SlideShare a Scribd company logo
METHOD is DEADTESOL METHODS: CHANGING TRACKS, CHALLENGING TRENDSKumaravadivelu, B. TESOL Quarterly  Vol. 40. No. 1 March 2006.MK.: TeoriPengajaranBahasaAsingPengajar: Sisilia S. Halimi, SS, MA, PhDDipresentasikanOleh:JuniatoSidaurukNPM   0906655282PascasarjanaLinguistik, FakultasIlmuPengetahuanBudaya, Universitas Indonesia,22Des2010
3 Perceptible Shifts:From CLT  TBLTFrom Method-based Pedagogy Postmethod PedagogyFrom Systemic Discovery  Critical Discourse .: Awareness about:Communicative and task-based language teachingThe limitations of the concept of methodPossible postmethod pedagogies (to answer limitations above)The complexity of teacher’s beliefsThe vitality of the macrostructures –(social, cultural, political, historical). Kumaravadivelu, focuses on the nature and scope of the transitions (work in progress, not replaced completely); > Before 1990 = Period of Awareness>  After 1990 = Period of AwakeningMethod = refer to what theoriests propose and to what teachers practice.The article is about method analysis, not teaching analysis.
From CLT  TBLT
Presentasi tesol method
Presentasi tesol method
From Method-based Pedagogy Postmethod PedagogyPennycook; Prabhu what really matters is the need for teachers to learn “to operate with some personal conceptualization of how their teaching leads to desired learning”sense of plausibility  : is not how to design a new method BUT how to devise a new way “to help activate and develop teachers varied senses of plausibility” (reasonable). Allwright (1991):  Method is DEAD. (Brown, 2002).And that what is needed is NOT an alternative method, BUT an alternative TO method. Kumaravadivelu (1994)  “POSTMETHOD CONDITION”. 3 tokohPostmethod:1. Stern’s “Three-dimensional Frameworks”2. Allwright’s “Exploratory Practice F.”3. Kumaravadivelu’s “Macrostrategic F.”
Presentasi tesol method
From Systemic Discovery  Critical Discourse“Critical Turn”, is about:Connecting the word with the worldRecognizing lg as ideology, NOT just a systemExtending the educational space to extraRealizing Lg learning and Teaching is more than learning and teaching Lg.Creating the cultural forms and interested knowledge.Pennycook “critical applied linguistics”.
Presentasi tesol method
The progress the TESOL profession 1970s and 80s, shifting focus from:Product-oriented teaching  process-oriented teachingA rigid curriculum a more flexible one.Moved from a state of awareness  a state of awakeningAwakened to:The necessity of making method-based pedagogies more sensitive to local exigenciesThe opportunity afforded by postmethod pedagogyThe multiplicity of learner identitiesThe complexity of teacher beliefsThe vitality of macro-structures???What is not clear is how this awakening has actually changed the practice of everyday teaching and teacher preparation? Expectation thru Competition for TESOL golden jubilee 2016…
Terimakasih
Stop WatchScaleThermometerSpeedometerOdometerDistanceTemperatureElapsed TimeWeightRate of TravelMatch the device to what it measures:

More Related Content

PPTX
Postmethod and elt
PPT
Current Prospectives on Teaching WEs and ELF
PPTX
Post methods era
PPTX
A critical view of ELT history
PPTX
Post method
PPTX
From syllabus design to curriculum development
PPT
Language learning strategies : Rebecca L. Oxford
PPTX
Sociocultural perspectives on SLA
Postmethod and elt
Current Prospectives on Teaching WEs and ELF
Post methods era
A critical view of ELT history
Post method
From syllabus design to curriculum development
Language learning strategies : Rebecca L. Oxford
Sociocultural perspectives on SLA

What's hot (20)

PDF
Enhancing participation through translanguaging
PPT
Clil theory
PDF
The Linguistics of Second Language Acquisition
PPTX
Post methodpedagogy - copy
PPTX
Task based language learning
PPT
CLIL - Content and Language Integrated Learning
PPT
Unit 1 From syllabus design to curriculum design
PPTX
Post method pedagogy
PPTX
Content-Based Instruction (CBI)
PPT
Definitions of Language Learning Strategies
PDF
Summary of approaches and methods in language teaching
PDF
CLIL 1: What is it? Advantages and Drawbacks
PPTX
Needs analysis in syllabus design.pptx
PPTX
Cooperative language learning
PPTX
Current trends and issues in english language education in asia.
PPTX
Approaches and methods in language teaching
PPTX
Post Method In ELT
PPTX
Clil Method- David Marsh
DOC
Interlanguage in SLA
PPTX
Post methods era in Language Teaching
Enhancing participation through translanguaging
Clil theory
The Linguistics of Second Language Acquisition
Post methodpedagogy - copy
Task based language learning
CLIL - Content and Language Integrated Learning
Unit 1 From syllabus design to curriculum design
Post method pedagogy
Content-Based Instruction (CBI)
Definitions of Language Learning Strategies
Summary of approaches and methods in language teaching
CLIL 1: What is it? Advantages and Drawbacks
Needs analysis in syllabus design.pptx
Cooperative language learning
Current trends and issues in english language education in asia.
Approaches and methods in language teaching
Post Method In ELT
Clil Method- David Marsh
Interlanguage in SLA
Post methods era in Language Teaching
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPT
English 625 Session # 2
PPTX
Post method era
PDF
The post methods era pdf
PPTX
The post method era
PPTX
English 345 slide 1
PPT
61 Web 2.0 Activities for TESL Teachers
PPT
How to integrate ICTs in the TEFL classroom
PPT
Tesol Ragab 2
PPT
Teaching English as a Foreign Language at UVic
PPTX
Describing two esl efl articles from the internet tesl journal
PPTX
Status, Potential and Constraints in e-business application in Bangladesh
DOCX
Tesol methods & materials dmavd
PPT
Materials and methods slides lecture 4
PPTX
Researching language as a complex adaptive system
DOC
An evaluation of_communicative_language_teaching_in_bangladesh
PPT
Complex Adaptive System Architecture By Marcela Oliva B
PPT
Clarck postmodern pedagogy
PPTX
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
PPT
Teaching English as a Foreign Language at the University of Victoria
PDF
Five approaches to TESOL
English 625 Session # 2
Post method era
The post methods era pdf
The post method era
English 345 slide 1
61 Web 2.0 Activities for TESL Teachers
How to integrate ICTs in the TEFL classroom
Tesol Ragab 2
Teaching English as a Foreign Language at UVic
Describing two esl efl articles from the internet tesl journal
Status, Potential and Constraints in e-business application in Bangladesh
Tesol methods & materials dmavd
Materials and methods slides lecture 4
Researching language as a complex adaptive system
An evaluation of_communicative_language_teaching_in_bangladesh
Complex Adaptive System Architecture By Marcela Oliva B
Clarck postmodern pedagogy
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
Teaching English as a Foreign Language at the University of Victoria
Five approaches to TESOL
Ad

Similar to Presentasi tesol method (20)

PPTX
Bell.bolouri
PDF
Kumaravdivelu2006TESOLTrends.pdf
PPT
ELT505 Presentation
PPTX
English 345 slide 1
PDF
Qualitative Methods: Ethnography & Participant Observation
DOCX
B.ed. 5th sem diversity and education
PPTX
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
PPTX
Engl 625 Session 1
DOCX
CONSTRUCTIVISM IN THEORY AND PRACTICE TO.docx
PPTX
CURRICULUM COMPONENTS.pptx
DOCX
MGT_The Importance of Acknowledging Cultural Orientation to Guide Pedagogical...
PDF
Language teaching methodology
PPTX
Presentation on post methodology
PDF
The Social Media Workshop: from research to development
PDF
The socratic dialogue and teacher education
PPT
The pedagogy of social science research methods: a textbook case
PDF
Application and evaluation of differentiation instruction in mixed ability cl...
PPTX
Research Paradigms.pptx
DOCX
CHS281Recap and assignment guidanceThis module addressed
PDF
Bell.bolouri
Kumaravdivelu2006TESOLTrends.pdf
ELT505 Presentation
English 345 slide 1
Qualitative Methods: Ethnography & Participant Observation
B.ed. 5th sem diversity and education
Sep 1 345 week 2 class 2
Engl 625 Session 1
CONSTRUCTIVISM IN THEORY AND PRACTICE TO.docx
CURRICULUM COMPONENTS.pptx
MGT_The Importance of Acknowledging Cultural Orientation to Guide Pedagogical...
Language teaching methodology
Presentation on post methodology
The Social Media Workshop: from research to development
The socratic dialogue and teacher education
The pedagogy of social science research methods: a textbook case
Application and evaluation of differentiation instruction in mixed ability cl...
Research Paradigms.pptx
CHS281Recap and assignment guidanceThis module addressed

More from juniato (20)

DOCX
Jadwal simulasi sidang ta
PPTX
Teenagers’ short message service (sms)
PPTX
Teenagers’ short message service (sms)
PPTX
Teenagers’ short message service (sms)
PPTX
Cat ppt
DOC
Perspektif sosial dan psikologis dalam pengajaran bahasa juniato sidauruk
XLSX
Nilai hadir n tugas margonda
XLSX
Nilai hadir n tugas fatmawati
XLSX
Newest tugas
XLSX
Nilai uts n tugas
PPTX
Linguistik abad 20 presentasi
DOCX
123 kata mutiara motivasi
DOCX
Kumpulan cerita lucu
PPTX
Neurolinguistics lg n brain
DOCX
Jawaban uas no 1 prof benny hoed
DOCX
Uas des 2010 soal 6 mundarjito
DOCX
Uas 3 mitos barthes prof okke
DOCX
Uas jawaban no 5 djoko
PPTX
Cat ppt
DOCX
Uas jawaban no. 2 sulistyowati
Jadwal simulasi sidang ta
Teenagers’ short message service (sms)
Teenagers’ short message service (sms)
Teenagers’ short message service (sms)
Cat ppt
Perspektif sosial dan psikologis dalam pengajaran bahasa juniato sidauruk
Nilai hadir n tugas margonda
Nilai hadir n tugas fatmawati
Newest tugas
Nilai uts n tugas
Linguistik abad 20 presentasi
123 kata mutiara motivasi
Kumpulan cerita lucu
Neurolinguistics lg n brain
Jawaban uas no 1 prof benny hoed
Uas des 2010 soal 6 mundarjito
Uas 3 mitos barthes prof okke
Uas jawaban no 5 djoko
Cat ppt
Uas jawaban no. 2 sulistyowati

Presentasi tesol method

  • 1. METHOD is DEADTESOL METHODS: CHANGING TRACKS, CHALLENGING TRENDSKumaravadivelu, B. TESOL Quarterly Vol. 40. No. 1 March 2006.MK.: TeoriPengajaranBahasaAsingPengajar: Sisilia S. Halimi, SS, MA, PhDDipresentasikanOleh:JuniatoSidaurukNPM 0906655282PascasarjanaLinguistik, FakultasIlmuPengetahuanBudaya, Universitas Indonesia,22Des2010
  • 2. 3 Perceptible Shifts:From CLT  TBLTFrom Method-based Pedagogy Postmethod PedagogyFrom Systemic Discovery  Critical Discourse .: Awareness about:Communicative and task-based language teachingThe limitations of the concept of methodPossible postmethod pedagogies (to answer limitations above)The complexity of teacher’s beliefsThe vitality of the macrostructures –(social, cultural, political, historical). Kumaravadivelu, focuses on the nature and scope of the transitions (work in progress, not replaced completely); > Before 1990 = Period of Awareness> After 1990 = Period of AwakeningMethod = refer to what theoriests propose and to what teachers practice.The article is about method analysis, not teaching analysis.
  • 6. From Method-based Pedagogy Postmethod PedagogyPennycook; Prabhu what really matters is the need for teachers to learn “to operate with some personal conceptualization of how their teaching leads to desired learning”sense of plausibility  : is not how to design a new method BUT how to devise a new way “to help activate and develop teachers varied senses of plausibility” (reasonable). Allwright (1991):  Method is DEAD. (Brown, 2002).And that what is needed is NOT an alternative method, BUT an alternative TO method. Kumaravadivelu (1994)  “POSTMETHOD CONDITION”. 3 tokohPostmethod:1. Stern’s “Three-dimensional Frameworks”2. Allwright’s “Exploratory Practice F.”3. Kumaravadivelu’s “Macrostrategic F.”
  • 8. From Systemic Discovery  Critical Discourse“Critical Turn”, is about:Connecting the word with the worldRecognizing lg as ideology, NOT just a systemExtending the educational space to extraRealizing Lg learning and Teaching is more than learning and teaching Lg.Creating the cultural forms and interested knowledge.Pennycook “critical applied linguistics”.
  • 10. The progress the TESOL profession 1970s and 80s, shifting focus from:Product-oriented teaching  process-oriented teachingA rigid curriculum a more flexible one.Moved from a state of awareness  a state of awakeningAwakened to:The necessity of making method-based pedagogies more sensitive to local exigenciesThe opportunity afforded by postmethod pedagogyThe multiplicity of learner identitiesThe complexity of teacher beliefsThe vitality of macro-structures???What is not clear is how this awakening has actually changed the practice of everyday teaching and teacher preparation? Expectation thru Competition for TESOL golden jubilee 2016…