GROUND PATTERNS (20)

More from ijistjournal (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

SUPPRESSION OF COMMON-MODE RADIATION FROM HIGH SPEED PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD USING MODIFIED GROUND PATTERNS