The Arrival Discussion Questions - Chapter 2
1 like9,571 views
The document provides discussion questions for analyzing various pages from Chapter 2 of Shaun Tan's graphic novel The Arrival. It asks questions about: 1) Images on pages 17-19 and what is being conveyed through panel size and cloud imagery. 2) Page 23 resembling a photograph of immigrants at Ellis Island and the symbolism of statues on pages 24-25. 3) How lighting and tone are used on page 26 to impact meaning. 4) Comparing pages from the book to film clips and photographs of Ellis Island. 5) Details examined in the immigration process and what caused some to be turned away.
The Arrival Discussion Questions - Chapter 2
- 1. Discussion Questions for Shaun Tan’s The Arrival - Chapter 2 The pages are not numbered in the book, but Chapter 2 begins on the 17th page. Page 17 (panel 1) Who is in the photograph? Why is the man eating while looking at the picture? Pages 18-19 Why has the artist chosen to use two pages for this panel? Why do you think the boat is so small in comparison to the cloud? Pages 20-21 What is the artist trying to convey by having so many panels with clouds in them? Page 23 Look at the following photograph and the page from The Arrival: http://www.ellisisland.org/photoalbums/ellis_island_album106.asp Page 23 Why has the artist chosen to make this page look like a photograph of Immigrants coming to Ellis Island? Page 1 Version 1.0 www.makingvisualnarratives.com
- 2. Discussion Questions for Shaun Tan’s The Arrival - Chapter 2 Page 24-25 Look at these images of the Statue of Liberty: What ideas are being shown in the Statue of Liberty? What ideas are being shown in the statue on page 25? How are these two sculptures alike? How are they different? Page 26 What do you think the artist is trying to convey with the way lighting shown in the pic- ture? How would the meaning change if the lighting were darker? Page 2 Version 1.0 www.makingvisualnarratives.com
- 3. Discussion Questions for Shaun Tan’s The Arrival - Chapter 2 Watch the movie clip “Immigrants Landing at Ellis Island” YouTube Link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3bhufeQDRoM&feature=youtu.be Library of Congress Link: http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/h?ammem/papr:@field(NUMBER+@band(lcmp002+m2a10987)) Page 27 Compare and contrast the sequence of panels on this page to the movie clip. Page 28 Look at this iconic image from the Great Hall of Ellis Island (1907-1912). Compare and contrast it to the image on page 28. Page 29 What kinds of things do you think they are they checking on? What things caused immigrants to be turned away from the USA? Page 30 How does the man in the hat feel? What do you see in the images that support your opinion? Page 31 What do you think they are writing? What is the hand doing in the final panel? Page 3 Version 1.0 www.makingvisualnarratives.com
- 4. Discussion Questions for Shaun Tan’s The Arrival - Chapter 2 Page 39 What are some items that the artist has changed the scale or size of? What effect does this have on you, the reader? Page 44 How does the man in the hat figure out what room he is supposed to stay in? Page 47 Why does the man’s family appear in the suitcase? Why does the man hang up the photograph? Page 4 Version 1.0 www.makingvisualnarratives.com