SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Rapat Koordinasi Pengendalian, Evaluasi APBD dan APBN Semester I Tahun 2014
Bappeda - Provinsi Jawa Barat
18 September 2014
Edy Hardiyanto
Output
Membedakan Monitoring dan Evaluasi (M&E)
Menceritakan contoh pelaksanaan M&E
Mengenali masalah dan solusi M&E
Outcome
Kesamaan Pemahaman dan Persepsi terhadap M&E
Impact
Penyelenggaraan M&E yang berhasil guna dan berdaya guna
SiklusPerencanaan
Solihin, Dadang (2004:5)
Puradimaja, Deny Juanda (2014:27)
Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan
Hussain A. Samad (2010:3)
Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)
The social systems that have to be dealt with
through planning and implementation of plans
consist of human actors who may often not play their
roles as envisioned by the planner but act under the
influence of the pressures in life that they actually
experience.
Saeed, Khalid dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994:1)
Sterman, John (2013)
Hardiyanto, Edy (2013)
Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:14)
Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)
* Time
* Cost
* Resources
* Internal Factors
* Ethical and Legal Considerations
* Core Competenecies (talent, ability, and
knowledge)
* Implementation
Witzel, Morgan (2004:13 - 14)
Wolff, James (2011)
Wolff, James (2011)
Wolff, James (2011)
UNICEF (-:4)
Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B
Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad
(2010:9) Kurniadi (2013:15)
Flipp, Chris (2014)
DrDawg, Tamuc (2011)
*
Chaplowe, Scott (2012:2-5)
Schmidt, Terry (2013)
Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)
Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)
⁻ Chaplowe, Scott (2012) Monitoring and Evaluation Planning for Projects & Program. ON-
LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejVmqSxF33Q diunduh Kamis 4
September 2014 jam 01.50
⁻ DrDawg, Tamuc (2011) Differences in Quantitative and Qualitative Research. ON-LINE
tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxFuw22bPnE diunduh Kamis 4
September 2014 jam 01.50
⁻ Flipp, Chris (2014) Qualitative vs Quantitative. ON-LINE tersedia pada:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X-QSU6-hPU diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014
jam 01.50
⁻ Hardiyanto, Edy (2013) HDI Parameters that imply NFE towards LIFE LONG EDUCATION
ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.slideshare.net/yangyatao/1-hdi-parameters-that-
imply-nfe-towards-lifelong-education-190913 diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam
01.50
⁻ Khalid, Saeed dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994) Development Planning and Policy Design. A
System dynamics approach. Englad: Avebury
⁻ Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010) Handbook on
Impact Evaluation. World Bank: Washington DC
⁻ Kurniadi (2013) Evaluasi Wajib Belajar Pendidikan Dasar di Kota Bandung dalam WARTA
BAPPEDA Volume 21 Nomor 4 Oktober Desember 2013. Bappeda Provinsi Jawa Barat:
Bandung
⁻ Lumadue, Rick dan Rusty Waller (2013) Educational Research Today. ON-LINE tersedia
pada: https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/educational-research-
today/id691632696?ls=1 diunduh Jumat 5 September 2014 jam 07.50
⁻ Nuthall, Keith (2013) Happy Talks dalam Accounting and Business. International Edition.
ON-LINE tersedia pada:
http://issuu.com/accaglobal_publications/docs/ab_int_sept13_comp_rgb_150 diunduh
Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 14.50
⁻ Puradimaja, Deny Juanda (2014) Harmonisasi dan Sinergi Perencanaan Provinsi
dan Kabupaten/Kota Tahun 2015. Paparan Kepala Bappeda Jawa Barat dalam
Musrenbang Senin, 14 April 2014. ON-LINE tersedia pada:
http://bappeda.jabarprov.go.id/assets/images/upload/paparan/paparan%20ke
pala%20bappeda%20hari%20pertama%20musrenbang%2014%20april%202014.pptx
diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.40
⁻ Solihin, Dadang (2004) Pembangunan Masyarakat Kota. ON-LINE tersedia pada:
http://issuu.com/dadangsolihin/docs/pembangunan_kota Senin 4 Agustus 2014
jam 17.30
⁻ Schmidt, Terry (2013) Introduces to Logical Framework. ON-LINE tersedia pada:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IX09_y4O1aI Kamis 7 Agustus 2014 jam 09.50
⁻ Sterman, John (2013) Introduction to System Dynamic: Overview. ON-LINE
tersedia pada:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnTwZVviXyY&list=PLAob8AuLt-J9t-
eJlIWlkup-EaFf5H61L diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.10
⁻ The Arizona Public Health Training Center (AzPHTC) (2012) An Introduction to
Strategic Planning. ON-LINE tersedia pada:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IArJqjJPTLI&list=UUCGBhLnfcuoaZpT_QfgU
RNg diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.20
⁻ UNICEF (2012) Guide for Monitoring and Evaluation - Making a Difference? ON-
LINE tersedia pada: http://preval.org/documentos/00473.pdf diunduh Kamis 4
September 2014 jam 02.10
⁻ Witzel, Morgen (2004) Management -The Basic. Routledge: London
⁻ Wolff, James (2011) Monitoring and Evaluation. ON-LINE tersedia pada:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CszDMlXjz8E diunduh Kamis 4 September
2014 jam 04.30
Edy Hardiyanto
PO BOX 8416 Lembang Bandung 40791
Fax +62-22-7278005
Ponsel +62-(0)-8562127048
Terima Kasih

More Related Content

DOC
Offerman Letter for B Smith
PPT
Imagine Austin: The Way Forward
PDF
Open Web Games using HTML5 & JavaScript
PDF
Majalah INFO-UFO no 01
PPT
YPT10J BENUTZERHANDBUCH
PPS
LOS ASTRONOMOS-3
PPT
六合彩,香港六合彩 » SlideShare
PDF
HTML5 Games - Not Just for Gamers
Offerman Letter for B Smith
Imagine Austin: The Way Forward
Open Web Games using HTML5 & JavaScript
Majalah INFO-UFO no 01
YPT10J BENUTZERHANDBUCH
LOS ASTRONOMOS-3
六合彩,香港六合彩 » SlideShare
HTML5 Games - Not Just for Gamers

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
Melbourne Geek Night - Boot to Gecko – The Web as a Platform
PDF
MOSAICA: Semantically Enhanced Multifaceted Collaborative Access to Cultural ...
PDF
Calculating building heights using a phone camera
PPT
Ramadan 2008
PPT
E write writing for the web 1-2 june2011
PDF
WCIT 2010 Dov Winer
PPT
Session3 pl online_course_22_september2011
PDF
MozTW Off-Line Paper at 2009
PPS
Wilfreda - Oscar
PDF
Samsung YP-U4 Bilder
PDF
Helmi Suhaimi
PDF
ViziCities: Making SimCity for the Real World
DOCX
Ettore
PPT
Session3 pl online_course_22_september2011
PDF
040709 Iajgs Powerful Technologies Genealogy
PPT
Session1 pl online_course_8_september2011
PDF
Usabilities
PPSX
IIG_IFCA_Presentation-0909
PPT
Semibase Portfolio
PPT
E write - loc advanced writing for the web 23 may2011
Melbourne Geek Night - Boot to Gecko – The Web as a Platform
MOSAICA: Semantically Enhanced Multifaceted Collaborative Access to Cultural ...
Calculating building heights using a phone camera
Ramadan 2008
E write writing for the web 1-2 june2011
WCIT 2010 Dov Winer
Session3 pl online_course_22_september2011
MozTW Off-Line Paper at 2009
Wilfreda - Oscar
Samsung YP-U4 Bilder
Helmi Suhaimi
ViziCities: Making SimCity for the Real World
Ettore
Session3 pl online_course_22_september2011
040709 Iajgs Powerful Technologies Genealogy
Session1 pl online_course_8_september2011
Usabilities
IIG_IFCA_Presentation-0909
Semibase Portfolio
E write - loc advanced writing for the web 23 may2011
Ad

Similar to Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914) (20)

PDF
Penilaian hasil dan dampak program
PDF
Niharika Bhatia
DOCX
Ravindra Resume new
DOCX
PDF
4th Wheel Social Impact - Company Presentation
PDF
Latest achmad noviar CV with photo
PDF
Tracking the Global Goals in India
DOCX
Dattatraya suresha naik
DOCX
Dattatraya Suresha Naik
PDF
Towards Speculative Services for an Inclusive Society
DOCX
Shujun Jiang education management in education
DOCX
MSW with 4.9 years experience in Community Development program
PPTX
Financial inclusion in rural areas
DOC
Tatasteel_CV
PDF
India’s Neighbourhood: Challenges in the Next Two Decades
PDF
Urban WASH Strategy_ WaterAid India
PDF
ZONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF HERITAGE ZONE BHOPAL
PPT
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
DOC
De 1b report
PDF
APHA Presentation HIA 10 27 2012
Penilaian hasil dan dampak program
Niharika Bhatia
Ravindra Resume new
4th Wheel Social Impact - Company Presentation
Latest achmad noviar CV with photo
Tracking the Global Goals in India
Dattatraya suresha naik
Dattatraya Suresha Naik
Towards Speculative Services for an Inclusive Society
Shujun Jiang education management in education
MSW with 4.9 years experience in Community Development program
Financial inclusion in rural areas
Tatasteel_CV
India’s Neighbourhood: Challenges in the Next Two Decades
Urban WASH Strategy_ WaterAid India
ZONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF HERITAGE ZONE BHOPAL
Evaluation of the SEA for the Dhaka Metropolitan Plan
De 1b report
APHA Presentation HIA 10 27 2012
Ad

More from Centre for Adult Learning and Literacy (20)

PDF
Paparan Gema Tunas PKBM 2024 - Peran dan Kontribusi SWBB
PDF
Diagnostik pada Sektor Bidang Pendidikan
PDF
Paparan DSP, VIII - 2022 Medan
PPTX
Teknik Proyeksi dan Model Simulasi
PDF
Penguatan Administrasi Lembaga PKBM
PDF
Monitoring Supervisi Kab. sumedang
PDF
Standar Nasional Pendidikan
PDF
Recognizing ECCE program planning through rembug warga mechanism
PDF
Life-skills Service Unit
PPTX
Diagnosis Sektor Pendidikan
PDF
PDF
Education in Sector Diagnostic
PDF
action plan on educational planning
PDF
Projection along with Educational Planning
PDF
Implementasi Perdagangan Bursa, LP3I Cirebon - shared (030515)
PDF
Model Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan
PDF
Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan (040215)
PDF
Implikasi Pelaksanaan Undang Undang Desa (161115)
Paparan Gema Tunas PKBM 2024 - Peran dan Kontribusi SWBB
Diagnostik pada Sektor Bidang Pendidikan
Paparan DSP, VIII - 2022 Medan
Teknik Proyeksi dan Model Simulasi
Penguatan Administrasi Lembaga PKBM
Monitoring Supervisi Kab. sumedang
Standar Nasional Pendidikan
Recognizing ECCE program planning through rembug warga mechanism
Life-skills Service Unit
Diagnosis Sektor Pendidikan
Education in Sector Diagnostic
action plan on educational planning
Projection along with Educational Planning
Implementasi Perdagangan Bursa, LP3I Cirebon - shared (030515)
Model Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan
Pembelajaran Pendidikan Keorangtuaan (040215)
Implikasi Pelaksanaan Undang Undang Desa (161115)

Penilaian Hasil dan Dampak Program - shared version (180914)

  • 1. Rapat Koordinasi Pengendalian, Evaluasi APBD dan APBN Semester I Tahun 2014 Bappeda - Provinsi Jawa Barat 18 September 2014 Edy Hardiyanto
  • 2. Output Membedakan Monitoring dan Evaluasi (M&E) Menceritakan contoh pelaksanaan M&E Mengenali masalah dan solusi M&E Outcome Kesamaan Pemahaman dan Persepsi terhadap M&E Impact Penyelenggaraan M&E yang berhasil guna dan berdaya guna
  • 5. Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:3)
  • 7. The social systems that have to be dealt with through planning and implementation of plans consist of human actors who may often not play their roles as envisioned by the planner but act under the influence of the pressures in life that they actually experience. Saeed, Khalid dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994:1)
  • 10. Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:14)
  • 12. * Time * Cost * Resources * Internal Factors * Ethical and Legal Considerations * Core Competenecies (talent, ability, and knowledge) * Implementation Witzel, Morgan (2004:13 - 14)
  • 17. Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010:9) Kurniadi (2013:15)
  • 24. ⁻ Chaplowe, Scott (2012) Monitoring and Evaluation Planning for Projects & Program. ON- LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejVmqSxF33Q diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.50 ⁻ DrDawg, Tamuc (2011) Differences in Quantitative and Qualitative Research. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxFuw22bPnE diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.50 ⁻ Flipp, Chris (2014) Qualitative vs Quantitative. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X-QSU6-hPU diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam 01.50 ⁻ Hardiyanto, Edy (2013) HDI Parameters that imply NFE towards LIFE LONG EDUCATION ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.slideshare.net/yangyatao/1-hdi-parameters-that- imply-nfe-towards-lifelong-education-190913 diunduh Senin, 15 September 2014 jam 01.50
  • 25. ⁻ Khalid, Saeed dan Dennis L. Meadows (1994) Development Planning and Policy Design. A System dynamics approach. Englad: Avebury ⁻ Khandker, Shahidur R, Gayatri B Koolwal dan Hussain A. Samad (2010) Handbook on Impact Evaluation. World Bank: Washington DC ⁻ Kurniadi (2013) Evaluasi Wajib Belajar Pendidikan Dasar di Kota Bandung dalam WARTA BAPPEDA Volume 21 Nomor 4 Oktober Desember 2013. Bappeda Provinsi Jawa Barat: Bandung ⁻ Lumadue, Rick dan Rusty Waller (2013) Educational Research Today. ON-LINE tersedia pada: https://itunes.apple.com/us/book/educational-research- today/id691632696?ls=1 diunduh Jumat 5 September 2014 jam 07.50 ⁻ Nuthall, Keith (2013) Happy Talks dalam Accounting and Business. International Edition. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://issuu.com/accaglobal_publications/docs/ab_int_sept13_comp_rgb_150 diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 14.50
  • 26. ⁻ Puradimaja, Deny Juanda (2014) Harmonisasi dan Sinergi Perencanaan Provinsi dan Kabupaten/Kota Tahun 2015. Paparan Kepala Bappeda Jawa Barat dalam Musrenbang Senin, 14 April 2014. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://bappeda.jabarprov.go.id/assets/images/upload/paparan/paparan%20ke pala%20bappeda%20hari%20pertama%20musrenbang%2014%20april%202014.pptx diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.40 ⁻ Solihin, Dadang (2004) Pembangunan Masyarakat Kota. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://issuu.com/dadangsolihin/docs/pembangunan_kota Senin 4 Agustus 2014 jam 17.30 ⁻ Schmidt, Terry (2013) Introduces to Logical Framework. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IX09_y4O1aI Kamis 7 Agustus 2014 jam 09.50
  • 27. ⁻ Sterman, John (2013) Introduction to System Dynamic: Overview. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnTwZVviXyY&list=PLAob8AuLt-J9t- eJlIWlkup-EaFf5H61L diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 01.10 ⁻ The Arizona Public Health Training Center (AzPHTC) (2012) An Introduction to Strategic Planning. ON-LINE tersedia pada: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IArJqjJPTLI&list=UUCGBhLnfcuoaZpT_QfgU RNg diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.20 ⁻ UNICEF (2012) Guide for Monitoring and Evaluation - Making a Difference? ON- LINE tersedia pada: http://preval.org/documentos/00473.pdf diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 02.10 ⁻ Witzel, Morgen (2004) Management -The Basic. Routledge: London ⁻ Wolff, James (2011) Monitoring and Evaluation. ON-LINE tersedia pada: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CszDMlXjz8E diunduh Kamis 4 September 2014 jam 04.30
  • 28. Edy Hardiyanto PO BOX 8416 Lembang Bandung 40791 Fax +62-22-7278005 Ponsel +62-(0)-8562127048 Terima Kasih