SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1
2
IPv6 Deployment
My Stories
Hard Lessons
IPv6 Deployment Strategy
APNIC Academy
3
Terry Sweetser
Been doing this “Internet thing” since
1989.
Former APNIC Community Trainer, CTO,
Founder, Engineering Manager, etc
APNIC Training Delivery Manager for
South Asia and Oceania
Nationality: Australian
Languages: English
about.me/terry.sweetser
4
“A great many stories I can tell you about network operations are not examples
of best practice but more cautionary tales of failures and unintended
consequences.” -- Terry Sweetser
“I have not failed. I’ve just found 10,000 ways
that won’t work.” -- Thomas Edison
Always be learning …
5
So it started in 2015 …
IPv6?
How hard could that be?
Note: all data sources are APNIC unless otherwise stated.
6
6
Deployment Success …
Source: Author
7
7
Oh, 13.44% at 22 November 2016
8
8
AS7477 “Looks OK?”
9
9
AS1221 “Catch Them If You Can”
10
Then I’m “NANOG” Famous …
Geoff Huston Andrew Khoo
Source: Author & Andrew Khoo
11
11
Lately, AU looks better …
12
12
Congratulations Sri Lanka!
13
IPv6 Deployment Strategy
Where do you start?
AUDIT
• What is the current state of your
network and what capability
exists to support dual stack?
PLANNING
• Gather your information and
resources before making
decisions. Then DECIDE.
TEAMWORK
• Build your team up with
knowledge and resources: you
will need time and training.
CONSULT
• Talk to managers, executives and
customer experience teams.
More input = more traction.
14
14
IPv6 Capability Considerations
When we say capable of ipv6, this refers to:
• People
– Engineers, Managers, Helpdesk, Field techs
• Equipment
– Core, Edge and Customer
• Capital
– Human, Financial
• Suppliers of Transit and Peering
– Are they capable?
CPE IPv6 Support is
often overlooked!
15
IPv6 Planning Considerations
• Address Planning
– Number One issue raised time and again!
– “Measure Twice, Cut Once” as renumbering is always painful.
– Be Generous with what you keep in reserve.
– Review it against all progress during deployment.
• Deployment Planning
– You can only start at your border routers, why?
– Pick a service to do first, like DNS or WWW, end-to-end testing.
– Then slowly over Core, Intermediate and then BNG+CPE.
16
IPv4 Depletion: “Blood From A Stone”
• NAT444 aka Double NAT aka The NAT has been NATed.
• NAT64/DNS64, aka “Hey, try this ipv6 address instead.”
• XLAT464 aka “You can’t bypass my NAT64 now.”
• Above will generate end user complaints.
• But you can deploy dual stack alongside above.
• The real solution is “IPv6 before IPv4” and make it stick.
17
IPv4 Depletion …
• The cost of ipv4 is too high.
• Price plateau due to the finding
the maximum willingness-to-pay.
• Capital better spent elsewhere,
even on LSN and CGN hardware.
Market Signal:
• A price drop means IPv6 has
“won the deployment war” and no
one (sensible) is buying it.
IPv4 price history between 2014
and 2022 (data by IPv4.Global)
Source: https://www.ipxo.com/blog/ipv4-price-history/
18
Terry Says
“If you have not talked to everyone about your big
technical plan for ipv6, you have not done enough
consultation.” – Terry Sweetser
“Move fast and break things.” – Mark Zuckerberg until 2014 ☺
“Prototype and test things in a lab, better to set that on
fire than your production network!” – Terry Sweetser
19
Listen to everyone’s stories …
• https://blog.apnic.net/2018/09/24/ipv6-at-dialog-axiata-
switch-from-survival-to-innovation/
• Assessed Network, Significant Management Buy-In
• Testing, testing, and more testing
20
How can we help you?
techassist@apnic.net
https://www.apnic.net/community/ipv6/deploy-ipv6/
21
IPv6 grants are open for
applications
IPv6 Deployment Grants are
targeted to support concrete
IPv6 deployment plans from
network operators in the Asia
Pacific region at different
stages of development.
ISIF Asia Grants
Applications open all year round
https://isif.asia/apply
22
APNIC Academy
Online Courses
Webinar courses
Self-paced courses Virtual Labs Technical Assistance
Book an Expert
23
Join Orbit
• Evolution of mailing lists with social media features
• To make active, online participation easier
• THE place for the APNIC community to connect, discuss, and share
information for APNIC SIGs and working groups, community topics, general
discussion and announcements
https://orbit.apnic.net/news-feed/
24
24
Next time: RPKI Validation
https://stats.labs.apnic.net/rpki/LK
25
Questions?
Many thanks for your attention!

More Related Content

PPTX
IETF Activities Update
PDF
Tmo ipv6-feb-2013 1361827441
PDF
2015 update: SIP and IPv6 issues - staying Happy in SIP
PDF
Getting The World IPv6 Enabled
PDF
Tech 2 Tech IPv6 presentation
PDF
IPv6 IAB/IETF Activities Report from ARIN 32
PDF
npNOG 5: IPv6 Deployment Update
PDF
Things I wish I had known about IPv6 before I started
IETF Activities Update
Tmo ipv6-feb-2013 1361827441
2015 update: SIP and IPv6 issues - staying Happy in SIP
Getting The World IPv6 Enabled
Tech 2 Tech IPv6 presentation
IPv6 IAB/IETF Activities Report from ARIN 32
npNOG 5: IPv6 Deployment Update
Things I wish I had known about IPv6 before I started

Similar to LKNOG6 IPv6 Implementation Stories and Where to Start presentation by Terry Sweetser for LkNOG 6 (20)

PDF
Supporting internet growth and evolution
PPTX
Parallel session: IPv6
PDF
ION Belfast - IPv6 Success Stories: Network Operators Tell All! - Ian Farrer
PPTX
An IPv6 Primer
PDF
bdNOG 11: IPv6 Update
PDF
Fred explainsi pv6-v2-alpha
PPT
IPv6 Troubleshooting for Helpdesks
PPTX
The Background Noise of the Internet
PDF
Ventajas de IPv6
PDF
Fred explains IPv6
PDF
Successfully Deploying IPv6
PPTX
IGFA 2017: IPv6 deployment
PDF
TCP/IP Geeks Stockholm :: Introduction to IPv6
PDF
The Case for IPv6: Paving the Way for the Internet of Things
PDF
btNOG 4: IPv6 deployment - where are we now?
PPTX
Final.pptx
PDF
IPv6 Enabled WiFi: Planning, Deployment and Best Practices
PPTX
BioIT Trends - 2014 Internet2 Technology Exchange
PPTX
ARIN 36 IETF IPv6 Activities Report
PDF
IPv6 Deployment Update
Supporting internet growth and evolution
Parallel session: IPv6
ION Belfast - IPv6 Success Stories: Network Operators Tell All! - Ian Farrer
An IPv6 Primer
bdNOG 11: IPv6 Update
Fred explainsi pv6-v2-alpha
IPv6 Troubleshooting for Helpdesks
The Background Noise of the Internet
Ventajas de IPv6
Fred explains IPv6
Successfully Deploying IPv6
IGFA 2017: IPv6 deployment
TCP/IP Geeks Stockholm :: Introduction to IPv6
The Case for IPv6: Paving the Way for the Internet of Things
btNOG 4: IPv6 deployment - where are we now?
Final.pptx
IPv6 Enabled WiFi: Planning, Deployment and Best Practices
BioIT Trends - 2014 Internet2 Technology Exchange
ARIN 36 IETF IPv6 Activities Report
IPv6 Deployment Update
Ad

More from APNIC (20)

PPTX
APNIC Report, presented at APAN 60 by Thy Boskovic
PDF
APNIC Update, presented at PHNOG 2025 by Shane Hermoso
PDF
RPKI Status Update, presented by Makito Lay at IDNOG 10
PDF
The Internet -By the Numbers, Sri Lanka Edition
PDF
Triggering QUIC, presented by Geoff Huston at IETF 123
PDF
DNSSEC Made Easy, presented at PHNOG 2025
PDF
BGP Security Best Practices that Matter, presented at PHNOG 2025
PDF
APNIC's Role in the Pacific Islands, presented at Pacific IGF 2205
PDF
IPv6 Deployment and Best Practices, presented by Makito Lay
PDF
Cleaning up your RPKI invalids, presented at PacNOG 35
PDF
The Internet - By the numbers, presented at npNOG 11
PDF
Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and Starlink
PDF
DDoS in India, presented at INNOG 8 by Dave Phelan
PDF
Global Networking Trends, presented at the India ISP Conclave 2025
PDF
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
PDF
Fast Reroute in SR-MPLS, presented at bdNOG 19
PDF
DDos Mitigation Strategie, presented at bdNOG 19
PDF
ICP -2 Review – What It Is, and How to Participate and Provide Your Feedback
PDF
APNIC Update - Global Synergy among the RIRs: Connecting the Regions
PDF
Measuring Starlink Protocol Performance, presented at LACNIC 43
APNIC Report, presented at APAN 60 by Thy Boskovic
APNIC Update, presented at PHNOG 2025 by Shane Hermoso
RPKI Status Update, presented by Makito Lay at IDNOG 10
The Internet -By the Numbers, Sri Lanka Edition
Triggering QUIC, presented by Geoff Huston at IETF 123
DNSSEC Made Easy, presented at PHNOG 2025
BGP Security Best Practices that Matter, presented at PHNOG 2025
APNIC's Role in the Pacific Islands, presented at Pacific IGF 2205
IPv6 Deployment and Best Practices, presented by Makito Lay
Cleaning up your RPKI invalids, presented at PacNOG 35
The Internet - By the numbers, presented at npNOG 11
Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and Starlink
DDoS in India, presented at INNOG 8 by Dave Phelan
Global Networking Trends, presented at the India ISP Conclave 2025
Make DDoS expensive for the threat actors
Fast Reroute in SR-MPLS, presented at bdNOG 19
DDos Mitigation Strategie, presented at bdNOG 19
ICP -2 Review – What It Is, and How to Participate and Provide Your Feedback
APNIC Update - Global Synergy among the RIRs: Connecting the Regions
Measuring Starlink Protocol Performance, presented at LACNIC 43
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
📍 LABUAN4D EXCLUSIVE SERVER STAR GAMING ASIA NO.1 TERPOPULER DI INDONESIA ! 🌟
PPTX
module 1-Part 1.pptxdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
PDF
mera desh ae watn.(a source of motivation and patriotism to the youth of the ...
PPTX
IPCNA VIRTUAL CLASSES INTERMEDIATE 6 PROJECT.pptx
PPTX
Internet Safety for Seniors presentation
PDF
Uptota Investor Deck - Where Africa Meets Blockchain
PDF
Alethe Consulting Corporate Profile and Solution Aproach
PDF
Top 8 Trusted Sources to Buy Verified Cash App Accounts.pdf
PPTX
AI_Cyberattack_Solutions AI AI AI AI .pptx
PPT
12 Things That Make People Trust a Website Instantly
PDF
The Evolution of Traditional to New Media .pdf
PPTX
TITLE DEFENSE entitle the impact of social media on education
PPTX
Layers_of_the_Earth_Grade7.pptx class by
PDF
si manuel quezon at mga nagawa sa bansang pilipinas
PPTX
curriculumandpedagogyinearlychildhoodcurriculum-171021103104 - Copy.pptx
PDF
Containerization lab dddddddddddddddmanual.pdf
DOCX
Powerful Ways AIRCONNECT INFOSYSTEMS Pvt Ltd Enhances IT Infrastructure in In...
PPTX
Introduction to cybersecurity and digital nettiquette
PPT
250152213-Excitation-SystemWERRT (1).ppt
PPT
FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PLAN- LUS.FM.MQ.OM.UTM.PLN.00014.ppt
📍 LABUAN4D EXCLUSIVE SERVER STAR GAMING ASIA NO.1 TERPOPULER DI INDONESIA ! 🌟
module 1-Part 1.pptxdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
mera desh ae watn.(a source of motivation and patriotism to the youth of the ...
IPCNA VIRTUAL CLASSES INTERMEDIATE 6 PROJECT.pptx
Internet Safety for Seniors presentation
Uptota Investor Deck - Where Africa Meets Blockchain
Alethe Consulting Corporate Profile and Solution Aproach
Top 8 Trusted Sources to Buy Verified Cash App Accounts.pdf
AI_Cyberattack_Solutions AI AI AI AI .pptx
12 Things That Make People Trust a Website Instantly
The Evolution of Traditional to New Media .pdf
TITLE DEFENSE entitle the impact of social media on education
Layers_of_the_Earth_Grade7.pptx class by
si manuel quezon at mga nagawa sa bansang pilipinas
curriculumandpedagogyinearlychildhoodcurriculum-171021103104 - Copy.pptx
Containerization lab dddddddddddddddmanual.pdf
Powerful Ways AIRCONNECT INFOSYSTEMS Pvt Ltd Enhances IT Infrastructure in In...
Introduction to cybersecurity and digital nettiquette
250152213-Excitation-SystemWERRT (1).ppt
FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PLAN- LUS.FM.MQ.OM.UTM.PLN.00014.ppt

LKNOG6 IPv6 Implementation Stories and Where to Start presentation by Terry Sweetser for LkNOG 6

  • 1. 1
  • 2. 2 IPv6 Deployment My Stories Hard Lessons IPv6 Deployment Strategy APNIC Academy
  • 3. 3 Terry Sweetser Been doing this “Internet thing” since 1989. Former APNIC Community Trainer, CTO, Founder, Engineering Manager, etc APNIC Training Delivery Manager for South Asia and Oceania Nationality: Australian Languages: English about.me/terry.sweetser
  • 4. 4 “A great many stories I can tell you about network operations are not examples of best practice but more cautionary tales of failures and unintended consequences.” -- Terry Sweetser “I have not failed. I’ve just found 10,000 ways that won’t work.” -- Thomas Edison Always be learning …
  • 5. 5 So it started in 2015 … IPv6? How hard could that be? Note: all data sources are APNIC unless otherwise stated.
  • 7. 7 7 Oh, 13.44% at 22 November 2016
  • 9. 9 9 AS1221 “Catch Them If You Can”
  • 10. 10 Then I’m “NANOG” Famous … Geoff Huston Andrew Khoo Source: Author & Andrew Khoo
  • 13. 13 IPv6 Deployment Strategy Where do you start? AUDIT • What is the current state of your network and what capability exists to support dual stack? PLANNING • Gather your information and resources before making decisions. Then DECIDE. TEAMWORK • Build your team up with knowledge and resources: you will need time and training. CONSULT • Talk to managers, executives and customer experience teams. More input = more traction.
  • 14. 14 14 IPv6 Capability Considerations When we say capable of ipv6, this refers to: • People – Engineers, Managers, Helpdesk, Field techs • Equipment – Core, Edge and Customer • Capital – Human, Financial • Suppliers of Transit and Peering – Are they capable? CPE IPv6 Support is often overlooked!
  • 15. 15 IPv6 Planning Considerations • Address Planning – Number One issue raised time and again! – “Measure Twice, Cut Once” as renumbering is always painful. – Be Generous with what you keep in reserve. – Review it against all progress during deployment. • Deployment Planning – You can only start at your border routers, why? – Pick a service to do first, like DNS or WWW, end-to-end testing. – Then slowly over Core, Intermediate and then BNG+CPE.
  • 16. 16 IPv4 Depletion: “Blood From A Stone” • NAT444 aka Double NAT aka The NAT has been NATed. • NAT64/DNS64, aka “Hey, try this ipv6 address instead.” • XLAT464 aka “You can’t bypass my NAT64 now.” • Above will generate end user complaints. • But you can deploy dual stack alongside above. • The real solution is “IPv6 before IPv4” and make it stick.
  • 17. 17 IPv4 Depletion … • The cost of ipv4 is too high. • Price plateau due to the finding the maximum willingness-to-pay. • Capital better spent elsewhere, even on LSN and CGN hardware. Market Signal: • A price drop means IPv6 has “won the deployment war” and no one (sensible) is buying it. IPv4 price history between 2014 and 2022 (data by IPv4.Global) Source: https://www.ipxo.com/blog/ipv4-price-history/
  • 18. 18 Terry Says “If you have not talked to everyone about your big technical plan for ipv6, you have not done enough consultation.” – Terry Sweetser “Move fast and break things.” – Mark Zuckerberg until 2014 ☺ “Prototype and test things in a lab, better to set that on fire than your production network!” – Terry Sweetser
  • 19. 19 Listen to everyone’s stories … • https://blog.apnic.net/2018/09/24/ipv6-at-dialog-axiata- switch-from-survival-to-innovation/ • Assessed Network, Significant Management Buy-In • Testing, testing, and more testing
  • 20. 20 How can we help you? techassist@apnic.net https://www.apnic.net/community/ipv6/deploy-ipv6/
  • 21. 21 IPv6 grants are open for applications IPv6 Deployment Grants are targeted to support concrete IPv6 deployment plans from network operators in the Asia Pacific region at different stages of development. ISIF Asia Grants Applications open all year round https://isif.asia/apply
  • 22. 22 APNIC Academy Online Courses Webinar courses Self-paced courses Virtual Labs Technical Assistance Book an Expert
  • 23. 23 Join Orbit • Evolution of mailing lists with social media features • To make active, online participation easier • THE place for the APNIC community to connect, discuss, and share information for APNIC SIGs and working groups, community topics, general discussion and announcements https://orbit.apnic.net/news-feed/
  • 24. 24 24 Next time: RPKI Validation https://stats.labs.apnic.net/rpki/LK
  • 25. 25 Questions? Many thanks for your attention!