SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Linked Open Data
in limbo
Co-creation as a catalyst for
open cultural heritage resources
Open Belgium 12.03.2018
Sam Donvil Alina Saenko
sam@packed.be alina@packed.be
@PACKEDvzw
• 2006 - 2010: Platform for Archiving and Conservation of Art on Electronic
and Digital Media
• 2011 - present: Centre of Expertise Digital Heritage
• Flemish, Belgian and European projects
• Support for ICT-processes at heritage and arts organisations (o.a.
creating, storage, cataloguing, online access, exchange and reuse) and
policy thereof
• Central concern: sustainability (digital heritage is vulnerable)
The museum as a changing concept: antiquity >
museion
Role: scholarship
Audience: research
community
The museum as a changing concept: renaissance >
cabinet of curiosities
Role: prestige, display of ‘all’
objects
Audience: privileged visitors,
courtiers
The museum as a changing concept: enlightenment
and modern era > birth of the modern museum
Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, not
necessarily display
Audience: research community & privileged
visitors
Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, national
prestige
Audience: research community, large middle class
audiences
The museum as a changing concept: contemporary
era > changing consumer demands
The museum as a changing concept: contemporary
era > memory institution as an online knowledge
source
Future
interpretation:
-Share
-Contextualise
-Coordinate
-Facilitate
Conventional
interpretation:
-Control quality
-Control access
Current ICOM definition:
A museum is a non-profit, permanent
institution in the service of society and
its development, open to the public,
which acquires, conserves, researches,
communicates and exhibits the tangible
and intangible heritage of humanity and
its environment for the purposes of
education, study and enjoyment.
Accumulation and
registration of data
Back-office:
- Not a ‘popular’ topic to invest in
- Often no ‘digital mindset’ inside the institutions > external IT services
Data
- Messy and not complete, but a lot of potential knowledge
- Captured on different carriers (systems, digital and analogue files)
- Often closed (and obsolete) software
Audio-visual material
- Different tools and DAMs, but not good enough
- ‘Analogue mindset’: distributed versions and copies
The situation in the Flemish artmuseums
Linked Open Data in limbo: Open cultural heritage resources
2012 http://smak.be/collectie_kunstenaar.php?kunstwerk_id=1461&l=a&kunstenaar_id=41
Open source tool:
https://github.com/PACKED-vzw/resolver
Resolver-tool
Resolver
Persistent URI: 2016 - ... http://resolver.smak.be/collection/work/data/3385
http://smak.be/nl/kunstwerk/75872016
http://newwebsite.be/3542019
http://evenbetterwebsite.be/lod/the-journey2030
Enrichment of data via external authorities
External authorities:
- Wikidata, VIAF, RKDartists, ODIS,
Geonames, AAT (Getty Vocabularies),
Iconclass
https://www.projectcest.be/wiki/Publicatie:Project_Persist
ente_identificatie
Visualisations with internally shared data
Acquisition source:
From which source did a museum
acquire artworks? (5 museums)
- Private
- Artist
- Gallery
- Government
- The Monarchy
- The Church
https://thedatahub.github.io/
Blueprint distributed AV management
Making data and images
accessible
Open Cultuur Data project
Open data on Wikimedia platforms
Why Wikimedia?
● visibility
● reuse
● engagement
Wikidata
○ Royal Museum of Fine Arts Antwerp (7.798 artworks)
○ Museum of Fine Arts Ghent (6.973 artworks)
○ Groeningemuseum Brugge (2.858 artworks)
○ M - Museum Leuven (3.137 artworks)
○ Mu.ZEE (3.979 artworks)
○ S.M.A.K. (2.579 artworks)
Wikimedia Commons
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Conclusion and next steps
Why Linked Open Data in Limbo?
digital movement <> no digital mindset
reducing costs <> out-of-control IT-budgets
new ‘digital’ audiences <> losing ‘traditional’ audiences
showing off with fancy tools <> locked up in obsolete technology
engaging with the ‘crowd’ <> abandoned web portals
- More IT profiles in the cultural heritage sector and less dependence on the providers
- More freedom to play around and test things out
- Better open infrastructures and tools that make better internal workflows and LOD
possible:
- Back office tools: Collection Management Systems, DAMs , Datahubs…
- Publishing online tools: Resolvers, API’s...
- Reusing: Wikimedia art viewers, apps...
- etc...
- Vocal and demanding audience:
- (examples of) reuse
- curating/enriching data
Wishlist
- Datahub project fase 2 en 3
- Resolver-tool op Open Summer of Code 2018
- Wikimedia projects:
- Public Domain publication
- Publishing images and more structured data
- Reusing in Wikipedia-articles and outside of the platform
- Networked cultural data
- survey on the current demand for cultural heritage data by various
sectors
Do you see yourself contributing to one of the projects or to the wishlist?
Idea’s or feedback? Please contact us!
PACKED vzw 2018 -...
Thank you!
Questions? Feedback?
Sam Donvil Alina Saenko
sam@packed.be alina@packed.be
@PACKEDvzw

More Related Content

PDF
20180312 lod in_limbo_open_belgium
PDF
PIDs for cultural heritage Flanders
PDF
Persistent identification
PPTX
Cultural Heritage & H2020
PPTX
The Mint Mapping tool
PPTX
Bart Noels, External Relations, Communication and eGovernment, Leiedal (BE)
PPTX
Persistent identification: supporting digital humanities
PPTX
Introduction to CARARE
20180312 lod in_limbo_open_belgium
PIDs for cultural heritage Flanders
Persistent identification
Cultural Heritage & H2020
The Mint Mapping tool
Bart Noels, External Relations, Communication and eGovernment, Leiedal (BE)
Persistent identification: supporting digital humanities
Introduction to CARARE

What's hot (19)

PPT
Introducing DARIAH
PPT
Towards DARIAH in Belgium
PPT
Facilitating digital research in the humanities: from local services to Europ...
PDF
Connecting archaeology and architecture data
PPTX
Europeana Archaeology
PPTX
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage: Standards and metadata
PDF
Escena Digital, a new product to dissemination of heritage
PDF
Work Package 4 - Month 6 by Sam Leon
PDF
CEMEC Discovery Programme discussion digital heritage
PPT
From Catalogue 2.0 to the digital humanities: exploring the future of librari...
PPTX
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage
PPT
Dynamics and partnerships with local associations involved in LoCloud: a case...
PPTX
A History of Digitization - summary
PPT
Open Culture Data: Opening GLAM Data Bottom-up
PDF
Butigan vucaj dh_ilde
PPT
130130 luxinnovation -europeana cip ict psp workshop
PDF
Dissemination of Heritage: Experience of the Museu of Performing Arts (BCN)
PDF
3D reconstructions for story telling and understanding
Introducing DARIAH
Towards DARIAH in Belgium
Facilitating digital research in the humanities: from local services to Europ...
Connecting archaeology and architecture data
Europeana Archaeology
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage: Standards and metadata
Escena Digital, a new product to dissemination of heritage
Work Package 4 - Month 6 by Sam Leon
CEMEC Discovery Programme discussion digital heritage
From Catalogue 2.0 to the digital humanities: exploring the future of librari...
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage
Dynamics and partnerships with local associations involved in LoCloud: a case...
A History of Digitization - summary
Open Culture Data: Opening GLAM Data Bottom-up
Butigan vucaj dh_ilde
130130 luxinnovation -europeana cip ict psp workshop
Dissemination of Heritage: Experience of the Museu of Performing Arts (BCN)
3D reconstructions for story telling and understanding
Ad

Similar to Linked Open Data in limbo: Open cultural heritage resources (20)

PDF
20190304 shifting minds_open_belgium_2019
PDF
20190304_shifting_minds_open_belgium_2019
PDF
Shifting minds open belgium 2019
PDF
20190304 shifting minds open belgium 2019
PDF
Sam Donvil PACKED public domain day 2018
PPTX
20180526 sam donvil_packed_public_domain_day
PPT
Datahub for museums (poster)
PDF
From Open Acces to Open Collections to Open Minds
PDF
Forever In Between : similarities and differences, opportunities and responsa...
ODP
Linked Open Europeana: Semantics for the Citizen
PDF
Datahub for museums (poster)
PDF
20170620_sam_donvil_sharing_is_caring_bxl_intro_WLA_panel_discussion
PDF
20170620 sam donvil_sharing_is_caring_bxl_master
PDF
2018 03-03 culture hack-bucharest-marco streefkerk
PPTX
American Art Collaborative Linked Open Data presentation to "The Networked Cu...
PPT
"Opening GLAM Data Bottom-up" by Maarten Brinkerink
PPTX
Estermann wikimania2015 glam-survey_20150719
PDF
OpenGLAM in museums: Linked Open Data and Wikipedia
PPT
Sharing is caring conference in Copenhagen 2011-11-111
PDF
Europeana and linked cultural heritage data
20190304 shifting minds_open_belgium_2019
20190304_shifting_minds_open_belgium_2019
Shifting minds open belgium 2019
20190304 shifting minds open belgium 2019
Sam Donvil PACKED public domain day 2018
20180526 sam donvil_packed_public_domain_day
Datahub for museums (poster)
From Open Acces to Open Collections to Open Minds
Forever In Between : similarities and differences, opportunities and responsa...
Linked Open Europeana: Semantics for the Citizen
Datahub for museums (poster)
20170620_sam_donvil_sharing_is_caring_bxl_intro_WLA_panel_discussion
20170620 sam donvil_sharing_is_caring_bxl_master
2018 03-03 culture hack-bucharest-marco streefkerk
American Art Collaborative Linked Open Data presentation to "The Networked Cu...
"Opening GLAM Data Bottom-up" by Maarten Brinkerink
Estermann wikimania2015 glam-survey_20150719
OpenGLAM in museums: Linked Open Data and Wikipedia
Sharing is caring conference in Copenhagen 2011-11-111
Europeana and linked cultural heritage data
Ad

More from Open Knowledge Belgium (20)

PPTX
Open Data Stories You haven't heard!
PPTX
A​ FUNUMENTARY:​ Take what you can, give nothing back...​ ​(NOT)
PDF
Smarter by Open Data: Process and Practice in Flevoland (NL)
PDF
Open Knowledge for Social Innovation
PDF
Smart Flanders: Tackling urban challenges through Open Data
PDF
EIF and NIFO connecting public administrations, businesses, and citizens
PDF
Connecting Open data for solving the fiscal transparency puzzle in the EU
PDF
Open Government and Networked European Democracy
PPTX
Mundaneum Factories for Open Tokenomics
PDF
MIRVA: The European Open Recognition Project
PPTX
Bike for Brussels - Open Summer of Code 2017
PPTX
The story behind SNCB alerts
PPTX
Traffic safety - answering tough questions with open data
PPTX
Eliminating data roadbloacks to get by traffic roadblocks without pain
PPTX
A journey to Linked Open Touristic Data
PDF
How we use the massive open lidar dataset for the benfit of our clients
PPTX
mu.semte.ch: A transitional architecture for Linked Data
PPTX
Linked Open Chatbots
PDF
The role and value of making data inventories
PDF
Open for Business
Open Data Stories You haven't heard!
A​ FUNUMENTARY:​ Take what you can, give nothing back...​ ​(NOT)
Smarter by Open Data: Process and Practice in Flevoland (NL)
Open Knowledge for Social Innovation
Smart Flanders: Tackling urban challenges through Open Data
EIF and NIFO connecting public administrations, businesses, and citizens
Connecting Open data for solving the fiscal transparency puzzle in the EU
Open Government and Networked European Democracy
Mundaneum Factories for Open Tokenomics
MIRVA: The European Open Recognition Project
Bike for Brussels - Open Summer of Code 2017
The story behind SNCB alerts
Traffic safety - answering tough questions with open data
Eliminating data roadbloacks to get by traffic roadblocks without pain
A journey to Linked Open Touristic Data
How we use the massive open lidar dataset for the benfit of our clients
mu.semte.ch: A transitional architecture for Linked Data
Linked Open Chatbots
The role and value of making data inventories
Open for Business

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Introduction to Firewall Analytics - Interfirewall and Transfirewall.pptx
PDF
Foundation of Data Science unit number two notes
PPTX
Global journeys: estimating international migration
PDF
Introduction to Business Data Analytics.
PPTX
Computer network topology notes for revision
PDF
“Getting Started with Data Analytics Using R – Concepts, Tools & Case Studies”
PPTX
Business Ppt On Nestle.pptx huunnnhhgfvu
PPTX
Acceptance and paychological effects of mandatory extra coach I classes.pptx
PPTX
CEE 2 REPORT G7.pptxbdbshjdgsgjgsjfiuhsd
PDF
Recruitment and Placement PPT.pdfbjfibjdfbjfobj
PPTX
climate analysis of Dhaka ,Banglades.pptx
PPTX
mbdjdhjjodule 5-1 rhfhhfjtjjhafbrhfnfbbfnb
PPTX
STUDY DESIGN details- Lt Col Maksud (21).pptx
PDF
Clinical guidelines as a resource for EBP(1).pdf
PPT
Reliability_Chapter_ presentation 1221.5784
PDF
Launch Your Data Science Career in Kochi – 2025
PPTX
Major-Components-ofNKJNNKNKNKNKronment.pptx
PPTX
Business Acumen Training GuidePresentation.pptx
PDF
Mega Projects Data Mega Projects Data
PPT
Chapter 3 METAL JOINING.pptnnnnnnnnnnnnn
Introduction to Firewall Analytics - Interfirewall and Transfirewall.pptx
Foundation of Data Science unit number two notes
Global journeys: estimating international migration
Introduction to Business Data Analytics.
Computer network topology notes for revision
“Getting Started with Data Analytics Using R – Concepts, Tools & Case Studies”
Business Ppt On Nestle.pptx huunnnhhgfvu
Acceptance and paychological effects of mandatory extra coach I classes.pptx
CEE 2 REPORT G7.pptxbdbshjdgsgjgsjfiuhsd
Recruitment and Placement PPT.pdfbjfibjdfbjfobj
climate analysis of Dhaka ,Banglades.pptx
mbdjdhjjodule 5-1 rhfhhfjtjjhafbrhfnfbbfnb
STUDY DESIGN details- Lt Col Maksud (21).pptx
Clinical guidelines as a resource for EBP(1).pdf
Reliability_Chapter_ presentation 1221.5784
Launch Your Data Science Career in Kochi – 2025
Major-Components-ofNKJNNKNKNKNKronment.pptx
Business Acumen Training GuidePresentation.pptx
Mega Projects Data Mega Projects Data
Chapter 3 METAL JOINING.pptnnnnnnnnnnnnn

Linked Open Data in limbo: Open cultural heritage resources

  • 1. Linked Open Data in limbo Co-creation as a catalyst for open cultural heritage resources Open Belgium 12.03.2018 Sam Donvil Alina Saenko sam@packed.be alina@packed.be @PACKEDvzw
  • 2. • 2006 - 2010: Platform for Archiving and Conservation of Art on Electronic and Digital Media • 2011 - present: Centre of Expertise Digital Heritage • Flemish, Belgian and European projects • Support for ICT-processes at heritage and arts organisations (o.a. creating, storage, cataloguing, online access, exchange and reuse) and policy thereof • Central concern: sustainability (digital heritage is vulnerable)
  • 3. The museum as a changing concept: antiquity > museion Role: scholarship Audience: research community
  • 4. The museum as a changing concept: renaissance > cabinet of curiosities Role: prestige, display of ‘all’ objects Audience: privileged visitors, courtiers
  • 5. The museum as a changing concept: enlightenment and modern era > birth of the modern museum Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, not necessarily display Audience: research community & privileged visitors Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, national prestige Audience: research community, large middle class audiences
  • 6. The museum as a changing concept: contemporary era > changing consumer demands
  • 7. The museum as a changing concept: contemporary era > memory institution as an online knowledge source Future interpretation: -Share -Contextualise -Coordinate -Facilitate Conventional interpretation: -Control quality -Control access Current ICOM definition: A museum is a non-profit, permanent institution in the service of society and its development, open to the public, which acquires, conserves, researches, communicates and exhibits the tangible and intangible heritage of humanity and its environment for the purposes of education, study and enjoyment.
  • 9. Back-office: - Not a ‘popular’ topic to invest in - Often no ‘digital mindset’ inside the institutions > external IT services Data - Messy and not complete, but a lot of potential knowledge - Captured on different carriers (systems, digital and analogue files) - Often closed (and obsolete) software Audio-visual material - Different tools and DAMs, but not good enough - ‘Analogue mindset’: distributed versions and copies The situation in the Flemish artmuseums
  • 13. Resolver Persistent URI: 2016 - ... http://resolver.smak.be/collection/work/data/3385 http://smak.be/nl/kunstwerk/75872016 http://newwebsite.be/3542019 http://evenbetterwebsite.be/lod/the-journey2030
  • 14. Enrichment of data via external authorities External authorities: - Wikidata, VIAF, RKDartists, ODIS, Geonames, AAT (Getty Vocabularies), Iconclass https://www.projectcest.be/wiki/Publicatie:Project_Persist ente_identificatie
  • 15. Visualisations with internally shared data Acquisition source: From which source did a museum acquire artworks? (5 museums) - Private - Artist - Gallery - Government - The Monarchy - The Church
  • 18. Making data and images accessible
  • 19. Open Cultuur Data project
  • 20. Open data on Wikimedia platforms Why Wikimedia? ● visibility ● reuse ● engagement
  • 21. Wikidata ○ Royal Museum of Fine Arts Antwerp (7.798 artworks) ○ Museum of Fine Arts Ghent (6.973 artworks) ○ Groeningemuseum Brugge (2.858 artworks) ○ M - Museum Leuven (3.137 artworks) ○ Mu.ZEE (3.979 artworks) ○ S.M.A.K. (2.579 artworks)
  • 31. Why Linked Open Data in Limbo? digital movement <> no digital mindset reducing costs <> out-of-control IT-budgets new ‘digital’ audiences <> losing ‘traditional’ audiences showing off with fancy tools <> locked up in obsolete technology engaging with the ‘crowd’ <> abandoned web portals
  • 32. - More IT profiles in the cultural heritage sector and less dependence on the providers - More freedom to play around and test things out - Better open infrastructures and tools that make better internal workflows and LOD possible: - Back office tools: Collection Management Systems, DAMs , Datahubs… - Publishing online tools: Resolvers, API’s... - Reusing: Wikimedia art viewers, apps... - etc... - Vocal and demanding audience: - (examples of) reuse - curating/enriching data Wishlist
  • 33. - Datahub project fase 2 en 3 - Resolver-tool op Open Summer of Code 2018 - Wikimedia projects: - Public Domain publication - Publishing images and more structured data - Reusing in Wikipedia-articles and outside of the platform - Networked cultural data - survey on the current demand for cultural heritage data by various sectors Do you see yourself contributing to one of the projects or to the wishlist? Idea’s or feedback? Please contact us! PACKED vzw 2018 -...
  • 34. Thank you! Questions? Feedback? Sam Donvil Alina Saenko sam@packed.be alina@packed.be @PACKEDvzw