Time to Learn, Time to Grow

A Time to Learn,
A Time to Grow
California Parents Talk about
Summertime and Summer programs

Highlights from Research Conducted for the
David and Lucile Packard Foundation

Introduction
What follows is a summary of key findings from Minority parents, low-income parents and
a telephone survey of 1,204 California parents parents in rural areas are not as well served
conducted in September and October 2009 by the current system. They are most likely to
in both English and Spanish. The survey was say that there just are not good programs to
prefaced by four focus groups: in Oakland, San choose from. Significantly, minority parents
Jose, Fresno and Los Angeles. The survey high- are even more concerned about using the
lights several important themes for educators summer to bolster their children’s prospects
and policymakers, the most important of which to succeed academically when they return to
may be that California parents see a variety school in the fall.
of activities—including academics—as poten-
Some experts concerned about expanding
tially important and valuable for their children.
summer learning have worried that parents
Yet, despite this widespread appetite for rich
are in some senses “fighting” the notion.
summer programs for their children, about six
They worry that parents are so wedded to
in ten parents report that their children either
traditional ideas about “the good old summer-
did not attend a summer program or went to
time” that they resist placing their children
one for a relatively short period. That is, there
in programs that would benefit them. This
appears to be a major gap between what most
survey paints a different picture. Most parents
parents think would be good for their children
are receptive to academics in the summer,
in the summer and what actually happens
and they believe they can be an essential
when the summer months roll around. Very
part of good summer programs. At the same
few parents appear to be specifically avoiding
time, they do want their children to have new
summer programs just so their children can
and rewarding experiences in the summer,
“relax” or have several months of downtime.
the kinds of experiences that can make both
Parents whose children are in summer programs learning and the summer itself “fun.”
with academic and enrichment components
For more information on this survey, including
voice a great deal of satisfaction with these
methodology and full questionnaire results,
programs. At the same time, most parents
please visit: http://www.publicagenda.org/
appear to be interested in summer programs
pages/Calif-summer-survey.
that are “different” from the regular school
year. That is, they are interested in activi-
ties that help their children learn and thrive
academically, but they also want summer to
be a time when their children can have new
experiences and enjoy a different change of
pace from the regular school year. Most want
to use some of that time for the family to be
together, and they want to use some of that
time for the children to be out-of-doors, exer-
cising and enjoying the summer weather.

2 | A Time to Learn, A Time to Grow

FINDING ONE:
In summer 2009, nearly 6 in 10 parents in 4 More than 1 in 5 (22 percent) say it was more
California (59 percent) either did not enroll difficult this year to find activities for their child
their child in a summer program at all or did to do this summer than in past summers.
so for less than half the summer.
4 Well over half (59 percent) report that their chil-
4 Half of all parents (51 percent) say that summer is dren, aged 5 to 15, were not in summer programs
the most difficult time to make sure their child is for at least half the summer—29 percent enrolled
well taken care of and has interesting things to do. their child for less than half the summer; over 3
in 10 (30 percent) of parents did not enroll their
child in a summer program at all.

Parents say summer is the most 4 Nearly two-thirds of all parents (65 percent)
difﬁcult time to care for their child say they wish they knew about more summer
Which time would you say is the hardest to programs that fit their budget.
make sure your child is well taken care of and
has interesting things to do?

Nearly 6 in 10 say they did not
enroll their child for more than
half the summer
15%

51% 16% 59%

10% 41%

5%

2%

51% The summer months

15% The hours after school 41% Participated in programs
for more than half the summer
16% The weekend during the school year
Underenrolled in summer programs 59%
10% Never have to struggle Participated in programs for
less than half the summer
29%
5% All
Did not participate in summer programs
2% Don’t know 30%

A Time to Learn, A Time to Grow | 1

FINDING TWO:
Parents whose children participated
Most parents say academics and enrichment in academic and enrichment
activities should be an essential part of summer. activities say that they prepared
More than half say that their child was either not them for the school year
enrolled in any summer program or one with an Percent of parents who agree that the
academic component. summer program helped prepare their child
for school, based on those who also said
4 While majorities of parents—whether or not they the program had:
enrolled their children in summer programs—
say that having their child do academics and
Academics and enrichment activities
summer enrichment activities is essential during
45% 42% 87%
the summer, more than half of all parents (58
percent) did not send their child to a program
that had any academics, and 4 in 10 (43 percent)
parents did not send their children to programs Enrichment activities, but not academics
with enrichment activities. 20% 34% 54%

4 Among parents who sent their child to a summer
program that included both academics and
Neither academics nor enrichment
enrichment (54 percent of those who partici-
11% 30% 41%
pated) more than 8 in 10 (87 percent) agreed that
the programs helped prepare their child for the
0 20 40 60 80 100%
school year, with 45 percent agreeing strongly.
Among parents whose children attended programs  Strongly agree  Somewhat agree
without an academic or enrichment component,
Note: Very few parents say they enrolled their child in summer
only 4 in 10 (41 percent) said that the program programs that only included academic activities, so it is not
helped prepare their child for school. possible to make a statistically significant comparison here.


FINDING Three: FINDING Four:
Finances and lack of available programs are Parents believe that along with academics,
important factors that prevent many families many kinds of summer experiences are valuable
from participating in summer programs. for their children, ranging from spending more
time with family to being outdoors to working
4 As much as parents might like their child to
on hobbies. In their view, an ideal summer is
participate in a summer program, the cost of
one that offers variety.
these programs is a major concern, especially for
those with lower incomes or changed financial 4 The survey asked parents about 10 different
circumstances. activities that might or might not be considered
an essential part of their child’s summer including
4 Among parents who say their family had a change
both academic and enrichment activities. More
in employment status last year, 73 percent said
than 4 in 10 parents said that every activity we
that they wished they knew of more affordable
mentioned was an essential part of their child’s
programs.
summer (See chart on following page). The results
4 Among parents who did not enroll their child in a show that most parents believe that when it
summer program in 2009, nearly half (46 percent) comes to summer plans, a variety of activities of
say there was a program they were interested in, different kinds are valuable.
but that they couldn’t afford it this year because
4 In addition, more than three-quarters of California
of changing finances.
parents (76 percent) prefer a program that offers
4 Nearly half of parents (48 percent) who make a variety of activities for the summer, including
less than $35,000 did not enroll their child in academics, compared with 11 percent that want the
any summer program. Looked at another way, most academically focused program and 12 percent
among those who did not enroll their child in any who favor a an exclusively recreational program.
summer program, more than 4 in 10 (43 percent)
4 Parents also have a variety of concerns about how
made less than $35,000 a year.
their child can spend their free time during the
summer. A quarter say they are most concerned that
their children will not keep up with educational
activities and fall behind in school (25 percent).
Nearly as many say their main worry is that their
child will not have enough to do and will become
bored (24 percent); about 1 in 5 (21 percent) are
most worried that their children won’t get enough
exercise and be out-of-doors, while 16 percent worry
that their child might not be well-supervised and
might get into trouble.

4 In focus groups, the great majority of parents said
that the ideal summer program for their child would
have a variety of structured activities, but also some
unstructured fun time. As one father in Fresno said,
“I think there’s something to be said for not [being
in an organized activity]. You get to use your imagi-
nation. You get to play… just exploration is such a
huge part. There’s so much you can learn.”


Parents say their child should Parents want summer programs
participate in a variety of activities that have a mix of activities,
during the summer including academics
Percent who say it is “absolutely essential” that Which comes closest to describing the
their child does the following during the summer: ideal summer program for your child?
Spends more time with you
63%
12%
Spends time doing academics so
he/she does not fall behind in school
11%
58%

Develops own interests and hobbies 76%
57%

Does fun activities that helped
enrich his/her learning
56%
Spends time outdoors, such as
in local parks and playgrounds
47%
76% One that has a variety of activities
and also includes academics
Spends time relaxing and having fun
46%
12% One that is all recreational and does
not spend time on academics
Spends time doing sports
or other athletic activities
11% One that focuses on academics
42%
and only has a little time for
Spends time doing church-based recreational activities
activities or activities focused
on reinforcing your religious faith
1% Don’t know
42%

Takes some trips to museums
or other educational places
41%

Does some creative activities
like arts and crafts, dance or music
40%

0 20 40 60 80 100%


FINDING FIVE:
Access to quality programs is a special issue Latino and African-American parents
are more likely to say that there are
for rural parents, along with lower-income,
no high-quality summer programs
African-American and Latino parents.
available in their area
4 Latino parents (32 percent) and African-American Percent of parents who say that there are no
parents (31 percent) are more likely to say that there high quality summer programs in their area:
are no high–quality summer programs available in
their neighborhood, compared with 15 percent of
Latino parents
Asian parents and 20 percent of whites parents.
32%
4 More than 4 in 10 parents (43 percent) living in
rural areas said that quality summer programs are African-American parents
not available, compared with a quarter of parents in 31%
urban (24 percent) and suburban (25 percent) areas.
White parents
4 Lower-income parents (those making less than 20%
$35,000 a year) are twice as likely as higher
income parents (those with incomes over $75,000 Asian parents
annually) to say that there are no high quality 15%
summer programs available in their area, by a 37
percent to 18 percent margin. Both lower-income
0 20 40 60 80 100%
(42 percent) and middle-income (39 percent)
area more likely than higher-income parents (19
percent) to say there were no affordable programs
that would be good for their child.

4 In a Los Angeles focus group with Latino parents
(conducted in Spanish), a number of the partici-
pants said there were not any good programs
available for their child. One parent of a six year-
old daughter said, “She was behind in her reading,
and now during the summer she is forgetting
what she learned… There was no program to
enroll her [in].” Another focus group participant
said, “As parents we cannot pay someone to take
care of our children during the summer. Plus,
almost all parks have a waiting list. We could not
involve our children in park activities because
there was a wait list and the places that were
available were too expensive.”

4 Overall, 3 in 10 (30 percent) parents whose
children did not participate in summer programs
at all said that there are no high quality programs
in the area. Nearly a quarter (24 percent) of those
who enrolled their child for less than half of the
summer said the same thing.

FINDING SIX:
Lower-income parents are more
likely to say there are no affordable Latino parents are more likely than white parents
or high-quality summer programs in to want academics and enrichment in summer
their area programs and to be dissatisfied with the quality
Percent who say the following is a reason of summer programs their children attend.
why their child did not participate in a
summer program: 4 Fifty percent of all children in California are
Latino.1 Public Agenda and other organizations
have documented that Latino parents are more
There were no affordable programs
concerned about low academic standards in their
that I thought were good for my child
schools than are white parents. The survey findings
42% here reflect a similar worry: Latino families are
19% more likely than white parents to voice concerns
about lack of learning during the summer.
There were no high quality programs
for my child to participate in 4 Fewer than half of Latino parents (41 percent)
said that, overall, children get enough academics
27%
during the school year, compared to 55 percent
17%
of white parents.

4 More than 6 in 10 (62 percent) Latino parents
0 20 40 60 80 100% said it is essential that their child’s summer
activities include academics to avoid losing what
 Lower-income parents
(<$35,000 per year) they have learned in the school year compared to
50 percent of white parents.
 Higher-income parents
(>$75,000 per year) 4 Latino parents were twice as likely as white
parents to say that they preferred a program that
focuses on academics (14 percent to 7 percent)
and almost twice as likely to want to see a focus
Base: Asked of parents who did not
on classroom learning over outdoor enrichment
enroll their child in a summer program.
activities (31 percent to 17 percent).

4 As noted in the previous finding, nearly a third
(32 percent) of all Latino parents say there are no
high quality programs in the area for their child.
And among Latino parents who enrolled their child
in a summer program, 1 in 10 (11 percent) gave it
a fair or poor rating, compared to just 6 percent of
white parents. Latino parents were also more likely
to agree with the statement “the program really
just supervised their child and did not involve any
interesting or educational activities,” 26 percent
compared to 15 percent of white.

1
“Kids Count 2008”, 2008, Ann E. Casey Foundation http://datacenter.kidscount.org/data/acrossstates/Rankings.aspx?ind=103


Latino parents are more likely to About Public Agenda
prefer an academic summer program
Founded in 1975 by social scientist and author
Percent of parents who say: Daniel Yankelovich and former U.S. Secretary
of State Cyrus Vance, Public Agenda works to
100%
help the nation’s leaders better understand
the public’s point of view and to help average
citizens better understand critical policy
issues. Our in-depth research on how citizens
80 think about policy has won praise for its
credibility and fairness from elected officials
from both political parties and from experts
62%
and decision makers across the political spec-
60 trum. Our citizen education materials and
award-winning website, PublicAgenda.org,
50% offer unbiased information about the chal-
lenges the country faces. Twice nominated for
the prestigious Webby award for best political
40
site, PublicAgenda.org provides comprehensive
information on a wide range of policy issues.

About The David and
20
14%

7% Lucile Packard Foundation
0
The David and Lucile Packard Foundation is
A. B. a private family foundation created in 1964
by David Packard (1912–1996), cofounder of
 Latino parents  White parents the Hewlett-Packard Company, and Lucile
A. It is essential that their child’s Salter Packard (1914–1987). The Foundation
summer activities include academics provides grants to nonprofit organizations in
the following program areas: Conservation
B. The ideal summer program is and Science; Population and Reproductive
one that focuses on academics
Health; and Children, Families and Communities.
Foundation grantmaking includes support for
a wide variety of activities including direct
4 And 37 percent of Latino parents did not enroll services, research and policy development,
their child in a summer program at all, compared and public information and education. The
with 26 percent of white parents. As one parent Foundation does not make grants intended to
in Los Angeles said, “There are a lot of options influence legislation or support candidates for
available but [not for me]. Because of the political office.
economy, they all require money.”


“A Time to Learn, A Time to Grow” online at http://www.publicagenda.org/pages/Calif-summer-survey

Topline: Survey Methodology, Questions & Answers
http://www.publicagenda.org/files/pdf/Calif-summer-survey-topline.pdf

Copyright (c) 2010 Public Agenda

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.
To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative
Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California 94105, USA

6 East 39th Street | New York, NY 10016 | t (212) 686.6610 | f (212) 889.3461
Web: PublicAgenda.org | Twitter: @PublicAgenda | Facebook: Public Agenda

Time to Learn, Time to Grow

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Viewers also liked (6)

Similar to Time to Learn, Time to Grow (20)

More from Amber Ott (7)

Recently uploaded (20)

Time to Learn, Time to Grow