Oh... that's ransomware and... look behind you a three-headed Monkey

1 ©2020 RSA Security LLC or its affiliates. All rights reserved.©2020 RSA Security LLC or its affiliates. All rights reserved.
OH... THAT'S RANSOMWARE AND...
LOOK BEHIND YOU…
A THREE-HEADED MONKEY!...
A flamboyant tale of swashbucklers and leakware....
CONFIDENTIAL

2 ©2020 RSA Security LLC or its affiliates. All rights reserved.
Who we are...
Evolution of the Ransom-world
From Cryptware to Leakware
The Rise of the MaaS
A very recent Ransomware case…
Negotiation, investigation and recovery…
Lesson learned
AGENDA

I am a Senior Principal Consultant and a leading figure of the RSA IR Team
operating worldwide.
I started my career cracking software in 1985 with a Commodore C64…
I decided to get out of the cracking scene in early 2000s and for about three
years I remained focused on Networking… until Nimda and Blaster came out
and testing networks and systems security became an interesting career…
I worked on the offensive side until 2009 when I jumped onto the IR
bandwagon.
Since then, I got busy with engagement around the world covering investigation
in banks, military, governments and telco companies.
STEFANO MACCAGLIA

MARCO FAGGIAN
I am a Senior Consultant for Incident Response operating in the EMEA area.
I joined RSA in 2012 as Delivery Specialist performing implementation, design
and analytics support to customers globally.
From 2016 I am part of the RSA Incident Response team and I participate to
engagements covering Private and Public companies and the Telco sector.
Graduated in Computer Engineering in Padua, I started my career by dealing
with issues related to computer security, collaborating with different
consultancy companies located in Italy and in UK.
My actual role led me to follow some of the most important customers in the
EMEA region.

▪ If we look at the common definition of Ransomware, we stumble on something like this…
Evolution of the ransom-world
Ransomware is malware that employs encryption to hold a victim’s information at ransom.
A user or organization’s critical data is encrypted so that they cannot access files, databases, or applications.
A ransom is then demanded to provide access.
Ransomware is often designed to spread across a network and target database and file servers and can thus quickly paralyze
an entire organization.
It is a growing threat, generating billions of dollars in payments to cybercriminals and inflicting significant damage and
expenses for businesses and governmental organizations.
▪ Are we sure this description is exhaustive nowadays???

• Let’s just play with this…
• Do you see anything strange in this ransomware message?...
• C’mon… don’t focus on the fact they hacked the network…
there is more in this message…
Evolution of the
ransom-world

• Look!... A the three headed monkey!...
Evolution of the
ransom-world

▪ Since December 2019, ransomware operators have been using leakware/ransomware hybrid attacks
more and more often.
▪ These attacks combine the classic ransomware attack with a leakware attack.
Evolution of the Ransom-world
In a classic
ransomware attack,
the victim’s data is
encrypted and is
decrypted after the
victim pays a
ransom.
In a hybrid attack,
the data is stolen,
then encrypted.
The victim is
blackmailed with the
data being released
publicly unless he
pays a certain fee.
In a classic
ransomware attack,
the Ransomware is
the main tool.
In a hybrid attack,
the Ransomware is
just one of the tools.

Long story short…
They just forgot to
tell us:

Hybrid Attacks
• In a hybrid attack, the data is first
stolen, then encrypted.
• Then the victim is asked to pay the
ransom for decryption.
• If the victim declines to pay the
ransom, the attackers threaten him
to release the stolen data publicly.
• In some cases, business partners
and/or customers of the victim are
also informed of the impending
data release to put even more
pressure on the victim.
This strategy is a “game-changer” as it introduces new techniques and new actors…
let’s see an example…

The Malware-as-a-Service

MaaS auction example

17 ©2020 RSA Security LLC or its affiliates. All rights reserved.©2020 RSA Security LLC or its affiliates.
All rights reserved.
A recent case
C O N F I D E N T I A L

19

20

21

Nefilim Ransomware banner

23
Spearphish
email
Macro in
Weaponized
Document
CommandLine
Powershell
downloads
Emotet
Emotet
Nefilim
Ransomware
Disable AV
Data harvesting
Credential theft
TrickBot
Drop final
stage
If the system is of
interest Emotet
accesses a
dropzone
Emotet
downloads
Trickbot
C&C
Dropzone
HTTPS
HTTPS
HTTPS
Look behind you… a one-headed human...

24

25

A Second case

27 ©2020 RSA Security LLC or its affiliates. All rights reserved. C O N F I D E N T I A L
▪ On a lazy morning in a far land… a customer IPS sent an alert to the SOC:
Dead Men Tell No Tales
▪ Due the fact that the customer has a retainer contract in place with RSA, SOC team decide to open
a call to verify if the IPS alert is anything to worry about… more a scruple from the SOC team,
than a real point of attention.
“Possible Metasploit Reverse HTTPS traffic”

▪ RSA NetWitness packet was already in place on the main datacenter to monitor the network traffic.
Dead Men Tell No Tales
▪ When the incident occurred, the Customer was not having an EDR solution in place, so RSA IR
Team proceeded to deploy RSA NetWitness Endpoint and started to distribute the agent on all the
involved hosts.

▪ EURMILLAP3275 contacts the link included on the email and few minutes after starts to
communicate on SSL with 2 more hosts.
Patient Zero analysis
No website associate
to the hostname and no
information on Google
about it!
Organization (O) and
Organizational Unit (OU)
on the certificate
Pretend to be signed by a
CA but the CA chain was
not real
Looking for all the SSL traffic
with similar charatteristics allow
RSA analysts to uncover all the
C2 stations used by the attacker.

Patient Zero analysis
The two TXT files, with a name formed
by strings of random characters,
saved in c:ProgramDataMicrosoft
are actually the two javascript that
allow communication with the C2
Through the endpoint analysis performed using NetWitness Endpoint, RSA analyst was able to retrieve part of the
malware artifacts used for the initial infection.

The Malware infection flow

On the same client RSA was able to identify a command line Active Directory query tool called:
Patient zero analysis
File has been stored under
c:WindowsTemp and
executed on the day of the
initial infection, presumably to
enumerate the the Active
Directory servers.
RSA was not able to recover the data exfiltrated due the missing of an EDR in place during the attack.
AdFind.exe

Living-off-the-land
attacks
• Attacker behavior that uses tools or features that already exist in the target
environment.
• Using pre-existing software avoids the process being flagged as suspicious
and reduce the possibility to be intercepted.
• Distinguish malicious use of built-in tools versus the authorized use of
tools by the system administrator can be tough for the analyst.
• Additionally, the attacker is secure to find the correct version of the
software on each machine, don’t need to be warried about compatibility of
it is artifacts.
• Attacker tend to use fileless attack where the resources used are not written
to disk. Thinks that stay in memory are much harder to both detect and to
find later.

To protect and serve…

Advices for the
Negotiation
• When the Ransomware is detonated it will display
information about on how to contact (the crime gang) to
pay the fee that they are looking for and receive the key to
unencrypt the data.
• While we recommend not to pay, unless critical to keep the
business on, we advise to open the channel for a
conversation with the cybercriminals.
• Once authorized by counsel/client, contact is made with
the gang on the dark web to advise them that systems are
impacted and we would like to discuss getting our data
back, or data not being released to public sites, etc.
• We provide them with a known encrypted file to make sure
they are able to unencrypt and provide us back the known
file to ensure that actually have the decryptor.
• In addition, to gain credibility, we have a discussion about
how to lower price, funds available, etc…
• There is always room in negotiating a fee lower, and the
cybercriminals expect that.

▪ In the last twelve months we participated to the negotiation in several cases and we learned some
important aspects:
▪ Do not underestimate the negotiation from the Cybercriminal gang, they are often skilled individual
with wide experience on such topics… in fact, in one case, we clearly faced a conversation with a
former FSB negotiator (he told us about that).
▪ The conversation should be strictly limited in number of participants. In one case, when an
uninvited participant joined the negotiation at a later stage, the attacker get off the channel and the
data went immediately released…
▪ The attackers are willing to explain how good they are… this is the only weak spot we found during
the negotiations… you can leverage on this to collect some critical items useful for the IR
investigation.
▪ The attacker is usually not keen to overreact, he knows he has some good files in his hand... He
reviewed his stuff before detonating the ransomware, so every attempt to downsize the value of the
stolen material, during the negotiation, will fail… sometime will fail miserably…
Negotiation pitfalls

LESSON LEARNED
Don’t let the pressure guide you… Always think about possibilities…
The blackhats tell you they are perfect… but they are not…
The key is to use the negotiation as a functional step
Don’t take shortcuts… try to support the investigation
Think positive…

Post-Incident
recommendations
• Even with the decryptor, unencrypting the data is a painful and costly experience for a
company...
• Our continuous message to clients is to secure and segment their infrastructure so these
attacks are not as successful. That is cheaper than the response efforts that occur with a breach.
• The anonymity of the Internet and the lack of international cooperation between the
countries have really hampered the ability of law enforcement/prosecutors to take any real
meaningful action to identify and prosecute these OC (organized crime) and nation-state
actors.
• Thus, since this avenue is a long shot to dissuade threat actors, it is up to companies to do a
better job of protecting themselves

Q’n’A

Thanks!

Oh... that's ransomware and... look behind you a three-headed Monkey

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to Oh... that's ransomware and... look behind you a three-headed Monkey (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Oh... that's ransomware and... look behind you a three-headed Monkey