PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS AND EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT OF COOLING TOWER AT MTPS-I

© 2022, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 378
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS AND EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT OF
COOLING TOWER AT MTPS-I
Mr. N.THIRU SENTHIL ADHIBAN1, M.SUKEL AHAMED2, S.SUGUMAR3, P.NETHAJI4
1Head of the Department, 2,3,4 UG Scholar
1,2,3,4 Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Sengunthar Engineering College (Autonomus), Tiruchengode, Namakkal, India.
---------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - In thermal power station one of the main part is
condenser which cools the hot water. When cooling the hot
water, it becomes cold water. The how water temperature is
reduced by the cooling tower. When hot water enters into the
cross flow induced draft cooling tower and sprayed by the
nozzle, so that hot water is converted into cold water. The
effective cooling water is depends upon wet bulbtemperature,
dry bulb temperature, size and height. This project deals with
analysis of cooling tower which is one of the deciding factors
used for the power plant efficiency.
Key Words: Wet bulb temperature, dry bulb temperature,
cooling water range, cooling water approach, inlet air and
water temperature, outlet air and water temperature etc.
1.INTRODUCTION
The Mettur thermal power station is the Tamilnadu
electrical board's inland thermal power facility. Industrial
development is critical to the country's economic success.
The facility is on Stanley reservoir's left edge, on the Ellis
Surplus route. The major goal ofthe840MWMetturThermal
Electricity Station is to meet the power needs of the state of
Tamilnadu's industrial centers. Work onthe projectbeganin
1981, and the first unit was commissioned in 1987. The last
three units were put into service in 1987, 1989, and 1990,
respectively.
1.1 SCOPE OF THE PROJECT
The scope of the project is to find the energy conservation
opportunities in Mettur Thermal Power Stationbyfollowing
methods:
 To find the various opportunities in cooling tower
casing, fan blade material and fan blade angle.
 Through replacement of motors to reduce the
current and horse power.
 To optimize the blow down rate.
 To restrict flows through the large loads to design
values.
 To increase the cooling tower efficiency.
2.COOLING TOWER
The cooling system conjointly includes any machinery
accustomed operatethe tower andanytanks,pipesorvalves.
A cooling is instrumentality accustomed cut back the
temperature of the water by extracting heat from water and
emitting to the atmosphere. cooling build use to evaporation
wherever by a number of the water is gaseous into a moving
air stream and afterward discharged into the atmosphere.As
a results the reminder of the water is cooled down
considerably. coolingsquaremeasureabletolowerthewater
temperatureover devicesthatusesolelyairtorejectheatjust
like the radiator within the automobile and square measure
thus most value effective and energy economical. cooling
square measureemployed in air con system forrefrigeration
or to cool down materials in industrial processes. cooling
square measuredevices thatusecloseairtocooldownwater.
A cooling system mightcontain oneoralotofcoolingthatuse
identical recirculating water.
2.1 HOW DOES A COOLING TOWER WORKS?
In a cooling tower system, the fan pushes or attractsairfrom
the atmosphere into the tower to cool down recirculating
water. Warm water, that has removed heat from associate
air-con, refrigeration or process, enters the highest of the
tower. because the water falls throughthetowerrecentairis
forced through it. This recent air cools the water. The cooled
water then falls to a storage basin before being recirculates
through system once more.
2.2 TYPES OF COOLING TOWER
The section describes about the types of cooling tower
they are:
Types of draft in cooling tower
 Natural draft cooling tower
 Mechanical draft cooling tower
1. Forced draft cooling tower
2. Induced draft cooling tower
Types of water and air flow in cooling tower
 Cross flow
 Counter Flow
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 09 Issue: 06 | June 2022 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072

2.3 NATURAL DRAFT COOLING TOWER
This type of tower is incredibly common. It are often
known by the fan at the highest of the tower. The fan pulls
air up through the tower within the wrong way to that the
water is falling. The air sometimes enters the tower through
body of water louvers on the perimeters of the tower. This
type of tower as shown in Fig. -1.
Fig -1: Natural Draft Cooling Tower
2.4 MECHANICAL DRAFT COOLING TOWERS
Mechanical draft cooling towers have giant fans to force or
draw air through circulated water. The water falls
downward over fill surface that facilitate increase the
contact time between the water and therefore the air this
helps maximize heat transfer between the 2 cooling rates of
mechanical draft towers rely upon numerous parameters
like fan diameter and speed of operation, fill for system
resistance etc.
2.4.1 COUNTER FLOW TOWERS
Counter flow cooling tower air is drawn through the falling
water and the fill thereforelocatedinsidethetoweralthough
design depends on specific site conditions.
2.4.2 CROSS FLOW TOWERS
Cross flow tower air is drawn the falling water and the fill
is located outside the water.
2.5 INDUCED DRAFT COOLING TOWER
Type of mechanical draft cooling tower with a fan at the
discharge (at the top) which pulls air up through the tower.
The fan induces hot moist air out the discharge
2.5.1 INDUCED DRAFT COUNTER FLOW COOLING
TOWER
This is a relatively popular form of tower. The fan at the top
of the tower can be used to identify it. In the opposite
direction from where the water is falling,thefandrawsairup
through the tower. Normally, air enters the tower through
intake louvers on the tower's sides. This type of tower as
shown in Fig. -2.
Fig -2: Induced Draft Counter Flow Cooling Tower
2.5.2 INDUCED DRAFT CROSS FLOW COOLING
TOWER
The fan is also mounted on the top of a cross flow cooling
tower with induced draught. In this type of tower, the fan, on
the other hand, pulls or induces atmospheric air over the
water falling from the top of the tower to the basin This type
of tower as shown in Fig. -3.
Fig -3: Induced Draft Cross Flow Cooling Tower

2.6 FORCED DRAFT COOLING TOWER
Type of mechanical draft tower in which one or more fans
located at the air inlet to force air into the cooling tower.
2.6.1 FORCED DRAFT COUNETER FLOW COOLING
TOWER
The water in a forced draught counter flow cooling tower is
cooled by air driven through the top of the water and into
the falling water. This type of tower as shown in Fig. -4
Fig -4: Forced Draft Counter Flow Cooling Tower
2.6.2 FORCED DRAFT CROSS FLOW COOLING
TOWER
The fan is mounted on one or double side of the tower in a
forced draught cross flow cooling tower. This fan forces
atmospheric air to the fill. This fan is horizontally across the
tower, passing through the water dropping from the top of
the forced draft cooling tower's top to the basin through the
fill. This type of tower as shown in Fig. -5.
Fig -5: Forced Draft Cross Flow Cooling Tower
3. DESIGN OF INDUCED DRAFT COOLING TOWER
IDCT FAN : 11 No per unit
Totally 22 No for stage (unit I & II)
Flow control valves : 22 N per unit
Totally 44 No for stage (unit I & II)
Total height of cooling : 20.13m
tower
Depth of cooling tower : 2.88m
sump
Height from ground level: (11.45+5.8) =17.25m
Fan stack height : 5.80m
Height from ground level to top : 11.45m
Fig -6: Design of Induced Draft Cooling Tower
3.1. COMPONENTS OF COOLING TOWER
Basic components of cooling tower is given below
 Frame and casing
 Fills
 Hot warer basin
 Cold water basin
 Drift eliminator
 Louvers
 Nozzles
 Fans
Fig -7: Cooling Tower Basins

3.2 PERFORMANCE OF COOLING TOWER
During the performance evaluation, portable monitoring
instruments are used to measure the following parameters.
 Wet bulb temperature
 Dry bulb temperature
 Cooling tower inlet water temperature
 Cooling water outlet temperature
 Inlet and Exhaust air temperature
 Range and Approach
 Air and water flow rate
4. PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION IN INDUCED DRAFT
COOLING TOWER
The cooling towers efficiency and performance is reduced
due to these problems they are given below
 Algae grows fastly due to sunlight falling on
cooling tower hot water basin. Algae blocks the
cooling tower nozzle.Ifalgae growscontionously
these leads to stop the water flow to the cooling
tower.
 The temperature of the hot water doesn’t
maintain evenly on all cells of the cooling tower.
Uneven temperature cause efficiency drop
 Dust and garbages are blocks the cooling tower
nozzle.
To solve these problems cover the cooting tower by using
GI roof sheets.
4.1 FACTORS AFFECTING THE COOLING TOWER
 Capacity
 Range
 Head load
 Algae growth.
5. ALGAE GROWTH IN COOLING TOWER
5.1 HOW ALGAE IS FORMED IN COOLING TOWER
Moisture, sunshine, and nutrients are required for algae to
flourish. Because cooling towers are exposed to the outside
air, they frequently enable outside bacteria (algal nutrients)
and sunlight to enter the water. As a result, if left untreated,
algae may soon grow out of control.
5.2 PROBLEM OF ALGAE GROWTH IN COOLING
TOWER
 If algae are growing continuously, they block the
cooling tower spray nozzle and reduces the water
flow
 They make more maintenance cost then regular
maintenance.
 This makes more water loss.
5.3 REDUCTION OF ALGAE GROWTH IN COOLING
TOWER
 To control the algae growth, preventsunlightfalling
on hot water basin of the cooling tower by using GI
roof sheets.
 Periodic water chemical dosing reduces the water
nutrients and algae growth
 Periodic maintenance and cleaning excess algae
improves the cooling tower performance.
Fig -8: Algae Growth Cooling Tower
6. PROVIDING GI ROOFSHEETONCOOLINGTOWER
HOT WATER BASIN
6.1 PURPOSE OF PROVIDINGGISHEETONCOOLING
TOWER HOT WATER BASIN
 To reduce algae growth in cooling tower
 To maintain hot water temperature evenly on all
cells of the cooling tower

 To prevent spray nozzle blockage due to dust
particles forming on hot water basin.
6.2 MATERIAL PROPERTIES OF GI ROOF SHEET
Material : Galvanized Iron (GI)
Thickness of the sheet : 0.6 – 1.2 mm
Resistance : Corrosion Resistance
Tensile strength : 300 MPa
Yield Strength : 220 Mpa
Fig -9: Cooling Tower hot water basin without GI
roof sheet
Fig -10: Cooling Tower hot water basin with GI
roof sheet
7. COOLING TOWER CALCULATIONS
7.1 COOLING TOWER CALCULATIONS BEFORE GI
ROOF SHEET PROVIDED ON HOT WATER BASIN
Hot water temperature (thw) = 40°C
cold water temperature (tcw) = 30°C
Inlet air temperature = 32.5°
Outlet air temperature = 33.9°
Cold water basin temperature = 30°C
Wet bulb temperature = 24.5°C
Dry bulb temperature = 36.5°C
1) Cooling water range = (Hot water temperature) -
(Cold wate temperature)
= 40-30
= 10°C
2) Cooling water =(Water outlet temperature) -
Approach (Wet bulb temperature)
= 30-24.5
= 5.5°C
3) L/G Ratio = water flow in Kg /
Air flow in Kg
= 20794/7655
= 2.7164
4) Fan Air Flow Actual / = (Rated fan flow  fan input) /
Cells (fan input speed rated )1.3
=(1945950  56.03 ) / (75)1.3
= 25.534  106 Nm3//hr
5) Air Mass Flow / Cell = flow  density of air
= (1945950  56.03 ) / (75)1.3
= 25.534  106 m3/hr
6) Density ratio = actual air density / 0.0075
= 1.164 / 0.0075
= 15.52 Kg/m3
7) Fraction of water = mass of water evaporated /
mass of water
= 240.28 / 20794
= 0.0115
8) Enthalpy of inlet air (h1)=78.5 KJ/Kg[using psychometric
chart for wet bulb and dry bulb
temperature ]
9) Enthalpy of exit air (h2 )= h1 + ( L/G ratio  range)
= 78.5 + ( 2.7164  10 )
= 105.66 KJ/Kg
10) Evaporation Loss = (Cooling water flow  cooling
Tower Range ) / 675
= (20794 10) / 67
= 308.05 m3/hr
11) Make up water = Evaporation loss / (coc - 1)
consumption
= 308.05 / (1.45 – 1)
= 684.55 m3/hr
12) Drift loss = 0.2% of water supply
= (0.2 / 100)  (20794)
= 41.588 m3/hr
13) Efficiency = [Range / (Range + approach)
 100 ]
= [10/ (10 - 5.5)  100]
= 64.51%
7.1 COOLING TOWER CALCULATIONS AFTER GI
ROOF SHEET PROVIDED ON HOT WATER BASIN
Hot water temperature (thw) = 42°C
cold water temperature (tcw) = 30°C
Inlet air temperature = 32.5°
Outlet air temperature = 33.9°

Cold water basin temperature = 30°C
Wet bulb temperature = 24.5°C
Dry bulb temperature = 36.5°C
1) Cooling water range = (Hot water temperature) -
(Cold wate temperature)
= 42-30
= 12°C
2) Cooling water =(Water outlet temperature) -
Approach (Wet bulb temperature)
= 30-24.5
= 5.5°C
3) L/G Ratio = water flow in Kg /
Air flow in Kg
= 20794/7655
= 2.7164
5) Air Mass Flow / Cell = flow  density of air
= (1945950  56.03 ) / (75)1.3
= 25.534  106 m3/hr
6) Density ratio = actual air density / 0.0075
= 1.164 / 0.0075
= 15.52 Kg/m3
7) Fraction of water = mass of water evaporated /
mass of water
= 240.28 / 20794
= 0.0115
10) Evaporation Loss = (Cooling water flow  cooling
Tower Range ) / 675
= (20794  12) / 675
= 369.67 m3/hr
11) Make up water = Evaporation loss / (coc - 1)
consumption
= 369.67 / (1.45 – 1)
= 821.4 m3/hr
12) Drift loss = 0.2% of water supply
= (0.2 / 100)  (20794)
= 41.588 m3/hr
13) Efficiency = [Range / (Range + approach)
 100 ]
= [12/ (12 - 5.5)  100]
= 68.57 %
8. PERFORMANCE GRAPH
8.1 RANGE vs EFFICIENCY
Graph is plotted between the range of the cooling tower
and corresponding efficiency of the cooling tower
Fig -11: Range vs Efficiency Graph
8.2 INPUT vs EFFICIENCY
Graph is plotted between the input temperature of hot
water and corresponding efficiency of the cooling tower.
Fig -12: Input vs Efficiency Graph
9. CONCLUSION
After theoretical analysis, it works found the efficiency of
cooling tower-I was 64.1% which islowerthanthedesigned
value at 70.97% which is due to atmospheric temperature.
Because of frequent and periodic maintenance of fans. gear
box, drive shaft, hot water basin, flow control valves, hot
water pipe lines, and nozzles. It will attain stable efficiency.
Due to scheduled maintenance. There is no algae formation
in the hot water basin and so the cooling tower is still in
better condition and also improvement inthecoolingtower-
I by providing Gl sheet on the hot water basin cell top to
reduce the algae growth and cold-water temperature
reduced up to 68.57% (-4°c). It also to improve the cooling
tower and generation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We wish to express our sincere thanks to our honorable
chairman Thiru. JANSONS.T.S.NATARAJAN, Sengunthar
Institutions, Tiruchengode for providing opportunity to do

this project. We wish to extend our heartfelt thanks to our
honorable Secretary and Correspondent Prof.
A.BALADHANDAPANI, M.A., M.Phil., and other respected
Trust members for providing us with all the facilities to
develop the project successfully.
We would like to express oursinceregratitudetoourbeloved
Principal Dr.K.UMADEVI.ME., Ph.D., for having rendered us
moral support in our endeavor
We feel elated by the encouragement of Mr. N.THIRU
SENTHIL ADHIBAN,M.E., Head of the Department of
Mechanical Engineering for motivating us throughout the
completion of this project
REFERENCES
[1] R. Ramkumar A. Ragupathy. Thermal Performance of
Forced Draft Counter Flow Wet Cooling Tower with
Expanded Wire Mesh Packing International Journal on
Technical and Physical Problems of Engineering"
(IJTPE), Issue. 6, Vol. 3, No. 1, Mar. 2011
[2] Ronak Shah, TruptiRathod, Thermal Design Of Cooling
Tower, International Journal of Advanced Engineering
Research and Studies E-ISSN2249-8974
[3] Xiaoni Qi. Yongqi Liu Zhenyan Liu Exergy Based
Performance Analysis of a Shower Cooling Tower
Strojniš kivestnik- Journal of Mechanical Engineering
59(2013)4, 251-259
[4] Ding Feng, Xing Ke-jia, Li Shi-Bei, Bai Jun-hong,
Sensitivity Analysis of Plume RisingHeightfromCooling
Tower, Procedia Environmental Sciences2(2010)1374-
1379.
[5] Y.A. Li and M.Z. Yu, F.W. Shang, P. Xie, The Development
of A Mathematical Model With An Analytical Solution Of
The Counter flow Closed Circuit Cooling Tower,
International Journal on Architectural Science, Volume
1, Number 3, p.120-122, 2000.
[6] L. Lu, W. Cai, A Universal Engineering Model ForCooling
Towers, (2002). International Refrigeration and Air
Conditioning Conference. Paper 625.

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS AND EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT OF COOLING TOWER AT MTPS-I

More Related Content

Similar to PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS AND EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT OF COOLING TOWER AT MTPS-I (20)

More from IRJET Journal (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS AND EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT OF COOLING TOWER AT MTPS-I