C-SAP student cascade activity feedback

C-SAP: Student/OER Cascade Activity Task & Feedback – July 2011

Phil Johnson and Craig Hammond utilised www.dropbox.com as a research facility, aimed at
engaging two groups of students in OER-related ‘cascade’ activities:

As part of this process, we e-mailed out the following (activity 3) ‘invitation’ to the two student
researcher groups:

As students accepted this task, downloaded dropbox, and then accessed the shared folder, they
each accessed their specific (named) word document, and undertook the OER-related research
activities identified (see example document below). A total of 19 students were invited to complete
the activity, 14 students accessed their documents in the shared folder, and 7 successfully
completed the tasks.

P. Johnson/C. Hammond (C-SAP Student OER Cascade feedback) Page 1


The Open Educational Resources (OER's) movement has received major backing from
governments in both the UK and USA and has the potential to do to the education
industry what the web 2.0 has done to other information industries such as news, music
and publishing (e.g. think of Twitter and Wiki Leaks, Limewire etc.); i.e. create significant
and increasing opportunities for public and democratic engagement and interaction.

Education will have to increasingly confront (and utilise) these changes; this is the
reason why institutions such as Harvard, Stanford, MIT and Oxford (for example) are
now producing OER materials (and allowing general public access).

OERs also offer new opportunities for organisations to collaborate, and provide multi-
disciplinary approaches as part of their studies and educational provision.

The OER field is evolving and it is therefore prudent for us to engage with it now, so that
we, as students and educational practitioners can be prepared to meet the immediate
and future changes in H.E.

Your/our research activities are part of Phase 2 of a JISC/C-SAP funded research
project – known as the ‘OER2 Cascade’ element, (i.e. the processes and effectiveness
of students and academic staff accessing and distributing OER materials – and their
current and impending ‘impact’).

The final part of our research activity, invites you to access the following OER resources,
and to provide Phil and I with detailed feedback, on how you found:



(Write student-researcher name here) Task 1:

OER resources on how to create:
Please provide your responses to the four
(Click into): Contents pages * questions in the boxes below:

(Click into): Referencing *

In Word 2007

1. How useful/accessible did
you find the presentation of
the information in these
resources?

2. Explain the likelihood of
you using this/similar
resource(s) as part of your
future studies (i.e. in
assignments, presentations
etc.).

3. Would you recommend the
use of these OER resources
to other students/learners?
Please explain your answer.

4. What could be ‘improved’
(if anything) in order for
you to use/recommend
these OER resources as part
of future studies?

* This activity consists of a ‘Voicethread/Jing-styled’ OER resource (which was then uploaded to
www.vimeo.com), where a UCBC lecturer explains and visualises how to create a contents page, and
how to reference using Word 2007.



(Write student-researcher name here) Task 2:

(Click into): French Revolution ** questions in the boxes below:

In Word 2007
Pay particular attention to this important ‘symbol’ (at the
This is a large document – only bottom of each page in this resource)
access and comment on section
1 AND section 7.2. It is important where the usage and citing of this OER is
concerned (click onto the image):

1. How useful/accessible did
resources?

2. Explain the likelihood of
resource(s) as part of your
future studies (i.e. in
etc.).

3. Would you recommend the
Please explain your answer.

4. What could be ‘improved’
you to use/recommend
of future studies?

** This OER-resource is an Open Learning resource (provided by the Open University), which,
usefully, also cites the Creative Commons Licence.



Collation of ‘selected’ student feedback points (Task 1):
(Click into): Contents pages questions in the boxes below:

(Click into): Referencing

In Word 2007
The information was useful ... The commentary was a little quiet
1. How useful/accessible did possibly, but the visuals were very clear (Student 1)
the information in these At one point the tutor mentioned putting the video on pause
resources? and trying it ourselves, and from personal experience I would
probably have to do that ... (Student 2)

Easily accessible and extremely useful, particularly if students
are embarking on their initial assignments and need guidance ...
(Student 3)

I think anyone could learn from these resources as the
information is presented in a very clear and simple manner.
(Student 4)

The information was also very accessible as you could watch the
video and pause/rewind at any time. On the right hand side you
could also refer back or look at other videos which are also
relevant. (Student 5)

I found them useful as some of the information I didn’t know
and the video’s are in an easy to follow format that you can re-
watch if needed. Also, the parts I already knew were a result of
being shown in university and so this way I could learn the same
information at home in my own time. They are accessible and
easy to follow. (Student 6)
I would use something like this very regularly; I have often used
2. Explain the likelihood of YouTube for similar hints and tips. (Student 1)
resource(s) as part of your ... I would love to have all our lectures recorded so I could listen
future studies (i.e. in to them over and over until the information went in and stayed
there. (Student 2)
etc.).

It has demonstrated straightforward short cuts which are
extremely useful towards saving time when writing assignments.
(Student 3)

It is very likely that I will refer back to this resource or something
similar when I do my dissertation. (Student 4)

The likelihood of using this in my future studies in very high, as it
would save me time in the long run ... (Student 5)



I would use these resources for other things in my studies. I
think they are really helpful, and I especially like how I can
access them so easily at home and watch as many times as I
needed to ... Moreover, I would use them as it gives me the
opportunity to pick my learning environment to ensure I get the
most of the information, unlike in a classroom where I am less
likely to learn it. (Student 6)
Yes I think I would ... This video was concise and helpful and
3. Would you recommend the slowly explained ... (Student 1)
to other students/learners? Yes definitely, as previously mentioned, it is very good when you
Please explain your answer. need a point repeating, maybe to jog your memory at
assignment time. (Student 2)

Absolutely! They are easily accessible, short and straightforward
demonstrations which can save people time ... (Student 3)

... if you forget something you can go over It in your own time
and at your own pace. (Student 4)

Yes I would, as some people don’t always get what your
explaining first time, and may feel daft asking again. (Student 5)

Yes I would. Visual help is better than written instructions.
(Nicola Wilson)

... making the move from college to university can be daunting,
but easy to follow videos that explain everything so clearly
would be great. (Student 6)
I would maybe have the volume of the video a little louder ...
4. What could be ‘improved’ (Student 1)
you to use/recommend ... shorter videos may keep the students more interested ...
these OER resources as part (Student 2)
of future studies?
I do not think anything could be improved. (Student 3)

I think these specific resources are straightforward and go
straight to the point so I don’t feel like they could be improved
in any way ... (Student 4)

Higher level of sound as I had it at 100% and still could not hear
it that well. (Student 5)

The only thing is for people that are savvier with a computer
they are a little slow moving. Like I mentioned I knew some of
the information but not all of it and found some of the videos a
bit tedious. I’m not sure what could be done about this. (Student
6)



Collation of selected student feedback points (Task 2):
(Click into): French Revolution questions in the boxes below:

In Word 2007
Pay particular attention to this important ‘symbol’ (at the
This is a large document – only bottom of each page in this resource)
access and comment on section
1 AND section 7.2. It is important where the usage and citing of this OER is
concerned (click onto the image):

I don’t really ... enjoy reading content similar to this as I often
1. How useful/accessible did lose which line I am on ... I often print out resources to read ... to
you find the presentation of ensure things are not missed. (Student 1)
resources? These types of documents I find only useful for skimming
through and finding the odd reference. It’s very hard for me as a
student to learn from reading to myself as I tend to go off track
and stop thinking about what I supposed to be learning.
(Student 2)

Easily accessible and interesting to read, useful in how it explains
... The French Revolution ... straightforward to read, being
academic but not overly so that it would put the reader off.
(Student 3)

... it was easy to navigate it. This particular text is full of
references, which is very useful and can be used for further
research (Student 4)

The information was useful, and the use of pictures / quotes /
italic writing made the text easier to read, as it broke the text up
and kept me interested. (Student 5)

Bit boring but useful. (Nicola Wilson)

I found this information easy to access and informative. I
preferred section 7.2 to section 1 as it is broken up by bullets
and graphs. This is my learning style as a big page of writing,
especially on a computer is hard for me to focus on. I did find it
useful, for me I would prefer to see it in hard copy version but
could easily do this myself. (Student 6)

2. Explain the likelihood of I’m not sure I would read things like this ... (Student 1)



resource(s) as part of your I’d say it’s highly unlikely that I would use this type of source to
future studies (i.e. in try and teach myself any new skills but I may use it to extract the
assignments, presentations odd reference from. (Student 2)
etc.).
... a great introduction to researching information for new
learners who may struggle to access the correct information.
(Student 3)

It is very likely that I would use similar resources in my studies
(Student 4)

The likelihood of using a similar resource in a future assignment
would be quite high as there is a lot of information given and
you would be able to reference it. However it would take up a
lot of time to read which could potentially put people off!
(Student 5)

I would use information like this. I think it’s often hard to find
good, reliable information online, but resources that are trusted
like this is accessible thanks to the creative commons attribution
are great ... It would allow students to access the information
easily. (Student 6)

Possibly, concise, but much like reading a textbook, the
3. Would you recommend the information of the textbook is only as good as its layout and
use of these OER resources digestion. (Student 1)
Please explain your answer. I would recommend this type of learning to students but as a
side line to the other type of learning (the video’s) ... (Student 2)

Yes because once again they save time, are genuine and give
clear, concise information about the topics. It is a good habit to
develop in using these resources and I think it is important to
encourage others to do the same. (Student 3)

Yes I would recommend them because they are a useful source
of information which is clearly laid out and easy to use (Student
4)

Yes I would as the information needed is provided and it would
save time for doing research, therefore giving more time on the
content of the assignment. (Student 5)

Yes. I think these are invaluable to students. Although the
format is hard for me to read, it would not be for most students.
(Student 6)

Verbalising of the material could potentially be better, making it
4. What could be ‘improved’ easier to make your own notes. (Student 1)
you to use/recommend If the whole document had the option to have the writing in



of future studies? audio whilst you read along this may be a little more helpful,
however I’m aware this would be very time consuming to put
together. (Student 2)

I do not think anything could be improved. (Student 3)

I can’t see however room for improvement with the resource in
question. (Student 4)

Break the text up a bit more – as otherwise you could look at it
and be put off straight away by the sheer amount of words!
(Student 5)

Section 1 could be better if it was also broken up more but I
think they are an invaluable resource. (Student 6)

Brief summary of findings:
• It appears that the accessibility, visuality, and availability of the ‘Task 1’ OER-resources are
preferred over the ‘standard text’ (Task 2) OER open resources.

• The audio quality of the Task 1 resource would need to be considered.

• Students clearly identified the ‘recognition’ (and necessity) of different learning styles and
learning environments – the ‘physicality of attending a lecture’ in the University setting is
not necessarily conducive with effective or bespoke learning.

• The Creative Commons licensing of the Task 2 resource appealed to students.

• The quality and the differentiated sections associated with the Task 2 OER resource also
positively acknowledged by students.

• It would appear reasonable to assume that as more ‘quality’ OER resources, (such as these),
become increasingly available for (our) students, they would indeed utilise them and
cascade them to fellow-learners.


C-SAP student cascade activity feedback

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (6)

Similar to C-SAP student cascade activity feedback (20)

More from CSAPSubjectCentre (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

C-SAP student cascade activity feedback