The hidden fact playing with metaphors to reframe the domains of meaning
1 like1,760 views
This document discusses narrative, metaphor, and performance. It argues that all narratives are incomplete and require the reader to fill in gaps. Metaphors relate one domain of experience to another and imply omissions. Living metaphors can be performed to generate new meanings. Everyday experiences provide rich sources for transformative metaphors. Performing metaphors in an improvised way allows meanings to be co-constructed and can interrupt old patterns or generate new ideas.
The hidden fact playing with metaphors to reframe the domains of meaning
- 1. February 7,2012 Edgardo Morales Ed.D Mary Gergen, Ph. D Play with purpose: relational and performative practices in everyday
- 2. “This is the greatest triumph of technical skill in novel writing: to achieve invisibility, the ability to endow a story with color, drama, subtlety, beauty and suggestive power so effectively that no reader even notices that the narrative exists…he feels he is not reading but rather “living” the story…” (MarioVargas Llosa)
- 4. All narrative is inevitably incomplete, if one was to tell a whole story it would never end, for all stories are interconnected. It means narrating through "an extraordinary explicit silence", through pauses and through the information that is left out. It actives the readers curiosity and imagination. The reader is required to fill his own blanks and provide his or her own meaning to what is being told. The reader may be asked to question, provide an answer or invent a solution to decipher the meaning of the story.
- 5. “The essence of Metaphor is understanding and experiencing one thing in terms of another” (Lakoff &Johnson) It implies relating to one domain of experience, in terms of another domain.
- 6. All metaphors imply an omission They are relationally constructed and contextual In inviting us to think or experience one thing in terms of another, we miss alternate possibilities of meaning
- 7. Life is not really a bowl of cherries Genes are not “selfish” We don’t really “save” time Relationships are not really “sick” These ideas will not really be “food” for thought And meanings are not really “constructed”
- 8. They can enable a “standing a part” from a situation They can help us to connect and relationally engage with others They can serve to provoke and shock, pose questions and introduce and sometimes answer dilemmas. They can facilitate the co creation of new meanings and the affirmation of forgotten, or alternate identities
- 9. Metaphors can be explicit, but they don’t have to be. They may be linguistically delivered and performed in the form of an analogy or a story. They can also be part of a performance as what we can call living metaphors.
- 10. We can move from one domain to another How is this like learning to dance? How is what’s happening like an acid trip? How is this, like I eating a warm chocolate meting cake (Molten)? How is what’s occurring like Alice inWonderland? How is this like the “real story” of Hansel and Gretel? How is this like the movie Kick Ass?What would “Hit Girl” really do? How is this situation like a beauty parlor, like gardening or like an emergency room?
- 11. Dramatically, through performance we play with metaphoric paradox– We are and we are not in this space We are and are not in this time We are and are not in this identity or in this role We are and we’re not of this age And this activity is and is not what we call it Performance for play??????
- 12. Everyday experiences, stories, and anecdotes can be a rich source for generating transformative metaphors. We can pay attention to the way metaphors are “languaged” in the everyday experience of people we work or relate with. People often provide “obvious” metaphors. “This is a prison”. “This is like an emergency ward”
- 13. If this situation was a metaphor, what would it be a metaphor of? How can I use this (image, situation or analogy)? What could it be useful for? How can it serve to connect, shock, question, or surprise? In what context would it be useful?
- 14. Trust emergence Maintain a relational connection Begin to improvise and perform Let the response and involvement of your audience guide your performance of the metaphor Allow meanings to be c0-constructed (Remember an explicit moral or teaching or explanation is not required.)
- 15. What does it tell us about the situation, that may not be initially apparent? What meanings does it generate? Where does it take us as an audience? If the characters in the story heard it, in what direction would it take them? Would anything “old” be interrupted? Could anything new be generated and co-created?