1. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Epithermal High-sulphidation Gold Deposits:
Epithermal High-sulphidation Gold Deposits:
Characteristics, related ore types, and exploration
Characteristics, related ore types, and exploration
Jeffrey W. Hedenquist
Jeffrey W. Hedenquist
Colorado School of Mines
Colorado School of Mines
&
&
Consulting Economic Geologist, Ottawa
Consulting Economic Geologist, Ottawa
Hedenquist@aol.com
Hedenquist@aol.com
BCYCM Roundup 2003
2. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Epithermal High-sulphidation Gold Deposits:
Epithermal High-sulphidation Gold Deposits:
Characteristics, related ore types, and exploration
Characteristics, related ore types, and exploration
Acknowledgements:
Acknowledgements:
Antonio Arribas R. , Placer Dome
Antonio Arribas R. , Placer Dome
Marco T. Einaudi & E. Esra Inan , Stanford Univ.
Marco T. Einaudi & E. Esra Inan , Stanford Univ.
Richard H. Sillitoe , London & David John , USGS
Richard H. Sillitoe , London & David John , USGS
BCYCM Roundup 2003
3. Research applied to mineral
exploration
White Island, NZ: 300 t Au flux to atmosphere over life of ~10,000 yrs
Terminology
Terminology
Importance and size
Importance and size
Principal characteristics
Principal characteristics
Origin of features, background
Origin of features, background
Case examples
Case examples
Exploration implications
Exploration implications
HS epithermal deposits:
Outline
4. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Epithermal types:
Epithermal types: Alternative terminology
Alternative terminology
Largely synonymous
Largely synonymous
Type 1 Type 2 Type 3
• Goldfield type, Au-al, 2nd qtzite
Goldfield type, Au-al, 2nd qtzite Ag-bms veins
Ag-bms veins Gold (Te, Se)-qtz veins
Gold (Te, Se)-qtz veins 1906-33
1906-33
• Acid epithermal
Acid epithermal Alkaline epithermal
Alkaline epithermal 1977
1977
• - - - - Epithermal - - - - -
- - - - Epithermal - - - - - 1981
1981
• Au-enargite
Au-enargite Hot spring
Hot spring 1982
1982
• Acid sulfate, high sulfur, al-kaol
Acid sulfate, high sulfur, al-kaol Adularia-sericite, low sulfur
Adularia-sericite, low sulfur 1986-89
1986-89
• High sulfidation
High sulfidation Low sulfidation
Low sulfidation 1987
1987
• High sulfidation
High sulfidation High sulfide/bms,
High sulfide/bms, Low sulfide/bms,
Low sulfide/bms, 1989-94
1989-94
Type 1 ad-ser,
Type 1 ad-ser, Type 2 ad-ser
Type 2 ad-ser
Carbonate-bms-Au
Carbonate-bms-Au
• High sulfidation
High sulfidation Western andesite
Western andesite Bimodal basalt-rhyolite
Bimodal basalt-rhyolite 1999, 01
1999, 01
• High sulfidation
High sulfidation (HS)
(HS) Intermediate
Intermediate (IS)
(IS) Low sulfidation
Low sulfidation (LS)
(LS) 2000, 03
2000, 03
– Lithocap (barren)
Lithocap (barren)
Ransome, Emmons, Lindgren, Nakovnik, Sillitoe, Buchanan, Ashley, Giles et al., Bonham,
Ransome, Emmons, Lindgren, Nakovnik, Sillitoe, Buchanan, Ashley, Giles et al., Bonham,
Bethke, Heald et al., Berger, Albino et al., Leach et al., John, Hedenquist et al., Einaudi et al.
Bethke, Heald et al., Berger, Albino et al., Leach et al., John, Hedenquist et al., Einaudi et al.
5. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Ore-deposit styles: Relative amounts of gold
Ore-deposit styles: Relative amounts of gold
(>5 Moz deposits, 1997)
(>5 Moz deposits, 1997)
50%
50% Witwatersrand
Witwatersrand
12%
12% Epithermal
Epithermal
10%
10% Porphyry (+ intrusion hosted)
Porphyry (+ intrusion hosted)
12%
12% Sediment hosted (incl. 4% “Carlin”)
Sediment hosted (incl. 4% “Carlin”)
9%
9% Greenstone lode (“orogenic”)
Greenstone lode (“orogenic”)
7%
7% Other (Fe Fm, VHMS, etc.)
Other (Fe Fm, VHMS, etc.)
>40% (non Wits) gold from intrusion-centered
>40% (non Wits) gold from intrusion-centered
deposits, ~1/4 from epithermal (>5 Moz Au)
deposits, ~1/4 from epithermal (>5 Moz Au)
Arribas, UBC, March 2000
Arribas, UBC, March 2000
7. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Types of epithermal deposits
Types of epithermal deposits
3 endmember types
3 endmember types
HS bodies:
HS bodies: Cu-Au-As, sulfide rich, andesite arcs
Cu-Au-As, sulfide rich, andesite arcs
– Barren lithocaps:
Barren lithocaps: advanced argillic zones over porphyry systems
advanced argillic zones over porphyry systems
IS veins:
IS veins: Ag-Au ± Zn-Pb, sulfide rich, andesite arcs
Ag-Au ± Zn-Pb, sulfide rich, andesite arcs
– Wide variation in metal complement, but continuum
Wide variation in metal complement, but continuum
LS veins:
LS veins: Au-Ag bonanzas, sulfide poor, bimodal setting
Au-Ag bonanzas, sulfide poor, bimodal setting
– LS veins:
LS veins: Au-Ag-Te, sulfide poor, alkalic association
Au-Ag-Te, sulfide poor, alkalic association
HS and IS appear related
HS and IS appear related
9. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Examples of epithermal deposits
Examples of epithermal deposits
HS replacements:
HS replacements: Goldfield, Summitville, Sauzal, Mulatos,
Goldfield, Summitville, Sauzal, Mulatos,
Pueblo Viejo, Yanacocha, Pierina, Alto Chicama, El Indio, La Coipa,
Pueblo Viejo, Yanacocha, Pierina, Alto Chicama, El Indio, La Coipa,
Pascua-Veradero, Lepanto, Chelopech, Bor
Pascua-Veradero, Lepanto, Chelopech, Bor
– Barren lithocaps:
Barren lithocaps: common, W. US, Andes, Asia, etc.
common, W. US, Andes, Asia, etc.
IS veins:
IS veins: Comstock, Creede, Mexican Ag, Perú bms, ABCD of
Comstock, Creede, Mexican Ag, Perú bms, ABCD of
eastern Tethys, Philippines (Victoria & Baguio)
eastern Tethys, Philippines (Victoria & Baguio)
LS veins:
LS veins: Midas, Sleeper, El Peñón, Esquel, Hishikari
Midas, Sleeper, El Peñón, Esquel, Hishikari
– LS veins, alkalic:
LS veins, alkalic: Cripple Creek, Emperor, Porgera, Ladolam
Cripple Creek, Emperor, Porgera, Ladolam
10. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Location of principal epithermal deposits
Location of principal epithermal deposits
11. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Geologic setting of HS (and IS) deposits
Geologic setting of HS (and IS) deposits
Circum Pacific, 43 deposits
Circum Pacific, 43 deposits
Neutral - mild extension, calc-alkaline andesite-dacite arcs
Neutral - mild extension, calc-alkaline andesite-dacite arcs
22
22 Volcanic domes
Volcanic domes (single, complex, summit; not host)
(single, complex, summit; not host)
12
12 Central vent volcanoes
Central vent volcanoes (including IS)
(including IS)
3
3 Calderas
Calderas
3
3 Diatremes
Diatremes
10
10 Insufficient information
Insufficient information
Hosts: A/D flows, bxs, ignimbrites, intrusions, seds
Hosts: A/D flows, bxs, ignimbrites, intrusions, seds
LS deposits: Bimodal (rhyolite domes--basalt dikes) in extensional settings:
LS deposits: Bimodal (rhyolite domes--basalt dikes) in extensional settings:
Intra, near, and backarc; postcollision rifts (non porphyry)
Intra, near, and backarc; postcollision rifts (non porphyry)
Arribas, 1995; White et al., 1995, Sillitoe, 1999
Arribas, 1995; White et al., 1995, Sillitoe, 1999
12. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Sillitoe and Hedenquist, 2003
Schematic relations: HS and IS epithermal deposits
and porphyry systems
13. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Epithermal alteration, gangue minerals
Epithermal alteration, gangue minerals
HS replacements:
HS replacements: silicic host, alunite, barite, anhydrite
silicic host, alunite, barite, anhydrite
– Barren lithocaps:
Barren lithocaps: silicic core, quartz-alunite halo
silicic core, quartz-alunite halo
IS veins:
IS veins: quartz, sericite, rhodochrosite, barite, anhydrite
quartz, sericite, rhodochrosite, barite, anhydrite
LS veins:
LS veins: chalcedony, adularia with illite, calcite (roscoelite)
chalcedony, adularia with illite, calcite (roscoelite)
14. Research applied to mineral
exploration
HS and IS deposits: sulfide assemblages
HS and IS deposits: sulfide assemblages
HS replacements:
HS replacements: Cu-Au-Ag
Cu-Au-Ag
– Initial leaching, vuggy qtz-py
Initial leaching, vuggy qtz-py
– Early py–enargite–lz-fm
Early py–enargite–lz-fm
– Late Au–
Late Au–py–low-Fe sph– tn/td–
py–low-Fe sph– tn/td–
ccp–gn, ± Te-Bi-Sn
ccp–gn, ± Te-Bi-Sn
IS veins:
IS veins: Ag–Au ± Pb–Zn
Ag–Au ± Pb–Zn
– Py–low-Fe sph–tn/td–ccp–gn,
Py–low-Fe sph–tn/td–ccp–gn, ±
±
Te
Te
HS-IS vs LS distinction related to
HS-IS vs LS distinction related to
volcanotectonic setting
volcanotectonic setting
Barton et al., 1977, John, 2001,
Barton et al., 1977, John, 2001, Einaudi
Einaudi
et al., 2003, others
et al., 2003, others
15. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Einaudi, Hedenquist and Inan, 2003
Sulfidation states
Sulfidation states
17. Research applied to mineral
exploration
LS deposits
HS deposits
Hedenquist et al., 1996
18. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Steam-heated acid sulfate waters
Steam-heated acid sulfate waters
19. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Sillitoe, 1993
LS settings only
Lithocap (± HS) settings only
(steam-heated blanket possible)
Any sulfide-rich setting
Steam-heated waters,
LS, IS, HS possible
(HCl, SO2)
3 types only !
20. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Lewis-Crofoot, NV:
Lewis-Crofoot, NV: LS veins, steam-heated overprint (falling water table)
LS veins, steam-heated overprint (falling water table)
Similar blankets common in lithocap and HS, IS deposits
Similar blankets common in lithocap and HS, IS deposits
21. Research applied to mineral
exploration
McLaughlin, CA
LS sheeted veins beneath sinter
Sinters never in HS setting
22. Research applied to mineral
exploration
El Chichon, 1979:
El Chichon, 1979: magmatic vapors degassing
magmatic vapors degassing
23. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Kawah Ijen, Java:
Kawah Ijen, Java: magmatic vapors condensed into ground water
magmatic vapors condensed into ground water
24. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Satsuma Iwojima, S. Kyushu:
passive degassing of dome (~1000 yrs)
26. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Werner Giggenbach,
Werner Giggenbach,
geochemist, 1937-1997
geochemist, 1937-1997
Condensation of magmatic
Condensation of magmatic
vapor with HCl and SO
vapor with HCl and SO2
2
generates acidic (pH ~1)
generates acidic (pH ~1)
waters, causes leaching of rocks
waters, causes leaching of rocks
to leave residual silica: re-xstal
to leave residual silica: re-xstal
to vuggy quartz or silicic rock
to vuggy quartz or silicic rock
View: “rhyolite”, 99.9% SiO
View: “rhyolite”, 99.9% SiO2
2
27. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Flux of rock-forming components to sea:
Flux of rock-forming components to sea:
0.4 Mt/yr
0.4 Mt/yr of rhyolite cations leached,
of rhyolite cations leached,
i.e., 400 Mt of vuggy quartz over life of degassing dome
i.e., 400 Mt of vuggy quartz over life of degassing dome
28. Research applied to mineral
exploration
after Gray and Coolbaugh, 1994, by Arribas, 1995
after Gray and Coolbaugh, 1994, by Arribas, 1995
29. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Steven & Ratté, 1960
Summitville, CO
Vuggy qtz zone
flares upward
pH ~ >6 4 - 6 2 - 4 <2
30. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Summitville, CO: vuggy qtz with alunite halo
31. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Research applied to mineral exploration
Arribas, 1995
Advanced argillic lithocap, host to HS ore deposits
Summitville, CO:
Summitville, CO:
Alteration zoning
Alteration zoning
and ore bodies
and ore bodies
after Gray and Coolbaugh,
after Gray and Coolbaugh,
1994
1994
Magmatic vapor
Magmatic vapor
condensation; Arribas, 1995
condensation; Arribas, 1995
32. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Advanced argillic slides: 11
Advanced argillic slides: 11
(if scanned can be reduced to 5)
(if scanned can be reduced to 5)
Vuggy quartz, Summitville Quartz-alunite, Summitville
Hypogene alunite, El Tambo
Residual quartz, Pierina
Arribas et al., 2000
33. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Supergene alunite,
Rodalquilar
Steam-heated advanced argillic blanket, La Coipa
Supergene alunite,
Riaza Supergene alunite, Rodalquilar
Massive supergene
alunite,
Rodalquilar
Arribas et al., 2000
34. Research applied to mineral
exploration
La Coipa: Steam-heated cristobalite-
alunite blanket over vuggy quartz zone
35. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Chalcedony blanket at
paleowater table
53. Research applied to mineral
exploration
El Indio 3500 vein:
quartz-pyrite-Au (tn-
ccp) with sericite
halo, post enargite
DSO: 200 g/t Au av.,
cutoff 100 g/t (1.5
Moz of 8 Moz total)
60. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Arribas et al., 1995; Sajona et al., 2001, Hedenquist et al., 2001
61. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Lithocap collapse
Lithocap collapse
HS ore, if present,
HS ore, if present,
overprints porphyry
overprints porphyry
Varying depths and
Varying depths and
intervals between
intervals between
base of lithocap and
base of lithocap and
top of porphyry
top of porphyry
63. Research applied to mineral
exploration
HS deposits:
HS deposits: Observations relevant to exploration
Observations relevant to exploration
Shallow, lithologic host; deep, structural control
Shallow, lithologic host; deep, structural control
Vuggy quartz main host: steep (can be barren!)
Vuggy quartz main host: steep (can be barren!)
Ore (sulfides + Au) introduced after leaching (or not)
Ore (sulfides + Au) introduced after leaching (or not)
– Low-grade bodies: evidence for oxidation
Low-grade bodies: evidence for oxidation
Identify center(s) from alteration: size can be critical
Identify center(s) from alteration: size can be critical
Local high-grade zones (late): cf. El Indio
Local high-grade zones (late): cf. El Indio
Marginal IS veins, locally significant
Marginal IS veins, locally significant
Pyrophyllite and sericite roots: porphyry tops
Pyrophyllite and sericite roots: porphyry tops
64. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Masupa Ria, Kalimantan: IS veins cut barren lithocap
65. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Arcata, Perú, IS Ag vein
Arcata, Perú, IS Ag vein (100 Moz Ag, 1 Moz Au): argillic halo at surface
(100 Moz Ag, 1 Moz Au): argillic halo at surface
66. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Arcata, Perú:
Arcata, Perú:
IS Ag vein: qtz-
IS Ag vein: qtz-
rhodochrosite
rhodochrosite
Zacatecas,
Mexico
68. Research applied to mineral
exploration
IS veins
IS veins
Common on margin of HS deposits
Common on margin of HS deposits
– Typically small, but exceptions (Victoria)
Typically small, but exceptions (Victoria)
Principle IS deposits: Ag-Au (Zn-Pb, Cu)
Principle IS deposits: Ag-Au (Zn-Pb, Cu)
– Simple sulfide mineralogy, gangue
Simple sulfide mineralogy, gangue
Large veins: up to several km long
Large veins: up to several km long
Up to 800 m vertical
Up to 800 m vertical
– Tops and bottoms not uniform
Tops and bottoms not uniform
71. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Exploration for HS epithermal gold deposits
Exploration for HS epithermal gold deposits
General guidelines
General guidelines
HS-IS epithermal: Neutral (~extensional) setting vs.
HS-IS epithermal: Neutral (~extensional) setting vs.
contraction (large porphyry)
contraction (large porphyry)
HS: Define silicic (± vuggy) core, alteration halo
HS: Define silicic (± vuggy) core, alteration halo
HS: Beware barren lithocaps vs. oxidized sulfide
HS: Beware barren lithocaps vs. oxidized sulfide
Lithocaps: overlie porphyry Cu-Au systems
Lithocaps: overlie porphyry Cu-Au systems
IS veins: Potential importance near HS prospects
IS veins: Potential importance near HS prospects
– Large lateral and vertical ranges, not uniform top or base
Large lateral and vertical ranges, not uniform top or base
Sillitoe and Hedenquist, 2003
Sillitoe and Hedenquist, 2003
72. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Exploration for HS epithermal gold deposits
Exploration for HS epithermal gold deposits
Conclusions
Conclusions
Prospective to target for world-class ore bodies
Prospective to target for world-class ore bodies
– Low-grade oxide ore (local bonanza veins)
Low-grade oxide ore (local bonanza veins)
Potential for related deposits in a district
Potential for related deposits in a district
– Cu-Au porphyries, polymetallic Ag-Au-Zn-Pb veins
Cu-Au porphyries, polymetallic Ag-Au-Zn-Pb veins
Basic questions: regional to district implications
Basic questions: regional to district implications
– Arc vs. rift, ligand source (porphyry, alkalic, mafic), Cu vs
Arc vs. rift, ligand source (porphyry, alkalic, mafic), Cu vs
Pb-Zn (zoning), barren lithocaps, etc.
Pb-Zn (zoning), barren lithocaps, etc.
74. Research applied to mineral
exploration
Temperature-
dependent alteration
mineralogy
Useful for paleo-
isotherm zoning in
epithermal deposits
Hedenquist et al., 1996