Visualizing the Geography of
Platform Boundary Resources: The
Case of the Global API Ecosystem
Jukka Huhtamäki
Rahul C. Basole
Kaisa Still
Martha G. Russell
Marko Seppänen
http://bit.ly/apiglobal2017preso
http://bit.ly/apiglobal2017paper
Introduction
Why APIs?
• APIs are replacing “traditional” interfirm
relationships
• APIs are lightweight boundary resources that
allow for complementors to create value for
the focal companies
• APIs are artifacts of both lightweight software
development and business strategy6.1.2017 4
API vs. platform economy
6.1.2017 6
6.1.2017 7Biswarup Ganguly, CC BY 3.0
6.1.2017 8
6.1.2017 9
6.1.2017 10
(Evans and Basole, 2016;
Basole, 2016)
6.1.2017 11
(Evans and Basole, 2016;
Basole, 2016)
Why Geography?
• Digitization is eliminating “distance” and
therefore one can assume that geography
would have a smaller role
• At the same time, we see that large
companies continue to be co-located
6.1.2017 12
We asked
• Where are APIs located geographically*?
• Is the geographical location of a company
less important in the digital age?
6.1.2017 13
Method
• Data collection using crawling and scraping
• Data-driven visual network analytics
• Semi-automated data curation process
6.1.2017 14
Visualizing the Geography of Platform Boundary Resources
Data curation
• 13,366 APIs and 6,271 mashups from
ProgrammableWeb
• Using URIs as identifiers, company location
lookup using Crunchbase
• Mapping the 6,218 APIs with location data to
city-level entrepreneurial regions and global
regions
6.1.2017 16
Results–two levels of analysis
1. Where are the APIs available globally?
2. How are APIs co-used between regions?
H
6.1.2017 18
API Co-use
• Cf. co-citation analysis
Three resulting connections (here
regions):
Twitter - Twitter Search
Twitter - Google App Engine
Twitter Search - Google App Engine
6.1.2017 20
Regions connected on
basis of API co-use
6.1.2017 21
Regions connected on
basis of API co-use
Conclusions
Takeaways
• API ecosystem is highly concentrated to a
few regions
• API ecosystem is particularly flexible for
actors to offer and consume services
• API co-use is not API usage
• Public APIs vs. Private APIs
Future work
• Investigating the internal company-level network
structure of entrepreneurial regions
• Introducing dynamics to the analysis: API diffusion
studies
• How policy makers can facilitate the emergence of
national and e.g. European API ecosystem?
• How will the changes in international data governance
policy impact the API ecosystem?
6.1.2017 24

More Related Content

PDF
The global API Ecosystem: A deep dive into gaming
PPTX
Integrating SAPUI5 with ArcGIS Maps (Leon van Ginneken)
PPTX
Esri UK - Annual Conference 2016 Transport for london
PPTX
OGA - Esri UK Annual Conference 2016
PPTX
Forestry Commission - Smart Collaboration - Esri UK Annual Conference 2017
PDF
Netbiscuits - CareerOneStop Infographic
PPTX
HERE - Esri UK Annual Conference 2016
PDF
The global API Ecosystem: A deep dive into gaming
Integrating SAPUI5 with ArcGIS Maps (Leon van Ginneken)
Esri UK - Annual Conference 2016 Transport for london
OGA - Esri UK Annual Conference 2016
Forestry Commission - Smart Collaboration - Esri UK Annual Conference 2017
Netbiscuits - CareerOneStop Infographic
HERE - Esri UK Annual Conference 2016

Viewers also liked (6)

PPTX
BANKING API AND API ECOSYSTEM
PDF
Banking APIとAPIエコシステム
PDF
プラットフォームエコノミーの将来
PPTX
金融業界におけるAPIエコノミー / Fintech meetup / IBM
PPTX
Creating a Digital Supply Chain: Monsanto's Journey
PDF
Platform Economy - Tech Vision 2016 Trend 3
BANKING API AND API ECOSYSTEM
Banking APIとAPIエコシステム
プラットフォームエコノミーの将来
金融業界におけるAPIエコノミー / Fintech meetup / IBM
Creating a Digital Supply Chain: Monsanto's Journey
Platform Economy - Tech Vision 2016 Trend 3
Ad

Similar to Visualizing the Geography of Platform Boundary Resources (20)

PDF
Visualizing the Maturing Global API Ecosystem
PDF
apidays Helsinki & North 2023 - Business-oriented API products with APIOps Cy...
PDF
Navigating-the-API-Ecosystem-Strategies-for-Effective-Management-in-the-Banki...
PPTX
API economy
 
PDF
The Business of APIs 2009 - ProgrammableWeb.com
PDF
Open Ap Is State Of The Market
PPTX
Era of APIs: Why do we need an API Strategy
PPT
API Management and Community Development layer 7 in london 2012
PDF
Introduction to The 6 Insights of API Practice (Bill Doerrfeld)
PDF
APIdays Zurich 2019 - Digital Ecosystems, fueled by APIs Matthias Biehl, API ...
PPTX
INTERFACE, by apidays - Design for your API customers with APIOps Cycles by ...
PDF
apidays LIVE Hong Kong 2021 - Planning Your Steps to Data Economy Using APIOp...
PPTX
APIs + Business Models = New Ecosystems - APIdays Paris 2019
PPTX
APIdays Paris 2019 - APIs + Business Models = New Ecosystem? by Marjukka Nii...
PDF
Introduction to the Art of API Practice
PDF
Web APIs - Infrastructure for the (Intelligent) Programmable Web (R&D Talk)
PPTX
Changing the Face of Transport via APIs. Talk at APIDays Paris 2014
PPTX
Reaching 1 Million APIs and what to do when we get there
PPTX
The Hitch Pitch Deck
PPTX
A mercantile api economy jw
Visualizing the Maturing Global API Ecosystem
apidays Helsinki & North 2023 - Business-oriented API products with APIOps Cy...
Navigating-the-API-Ecosystem-Strategies-for-Effective-Management-in-the-Banki...
API economy
 
The Business of APIs 2009 - ProgrammableWeb.com
Open Ap Is State Of The Market
Era of APIs: Why do we need an API Strategy
API Management and Community Development layer 7 in london 2012
Introduction to The 6 Insights of API Practice (Bill Doerrfeld)
APIdays Zurich 2019 - Digital Ecosystems, fueled by APIs Matthias Biehl, API ...
INTERFACE, by apidays - Design for your API customers with APIOps Cycles by ...
apidays LIVE Hong Kong 2021 - Planning Your Steps to Data Economy Using APIOp...
APIs + Business Models = New Ecosystems - APIdays Paris 2019
APIdays Paris 2019 - APIs + Business Models = New Ecosystem? by Marjukka Nii...
Introduction to the Art of API Practice
Web APIs - Infrastructure for the (Intelligent) Programmable Web (R&D Talk)
Changing the Face of Transport via APIs. Talk at APIDays Paris 2014
Reaching 1 Million APIs and what to do when we get there
The Hitch Pitch Deck
A mercantile api economy jw
Ad

More from Jukka Huhtamäki (20)

PPTX
Datavisualisoinnin perusteet – käytännönläheinen johdanto
PPTX
Diversity Exposure in Social Recommender Systems: A Social Capital Theory Pe...
PPTX
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
PPTX
Kevyet lähdöt – case Twitter | Data-analytiikka liiketoiminnan kehittämisessä
PPTX
Organizational Hybridity and Fluidity: Possibilities and Challenges for Knowl...
PPTX
Making sense of big data with the Ostinato Model
PPTX
Mikä ekosysteemitutkimuksessa kiinnostaa juuri nyt?
PPTX
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
PPTX
Katsaus API-talouteen | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan: tapaus Twitter
PPTX
Five viewpoints to visualization
PPTX
Lean Startup ja datalla ohjattu kehitystyö
PPTX
Johdanto API-talouteen
PPTX
Katsaus API-talouteen 2017
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä -johdanto
PPTX
Exploring platform boundary resources with a data-driven approach
PPTX
API-talous ja liiketoimintatiedon hallinta 2017
PPTX
Miten yritysverkostoja voi analysoida - ja miksi?
PPTX
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan
Datavisualisoinnin perusteet – käytännönläheinen johdanto
Diversity Exposure in Social Recommender Systems: A Social Capital Theory Pe...
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
Kevyet lähdöt – case Twitter | Data-analytiikka liiketoiminnan kehittämisessä
Organizational Hybridity and Fluidity: Possibilities and Challenges for Knowl...
Making sense of big data with the Ostinato Model
Mikä ekosysteemitutkimuksessa kiinnostaa juuri nyt?
Sosiaalisen median analysointi ja dokumenttipohjainen tutkimus
Katsaus API-talouteen | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan | Edutech Pilviasiantuntija 2018
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan: tapaus Twitter
Five viewpoints to visualization
Lean Startup ja datalla ohjattu kehitystyö
Johdanto API-talouteen
Katsaus API-talouteen 2017
Kevyitä lähtöjä -johdanto
Exploring platform boundary resources with a data-driven approach
API-talous ja liiketoimintatiedon hallinta 2017
Miten yritysverkostoja voi analysoida - ja miksi?
Kevyitä lähtöjä data-analytiikkaan

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
chuitkarjhanbijunsdivndsijvndiucbhsaxnmzsicvjsd
DOCX
Factor Analysis Word Document Presentation
PPT
statistic analysis for study - data collection
PDF
OneRead_20250728_1808.pdfhdhddhshahwhwwjjaaja
PDF
Systems Analysis and Design, 12th Edition by Scott Tilley Test Bank.pdf
PDF
CS3352FOUNDATION OF DATA SCIENCE _1_MAterial.pdf
PDF
©️ 02_SKU Automatic SW Robotics for Microsoft PC.pdf
PPTX
CYBER SECURITY the Next Warefare Tactics
PDF
Best Data Science Professional Certificates in the USA | IABAC
PPTX
Phase1_final PPTuwhefoegfohwfoiehfoegg.pptx
PPT
statistics analysis - topic 3 - describing data visually
PDF
Tetra Pak Index 2023 - The future of health and nutrition - Full report.pdf
PPT
PROJECT CYCLE MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK (PCM).ppt
PPTX
Machine Learning and working of machine Learning
PPTX
MBA JAPAN: 2025 the University of Waseda
PDF
Navigating the Thai Supplements Landscape.pdf
PPTX
Crypto_Trading_Beginners.pptxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
PDF
A biomechanical Functional analysis of the masitary muscles in man
PPT
lectureusjsjdhdsjjshdshshddhdhddhhd1.ppt
PDF
Global Data and Analytics Market Outlook Report
chuitkarjhanbijunsdivndsijvndiucbhsaxnmzsicvjsd
Factor Analysis Word Document Presentation
statistic analysis for study - data collection
OneRead_20250728_1808.pdfhdhddhshahwhwwjjaaja
Systems Analysis and Design, 12th Edition by Scott Tilley Test Bank.pdf
CS3352FOUNDATION OF DATA SCIENCE _1_MAterial.pdf
©️ 02_SKU Automatic SW Robotics for Microsoft PC.pdf
CYBER SECURITY the Next Warefare Tactics
Best Data Science Professional Certificates in the USA | IABAC
Phase1_final PPTuwhefoegfohwfoiehfoegg.pptx
statistics analysis - topic 3 - describing data visually
Tetra Pak Index 2023 - The future of health and nutrition - Full report.pdf
PROJECT CYCLE MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK (PCM).ppt
Machine Learning and working of machine Learning
MBA JAPAN: 2025 the University of Waseda
Navigating the Thai Supplements Landscape.pdf
Crypto_Trading_Beginners.pptxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
A biomechanical Functional analysis of the masitary muscles in man
lectureusjsjdhdsjjshdshshddhdhddhhd1.ppt
Global Data and Analytics Market Outlook Report

Visualizing the Geography of Platform Boundary Resources

  • 1. Visualizing the Geography of Platform Boundary Resources: The Case of the Global API Ecosystem Jukka Huhtamäki Rahul C. Basole Kaisa Still Martha G. Russell Marko Seppänen http://bit.ly/apiglobal2017preso http://bit.ly/apiglobal2017paper
  • 3. Why APIs? • APIs are replacing “traditional” interfirm relationships • APIs are lightweight boundary resources that allow for complementors to create value for the focal companies • APIs are artifacts of both lightweight software development and business strategy6.1.2017 4
  • 4. API vs. platform economy 6.1.2017 6
  • 8. 6.1.2017 10 (Evans and Basole, 2016; Basole, 2016)
  • 9. 6.1.2017 11 (Evans and Basole, 2016; Basole, 2016)
  • 10. Why Geography? • Digitization is eliminating “distance” and therefore one can assume that geography would have a smaller role • At the same time, we see that large companies continue to be co-located 6.1.2017 12
  • 11. We asked • Where are APIs located geographically*? • Is the geographical location of a company less important in the digital age? 6.1.2017 13
  • 12. Method • Data collection using crawling and scraping • Data-driven visual network analytics • Semi-automated data curation process 6.1.2017 14
  • 14. Data curation • 13,366 APIs and 6,271 mashups from ProgrammableWeb • Using URIs as identifiers, company location lookup using Crunchbase • Mapping the 6,218 APIs with location data to city-level entrepreneurial regions and global regions 6.1.2017 16
  • 15. Results–two levels of analysis 1. Where are the APIs available globally? 2. How are APIs co-used between regions?
  • 17. API Co-use • Cf. co-citation analysis Three resulting connections (here regions): Twitter - Twitter Search Twitter - Google App Engine Twitter Search - Google App Engine
  • 18. 6.1.2017 20 Regions connected on basis of API co-use
  • 19. 6.1.2017 21 Regions connected on basis of API co-use
  • 21. Takeaways • API ecosystem is highly concentrated to a few regions • API ecosystem is particularly flexible for actors to offer and consume services • API co-use is not API usage • Public APIs vs. Private APIs
  • 22. Future work • Investigating the internal company-level network structure of entrepreneurial regions • Introducing dynamics to the analysis: API diffusion studies • How policy makers can facilitate the emergence of national and e.g. European API ecosystem? • How will the changes in international data governance policy impact the API ecosystem? 6.1.2017 24

Editor's Notes

  • #25: Comments (MR): Shared mindset, network connections for need identification and development Access to customers, market, deals Financing perspectives Implications for further study – national security and data management policies