SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Strengthening Planning Capacity for Low-
    Carbon Growth in Developing Asia
                TA-7645

                Tools to Help
    Transiting to a Low Carbon Economy



        INDONESIA LOW CARBON DEVELOPMENT FORUM
         11 – 12 October, 2012 Jakarta, Indonesia
Green Growth




Involves agreeing on many cross-sector adaptation and
mitigation measures
Is about generating an enabling environment (reinforced
development planning, new policies, new markets)
Green Growth is first and foremost about
Development
Needs to value all of the benefits:
GHG Mitigation            Climate Resilience
Energy Security           Economic growth and stability
Trade Balance             Job creation and skill sets
Inflation                 Quality of Life, etc

And reach consensus amongst multiple stakeholders:
Investment priorities and amounts
Enabling policies, etc
To EFFECT Low Carbon Development
      Several tools are required to
       answer different questions

                             Top-down
                           Impact on
                           Economic growth,
Abatement opportunities    Employment,
Technologies               Trade,
Investments                Production choices, etc.
Additional costs


 Bottom-up
Model suite for low carbon growth assessment


                    World Induced Technical Change Hybrid
      WITCH         Integrated Assessment model



                    Recursive dynamic CGE multicountry-
   ICES             multisector model with international
                    trade


                    Energy Forecasting Framework and
      EFFECT        Emissions Consensus Tool
What is EFFECT?



• Developed by the World Bank originally for the
     India Low Carbon Growth Planning Study
• Excel-based, bottom-up, engineering style model
• Supports consensus building and planning in key
  sectors of the economy
• Helps assess the impact of policy choices on GHG
  emission levels
Ribbon-based navigation, analysis and help
Easy to understand, adaptable, modifiable
Used previously by the World Bank and others in
many countries and cities
Power Sector
   – India, Nigeria

Transport
    – 9 Cities and 7 countries:
        Bangkok, Beijing, Chengdu, Guangzhou, Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh City, Jakarta,
          Manila, Ulaanbaatar
        India, Brazil ,Poland, Macedonia, Georgia, Nigeria,
        Basis for CTF measurement methodology

Household electricity
   – India, Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam, Macedonia

Nonresidential and Industry
   – India, Macedonia
Current modules




  Land Transport        Power      Industry




Household Electricity           Non-residential
EFFECT has been extensively customized by ADB
specifically for this regional TA

• Modeling period extended to 2050
• CO2 emissions factors and Net Calorific Values now comply
  with the 2006 IPCC Guidelines
• Contains 45 technologies for power generation
• New Investment Learning Curve Effect
• Includes process and project contingencies
• New MAC Curve drawing utility and results summary
• Major improvement to vintaging calculations on all appliances
• Additional Appliances and major changes to lighting energy
  forecasts
• etc
How will EFFECT be used in TA-7645?
Strengthening Planning Capacity for Low-Carbon Growth in Developing Asia

Work with Country Experts and Counterparts with:

1 Objective:
Facilitate transition towards low-carbon development

2 Scenarios:
Develop a “business-as-usual” reference scenario 2010-2050
and low-carbon scenario taking into account suitable technology options in
the sectors
Feed into the CGE modeling effort

3 Sectors:
Household Electricity consumption, Land Transport, Power Generation

5 countries:
Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam
Objective: Facilitate transition towards low-
carbon development
 development and application of country-specific low-carbon
  growth modeling framework that is transparent, flexible, and
  user-friendly
 analysis to help create/update low-carbon roadmaps and
  provide input to development plans based on the framework
 training sessions and hands-on computer workshops to
  enhance the capacity of relevant agencies/institutions to
  maintain and utilize the models and associated database for
  planning purposes
 serve as a platform for experience sharing,
       policy dialogue and cooperation
Current Status with Indonesia
Transport,
Household electricity consumption,
Power generation
Modules are customized for Indonesia and already
populated with initial baseline data for analysis and
discussion


Training underway
1st Workshop in Bangkok (March 2012)
2nd Workshop in Jakarta (Oct 11-12, 2012)
To be EFFECTive this exercise needs strong local
commitment on Data and Assumptions

Bottom-up modeling requires a lot of micro-level data
To be useful, the data must be :
    Detailed and good quality
    Country-specific
    Freely sharable
    Recent and regularly updated
    Final Goal: to be managed by the country in a data
      system

  This is a rigorous exercise that will help set the stage for
  measuring future achievements
Next Steps

Close involvement with local counterparts to:
1. Agree on historic data and cross-country
    comparisons used
2. Agree specific additional data needs and define
    data collection plans
3. Agree on assumptions to be used to 2050
4. Further training
5. Possible uptake of the EFFECT model by a local
    institution
Thank You




            John Rogers
            jar@tstes.com

More Related Content

PPTX
Regulatory Innovation in the Heartland: Electricity for the 21st century
PDF
CCXG Global Forum March 2018, Financing Climate Futures – Rethinking Infrastr...
PDF
ResidentialCleanEnergyRoundtable-Presentation_11-14-14
PPS
Koshy Cherail - AEEE
PPTX
ABB - Sustainable Procurement by Philip Juneau at GIB Summit
PDF
A snapshot of sustainable strategy integration by ge, ibm, toyota & du pont
PPTX
IRENA’s Power Generation Cost Analysis and Geothermal Power
PDF
Climate Change & Good Governance, Wednesday 17 November 2021
Regulatory Innovation in the Heartland: Electricity for the 21st century
CCXG Global Forum March 2018, Financing Climate Futures – Rethinking Infrastr...
ResidentialCleanEnergyRoundtable-Presentation_11-14-14
Koshy Cherail - AEEE
ABB - Sustainable Procurement by Philip Juneau at GIB Summit
A snapshot of sustainable strategy integration by ge, ibm, toyota & du pont
IRENA’s Power Generation Cost Analysis and Geothermal Power
Climate Change & Good Governance, Wednesday 17 November 2021

What's hot (17)

PPTX
Digital artifact financing for development
PDF
CEFI Roadmap Overview: John Dulac & Poonam Sandhu
PDF
Communicating Sustainability
PPTX
How project managers influence sustainable development.
PDF
Energy efficiency project financing in india
PPTX
ICBF 2015 PPT Julius
PDF
Industrial briefing state and utility partnerships - nicol
PPTX
Digital government in developing countries
PDF
Crittenden_Delhi_India_25Feb15
PDF
SMART International Symposium for Next Generation Infrastructure: Macroeconom...
PDF
Circular Economy Center: Creating a General Concept for Circular Economy Cons...
PPTX
IISD Performance Based Specifications in Public Procurement by Laura Turley a...
PPTX
Diffusion and adoption of innovation: International perspectives on theory an...
PPT
ICBC - The Practice of Green Credit in ICBC by Hong Yin at GIB Summit
PPTX
What is the role for Public-Private Partnerships? Delivering on the Post-2015...
PDF
Session 4.4. reyer gerlagh tilburg university
Digital artifact financing for development
CEFI Roadmap Overview: John Dulac & Poonam Sandhu
Communicating Sustainability
How project managers influence sustainable development.
Energy efficiency project financing in india
ICBF 2015 PPT Julius
Industrial briefing state and utility partnerships - nicol
Digital government in developing countries
Crittenden_Delhi_India_25Feb15
SMART International Symposium for Next Generation Infrastructure: Macroeconom...
Circular Economy Center: Creating a General Concept for Circular Economy Cons...
IISD Performance Based Specifications in Public Procurement by Laura Turley a...
Diffusion and adoption of innovation: International perspectives on theory an...
ICBC - The Practice of Green Credit in ICBC by Hong Yin at GIB Summit
What is the role for Public-Private Partnerships? Delivering on the Post-2015...
Session 4.4. reyer gerlagh tilburg university
Ad

Viewers also liked (17)

DOCX
Family mediation
DOCX
Social studies vocabulary
DOC
Ativ1 5 rita
PPT
資訊教室使用需知 990206
DOCX
GAUTAM MURTHY-BOOK LAUNCH BY PRESIDENT OF INDIA
POT
DOC
DIADEMA FLOR BOTÓN ZIG-ZAG
PPTX
los tipos de vigilancia epidimiologia
PDF
World Investment Report 2015 of UNITED NATIONS from UNCTAD
PPT
Gloucestershire College BTEC Level 4 Higher National Certificate in Construct...
PDF
Leonardo Corporate Presentation 11 05 2016
PDF
Mit Conversion Tracking zum Facebook ROI @ AllFacebook Marketing Conference
PDF
Social SEO mit der Facebook Backdoor @ AllFacebook Marketing Conference
PPT
Gloucestershire College Level 3 Construction and the Built Environment Handbo...
PPTX
Symbolism in "Scarlet Letter"
PPTX
Firmenppt_gesamt_master_LinkedIn
Family mediation
Social studies vocabulary
Ativ1 5 rita
資訊教室使用需知 990206
GAUTAM MURTHY-BOOK LAUNCH BY PRESIDENT OF INDIA
DIADEMA FLOR BOTÓN ZIG-ZAG
los tipos de vigilancia epidimiologia
World Investment Report 2015 of UNITED NATIONS from UNCTAD
Gloucestershire College BTEC Level 4 Higher National Certificate in Construct...
Leonardo Corporate Presentation 11 05 2016
Mit Conversion Tracking zum Facebook ROI @ AllFacebook Marketing Conference
Social SEO mit der Facebook Backdoor @ AllFacebook Marketing Conference
Gloucestershire College Level 3 Construction and the Built Environment Handbo...
Symbolism in "Scarlet Letter"
Firmenppt_gesamt_master_LinkedIn
Ad

Similar to Intoduction to E F F E C T (20)

PDF
Integrating development into the global climate regime
PPTX
Global Climate Leadership Review 2012
PPTX
Transition to low emission development
PDF
Steckel daad 271112_v02
PDF
Climate mitigation and energy challenge
PDF
Combined use of TIMES and CGE models to explore methodological issues related...
PPTX
Low emission strategy dc zagreb_2012
PDF
2nd Energy Efficiency Finance and Investment Forum - Global context and polic...
PPTX
Climate Change and Development - Updates from COP18
PPT
090112 Low Carbon Innovation Tour 2009
DOCX
STS TERM PAPER
PDF
The Cap And Trade Program
PDF
ICT and sustainable Cities
PDF
Business out of Climate Change
PDF
Modeling and Data-Analysis in Developing Long-Term Low-Emission Development S...
PDF
Dr. Madan Lall Shrestha
PPT
Diana Liverman Plenary Speaker 12 March2009
PDF
IChemE Energy Centre report - Transitions in electricity systems towards 2030...
PDF
Advances In Low Carbon Technologies And Transition Shigemi Kagawa
PDF
CCXG Global Forum March 2018, Transparency of reporting in technology support...
Integrating development into the global climate regime
Global Climate Leadership Review 2012
Transition to low emission development
Steckel daad 271112_v02
Climate mitigation and energy challenge
Combined use of TIMES and CGE models to explore methodological issues related...
Low emission strategy dc zagreb_2012
2nd Energy Efficiency Finance and Investment Forum - Global context and polic...
Climate Change and Development - Updates from COP18
090112 Low Carbon Innovation Tour 2009
STS TERM PAPER
The Cap And Trade Program
ICT and sustainable Cities
Business out of Climate Change
Modeling and Data-Analysis in Developing Long-Term Low-Emission Development S...
Dr. Madan Lall Shrestha
Diana Liverman Plenary Speaker 12 March2009
IChemE Energy Centre report - Transitions in electricity systems towards 2030...
Advances In Low Carbon Technologies And Transition Shigemi Kagawa
CCXG Global Forum March 2018, Transparency of reporting in technology support...

More from Ira Tobing (20)

PDF
Integrating developing countries’ SMEs into Global Value Chain.
PDF
Regional and bilateral trade agreement
PDF
Negotiations
PDF
The Doha Round
PDF
UNCTAD and the post 2015 agenda -
PDF
Assessing the evolution of the international trading system and enhancing its...
PDF
International cooperation and development: a conceptual overview
PDF
Supply Chain Perspectives and Issues: A Literature Review
PDF
Non-Tariff Measures - A Fresh Look at Trade Policy's New Frontier
PDF
FTA policy and strategy
PDF
Beyond 2015
PDF
Coalition proofness in a class of games with strategic substitutes
PDF
Dr. Andrea Goldstein - Industrial Cluster in the Global Economy
PDF
Patacconi perspectives from international organization and private sectors ...
PDF
Dr.Andrea Goldstein - Developing Industrial Cluster and The Role of Investment
PDF
Investment promotion handbook for diplomat
PDF
Introduction to Climate Change
PDF
Negotiation
PDF
Communicating financial information
PDF
Nonverbal communication
Integrating developing countries’ SMEs into Global Value Chain.
Regional and bilateral trade agreement
Negotiations
The Doha Round
UNCTAD and the post 2015 agenda -
Assessing the evolution of the international trading system and enhancing its...
International cooperation and development: a conceptual overview
Supply Chain Perspectives and Issues: A Literature Review
Non-Tariff Measures - A Fresh Look at Trade Policy's New Frontier
FTA policy and strategy
Beyond 2015
Coalition proofness in a class of games with strategic substitutes
Dr. Andrea Goldstein - Industrial Cluster in the Global Economy
Patacconi perspectives from international organization and private sectors ...
Dr.Andrea Goldstein - Developing Industrial Cluster and The Role of Investment
Investment promotion handbook for diplomat
Introduction to Climate Change
Negotiation
Communicating financial information
Nonverbal communication

Intoduction to E F F E C T

  • 1. Strengthening Planning Capacity for Low- Carbon Growth in Developing Asia TA-7645 Tools to Help Transiting to a Low Carbon Economy INDONESIA LOW CARBON DEVELOPMENT FORUM 11 – 12 October, 2012 Jakarta, Indonesia
  • 2. Green Growth Involves agreeing on many cross-sector adaptation and mitigation measures Is about generating an enabling environment (reinforced development planning, new policies, new markets)
  • 3. Green Growth is first and foremost about Development Needs to value all of the benefits: GHG Mitigation Climate Resilience Energy Security Economic growth and stability Trade Balance Job creation and skill sets Inflation Quality of Life, etc And reach consensus amongst multiple stakeholders: Investment priorities and amounts Enabling policies, etc
  • 4. To EFFECT Low Carbon Development Several tools are required to answer different questions Top-down Impact on Economic growth, Abatement opportunities Employment, Technologies Trade, Investments Production choices, etc. Additional costs Bottom-up
  • 5. Model suite for low carbon growth assessment World Induced Technical Change Hybrid WITCH Integrated Assessment model Recursive dynamic CGE multicountry- ICES multisector model with international trade Energy Forecasting Framework and EFFECT Emissions Consensus Tool
  • 6. What is EFFECT? • Developed by the World Bank originally for the India Low Carbon Growth Planning Study • Excel-based, bottom-up, engineering style model • Supports consensus building and planning in key sectors of the economy • Helps assess the impact of policy choices on GHG emission levels
  • 8. Easy to understand, adaptable, modifiable
  • 9. Used previously by the World Bank and others in many countries and cities Power Sector – India, Nigeria Transport – 9 Cities and 7 countries: Bangkok, Beijing, Chengdu, Guangzhou, Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh City, Jakarta, Manila, Ulaanbaatar India, Brazil ,Poland, Macedonia, Georgia, Nigeria, Basis for CTF measurement methodology Household electricity – India, Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam, Macedonia Nonresidential and Industry – India, Macedonia
  • 10. Current modules Land Transport Power Industry Household Electricity Non-residential
  • 11. EFFECT has been extensively customized by ADB specifically for this regional TA • Modeling period extended to 2050 • CO2 emissions factors and Net Calorific Values now comply with the 2006 IPCC Guidelines • Contains 45 technologies for power generation • New Investment Learning Curve Effect • Includes process and project contingencies • New MAC Curve drawing utility and results summary • Major improvement to vintaging calculations on all appliances • Additional Appliances and major changes to lighting energy forecasts • etc
  • 12. How will EFFECT be used in TA-7645? Strengthening Planning Capacity for Low-Carbon Growth in Developing Asia Work with Country Experts and Counterparts with: 1 Objective: Facilitate transition towards low-carbon development 2 Scenarios: Develop a “business-as-usual” reference scenario 2010-2050 and low-carbon scenario taking into account suitable technology options in the sectors Feed into the CGE modeling effort 3 Sectors: Household Electricity consumption, Land Transport, Power Generation 5 countries: Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam
  • 13. Objective: Facilitate transition towards low- carbon development  development and application of country-specific low-carbon growth modeling framework that is transparent, flexible, and user-friendly  analysis to help create/update low-carbon roadmaps and provide input to development plans based on the framework  training sessions and hands-on computer workshops to enhance the capacity of relevant agencies/institutions to maintain and utilize the models and associated database for planning purposes  serve as a platform for experience sharing, policy dialogue and cooperation
  • 14. Current Status with Indonesia Transport, Household electricity consumption, Power generation Modules are customized for Indonesia and already populated with initial baseline data for analysis and discussion Training underway 1st Workshop in Bangkok (March 2012) 2nd Workshop in Jakarta (Oct 11-12, 2012)
  • 15. To be EFFECTive this exercise needs strong local commitment on Data and Assumptions Bottom-up modeling requires a lot of micro-level data To be useful, the data must be :  Detailed and good quality  Country-specific  Freely sharable  Recent and regularly updated  Final Goal: to be managed by the country in a data system This is a rigorous exercise that will help set the stage for measuring future achievements
  • 16. Next Steps Close involvement with local counterparts to: 1. Agree on historic data and cross-country comparisons used 2. Agree specific additional data needs and define data collection plans 3. Agree on assumptions to be used to 2050 4. Further training 5. Possible uptake of the EFFECT model by a local institution
  • 17. Thank You John Rogers jar@tstes.com