SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Rapat Koordinasi Pengendalian, Evaluasi APBD dan APBN Semester I Tahun 2014 
Bappeda - Provinsi Jawa Barat 
18 September 2014 
Edy Hardiyanto
Output 
Membedakan Monitoring dan Evaluasi (M&E) 
Menceritakan contoh pelaksanaan M&E 
Mengenali masalah dan solusi M&E 
Outcome 
Kesamaan Pemahaman dan Persepsi terhadap M&E 
Impact 
Penyelenggaraan M&E yang berhasil guna dan berdaya guna
Siklus Perencanaan 
Solihin, Dadang (2004:5)
Puradimaja, Deny Juanda (2014:27)
Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:3)
Penilaian hasil dan dampak program
The social systems that have to be dealt with through planning and implementation of plans consist of human actors who may often not play their roles as envisioned by the planner but act under the influence of the pressures in life that they actually experience. 
Saeed, Khalid dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994:1)
Sterman, John (2013)
Hardiyanto, Edy (2013)
Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:14)
Penilaian hasil dan dampak program
*Time 
*Cost 
*Resources 
*Internal Factors 
*Ethical and Legal Considerations 
*Core Competenecies (talent, ability, and knowledge) 
*Implementation 
Witzel, Morgan (2004:13 - 14)
Wolff, James (2011)
Wolff, James (2011)
Wolff, James (2011)
UNICEF (-:4)
Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:9) 
Kurniadi (2013:15)
Flipp, Chris (2014)
DrDawg, Tamuc (2011)
* 
Chaplowe, Scott (2012:2-5)
Schmidt, Terry (2013)
Penilaian hasil dan dampak program
Penilaian hasil dan dampak program
⁻Chaplowe, Scott (2012) Monitoring and Evaluation Planning for Projects & Program. ON- LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejVmqSxF33Q diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.50 
⁻DrDawg, Tamuc (2011) Differences in Quantitative and Qualitative Research. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxFuw22bPnE diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.50 
⁻Flipp, Chris (2014) Qualitative vs Quantitative. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X-QSU6-hPU diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam 01.50 
⁻Hardiyanto, Edy (2013) HDI Parameters that imply NFE towards LIFE LONG EDUCATION ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.slideshare.net/yangyatao/1-hdi-parameters-that- imply-nfe-towards-lifelong-education-190913 diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam 01.50
⁻Khalid, Saeed dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994) Development Planning and Policy Design. A System dynamics approach. Englad: Avebury 
⁻Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010) Handbook on Impact Evaluation. World Bank: Washington DC 
⁻Kurniadi (2013) Evaluasi Wajib Belajar Pendidikan Dasar di Kota Bandung dalam WARTA BAPPEDA Volume 21 Nomor 4 Oktober Desember 2013. Bappeda Provinsi Jawa Barat: Bandung 
⁻Lumadue, Rick dan Rusty Waller (2013) Educational Research Today. ON-LINE tersedia pada: https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/educational-research- today/id691632696?ls=1 diunduh Jumat 5 September 2014 jam 07.50 
⁻Nuthall, Keith (2013) Happy Talks dalam Accounting and Business. International Edition. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://issuu.com/accaglobal_publications/docs/ab_int_sept13_comp_rgb_150 diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 14.50
⁻Puradimaja, Deny Juanda (2014) Harmonisasi dan Sinergi Perencanaan Provinsi dan Kabupaten/Kota Tahun 2015. Paparan Kepala Bappeda Jawa Barat dalam Musrenbang Senin, 14 April 2014. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://bappeda.jabarprov.go.id/assets/images/upload/paparan/paparan%20kepala%20bappeda%20hari%20pertama%20musrenbang%2014%20april%202014.pptx diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.40 
⁻Solihin, Dadang (2004) Pembangunan Masyarakat Kota. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://issuu.com/dadangsolihin/docs/pembangunan_kota Senin 4 Agustus 2014 jam 17.30 
⁻Schmidt, Terry (2013) Introduces to Logical Framework. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IX09_y4O1aI Kamis 7 Agustus 2014 jam 09.50
⁻Sterman, John (2013) Introduction to System Dynamic: Overview. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnTwZVviXyY&list=PLAob8AuLt-J9t- eJlIWlkup-EaFf5H61L diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.10 
⁻The Arizona Public Health Training Center (AzPHTC) (2012) An Introduction to Strategic Planning. ON-LINE tersedia pada: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IArJqjJPTLI&list=UUCGBhLnfcuoaZpT_QfgURNg diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.20 
⁻UNICEF (2012) Guide for Monitoring and Evaluation - Making a Difference? ON- LINE tersedia pada: http://preval.org/documentos/00473.pdf diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.10 
⁻Witzel, Morgen (2004) Management -The Basic. Routledge: London 
⁻Wolff, James (2011) Monitoring and Evaluation. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CszDMlXjz8E diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 04.30
Edy Hardiyanto PO BOX 8416 Lembang Bandung 40791 Fax +62-22-7278005 Ponsel +62-(0)-8562127048 
Terima Kasih

More Related Content

PDF
University of The Future 2012
PPT
Disconnected Random Photographs
PDF
Analytics GAE - Plurk Avatar History 20090825-20090909
PPSX
大山里的日子(一)
PDF
981金融機構與管理辯論報告(反對方)
PDF
Boot to Gecko – The Web as a Platform
PDF
Jurnal gandrung vol2 no1 (e jurnal)
DOC
Talent Revolution Workshop
University of The Future 2012
Disconnected Random Photographs
Analytics GAE - Plurk Avatar History 20090825-20090909
大山里的日子(一)
981金融機構與管理辯論報告(反對方)
Boot to Gecko – The Web as a Platform
Jurnal gandrung vol2 no1 (e jurnal)
Talent Revolution Workshop

Viewers also liked (19)

PDF
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
PPT
ODP
Styc Report
PDF
2012 11 07 pre incubator workshop
PDF
Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: FrenetiCore
PPT
Session3 pl online_course_31_may2011
PDF
2013 04 HAA Accelerator & Sustainability App Workshop
PPT
Blue Rose Jf
PDF
WOLLEN SIE Q1 SCHAUEN?
PDF
2013.04.25 Learning Sessions 6 - HITS Theatre
PDF
Beautiful Data Visualisation & D3
DOCX
Raisa anthony web programming 1st week
PPSX
大山里的人(一)
PDF
Usabilities
PDF
Proyek Stargate
PDF
Governance as Sustainability in the Enterprise Architecture Discipline
PPT
Session2_WMU_Plain_Language_Online_26May2011
PDF
MOSAICA: Semantically Enhanced Multifaceted Collaborative Access to Cultural ...
Judaica europeana dovwinerjudaicalibrarians
Styc Report
2012 11 07 pre incubator workshop
Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: FrenetiCore
Session3 pl online_course_31_may2011
2013 04 HAA Accelerator & Sustainability App Workshop
Blue Rose Jf
WOLLEN SIE Q1 SCHAUEN?
2013.04.25 Learning Sessions 6 - HITS Theatre
Beautiful Data Visualisation & D3
Raisa anthony web programming 1st week
大山里的人(一)
Usabilities
Proyek Stargate
Governance as Sustainability in the Enterprise Architecture Discipline
Session2_WMU_Plain_Language_Online_26May2011
MOSAICA: Semantically Enhanced Multifaceted Collaborative Access to Cultural ...
Ad

Similar to Penilaian hasil dan dampak program (20)

PDF
Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)
DOCX
Shashikant n sharma cv 2011 new
PDF
WhatsApp an educational treasure hunt with mobile phones
PDF
ZONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF HERITAGE ZONE BHOPAL
PDF
#oersymposium2014 S2 P4 Shironika
PPTX
Seda workshop - exploring the future
PDF
Applying and translating learning design and analytics approaches in your ins...
PPTX
160405 zuyd hogeschool video teaching and blended learning (slideshare)
PPTX
Section E: Existing evaluation and monitoring of TOD
PPTX
What does an effective e learning video look like?
PDF
Ayu Lestari S.
PDF
CV_MohitGoyal
PDF
Brief resume with recent publication augest 2021
PDF
PDU 214 Methods of Observation & Interviewing: Interviewing Skills & Techniques
PDF
RECOD at MediaEval 2014: Violent Scenes Detection Task
DOCX
CV - Indita Hendraningtyas - Female
DOC
De 1b report
PPTX
Mentors as connectors
PDF
Towards Speculative Services for an Inclusive Society
PPTX
Online Teaching & Learning: Designing for Student Engagement
Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)
Shashikant n sharma cv 2011 new
WhatsApp an educational treasure hunt with mobile phones
ZONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF HERITAGE ZONE BHOPAL
#oersymposium2014 S2 P4 Shironika
Seda workshop - exploring the future
Applying and translating learning design and analytics approaches in your ins...
160405 zuyd hogeschool video teaching and blended learning (slideshare)
Section E: Existing evaluation and monitoring of TOD
What does an effective e learning video look like?
Ayu Lestari S.
CV_MohitGoyal
Brief resume with recent publication augest 2021
PDU 214 Methods of Observation & Interviewing: Interviewing Skills & Techniques
RECOD at MediaEval 2014: Violent Scenes Detection Task
CV - Indita Hendraningtyas - Female
De 1b report
Mentors as connectors
Towards Speculative Services for an Inclusive Society
Online Teaching & Learning: Designing for Student Engagement
Ad

More from Centre for Adult Learning and Literacy (20)

PDF
Paparan Gema Tunas PKBM 2024 - Peran dan Kontribusi SWBB
PDF
Diagnostik pada Sektor Bidang Pendidikan
PDF
Paparan DSP, VIII - 2022 Medan
PPTX
Teknik Proyeksi dan Model Simulasi
PDF
Penguatan Administrasi Lembaga PKBM
PDF
Monitoring Supervisi Kab. sumedang
PDF
Standar Nasional Pendidikan
PDF
Recognizing ECCE program planning through rembug warga mechanism
PDF
Life-skills Service Unit
PPTX
Diagnosis Sektor Pendidikan
PDF
PDF
Education in Sector Diagnostic
PDF
action plan on educational planning
PDF
Projection along with Educational Planning
PDF
Implementasi Perdagangan Bursa, LP3I Cirebon - shared (030515)
PDF
Model Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan
PDF
Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan (040215)
PDF
Implikasi Pelaksanaan Undang Undang Desa (161115)
Paparan Gema Tunas PKBM 2024 - Peran dan Kontribusi SWBB
Diagnostik pada Sektor Bidang Pendidikan
Paparan DSP, VIII - 2022 Medan
Teknik Proyeksi dan Model Simulasi
Penguatan Administrasi Lembaga PKBM
Monitoring Supervisi Kab. sumedang
Standar Nasional Pendidikan
Recognizing ECCE program planning through rembug warga mechanism
Life-skills Service Unit
Diagnosis Sektor Pendidikan
Education in Sector Diagnostic
action plan on educational planning
Projection along with Educational Planning
Implementasi Perdagangan Bursa, LP3I Cirebon - shared (030515)
Model Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan
Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan (040215)
Implikasi Pelaksanaan Undang Undang Desa (161115)

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Phillips model training for evaluation pdf
PDF
CISSP Domain 6: Security Assessment and Testing
PDF
1_Corporate Goverance presentation topic
PDF
Contemporary management and it's content
PPTX
Basics of Project Management for development of leadership skills in practice
PPTX
Human resources management -job perception concept
PDF
The Untold Story of Swami Vijay Kumar Durai: Building PRS International
PPTX
2. CYCLE OF FUNCTIONING RIFLE -PP Presentation..pptx
PDF
The Sustainable Site: Boosting Productivity in Construction – Pipe Dream or P...
PPTX
Press Release Importance & Structure.pptx
PPTX
Course Overview of the Course Titled.pptx
PPTX
TCoE_IT_Concrete industry.why is it required
PDF
Timeless Leadership Principles from History’s Greatest Figures by Alfonso Ken...
PDF
CHAPTER 15- Manageement of Nursing Educational Institutions- Staffing and st...
PDF
Human resources management is a best management
PPTX
Project Management Methods PERT-and-CPM.pptx
PDF
Equity at the Helm_ Guiding Schools Through Inclusive Leadership by Dr.pdf
PPTX
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW IN UGANDA.pptx
PPTX
Strategic Plan 2023-2024 Presentation.pptx
PPTX
Self-Awareness and Values Development presentation
Phillips model training for evaluation pdf
CISSP Domain 6: Security Assessment and Testing
1_Corporate Goverance presentation topic
Contemporary management and it's content
Basics of Project Management for development of leadership skills in practice
Human resources management -job perception concept
The Untold Story of Swami Vijay Kumar Durai: Building PRS International
2. CYCLE OF FUNCTIONING RIFLE -PP Presentation..pptx
The Sustainable Site: Boosting Productivity in Construction – Pipe Dream or P...
Press Release Importance & Structure.pptx
Course Overview of the Course Titled.pptx
TCoE_IT_Concrete industry.why is it required
Timeless Leadership Principles from History’s Greatest Figures by Alfonso Ken...
CHAPTER 15- Manageement of Nursing Educational Institutions- Staffing and st...
Human resources management is a best management
Project Management Methods PERT-and-CPM.pptx
Equity at the Helm_ Guiding Schools Through Inclusive Leadership by Dr.pdf
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW IN UGANDA.pptx
Strategic Plan 2023-2024 Presentation.pptx
Self-Awareness and Values Development presentation

Penilaian hasil dan dampak program

  • 1. Rapat Koordinasi Pengendalian, Evaluasi APBD dan APBN Semester I Tahun 2014 Bappeda - Provinsi Jawa Barat 18 September 2014 Edy Hardiyanto
  • 2. Output Membedakan Monitoring dan Evaluasi (M&E) Menceritakan contoh pelaksanaan M&E Mengenali masalah dan solusi M&E Outcome Kesamaan Pemahaman dan Persepsi terhadap M&E Impact Penyelenggaraan M&E yang berhasil guna dan berdaya guna
  • 3. Siklus Perencanaan Solihin, Dadang (2004:5)
  • 5. Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:3)
  • 7. The social systems that have to be dealt with through planning and implementation of plans consist of human actors who may often not play their roles as envisioned by the planner but act under the influence of the pressures in life that they actually experience. Saeed, Khalid dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994:1)
  • 10. Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:14)
  • 12. *Time *Cost *Resources *Internal Factors *Ethical and Legal Considerations *Core Competenecies (talent, ability, and knowledge) *Implementation Witzel, Morgan (2004:13 - 14)
  • 17. Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:9) Kurniadi (2013:15)
  • 20. * Chaplowe, Scott (2012:2-5)
  • 24. ⁻Chaplowe, Scott (2012) Monitoring and Evaluation Planning for Projects & Program. ON- LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejVmqSxF33Q diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.50 ⁻DrDawg, Tamuc (2011) Differences in Quantitative and Qualitative Research. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxFuw22bPnE diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.50 ⁻Flipp, Chris (2014) Qualitative vs Quantitative. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X-QSU6-hPU diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam 01.50 ⁻Hardiyanto, Edy (2013) HDI Parameters that imply NFE towards LIFE LONG EDUCATION ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.slideshare.net/yangyatao/1-hdi-parameters-that- imply-nfe-towards-lifelong-education-190913 diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam 01.50
  • 25. ⁻Khalid, Saeed dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994) Development Planning and Policy Design. A System dynamics approach. Englad: Avebury ⁻Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010) Handbook on Impact Evaluation. World Bank: Washington DC ⁻Kurniadi (2013) Evaluasi Wajib Belajar Pendidikan Dasar di Kota Bandung dalam WARTA BAPPEDA Volume 21 Nomor 4 Oktober Desember 2013. Bappeda Provinsi Jawa Barat: Bandung ⁻Lumadue, Rick dan Rusty Waller (2013) Educational Research Today. ON-LINE tersedia pada: https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/educational-research- today/id691632696?ls=1 diunduh Jumat 5 September 2014 jam 07.50 ⁻Nuthall, Keith (2013) Happy Talks dalam Accounting and Business. International Edition. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://issuu.com/accaglobal_publications/docs/ab_int_sept13_comp_rgb_150 diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 14.50
  • 26. ⁻Puradimaja, Deny Juanda (2014) Harmonisasi dan Sinergi Perencanaan Provinsi dan Kabupaten/Kota Tahun 2015. Paparan Kepala Bappeda Jawa Barat dalam Musrenbang Senin, 14 April 2014. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://bappeda.jabarprov.go.id/assets/images/upload/paparan/paparan%20kepala%20bappeda%20hari%20pertama%20musrenbang%2014%20april%202014.pptx diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.40 ⁻Solihin, Dadang (2004) Pembangunan Masyarakat Kota. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://issuu.com/dadangsolihin/docs/pembangunan_kota Senin 4 Agustus 2014 jam 17.30 ⁻Schmidt, Terry (2013) Introduces to Logical Framework. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IX09_y4O1aI Kamis 7 Agustus 2014 jam 09.50
  • 27. ⁻Sterman, John (2013) Introduction to System Dynamic: Overview. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnTwZVviXyY&list=PLAob8AuLt-J9t- eJlIWlkup-EaFf5H61L diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.10 ⁻The Arizona Public Health Training Center (AzPHTC) (2012) An Introduction to Strategic Planning. ON-LINE tersedia pada: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IArJqjJPTLI&list=UUCGBhLnfcuoaZpT_QfgURNg diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.20 ⁻UNICEF (2012) Guide for Monitoring and Evaluation - Making a Difference? ON- LINE tersedia pada: http://preval.org/documentos/00473.pdf diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.10 ⁻Witzel, Morgen (2004) Management -The Basic. Routledge: London ⁻Wolff, James (2011) Monitoring and Evaluation. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CszDMlXjz8E diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 04.30
  • 28. Edy Hardiyanto PO BOX 8416 Lembang Bandung 40791 Fax +62-22-7278005 Ponsel +62-(0)-8562127048 Terima Kasih