SlideShare a Scribd company logo
FOƱNI:M ƏND
DɪSTɪŊ(K)TɪV
FI:TƩƏR ΘI:ƏRI:


phoneme and distinctive
    feature theory
Presenters




             2
DIFFERENCE?
                                               /k/



   kit                           [ko]
                                 after s
                                                     [kh]
                                                     Initial
                                                               [k]
                                                               elsewhere



                     k
                   s ill

                                   sac     k
We pronounce them differently but we know they are the
  same sound.
How do we know two sounds are the same or different?                3
4
PHONOLOGY
   Phonology is how speech sounds are organized and
    affect one another in pronunciation.


   Key terms:
     Phone
     Phoneme
     allophone



   This organization is explained in phonological rules

                                                           5
CONCEPTUALITY

Articulatory phonetics   •   Phonology

Real sounds = phones     •   system and rules of sound
                             patterns
•    [p], [t], [k]
                         •   Abstractions = phoneme
•    [i], [æ]
                         •   /p/, /t/, /k/
                         •   /i/, /æ/

                         •   Inventory of sounds and
                             how they are realized.



                                                       6
Phonetics                      Phonology
• Phone                        • Phoneme




 CAN U IDENTIFY SMALLEST SEGMENT OF :
            SIGN LANGUAGE
                 OR
            SIGN WRITING?




                                           7
PHONEME
    a PHONEME is the minimal distinctive
        (contrastive ) linguistic sound


             Mental unit     Meaningful     Not realized

  Phoneme
             Physical/environ Meaningless   Realized

   Phone     mental unit


             Phonetic unit   Variation of   variations

 Allophone                   phoneme
                                                           8
   phoneme
        (from the Greek: φώνημα, phōnēma, "a sound uttered") is
         the smallest segmental unit of sound employed to form
         meaningful contrasts between utterances. (Wikipedia)


    Segment: "any discrete unit that can be identified,
     either physically or auditorily, in the stream of
     speech."

multiple segments
           vowels, consonants
supra-segmental                              1. separate and
           tone,stress, length,intonation
                                             individual,
secondary articulations
           nasalization
           vowel harmony                     such as consonants and
Marginal segments                            vowels,
           onomatopoeic words,                                        9
           interjections, loan words         2. occur in a distinct
                                               Source: Wikipedia
                                             temporal order
PHONEME

   A unit of speech that can be used to differentiate
    words(e.g.“cat”/kaet/vs.“bat”/baet/).


   Phonemes identify minimal pairs in a language.


   The set of phonemes in a language subject to interpretation;
    most languages have 20 to 40 phonemes.


   The phoneme cannot therefore be acoustically defined. The
    phoneme is instead a feature of language structure.            10
Defining
phoneme
  Easy?




 NO        11
what is the
What sort of     content       how does
entity is the                 one identify
phoneme?          of the      phonemes
                phoneme

                Issues
                                        12
1. WHAT SORT OF ENTITY IS THE PHONEME?

   Twaddell (1935)
      1) phoneme is a physical reality
         “count for practical purposes as if they were one and the

          same.” JONES (1967: 258)

       2) it is a psychological notion
          a mental or psychological reality

           the phoneme is a constant acoustic and auditory image (Sommerfelt); a
            thought sound (Beni); a sound idea (Trubetzkoy); a psychological
            equivalent of an empirical sound (UÓaszyn);
   In modern terms:
      phoneme is some sort of mental representation

                                                                                    13
                     TWADDELL criticized this mental phenomenon
2. WHAT IS THE CONTENT OF THE PHONEME
   What are phonemes made of? How are they represented?
                                                             underspecified,
   what position specific phoneme takes in the given phonemicin the sense
                                                                system.
                                                                  that it
   Which phoneme is in the opposition to a specific phonemeconsists only of
                                                                contrastive
   Sapir (1925, 1933) Sapir’s “point in the pattern.”        properties and
                                                              other features
      phoneme as a set of contrastively underspecified features omitted
                                                               are

       This notion further corresponded to the theory of Distinctive feature




    ⇒ this underspecification theory has been proposed under generative
        phonology under the name Modified Contrastive Specification
                                                                                14
CONTINUE…
   Prague School: Phonemic make-up or content
      phonemic make-up(Jakobson)
      phonemic content of the phoneme (Trubetzkoy)




                         those properties which are common to all
                                   variants of a phoneme
                        Each phoneme has a definable phonemic
                        content only because the system of
                        distinctive oppositions shows a definite
                        order or structure.
                                                                    15
16
3. HOW DOES ONE IDENTIFY PHONEMES
                         Practical aspect of phoneme:
                              phonemic analysis
   whether a sound is a
      single phoneme (/ts/,/nd/, or /oe/)
      a sequence of phonemes (/t-s/, /n-d/, or /s-j/).


   Minimal pair
       Differ in one phonological element (phone, phoneme, toneme or
        chroneme )
   complementary distribution
   Contrastive distribution
   Free variation
   Mutation methods
                                                                        17
SPOT THE ODD ONE OUT

 Look carefully at the words below.
 Can you spot the phoneme that is common to each
  set?
 Which word doesn’t share the common phoneme?


 tree      feet         grew       sleep
 rain      pain         mail       slap
 know      seat         grow       show
 Boat      away         play       stay


                                                    18
VIEWS OF WHAT THE PHONEME IS
   Empiricist notion: Twaddell
       the phoneme is a collection of sounds (a fictitious unit )


   Mentalist: Chomsky ( realistic view)
       the phoneme is the mental category that corresponds to a
        coherent set of sounds in a language


   American structuralist tradition:
       a phoneme is defined according to its allophones and
        environments


   generative tradition:
       a phoneme is defined as a set of distinctive features.       19
BLOOMFIELD’S PHONEME
   “The smallest units which make a difference in meaning”

   “A minimum unit of distinctive sound feature” (p. 77).
      non-mentalistic unit


   He identifies “primary” (segmental sounds) and “secondary”
    (stress and tone) phonemes according to their function in
    language (primary: syllable forming; secondary: structuring
    larger units).

   Phonemes are defined by their participation in structural sets.
     (syllabic, open-syllable, closed syllable, non-syllabic, initial,
                                                                          20
     medial, final, initial cluster, final cluster, etc.)
COMMON PHONEMIC RULES
 Aspiration [h]
 Unreleased   Stop [ ̚ ]
 Flap   [ɾ]
 Dental Consonants [⊓]
 Velarization [ɫ]

 Voicelessness [˚]

 Vowel lengthening [ ]
 Vowel nasalization [~]

                            21
Phonemic Awareness

  Phonemic Awareness is a
    subset of phonological
 awareness in which listeners
 are able to hear, identify and
  manipulate phonemes, the
smallest units of sound that can
    differentiate meaning.

   Separating the spoken word
      "cat" into three distinct
             phonemes,
     /k/, /æ/, and /t/, requires
                                   22
    phonemic awareness skill.
23
COMMON TYPES OF PHONEMIC AWARENESS
   Isolating
        Hear and isolate sounds in initial, medial or final positions in
         word (e.g. bat, ball, bell, pal)

   Segmenting
        Pronounce each phoneme in order as it occurs in word (bat
         >> b-a-t)

   Blending
        Combine phonemes to make a word (hear sh-ip and say ship)

   Manipulating
        Add or delete sounds in word to make new word
        (add a “t” to an” and say ant; replace the sound “d” in sad with
         a “t” and say sat)

                                                                            24
THEORETICAL TIMELINE OF PHONEME

   Ancient forerunners of modern descriptive linguistics (P¯ANINI, PATAÑJALI

    (India), the Greeks & “Anon” (Iceland, 12th C.)) clearly recognized the

    systematic nature between distinctive sound properties and the identity of

    words in their languages


   DE SAUSSURE (1857-1913) used “phonème”, first as a term for speech
    sounds, later as a purely functional entity.


   A. Dufriche-Desgenettes 1873
                                                                                   25
        French   word phonème as a speech sound
                                                         Source: B. Elan Dresher
TIMELINE…
   Structuralism (Ferdinand de Saussure(1879), E. Sapir, and L. Bloomfield)

        Tried to eliminate cognitive and psycholinguistic function of phoneme

        Used to refer to a hypothesized sound in a proto-language together with its
         reflexes in the daughter languages



   Polish Kazan school (Jan Niecisław Baudouin de Courtenay and MikoÓaj Kruszewski
    1875–1895)

        As an abstract set of alternating invariant psycho phonetic elements : fonema,

   Prague School 1926–1935

        the first group to formulate an explicit phonological theory


   Generative linguistics (Noam Chomsky and Morris Halle)
                                                                                          26
   modern phonology

More Related Content

PPTX
Phonology
PPTX
DOCX
Phonetic and phonology concepts
PPTX
Phonetics and phonology
PPTX
Phonetics and Phonology: Long Vowels, Diphthongs and Thripthong
PPT
The Sounds of Language by George Yule
DOCX
Stress
 
Phonology
Phonetic and phonology concepts
Phonetics and phonology
Phonetics and Phonology: Long Vowels, Diphthongs and Thripthong
The Sounds of Language by George Yule
Stress
 

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Diphthongs
PPTX
Allophone and phoneme. persentation
PPT
Phonetics & phonology
PPTX
Syllable and syllabification
PPT
GENERAL CLASSIFICATION OF VOWELS
PPT
Consonants presentation
PPTX
Phonetics ( Introduction to Linguistics )
PPT
phonetics and phonology
PPTX
minimal pairs
PPTX
Phonology
PDF
English Allophones
PPTX
Phoneme and feature theory
PPTX
Phonotactics
PPT
Phonetics and phonology pp1
PPTX
Phonetics lesson 1 - general introduction
PPTX
phonology Chapter 8
PPT
ppt on phonology
PPTX
Phone, phoneme and allophone
Diphthongs
Allophone and phoneme. persentation
Phonetics & phonology
Syllable and syllabification
GENERAL CLASSIFICATION OF VOWELS
Consonants presentation
Phonetics ( Introduction to Linguistics )
phonetics and phonology
minimal pairs
Phonology
English Allophones
Phoneme and feature theory
Phonotactics
Phonetics and phonology pp1
Phonetics lesson 1 - general introduction
phonology Chapter 8
ppt on phonology
Phone, phoneme and allophone
Ad

Viewers also liked (17)

PPT
Minimal pairs
PPTX
Phonemes and allophones
PPT
Phoneme Segmentation Practice Mixed2[1]Kelly(2)
PDF
Essaywriting
PPTX
Class phonetics and phonology - phoneme
DOCX
Syntax feature theory.. good
PDF
Phoneme Serialisation In Speech Production
PDF
linguistics glossary and terminology
PPTX
Phoneme (2)
PPTX
Intro to phonology lectr 2
PPT
Phonemes (1)
PPTX
Phonemes
PDF
translation
PPT
Allophone
PPTX
Phonology Introduction
PPTX
Minimal pairs
PPTX
Minimal pairs and minimal sets in Phonology
Minimal pairs
Phonemes and allophones
Phoneme Segmentation Practice Mixed2[1]Kelly(2)
Essaywriting
Class phonetics and phonology - phoneme
Syntax feature theory.. good
Phoneme Serialisation In Speech Production
linguistics glossary and terminology
Phoneme (2)
Intro to phonology lectr 2
Phonemes (1)
Phonemes
translation
Allophone
Phonology Introduction
Minimal pairs
Minimal pairs and minimal sets in Phonology
Ad

Similar to Phoneme my intro (20)

PDF
Linguistics
PDF
335 chpt 7 summary
PPT
Unit 1
PPT
Introduction to Phonetic Science
PPTX
Phonology in English- Introduction
PPTX
3 phonology slides
PPTX
3 phonology slides
PPTX
Chapter4 natural classes of sounds distinctive features
PPTX
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
PDF
INDTRODUCTION TO PHONETICS SCIENCE.pdf
PPT
Phonetics
PPT
Session 3 english phonology
PPTX
The sound patterns of language
PPTX
Phonology -- The Sound Patterns of Language Made Easy
PPTX
The patterns of sounds
PPT
Phonology
PPT
The sound pattern of language The sound pattern of language The sound patte...
PPT
Phonology
PPT
Intro to Phonology
PDF
Phone phoneme and allophone. Explaining the concepts pdf.
Linguistics
335 chpt 7 summary
Unit 1
Introduction to Phonetic Science
Phonology in English- Introduction
3 phonology slides
3 phonology slides
Chapter4 natural classes of sounds distinctive features
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
INDTRODUCTION TO PHONETICS SCIENCE.pdf
Phonetics
Session 3 english phonology
The sound patterns of language
Phonology -- The Sound Patterns of Language Made Easy
The patterns of sounds
Phonology
The sound pattern of language The sound pattern of language The sound patte...
Phonology
Intro to Phonology
Phone phoneme and allophone. Explaining the concepts pdf.

More from Hina Honey (20)

PDF
6 suprasegmental phonology pp186-238
PDF
Discourse analysis-by-gillian-brown-george-yule
PDF
Critical discourse analysis
PDF
Applying simclair coulthard model
PDF
Phonology by vikner
PDF
Kirchner on phonology
DOCX
Mikhail mikhailovich bakhtin, lecture outline
PDF
Technical report writing
PDF
Bullah shah
PDF
48652380 functional-english
PDF
Business communication & principles
PDF
32604885 functional-english-for-entrepreneurs
PDF
61739515 functional-english-grammar
PPTX
Honey's presentaion
PDF
Phonetics full
PPTX
Lexical relations
PDF
51285452 seven-types-of-meaning
PPTX
Speaking skills presentation by hina 2
DOCX
vocabulary for Essay writing
PDF
Apawork, best and appropriate, concise and brief
6 suprasegmental phonology pp186-238
Discourse analysis-by-gillian-brown-george-yule
Critical discourse analysis
Applying simclair coulthard model
Phonology by vikner
Kirchner on phonology
Mikhail mikhailovich bakhtin, lecture outline
Technical report writing
Bullah shah
48652380 functional-english
Business communication & principles
32604885 functional-english-for-entrepreneurs
61739515 functional-english-grammar
Honey's presentaion
Phonetics full
Lexical relations
51285452 seven-types-of-meaning
Speaking skills presentation by hina 2
vocabulary for Essay writing
Apawork, best and appropriate, concise and brief

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
PDF
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
PDF
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
PDF
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles - August'25 Week I
PDF
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
PPTX
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
PDF
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
PDF
Review of recent advances in non-invasive hemoglobin estimation
PPT
Teaching material agriculture food technology
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PDF
How UI/UX Design Impacts User Retention in Mobile Apps.pdf
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
PDF
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
PDF
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
PDF
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
PDF
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PDF
Spectral efficient network and resource selection model in 5G networks
PPTX
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles - August'25 Week I
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
Review of recent advances in non-invasive hemoglobin estimation
Teaching material agriculture food technology
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
How UI/UX Design Impacts User Retention in Mobile Apps.pdf
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
The Rise and Fall of 3GPP – Time for a Sabbatical?
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
Spectral efficient network and resource selection model in 5G networks
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity

Phoneme my intro

  • 3. DIFFERENCE? /k/ kit [ko] after s [kh] Initial [k] elsewhere k s ill sac k We pronounce them differently but we know they are the same sound. How do we know two sounds are the same or different? 3
  • 4. 4
  • 5. PHONOLOGY  Phonology is how speech sounds are organized and affect one another in pronunciation.  Key terms:  Phone  Phoneme  allophone  This organization is explained in phonological rules 5
  • 6. CONCEPTUALITY Articulatory phonetics • Phonology Real sounds = phones • system and rules of sound patterns • [p], [t], [k] • Abstractions = phoneme • [i], [æ] • /p/, /t/, /k/ • /i/, /æ/ • Inventory of sounds and how they are realized. 6
  • 7. Phonetics Phonology • Phone • Phoneme CAN U IDENTIFY SMALLEST SEGMENT OF : SIGN LANGUAGE OR SIGN WRITING? 7
  • 8. PHONEME a PHONEME is the minimal distinctive (contrastive ) linguistic sound Mental unit Meaningful Not realized Phoneme Physical/environ Meaningless Realized Phone mental unit Phonetic unit Variation of variations Allophone phoneme 8
  • 9. phoneme  (from the Greek: φώνημα, phōnēma, "a sound uttered") is the smallest segmental unit of sound employed to form meaningful contrasts between utterances. (Wikipedia)  Segment: "any discrete unit that can be identified, either physically or auditorily, in the stream of speech." multiple segments vowels, consonants supra-segmental 1. separate and tone,stress, length,intonation individual, secondary articulations nasalization vowel harmony such as consonants and Marginal segments vowels, onomatopoeic words, 9 interjections, loan words 2. occur in a distinct Source: Wikipedia temporal order
  • 10. PHONEME  A unit of speech that can be used to differentiate words(e.g.“cat”/kaet/vs.“bat”/baet/).  Phonemes identify minimal pairs in a language.  The set of phonemes in a language subject to interpretation; most languages have 20 to 40 phonemes.  The phoneme cannot therefore be acoustically defined. The phoneme is instead a feature of language structure. 10
  • 12. what is the What sort of content how does entity is the one identify phoneme? of the phonemes phoneme Issues 12
  • 13. 1. WHAT SORT OF ENTITY IS THE PHONEME?  Twaddell (1935)  1) phoneme is a physical reality  “count for practical purposes as if they were one and the same.” JONES (1967: 258)  2) it is a psychological notion  a mental or psychological reality  the phoneme is a constant acoustic and auditory image (Sommerfelt); a thought sound (Beni); a sound idea (Trubetzkoy); a psychological equivalent of an empirical sound (UÓaszyn);  In modern terms:  phoneme is some sort of mental representation 13 TWADDELL criticized this mental phenomenon
  • 14. 2. WHAT IS THE CONTENT OF THE PHONEME  What are phonemes made of? How are they represented? underspecified,  what position specific phoneme takes in the given phonemicin the sense system. that it  Which phoneme is in the opposition to a specific phonemeconsists only of contrastive  Sapir (1925, 1933) Sapir’s “point in the pattern.” properties and other features  phoneme as a set of contrastively underspecified features omitted are  This notion further corresponded to the theory of Distinctive feature ⇒ this underspecification theory has been proposed under generative phonology under the name Modified Contrastive Specification 14
  • 15. CONTINUE…  Prague School: Phonemic make-up or content  phonemic make-up(Jakobson)  phonemic content of the phoneme (Trubetzkoy) those properties which are common to all variants of a phoneme Each phoneme has a definable phonemic content only because the system of distinctive oppositions shows a definite order or structure. 15
  • 16. 16
  • 17. 3. HOW DOES ONE IDENTIFY PHONEMES Practical aspect of phoneme: phonemic analysis  whether a sound is a  single phoneme (/ts/,/nd/, or /oe/)  a sequence of phonemes (/t-s/, /n-d/, or /s-j/).  Minimal pair  Differ in one phonological element (phone, phoneme, toneme or chroneme )  complementary distribution  Contrastive distribution  Free variation  Mutation methods 17
  • 18. SPOT THE ODD ONE OUT  Look carefully at the words below.  Can you spot the phoneme that is common to each set?  Which word doesn’t share the common phoneme?  tree feet grew sleep  rain pain mail slap  know seat grow show  Boat away play stay 18
  • 19. VIEWS OF WHAT THE PHONEME IS  Empiricist notion: Twaddell  the phoneme is a collection of sounds (a fictitious unit )  Mentalist: Chomsky ( realistic view)  the phoneme is the mental category that corresponds to a coherent set of sounds in a language  American structuralist tradition:  a phoneme is defined according to its allophones and environments  generative tradition:  a phoneme is defined as a set of distinctive features. 19
  • 20. BLOOMFIELD’S PHONEME  “The smallest units which make a difference in meaning”  “A minimum unit of distinctive sound feature” (p. 77).  non-mentalistic unit  He identifies “primary” (segmental sounds) and “secondary” (stress and tone) phonemes according to their function in language (primary: syllable forming; secondary: structuring larger units).  Phonemes are defined by their participation in structural sets.  (syllabic, open-syllable, closed syllable, non-syllabic, initial, 20  medial, final, initial cluster, final cluster, etc.)
  • 21. COMMON PHONEMIC RULES  Aspiration [h]  Unreleased Stop [ ̚ ]  Flap [ɾ]  Dental Consonants [⊓]  Velarization [ɫ]  Voicelessness [˚]  Vowel lengthening [ ]  Vowel nasalization [~] 21
  • 22. Phonemic Awareness  Phonemic Awareness is a subset of phonological awareness in which listeners are able to hear, identify and manipulate phonemes, the smallest units of sound that can differentiate meaning.  Separating the spoken word "cat" into three distinct phonemes, /k/, /æ/, and /t/, requires 22 phonemic awareness skill.
  • 23. 23
  • 24. COMMON TYPES OF PHONEMIC AWARENESS  Isolating  Hear and isolate sounds in initial, medial or final positions in word (e.g. bat, ball, bell, pal)  Segmenting  Pronounce each phoneme in order as it occurs in word (bat >> b-a-t)  Blending  Combine phonemes to make a word (hear sh-ip and say ship)  Manipulating  Add or delete sounds in word to make new word  (add a “t” to an” and say ant; replace the sound “d” in sad with a “t” and say sat) 24
  • 25. THEORETICAL TIMELINE OF PHONEME  Ancient forerunners of modern descriptive linguistics (P¯ANINI, PATAÑJALI (India), the Greeks & “Anon” (Iceland, 12th C.)) clearly recognized the systematic nature between distinctive sound properties and the identity of words in their languages  DE SAUSSURE (1857-1913) used “phonème”, first as a term for speech sounds, later as a purely functional entity.  A. Dufriche-Desgenettes 1873 25  French word phonème as a speech sound Source: B. Elan Dresher
  • 26. TIMELINE…  Structuralism (Ferdinand de Saussure(1879), E. Sapir, and L. Bloomfield)  Tried to eliminate cognitive and psycholinguistic function of phoneme  Used to refer to a hypothesized sound in a proto-language together with its reflexes in the daughter languages  Polish Kazan school (Jan Niecisław Baudouin de Courtenay and MikoÓaj Kruszewski 1875–1895)  As an abstract set of alternating invariant psycho phonetic elements : fonema,  Prague School 1926–1935  the first group to formulate an explicit phonological theory  Generative linguistics (Noam Chomsky and Morris Halle) 26  modern phonology

Editor's Notes

  • #5: We all know them very well but is it all we know about phoneme? No its notta as simple as it looks like there is much to be explored yet
  • #6: Source:
  • #8: Sign language: visualsSign writing: graphemehttp://www.sil.org/linguistics/GlossaryOfLinguisticTerms/WhatIsAPhoneme.htm
  • #10: Segments are called discreet bec they are separate and individual and occur in a distinct temporal order.
  • #13: Like other linguistic notions, such as “sentence,”“syllable,” and “topic,” what starts out as a relatively unproblematic intuitiveconcept inevitably gets caught up in theory-internal considerations. In the caseof the phoneme, three issues have been particularly contentious: (i) what sort ofentity is the phoneme (physical, psychological, other); (ii) what is the contentof the phoneme; and (iii) how does one identify phonemes?
  • #14: SAPIR(1933): “the phonemic attitude is more basic, psychologically speaking,than the more strictly phonetic one,”
  • #15: Representing the underspecified phoneme. The remarks concerning Sapir, Jakobson,and Trubetzkoy above suggest a view of the phoneme as having a single representation,from which other variants, or allophones, are derived. Moreover, ifthe interpretation of these proposals given above is correct, it would appearthat this one representation of the phoneme is underspecified, in the sense that itconsists only of contrastive properties (chapter 7: feature specification andunderspecification). Underspecified phonemic representations were proposedby Jakobson and his colleagues (see, among others, Jakobsonet al. 1952 and Jakobsonand Halle 1956). They proposed that contrastive features are assigned by successivelydividing up an inventory until each phoneme has been assigned a uniquerepresentation. This theory has been taken up within generative phonology underthe name Modified Contrastive Specification (MCS; Dresher et al. 1994; D. C. Hall2007; Dresher 2009).
  • #17: Jakobson notes (1962: 224) that the presence of /æ/ in Slovak, though “a mere detailfrom a phonetic point of view . . . determines the phonemic make-up of all the shortvowels.” Thus all the short vowels in Standard Slovak come in pairs that contrastin the frontness/backness dimension, so that the vowels /i e æ/ are contrastivelyfront (acute, in terms of Jakobson’s features), and /u o a/ are contrastively back(grave). Lip rounding, though present phonetically in /u/ and /o/, is not contrastiveand therefore does not enter into the phonemic make-up of these vowels.This concept can be illustrated with respect to the phoneme /r/ in three differentlanguages. German has two liquids, /r/ and /l/, which are set apart fromall other consonants by being liquids (3a). Trubetzkoy (1969: 73) observes that thephonemic content of German /r/ is “very poor, actually purely negative: it is nota vowel, not a specific obstruent, not a nasal, nor an l. Consequently, it also variesgreatly with respect to its realization” (see also chapter 30: the representationof rhotics). By “purely negative,” Trubetzkoy means that the contrastivespecifications of /r/ are all the unmarked members of their respective contrasts.He proposes that because /r/ is not contrastively specified for place or specificmanner of articulation, some speakers pronounce it as a dental vibrant, some asa uvular vibrant, some as a noiseless guttural spirant, and it varies a great dealin different contexts as well. By contrast, “Czech /r/ has a much richer phonemiccontent,” because it stands in a relation not only to /l/ but to /Å/ (3b): /r/is distinguished from /Å/ in that it is not an obstruent but a liquid, and from /l/in that it is a vibrant. “For this reason, Czech r is always, and in all positions,pronounced as a clear and energetically trilled sonorant.”3 In Gilyak (also calledNivkh, a language isolate spoken in Russia along the Amur River and on SakhalinIsland) (3c), /r/ is opposed to a voiceless spirant, and the two fall into place as thedental members of a series of oppositions between voiced and voiceless spirants,from which it follows that Gilyak /r/ is always dental (the Gilyak phonemes arelisted as in Gruzdeva 1998: 10).
  • #18: Chroneme: word IPA meaning pala /ˈpala/ shovel palla /ˈpalla/ ball
  • #21: Bloomfield recognised the need for underlying forms tosimplify the description of morphopho202020nemicalternations.Only later (1939) did he call for a separate discipline calledmorphophonemics whose basic units weremorphophonemes.He chose the forms and used ordered rules to achieve thesimplest possible description.He even set up “artificial” underlying forms to achieve asimpler description.Post-Bloomfieldians were strictly insistent on theseparation of levels (morphophonemics from phonology)and did not accept ordered rules.