![American Progress by John Gast
Excerpts from explanatory text that George A. Croffut provided to market John Gast's
1872 lithograph American Progress.
This rich and wonderful country--the progress of which at the present time, is the
wonder of the old world--was until recently, inhabited exclusively by the lurking savage
and wild beasts of prey. If the rapid progress of the "Great West" has surprised our
people, what will those of other countries think of the "Far West," which was destined
at an early day, to be the vast granary [grain producing region], as it is now the
treasure chamber of our country?...
In the foreground, the central and principal figure, a beautiful and charming Female, is
floating westward through the air bearing on her forehead the "Star of Empire...." On
the right of the picture is a city, steamships, manufactories, schools and churches
over which beams of light are streaming and filling the air--indicative of civilization.
The general tone of the picture on the left declares darkness, waste and confusion.
From the city proceed the three great continental lines of railway.... Next to these are
the transportation wagons, overland stage, hunters, gold seekers, pony express,
pioneer emigrant and the warrior dance of the "noble red man." Fleeing from
"Progress"...are Indians, buffaloes, wild horses, bears, and other game, moving
Westward, ever Westward, the Indians with their squaws, papooses, and "pony
lodges," turn their despairing faces towards, as they flee the wondrous vision. The
"Star" is too much for them.
...What home, from the miner's humble cabin to the stately marble mansion of the
capitalist, should be without this Great National Picture, which illustrates in the most
artistic manner all the gigantic results of American Brains and Hands! Who would not
have such a beautiful token to remind them of the country's grandeur and enterprise
which have caused the mighty wilderness to blossom like the rose!!!](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/thepersuasivespeech-221212062912-d161975e/85/The-Persuasive-Speech-ppt-13-320.jpg)
The Persuasive Speech.ppt
- 1. THE PERSUASIVE SPEECH “Words create ripples, and ripples can come together to make waves.” –Michael Osborn
- 2. The Definition of the Persuasive Speech The art of gaining fair and favorable consideration for your point of view.
- 3. Eight Purposes of Persuasive Speeches: 1. To urge a choice among options. 2. Persuaders act as advocates for a cause or point of view. 3. To use supporting materials as evidence that justified advice. 4. Persuaded listeners become agents of change. 5. Asks for audience commitment to a cause 6. Establishes character and commitment of speaker through leadership 7. Makes appeals to feelings 8. Makes us confront our obligation to believe and act in socially and morally responsive ways.
- 4. Harmful forms of persuasion: Argumentative persuasion Evil speakers can twist evidence and disguise bad reasoning “The relation of the Jews to prostitution and, even more, to the white-slave traffic, could be studied in Vienna…When thus for the first time I recognized the Jew as the cold- hearted, shameless, and calculating director of this revolting vice traffic in the scum of the big city, a cold shudder ran down my back.” –Adolph Hitler
- 5. Harmful forms of persuasion: Manipulative persuasion Works by suggestion, colorful images, appealing music, and attractive spokespersons
- 6. What is manipulative about these images?
- 7. Types of Evidence to use in Persuasive Speeches: Facts, figures, statistics Use examples from “real life” Narratives—make your audience witness to a living drama Use Expert Testimony/Witnesses When you quote others, you are associating yourself with them, so be careful whom you choose! Reluctant witnesses are those who testify against their apparent self-interest and so are often more powerful (such as Democratic critics of a Democratic president).
- 8. Evidence Example: “I know a child—well, she must be 13 now—I’d better call her a young woman…She has memories. She has hopes. And she has juvenile diabetes. Like so many kids with this disease, she has adjusted amazingly well. The insulin pump she wears—she’s decorated hers with rhinestones. She can insert her own catheter needle. She has learned to sleep through the blood drawings in the wee hours of the morning. She’s very brave. She is also quite bright and understands full well the progress of her disease and what it might ultimately mean: blindness, amputation, diabetic coma. Every day, she fights to have a future. What excuse will we offer this young woman should we fail her now? What might we tell…the millions of others who suffer? That when given an opportunity to help, we turned away? That facing political opposition, we lost our nerve? That even though we knew better, we did nothing?” -Ron Reagan at the 2004 Democratic Convention urging delegates to support embryonic stem cell research
- 9. Evidence Example: “It’s a cold, icy December afternoon. You hear a distant crash, then screams, and finally the unending moan of a car horn fills the silence. You rush the short distance to the scene of the crash, where you find an SUV overturned with a young woman and two small boys inside. The woman and one of the boys climb from the wreckage unhurt; the other boy, however, is pinned between the dashboard and the roof of the car, unconscious and not breathing. Would you know what to do? Or would you stand there wishing you did? These events are real. Bob Flath saved this child with the skills he acquired at his company’s first aid workshop.” -Kirsten Lientz, urging students to take a first aid course offered at her university
- 10. Develop a Proof (an argument): Aristotle believed there were three forms of proof: Pathos: appeals to personal feelings such as fear, pity, and anger Ethos: audiences respond to the speaker’s competence, character, goodwill, and dynamism and the credibility of the evidence Logos: appeals to reason (logical arguments) Scholars today believe that there is one final element to the proof: Mythos: appeals to the traditions and values of your
- 11. Logos: The heart of an argument Reason from a principle that you believe everyone in your audience accepts (such as “Freedom of Speech”) Reason from reality using statistics, comparisions, and even scientific data (Science is a god-term---a key word to give your data credibility) Reason with parallel cases which are used to frame an unfamiliar concept in something more familiar
- 12. Which element is used in this painting? American Progress by John Gast
- 13. American Progress by John Gast Excerpts from explanatory text that George A. Croffut provided to market John Gast's 1872 lithograph American Progress. This rich and wonderful country--the progress of which at the present time, is the wonder of the old world--was until recently, inhabited exclusively by the lurking savage and wild beasts of prey. If the rapid progress of the "Great West" has surprised our people, what will those of other countries think of the "Far West," which was destined at an early day, to be the vast granary [grain producing region], as it is now the treasure chamber of our country?... In the foreground, the central and principal figure, a beautiful and charming Female, is floating westward through the air bearing on her forehead the "Star of Empire...." On the right of the picture is a city, steamships, manufactories, schools and churches over which beams of light are streaming and filling the air--indicative of civilization. The general tone of the picture on the left declares darkness, waste and confusion. From the city proceed the three great continental lines of railway.... Next to these are the transportation wagons, overland stage, hunters, gold seekers, pony express, pioneer emigrant and the warrior dance of the "noble red man." Fleeing from "Progress"...are Indians, buffaloes, wild horses, bears, and other game, moving Westward, ever Westward, the Indians with their squaws, papooses, and "pony lodges," turn their despairing faces towards, as they flee the wondrous vision. The "Star" is too much for them. ...What home, from the miner's humble cabin to the stately marble mansion of the capitalist, should be without this Great National Picture, which illustrates in the most artistic manner all the gigantic results of American Brains and Hands! Who would not have such a beautiful token to remind them of the country's grandeur and enterprise which have caused the mighty wilderness to blossom like the rose!!!
- 14. Which element is used in this example? “There was a day when I walked into the halls of this Senate and worked closely with many of you and your staffs. There was a wonderful day when I was fortunate enough to serve the President of the United States in a capacity I had dreamed of all my life. And for a time, I felt that people looked up to me. Today, I can tell you how hard it is to have people speaking down to me. But nothing has been harder than losing the independence and control we all so value in life. I need help getting out of bed, help taking a shower, and help getting dressed. There are some who oppose a simple seven-day waiting period for hand-gun purchases because it would inconvenience gun buyers. Well, I guess I am paying for their convenience. And I am one of the lucky ones. I survived being shot through the head. Other shooting victims are not as fortunate.” -James Brady, Presidential Press Secretary who was shot during the
- 15. Which element is used in this example? “The American flag stands for more than our power and our interests. Our founders dedicated this country to the cause of human dignity, the rights of every person and the possibilities of every life. This conviction leads us into the world to help the afflicted, and defend the peace, and confound the designs of evil men.” President George W. Bush, State of the Union address 2003
- 16. Which element is used in this example? “I want you to imagine with me a computer game called “Puppy Shoot.” In this game puppies run across the screen. Using a joystick, the game player aims a gun that shoots the puppies. The player is awarded one point for a flesh wound, three points for a body shot, and ten points for a head shot. Blood spurts out each time a puppy is hit—and brain tissue splatters all over whenever there’s a head shot. The dead puppies pile up at the bottom of the screen. When the shooter gets to 1,000 points, he gets to exchange his pistol for an Uzi, and the point values go up. If a game as disgusting as that were to be developed, every animal rights group in the country, along with a lot of other organizations, would protest, and there would be all sorts of attempts made to get the game taken off the market. Yet, if you just change puppies to people in the game I described, there are dozens of them already on the market—sold under such names as “Blood Bath,” “Psycho Toxic,” “Redneck Rampage,” and “Soldier of Fortune.” -Dr. Richard Corlin, President of the American Medical Association, 2001. “The Secrets of Gun Violence in America.”
- 17. Constructing an Argument Create an Awareness of the problem/issue First, make sure that the audience knows that the issue exists Make a case for the problem/issue is an important one that needs to be fixed/addressed
- 18. Constructing an Argument Create an understanding of the issue/problem Use data and statistics to illustrate the problem/issue Use testimony, stories, examples to connect with your audience (Logos, Pathos, Ethos, Mythos) You can also respectfully address the “other side” of the issue/problem
- 19. Constructing an Argument Offer a solution/plan/action that would address the issue or solve the problem: If you have offered a valid argument, the audience may accept your position and be ready to act. Have a valid plan that is logical
- 20. Constructing an Argument Enactment: Get them to act on what you say or the argument you presented Have them sign a petition, raise their hands, voice agreement, write letters to politicians, etc.
- 21. Very Controversial Topics/ Difficult audiences: Set modest goals (you may not change anyone’s mind), such as asking only for a fair hearing from the audience. Give a multi-sided presentation Acknowledge the arguments on the other side Show respect at all times for the opposition
- 22. Example of Multi-Sided: “I know that many of you may not like to hear what I’m saying, but think about it. If capital punishment does not deter violent crime, if indeed it may encourage more violent crime, isn’t it time we put capital punishment itself on trial? I know that the desire for revenge can be strong. If someone I love had been murdered, I would want the killer’s life in return. I wouldn’t care if capital punishment wasn’t fair. I wouldn’t care that it condones brutality. I would just want an eye for an eye. But that doesn’t mean you should give it to me. It doesn’t mean that society should base its policy on my anger and hatred.”